Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3300 I
p.
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(Special Origina! Jurisdiction)
l
TUESDAY, THE THIRD DAY OF IVIARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION NO: 26921 OF 2025
Between:
1. Dr. [Vl, W/o Shri Sl aged 32 yrs., Occ. Doctor,
2. S, S/o Shri V., aged 31 yrs., Occ.Business
Both are residents of Flat No.403, Kolan Veera Reddy Space, Near tt/unicipal
Office, Nizampet, Kukatpally, Hyderabad.
...PETITIONERS
AND
The Union of lndia, Represented by its Secretary [Vlinistry of Health and
Family Welfare (tt/oHFW) Room No. 156-A, Nirman Bhavan, New Delhi1 1 0001 Email .secvhfirugnic.in
Appropriate Authority, Through - its Chairperson (Commissioner, Health and
Family Welfare), Opposite Dt\4E Building, DIM and H5 Campus, .Opp. .Koti
Wom5n's College Road, KutbiGuda, Sultan Bazar, Koti, Hyderabad,
Telengana - 500095.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a Writ, Order or Direction more particularly one in the nature of a
WRIT OF MANDAMUS or any other order or writ aggrieved by the action of the 2t
respondent in passing the impugned order's vide proceedings Rc.No.228lART
and Surrogacy/Govl.lnstt2024-1 dated 18-08-2025 thereby declining to consider
petitioner's application for issuance of certificate of essentiality and eligibility for
Surrogacy on the ground that the Cytogenetic report from the Institute of Genetics
and Hospitals for Genetic Diseases lndicates Chromosome Analysis 46 KY
Karyotype being illegal irregular and in violation of articles 14, 21of Constitution
of lndia and consequently set-aside the 2' respondent proceedings Rc.No.228
:1.: :
..
t
,,'..,t . .
.;:-."*i-+i s :.:
' . '-.lii6rI:l:.:a;1
- -,li;i:E#.iii-.:l
.E;
..,1:;
ART and Surrogacy/Govt.lnsU2124-1 dated 18-08-2025 by directing them to issue
, certificate of essentiality and eligibility in favour of the Petitioners.
lA NO: 2 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased direct
the 2nd respondent to consider the case of the petitioner and issue certificate of
essentiality anc eligibility pending disposal of the main writ petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner : SRI P.D.VINEELA
counser ror th' Respondent No'1
counser ror th* Respondent No'2
' 3I.'.tt."T,::H:*Xt?i"r,,
'iXJ f"t#,fE$,ttr1fiHflLa'rH
The Court macle the foliowing: ORDER
l
!
j
,l
I
I
,,{
i{C
IN THE HIGH COURT OF'JUDICATURE FOR THE STATE OF
TELANGANA
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAI(A
o.3.o3.20/26
Between:
Dr. M & another
Petitioners
And
The Union of India,
Rep. by its Secretary,
Ministry of Health & Family Welfare (MoHFW)
& another
Respondents
OR
ER:
The Hindu marriage (Sanskrit: fuqf6 romanized:
Vivaha lit 'Marriage') is the most important of all the samskaras,
the rites of passage described in the Dharmashastra texts.
variously defined, it is generally described to be a social
institution for the establishment and regulation of a proper
relationship between the sexes, as stated by 'Manu'. Marriage is
regarded to be a sacrament by Hindus, rather than a form of
social contract, since they believe that all men and women are
created to be parents, and practise dharma together, as
ordained by the Vedas.
r
1.1.
For centuries, marriage in India has been more
than jur;t a union between two individuals; it has been a
cornerstone of stlcietr,z, deeply rooted in tradition and scripture'
while ar.ranged marriages are often seen as the typical form of
matrimony in India, historical texts reveal a far more nuanced
picture.
1.2. ConcePtion:
The ideal conception of marriage that was laid dou'n
by the ancient Indians is one in which it is a ceremonial gift of a
bride (Vadhir) by her father, or another appropriate family
member, to a bride-groom (Vara), so that they may fulfil the
purposes of human existence together. In such a conception,
vivaha, which originally meant the wedding ceremony, but has
to acqrrire the definition of marriage as a whole, is meant for
procre:rtion, and the establishment of a famity (kutumba). After
one's rved<ling, one is believed to have entered the second stage
of life, the grihastha ashrama, performing the duties of a
house eolder.
1.3. Goals:
In Hinduism, the four goals of life (Purusarthas) are
regarcled to be righteousness (dharma), wealth (artha), pleasure
*[ke,meJ,
zrnd liberation (moksha). Marriage is generally not
consirlered necessary to fulfil these goals because following
i
', ,.., l
#ii*-l
aa
.,i.1
righteousness (dharma) applies to a person since birth and
wealth (artha) and liberation (moksha) are again one's personal
goal as dharma and need not to be aligned with marriage as
they can be practiced with or without it. The three goals of
marriage include allowing a husband and a wife to fulfil their
dharma, bearing progeny (praja), and experiencing pleasure
(rati). Sexual intercourse between a husband and wife is
regarded to be important in order to produce children, but is the
least desirable purpose of marriage in traditional Hindu schools
of thought.
L.4. Ase:
The Naradasmrti states a daughter should be given
away for once and all, as soon as her menses appear. The
Mdnusmriti states that following menarche, a maiden may wait
for three years, after which she may marry. Girls are usually
considered to have achieved puberty when they are 12 years
old, and are allowed to choose their own husbands if a suitable
groom is not procured for them.
:
1.5.
There are several types of marriages in Hindu
I
religion.
I
Brahma vivah (The Divine Marriaqel:
''i
I
\
Brahma marriage is the most pious and ideal form
of marriage. In this form, parents of the bride choose a groom
'4=4
'l
ii
il
ii
i
J
I
i
ii
lr
rl
it
,j
I
!
for the girl based on his goodness,
charactr:r' The marriage is
virtuous person' This type
and hor:or' which forms
happy nrarried rife. In
The father of the bride gives
bridegroom who is a rearned
l
his
and
of marriage stresses dharma,
duty
the basis for a stable, furfilring
and
modern Hindu societ5r, the
arranged marriages is mainl,y
norms, u'ith speciar emphasis
(.
conducted with vedic ceremonies,
and the'e is no dowry exchange.
daughter as a gift to the
education and good
practice of
based on Brahma marrlage
on the acceptance of both
families
and beinl3 compatible.
