Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
W.P.(C) 596/2026
DIRECTORATE GENERAL OF HEALTH SERVICES .....Petitioner
Through:
Mr. Tushar Sannu, Counsel for
GNCTD with Mr. Priyankar Tiwary
and Ms. Shaoni Das, Advocates.
versus
SANJEEV KUMAR & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Pranav Sachdeva, Mr. Sanyam
Jain, Ms. Khushboo Singhal, Mr. P,
Rohit Ram, Ms. Mishra Divya
Santosh, advocates for R-1.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV
ORDER
%
16.01.2026
CM APPL. 2908/2026
1.
Exemption allowed, subject to all just exceptions.
2.
The application stands disposed of.
W.P.(C) 596/2026
3.
The petitioner seeks to challenge the order dated 16.01.2025 passed
by the Central Information Commission, whereby, in addition to directing
disclosure of certain information to Respondent No. 1, the Commission has
also directed payment of compensation amounting to ₹45,000/-, issued an
advisory under Section 25(5) of the Right to Information Act, 2005
(hereinafter ‘RTI Act’) and also imposed a penalty.
4.
The facts manifest that an application under the RTI Act was filed by
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 27/01/2026 at 12:27:31
Respondent No. 1 on 31.10.2023, seeking the following information:
“Please provide me complete and detailed point-wise information
together with all related documents/correspondence/file-notings etc on
under-mentioned aspects:
1. Regulatory public-authority for Artemis Hospital (A-1, New Friends
Colony, New· De!hi- 110025) mentioning date of first issue of license to
the said Artemis Hospital by the said regulatory authority
2. Had the said Artemis Hospital valid license issued by DGHS anc/or
any regulatory publicauthority on the dates of hospitalization
(07.04.2023 and 08.04.2023) of my wife Smt Shikha Aggarwd
3. If yes to (2), provide a copy of the license with validity of 07.04.2023
to 08.04.2023 from the concerned regulatory authority to the said
Artemis Hospital
4. If no to (2), complete and detailed information together with all
related documents/correspondence/file-notings etc on action taken
against the said Artemis Hospital for continuing hospital and medical
treatments on 07.04.2023 and 08.04.2023 without having a valid
license
5. Please provide me complete and detailed information together with
an related documents/correspondence/file-notings etc on action taken
on my complaint dated 06.06.2023 lodged at CPGRAMS portal (copy
enclosed) either by DGHS and/or by any authority where the said
complaint might have been forwarded r ANNEXURE P-1/B 102
6.. Relationship of Claim Therapist with the said Artemis Hospital for
cashless hospitaltreatment
7. Year-wise number of cases settled by Claim Therapist in respect of
the said Artemis Hospital ever since the said Artemis Hospital started
its hospital-activities
8. Copies of complete correspondence by the regulatory authority with
the said Artemis Hospital in respect of my enclosed complaint
9. Names of doctors for which hospital-authorities charged fees in
respect of treatment of my wife Smt Shikha Aggarwal clearly
mentioning part of charged fees (a) paid to concerned doctors (b)
retained by hospital-authorities
10. Complete information on preventive steps taken by the concerned
regulatory authority to ensure that the said Artemis Hospital may not
cheat patients/attendants in the manner I was cheated in respe.ct of
treatment of my wife Smt Shikha Aggarwal
11. Any other related information
12. File-notings on movement of this RTI application.
In case queries relate to some other public-authority,. transfer this RTI
application there under section 6(3) of RTI Act under intimation to me.
Above information is also being sought under section 4(1)(d) ofRTI Act
with myself being the affected individual.”
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 27/01/2026 at 12:27:31
5.
The Public Information Officer (PIO) furnished a reply to the RTI
application on 21.11.2023, providing the following information to
Respondent No. 1:
“Sir,
With reference to RTI application on above mentioned subject, the
reply pertaining to this branch is as under:
1. The regulating authority of Artemis Hospital (A-1, New
Friends Colony, New Delhi – 110025) is Director General
Health Services as per Delhi Nursing Homes Registration
Act, 1953.
2. Yes.
3. Copy of registration certificate is enclosed.
4. Not applicable in view of reply given at point No. 2 above.
5. No such complaint is found in CPGRAMS Portal of Nursing
Home Cell. The RTI representation is taken as grievance and
letter dated 15.11.2023 is issued by this Directorate. Copy of
the same is enclosed.
