Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:18894
IN THE HIGH COURT OF
JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
Cr. Revision No. 1000 of 2022
--------Dr. Mani Bhushan Prasad, aged about 64 years, S/o-Late Satya Narayan
Prasad, Resident of A-30, Harmu Housing Colony, P.O. & P.S.-Argora,
District-Ranchi
… … Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand
2. Dwarika Singh, S/o-Ramkishan Singh, R/o-Lewada, P.O. & P.S.Tilauthu, Dist.-Rohtas (Bihar)
…. Opp. Parties
With
Cr. Revision No. 1052 of 2022
--------1. Dr. Akhouri Durganandan Prasad @ Dr. A. Durganandan Prasad, aged
about 70 years, Son of Late Akhouri Ravi Nandan Prasad, resident ofHospital Road, Gumla, P.O. & P.S.-Gumla, District-Gumla (Jharkhand)
2. Dr. Jemma Lakra, aged about 72 years, wife of Vijay Khalkho, resident
of-D.S.P. Road, Gumla, P.O. & P.S.-Gumla, District-Gumla (Jharkhand)
… … Petitioners
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand
2. Dwarika Singh, S/o-Ramkishan Singh, permanent resident of GramLewda, P.O. & P.S.-Tilauthu, Dist.-Rohtas (Bihar), presently residing at
Palkot Road, P.O. & P.S.-Gumla, District-Gumla
…. Opp. Parties
For the Petitioners
For the Opp. Party
For the O.P. No.2
---------: Mr. Mohit Prakash, Advocate
Mrs. Vani Kumari, Advocate
[Cr. Rev. No.1000 of 2022]
Mr. Mukesh Kr. Sinha, Advocate
Mr. Debarsi Mondal, Advocate
Mr. Ankit Apurva, Advocate
[Cr. Rev. No.1052 of 2022]
: Mrs. Priya Shrestha, Spl.P.P. (through V.C.)
Mrs. Ruby Pandey, A.P.P.
: Mr. Dwarika Singh, In person
Mrs. Anupama Kaushal, Advocate
--------PRESENT
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE PRADEEP KUMAR SRIVASTAVA
ORDERS
----------Cr. Revision Nos.1000 and 1052 of 2022
2026:JHHC:18894
CAV On 12.06.2026
Pronounced on 29/06/2026
1. Heard Mr. Mohit Prakash and Mr. Mukesh Kumar Sinha, learned
counsel for the respective parties as well as learned counsel for the State
assisted by Mr. Dwarika Singh in person and Mrs. Anupama Kaushal,
learned counsel for the opposite party No.2.
2. Both the above criminal revisions are arising out of common order,
hence are heard together and being disposed of by common order.
3. Instant criminal revisions have been preferred against the order dated
05.08.2022 passed by learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Gumla in
connection with Complaint Case No.22 of 1996 wherein Cr.
Application Nos.986 and 987 of 2022 filed by the petitioners under
section 245 of Cr.P.C. to discharge them from the accusation levelled
against them have been rejected by the concerned trial court.
Factual Matrix:4. Factual matrix giving rise to these revisions is that the complainant,
Dwarika Singh has lodged a complaint case stating inter alia that in the
night of 22.01.1996 at about 9:00 pm, his wife felt abdominal pain.
Thereafter, the complainant visited to Sadar Hospital, Gumla and came
to know that Dr. Mani Bhushan was at night duty but he was not present
in the hospital, then the informant went to the residence of Dr. Mani
Bhushan and requested him for providing a vehicle of the hospital to
bring his wife to the hospital, but he refused and suggested the
Cr. Revision Nos.1000 and 1052 of 2022
2026:JHHC:18894
complainant to visit Dr. Jemma Lakra, but on request, she also refused
to provide a hospital vehicle. It is further alleged that due to delay in
treatment, the wife of the complainant started bleeding while she was
carrying a pregnancy of four months. The complainant made
communication with DDC, Gumla, who provided his own car and the
complainant brought his wife to Sadar Hospital and admitted for her
treatment. It is further alleged that Dr. Jemma Lakra had clinically
examined the complainant’s wife and told that pregnancy has been
terminated and rest cleaning will be started from next morning and she
also prescribed some medicines. The complainant purchased medicines
and injections as prescribed and after giving injection and medicines to
the complainant’s wife, Dr. Jemma Lakra went to her own residence.
