Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:14284-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
L.P.A. No. 642 of 2022
Dr. Nikhat Parween, D/o Md. Abdul Fatah, R/o Shastri Nagar, PO &
PS-Medininagar, District-Palamau
...
...
Appellant
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand
2. The Jharkhand Public Service Commission, through its Chairman,
having office at Circular Road, PO-GPO, PS-Lalpur, DistrictRanchi
...
…
Respondents
----CORAM:
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH SHANKAR
----For the Appellant
: Mrs. Darshana Poddar Mishra, Advocate
For the Respondent-State
: Mr. Karan Shahdeo, AC to SC-II
For the Respondent-JPSC
: Mr. Sanjoy Piprawall, Advocate
Mr. Rakesh Ranjan, Advocate
Mr. Jay Prakash, Advocate
Mr. Prince Kumar, Advocate
----Order No. 13
Dated: 12.05.2026
I.A. No. 8646 of 2023
1.
The present interlocutory application seeks condonation of
delay of 54 days in instituting this appeal.
2.
We have perused the averments in the I.A. and we are
satisfied that the cause shown is sufficient.
3.
Accordingly, the delay is condoned and I.A. is disposed of.
L.P.A. No. 642 of 2022
4.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
5.
This appeal challenges the learned Single Judge’s order dated
02.08.2022 dismissing petitioner’s W.P.(C) No. 3790 of 2018.
6.
Mrs. Darshana Poddar Mishra, the learned counsel for the
appellant, submits that in this case the appellant had
produced a caste certificate in the format issued by the
respondent authorities. Based on such caste certificate, the
appellant was also invited to attend the interview. She
2026:JHHC:14284-DB
submitted that if the format in which the caste certificate was
issued was not found to be aligning with the format
prescribed in Advertisement No. 2/2016, the appellant,
should not have been faulted and her candidature rejected on
the said ground.
7.
Mrs. Darshana Poddar Mishra, learned counsel for the
appellant, submitted that the above facts did not obtain in
the case of Dr. Nutan Indwar @ Nutan Indwar Vs. The
State of Jharkhand & Ors. and connected matters i.e.,
L.P.A. No. 64 of 2020 and connected matters, which were
disposed
of
by
common
judgment
and
order
dated
07.05.2026. She submitted that for no fault of the appellant,
the candidature of the appellant would not have been
rejected or the appellant would not have been denied the
benefits of reservation and treated as a general-category
candidate.
8.
Mr. Sanjoy Piprawall, learned counsel for the J.P.S.C,
submitted that there is no error in the view taken by the
learned Single Judge in the impugned order. He submitted
that such a view aligns with the decision in Dr Nutan
Indwar (supra) and the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of Mohit Kumar Vs. State of Uttar
Pradesh & Ors., 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1125.
9.
Accordingly, he submitted that the issue raised in this appeal
is no longer res integra, and therefore, the appeal may be
dismissed.
2026:JHHC:14284-DB
10.
The rival contentions now fall for our determination.
11.
In this case, Advertisement No. 2/2016 was issued in January
2016. In terms of the advertisement, the last date for
applying was initially 29.02.2016, which was subsequently
extended to 15.03.2016. Crucially, the format in which the
caste certificate was to be filed was also specified in the
advertisement itself.
12.
The appellant, admittedly, did not file the caste certificate in
the
prescribed
format.
Mrs
Darshana
Poddar
Mishra
contended that since the caste certificate was issued by the
authorities themselves, the appellant was under the bona fide
belief that there was nothing wrong with the caste certificate
issued and produced on or before the last date prescribed in
the advertisement.
13.
According to us, the caste certificate produced by the
appellant could not have been regarded as the latest caste
certificate, as contemplated in Advertisement No. 2/2016.
There is a purpose behind insisting on the latest caste
certificate,
of
which
even
the
format
was
provided,
particularly in the context of candidates claiming reservations
to the posts reserved for the backward classes. This is
because the issue of the creamy layer is quite relevant when
considering the candidatures of such reserved-category
candidates.
14.
