Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:934
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P.(S) No. 5172 of 2019
….…..
1. Dr. Smita Kumari Gupta, aged about 52 years, wife
of Dr. Niraj Kumar Jha, resident of Deputy Para, P.O.Kutchery Chowk, P.S. - Lalpur, District - Ranchi
(Jharkhand)
2. Dr. Arvind Kumar, aged about 54 years, son of Late
Madan Mohan Prasad, resident of Vibha Niketan,
Behind P&T Colony, Burdwan Compound, P.O. & P.S.
Lalpur, District – Ranchi (Jharkhand)
3. Dr. Saurav Banerjee, aged about 46 years, son of
Late Nepal Chandra Banerjee, resident of B3, Abhilasha
Apartment, 11/A Purulia Road, P.O. Lalpur, P.S. Lower
Bazar, District -Ranchi (Jharkhand)
4. Dr. Satyabrata Patra, aged about 53 years, son of
Late J. Patra, resident of ID, Sushama Palace, Matrika
Ashram Road, Burdwan Compound, P.O. & P.S. Lalpur,
District – Ranchi (Jharkhand)
5. Dr. Kavita Topno, aged about 47 years, wife of Dr.
Marshall Daud Kerketta, resident of 1/J4, Opposite
Ranchi Science Centre, Chiraundi, PO- Boreya, P.S.Bariatu, District – Ranchi (Jharkhand)
6. Dr. Manisha Kujur, aged about 41 years, wife of Dr.
Anuj Pankaj Xaxa, resident of Dibadih, Daudnagar,
Near Lohardaga Railway Line, P.O. & P.S. Doranda,
District Ranchi (Jharkhand)
7. Dr. Abha Deepti Kerketta, aged about 46 years, wife
of Abhay Gyan P. Kujur, resident of 19, Peace Road,
Lalpur, PO- Lalpur, PS- Lalpur, District - Ranchi
(Jharkhand)
8. Dr. Vijaya Gupta, aged about 41 years, wife of Dr.
Amit Kumar, resident of Shivam Apartment, Flat
No.303 'B', Kilburn Colony, Near Eyelx, Hinoo, P.O.
Hinoo, P.S. Doranda, District - Ranchi
..… Petitioner (s)
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand
2. Secretary, Health Medical Education and Family
Welfare Department, Directorate of Health, having its
office at I.P.H. Building, Nepal House, P.O. Doranda,
P.S. - Doranda, District - Ranchi (Jharkhand)
2026:JHHC:934
3. Director, Rajendra Institute of Medical Sciences
(RIMS), PO-Bariatu, PS- Bariatu, District - Ranchi
(Jharkhand)
..... Respondent(s)
….…..
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK ROSHAN
CORAM:
For the Petitioner(s)
For the Resp.-State
For the Resp.-RIMS
….…
: Mr. A.K.Das, Advocate
: Mr. Ashok Kumar, AAG-IV
: Dr. A.K.Singh, Adv
….…..
C.A.V. ON 04/12/2025
PRONOUNCED ON: 08/01/2026
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2.
The instant writ application has been preferred by the
Petitioners praying for a direction upon the Respondent
authorities
to
immediately
grant
the
1st
and
2nd
upgradation of scale to the Petitioner nos.1 to 6 with effect
from 2011 & 2017 respectively under the Dynamic Assured
Career Progression Scheme and further prayed for a
direction upon the Respondents to pay the benefits of
upgradation of scale under the Dynamic Assured Career
Progression Scheme to the Petitioner nos.7 and 8 with
effect from 2018.
3.
During pendency of the writ petition when the
Respondents solely on the advice of their Retainer Counsel,
chose to withdraw the earlier resolution of the Governing
Body dated 11.10.2021; whereby the Respondents had in
principle agreed to extend the benefits of the Dynamic
Assured Career Progression Scheme to the Petitioner nos.1
to
was
withdrawn
vide
a fresh
resolution dated
2026:JHHC:934
05.03.2024,
the
same
was
challenged
by
filing
an
Interlocutory Application seeking amendment of the reliefs
which was allowed vide order dated 05.03.2024.
4.
Brief Facts:(i)
Petitioner Nos.1 to 6 were appointed pursuant to
an advertisement, selection process and against the
permanent post of Tutor in the respondents-Institution vide
appointment letters, details of which are as under:Sn. Name of the
petitioner
Appointment Date
Date of
Letter No.
of Issue
Joining
1.