Apatyam
Children
o Lord of ihe home, best
fi.nder of richesfor our chldren qre
aou. Grant
to us spler,dor and. strengtlt,
O Master of our home.
Sukla yajur Ved.a 3.59.
1.6.
What is the Fulfilment
ue, 343
of a Marriage?
SLOI(A 8.I:
Children are the greatest
marriage' Househorder life is
sons and daughters are
becomes a family and
source of happiness in
made rich and comprete
born, at which time the
a new generation begins.
when
marriage
Aum.
BHASTIYA:
l1
;J
il
tii
The total fulfilment of the grihastha dharma, family
life, is children. Marriage remains incomplete until the first
child is born or adopted. The birth of the first child cements the
family together.
At the birth itself, the community of guardian devas
of the husband, wife and child are eminently present. Their
collective vibration showers blessings upon the home, making of
,i
ilr.
iI
itafultplace,awarmplace.ItistheduWofthehusbandand
J,
J .!
q,ife to become father and mother. This process begins prior to
conception with prayer, meditation and a conscious desire
to
bringahighsoulintohumanbirthandcontinueswith
providing the best possible conditions for its upbringing.
Raisingseveralchildrenrewardstheparentsand
their'offspring as well. Large families are more cohesive, more
stable, and are encouraged within the limits of the family's
ability to care for them. Parents, along with all members of the
extended family, are responsible to nurture the future
generationthroughchildhoodintopubertyandadulthood.
1.7.
Tlrc Vedas exclaim:
,,
Blessed with sons and daughters, mag theg enjoy
of ltfe, d.ecked' with ornaments of gold"' Attm
their full ertent
Namah SiuaYa.
-4
T.
,i
il
it
i
ii
I
I
i
When Brahmanas know that Self, and
I
t,
i
i.
:
I
I
above t,e desire for sons, wearth, and (new)
worlds, they wander
about as mendicants. For a desire for sons
is desire for wealth,
I
I
have risen
a desire for u'earth is clesire for worlds. Both
these are indeed
I
I
i
desires. (Brihacla rang aka Upanishad)
Through a son he conquers the worlds,
i
grandson he obtains immortalit5r,
grandsor he ascends to the (highest)
through a
but through his son,s
heaven. (Ail that) has been
declared in rhe Veda. (Baud"hayana Sutras
2_9_16.3)
The son of a wife wedded, according
to the Brahma
rite, if he performs meritorious acts, riberates
ancestors, ten descendants and himself
from sin ten
as the twenty_first.
(Manusntiti 3:37).
1'8'
Hindus rove their children dearly. They
their chi,dren are gifts from GoD and products
karma. I\dany presume that their children
of their previous
were rerated to them
in their past lives or were their close friends.
Manu, a man recreates himself through
individual existence
ae a
a part
narr of
""-"ince as
^r
his own rife from a
not just this rife but many
other liv'-s that preceded it as we,
'- *-
According to
his own children. Since
a Hindu firmry berieves in rebirth, he views
wider pe'spective that encompasses
berieve that
as succeed it, and his
a great cosmic cycle. Endowed
with the r:erief that his rerationships
repeat themselves and that
-r_illrl
:lirl
:l:ll
l'l
i,i
l:i
iti
:i
:lli
'i3
his life is intricately intertwined with many others who share the
same destiny, he acts with a greater sense of duty and
.ll
,!|
t'
i
responsibility towards himself and all those who depend upon
him and are related to him. Since he sincerely
_believes
in the
continuity of his life and relationships, he works for the welfare
of his family and their financial security through a policy of self
denial and austerity in personal expenditure.
1.9.
Orthodox Hindus do not approve childlessness and
i!
consider it to be very inauspicious. Women without children
have to face social discomfort and questioning looks from
friends and relations. Newlv-married couple have to deal with
peer pressure if they fa,, to produce children within a
reasonable time after their marriage. Childlessness causes great
hardship for both men and women in Hindu families, despite
the fact that over population is a major problem of present-day
India. While for men it is mostly a problem of their virility and
manhood for women it is the stigma of barrenness and the
absence of the pleasures of motherhood. Barren women are not
allowed to participate in certain rituals and on Some occasions
their very presence is considered inauspicious, which add to the
stigma of infertility.
1.10.
A son is generally preferred because he upholds the
family values and ensures its continuity. The Vedas clearly state
li'
I
I
I
I
I
i
that a ,,ran lives through his son. Before passing
welr-vers;ed in the Vedas transmits
away, a father
his quarities and powers to
his eldest son performing a special transmission
which gives the son the right to head the
ceremony,
family and continue
the famity tradition in the footsteps of
his father and ancestors.
Hence, the birth of a son in the family
is cruciar for the lineage
to continue. The Vedic people performed different
obtain different types of sons. The Bihad"aranyaka
(6.4) suggests what procedures coupres
complexicn with specific knowledge of
shourd foilow to obtain a
accursed Male children are preferred for
Financially a male child is an asset. socially
is considered
many reasons.
he stands for the
the family. spiritualry he
helps his parents in their afterrife, by performing
rites whe:e they die and saving them from
where pe,:ple without sons are believed
performs the shradda ceremonies
if a person
ask his daughter to raise a
sop for him. A family without a mare chilct
continuiQr and the exarted image of
or dark
the vedas and rifespan.
According to Gaurama Sutras (2g:1g),
does not have male children, he may
rituals to
tlpanishad.
son of fair complexion, or brown complexion,
1'11'
i.\
their funeral
the heil of punnama
to go. Thereafter, he
at regular intervars to ensure
their welt being in the heavens. The
female children are
excluded from participating in
funeral ceremonies and are not
I
I
I
I
I
I
};
- ffl r"
stl
11tlil
i.i,lil
.,iill
riil
.'riill
.o!.
iiiili
even allowed to visit the cremation grounds. If a couple has
more than one son, the elder one and the younger one would lit
!iill
r i ii
.l
I
the funeral pyres of their father and mother respectively.
1.L2.
