Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010731392017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
SATURDAY,THE THIRTY FIRST DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM
WRIT PETITION NO: 18603 OF 2017
Between:
1. Dr.G.Sri Ranganayakulu, S/o G.Ramachandraiah, 41 Years, Assistant
Professor in Botany Rayalseema University, Kurnool, Kurnool District,
Andhra Pradesh
2. Dr.M.Nagabhushan Reddy, S/o M.Ram Reddy, 41 Years, Asst. Professor
in Zoology, Rayalseema University, Kurnool, Kurnool District, Andhra
Pradesh
3. Dr.M.Venkata Chandrudu, S/o Late M.Sreeramulu, 37 Years, Asst.
Professor in Zoology, Rayalseema University, Kurnool, Kurnool District,
Andhra Pradesh
...Petitioners
AND
1. Rayalaseema University, Rep. by its Registrar, Kurnool, Kurnool District,
State of Andhra Pradesh,
2. State Council of Higher Education, Represented by its Chairman,
Veereshalingam Bhavan, Khairthabad, Hyderabad.
3. State of Andhra Pradesh, Represented by its Principal Secretary, Higher
Education Department, Secretariat, Velagapudi, Guntur District.
...Respondents
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in
the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may
be pleased to grant appropriate relief more in the nature of Writ of
Mandamus under Article 226 of the Constitution of India declaring the
Circular No. RU/Teaching Estt./Circular/2017, dt. 18.05.2017 issued by the
1St Respondent as arbitrary, illegal, malafide, discriminatory and
unconstitutional violating Article 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution of India
and set aside the same in so far as the Petitioners are concerned and issue
consequential directions restraining the Respondents from replacing the
Petitioners by any other contract lecturers in pursuance of the Circular No.
RU/Teaching Estt./Circular/2017, dt. 18.05.2017 and issue further directions
directing the Respondents to continue the Petitioners as contract lecturers
till regularizing their services against regular posts and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2017(WPMP 22700 OF 2017
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances
stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be
pleased to direct the Respondents not to replace the Petitioners by any
other contract lecturers in pursuance of the Circular No. RU/Teaching
Estt./Circular/2017, dt. 18.05.2017 and continue the Petitioners in service.
IA NO: 2 OF 2017(WPMP 22701 OF 2017
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances
stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be
pleased to suspend the operation of the Memorandum in proceedings
No.ANU/TS-Estt/T.S on Con.Basis/Interviews/2017,dt.17.04.2017 issued by
the 1st Respondent in so far as the Petitioners are concerned pending
disposal of the Writ Petition.
Counsel for the Petitioners: P V KRISHNAIAH
Counsel for the Respondents: P HARINATH GUPTA
Counsel for the Respondents: N VIJAYA SANTHI SC FOR
RAYALASEEMA UNIVERSITY KURNOOL
The Court made the following order:
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM
WRIT PETITION No.18603 of 2017
ORDER:
The writ petition is filed under Article 226 of Constitution of India,
seeking the following main prayer:“……..declaring
Estt./Circular/2017,
dt.
the
Circular
18.05.2017
No.
issued
RU/Teaching
by
the
1St
Respondent as arbitrary, illegal, malafide, discriminatory and
unconstitutional violating Article 14, 16 and 21 of the
Constitution of India and set aside the same in so far as the
Petitioners are concerned and issue consequential directions
restraining the Respondents from replacing the Petitioners by
any other contract lecturers in pursuance of the Circular No.
RU/Teaching Estt./Circular/2017, dt. 18.05.2017 and issue
further directions directing the Respondents to continue the
Petitioners as contract lecturers till regularizing their services
against regular posts and pass…….”
2.
Heard Sri S.Karunakar, learned counsel representing Sri
P.V.Krishnaiah, learned counsel for the petitioners, Smt. N. Vijay
Santhi, learned Standing Counsel for the 1st respondent University
and the learned Assistant Government Pleader for Higher Education.