Dr. Smita Kumari
Gupta
23.08.2005
10.09.2005
2.
Dr. Arvind Kumar
23.08.2005
29.08.2005
3.
Dr. Saurav Banerjee
23.08.2005
01.10.2005
4.
Dr. Satyabrata Patra
10.01.2006
16.01.2006
5.
Dr. Kavita Topno
23.06.2005
09.07.2005
6.
Dr. Manisha Kujur
23.06.2005
04.07.2005
(ii)
So far as Petitioner nos.7 and 8 are concerned,
they were initially appointed in the post of Tutor for a fixed
tenure, but subsequently when the permanent vacancies of
permanent Medical Officer were advertised, they applied
against the said posts and on being selected, were offered
appointment to the post of Medical Officers where they gave
their joining on 29.10.2012.
2026:JHHC:934
(iii)
The
Finance
Department,
Government
of
Jharkhand, vide resolution as contained in letter No.12/SDSEP(HES)-27/2015-1795/F dated 25.06.2015 introduced
the Dynamic Assured Career Progression Scheme under
which
an
employee
of
a
Medical
College
including
Tutors/Residents/Senior Residents are entitled to 1st
upgradation of scale after 06 years of service and 2nd
upgradation of scale on 06 years of further service from the
date of 1st upgradation of scale i.e. on completion of 12
years of continuous service (Annexure 2).
(iv) The Respondents-Institution adopted the said
scheme and under the Scheme, the Petitioner nos.1 to 6
became eligible for grant of 1st upgradation of scale on
completion of 06 years of service in the year 2011 and 2nd
upgradation of scale on completion of further 06 years i.e.
with effect from 2017. So far as petitioner nos.7 and 8 are
concerned, they were appointed in the year 2012 and,
therefore, they became eligible for the 1st upgradation of
scale under Dynamic Assured Career Progression Scheme
with effect from October 2018.
(v)
The representation of the petitioners was duly
placed before the Governing Body of RIMS, Ranchi in their
43rd Meeting held on 14.12.2017 wherein at Agenda
No.43.06(12), the Governing Body of RIMS in principle
2026:JHHC:934
approved the grant of upgradation of scale under Dynamic
Assured Career Progression Scheme and further also
resolved that the Petitioner nos.1 to 6 would be placed in
regular higher post in consonance with their educational
qualification and experience.
Despite such decision, when the benefits were not
being extended, the petitioners made a representation
before
the
respondents-authorities
(Annexure
4)
and
ultimately having no alternative, moved before this Court.
5.
The writ application was initially heard by this Court
on 09.01.2020 and the Respondents were directed to file
counter affidavit. Surprisingly, for the purpose of filing the
counter affidavit, the Retainer Counsel of the Respondents
advised the Respondents to withdraw the relevant part of
the resolution of the Governing Body of RIMS in its 43rd
Meeting (Annexure 3) wherein the Respondents had in
principle agreed to extend the benefits of upgradation of
scale under DACP scheme to the Petitioners and the
Respondents blindly by mentioning the same, withdrew the
resolution as contained in Agenda No.43.06(12) in their
43rd General Body Meeting in their 52nd General Body
Meeting held on 11.10.2021. The copy of the said Minutes
of the Meeting has been brought on record by the
Petitioners
by
filing
a
supplementary
affidavit
on
2026:JHHC:934
13.12.2021 as Annexure-5 and challenged by filing an
amendment application.
6.
It is also relevant to mention here that as the
Respondents since the very inception were trying to defeat
the legitimate claim of the Petitioner nos.1 to 6 by alleging
that the Petitioners are holding tenure posts and not
permanent posts and as such are not otherwise eligible for
promotion; these Petitioners earlier moved this Court in
W.P. (S) No. 4435 of 2009 claiming promotion to the post of
Assistant Professor with effect from dates of entitlement. In
the said writ application also, a specific plea was taken by
the
Respondents
that
the
posts
of
Tutors are
not
permanent posts and are tenure posts. They have also
taken a plea that the Petitioners are not permanent
employees of RIMS.
