Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:550
Serial No. 10
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
Cont.Cas(C) No. 65 of 2022
Date of Decision: 18.06.2024
Dr. Nilesh K. Jaybhaye
S/o Shri Keshaorao Jaybhaye,
Indira Colony, Dabaki Road Old City,
PIN Code: 444002
District: Akola, Maharashtra
…….Petitioner
-Versus1. Dr. Nalin Mehta
Director, North Eastern Indira Gandhi
Regional Institute of Health and Medical Sciences, (NEIGRIHMS),
Mawdiangdiang, Shillong-793018
District: East Khasi Hills, Meghalaya
2. Dr. (Mrs) Asima Bhattacharya
Dean and HOD, Anatomy Department
North Eastern Indira Gandhi Regional
Institute of Health and Medical Sciences
(NEIGRIHMS), Mawdiangdiang,
Shillong-793018,
District: East Khasi Hills, Meghalaya
3. Dr. A. J. Patowary
HOD, Department of Forensic Science/
Post Graduate Exam Controller/
Chairman of Ex-parte Committee,
North Eastern Indira Gandhi Regional
2024:MLHC:550
Institute of Health and Medical Sciences
(NEIGRIHHMS), Mawdiangdiang,
Shillong-793018
District: East Khasi Hills, Meghalaya
4. Shri Jiten Singh
Law Officer/RTI Officer
North Eastern Indira Gandhi Regional
Institute of Health and Medical Sciences
(NEIGRIHMS), Mawdiangdiang,
Shillong-793018.
District: East Khasi Hills, Meghalaya
…Respondents/Contemnors
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Mr. S.D. Upadhaya, Adv. with
Ms. A. Synrem, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Dr. N. Mozika, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. L.M.D. Marak, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
ORDER AND JUDGMENT (ORAL)
1.
This is an application filed under Section 12 of the Contempt of
Courts Act, 1971 read with Article 215 of the Constitution of India with a
prayer
for
drawing
contempt
proceedings
against
the
respondents/contemnors herein and to punish them for willful disobedience
2024:MLHC:550
of this Court’s order dated 25.07.2017 passed in WP(C) No. 61 of 2017.
2.
Heard Mr. S.D. Upadhaya, learned counsel for the petitioner who
has submitted that the petitioner was a medical student of North Eastern
Indira Gandhi Regional Institute of Health and Medical Sciences
(NEIGRIHMS) in the Department of Anatomy for the session of 20132016 pursuing his MD/MS course.
3.
In course of his studies in the said institute, the petitioner was
subjected to discrimination, torture and harassment by the authorities of the
Institute and faculty members of the Anatomy Department. Such
discriminations are mostly in the area of caste, language and religion
wherein he was looked down by those in position of authorities and the
like. In the process, two years of his academic career and in spite of his
complaint, the Institute has failed to provide security to him or to look into
his grievance.
4.
Under such circumstances, the petitioner was compelled to approach
this Court by way of a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India, the same being registered as WP(C) No. 61 of 2017.
5.
The said writ petition was disposed of by this Court vide order dated
25.07.2017, the relevant and operative portion of the said judgment being
para 7, wherein inter alia at para 7(v) the following direction has been set
out:“7…
(v) In case the petitioner does not want to pursue further studies
and wants to leave the university, no adverse remark should be
2024:MLHC:550
noted or written in his certificates and he should be treated at par
with the other students without any malicious intention.”
6.
The learned counsel has also submitted that in due course the
petitioner completed his MD course and a provisional certificate dated
02.11.2021 was issued by the North Eastern Hill University (NEHU) to
indicate that he has passed the course of MD (Anatomy).
7.
However, when a Character and Conduct Certificate dated
27.01.2022 was issued to him by the NEIGRIHMS under the signature of
Prof. (Dr.) A. Bhattacharyya, Dean, NEIGRIHMS, the last portion of the
said certificate reads as follows:“During this period his character is satisfactory and his conduct
was found to be not appropriate and conducive for a P.G student.”
8.
This according to the learned counsel for the petitioner is a clear
violation of the direction issued by this Court in WP(C) No. 61 of 2017,
more specifically of sub-para (v) of para 7 of the said order dated
25.07.2017.
9.
The learned counsel has also further submitted that the petitioner
having faced discrimination in the Institute, for example, when his prayer
for extension of time to submit his thesis, which was supposed to be
submitted by 15.10.2019, the same not being granted, he was compelled to
approach this Court wherein vide order dated 20.11.2019 passed in WP(C)
No. 475 of 2019 this Court had directed the relevant authorities to extend
the date of submission of his thesis by 31.12.2019 which was accordingly
done so.
2024:MLHC:550
10.
Another instance cited is the action of his guide, the respondent No.
