Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Judgment reserved on: 02.02.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 24.02.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 24.02.2026
FAO(OS) (COMM) 363/2019
DIVYA ASHISH JAMWAL
.....Appellant
Through: Dr. Riju Raj Singh Jamwal &
Mr. Manoj, Advs.
versus
INDIA YAHAMA MOTOR PVT LTD
.....Respondent
Through:
Mr. Arpit Dwivedi, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
JUDGMENT
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.:
1.
The present Appeal under Section 37 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 [hereinafter referred to as „the Act’] is directed
against the judgment dated 30.01.2019 passed by the Learned Single
Judge in O.M.P. No. 1107/2012, captioned India Yamaha Motor Pvt.
Ltd. v. Divya Ashish Jamwal [hereinafter referred to as „Impugned
Judgment‟], whereby the Arbitral Award dated 16.04.2012 rendered
by the Sole Arbitrator came to be set aside in proceedings under
Section 34 of the Act.
2.
By the Impugned Judgment, the learned Single Judge held that
the Arbitral Award was contrary to the terms of the contract between
the parties, was founded on surmises and extraneous considerations,
and was unsupported by evidence on record. On the basis of these
findings, the learned Single Judge allowed the petition filed by the
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
FAO(OS)(COMM) 363/2019
15:30:24
respondent under Section 34 of the Act and set aside the Arbitral
Award in its entirety.
3.
Before adverting to the rival submissions, it would be apposite
to briefly notice the factual background leading to the passing of the
Arbitral Award and the Impugned Judgment. The facts are set out
hereinafter only to the extent necessary for examining the jurisdiction
exercised by the learned Single Judge under Section 34 of the Act and
the scope of interference of this Court in the present Appeal under
Section 37 of the Act.
FACTUAL MATRIX
4.
The Appellant and the Respondent were governed by a
Dealership Agreement dated 10.10.2005, under which the Appellant
was appointed as an authorised dealer for the Respondent‟s
motorcycles, spare parts and automotive products in the Jammu
region. The agreement, which was valid for a period of three years,
contained detailed provisions relating to the obligations of the dealer,
termination of the dealership, and the consequences thereof, as well as
an arbitration clause for the resolution of disputes between the parties.
5.
Disputes having arisen between the parties, the Appellant herein
invoked arbitration under the aegis of the Indian Council of
Arbitration. In the original statement of claim, the Appellant sought,
inter alia, monetary reliefs and a direction for resumption of supplies.
During the pendency of the arbitral proceedings, the Respondent
terminated the dealership by a notice dated 04.06.2007, whereupon the
claimant amended the statement of claim to additionally seek
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
FAO(OS)(COMM) 363/2019
15:30:24
compensation towards unsold spare parts and a direction requiring the
Respondent to take back the said stock.
6.
By the Arbitral Award dated 16.04.2012, the learned Sole
Arbitrator, inter alia, awarded compensation towards loss of expected
profits and establishment costs, and further directed the respondent to
take back the stocks of spares, accessories, and fittings lying with the
Appellant and to refund the full price thereof along with interest at the
rate of 16% per annum with effect from 04.06.2007, subject to the
conditions specified in the award.
7.
It is in this backdrop that the rival submissions advanced on
behalf of the parties fall for consideration.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Contentions on behalf of the Appellant:
8.
Learned counsel appearing for the Appellant submits that the
learned Single Judge erred in the exercise of jurisdiction under Section
34 of the Act by re-appreciating the material on record and
substituting the findings of the Arbitral Tribunal with their own. It is
contended that the Arbitral Award was rendered after due
consideration of the pleadings and evidence adduced by the parties.
Learned counsel further submits that an objection as to the
maintainability of the petition under Section 34, on the ground of
limitation, was specifically raised by the Appellant, and that the
learned Single Judge, in entertaining and allowing the petition,
exceeded the limited scope of interference permissible under Section
34 of the Act.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
FAO(OS)(COMM) 363/2019
15:30:24
9.