Brief case of the petitioners:
3.
The petitioners, consequent to the notifications issued by
Sri Krishnadevaraya University, Ananthapur, for appointment of
Teaching Assistants, after going through the interview process
conducted by the select committee constituted by the said University,
were appointed as Teaching Assistants in the years 2006-2007 in
Botany and Zoology subjects respectively. Later on, the petitioners
were transferred to S.K. University, P.G. Center at Kurnool.
4.
On an establishment of the 1st respondent Rayalaseema
University at Kurnool by the enactment i.e., Act No.29/2008 dated
24.09.2008 by the 3rd respondent Government, the petitioners
continued to work as Assistant Professors on contract basis at the 1st
respondent Rayalaseema University, Kurnool and completed 11 years
of service in the cadre of Assistant Professors.
5.
It is the case of the petitioners that even though the petitioners
are working in the teaching side for more than 10 years as Assistant
Professors without any blemish, the 1st respondent University has not
regularized the petitioners’ services and continued to pay the salaries
on adhoc basis, which is less than the salaries that are being paid to
the regular posts even though the duties discharged by the petitioners
are similar to the regular employees.
6.
The 1st respondent University being the autonomous increasing
posts and subjects day by day, however, denying for payment of
minimum time scale to the petitioners on par with regular lecturers,
who worked for 10 years on adhoc basis at the 1st respondent
University and it is the minimum obligation of the 1st respondent
University to treat the equals as equals and regularize the services of
the petitioners in view of the decisions rendered by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India.
7.
While so, to the petitioners’ utter disgrace, the 1st respondent
University has issued the impugned circular dated 18.05.2017 and
chosen to recruit the Assistant Professors/Teaching Assistants on
temporary basis and asked the Assistant Professors/Teaching
Assistants, who are presently working on contract basis in respective
departments, to submit their applications. Hence, having left with no
other option, the petitioners filed the present writ petition seeking
direction against the action of the respondents from replacing the
petitioners by another contract lecturers in pursuance to the impugned
circular and also seeking direction against the respondents to
continue them as contract lecturers till regularizing their services
against the regular posts.
Brief case of the respondents:
8.
During the course of arguments, the learned Standing Counsel
for the 1st respondent University in view of the identical facts and
circumstances, adopted the counter affidavit filed in connected matter
i.e., W.P.No.21904 of 2017, wherein, it is stated that the petitioners
were engaged purely on a temporary and contractual basis as
Teaching Assistants/Assistant Professors without undergoing the
regular selection process prescribed by UGC regulations. The
engagement was for a limited period of approximately 11 months in
a year, initially at a consolidated salary of Rs. 15,000/- per month,
which was subsequently enhanced to Rs.20,000/- and presently
Rs.30,000/- per month on mutually agreed terms. There was no
notification or constitution of a selection committee with external
subject experts at the time of initial engagement, and the petitioners
had no vested right to ask for continuation or regularization of their
services.
9.
Regular teaching posts in the 1st respondent University were
sanctioned only through G.O.Ms.No.33 dated 30.06.2017 issued by
the Government of Andhra Pradesh. Since the 1st respondent
University recruited seven Professors on a regular basis and
distributed the teaching workload among existing regular faculty as
per UGC norms. In view of the reduced workload, there is no further
requirement for the services of temporary/contractual faculty as the
petitioners.
10.
According to the 1st respondent University, all temporary
engagements were made in accordance with the guidelines of the
Andhra Pradesh State Council of Higher Education (A.P.S.C.H.E.)
and the State Government to meet immediate academic needs
pending sanction of regular posts. Contractual faculty appointments
are subjected to annual performance review, and there is no provision
for automatic regularization or absorption into regular service without
undergoing
the
prescribed
regular
allegations
of
irregularity
and
selection
entitlement
procedure.
for
The
continuation/
regularization raised by the petitioners are baseless, and the
1strespondent University has acted upon in full compliance with
statutory norms without any retractions whatsoever.