This Court after hearing the parties framed a specific
issue as to whether the Petitioners have been permanently
absorbed as Tutors in the RIMS and are to be considered
for promotion to the posts of Assistant Professors after
rendering 03 years of service on the said posts as has been
done in the case of similarly situated employees and replied
the same in the following manners in paragraphs 9 and 10
of the judgment. For brevity, the same is extracted herein
below: 6
2026:JHHC:934
“9. After bestowing my anxious consideration to the rival
submissions and on perusal of the record, the question
which falls for determination is as to whether petitioners
have been permanently absorbed as tutors in the RIMS, are
entitled to be considered for promotion to the post of
Assistant Professor after rendering three years of service on
the said post as has been done in the case of similarly
situated employees.
10. Indisputably, the conditions of service of the RIMS
employees are governed by RIMS Act, 2002, RIMS Rules
2002 and RIMS Regulations 2014. All the petitioners are
permanent
employees
of
the
RIMS
and
have
been
permanently absorbed on the post of tutors. In the meantime,
they have been continuing on the post of tutors for more than
one decade. There is also no denying of the fact that some of
the similarly placed tutors have been promoted to the post of
Assistant Professor after coming into force of the RIMS Act
and Rules.”
7.
The Petitioners by filing an Interlocutory Application,
as has been mentioned hereinabove, challenged the portion
of the resolution dated 11.10.2021 passed by the Governing
Body
in
their
52nd
meeting;
whereby
the
Agenda
No.43.06(12) regarding grant of 1st and 2nd upgradation of
scale under the Dynamic Assured Career Progression
Scheme to the Petitioner nos.1 to 6 has been withdrawn.
Said amendment, as has been stated hereinabove, was
allowed vide order dated 05.03.2024. It is only after the
resolution passed in favour of Petitioner nos.1 to 6
regarding extension of benefit of Dynamic Assured Career
Progression Scheme was withdrawn on the advice of
2026:JHHC:934
Retainer Counsel for the respondents in the 52nd General
Body Meeting held on 11.10.2021, the Respondents filed a
counter affidavit wherein the respondents mainly took the
following objections: (i)
Decision of Governing Body of the RIMS in their 43rd
meeting dated 14.02.2017 with respect to grant of Dynamic
Assured Career Progression Scheme was a mistake.
(ii)
Tutors/Senior Residents/Residents/Registrars are
tenure posts for three years only and holders of those posts
are not entitled to promotion.
8.
In support of the contention, the Respondents have
relied upon the common judgment passed in L.P.A. No. 313
of 2021 with L.P.A. No. 615 of 2017 dated 11.09.2023.
The Respondents thereafter filed a supplementary
counter affidavit bringing on record residency scheme and
certain documents showing framing of Senior Residency
Scheme.
9.
The
contentions
of
the
Respondents
are
wholly
misconceived and misleading for the following reasons: (i)
The plea as to whether the petitioners had
been permanently employed or were appointed
against a fixed tenure or not was duly considered
by this Court in W.P. (S) No. 4435 of 2009
(Annexure 6), wherein this Court had specifically
held that all the Petitioners are permanent
employees of RIMS and have been permanently
2026:JHHC:934
absorbed
on
the
posts
of
Tutors.
As
the
Petitioners were continuing in the posts of Tutors
for more than one decade, they were directed to
be considered for promotion to the post of
Assistant Professors as was done in case of other
Tutors.
The issue therefore as to whether the
Petitioners
were
permanently
appointed
and
absorbed in service against the posts of Tutors or
not no longer remain res integra.
(ii)
So far as the reliance of the Respondents on
the judgment of this Court passed in L.P.A. No.
615 of 2017 and with L.P.A. No. 313 of 2021 is
concerned; this Court is of the considered view
that the same is not applicable, inasmuch as, the
said cases related to such appointees who were
appointed for a fixed tenure. The advertisement
pursuant to which those writ petitioners were
appointed,
specifically
mentioned
that
their
appointment would be for a fixed period of three
years. This apart, even the appointment letters
issued to those employees specifically mentioned
that such appointment is for a fixed tenure and it
is
on
that
context
this
Court
held
that
2026:JHHC:934
appointment was for a fixed tenure and they
cannot be permanently absorbed.
Thus, the said judgment has absolutely no
application in the instant case. Paragraph 49 of
the
said
judgment
records
that
offer
of
appointment in those cases were for three years
only
and
the
posts
against
which
such
appointments were made against those posts
were tenure posts, unlike that of the present
petitioners
who
were
appointed
permanent
posts
and
the
completion
of
their
against
petitioners
probation
period
on
were
permanently absorbed in their services, which
fact shall become further apparent from the
rejoinder filed by the petitioners to the counter
affidavit wherein firstly the petitioners highlighted
the pick & choose method adopted by the
respondents-authorities
wherein
the
respondents-authorities on one hand extended
benefits of Dynamic Assured Career Progression
Scheme to other Tutors appointed in their
Institution, but discriminated the petitioners. As
for instance, in Annexure-7 series at Serial No.