It is further submitted that the Arbitral Tribunal acted within the
framework of the Dealership Agreement and that the reliefs granted
were justified in the facts and circumstances of the case, particularly
having regard to the termination of the dealership during the pendency
of the arbitral proceedings. According to the Appellant, the Arbitral
Tribunal was competent to mould the relief so as to do complete
justice between the parties, and the Impugned Judgment fails to
accord due deference to the Tribunal‟s findings.
Contentions on behalf of the Respondent:
10.
Per contra, the learned counsel for the Respondent submits that
the scope of interference under Section 37 of the Act is extremely
limited and that no case for appellate interference is made out by the
Appellant. It is contended that the learned Single Judge confined the
scrutiny strictly within the parameters of Section 34 of the Act and set
aside the Arbitral Award on the ground that the relief granted therein
was contrary to the express terms of the Dealership Agreement.
11.
It is further submitted that the Arbitral Tribunal travelled
beyond the contractual framework by directing buy-back of stock and
refund of price, despite there being no provision in the agreement
obligating the Respondent to do so. According to the Respondent, the
findings returned by the Arbitral Tribunal were based on conjectures
and equitable considerations dehors the contract, and the learned
Single Judge was therefore justified in setting aside the Award in its
entirety.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
FAO(OS)(COMM) 363/2019
15:30:24
ISSUE FOR DETERMINATION
12.
The principal issue that arises for consideration in the present
Appeal is whether the learned Single Judge exceeded the limited
jurisdiction under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1996 in setting aside the Arbitral Award dated 16.04.2012, or whether
such interference was warranted on the ground that the Arbitral
Tribunal had granted relief contrary to the express terms of the
Dealership Agreement and on considerations dehors the contract.
ANALYSIS & FINDINGS
13.
Before adverting to the rival submissions, it is necessary to
reiterate the well-settled contours of appellate interference under
Section 37 of the Act. The jurisdiction under Section 37 of the Act is
circumscribed.
14.
An Appeal under Section 37 of the Act is not a rehearing of the
arbitral dispute on merits. The Appellate Court does not sit in appeal
over the arbitral award, nor does it re-appreciate the evidence or
substitute its own view merely because another view is possible. The
scope of interference is confined to examining whether the Court
exercising jurisdiction under Section 34 of the Act acted within the
parameters prescribed by law, and whether the order under challenge
suffers from any jurisdictional infirmity or perversity.
15.
It follows that where the learned Single Judge has set aside an
Arbitral Award on the ground that the Award was contrary to the
express terms of the contract or is founded on considerations dehors
the agreement between the parties, the Appellate Court would be slow
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
FAO(OS)(COMM) 363/2019
15:30:24
to interfere unless such findings are shown to be perverse or wholly
unsustainable in law.
16.
The Arbitral Tribunal, by the Award dated 16.04.2012, directed
the Respondent to take back all stocks of spares, accessories and
fittings lying with the Claimant, subject to certain exclusions, and to
refund the full price thereof along with interest at the rate of 16% per
annum with effect from 04.06.2007 till the date of payment. The
Respondent was further directed to collect the said stocks at its own
cost within a stipulated period.
17.
The relief granted by the Arbitral Tribunal thus comprised a
substantive monetary direction in the nature of refund along with
interest, coupled with a direction for reversal of stock post termination
of the dealership agreement.
18.
The relationship between the parties was governed by the
Dealership Agreement dated 10.10.2005. Clause 10 of the Agreement
deals with the Term and Termination, while Clause 11 enumerates the
Consequences flowing from termination or expiry of the Agreement.
19.
A plain conjoint reading of Clauses 5, 7, 11 and 12 of the
Dealership Agreement delineates with clarity the contractual
allocation of rights and obligations upon termination. Clause 10.4
entitled either party to terminate the Agreement by prior notice,
without assigning reasons and without incurring liability. Clause 11
enumerated the consequences of termination and obligated the dealer,
inter alia, to remit outstanding dues, cease use of the Respondent‟s
trademarks and intellectual property, and forthwith return all
properties of Yamaha held in trust for and on behalf of Yamaha.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
FAO(OS)(COMM) 363/2019
15:30:24
20.