Hindu law books do not ignore the rights of
illegitimate children. According to Gautama Sutras (28:33-3a)
the son of an unmarried damsel, the son of a pregnant bride,
the son of a twice-married woman, the son of an appointed
daughter, a son self-given, and a son bought belong to the
i;
l.
,t
famity of their fathers. In the absence of a legitimate son or
other heirs, they receive a fourth of the estate. The law books
also laid down elaborate rules of inheritance for children born
out of inter-caste marriages and polygamy.
1.13.
[n many families, girl children are subjected to
gender bias. Having too many girls in a family is considered a
great financial burden since the parents have to pay large
dowries for their marriages. The girls have no right of
inheritance. The ancestral property of the family invariably goes
to the male children. Parents have the right to distribute their
own wealth (swarjitam) to their daughters. But generally, they
do not do so unless they do not have male children. After
marriage, a girl child becomes the sole property of her husband
and cannot stay with her parents however strong might have
been their relationship. While the birth of a son is still welcome
l0
in alrrrost every Hindu family,
is alsc welcomed by many
an ausrpicious sign, as
1'14'
now a days the birth of
educated parents, who
if a goddess is born in their
Hindus are very possessive
spend a great deal of their
Becausre of orthodox
I
I
I
consider it as
house.
about their ch,dren and
time and ener$/ in bringing
sentiments and moral
are al.ways concerned about
I
baby girr
them up.
values, the parents
their children,s welfare and
upbrinl;ing and expect them
not to bring a bad name
to
themsetves or to their
families. Compared to
the r,r,estern
societies, the Hindus
are sentimentally and emotionalry
attacherr to their ch,dren
and experience a greater
intimacrr in their rerationships.
and children remains intact
even after the children
In a Hindu fam,y, it is
of the sons to lookafter their
with decent means of riving.
societies, aged peopre
negrect. ()Id-age homes
ago are now coming
grow up and
an obrigatory rerigious duty
aged parents and provide
them
Many do so. But Iike in
other
are increasingry suffering
of alienation, isolation and
warmth and
The bond between the parents
get married.
1'15'
more
from probrems
their children,s indifference
and
which were non_existent
a few decades
up in many parts of India
Hindu family
system ir; undergoing
radical transformation.
But a great
,,3
majority of Hindu families still consider their children as
'ii
products of their past deeds (purvajanma sukrutam). If a child
strays and brings bad name, they blame it upon themselves and
their previous karma.
1.16.
The social and cultural consequences of being
childless:
Approximately 7O-8O million couples worldwide are
currently infertile (Bos et al., 1995; Boivin et al., 2OOT) and it
can be estimated that tens of millions of couples are primary
infertile or childless. For most people, having children is
immensely important; not being able to have children is a major
life problem. There is also a large group of women and men, who
have children, possibly form a previous relationship, who
desperately wants to have another child. A considerable body of
research in Western countries has shown that involuntary
childlessness has strong psychological consequences (see for
reviews: Greil, 1997; Brokvich and Fisher, 1998). Most of the
studies carried out in this domain are quantitative and some are
qualitative. Both kind of studies, point in the same direction:
there are various psychological and psychosomatic effects, and
especially women are affected. The most frequently mentioned
effects are distress, raised depression and anxiet5r levels,
lowered self-esteem, feelings of blame and guilt, somatic
I
lii
lii
t2
complaints, and reduced sexual interest.
women and men in the western
For a small minorit5r of
li
t-.
worrd these effects are at a
clinical lever or can be considered extremely
serious (Greil,
7997).
1.17.
It is interesting that social and cultural
consequ3nces are seldom mentioned
in the reports on these
studies' when these aspects are considered,
related to studies about erderry people
regardler;s of the reason for being
wirhout children,
childress. [t is stressed in the
reports .f these studies that frail
ord people without children
have lesl; social support (cf., Johnson,
2006) and a less robust
network for independent living compared
children (cf', wenger et al-, 2oogr(2Qorl h.wever, carried out a study
to ord people with
wirtberg and co-workers
that is unique in the sense
that it ztims at erderry invoruntarily chirdless
reported on 14 women, and described
sexual life was affected negatively
they are often
women. They
that in ail cases but one
and that harf of these elderry
childless women were separated.
1'18'
some studies report the difficurty
couples have in communicating
children. They describe negative
meant) remarks within the coupres
birthday parties and other
that childless
with friends who do have
(although sometimes welr_
sociar worrds, for instance at
sociar gatherings: however,
I
I
I
I
I
ti
H
.: -- -il
.;il
l!
iij
il
l3
I
it:
I
:
ri
,4
supportive reactions are also mentioned very often (Greil, 1991;
van Balen et &1., 1996; Schmidt, 2006). It is possible for
childless couples to participate in the 'world of children',
especially if couples have good friends or relatives who have
children. They are able to participate in the lives and activities
of the children of their friends and relatives by, for instance
taking care of the children for a part of the week or when the
parents are on holiday; taking the children to school, music
lessons or sports activities; or going to games or shorvs in which
the children participate. An early study on childlessness found
that about ten per cent of couples had chosen this strates/ as a
way of coming to terms with their childless life (van Balen,
1991) Also, recently wirtberg and colleagues (2OO7l described
this as typical coping strategr for childlessness. It appears that
in the West childless people are not formally excluded from
being involved with raising children. In this background of
Marriage in Hindu Dharma and humiliation to a childless
couple in the society, now I will consider the merits of the case
on hand.
Factual Matrix:
2.
Challenging the order of the Commissioner, H&Fw,
chairperson, sAA, ART & Surrogacy uide Rc.No. 228IART &
surrogacy/Govt. lnstl 2024-1, dated L8.O8.2O25, rejecting the
,,1
'I
t;
li
:l
t4
Application of petitioner, for issuance of Certificate of
Essentie-lity and Eligibility under the provisions of the Surrogacy
(Regulation) Act, 2O2I (the 2021 Act), this Writ Petition is {iled.
2.1.