On the next day at about 10:30 am, Dr. Jemma Lakra along with Dr.
Akhauri Durga Nandan Prasad visited the complainant’s wife and asked
the complainant to fill and sign a Risk Bond. Then, the complainant
went out to bring medicines. In the meantime, the wife of the
complainant was also pressurized to sign a Risk Bond but she refused
then Dr. Lakra abused her. It is further alleged that when the
complainant returned and was asking Dr. Lakra regarding misbehave
with his wife then Dr. Akhauri Durga Nandan Prasad started abusing
him and pointed out pistol towards chest of the complainant and took
Cr. Revision Nos.1000 and 1052 of 2022
2026:JHHC:18894
out Rs.5,000/- from his pocket and dashed him out of the hospital
premises.
5. Learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Gumla after conducting inquiry
under section 202 of Cr.P.C summoned the accused persons vide order
dated 03.02.2014 for commission of offences under sections 323, 504
and 379 of IPC. The petitioner, Mani Bhushan Prasad filed Cr.M.P.
No.2821 of 2014 under section 482 of Cr.P.C. for quashing the
summoning order as well as entire proceeding of the complaint case in
which notices were issued to the complainant and the case was fixed for
22.01.2015 and till then further proceeding before trial court was stayed
and continued vide order dated 22.04.2016 till the next date of hearing.
Later on the petitioner, Mani Bhushan Prasad opted to withdraw his
criminal miscellaneous petition, which was dismissed as withdrawn
vide order dated 31.08.2022. In the meantime, learned trial court
vacating the interim order, proceeded to take before charge evidence of
the complainant, then discharge petition under section 245 of Cr.P.C.
was filed by the petitioners, which were rejected vide order dated
05.08.2022 (herein after called as the impugned order)
Submission on behalf of petitioners:6. Assailing the impugned order, it is submitted on behalf of petitioner, Dr.
Mani Bhushan Prasad in Cr. Revision No.1000 of 2022 that in the entire
complaint and sworn affirmation of complainant and the evidence of
Cr. Revision Nos.1000 and 1052 of 2022
2026:JHHC:18894
another inquiry witness, no allegation is levelled against him except that
he was asked to provide ambulance and he suggested to meet Dr.
Jemma Lakra. Therefore, no offence is constituted against him at all.
On behalf of petitioners, Dr. Jemma Lakra and Dr. Akhauri
Durga Nanda Prasad in Criminal Revision No.1052 of 2022, it is
submitted that no ambulance was provided to the complainant for
bringing his wife to hospital. Later on, the vehicle was managed by
DDC, Gumla. It is simply alleged that the complainant was asked to
sign on the Risk Bond and while he went out to bring medicines, his
wife was compelled to sign on Risk Bond in his absence and upon
refusal, she was abused by Dr. Lakra. The allegation against petitioner,
Dr. Akhauri Durga Nandan Prasad is that he whipped out pistol and put
on the chest of the complainant and robbed Rs.5,000/-. It is further
submitted that the entire case is purely an ornamental story to make the
case serious and deliberately. No FIR was lodged. Moreover, the
hospital is a public place where several patients and attendants along
with staffs remain present at all time but the complainant has examined
only his wife as an inquiry witness as well as before charge evidence
under section 244 of Cr.P.C. The prosecution evidence if remains unrebutted and taken to be true on its face value, no conviction could be
warranted against the petitioners.
Cr. Revision Nos.1000 and 1052 of 2022
2026:JHHC:18894
7. Learned counsel for the petitioners has further submitted that a
discharge application in a warrant trial case instituted, otherwise, than a
police report requires strong evidence for framing charge. The provision
makes a greater responsibility and stringent availability of evidence
before charge, constituting the proposed offences for which charge has
to be framed. Learned trial court has miserably failed to appreciate
before charge evidence adduced in this case and without following the
yardsticks laid down under section 245 of Cr.P.C, the discharge petition
of the petitioners have been dismissed. All the judgments of Hon’ble
Apex Court, pertaining to discharge applications under sections 227 and
239 of Cr.P.C, has been considered, which are based on different
considerations. Therefore, impugned order is liable to be set aside and
these matters be remitted back to the concerned trial court for re-hearing
and passing fresh orders in accordance with law.