27,
one
Dr.
Roseline
Toppo
was
granted
2026:JHHC:934
upgradation of scale under the Dynamic Assured
Career Progression Scheme, though she was a
Tutor in the FMT Department.
(iii) The petitioners also brought on record the
Office
Orders; whereby
the
services
of
the
petitioners were confirmed on completion of
probation period
vide
Memo No.1017 dated
25.07.2011 (Annexure 8); whereby names of
petitioner nos.1 to 6 are appearing at Serial Nos.
5, 4, 6, 7, 11 and 15 respectively and their
services have been confirmed with effect from
10.09.2007,
16.01.2008,
29.08.2007,
09.07.2007
and
01.10.2007,
04.07.2007
respectively.
Similarly, vide Memo No.3401 dated
29.05.2015, the services of petitioner no.7 have
been confirmed on completion of probation period
with effect from 29.10.2014 and vide Memo No.
3923 dated 12.10.2020, the services of petitioner
no.8 were confirmed against post of Medical
Officer with effect from 28.10.2014.
(iv) Under such circumstances, the pleas of the
respondents are not only unsustainable in the
eyes of law, but such plea appears to have been
2026:JHHC:934
taken only with an intent to somehow deprive the
petitioners of their legitimate claims.
10. In view of the facts stated hereinabove, following facts
get established: (i)
Petitioner nos.1 to 6 were appointed against
permanent vacancies and on completion of probation
period,
their
services
have
been
permanently
observed which facts find mentioned in the judgment
of this Court dated 28.09.2018 passed in W.P. (S)
No. 4435 of 2009.
(ii)
The General Body
after
considering
all
aspects of the matter decided in principle to give the
benefit of upgradation of scale to the Petitioner nos.1
to 6 in their 43rd meeting held on 14.02.2017.
(iii)
Withdrawal of the said resolution in the
subsequent meeting (52nd Meeting of the General
Body) on the advice of their retainer lawyer as finds
mentioned in the resolution itself shows the mala
fide and mischief in the mind of the respondentsauthorities.
(iv)
Such withdrawal of the previous resolution
being wholly for the purpose of contesting the instant
writ application is wholly illegal and cannot be
sustained in the eyes of law.
2026:JHHC:934
(v)
When similarly situated other Tutors have
been granted benefits of upgradation of scale under
the Dynamic Assured Career Progression Scheme,
denial of the same to the present petitioners would
be discriminatory and in violation of Article 14 of the
Constitution of India.
(vi)
So far
as
petitioner
nos.7
and
are
concerned; though they were initially appointed as
Tutors for fixed tenures, but realizing the uncertainty
in their services, they applied for permanent posts of
Medical Officers as and when advertised and on
being selected were appointed permanently against
the posts of Medical Officers and on completion of
period
of
confirmed
probation,
with
their
effect
services
from
were
duly
29.10.2014
and
28.10.2014 respectively.
11. Having regard to aforesaid discussions, this Court
holds that the Petitioner nos.1 to 6 are entitled to the grant
of 1st and 2nd upgradation of scale on completion of 06 and
12 years of service i.e. Petitioner nos.1 to 6 are entitled to
grant of 1st upgradation of scale under the Dynamic
Assured Career Progression Scheme with effect from 2011
and 2nd upgradation of scale under the said scheme with
effect from 2017.
2026:JHHC:934
Similarly, Petitioner nos.7 and 8 are entitled to their
1st upgradation of scale under the Dynamic Assured Career
Progression Scheme on completion of 06 years from the
date of their permanent appointment in the post of Medical
Officer with effect from October 2018.
12. The Respondents are hereby directed to grant the
benefit of the upgradation of scales with effect from the
date, the same fell due to the Petitioners and pay the
Petitioners all monetary benefits accruing therefrom.
The entire exercise shall be completed within a period
of 12 weeks from the date of receipt/production of copy of
this order.
13. As a result, the instant writ application stands
allowed. Pending I.A.s, if any, also stands closed.
(Deepak Roshan, J.)
Dated: 08 /01/2026
Amardeep/
A.F.R
Uploaded
08/01/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review