Submissions of the respective counsel:
11.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that in order to
interdict the petitioners’ services, the 1st respondent university issued
circular dated 12.05.2017, proposing to appoint a set of adhoc
employees in the category of Assistant Professors on the very same
contract basis in place of the petitioners and issued an advertisement
on 13.05.2017. The learned counsel restricts instant lis mainly on the
ground that though the petitioners are working for a long period, the
1st respondent authorities are contemplating to replace them and other
contract employees with another set of contract employees for oblique
reasons, which is arbitrary and illegal.
Though the petitioners raised several averments in respect of
their other issues, such as, regularization of their services, he fairly
submits that they are pursuing their remedies by way of filing other
cases etc.
To substantiate his assertions, the learned counsel relies
on the judgment of Rattan Lal & Ors. Vs. State of Haryana1 and
Manish Gupta Vs. President, Jan Bhagidari Samiti2.
12.
On the other hand, the learned standing counsel for the 1st
respondent University Smt.N.Vijaya Santhi, while reiterating the
contentions made in the counter affidavit in connected matter i.e.,
W.P.No.21094 of 2017, fairly submits that there is no dispute that the
petitioners were appointed on contract basis in the 1st respondent
University.
She also submits that in terms of the interim order dated
09.06.2017, the petitioners are continuing to work in the 1st
respondent University.
She further submits that the 1st respondent
University issued two notifications to fill up the posts through regular
appointments permanently, due to the administrative exigencies, the
(1985) 4 SCC 43
(2022) 15 SCC 540
same were not fructified. Hence, as on today no notification has been
issued for selection process of regular employees towards teaching
staff in the 1st respondent university. She also contended that in view
of reduced workload, there is no further requirement for the services of
the petitioners.
Consideration of the Court:
13.
This Court has considered the rival submissions made by both
counsel and has gone through the material available on record.
14.
In view of nature of facts and circumstances involved in the lis,
the core point emanated in the instant lis is:
“Whether the petitioners being contract employees in the 1st
respondent university can be substituted by another set of
contract employees in the absence of regular appointment
through proper notification?
15.
Before dwelling into the facts involved in the lis, it is relevant to
note the well settled legal principles crystallized by the Apex Court in
the very core point emanated in the instant case. It is pertinent to
note that in the Rattan Lal case relied by the learned counsel for the
petitioners, the Apex Court upheld the claim to replace a temporary
worker with someone hired through proper, fair procedures (regular
employees), not just another temporary person, preventing arbitrary
"hire-and-fire" cycles and ensuring fairness and consistent service for
essential, perennial jobs. This case is notable for the fact that duty
cannot be defeated by a continuous cycle of temporary appointments.
The relevant portion of the said dictum read as under:
“….1. These ad hoc teachers are unnecessarily subjected to
an arbitrary “hiring and firing” policy. These teachers who
constitute the bulk of the educated unemployed are compelled
to accept these jobs on an ad hoc basis with miserable
conditions of service. The Government appears to be exploiting
this situation. This is not a sound personnel policy. It is bound
to have serious repercussions on the educational institutions
and the children studying there. The policy of “ad hocism”
followed by the State Government for a long period has led to
the breach of Article 14 and Article 16 of the Constitution. Such
a situation cannot be permitted to last any longer.”
“......2. direct the State Government to take immediate
steps to fill up in accordance with the relevant rules the
vacancies in which teachers appointed on an ad hoc basis are
now working and to allow all those teachers who are now
holding these posts on ad hoc basis to remain in those posts till
the vacancies are duly filled up. The teachers who are now
working on such ad hoc basis if they have the prescribed
qualification may also apply for being appointed regularly in
those posts. The State Government may also consider
sympathetically the question of relaxing the qualification of
maximum age prescribed for appointment to those posts in the
case of those who have been victims of this system of “ad hoc”
appointments. If any of the petitioners in these petitions has
under any existing rule acquired the right to be treated as a
regularly appointed teacher, his case shall be considered by
the State Government and an appropriate order may be.
passed in his case....”