Petitioners got married according to Hindu Rites
and Ceremonies on 24.11.2021 and their marriage is duty
registerr:d in accordance with law uide Certificate of Marriage
dated CI3.1O.2O22 of Registrar Hindu Marriages, Kukatpally,
Medchal-Malkajgiri District. The wife (petitioner No.1) is
suffering from Complete Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome (CAIS
meaning missing uterus and ovaries), otherwise she has been
leading a normal life, but in view of the fact that the wifeintending mother has a chromosomal disorder namely CAIS, she
cannot conceive. Hence, she opted for surrogacy method and
applied to the District Medical Board under Regulation l4(a) of
the 2A2L Act. The District Medical Board, which is the
prescril:ed authority under Regulation a(iii) (a) (1) of the 2O2I
Act for issuance of Medical Indication certificate has considered
the case of petitioners and issued Medical Indication certificate
(MIC) <lated 22.10.2023, which was extended on 23.08.2024.
Therealter, petitioners approached the II Additional Junior civil
Judge-cum-X Addl. Metropolitan Magistrate, Ranga Reddy
Distric - at Kukatpally, seeking an order of parentage and
custody ol the child to be born through surrogacy. The court by
(
l5
'i.!3
order dated 26.07.2024 in S.R. No. 3927 of 2024 granted an
order concerning parentage and custody of the child to be born
through surrogacy.
2.2.
As prescribed under law, the intending couple have
also obtained an insurance coverage of such amount in favour
of the surrogate mother. Later, petitioners applied for Eligibility
Certificate to the Commissioner, H&FW, Chairperson, SAA ART
& Surrogacy. However, the Commissioner/Chairperson rejected
the said Application by the impugned order dated 18.08.2025. It
reads as under:
With reference to the subject cited, it is submitted that the
application of Smt. Maryada Sravani and Sri Seethareddy Pradeep Reddy
(Application No. 60) seeking issuance of certilicate of Essentiality and
Eligibility for undergoing surrogacy procedure was placed before the State
"
Appropriate Authority (SAA) for consideration.
-
As per the provisions of the Surrogacy (Regulationl Act 2021,
under Section 2(h), the term "couple" refers to a legally-married Indian man
and woman above the age of 21 years and 18 years respectively.
Further, uide reference 2"d cited (U llOl9/50/2O24-HR of
Under Secretary to the Govt. MoHFW, DHR, New Delhi dt. 05.03.2025) the
Department of Health Research, Government of India, has informed that in
pursuance of ongoing cases before the Hon'ble Supreme court, the matter
was referred to the Legislative Department, Ministry of Law & Justice, which
has opined that transgender persons are not covered under the Surrogacy
(Regulationl Act, 2O2 l.
In view of the reference 3rd cited (Cytogenetic report from
Institute of Genetics and Hospital for Genetic Diseases dt: 16.O6.2008i
wherein the Cytogenetic report from Institute of Genetics and Hospital for
Genetic Diseases with Regd. No. 2O8 dated: 16.06.2008 indicated
Chromosome analysis 46KY karyotype of the intending couple Smt. Maryada
Sravani, the application cannot be considered for issue of Certificate of
Essentialily and Eligibility under the provisions of the Act.
The communication is issued with due regard to the directions
of the Governrnent of India and in compliance vi,ith the statutory provisions
in force."
It is stated, the Governnrent of India vide
2.3.
Notification dated 21.O2.2024 clarified that if either the
husbanrl of the wife constituting the intending couple suffers
from arry rnedi<:al condition, then use of donor gemete for
surroga,ry proceriure is allowed. In view of the same, petitioner
submitted representation dated 22.1O.2024 to the 2nd
responcent to c:onsider their case for issue of certificates of
Essenti;rlity and Eligibility. Since there is no response, they are
stated to have filed Writ Petition No..16281 of 2025 wherein this
Court directed the 2nd respondent to dispose of the
representation within four weeks. Thereafter, petitioners again
submit-ed representation dated 27.06.2025 and the 2"d
responrlent considering the order passed by this Court, passed
the impugned order. According to petitioners, the impugned
order is contrary to the provisions of the 2O2l Act and also
violative of
3.
Article
2l
of
the
Constitution.
Respondent No.2 filed counter affidavit mainly
contending that the impugned ord.er was passed on the ground
that C:ytogenetic report from the Institute of Genetics and
a-
l
t7
Hospital for Genetic Diseases indicating Chromosome analysis
46 YY karyotype of petitioner which does not satisfy the said
Rules of the Act as it does not confirm to Sec. 2(ixh) which
defines couple as 'legally married Indian man and woman'. It is
further submitted that man is genetically identilied with XY
genotype and woman with XX genotype. The petitioners are not
fitting into the definition of the couple to issue the Certificate of
Essentiality and Eligibility and hence the further requirement of
I
donor gamete for surrogacy procedure does not stand.
I
3.1.
tt is stated, subsequent to the orders of the
:
Magistrate dated 26.07.2024, State Appropriate Authority
Committee conducted a meeting on 28.08.2024 with intending
couple application bearing NO. 60 where the Committee
members have detailedly examined the documents and in view
of the Karyotype report required clarification and decision was
taken to put in abeyance.
i
3.2.
[t is contended that in view of the findings observed
by the State Appropriate Committee members, clarification was
sought from the Director, Department of Health and Research,
Government of [ndia, for taking a decision regarding issuance of
Certificate of Essentiality and Eligibility uia mail dated
23.11.2024 for which Government of India has given response
il
I
i'i
Irl
iti
it!
1l
l
I
i
a
uia mail U.11019/5O12O24-HR of Under Secretary to the Gol
MoHFW. DFIR, New Delhi, dated 05.03.2025.
3.3.
[t is also contended that as per Section a(iii)(a) of
the 2O2l Act, the intending couple must be in possession of a
certificalion of essentiality issued by the State Appropriate
Authoriry having satisfied itself for the reasons to be recorded in
writing. As per Section 2(h), the 'couple' definition is legallyi
I
i
J
married [ndian man and woman where man is genetically
identifie d '*,ith XY genotype and woman with XX genotype, the
evidence of which is as per the cytogenetic report from Institute
of Geretics and Hospital for Genetic Diseases indicated
Chromosome analysis 46 XY karyotype of the lst petitioner
which loes not satisfy the said Rules of the Act. It is finally
stated that the State Appropriate AuthoritSr has rejected the
Application of petitioner No.l based on the report of SAA
Committee as per G.O.Ms.No. 68, dated 15.06.2022, it is
apposir.e to merntion that one ofi the committee memebrs is
Profess'or of oBG and has given an opinion as expert regarding
absence of Uterus investigated and conducrted as male
genotype.
