Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:7655
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P.(S) No. 7480 of 2017
….…..
Dr. Akhileshwar Pathak, Son of Late Balbhadra Pathak,
at present working as Lecturer in the Department of
Sanskrit, Markham College of Commerce, Vinoba Bhave
University, Hazaribagh, P.O.+P.S.+District- Hazaribagh
..… Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand, represented through
Secretary, Higher Education, Human Resource
Development Department, At: Nepal House, P.O.& P.S.:
Doranda, District: Ranchi.
2. The Secretary, Higher Education, Human Resource
Development Department, At: Nepal House, P.O.& P.S.:
Doranda, District: Ranchi.
3. Vinoba Bhave University, represented through its
Vice Chancellor, At + P.O.+ P.S. + District: Hazaribag.
4. Vice Chancellor, Vinoba Bhave University, At + P.O.+
P.S. + District: Hazaribag.
5. Registrar, Vinoba Bhave University, At + P.O.+ P.S.
+District: Hazaribag.
6. Principal, Markham College of Commerce, Vinoba
Bhave University, At + P.O.+ P.S. + District: Hazaribag.
..... Respondent(s)
….…..
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK ROSHAN
CORAM:
For the Petitioner
For the Resp.-State
For the University
C.A.V. ON 14/01/2026
….…
: Mr. Rajeev Ranjan Tiwary, Adv
: Mr. Ashutosh Anand No.1, A.C. to G.P.-IV
: Dr. Ashok Singh, Adv
….…..
PRONOUNCED ON:13/03/2026
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2.
The instant writ application has been preferred by the
petitioner primarily challenging the order dated 18.03.2015
passed
by
the
Hon’ble
Mr.
Justice
S.B.
Sinha
(Retd.)
Commission by reason of which the claim of the petitioner for
correction of date of his absorption on the post of ‘Lecturer’ in
2026:JHHC:7655
the University has been rejected and further for grant of 5th
and 6th pay revision which the petitioner claims to be entitled.
The petitioner further has prayed for quashing of the order
dated 09.05.2015, whereby the petition preferred by the
petitioner for recalling the order dated 18.03.2015 was rejected.
The petitioner has also prayed for quashing of the other
consecutive order dated 18.12.2015, passed by the Hon’ble Mr.
Justice S.B. Sinha (Retd.) Commission arising out of other
petition for recalling the aforesaid order dated 18.03.2015 on
the ground of retirement of one ‘Shambhu Nath Mishra’ which
was also rejected.
Lastly, the petitioner has prayed for a direction upon the
respondents to correct the date of absorption as well as grant
benefits of 5th and 6th pay revision.
3.
Earlier also, one writ petition being W.P.(S) no. 4197/2009
was filed by the petitioner, which stand dismissed as withdrawn
vide order dated 03.01.2018. Issues as were raised in the
earlier writ petition i.e. W.P.(S) no. 4197/2009 was for
correction of petitioner’s date of absorption as well as to grant
the benefits of 5th and 6th pay revision. However, after knowing
about
ongoing
Hon’ble
Mr.
Justice
S.B.
Sinha
(Retd.)
Commission considering the cases of University Teachers,
which was earlier subject to verification by the Hon’ble Mr.
Justice
S.C.
Agrawal
(Retd.)
Commission,
the
petitioner
2026:JHHC:7655
withdraws his writ to approach the Commission for redressal of
his grievance.
4.
Necessary facts related to the petitioner as per the
pleadings is that he was appointed by the Governing Body in its
meeting dated 07.10.1985 on the post of Lecturer in the
Department of Sanskrit in Markham College of Commerce,
Hazaribagh. Appointment letter was issued on 07.10.1985 and
accordingly the petitioner joined on 07.10.1985 (Annexure-1
series of the writ petition). The siad College was one of the
colleges, which by the decision of the then State of Bihar of
1986 was taken over as constituent unit of the University. The
College was taken over by the Government vide its decision
dated 19.08.1986 and thereafter, agreement was entered into
between the College, Management & employee Associations of
the University under section 4(1)(14) of the Bihar Universities
Act, 1976.
5.