The concept of creamy layer depends upon variable factors
and is never static. A candidate who may not have belonged
2026:JHHC:14284-DB
to the creamy layer a few years ago may belong to this layer
just before the last date prescribed for applying. Therefore,
there is nothing wrong with insisting on the latest certificate
and even providing a form
for its submission. This
requirement was not even challenged on any ground.
15.
Besides, in this case, we do not find any ambiguity in
Advertisement No. 2/2016, based upon which some confusion
was possible. Therefore, the argument that the petitioner was
under the bona fide impression that the old certificate, not in
the prescribed format, would suffice cannot be accepted.
Based on such an alleged bona fide impression or by vaguely
alleging ambiguity, a relaxation or deviation from the
advertising terms cannot be insisted upon.
16.
In any event, in Mohit Kumar (supra), the Hon’ble
Supreme Court has explained that even if there is some
ambiguity or confusion, it is for the candidate concerned to
immediately apply and seek clarification. Only if such
clarification is not issued may the aspirant participate in the
process without prejudice to his rights and question the
outcome even after the candidate is not selected. However, if
the aspirant does not make any such effort and takes a
calculated
chance
of
selection
based
upon
his
own
understanding of the disputed term in the advertisement and
later, he emerges unsuccessful, ordinarily, it would not be
open to him to challenge the selection on the ground that the
disputed term is capable of being understood differently. In
2026:JHHC:14284-DB
such cases, the courts should be loath to entertain such a
plea of ambiguity while preferring to accept the recruiting
authority’s understanding of the said term.
17.
In Dr. Nutan Indwar (supra), this Bench has considered
several precedents on the subject, including in the context of
Advertisement No. 2/2016 with which the appellant is
concerned.
18.
The observations in paragraphs 66 to 72 are relevant and are
transcribed below for the convenience of reference:
“66.
In the case of Mohit Kumar Vs. State of
Uttar Pradesh and Others decided together with
State of Uttar Pradesh and Anr. Vs. Kiran
Prajapati reported in 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1125,
the appellant- Mohit Kumar and the respondent of
the another case namely Kiran Prajapati had
submitted their OBC (Non Creamy Layer) caste
certificates
in
the
formats
prescribed
for
appointments to the central government services
and not the one prescribed for the state government
services, as mandated by Clause 5.4 of the
advertisement. Their Lordships in the said case have
held that irrespective of whether an aspirant for
public
employment
belongs
to
a
particular
community like SC/ST/OBC, the status claimed by
him for being accorded the benefit of reservation is
per se not decisive. Such status has to be certified
by the competent authority upon following due
process and identification that the aspirant is what
he claims to be. It has further been held that once a
process of recruitment is set in motion, all aspirants
are entitled in law to equal treatment. There cannot
be different yardsticks for different sets of aspirants.
Non-compliance
with
advertisement/notification
the
terms
is
bound
of
to
the
trigger
2026:JHHC:14284-DB
adverse consequences of rejection of the aspirant's
claimed status by the selecting body/appointing
authority, should he choose not to adhere to the
same.
Having
regard
thereto,
the
selecting
body/appointing authority would be justified in not
entertaining the application of an aspirant as a
member of the community for whom reservations
are permissible.
67.
It has further been held in the said judgment
that once an advertisement is issued inviting
applications for public employment, it is the
responsibility, nay duty, of an aspirant to read and
note
the
terms
and
understand
what
its
requirements are. If any aspirant finds any of the
terms ambiguous and there is scope for an inquiry
inbuilt in the advertisement or is provided by any
rule/regulation, an effort ought to be first made to
obtain clarity for understanding the requirements
accurately. If no such scope is available, nothing
prevents the aspirant from seeking clarity by making
a representation. Should such clarity be not
provided, the aspirant may participate in the process
without prejudice to his rights and may question the
term even after he is not selected. However, if the
aspirant does not make any such effort and takes a
calculated chance of selection based on his own
understanding
of
the
disputed
term
in
the
advertisement and later, he emerges unsuccessful,
ordinarily, it would not be open to him to challenge
the selection on the ground that the disputed term is
capable of being understood differently. In such
cases, the courts should be loath to entertain such
plea of ambiguity while preferring to accept the
recruiting authority's understanding of the said term.