6. Information does not pertain to this branch.
7. Information does not pertain to this branch.
8. Copy of letter issued on 15.11.2023 is enclosed.
9. Information does not pertain to this branch.
10.Information does not pertain to this branch.
11.Information does not pertain to this branch.
12.Information does not pertain to this branch.”
6.
Being dissatisfied with the information furnished, Respondent No. 1
preferred a first appeal, which was decided vide order dated 20.12.2023,
with the following observation:
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 27/01/2026 at 12:27:31
“This is an appeal under Secfion19(1) of RTI Act 2005 filed by Mr.
SanJeev Kum2r, for providing reply by the PIO in response to the
oniine RTI application Id no DROHS/R/2023/60359. The appeal was
conducted on 20.t2.2023.ASO (NH CeH) and APIO(RTI) were present
fo the appeal. And as reque51:ed by the appellant to authorize Rn
consultant Sh. Subhash Chander sharma to attend the appeal �s
allowed to attend hearing. During the appeal the copy of the letter was
provided by the Sb, Subhash Chander Sharma vide dated 29.11.2023
(copy enclosed) and t1-ie . � same has been provided to -the ASO (NH
Ceil) and I/C (NH Cell) directed to provide the reply of question no 6,7
and 9 within 15days. Order passed m1d appeal disposed of
accordingly. Iu case you are not satisfied you can file second appeal to
Central Information Commissioner CIC, Baba Gang Nath Marg,
Munirka, New Dellij..-110067.”
7.
Respondent No. 1, being further dissatisfied with the decision
rendered in the first appeal, approached the Central Information
Commission by way of a second appeal.
8.
During the pendency of the second appeal, the Commission took up
the matter on various dates and also passed interim orders from time to time.
9.
On 05.06.2024, the Commission recorded that Respondent No. 1 had
not been provided with correct and accurate information. Submissions were
advanced on his behalf seeking directions to the PIO to furnish complete and
requisite information. However, the Commission adjourned the matter to
13.06.2024, while making certain observations regarding the manner in
which the information had not been supplied.
10.
During the course of the hearing, on 24.09.2024, a revised reply/plan
was placed on record by the Medical Superintendent in the capacity of PIO,
wherein a particular stand was taken.
11.
The Commission also considered the additional submissions dated
20.09.2024 filed by the appellant. Vide order dated 07.10.2024, the
Commission held that the revised reply furnished by the appellant (petitioner
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 27/01/2026 at 12:27:31
herein) was not convincing, and that the information sought was legally
barred, except with respect to Points No. 1, 5, 6, 11, and 12 of the RTI
application. Reasons were specifically recorded as to why compliance with
Points No. 2, 3, 4, 7, 8, 9, and 10 was found to be unsatisfactory. The
relevant extract of the aforesaid reads as under :Having considered the rival contentions of both the parties and perusal of
records, the Commission found that the revised reply furnished by the
respondent vide letter dated 12.07.2024 is not convincing and legally
flawed (except for point No. 1,5,6,11,12} in terms of the RTI Act. The same
is evident from the below mentioned facts:
Point Nos. 2, 3 & 4: With the revised reply given by the respondent; the
relevant issue i.e. whether Artemis Hospital was having a valid
registration certificate at the time of hospitalization of the patient i.e. on
07.08.2023-08.04.2023 or not, is left unattended. The respondent has
enclosed a copy of Registration Certificate in the name of 'Artemis
Hospital' bearing No. Reg. No./ DHS/NH/721 dated 06.07.2022 which is
valid only up to 31.03.2023 and a further registration certificate bearing
No. Reg. No./DHS/NH/721 dated 01.08.2023 which is valid till March,
2026. In this regard, revised submissions/ reply of the PIO is totally silent
on the aspect. Further, the respondent has not quoted specific provisions
of the DHS Act, 1953 and Rules made thereunder in support of his
arguments which grants liberty to the private hospital to apply for
registration certificate ex-post facto. Apparently on the relevant date the
said hospital did not have a valid license.