Learned
counsel
for
the
petitioner
made
following
submissions:
a) Disputes regarding sanctioned posts and validity of staff
appointments in certain colleges led to vigilance inquiries,
prompting employees to form the Bihar Rajya Mahavidyalaya
Shikshak and Shikshakettar Karmchari Kalyan Mahasangh,
which filed C.W.J.C. No. 4021/1995 before the Patna High
Court seeking regularisation of services of teachers of 4th
phase colleges.
b) The Patna High Court directed Universities to consider
regularisation under Section 4(14) of the Bihar Universities Act,
2026:JHHC:7655
1976, which was challenged by the State before the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, leading to the constitution of the Justice S.C.
Agrawal Commission to examine disputes relating to absorption
of employees.
c) The Agrawal Commission report included the petitioner’s name
in Annexure III-A and Annexure IV-A, showing that he was
working prior to the cut-off date against a recommended post,
following which the Supreme Court accepted the report and
directed Universities to pass absorption orders.
d) Pursuant to the report and Government letters, the petitioner’s
services were absorbed as Lecturer in Sanskrit at Markham
College
of
Commerce,
Hazaribagh
under
Vinoba
Bhave
University vide memo dated 16.09.2005, with effect from
01.02.1988.
e) The petitioner filed W.P.(S) No. 4197/2009 seeking shifting of
the absorption date to 05.10.1985 and grant of 5th and 6th Pay
Revision benefits, and also approached the Justice S.B. Sinha
Commission,
which
rejected
his
claim
by
order
dated
18.03.2015 and dismissed subsequent recall applications.
f) The petitioner thereafter approached the Supreme Court, which
permitted aggrieved persons to approach the High Court,
leading
to
the
present
writ
petition
challenging
the
Commission’s order on the ground that the petitioner’s
absorption had already been recognised and the only issue
was correction of the date of absorption and consequential
financial benefits.
6.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondents
made following submissions:
a) The petitioner did not possess the requisite qualification on the date of
conversion of the college and acquired it only on 05.10.1985, hence
could not claim earlier absorption.
b) The petitioner was absorbed pursuant to Government Letter No. 38/C
dated 01.02.1988, and therefore any claim for absorption from
05.10.1985 is legally untenable.
c) Only one sanctioned post in Sanskrit existed at the relevant time, and
no recommendation for creation of a third post was ever made,
2026:JHHC:7655
making petitioner’s claim unsustainable.
d) As per the Justice S.C. Agrawal Commission Report, the petitioner’s
case falls under List (III), i.e., appointees against posts without valid
recommendation or beyond cut-off date, who have no right to
absorption.
e) The order dated 18.03.2015 correctly held that there was no material
showing recommendation for creation of a third post, and therefore
the petitioner’s absorption was not legally justified.
f) Letter No. 38/C dated 01.02.1988 merely provided for provisional
absorption subject to scrutiny, and did not confer any enforceable
right; hence University could not have granted final absorption under
Section 4(1)(14) of the Bihar Universities Act, 1976.
7.
In order to point out the issue involved in the present
case, he referred
to the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of ‘State of Bihar vs. Bihar Rajya
M.S.E.S.K.K. Maha Sangha reported in 2005(9) SCC 129]
particularly Para 73 (5); wherein it has been held that for those
posts for which recommendation were sent after the cut-off date
related to list (iii) does not deserve any consideration as
observed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
Further, even those employees who were working against
the posts for which no recommendations were sent for approval
to the State Government, have no right of being considered for
absorption. For ready reference the relevant para is quoted
herein below:
“73. In view of this judgment and the directions made herein to the
university to take a final decision based on the report of the Enquiry
Commission, all the applications for impleadment as parties and
objections filed to the enquiry report are rejected. It is for the university
to take a final decision concerning the individual employees. For the
same, no further orders are required on the interlocutory applications
seeking certain directions pending the appeal and for the modification
of earlier orders made. Other interlocutory applications need no further
directions or orders. They all stand disposed of.”
2026:JHHC:7655
Conclusions
5. The appointees mentioned in List (iii), being the appointees
against the posts for which recommendations were sent by the
universities to the State Government after the cut-off date or
those working against the posts which no recommendations
were sent for approval of the State Government, have no right
of being considered for absorption-whatever may be the
fortuitous circumstances or otherwise in the matter of not
sending recommendations for sanction in their cases. The
negative report of the Enquiry Commission with regard to List (iii) is
accepted and the universities are directed to exclude all such
appointees named in List (iii) from consideration for absorption.