2 herein who had discontinued to guide him causing interruption to his
studies. Yet another example is the fact that the petitioner came to know
that some materials used for the purpose of his thesis project that is, fetuses
of mice were found to be missing from his room and were recovered from
the room of an Asst. Prof. of Anatomy, resulting in the filing of a complaint
by the petitioner before the NEIGRIHMS authority, but till date no
decision or findings have been made as regard the said complaint.
11.
It is because of instances of such kind as have been indicated herein
above that the petitioner was compelled to file complaint before the
concerned authority which were not heeded, further submits the learned
counsel.
12.
It is also the submission of the learned counsel that the petitioner has
filed a petition before the respondent No. 1/Director, NEIGRIHMS on
28.01.2022 with a prayer to rectify and to quash the defamatory remarks
made in the said Character and Conduct Certificate issued to him on
27.01.2022. On noting that action has not been taken by the authorities
concerned in spite of reminders sent in this regard, the petitioner was
therefore compelled to file this application with the prayer made therein.
13.
The learned counsel has also referred to the minutes of the meeting
of a committee constituted to examine the conduct of the petitioner herein
held on 17.01.2022 in the office chamber of the HOD, Forensic Medicine
and the deliberations of the members therein which culminated in the
opinion formed by the members of the committee that the conduct of the
2024:MLHC:550
petitioner herein is not appropriate and conducive for the PG student of
NEIGRIHMS, which opinion found place in the said Character and
Conduct Certificate dated 27.01.2022 issued upon the petitioner, where
such opinion according to the learned counsel has been formed without any
opportunity given to the petitioner to be heard in the matter.
14.
Finally, the learned counsel has submitted that since the prayer of
the petitioner for issuance of a fresh character certificate with no adverse
remarks has not been taken heed of by the relevant authorities at
NEIGRIHMS, the petitioner was compelled to issue a pleader’s notice
dated 11.05.2022 through his legal counsel with a prayer for issuance of a
fresh Character and Conduct Certificate failing which the petitioner would
institute appropriate legal proceedings including contempt proceeding.
15.
In support of his submission the learned counsel has referred to the
case of Balwantbhai Somabhai Bhandari v. Hiralal Somabhai Contractor
(Deceased) rep. by Lrs. & Ors. reported in 2023 SCC Online SC 1139, para
40 and 43.
16.
Per contra, Dr. N. Mozika, learned Sr. Adv. appearing on behalf of
the respondents/contemnors has submitted that the petitioner has not been
able to make out any case of contempt against the respondents/contemnors
herein.
17.
The learned Sr. counsel has once again referred to the order dated
25.07.2017 passed by this Court in WP(C) No. 61 of 2017 and to the
relevant paragraph 7 and has submitted that the direction of this Court inter
alia is that if he wants to continue his MD course he should be allowed to
2024:MLHC:550
do so and he should not be discriminated in any manner and nobody should
harass him.
18.
At clause (v) of the said para 7, it is directed that “In case the
petitioner does not want to pursue further studies and wants to leave the
university, no adverse remark should be noted or written in his certificates
and he should be treated at par with the other students without any
malicious intention”. This, according to the learned Sr. counsel would mean
that if at any point of time the petitioner wishes to leave the university and
to continue further studies outside, then no adverse remark should be noted
or written in his certificate. However, this is not the case as far as the
petitioner is concerned since he has chosen to continue to study in the said
institute (NEIGRIHMS) and has also completed his MD from the same and
as such, clause (v) (supra) is not applicable to the case of the petitioner.
19.
Again, the learned Sr. counsel has submitted that it is but natural for
a student to submit his conduct to the rules and regulations laid down by the
institution and in the case of the petitioner, his conduct has clearly violated
the norms laid down in this regard. Instances of his misconduct have been
cited by referring to one of the complaints filed by the petitioner before the
Head of Department, Anatomy, NEIGRIHMS dated 17.05.2020, which
complaint was evidently directed against one Dr. Sarah Ralte and also to
the HOD, Anesthesia, Dr. Prithwi Bhattacharrya, irrespective of the subject
matter, what is to be noted is the use of unpleasant, coarse and
unparliamentary language such as “husbandless”, “mouse thief”, “Brahmin
gangism” and “India-non India Nonsense” while referring to the alleged
conduct of the abovementioned officers. The petitioner in the said
2024:MLHC:550
complaint has even uttered a curse on the pregnant daughter of Dr. Prithwi
Bhattacharya to the effect that the unborn child in her womb will die and
she will become a widow and a beggar. The use of such language has
definitely attracted the attention of the authorities and as such, a committee
was formed to enquire into this matter which was done so. The resultant
outcome being the remark made in the said Character and Conduct
Certificate (supra).
20.
The learned Sr. counsel has also submitted that the direction made
at clause (vi) of para 7 of the order dated 25.07.2017 cannot be ignored
wherein it was directed that the petitioner is to maintain peace and harmony
and the respondents are also directed not to disturb the petitioner. Both the
parties are to maintain peace and harmony. The petitioner having violated
this provision, he cannot in the same breath impute any disobedience of this
Court’s order by the respondents.
