Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
UKHC010083242020
2026:UHC:5301-DB
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
Writ Petition Service Bench No.250 of 2020
Dr. Jaspal Singh Khatri
--Petitioner
Versus
Union Of India and Others
--Respondents
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Presence:
Mr. Abhijay Negi, learned counsel for petitioner.
Mr. Krishan Mohan Joshi, learned counsel holding brief of
Mr. V.K. Kaparuwan, learned Standing Counsel for Union
of India/respondent No.1.
Dr. Kartikey Hari Gupta, learned counsel for respondent
No.2-University.
Mr. Kaushal Sah Jagati, learned counsel for respondent
No.3.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Coram: Hon’ble Manoj Kumar Tiwari, J. (Oral)
Hon’ble Pankaj Purohit, J.
Petitioner
responded
to
advertisement
dated
22.08.2019 issued by H.N.B. Garhwal University, for the post
of Assistant Professor in the Department of History, including
Ancient Indian History, Culture and Archeology.
2.
Petitioner possesses Master’s Degree in History
besides Ph.D. Degree in the same Subject. He participated in
the
selection
process,
however,
he
was
not
recommended for appointment, instead respondent No.3 was
recommended and appointed.
3.
In this writ petition, petitioner has challenged
selection and appointment of respondent No.3 mainly on the
ground that he does not possess Post Graduate Degree in
History, but, he possesses Masters Degree in Ancient Indian
History,
Culture
and
Archeology
from
H.N.B.
Garhwal
University.
4.
It
transpires
that
the
Screening
Committee
consisting of 05 Members examined the question of eligibility
of all the candidates who applied pursuant to the aforesaid
advertisement and in its report dated 12.12.2019, Screening
UKHC010083242020
2026:UHC:5301-DB
Committee opined that both petitioner and respondent No.3
are eligible to participate in the selection, as they possess the
qualification needed for the post in-question. Thereafter,
another
Screening
Committee
appears
to
have
been
constituted, consisting of only 02 Members, namely Dean and
Head of concerned Department, to examine the question of
eligibility of all candidates for the post of Assistant Professor
in the Department of History, including Ancient Indian
History,
Culture
and
Archeology.
The
said
Committee
screened out respondent No.3 for the post in-question.
5.
Thereafter, third Screening Committee was again
constituted consisting of the same 02 Members namely Dean
and Head of concerned Department and this time, the
Screening
Committee
found
respondent
No.3
to
be
educationally qualified for the post in-question.
6.
Respondent No.3 appeared before the Selection
Committee and based on the recommendation of the said
Committee,
he
was
offered
appointment
as
Assistant
Professor in the Department of History, including Ancient
Indian History, Culture and Archeology.
7.
Learned counsel for petitioner submits that since,
the appointment was to be made in the Department of History
and the Post Graduate Degree possessed by respondent No.3
is not in History subject but in some other allied subject,
therefore, respondent No.3 could not have been selected for
appointment, when candidates with Post Graduation Degree
in History subject were available. He relies upon the report of
Second Screening Committee in support of his contention
that the Screening Committee found respondent No.3 to be
not eligible for appointment.
8.
Learned counsel for respondent No.2-University
submits
that
first
Screening
Committee,
which
found
respondent No.3 to be educationally qualified, alone was
constituted in terms of decision taken by the Executive
UKHC010083242020
2026:UHC:5301-DB
Council of the University in its meeting held on 04.10.2019,
which was attended by Deans of different Schools of the
University.
He
submits
that
the
other
two
Screening
Committees were not properly constituted, as they consisted
of only 02 Members, which was contrary to the decision taken
by the Executive Council in its meeting held on 04.10.2019.
9.
Learned counsel for respondent No.2-University
further submits that the contention that respondent No.3
does not possess Masters Degree in History, therefore, is not
eligible, is without substance. He submits that appointment
was to be made in the Department of History, including
Ancient Indian History, Culture and Archeology, therefore,
Post Graduate Degree possessed by respondent No.3 was
valid for appointment as per University Grants Commission
(UGC) Regulations.
10.
He
refers
to
Clause
4.1-1-A(i)
of
the
UGC
Regulations on minimum qualifications for appointment of
Teachers, notified on 18.07.2018. The relevant provision of
the Regulations is extracted below:For the Disciplines of Arts, Commerce, Humanities,
Education, Law, Social Sciences, Sciences, Languages,
Library Science, Physical Education, and Journalism &
Mass Communication.
1. Assistant Professor:
Eligibility (A or B) :
A. i) A Master‘s degree with 55% marks (or an equivalent grade
in a point-scale wherever the grading system is followed) in
a concerned/relevant/allied subject from an Indian
University, or an equivalent degree from an accredited
foreign university.
ii) Besides fulfilling the above qualifications, the candidate
must have cleared the National Eligibility Test (NET)
conducted by the UGC or the CSIR, or a similar test
accredited by the UGC, like SLET/SET or who are or have
been awarded a Ph. D. Degree in accordance with the
University Grants Commission (Minimum Standards and
Procedure for Award of M.Phil./Ph.D. Degree) Regulations,
2009 or 2016 and their amendments from time to time as
the case may be exempted from NET/SLET/SET.”
“4.1
11.