• Point No. 7: On this point the appellant has sought the total number of
cases settled/passed by Claim Therapist through Artemis Hospital. Here,
the nature of information sought is in numeric figure, disclosure of which
cannot hamper the confidentiality aspect of the said Hospital by any
stretch of imagination.
• Point No. 8: The information provided to the appellant per se appears to
be incomplete. Here; the PIO or the answering respondent had failed to
apply his mind for invoking Section 10 of the RTI Act to facilitate
information to the appellant as he had sought correspondence pertaining
to his complainant.
• Point No. 9: Since the Artemis Hospital in their reply has already
claimed that name of treating doctors are mentioned in the medical
records of patients, then, why such available documents were not shared
with the appellant.
• Point No. 10: The preventive steps taken by regulatory authority more
specifically by the Respondent Public Authority are the information of
such nature which should be available in public domain under suo-moto
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 27/01/2026 at 12:27:31
disclosure. The non-disclosure of such generic information is against the
provisions of the RTI Act.”
12.
The Commission, therefore, clearly recorded that despite being
afforded reasonable opportunity, the information was not fully supplied, and
that the application of Respondent No. 1 was improperly handled by the
appellant. Further, in the interest of justice, the Commission permitted
Respondent No. 1 to place on record his version explaining why he should
be held entitled to an award of compensation. The matter was thereafter
adjourned to 06.01.2025.
13.
The reply submitted by the petitioner to each of the points raised was
also duly considered by the Commission. The Commission noted that the
conduct of the Medical Superintendent, Delhi Health Services, Delhi, was
casual in nature, and that he sought to sidestep his responsibility by merely
forwarding the hearing notice to the Medical Superintendent, Artemis Lite
Hospital. It was noted that his intention appeared to be limited to marking
his presence before the Commission and evading accountability. Vide the
order dated 16.01.2025, the Commission recorded the following
observations:
“Decision:
The Commission, upon a perusal of the facts on record as well as on the
basis of the proceedings during the hearing at the outset adversely
viewed the conduct of Shri Sandeep Kumar Agarwal, Medical
Superintendent, Delhi Health Services, Delhi who being the then and the
present PIO in this case hardly bothered to give any written
explanation/submission in compliance of the order dated 07.10.2024 and
casually opted to sidetrack his responsibility by merely forwarding the
hearing notice to the Medical Superintendent, Artemis Lite Hospital and
appeared with the intention to merely mark his presence before the
Commission in person. Upon being asked during the hearing regarding
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 27/01/2026 at 12:27:31
the status of revised rep!y, Shri Sandeep Kumar Agarwal, Medical
Superintendent and Shri Himanshu Sharma who claimed himself to be
In-house counsel (Legal), Artemis Hospital without producing any
authority letter in this regard, failed to give any specific response. Such
approach of the Respondent and third party appears to be premediated
which in turn leads to causing unwarranted obstruction to free flow of
information to the information seeker which is a grave violation of the
spirit of the RTI Act.
In view of the above, the Commission is of the considered view that the
provisions of the RTI Act have been cleariy violated by Shri Sandeep
Kumar Agarwal, Medical Superintendent-cum-PIO on the following
grounds:
1. Upon receiving the hearing notice of this matter twice of different
dates, he opted not to give specific point--wise updated reply to the
appellant and also failed to give any reasons before the Commission.
Further, there is no proper written explanation for such failure has been
given by him which shows his disregard towards the provisions of the
RTI Act.
2. The conduct of Shri Sandeep Kumar Agarwal, Medical Superintendent
cum-PIO depicts contravention of RTi Act because he has failed to
provide an adequate explanation to the instant hearing notice along with
reason for non-compliance of the previous -order and that the
Commission construes the said act/deed of Shri Sandeep Kumar
Ag2rwal, Medical Superintendent-cum-P,O as deliberately obstructing
the information to the Appellant.
3. His failure to comply with the directions of the Commission shows his
nonchalant attitude towards the Commission.
4. Further, there is nothing on record which shows that show cause
hearing notice of this case has been served upon the then PIO, Dr. Nitin
Kumar by Shri Sandeep Kumar, present PIO. In other words, it was
revealed that Shri Sandeep Kumar Agarwal who was under obligation to
serve a copy of this order to the then PIO, Dr. Nitin Kumar as per the
order dated 13.06.2024 has failed to do so and reasons for such omission
was also not explained by him. Resultantly, neither any written
explanation nor the appearance of the then PIO is available before the
Commission.”