Significantly, the expression “properties of Yamaha” occurring
in Clause 11.4 cannot be read expansively to include all unsold
products or spare parts lying with the dealer. Under Clause 5.10 and
5.26, the products and spare parts were held by the dealer “in trust”
for and on behalf of YMS/YMI only till complete payment was
realised. Upon payment, the relationship between the parties being
expressly on a principal-to-principal basis under Clause 7.1,
ownership of such goods vested in the dealer. The Agreement does
not impose any obligation on the Respondent to repurchase or take
back unsold stock upon termination. Clause 12 merely confers a
discretionary right upon YMI/YMS, at its election, to purchase or
accept return of stock on terms determined by it; it does not create a
corresponding enforceable right in favour of the dealer. No provision
of the Agreement, either expressly or by necessary implication,
mandates buy-back or restitution of stock at the instance of the dealer.
21.
The Arbitral Award in the present case was rendered on
16.04.2012. Accordingly, the examination undertaken by the learned
Single Judge under Section 34, and the scrutiny by this Court under
Section 37, are required to be confined to the statutory framework
governing arbitral proceedings as it stood on that date. Under Section
28(3) of the Act, the Arbitral Tribunal was required to decide the
dispute in accordance with the terms of the contract. In the absence of
any express authorisation by the parties to decide the dispute ex aequo
et bono or as an amiable compositeur, the arbitral tribunal could not
have granted relief founded on notions of equity or fairness dehors the
contract, as proscribed by Section 28(2) of the Act. While the tribunal
is entitled to interpret the contractual provisions, it is equally well
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
FAO(OS)(COMM) 363/2019
15:30:24
settled that it cannot rewrite the bargain between the parties or grant
relief which the contract itself does not contemplate.
22.
The learned Single Judge, while exercising jurisdiction under
Section 34, was therefore required to examine whether the Arbitral
Tribunal had remained within these jurisdictional limits. The present
Appeal is confined to testing the correctness of that exercise.
23.
Tested on the aforesaid contractual framework, the learned
Single Judge was justified in holding that the Arbitral Award travelled
beyond the terms of the Agreement. The direction to refund the price
of stock along with interest was not founded on any contractual
stipulation and was premised on considerations extraneous to the
Agreement.
24.
The learned Single Judge held that the Arbitral Tribunal relied
upon broad notions of fairness, alleged dominance, and human
conduct, without anchoring the relief granted to the express provisions
of the contract or to evidence establishing a contractual entitlement.
Such an approach clearly falls foul of Section 28(3) of the Act.
25.
Interference in such circumstances cannot be characterised as
re-appreciation of evidence. Where the relief granted is ex facie
contrary to the contract governing the parties, the court exercising
jurisdiction under Section 34 acted within its mandate in setting aside
the award. The Impugned Judgment, therefore, does not suffer from
any jurisdictional error warranting interference under Section 37 of
the Act.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
FAO(OS)(COMM) 363/2019
15:30:24
26.
The Appellant‟s objection to the maintainability of the petition
under Section 34 on the ground of limitation is also without merit.
The Respondent had specifically pleaded in its rejoinder that the
signed copy of the Arbitral Award was received by them on
08.11.2012 and that the petition under Section 34 was filed on
22.11.2012, well within the period prescribed under Section 34(3) of
the Act. The learned Single Judge entertained the petition on this basis
and adjudicated the same on the merits. No perversity or jurisdictional
infirmity in such determination has been demonstrated so as to
warrant interference.
CONCLUSION
27.
For the foregoing reasons, this Court finds no infirmity in the
exercise of jurisdiction by the learned Single Judge under Section 34
of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, in setting aside the
Arbitral Award dated 16.04.2012. The Appellant has failed to
demonstrate any ground warranting interference by this Court in this
Appeal.
28.
The Appeal is accordingly dismissed.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J.
FEBRUARY 24, 2026
s.godara/ad
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
FAO(OS)(COMM) 363/2019
15:30:24
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review