Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of Decision : 07.01.2026
+
LPA 800/2025 & CM APPL. 82745/2025, CM APPL. 82746/2025
DR. LAKSHAY BERIWAL
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Ankur Chibber, Mr. Avadh
Bihari Kaushik, Ms. Saloni Mahajan,
Mr. Prateek Goyal, sMr. Rishabh and
Mr. Anshuman, Advocates.
versus
GURU TEG BAHADUR HOSPITAL & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Ms. Avnish Ahlawat, SC and Mr.
N.K Singh, Ms. Aliza Alam,
Advocates for R-1 and 2.
Mr. Pushp Raj Yadav, Legal Assistant
R-1.
Mr. Anand Varma and Mr. Ayush
Gupta, Advocates for R-3.
Mr. Sudarshan Rajan, Mr. Hitan Bajaj
and Mr. Sambhav Sharma, Advocates
for R-4
Mr. Shiven Varma and Mr. Dhruv
Malik, Advocates for R-5.
CORAM:
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TEJAS KARIA
JUDGMENT
TEJAS KARIA, J. (ORAL)
1.
The present Appeal has been filed challenging the Judgement dated
24.12.2025 (“Impugned Judgement”) passed by the learned Single Judge
in W.P. (C) 19730/2025 (“Writ Petition”), whereby the Appellant’s Writ
Petition has been dismissed on the ground that administrative or policy
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:01:56
LPA 800/2025
decision taken by Respondent No. 1 - Hospital in granting No Objection
Certificate (“NOC”) to Respondent No. 5 for pursuing higher studies under
‘Sponsored Quota’ and rejecting the similar NOC to the Appellant on the
ground of inter se seniority between the Appellant and Respondent No. 5 is
a relevant factor for the issuance of NOC.
2.
The learned Counsel for the Appellant submitted that the Appellant
secured the All India Rank of 4358 as compared to Respondent No. 5, who
has secured Rank of 10032 in the All India Entrance Test conducted for
selecting the candidates for pursuing their Post Graduate (“PG”) courses
under the sponsored category. It was submitted that the Appellant joined as a
Medical Officer at Directorate General of Health Services, Government of
NCT of Delhi and after serving for about one and half year, the Appellant
was transferred to Respondent No. 1 - Hospital in April, 2022. After
completion of five years in service on 17.09.2025, the Appellant became
eligible for Study Leave as per Central Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1972
(“Rules”). The Appellant applied for permission of Respondent No. 1 Hospital to appear for All India Entrance Test for PG courses conducted by
All India Institute of Medical Sciences (“AIIMS”), New Delhi. On
30.10.2025, Respondent No. 1- Hospital issued the Sponsorship Certificate
in favour of the Appellant.
3.
Having secured All India Rank of 4358, in the counselling / seat
allocation, the Appellant was allocated seat in Nuclear Medicine at
Postgraduate Institute of Medical Education and Research (“PGIMER”),
Chandigarh under the sponsored category and an offer letter dated
18.12.2025 was issued to the Appellant to join PGIMER, Chandigarh for
pursuing his post-graduation in Nuclear Medicine on the sponsored seat
category. The Appellant requested Respondent No. 1 - Hospital to issue
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:01:56
LPA 800/2025
relieving orders and NOC and to Respondent No. 2 for grant of Study
Leave. However, Respondent No. 1 - Hospital vide Office Memorandum
dated 19.12.2025 (“Impugned OM”) rejected the request for grant of NOC
to the Appellant on the ground that in terms of the prevalent practice, the
senior doctor in Respondent No. 1 - Hospital has been recommended for
grant of Study Leave / NOC for pursuing PG course since only three
medical officers are allowed to join PG courses at a given time in terms of
Office Memorandum dated 02.11.2012 (“2012 OM”) issued by the Ministry
of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India. As there were already
two Medical Officers pursuing the higher studies, Respondent No. 5 was
granted NOC being senior to the Appellant and, consequently, the Appellant
was denied the Study Leave as well as NOC by Respondent No. 1 Hospital.
4.
Being aggrieved by the Impugned OM, the Appellant submitted a
Representation dated 19.12.2025 to Respondent No. 2 requesting that his
application for Study Leave be accepted considering the meritorious rank
secured by the Appellant in the examination. The Appellant also preferred
the Writ Petition challenging the Impugned OM on 23.12.2025. Vide
Impugned Judgment, the Writ Petition was dismissed by the learned Single
Judge. Hence, the Appellant has filed the present Appeal.
5.
The main grievance of the Appellant is that the Impugned OM solely
considered the seniority of Respondent No. 5 as basis for granting Study
Leave / NOC overlooking the merits of the Appellant having higher All
India Rank as compared to Respondent No. 5.
6.
The learned Counsel for the Appellant relied upon 2012 OM issued
by the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India,
relevant extract of which is as under:
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:01:56
LPA 800/2025
“6. Study leave may be granted to a CHS officer with due regard to the
exigency of public service to enable him/her to undergo, in or out of India, a
special course of study consisting of higher studies or specialized training in
a professional or technical subject having a direct and close connection with
the sphere of his/her duty.