Learned counsel for respondent No.2-University
further contends that as per the UGC Regulations, Master’s
Degree with 55% marks in the concerned/relevant/allied
UKHC010083242020
2026:UHC:5301-DB
subject is required for appointment to the post of Assistant
Professor in any discipline. He submits that careful perusal of
provision
contained
in
Clause
(i)
of
4.1-1-A
of
UGC
Regulations, indicates that a candidate, who has Masters
Degree in the concerned or relevant or allied subject from an
Indian University, is eligible for appointment, provided he has
secured minimum 55% marks in Post Graduation. He
submits that the expression used in Clause (i) of 4.1-1-A of
the Regulations, namely ‘concerned’, ‘relevant’ and ‘allied’ are
separated by ‘slash’, which has to be read as ‘or’, therefore,
even if the contention made on behalf of petitioner is taken on
its face value that respondent No.3 possesses Masters Degree
in an allied subject, then also he cannot be declared as
ineligible in view of the express provision contained in the
relevant UGC Regulations.
12.
Learned counsel for respondent No.2-University
submits that in the present case, Masters Degree possessed
by respondent No.3 cannot be treated to be in an allied
subject, as name of subject in which respondent No.3
pursued Master’s Degree Course resonates with the name of
department in which he sought appointment. He submits that
since concerned department is known as department of
History, including Ancient Indian History, Culture and
Archeology and the Post Graduation Degree possessed by
respondent No.3 is also in Ancient Indian History, Culture
and Archeology, therefore, the qualification possessed by
respondent No.3 is appropriate for appointment in the
concerned department.
13.
Learned counsel for respondent No.3 contends
that the first Screening Committee was constituted as per
norms and the other two Committees were not properly
constituted.
He
submits
that
the
properly
constituted
Screening Committee consisting of 05 Members declared
respondent No.3 as eligible after examining his academic
UKHC010083242020
2026:UHC:5301-DB
qualifications, therefore, constitution of another Screening
Committee, was without any valid reason. He points out that
two members Screening Committee could not have overruled
the decision taken by five member committee. He submits
that the third Screening Committee also found respondent
No.3 to be eligible for the post in-question. He thus submits
that the challenge thrown by petitioner to the selection and
appointment of respondent No.3 is without any basis.
14.
We find substance in the submissions made on
behalf of respondents. As per UGC Regulations governing the
field, anyone who possesses Masters Degree in concerned or
relevant or allied subject from an Indian University with 55%
marks, is eligible for appointment as Assistant Professor. As
per the UGC Regulations, degree in ‘concerned’ or ‘relevant’ or
‘allied' subject are to be treated at par as it does not provide
any preference to a candidate having Masters Degree in
concerned subject. The expressions ‘concerned’, ‘relevant’ and
‘allied’, are separated by using slash, which signifies intention
of the rule making authority that these are interchangeable
and a candidate with any one of the three qualifications is
eligible. Thus, petitioner cannot claim to be better placed
merely because he possesses Masters Degree in History.
15.
The contention raised on behalf of respondents
that Masters Degree in Ancient Indian History, Culture and
Archeology possessed by respondent No. 3 resonates with the
name of the Department in which appointment is to be made,
has substance. Name of the department indicates that
instructions are imparted not only in History but also in
Ancient Indian History, Culture and Archeology. Thus,
respondent No. 3 cannot be, held to be ineligible by accepting
the contention of the petitioner.
16.
Learned counsel for respondent No.2-University
concedes that the second Screening Committee consisting of
02 Members did not include name of respondent No.3 in the
UKHC010083242020
2026:UHC:5301-DB
list of eligible candidates. He however could not give any
satisfactory reply to the query put by us as to what was the
occasion for constituting another Screening Committee when
the first Screening Committee, which was constituted as per
norms, found respondent No.3 to be eligible.
17.
The sheet anchor of case of the petitioner is the
report of the second Screening Committee, which impliedly
screened out respondent No.3. Selection. Appointment of
respondent No.3 cannot be disturbed based solely on the
opinion of the second Screening Committee especially when a
third Screening Committee with same composition as that of
second Screening Committee, found respondent No.3 to be
eligible for appointment.
18.
The
Screening
Committee
consists
of
Academicians who are experts in their respective field,
therefore, while exercising power of judicial review, this Court
cannot sit in judgment over the opinion of subject experts.
Moreover, the opinion given by Subject Experts is in
consonance of UGC Regulations. Since, subject experts found
respondent No.3 qualified for appointment, therefore, this
Court do not find any reason to interfere in the matter. The
reliefs as claimed by petitioner therefore cannot be granted.
19.
The
writ
petition
accordingly
fails
and
is
dismissed.
20.
Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
(Pankaj Purohit, J.)
PN/PREETI
NEGI
(Manoj Kumar Tiwari, J.)
02.07.2026
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND,
ou=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND,
2.5.4.20=63c75a8c4765581180a58d7478fadbe383
31bac55c78b5f9f0276c16432f6aab,
postalCode=263001, st=UTTARAKHAND,
serialNumber=2BA53171893B3C3CB3CCCAE81FA
E064498483A83D84BDB0F9229D5BF08D959AC,
cn=PREETI NEGI
Date: 2026.07.06 15:55:08 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review