14.
In these circumstances, a penalty of Rs. 15,000/- was imposed upon
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 27/01/2026 at 12:27:31
Mr. Sandeep Kumar Agarwal, Medical Superintendent-cum-PIO, for
violation of the provisions of the RTI Act. Further, compensation of Rs.
45,000/- was directed to be paid to Respondent No. 1 by the petitioner.
While directing the award of compensation of Rs. 45,000/-, the Commission
assigned the following reasons:
“Taking into count all abovementioned facts and records filed in the case,
the Commission finds it just and reasonable that the appellant needs to be
compensated for loss, harassment and detriment suffered by him as the
DGHS; Delhi has failed to give timely specific information to the appellant
and compelled him to run time and again by blindly ignoring his tender old
age and also by not addressing the issue flagged by the appellant in toto.
Therefore, the respondent public authority i.e. DGHS is directed to pay to
the appellant compensation of Rs. 45,000/- (Rupees Forty-Five Thousand
only) through pay order/demand draft within two weeks of receipt of this
order and file a compliance with the Commission, immediately thereafter,
through the link given in the hearing notice.”
15.
In addition to the penalty and compensation, the Commission also
issued an advisory under Section 25(5) of the RTI Act.
16.
In view of the detailed findings rendered by the Commission, it is
manifest that the penalty imposed upon Mr. Sandeep Kumar Agarwal,
Medical Superintendent-cum-PIO, is the consequence of his own acts of
omission and commission, as specifically recorded in the impugned order.
The Commission has, after affording due opportunity and upon an
exhaustive consideration of the record, held that the said officer deliberately
obstructed the flow of information, failed to comply with binding directions
of the Commission, and exhibited a nonchalant and evasive approach
towards his statutory obligations under the RTI Act. The penalty has thus
been levied in his individual capacity and is statutorily recoverable from his
salary in terms of the Act. Consequently, any grievance arising out of such
penalty is personal to the said officer alone, and if aggrieved, the law
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 27/01/2026 at 12:27:31
provides him an independent remedy. The petitioner, therefore, lacks the
requisite locus standi to espouse or agitate any challenge in respect of the
penalty so imposed, or to assail the findings recorded by the Commission
against the said officer.
17.
Furthermore, the Commission has also correctly appreciated the scope
and object of Section 19(8)(b) of the RTI Act, which empowers it to direct
payment of compensation for any loss or detriment suffered due to noncompliance with the Act. The power is remedial in nature and aims to
redress prejudice caused by unlawful denial, delay, or inaction by the
concerned authority. In the present case, the Commission has rightly
recorded a prima facie satisfaction that respondent No. 2 suffered financial
loss and hardship on account of the petitioner’s inaction.
18.
Insofar as the advisory issued by the Commission under Section 25(5)
of the RTI Act is concerned, it is settled that such an advisory is purely
recommendatory in character and does not, by itself, entail any civil, penal,
or coercive consequences against the petitioner. The statutory scheme of the
RTI Act clearly envisages that an advisory under Section 25(5) is intended
to guide and sensitize the public authority for systemic improvement and
better compliance with the provisions of the Act. It is for the appropriate
Government or competent authority to examine the said advisory and to take
such action thereon, if any, as it may deem fit and proper in accordance with
law. The issuance of the advisory in the present case is founded upon
detailed findings recorded by the Commission regarding deficiencies in
handling the RTI application and non-compliance with its earlier directions.
19.
In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, and keeping in mind
the limited scope of judicial review under Articles 226 and 227 of the
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 27/01/2026 at 12:27:31
Constitution of India, this Court does not find it appropriate to interfere with
impugned order of the Commission. The Commission has exercised its
statutory discretion within the four corners of the RTI Act, after affording
due opportunity to the parties and recording cogent reasons for its
conclusions.
20.
No perversity, procedural impropriety, or patent illegality has been
demonstrated which would justify invocation of the extraordinary writ
jurisdiction of this Court.
21.
Accordingly, the petition stands dismissed.
PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV, J
JANUARY 16, 2026/SH
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 27/01/2026 at 12:27:31
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review