16.
The dictum as held in Rattan Lal case by the Apex Court was with
regard to repeatedly appointing teachers on temporary/adhoc basis by
terminating their services before summer vacation and re-appointing new
adhoc teachers. Thereafter, this practice led to artificial breaks in service
and was deprecated by the Apex Court.
17.
In the case of State of Haryana v. Piara Singh 3 , the Apex
Court had authoritatively held that adhoc or temporary employees
must be in strict conformity with the constitutional requirements of
fairness, transparency, and equal opportunity in public employment as
enshrined under Articles 14 and also held that action of merely
replacing temporary employees with another set of adhoc workers to
be constitutionally impermissible. The relevant portion of the said
judgment is extracted as under:
“….46. Secondly, an ad hoc or temporary employee should
not be replaced by another ad hoc or temporary employee; he
must be replaced only by a regularly selected employee. This is
necessary to avoid arbitrary action on the part of the appointing
authority.”
“….47. Thirdly, even where an ad hoc or temporary
employment is necessitated on account of the exigencies of
administration, he should ordinarily be drawn from the
employment exchange unless it cannot brook delay in which
case the pressing cause must be stated on the file. If no
candidate is available or is not sponsored by the employment
exchange, some appropriate method consistent with the
(1992) 4 SCC 118
requirements of Article 16 should be followed. In other words,
there must be a notice published in the appropriate manner
calling for applications and all those who apply in response
thereto should be considered fairly.”
18.
In the case of Secretary, State of Karnataka and others v.
Umadevi and Ors., the Constitutional Bench (Five judge Bench) of the
Apex Court explained that when the government hires someone on an
adhoc or temporary basis, it is meant only as a stop-gap arrangement until
a regular, lawful recruitment is made, and if the government wants to
replace an adhoc employee, it must do so only by appointing a regular,
properly selected candidate through the established recruitment process,
this ensures transparent and lawful recruitment. It is clear that the
Constitution Bench, for adhoc or Temporary employees, considered the
main aspect i.e., substitution of adhoc employees cannot be replaced with
another set of adhoc employees but with regular employees only.
It has
further discussed about the ratio held in Piara Singh case that adhoc or
temporary employee should not be replaced by another adhoc or temporary
employee, has not been unsettled.
19.
In other words, this aspect of principle of adhoc employee cannot be
replaced by adhoc employee was not set aside and overruled. Hence,
even after the dictum of Umadevi, the authoritative pronouncement in Piara
Singh is still stands good and continues to hold the field.
20.
In fact, this facet came up in the case of Dr. Barindar Singh Kaur
Vs. Guruvundar4, the Punjab and Haryana High Court in its vivid terms
explained that a proposition and ratio held in Piara Singh case is with
regard to temporary employee who should not be replaced by another
temporary employee, which was not disagreed in Umadevi dictum by the
Constitutional Bench. Para No.16 of Dr. Barindar Singh Kaur case reads
as under:“16…… it is clear that the Constitution Bench in the
case of Umadevi (supra) only disagreed with the last
direction in Piara Singh’s case (supra) which pertained
to
regularization
of
adhoc,
temporary
or
causal
employees. The direction in Piara Singh’s (supra) that
adhoc or temporary employees should not be replaced by
other adhoc or temporary employees and should only be
replaced by regularly selected employees was also
considered but not disagreed with…….”
21.
The Hon’ble Division Bench of Kerala High Court in Cochin
University of Science and Technology, Represented by its Registrar &
Ors. Vs. Sudheesh Kumar P.S. & Ors.5, in its vivid terms held as under:“……..11.