7. Study leave may be granted for a course of training or study tour in which
a Medical Officer may not attend a regular academic or semi-academic
course if the course of training or the study tour is certified to be of definite
advantage to Government from the point of view of public interest and is
related to sphere of duties of the CHS officer.
8. For the purpose of studies connected with the framework or background
of public administration subject to the condition that the particular study or
study tour should be approved by the authority competent to grant leave, the
CHS officer should be required to submit on return, a full report on the work
done by him/her while on study leave and for studies which may not be
closely or directly connected with the work of CHS officer, but which are
capable of widening his/her mind in a manner likely to improve his/her
abilities as a civil servant and to equip him/her better to collaborate with
those employed in other branches of public service.
9. It should be certified by the competent authority that the proposed course
of study or training shall be of definite advantage from the point of view of
public interest and should be for prosecution of studies in subjects of other
than academic or literary subject.”
7.
It was submitted that as per 2012 OM, no criteria has been fixed for
selection of the candidate for grant of Study Leave to pursue PG course and
such course should be of definite advantage from the point view of public
interest. Hence, seniority cannot be the sole basis for inter se selection of the
candidates.
8.
The learned Counsel for the Appellant also relied upon the Office
Memorandum dated 27.10.2023 issued by Respondent No. 2 providing the
Standard Operating Procedure (“SOP”) for processing of cases related to
grant of leave for higher studies. It was submitted that even in the SOP, no
criteria has been provided for selection of the medical officers, who have
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:01:56
LPA 800/2025
qualified and been selected to pursue higher studies. Accordingly, in the
absence of any specific criteria having been provided in the 2012 OM and
SOP, the Impugned OM relying upon the prevalent practice of giving
preference to senior doctor and disregarding the merits was arbitrary. The
Impugned OM ought to have considered the public interest and the merits
instead of seniority for considering the issuance of NOC between the
Appellant and Respondent No. 5.
9.
The learned Counsel for the Appellant submitted that the Impugned
Judgement has wrongly held that the criterion of seniority has a reasonable
nexus with the object of Study Leave without giving any reason in support
thereof. The Impugned Judgment has held that the Impugned OM is neither
arbitrary nor irrational, which has caused irreparable prejudice to the
Appellant.
10.
It was submitted by the learned Counsel for the Appellant that it is a
settled law that a discretion has to be exercised fairly, judiciously and in
transparent manner by the authority without any arbitrariness or irrationality
when there is no guidance for exercise of such discretion either in 2012 OM
or the SOP. Accordingly, the Impugned Judgement requires interference in
this Appeal.
11.
The learned Counsel for the Appellant has relied upon the decision of
the Supreme Court in Sudhir N. and others v. State of Kerala and others
(2015) 6 SCC 685, which held that inter se merit amongst candidates
belonging to any given category alone can be the basis of admission. It was
held that inter se merit cannot be overlooked only to promote seniority. The
relevant extract of the judgment cited is as under:
“24. It is in the light of the above pronouncements futile to argue
that the impugned legislation can hold the field even when it is in
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:01:56
LPA 800/2025
clear breach of the Medical Council of India's Regulations. The
High Court was, in our opinion, right in holding that inasmuch as
the provisions of Section 5(4) of the impugned enactment provides a
basis for selection of candidates different from the one stipulated by
the MCI Regulations it was beyond the legislative competence of the
State Legislature. Having said that, the High Court adopted a
reconciliatory approach when it directed that seniority of the inservice candidates will continue to play a role provided the
candidates concerned have appeared in the common entrance test
and secured the minimum percentage of marks stipulated by the
Regulations. The High Court was, in our opinion, not correct in
making that declaration. That is because, even when in Gopal D.
Tirthani case [(2003) 7 SCC 83 : 2 SCEC 301] this Court has
allowed in-service candidates to be treated as a separate channel
for admission to postgraduate course within that category also
admission can be granted only on the basis of merit. A meritorious
in-service candidate cannot be denied admission only because he
has an eligible senior above him though lower in merit. It is now
fairly well settled that merit and merit alone can be the basis of
admission among candidates belonging to any given category. Inservice candidates belong to one category. Their inter se merit
cannot be overlooked only to promote seniority which has no place
in the scheme of the MCI Regulations. That does not mean that merit
based admissions to in-service candidates, cannot take into account
the service rendered by such candidates in rural areas. Weightage
for such service is permissible while determining the merit of the
candidates in terms of the third proviso to Regulation 9 (supra).
Suffice it to say that Regulation 9 remains as the only effective and
permissible basis for granting admission to in-service candidates,
provisions of Section 5(4) of the impugned enactment
notwithstanding. That being so, admissions can and ought to be
made only on the basis of inter se merit of the candidates determined
in terms of the said principle which gives no weightage to seniority
simpliciter.”
12.
The learned Counsel for the Appellant has submitted that the selection
between the Appellant and Respondent No. 5 ought to have been on the
basis of merit and not only on the seniority. Accordingly, the Impugned
Judgement deserves to be set aside.
13.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:01:56
We have heard the learned Counsel for the Appellant at length.
LPA 800/2025
14.