4-
Petitioners filed reply affidavit stating that the case
of Petitioner No. 1 falls squarely within the ambit of Rule la(a)
of the surrogacy (Regulation) Rules, 2022. Accordingly, the
T9
ir'.{f
District Medical Board, being the competent authority under
Section +(iii)(a)(I) of the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021, rightly
issued the Medical [ndication Certificate. Owing to a
chromosomal disorder, Petitioner No. 1 does not possess a
uterus and is, therefore, covered under Rule 1a(a). The
Appropriate Authority has transgressed its jurisdiction in
refusing to accept the said Certificate duly issued by the
competent authority.
4.1.
The record clearly establishes that petitioners meet
the definition of "cotrple" under the statute. The contrary
observation of the Appropriate Authority is arbitrary and devoid
of legal basis. The object of the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act,
2021, is to safeguard family values and facilitate parenthood for
infertile couples. The action of the Appropriate Authorit5r runs
counter to this object and, if allowed to stand, would render the
Act otiose. The generalized statement made by the respondents
that XY genotSrpe denotes a man and XX genot5rpe denotes a
woman ignores universally recognized exceptions. Relevant
scientific literature on this subject is annexed herewith in the
Material Papers.
4.2.
In the present case, the documents fiIed establish
that petitioners are duly married and fall within the prescribed
I
at
I
I
il
ii
ii
.l
age limits. Therefore, rejection of their Application by the
Appropr.ate Authority is arbitrary and contrary to the statute.
5.
Learned counsel for petitioners Ms. PD Vineela
submits that the Appropriate Authority being a statutory
authority under law, is duly bound to pass appropriate orders,
in terms; of the procedure prescribed under Section a(iii) (a) & (c)
of the 2O2L Act. however, it failed to do so. According to her,
the im1>ugned rtrder is contrary to the Statutory Guidelines
issued b). the Government of India uide Gazette Notification
dated '.2L.O2.2O24 with reference to District Medical Board
Certifying Intending Couple either husband or wife suffer from
medical condition and in contravention of the judgment of the
Hon'ble, Supreme Court in ABC vs Lfnion of India (order dated
1'8.10.11023) and
failed to issue Eligibility/Essentiality
Certificate to the petitioners. The Appropriate Authorit5r, instead
of exercising powers vested in it by law, without jurisdiction,
sought clarification from the Ministry of Health & Family
Welfar,:, GOI, who gave opinion detailing the position reiterated
in all the above stated sources of law, but no whisper was made
specific to the facts of the case of petitioners.
5. 1.
It is further contended that the 2'd respondent,
ignoring the certificate of Medical Indication issued by the
Distrir:t Mediczrl Board and the order of parentage and custody
2t
passed by the II AJCJ-cum-X Addl. MM, as prescribed under
section 4 of the 2o2l Act, has proceeded to rely upon the e mail
received from the l"t respondent on the ground that the
Cytogenetic report from the Institute of Genetics and Hospitals
for Genetic Diseases indicates that the l"t petitioner (wife) has
chromosome analysis 46 XY karyotype. This action of the
respondent is completety arbitrary and without jurisdiction'
1"1
It is
also contended that due to the acts and deeds of the )nd
respondent, the 1st petitioner (wife) has been suffering/facing
a
social stigma of 'lnfertility' due to Androgen Insensitivity
Syndrome (AIS -missing uterus and ovaries) as it is'
6.HeardlearnedGovernmentPleaderforMedical&
Health.
7.
For better understanding of the case' the relevant
provisions of the 2O2l Act are extracted below:
CHAPTER III
REGULATIoNoFsURRoGAcYANDSURRoGACY
PROCEDURES
4. Regulation of surrogacy and surrogacy procedures onandfromthedateofcommencementofthisAct,(i}noplaceincludingasurrogacyclinicshallbeusedorcause.tobe
surrogacy procedures'
used by any person for conducting surrogacy or
exceptforthepurposesspecifiedinclause(ii)andaftersatisfyingallthe
conditions specified in clause (iii);
e''*"
:
il
'l
i
ll
:]
I
'
(ii) no surrogacy or surrogacy procedures shall be conducted,
undertakee, performed or availed of, except for the following purposes,
namely:
(a) when an rntending couple has a medical indication necessitating
gestationaI surrogacv:
Provided that a couple of Indian origin or an intending woman who
intends tc avail surrogacy, shall obtain a certificate of recommendation from
the Boarc on an application made b-y the said persons in such iorm and
manner as may be prescribed.
Esplanation For the purposes of this sub-clause and item (I) of subclause (a) of clause
(ii ) the exprr:ssion 'gestational surrogacy'means a practice whereby a
surrogate mother carries a child for the intending couple through
implantat.ion of embryo in her womb and the child is not genetically related
to the sulrogate mother,
(b) when it is only for altruistic surrogacy purposes;
(c) when it is not for commercial purposes or for commercialisation of
surrogacr' or surro€{acy procedures;
(c) when it is not for producing children for sale, prostitution or any
other forn of exploitation; and
(e ) an.y other condition or disease as may be specified by regulations
made by the Board;
'
(iiil no surrogacy or surrogacy procedures shall be conducted,
undertal<en, performed or initiated, unless the Director or in-charge of the
surroga(y clinic and the person qualified to do so are satisfied, for reasons to
be recorded in writing, that the following conditions have been fullilled,
namely:
(e) the intending couple is in possession of a certificate of essentialit5r
issued try the appropriate authorit5r, after satisfying itself, for the reasons to
be recorded in writing, about the fulfilment of the following conditions,
namely:-
(l) a certificate of a medical indication in favour of either or both
members of the intending couple or intending woman necessitating
gestational surrogac-v from a District Medical Board.