As rightly pointed out by the learned
counsel for the petitioners, the principle that a temporary
employee shall not be replaced by another temporary
employee and that he shall be replaced only by a regular
employee, is a principle consistently followed the Apex Court
and various High Courts. As clarified by the High Court of
Punjab and Haryana in Dr. Barinder Kaur, the said
proposition as reiterated in Piara Singh was not disagreed
2015 SCC Online P&H 12156
2023 SCC Online Ker 913
with by the Constitutional bench of the Apex Court in
Umadevi (3), though it was held Umadevi (3) that such
employees do not have any right to claim regularisation and
that their engagement ends when their term ends. Of
course, the said principle cannot be applied when
engagement on daily wage basis is governed by statutory
rules.”
22.
It is apt to note the relevant details of the petitioners in tabulated
format for the sake of comprehensive view, as under:Sl.
No.
23.
Name of the
petitioner/s
Designation
Subject
1.
Dr.G.Sri
Ranganayakulu
Assistant Professor
(Contract)
Botony
2.
Dr.M.Nagabhushan
Reddy
Assistant Professor
(Contract)
Zoology
3.
Dr.M.Venkata
Chandrudu
Assistant Professor
(Contract)
Zoology
Evidently, at the time of institution of the lis, this Court granted
interim order dated 09.06.2017, and the same is in subsistence as on
today. Thus, the petitioners are continuing to work right from their
appointment on contract basis in the 1st respondent University.
24.
It is also not in dispute that engagement of the petitioners in the
1st respondent university on contract basis is more than 10 years,
which was extended by the respondents from time to time till now
also. Even according to the version of the 1st respondent university
also, there are no allegations against the petitioners in respect of
dereliction of duties (or) indiscipline while extending their services in
the 1st respondent university.
25.
At this juncture, it is pertinent to go through the impugned
circular / notification and its modalities prescribed therein to arrive at a
logical conclusion in the instant lis. A close perusal of the impugned
circular dated 18.05.2017 and notification dated 12.05.2017 go to
show that, 1st respondent university authorities intended to fill up
Assistant Professor/Teaching Assistant posts on contract (purely
temporary) basis only. Thus, ex facie, the notification issued by the 1st
respondent university not relates to filling up regular posts on
permanent basis.
26.
Admittedly, the 1st respondent university was established way
back in the year 2008 and thereafter, the said institution has
transformed from one branch to another branch in its own by
expanding
its
academic
interruption.
Given
its
and
administrative
progressive
growth
structure
and
without
uninterrupted
functioning, the university could not have dispensed with its
employees in a manner that would adversely affect the academic
calendar and the interests of students. In fact, even as per assertion of
the 1st respondent university also two notifications were issued in order to
fill up the regular teaching posts. But the said notifications stalled due to
other reasons, which itself clearly contradicts the version of 1st respondent
university that there is no workload for faculty staff.
27.
In the case of Hargurpratap Singh v. State of Punjab6, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court stated that experienced adhoc employees
should be permitted to continue in their roles until regular employees
are made through proper selection procedures. This prevents arbitrary
terminations for the sole purpose of hiring new temporary staff. It
balances the need for adherence to constitutional recruitment
processes with the need for fairness to existing employees and
administrative continuity in public service, as held under:
“….3.The course adopted by the High Court is to displace
one ad hoc arrangement by another ad hoc arrangement
which is not at all appropriate for these persons who have
gained experience which will be more beneficial and useful to
the colleges concerned rather than to appoint persons afresh
on ad hoc basis.
28.
In the case of Manish Gupta and another v. President, JAN
BHAGIDARI SAMITI and Ors.,7 the Apex court by relying upon the
authoritative dictums held in Rattanlal and Hargurpratap Singh
Cases (stated supra), reiterated the same without any retractions.
29.
In the light of above legal position, this Court finds that when a
contractual employee is engaged for a specific purpose or tenure
(2007) 13 SCC 292
(2022) 15 SCC 540
under a defined agreement and does not form part of the permanent
cadre, but, where the duties performed are perennial, continuous, and
essential to the functioning of the establishment, the employer is
under a legal obligation to fill such posts through regular and fair
recruitment procedures.