This is for the simple reason that the recruiting
authority is the best judge of what its requirements
are and it is such understanding of the recruiting
authority that would matter most in cases brought
2026:JHHC:14284-DB
up before the courts; hence, after commencement
of the process wherein aspirants have participated
without raising any demur as to what a particular
term means, even if any of the terms be ambiguous,
the courts should lean in favour of the recruiting
authority.
68.
In the case of Sakshi Arya (supra), the fact
was that an advertisement inviting applications for
appointment to the post of Civil Judge Cadre was
published which was silent on the aspect of the last
date of issuance of the concerned certificates for
each reserved category. The Appellants in all the
appeals belonged to different reserved categories
and they had successfully cleared their preliminary
examination, followed by mains examination, as per
the requirements of marks in their respective
categories. However, as none of those candidates
had their certificates issued as per the date specified
in the subsequent notice, their names were not
included in the list of the candidates called for
interview. In the said case, Their Lordships by
relying on the judgments rendered in the cases of
Bhupinderpal Singh and Others Vs. State of
Punjab and Others reported in (2000) 5 SCC
562, Rekha Chaturvedi (Smt.) Vs. University
of Rajasthan and Others reported in 1993 Supp
(3) SCC 168, Ashok Kumar Sonkar Vs. Union
of India & Others reported in (2007) 4 SCC 54
and Divya (Supra.), have held that the claim
made by a candidate while filling his or her
application as per the concerned advertisement are
to hold good as on the date of his or her application
or as per the last date of submission of application
prescribed in the concerned advertisement.
69.
Thus, it is no more res integra that the
eligibility of a candidate is required to be judged at
the time of filling up of the application form. The
candidates are duty bound to carefully go through
2026:JHHC:14284-DB
the terms and conditions of the advertisement and
strictly comply the same. If any format for obtaining
caste certificate and cut-off date for its submission is
prescribed
in
the
concerned
rule
or
any
advertisement, the same is to be strictly complied
with by the candidates. In case of any confusion, the
candidates may seek clarification from the authority.
Any deviation from the said terms and conditions
entitles the authorities to reject the candidature of
the candidates.
70.
Even if there is no cut-off date fixed by the
rules or advertisement for producing the relevant
certificates, a candidate is required to have an
eligibility criterion on the last date of submission of
application form. The reason behind it is that in case
of uncertainty of cut-off date, the candidates who
apply for the advertised post will be unable to
ascertain whether they are qualified for the post
applied for or not. In such a situation, a candidate
who does not possess the requisite qualifications in
presenti and is likely to acquire them on an
uncertain future date, may also apply for the
advertised post and thus the number of applications
will enormously increase.
71.
No relaxation can be granted to a candidate if
the
same
is not
provided
in
the
rules
or
advertisement. The candidates cannot claim any
relaxation on the ground of mistake or otherwise. If
relaxation is granted to one candidate, the others
may seek similar relief from the court, which would
delay the completion of the appointment process.
Moreover, granting such relaxation would cause
prejudice to those candidates who did not apply due
to their ineligibility.
72.
A candidate cannot claim reservation mere by
the reason that he/she belongs to the reserved
category. For claiming reservation, the candidate is
bound to submit the caste certificate in the
2026:JHHC:14284-DB
prescribed format within the cut-off date.”
19.
In addition to our reasoning, the above observations also
answer the contentions now raised on behalf of the appellant.
Therefore, even after considering the submissions made by
Mrs Darshana Poddar Mishra, we are satisfied that there is no
error in the impugned judgment and order warranting
interference in this appeal.
20.
Accordingly, this appeal is liable to be dismissed and is hereby
dismissed without any order for costs.
(M. S. Sonak, C.J.)
(Rajesh Shankar, J.)
May 12, 2026
Manish/Ritesh/AFR
Uploaded on 13.05.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review