Dxplanation - For the purposes of this item, the expression "District
Medical Board" means a medical board under the Chairpersonship of Chief
Medical Officer or Chief Civil Surgeon or Joint Director of Health Services of
:1"^
.\J
the district and comprising of at least two other specialists, namely, the chief
ginaecologist or obstetrician and chief paediatrician of the district;
(II)
an order concerning the parentage and custody of the child to
be born through surrogacy, has been passed by a court of the Magistrate of
the first class or above on an application made by the intending couple or the
intending woman and the surrogate mother, which shall be the birth affrdavit
after the surrogate child is born, and
an insurance coverage of such amount and in such manner
as may be prescribed in favour of the surrogate mother for a period of thirty-
(lll)
six months covering postpartum delivery complications from an insurance
company or an agent recognized by the Insurance Regulatory and
Development Authority estabtished under the Insurance Regulatory and
Development Authority Act, 1999 (41 of 1999l,;
(b) the surrogate mother is in possession of an eligibility
certificate issued by the appropriate authority on fulhlment of the following
conditions, namely:-
(l)
no woman, other than an ever married woman having a child
of her own and between the age of 25 to 35 years on the day of implantation,
shall be a surrogate mother or help in surrogacy by donating her egg or
oocyte or otheru,ise;
(II)
a willing woman shall act as a surrogate mother and be
permitted to undergo surrogacy procedures as per the provisions of this Act:
Provided that the intending couple or the intending woman shall
approach the appropriate authority with a willing woman who agrees to act
as a surrogate mother,
(ltl]
no woman shall act as a surrogate mother by providing her
own gametes
(IV)
no woman shall act as a surrogate mother more than once in
her lifetime:
Provided that the number of attempts for surrogacy procedures on
the surrogate mother shall be such as may be prescribed; and
(V) a certificate of medical and psychological fitness for surrogacy
and surrogacy procedures from a registered medical practitioner,
an eligibility certificate for intending couple is issued
separafetA\-by the appropriate authority on fulfilment of the following
(c)
conditions, namely:-
the intending couple are married and between the age of 23 to
5O years in case of female and between 26 to 55 years in case of male on the
day of cer:ification,
(ll)
the intending couple have not had any surviving child
biologicaily or through adoption or through surrogacy earlier:
Prrvided that nothing contained in this item shall alfect the intending
couple who have a child and who is mentally or physicall-v challenged or
suffers frrlm life threatening disorder or fatal illness with no permanent cure
and apprrved by the appropriate authority with due medical certificate from
a District Medical Board; and
(lll)
such other conditions as may be specified b-y the regulations.
Appeal The surrogacy clinic or the intending couple or the intending
\.voman rray, within a period of thirtl' days from the date of receipt of the
communication relating to order of rejection of application, suspension or
cancellation of registration passed by the appropriate authorit-y under section
13 and (,ommunication relating to rejection of the certificates under section
4, prefer an appeal against such order to-
(20 the State Government, where the appeal is against the order
of the appropriate authority of a State;
(1, the Central Government, where the appeal is against the
order of the appropriate authority of a Union territory. in such manner as
may be ;lrescribed.
What is meant by Chromosome analysis 46 XY
karyoQrpe?
46 XJK|46 )ff is either a chimeric or mosaic genetic
condit.on characterized by the presence of some cells that
express a 46 XX karyotype and some cells that express a 46 ){Y
karyotype in a single human being. Individuals with these
conditions are classified as intersex.
Tetra gametic chimerism
",'
I
i
qt
i
The cause of the condition lies in conception or
utero with the aggregation of two distinct 4ygotes or blastocysts
(one of which expresses 46 XX and the other of which expresses
46 XYI into a single embryo which subsequently leads to the
development of a single individuat with two distinct cell lines,
instead of a pair of fraternal twins.
8.1.
In humans, sexual dimorphism is a consequence of
the XY sex-determination system. In typical prenatal sex
differentiation, the male and female embryo is anatomically
identical until week 7 of the pregnancy, when the presence or
the absence of the SRY gene on the Y chromosome causes the
undetermined gonadal tissue to undergo differentiation and
.
eventually will become either a pair of testes or ovaries
respectively. The cells of the developing testes produce Anti-
Mullerian hormone, causing the regression of the Mullerian
ducts. As individuals with 46 XXl46 XY partially dxpress the
SRY gene, the normal process by which an embryo normally
develops a phenotypic male or phenotypic female may be
significantly affected causing variation in the gonads, the
reproductive tract, and the genitals. Despite this, there have
been cases of completely normal sex differentiation occurring in
46 XXl46 XY individuals reported in the medical literature. 46
X./.l46 XY chimerism can be identified during pregnancy bv
r
r-.
R..
prenatal screening or in early childhood through genetic testing
and direr:t observation.
8.2. Mosaicism
The cause of this condition happens in early
developrnent resulting from a single fertilized 4rgote's cell line
divided into two cell lines; a genome that contains a
charactt:rized by the presence of some cells that express a 46
XX karyotype and some cells that express a 46 XY karyotype.
8.3. Si.gns and symptoms
Physice.l
4ti XX/46 XY chimeric or mosaic is associated with a wide
spectrum of different physical presentations, with cases ranging
from having a completely normal male or female phenotype to
some ,lases having ovotesticular syndrome". Due to this
variaticn, genetic testing is the only way to reliably make a
diagnor;is.
*Ovotesticular syndrome (also known as ovotesticular disorder or
OT-DSD| is a rare congenital condition where an individual is born with both
ovarian and testicular tissue. It is one of the rarest disorders of sex
developnent (DSDs), with only 5oo reported cases. commonly, one or both
gonads js an ovotestis containing both types of tissue. Although it is similar
in somr) lvays to mixed gonadal dysgenesis, the conditions can be
distingu ished histologically.
46 XX/46 Xy is possible if there is direct
observ.etion of one or more of the following:
1. sma.ll phallus midway in size between a clitoris and a penis
,l
'i rt
.,'
2. lncomptetely closed urogenital opening (shallow vagina)
3. Abnormal urethra opening on the perineum
8.4.
There have been no reported cases of both gonads
being functional in the same person; the functional tissue is
usually the ovarian tissue. A mix of male and female
characteristics may emerge at puberty. Some individuals will
experience secondary characteristics, such as breast
development during puberty in a male phenotype, while others
may experience deepening of the voice, secondary hair
development, and Srnecomastia'
g.5.
Segmentation of skin (distinct patches of skin) has
also been observed. However, this trait is not unique to 46
XXl46 XY chimerism nor mosaicism. tt has also been observed
in other types of chimerism.