21.
In conclusion, the learned Sr. counsel has submitted that this petition
is devoid of merit and the same is liable to be dismissed.
22.
This Court has carefully considered the submission of the parties and
is made to understand that the petitioner being aggrieved by the issuance of
the Character and Conduct Certificate dated 27.01.2022 (supra) wherein,
according to him, adverse remarks have been made, the nature of such
remarks being contrary to the directions of this Court in the order dated
25.07.2017
in
WP(C)
No.
of
and,
therefore,
the
respondents/contemnors are liable for proceedings under the Contempt of
Courts Act, 1971.
2024:MLHC:550
23.
To comprehend the case sought to be made out by the petitioner, the
case of Balwantbhai Somabhai Bhandari (supra) cited by the petitioner is
found relevant. Para 40, 41, 42, 43 and 44 are noteworthy to be referred to,
the same being reproduced hereunder as:
“40. The object of the discipline enforced by the court in case of
contempt of court is not to vindicate the dignity of the court or the
person of the Judge, but to prevent undue interference with the
administration of justice.
41. Any interference with the course of justice is an affront to the
majesty of law and the conduct of interference is punishable as
contempt of court. Public interest demands that there should be no
interference with the judicial process, and the effect of the judicial
decision should not be pre-empted or circumvented. (Reliance
Petrochemicals Ltd. v. Proprietors of Indian Express Newspapers
Bombay Pvt. Ltd., (1988) 4 SCC 592)
42. If a party, who is fully in the know of the judgment/order of the
Court, is conscious and aware of the consequences and implications
of the order of the Court, acts in violation thereof, it must be held
that disobedience is wilful. To establish contempt of court, it is
sufficient to prove that the conduct was wilful, and that the
contemnor knew of all the facts which made it a breach of the
undertaking.
43. The following conditions must be satisfied before a person can
be held to have committed civil contempt: (i) there must be a
judgment, decree, direction, order, writ or other process of a court;
(ii) there must be disobedience to such judgment, decree, direction,
order, writ or other process of a court; and (iii) such disobedience
of the judgment, decree, direction, order, writ or other process of a
court must be wilful. [Patel Rajnikant Dhulabhai v. Patel
Chandrakant Dhulabhai, (2008) 14 SCC 561]
44. It behoves the court to act with as great circumspection as
possible, making all allowances for errors of judgment. It is only
when a clear case of contumacious conduct, not explainable
otherwise, arises that the contemnor must be punished. Punishment
2024:MLHC:550
under the law of contempt is called for when the lapse is deliberate
and in disregard of one's duty and in defiance of authority. Contempt
proceedings are quasi-criminal in nature, and the standard of proof
is the same as in other criminal cases. The alleged contemnor is
entitled to the protection of all safeguards/rights, including benefit
of doubt. [Kanwar Singh Saini v. High Court of Delhi, (2012) 4 SCC
307].”
24.
It is the opinion of this Court that the issuance of the said Character
and Conduct Certificate to the petitioner was based on the conduct of the
petitioner, who, as has been indicated by the learned Sr. counsel for the
respondents, by filing such unwarranted complaints repleted with foul
language unbecoming of a person in medical profession or a medical
student for that matter, even if such complaint has any credence, the manner
it was presented can only lead one to form an opinion of the unsavory
character and conduct of the author of such a communication, and also lead
to the conclusion that the author is himself guilty of the prescribed code of
conduct of the Institution.
25.
As has been contended by the learned Sr. counsel for the
respondents, a reading of clause (v) of the said judgment dated 25.07.2017
would show that what is meant is that if the petitioner chooses to leave the
University, then no adverse remarks is to be noted in the certificate issued
to him. But the petitioner having opted to remain in the University and to
complete his course of MD/MS in Anatomy from NEIGRIHMS, the
certificate issued at the end of his course would depend on how he has
conducted himself throughout the course, as indicated herein, such being
his conduct and character even while filing of the related complaint, the
remarks made based on the findings of the said committee cannot be said to
2024:MLHC:550
be an act of contempt of court under the circumstances. Clause (vi) and (v)
of para 7 of the said judgment dated 25.07.2017 has to be read in
conjunction in the context of the issuance of the said certificate.
26.
In the light of the above, this Court finds that the petitioner has not
been able to make out a case of contempt of court against the respondents
herein. This petition is accordingly dismissed as devoid of merits.
27.
Taking into account the conduct of the petitioner, this petition is
hereby disposed of with cost of ₹ 20,000/- (rupees twenty thousand) only to
be paid by the petitioner in favour of the Shillong District Bar Association,
such payment to be made within four weeks from the date of this order.
Judge
Meghalaya
18.06.2024
TIPRILYNTI
TIPRILYNTI KHARKONGOR
2024.06.19 15:58:22
KHARKONGOR Date:
-07'00'
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review