30.
The practice of replacing one ad-hoc or contractual employee
with another adhoc or contractual employee amounts to an abuse of
the
contractual
system.
It
effectively
perpetuates
temporary
employment for work of a permanent nature, thereby defeating the
very object of regular appointment and undermining the principles of
fairness and equality in public employment.
31.
The
Court
is
of
the considered
view that contractual
appointments may only operate as a temporary bridge until a regularly
selected candidate is appointed. Once the need for the post is shown
to be ongoing and essential, the employer cannot justify the
continuation of contractual engagement by successive temporary
appointments. Any replacement of a contractual employee must
therefore be done by a duly selected regular employee, and not by
another contractual or adhoc appointee. Permitting otherwise would
allow the employer to indefinitely avoid regular recruitment, resulting in
arbitrary employment practices and denying eligible candidates the
opportunity to compete for regular appointment through proper
channels, which cannot be sustained in law.
32.
Before parting with the present case, it is deemed to be
appropriate to mention that the responsibility of imparting education is
not an optional administrative exercise of the State, but a binding
constitutional mandate linked to the future of the nation by virtue of
Article 21-A (Right to Education) of Constitution of India. Education is
not a mere administrative function of the State, but a constitutional
obligation intimately connected with the future of the nation.
Universities are temples of learning where continuity, academic
stability and sustained teacher–student engagement are statutes for
maintaining standards of higher education.
33.
The frequent engagement and disengagement of Assistant
Professors on adhoc or contractual basis disrupts fragments academic
planning and directly impairs the quality of education imparted to
students, who are the ultimate stakeholders in the educational
process.
34.
Very recently on 30.01.2026, the Hon’ble Apex Court in Dr.
Jaya Thakur v. Government of India8 in W.P.(C) No. 1000 of 2022,
2026 INSC 97
established a strong, purposeful view about the importance of Right
To Education for every child and it is part of shaping the child’s future
into better way to live. The relevant portion of the said judgment reads
as follows:
“...17. Education is a fundamental human right, as it ensures full and
holistic development of a human being. It is a stepping stone towards
realizing other human rights. Education is an integral part of dignity of
a child. It is a right, not a charitable concession. It promotes the
physical and cognitive development of a child. It also contributes to the
realization of the full potential of an individual. Most importantly, it
shapes a person’s sense of identity and affiliation.”
35.
At the same time, adhoc teachers, who discharge duties
identical to those of regular faculty against sanctioned posts, cannot
be treated as disposable resources, subjected to recurring insecurity
of tenure and livelihood. Such a system not only undermines the
dignity of labour and the right to livelihood but also erodes institutional
memory and academic excellence. Our Indian Constitution mandates
under Articles 14, 21 and 21-A that the State and its instrumentalities
have to balance the right of students to quality and stable education
with fair, non-arbitrary employment practices, ensuring that temporary
arrangements do not become a permanent mode of administration at
the cost of both educational standards and human dignity.
36.
In view of the above discussion and also the authoritative
constitutional dictums of the Hon’ble Apex Court as detailed supra,
this Court is inclined to allow the writ petition with the following
directions:i.
The petitioners herein would be entitled to
continue in their respective posts till the posts are
replaced by the permanent candidates by following the
due procedure established by law, subject to the
availability of a sufficient number of students for the
courses for which, the petitioners were appointed.
ii.
The respondent authorities be at liberty to issue
a fresh notification inviting applications for filling up the
said posts on a regular/permanent basis in accordance
with law.
iii. It is made clear that this order shall not preclude
the respondent authorities from initiating appropriate
disciplinary proceedings, if any, in accordance with law.
There shall be no order as to costs. As a sequel, all pending
applications shall stand closed.
______________________________
MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM, J
Date:31.01.2026
Rns
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM
WRIT PETITION No.18603 of 2017
Date:31.01.2026
Rns
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review