8.6.
Cognitive
Individuals with the condition do not experience cognitive
impairment.
Genetic mechanism
46, XX/46,XY is an example of tetragametic
chimerism because it requires four gametes-two sperm and two
ova.
46 XXl46 XY is most commonly explained during in
conception combination of two fertilized eggs zygotes. TWo ova
from the mother are fertilized by tu,o sperm from the father. One
sperm contains an X chromosome; the other contains a Y
chromosomc. The result is that a zygote with an XY genotype
and a 4'gote with an XX genot5rpe are produced. Under normal
circumstances, the two resulting zygotes would have gone on to
become fraternal twins. However, in 46 yrxl46 XY, the two
4rgotes merge shortly before or after fertilization to become a
tw'o-cell zygote made up of two different nuclei. The zygotes
merge r:arly enough that there is no risk of them developing into
conjoined twins. Variations of this mechanism include
fertllizetion of an ovum and its first or second polar body by two
:
l
;
I
sperm.
i
j
I
I
I
I
i
46 yJ/46 XY can also be explained by a mosaicbased mechanism. A single zygote is formed from the
I
!
I
p
fertilization of a normal X ovum. The resulting XX/>CY zygote
I
I
I
:
divide,; to give two cell lines: 46 XXI 46 XY. The 46 XXl46 XY
i
cell lirres remain and go on to become a chimeric individual.
46 XXl46 XY can also arise when a haploid ovum
undergoes a round of mitosis, and the subsequent daughter
cells are fertilized by an X and a Y sperm, respectively.
,f
,
..:i
IQ
it
8-7.
Diagnosing chimerism or mosaicism is particularly
difficult due to the random distribution of 46 XX and 46 YY
cells within the body. In a chimeric human, an organ might be
made up of a mix of 46 XX and 46 XY, but is made up entirely
only one genot5rpe. When that is the case, no abnormalities are
noted and other types of tissues need to be analyzed,. Blood
tests might contain both or red blood cells of different blood
types.
8.8.
Before birth, ambiguous genitalia might be observed
through ultrasound. The karyotype might also be observed
through amniocentesis or cord blood sampling.
9.
From the above, it is clear that in Chromosome
analysis 46 KY karyotype the woman was otherwise healthy and
did not have menarche or menstrual period as expected but was
able to be sexually active and enjoy sex through her vagina. XY
DSD can be caused by defects in androgen action typically due
to dysfunction of the androgen reception (AR). DSD due to
complete loss of function of the AR is called Complete Androgen
Insensitivity Syndrome (CAIS) whereas mutations that retain
some residual function result in Partial Androgen Insensitivity
Syndrome (PAIS). CAIS typically presents in adolescence as
primary amenorrhea despite normal breast development.
Alternatively, CAIS may present in childhood with palpable
inguinal masses in an individual with a 46 XY karyotype and a
u.
typicat J'emale appearance to the external genitalia. The
phenotyJre in PAIS i,ariable depending on the degree of androgen
sensitivity and there may be associated grnecomastia due to the
peripheral conversion of testosterone to estradiol. Individuals
rvith inzrctivating mutations of the LH receptor (Leydig cell
hypopla:;ia) have a variable appearance ranging from completely
female F,henotype to a variable degree of virllization, very similar
to patients with AIS. Fertility is impaired in the majority of
individuals with disorders of androgen action as a result of germ
cell loss anri/or failure of spermatogenesis.
10.
DSD are defined as congenital conditions in which
development of chromosomal, gonadal, or anatomic sex is
atypicat and a oonsensus statement has been issued that calls
for patient-and-family centered care delivered by an integrated,
interdir;ciplinary team. The primary role of that team would be
to assr:ss all of these perspectives and provide care that is
founded on a patient-and family-centered model. Variability
exists across stakeholder groups in the key concerns affecting
young children/family with DSD. Interdisciplinary DSD
healthcare team development should account for varying
perspe ctives when counselling families and planning treatment.
<t
3l
;,
-J
1.
Whereas the resulting recommendations for holistic,
multidisciplinary care seem to have been implemented rapidly
in speciatized pediatric services around the world, adolescents
often experience difficulties in finding access to expert adult
care and gradually or abruptly cease medical follow-up. May
adults with a DSD have health related questions that remain
unanswered owing to a lack of evidence pertaining to the
natural evolution of the various conditions in later life stages.
L2.
From the above analysis, it clear that Chromosome
analysis 46 XY karyotype of the wife (first petitioner) cannot
abridge her chances to beget a child through Surrogacy.
13.
Begetting of
children, as outlined in
Dharmashastra, encompasses various essential aspects of
pfocreation. It is viewed as a means to continue lineage and
repay debts to the Pitrus, highlighting the responsibilities tied to
fatherhood. The act of having children carries significant
cultural and religious implications, promoting familial and
social duties crucial for societal continuity. Additionally, it
emphasizes the importance of offspring in Hindu texts,
particularly regarding the responsibilities of men in the process
of reproduction and family life.
L4-
Keeping in view the humiliation of childless parents,
the legislature in its wisdom enacted the Surrogacy (Regulation)
Act, 2O2.- which is a beneficial piece of legislation to help the
infertile couple to get rid of the social taboo of infertility. The Act
is actually a tool for women suffering from rare disorders, to
develop z. family and lead a normal married life.
15.
Undisputedly, the marriage certificate of the
petitioners shows that they are married; their Aadhar cards
show thrtt they are within the prescribed age bracket; they do
not have any surviving child either biologically or through
adoptiorL or through surrogacy earlier. Therefore, the action of
the 2nd respondent in refusing to issue Certificate of
Essentiudity and Eligibility in favour of petitioners by the
impugnr:d order on the ground of some chromosome defect in
the first petitioner is unwarranted.
16.