Submission on behalf of State and Opp. Parties:8. On the other hand, the complainant has appeared in person and argued
that the present revision applications are barred by provision of section
397(2) of Cr.P.C being interlocutory order and revisions are not
maintainable. Learned trial court has very elaborately considered the
rival contentions of the parties in the light of allegations proved against
the petitioners and passed very reasoned order, considering the
guidelines propounded by Hon’ble Apex Court citing several cases. It is
Cr. Revision Nos.1000 and 1052 of 2022
2026:JHHC:18894
trite that at the stage of charge, the court cannot make a roving enquiry
or mini-trial as regards truth or falsity of allegations and therefore the
proposed defence pleas cannot be looked into at the stage of framing
charge or discharge application. The charges can be framed on the basis
of strong suspicion for commission of offence against the accused
persons. Therefore, there is no illegality or infirmity in the impugned
order calling for any interference in these revisions, which are fit to be
dismissed.
Analysis, Reasons and Decision:9. I have gone through the impugned order passed by learned trial court in
the light of contentions raised on behalf of both side.
10.Before delving upon adjudication of the above point, it is pertinent to
extract the relevant provisions of Sections 244 and 245 Cr.P.C. for
better appreciation of the matter, which is as under :"Section 244 Cr.P.C.- Evidence for prosecution.
(i) When, in any warrant case instituted otherwise than on a
police report, the accused appears or is brought before a
Magistrate, the Magistrate shall proceed to hear the
prosecution and take all such evidence as may be produced
in support of the prosecution.
(ii) The Magistrate may, on the application of the
prosecution, issue a summons to any of its witnesses
directing him to attend or to produce any document or other
thing.
Cr. Revision Nos.1000 and 1052 of 2022
2026:JHHC:18894
Section 245Cr.P.C-When accused shall be discharged.
(i) If, upon taking all the evidence referred to in section 244,
the Magistrate considers, for reasons to be recorded, that no
case against the accused has been made out which, if
unrebutted, would warrant his conviction, the Magistrate
shall discharge him.
(ii) Nothing in this section shall be deemed to prevent a
Magistrate from discharging the accused at any previous
stage of the case if, for reasons to be recorded by such
Magistrate, he considers the charge to be groundless.”
11.A conjoint reading of Sections 244 and 245 of the Cr.P.C., it clearly
transpires that the Magistrate has no power to pass an order under
Section 245(i) until he has examined all the witnesses under Section
244. The next rider is that if the evidence of witnesses recorded under
Section 244, the Magistrate considers for reasons to be recorded that no
case against the accused has been made out which if un-rebutted would
warrant his conviction. Therefore, it is mandatory for the Magistrate to
consider the evidence before charge adduced by complainant and record
a specific finding as to if before charge evidence remains un-rebutted
and taken to be true on its face value, no conviction of the accused
would be warranted.
12.In view of the above discussion and reasons, I find substance in the
argument of learned counsel for the petitioners and merits in these
revisions. It appears that learned trial court has not considered before
Cr. Revision Nos.1000 and 1052 of 2022
2026:JHHC:18894
charge evidence adduced in this case in the light of provisions under
section 245 of Cr.P.C rather applied the principles for discharge
propounded for dealing with a discharge application under section 239
or 227 of Cr.P.C.
13.Accordingly, the order dated 05.08.2022 passed by learned Chief
Judicial Magistrate, Gumla in connection with Complaint Case No.22 of
1996 is hereby set aside and the matter is remitted back to the concerned
Trial Court to pass a fresh order in light of the aforesaid observations
and provisions of law after providing reasonable opportunity of hearing
to both parties without being prejudiced by observations made herein
above by this Court. These revisions are allowed.
14.Interim order, if granted earlier in these cases, is vacated.
15. Let a copy of this order be sent to the court concerned through FAX for
information and needful.
(Pradeep Kumar Srivastava, J.)
High Court of Jharkhand, Ranchi
Date:29 /06 /2026
Pappu/N.A.F.R.
Uploaded on 30 /06 /2026
Cr. Revision Nos.1000 and 1052 of 2022
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review