Emphasis Supplied
8.
Having heard Ld. Counsel for the rival parties and
considering the prayers of the petitioner and also after perusing
the documents annexed with the respective affidavits and the
averments made therein, this Court finds that the petitioner is
mainly assailing the order dated 18.03.2015 passed by the
Hon’ble Justice S.B. Sinha (Retd.) Commission by reason of
which the claim of the petitioner for correction of date of
absorption as well as grant of 5th and 6th pay revision was
rejected. The Petitioner has further prayed for quashing
consequential order dated 09.05.2015 passed by the Hon’ble
Sinha Commission, which was passed pursuant to the petition
for recall of the order dated 18.03.2015 filed by the petitioner
which was rejected and also the order dated 18.12.2015 passed
by the Commission on application of the petitioner to
reconsider his claim based on retirement of one ‘Shambhu Nath
Mishra’ on 31.01.2010.
9.
Ld. Counsel of the petitioner mainly harped on the
observation made by the Hon’ble Justice S.B. Sinha (retd.)
2026:JHHC:7655
Commission stating that ‘the services of the claimant, therefore
could not have been absorbed by the University’.
10. From records it appears that the decision taken by the
University at the time of taking over of the 4th phase
constituent colleges under section 4(1)(14) of the University Act
caused
controversy/dispute,
and
further
the
University
implementation, in terms of direction given in the ‘Mahasangh
case’ (supra) has also caused similar controversy/dispute,
which necessitated the constitution of Hon’ble Justice S.B.
Sinha (retd.) Commission.
Though, to resolve such disputes, the Hon’ble Apex Court
in ‘Krishna Nand Yadav & Ors. vs. Magadh University & Ors,
[Civil Appeal no. 2703 of 2017] again on 22.01.2013 appointed
Mr. Justice S.C. Agrawal to enquire the issue framed therein.
However, Justice S.C. Agrawal decline to enquire; thereafter,
Hon’ble Justice S.B. Sinha (retd.) was appointed on 19.08.2013
as One-Man Commission to enquire and submit a report.
The Hon’ble Apex Court in ‘Krishna Nand Yadav’ case
observed as under (Relevant paragraph which is necessary for
the present case):14. In view of the factual matrix, the orders of accepting cases
passed by Justice Sinha Commission are fully in accordance
with law and the exercise undertaken by Justice Sinha cannot
be said to be in violation of either the Reports of Justice Agrawal
or the decisions of this Court in Mahasangha case (supra). It
was the decision in the case of Mahsangha that cases of
individuals were required to be examined and thereafter, under
the aforesaid terms of reference, Commission was required to
decide individual cases. Thus we find that the objections raised
by the State of Bihar and the State of Jharkhand, refusing to
2026:JHHC:7655
accept the orders, cannot be accepted.
15. Apart from that, in one such case, vide order dated
04.01.2015, Justice Sinha in the matter of ASJSN College, with
respect to non-teaching staff, has made an elaborate
consideration into this aspects, and the similar view has been
taken by Justice Sinha in other cases. The objection raised with
respect to other cases also does not survive. Thus, the first
submission does not survive and is hereby rejected. Even in grey
areas which were left for consideration by the Commission, the
view adopted is wholly justified and is in accordance with the
law, we are in agreement with the same.
16. Coming to second objection. It is submitted that in the
Agreement of taking over of the colleges, certain manipulations
were done so as to benefit incumbents in the list. We find that
Justice Sinha Commission has taken into consideration all these
aspects in individual cases as apparent from its various orders
and, therefore, only those cases have been recommended in
which it was found, on due considerations of the matter, that the
appointments were not made on the basis of any manipulation
or procured on the basis of illegal documents. The view taken by
the Commission is based on meticulous consideration of cases
cannot be said to be vitiated or illegal in any manner
whatsoever. to be vitiated or illegal in any manner whatsoever.
……………………………………………………………..
……………………………………………………………..
11. Thus, this Court finds that objections as were raised
against the observations of the Hon’ble Justice S.B. Sinha
(retd.) Commission in its report was declined by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court; except the fact that in cases of incumbents not
found fit for acceptance by the Commission, were given liberty
to approach the concerned High Court.