The Appellant has secured the All India Rank of 4358 in the entrance
test conducted by the AIIMS, Delhi and also secured a seat for MD in
Nuclear Medicine at PGIMER, Chandigarh under the sponsored category.
However, Respondent No. 1 - Hospital has refused the grant of Study Leave
/ NOC to the Appellant only on the ground that at a given time, only three
Medical Officers are permitted to pursue higher studies and as two Medical
Officers were already pursuing higher studies, there was vacancy for only
one Medical Officer, who can be granted Study Leave / NOC for pursuing
PG course. Therefore, Respondent No. 1 - Hospital had to choose between
the Appellant and Respondent No. 5.
15.
The Impugned OM has made a decision on the basis of the prevailing
practice of Respondent No. 1 - Hospital to select senior doctor for grant of
Study Leave / NOC. Accordingly, the Appellant was denied the grant of
Study Leave / NOC.
16.
The grievance of the Appellant is that the criterion of seniority cannot
be the sole ground on which the grant of Study Leave / NOC be decided. It
was submitted that in addition to the seniority, the merits and public interest
ought to have been taken into consideration by Respondent No. 1 - Hospital
for selecting the Appellant instead of Respondent No. 5, especially when
2012 OM and the SOP do not provide the criteria to be followed in case of
two candidates seeking the Study Leave / NOC and only one is to be
allowed.
17.
The Impugned Judgement has considered the grievance of the
Appellant and has concluded that the Impugned OM is neither arbitrary nor
unreasonable as the decision for selecting Respondent No. 5 instead of the
Appellant was arrived at relying upon the prevalent practice of giving
preference to the seniority of the candidates. The Impugned Judgement
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:01:56
LPA 800/2025
concludes that seniority can be a relevant factor for arriving at a decision
and the view taken is a possible one. The Impugned Judgement holds that
while dealing with the challenge to the policy decision, the power of judicial
review must be exercised only if the policy decision is contrary to law or
arbitrary and, therefore, the Impugned OM did not suffer from any legal or
factual error much less perversity. Accordingly, the Writ Petition was
dismissed.
18.
It is a settled law that the Court shall not sit as an Appellate Authority
over the administrative decision and only in exceptional circumstances; the
interference is to be made in the Writ jurisdiction as reiterated in the
Impugned Judgement.
19.
The Impugned Judgement considers the contention of the Appellant
that merit should be the basis for sanctioning the Study Leave and rejected
the said submission on the basis that the merit in the entrance test is for
allocation of seat and nature of course to be offered to the candidate and not
for the purpose of solving inter se issue between the two candidates of the
same institution with regard to sponsorship and grant of Study Leave / NOC.
For the same reason, the decision in Sudhir N. (supra), which is in relation
to the inter se selection for admission, does not apply to the facts of the
present case. This dispute is not regarding the admission in an institution,
but selection of one out of two candidates, who have already been admitted,
for administrative purposes as per 2012 OM, which is not under challenge
by the Appellant.
20.
We entirely agree with the reasons given in the Impugned Judgement,
which has followed the settled principles of law on the limited scope of
exercise of Writ jurisdiction in cases relating to exercise of discretion by an
administrative authority, when there is no arbitrariness or perversity.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:01:56
LPA 800/2025
21.
The grant of Study Leave / NOC is not a matter of right that the
Appellant can claim. It is entirely the discretion of Respondent No. 1 Hospital to select one candidate out of two, when there is only one position
available. In exercise of the said discretion, Respondent No. 1 - Hospital has
chosen seniority as the criteria as per the prevalent practice in Respondent
No. 1 – Hospital, which cannot be termed as arbitrary or capricious.
22.
Upon enquiry by the Court regarding the prevalent practice as
mentioned in the impugned OM, the learned Counsel for Respondent No. 1 Hospital submitted that even previously, the selection was based on the
criteria of seniority and, in fact, Respondent No. 5 was denied the Study
Leave / NOC in previous year even though she had qualified for higher
studies, on the ground of seniority and a preference was given to the medical
officer senior to Respondent No. 5. Therefore, it was just and fair that
Respondent No. 5 be given preference over the Appellant on the ground of
seniority as she was earlier denied the Study Leave / NOC on the very same
ground.
23.
We also inquired from the learned Counsel for the Appellant that if
there is any bar of age or number of attempts for pursuing higher studies in
future by the Appellant, to which it was responded that there is no such
restriction. Accordingly, no prejudice would be caused to the Appellant if
the Appellant applies again in future similar to Respondent No. 5, who was
previously denied the Study Leave / NOC and was granted preference this
time.
24.
Accordingly, we find no infirmity with the Impugned Judgement,
which has concluded that the Impugned OM is neither arbitrary nor
irrational and the view taken is a possible one.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:01:56
LPA 800/2025
25.
In view of the above analysis, the present Appeal is dismissed. No
order as to costs.
26.
In view of the above, pending applications stand disposed of.
TEJAS KARIA, J
DEVENDRA KUMAR UPADHYAYA, CJ
JANUARY 07, 2026/ ‘A’
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:01:56
LPA 800/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review