In similar circumstances, the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in Antn Muthiuel as tfnion of India [W.p.(s) (Civil) Nos,
756/20221 observed that 'it is stated that the petitioners, being
marriec, women, have a congenital disorder which is known as
Mayer-llokitansky-Kuster-Hauser (MRKH) syndrome, also
referrecl to as Mullerian Aplasia, characterized by aplasia of the
uterus and upper part of the vagina of the female with normal
secondary sex characteristics and a normal female karyotype
(46, xx). It is a condition which is stated to affect the
reprodrrctive system of the female and is caused by abnormal
development of the Mullerian ducts which are structures in the
embryo that develop into uterus, fallopian tubes, cervix and the
upper part of the vagina. tt is stated that the MRKH syndrome
involves absolute uterine factor infertility and the only option for
the persons with such disability to achieve biological
motherhood is through gestational surrogacy. on an elaborate
analysis of the Act, arguments of both sides, medical history
etc., the Hon'ble Supreme court opined that nothing can
override what is stipulated under Rule la(a) of the 2o2l Act''
The Hon'ble Supreme Court held as under:
"
We Iind substance in the arguments of the learned counsel
clearly
for the petitioner inasmuch as Rule 14 which is extracted above
owing to the
refers to the rvife as not being able to achieve parenthood
,,disability" on account of the absence of a uterus or repeatedly failed '
it
pregnancies, multiple pregnancies or an illness which makes
' impossible for a woman to carry a pregnancy to term or would make the
pregnancylife-threatening.Thejustificationfornecessitatinggestational
or the wife
surrogacy in Rule 14 is all related to the intending woman
anddoesnotrefertotheman/husbandatall.Thesaidprovisionsis
of a
woman-centric and relates to the medical or congenital condition
woman which impedes her from becoming a mother'
Tlrerefore,thewholeschemeoftheActrevolvesaroundthe
,.inability,,ofthewomantoconceiveandtogivebirthtoachildandthe
in Rule 14
medical indication necessitating gestational surrogacy
explainsthevariouscircumstanceswhichincapacitateordisablewomen
from having a normal pregnancy and having a child'"
17.
Apart from the above, in the case on hand' the
District Medical Board for surrogacy [U/sec' +(iii)(a)(l) of
the
I
I
,:j
li
lt
li
ll
II
il
il
2O2I Act] consisting of three members: Gynecologist,
ii
it
Pediatrician and the District Medical and Health oflicer as
ri
ii
chairpersion, examined petitioners and has given a certificate of
i
Medical Indication dated 23.o8.2o24. In para-1(d) of the
Certificate it is stated:
"1. Medical inclications necessitating gestational surrogacy, as per
Rule 14 of the Surrogacy (Regulationl Act,2021 & its Rules Dt. 21.06.2022:A woman ma)'opt for surrogacy if; -
(dl
Any illness that makes it impossible for woman to carr5r a
pregnanc5'to viability or pregnancy that is life threatening:
il
Cer:tificate for Donor Oocyte iu Surrogacy:
As per nerv amendment GST I l9(E) in exercise of power conveyed by
Section 5o o{' Surrogac_y (Regulation) Act the District Medical Board
certificate that Wife constituting the intending couple suflfers from Androgen
Insensitivity Syndrome, Karyotype xy absent ovaries and absent uterus
necessitating use of donor oocyte to avail the Surrogacy procedure."
18.
Following the above certilicate, the II AJCJ-cum-
AMM, F:.R. District at Kukatpally, allowed the Application of
petitionr:rs in s.R. No. 3927 of 2024 by order dared 26.0r.2024
holding "the application is allowed and the intending couple
shall hzrve the parentage and custody of the child to be born
through surrogacy."
19.
The l"t petitioner, as per the writ affidavit, is having
all phys;ical features of a woman; she is not a transgender and
she is Jit to lead conjugal life. To her ill-luck, she is suffering
from (lomplete Androgen Insensitivity syndrome (cAIS).
'<!
A
Because she is having CAIS problem and unable to give birth to
a child, she opted for surrogacy. otherwise, she would have
given birth to a child in the normal method. To extend a helping
,
I
hand to such a woman, the Government has enacted the
Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021. Denying her an opportunity to
get a child by Surrogacy method on the ground that she is not a
perfect weman is contrary to the letter and spirit of the 2o2l Act
and is nothing but denting the very purpose of ilne 2021 Act
itself.
20-
In view of the above, more particularly in view of the
certilication of the District Medical Board constituted under the
2021 Act that the wife-the first petitioner herein is suffering
from Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome, Karyotype Xy absent
ovaries and absent uterus necessitating use of donor oocyte to
avail the Surrogacy procedure, the impugned order of the 2"d
respondent dated 18.08.2025 rejecting the Application of
petitioners for issuance of certificate of Essentiality and
Eligibilily under the provisions of the 2021 Act, is not justiliahle
and is liable to be set aside, even on humanitarian grounds too.
21.
In the result, the Writ Petition is allowed and the
impugned order dated 18.O3.2025 is set aside. The 2nd
respondent is directed to issue Certificate of Essentiality and
I
I
a':
Eligibility lo petitioners under the provisions of the Surrogacy
(Regulatiotr) Act, 2021. No costs.
Consequently, the miscellaneous Applications, if
22.
any shall stand closed.
SD/- AHMED ABDULLA KHAN
ANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
ECTION OFFICER
To,
1. The Secretary Ministry of Health and F amily
(
lndia, Room No. 156-4, Nirman Bhava n, New Delhi-
HFW), Union of
1 Email
.secvhfiargnic.in
2. The ch;rirp^erson (commissioner, Health and Family welfare), Appropriate
Authorit'^ opposite DN/E Building, Dtv and H5 canipus, opp. Koti women's
_C-ollggq [oad, KutbiGuda, Sultan Bazar, Koti, Hyderabad, Telengana 500095. Email . md-nhm-chflru@telanRana. gov. in
3. One CC to M/s.P.D.VINEELA, Advocate. [OPUC]
4. One GC; to SRI N.BHUJANGA RAO, Deputy Solicitor General of lndia, High
Court fc'r the State of Telangana at Hydera6ad. [OPUC]
5. Two cc;s to GP for fi/edical, Health and Family welfare Department,, High
Court fcrr the State of Telangana at Hyderabad. [OUT]
6. Two CD Copies.
BSK
GJP /--
,W
ri{r&
:.1 .!-H
/!
<f't
HIGH COTIRT
DATED:0:3/03/2026
THE.> i.i
'..J
ORDER
WP.No.2Gg21 of 2O2S
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETIT
WITHC,UT C OSTS
,(S
t(tlx
I
ION
|s
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review