12. The petitioner in terms of the above liberty granted and
after approaching the Hon’ble Justice S.B. Sinha (retd.)
Commission and after being aggrieved by its order(s) dated
18.03.215, 09.05.2015 and 18.12.2015 has filed the present
writ petition.
13. From record, it further appears that the Hon’ble S. B.
Sinha Commission after delineating on the facts came to the
specific conclusion (Relevant portion of the Report is extracted
2026:JHHC:7655
herein below):This Commission in the order dated 11.09.2014 furthermore
noticed as under:“56. In view of the aforementioned clear direction issued by the
Supreme Court of India, it is not possible to hold that apart from
those whose names were recommended prior to the cut-off date,
their cases can be considered by this Commission”
The services of the claimant, therefore, could not have been
absorbed by the University.
14. The above observation was based on the fact that no
record was produced before the Hon’ble Justice S.B. Sinha
(retd.) Commission that any recommendation had been made
by the University for creation of a third post.
15. As
pointed
out
by
the
learned
counsel
for
the
Respondents, the petitioner is justifying its absorption based on
its name in the list (iii) and list (IV-A) of Justice S.C. Agrawal
report and Government letter no. “38C”; based on which the
University absorbed the petitioner w.e.f. 01.02.1988.
16. It is pertinent to mention here that the Government letter
no. ‘38C’ only suggest that government took a decision to
absorb the employees provisionally on the posts in the taken
over constituent college in 4th phase. Further, the list for
employees to be absorbed was subject to be enquired by a
university level committee and after recommendation of the
Vice-chancellor of University, the same was required to be sent
to the Government for its consideration.
17.
In the instant case, neither the list of employees as were
annexed in Government letter no. ‘38C’ was produced during
2026:JHHC:7655
the course of hearing; nor annexed with the writ petition.
Moreover, the Hon’ble Justice S.B. Sinha (retd.) Commission in
its order dated 18.03.2015 had categorically observed that “In
view of the matter, having regard to the limited jurisdiction of this
Commission, and furthermore in view of the Judgment and Order passed by
the Supreme Court of India in the case of Mahasangh, it is difficult to uphold
the absorption of the claimant on the basis of the Government letter no.
‘38C’ dated 01.02.1988, as such a direction would render absorption by
the University in its service more persons than the number of posts
sanctioned/recommended therefore.”
18. It is not in dispute that the petitioner even approached the
Hon’ble Justice S.B. Sinha (retd.) Commission for recall of the
order dated 18.03.2015, on the pretext of not bringing into the
knowledge of the Commission regarding the retirement of one
‘Shambhunath Mishra’, who retired on 31.01.2010 and thus
petitioner could have been adjusted in the death cum
retirement category. Meaning thereby; the petitioner had
knowledge that he has been wrongly absorbed.
19. Moreover, as was held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the judgment rendered in Mahasangh (supra) in Para 73(5) ….…
‘The appointees mentioned in List (iii), being the appointees against the
posts for which recommendations were sent by the universities to the State
Government after the cut-off date or those working against the posts which
no recommendations were sent for approval of the State Government, have
no right of being considered for absorption-whatever may be the fortuitous
circumstances or otherwise in the matter of not sending recommendations
2026:JHHC:7655
for sanction in their cases. The negative report of the Enquiry Commission
with regard to List (iii) is accepted and the universities are directed to
exclude all such appointees named in List (iii) from consideration for
absorption’.
20. Here it is pertinent to indicate that the Hon’ble Apex Court
in clear terms observed that posts for which recommendation
were sent after the cut-off date related to list (iii) does not
deserve any consideration. Further, even those employees who
were working against the posts for which no recommendations
were sent for approval of the State Government, have no right of
being considered for absorption.
21. In view of the noted facts above, the writ petition lacks
merit and thus liable to be dismissed. However, considering the
observation made by Hon’ble Justice
S.B. Sinha (retd.)
Commission in the order dated 18.12.2015, the petitioner may
approach the University for being absorbed against the vacancy
in accordance with law.
22. Accordingly, the instant writ application stands dismissed.
Pending I.A.s, if any, also stands disposed of.
(Deepak Roshan, J.)
Dated:13 /03/2026
Amardeep/
A.F.R
Uploaded on
23.03.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review