Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
Date of Decision: 07.09.2026
#
CNR No. DLHC010419012026
%
LPA 694/2026 & CM APPLs. 60034/2026
DIRECTOR, VALABHBHAI PATEL CHEST INSTITUTE
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. M.K. Singh, Adv.
versus
C. RAMESH & ORS.
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr.Mohinder J.S.Rupal, Adv. for
University of Delhi.
CORAM:
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TEJAS KARIA
DEVENDRA KUMAR UPADHYAYA, CJ. (ORAL)
1.
Seeking exception to the judgment dated 28.04.2026 passed by the
learned Single Judge in W.P.(C.) No. 10595/2018, the instant intra-Court
appeal has been preferred by Vallabhai Patel Chest Institute (hereinafter
referred to as ‘VPCI’), which is an institution maintained by Delhi
University in terms of Statute 30 of the Statutes of the Delhi University read
with Ordinance XX of the Ordinance promulgated by the University under
Section 31 of the Delhi University Act, 1922.
2.
The learned Single Judge, by the impugned judgment dated
28.04.2026, has set aside the order dated 02.05.2017 whereby the services of
Signed By:SHAILNDRA
KUMAR
20:43:07
LPA 694/2026
the respondent No.1 were terminated. Simultaneously, the resolution dated
28.02.2017/07.03.2017 passed by the Executive Council of the University
insofar as it declares the Governing Body as the competent appointing and
disciplinary authority for the respondent No.1 since 21.01.1955 and so far as
it endorses the decision of the Governing Body of the institution dated
08.01.2013, has been held to be inoperative against the respondent No.1.
2.1
The learned Single Judge, vide the impugned judgment, has given an
opportunity to the appellant to initiate fresh disciplinary proceedings in
accordance with University Non-Teaching Employees (Terms and
Conditions of Service) Rules, 1971 (hereinafter referred to as ‘Service
Rules, 1971’) subject to conferment of a requisite power by the Executive
Council read along with the directions contained in the judgment dated
29.01.2014 passed by learned Single Judge in W.P.(C.) 2110/2013 and the
judgment dated 25.02.2015 passed by the Division Bench in LPA 106/2015.
The appellant has also been directed to take a considered decision as to
whether disciplinary proceedings are required to be initiated against the
respondent No.1 and communicate the same to him within a period of four
weeks.
2.2
The impugned judgment also provides that in case the appellant
decides to initiate disciplinary proceedings, the same shall be conducted in
accordance with the applicable rules and shall be concluded as expeditiously
as possible, preferably within a period of six months from the date of
initiation of such disciplinary proceedings.
Signed By:SHAILNDRA
KUMAR
20:43:07
LPA 694/2026
FACTS
3.
Certain relevant facts that are necessary to be noticed for
appropriately deciding the issue involved in this appeal are as follows:
a)
The respondent No.1, on his selection, joined the services under the
appellant against the post of Assistant Registrar (Group-A) on 09.06.2001.
b)
Governing Body of the appellant – institute took a decision on
21.01.2011 to initiate disciplinary proceedings for major penalty against the
respondent No.1, pursuant whereof a charge sheet was issued on 28.03.2011.
The respondent, on initiation of the disciplinary proceedings and issuance of
the chargesheet, objected to the competence of the Governing Body and the
Director of the appellant – institute to initiate the disciplinary proceedings;
however, on conclusion of the inquiry, a show cause notice was issued to the
respondent No.1 on 08.01.2013 proposing the penalty of dismissal from
service.
c)
Vide order of punishment dated 18.02.2013, the respondent No.1 was
dismissed from service based on the decision of the Governing Body of the
appellant – institute, which was taken in its meeting held on 27.09.2012,
whereby it was decided that the penalty of dismissal from service be
imposed upon the respondent No.1.
d)
The order of dismissal dated 18.02.2013 was challenged by the
respondent No.1 by instituting the proceedings of W.P.(C.) 2110/2013,
which was allowed by the learned Single Judge vide judgment dated
29.01.2014. The learned Single Judge set aside the order of dismissal on the
Signed By:SHAILNDRA
KUMAR
20:43:07
LPA 694/2026
ground that in terms of the provisions of Rule 69 of the Service Rules, 1971,
it is the Executive Council of the University which is competent to institute
disciplinary proceedings against any employee and not the Governing Body
of the appellant institute; and thus, in absence of any such delegation of
power in this regard by the Executive Council to the Governing Body of the
institute, the order of dismissal dated 18.02.2013 was set aside. The learned
Single Judge in the order dated 29.01.2014 referred to the provisions of
Clause 2(1)(f) of Ordinance XX of the University and returned a finding that
the said provision does not vest any authority or power with the Governing
Body of the appellant – institute to initiate any disciplinary proceedings and
since, in the instant case, the disciplinary proceedings against the respondent
No.1 were instituted by the Governing Body of the appellant – institute and
not by the Executive Council of the University, as such the very initiation of
the disciplinary proceedings were non-est which vitiated the proceedings
drawn on the said basis, as also the order of punishment of dismissal from
service dated 18.02.2013.
e)
A petition preferred by the appellant – institute seeking review of the
order dated 29.01.2014 passed by the learned Single Judge was dismissed
vide order dated 20.01.2015, whereafter the appellant – institute filed LPA
106/2015 before Division Bench of this Court. The said Letters Patent
Appeal was disposed of vide order dated 25.02.2015 without interfering with
the orders passed by the learned Single Judge, dated 29.01.2014 and
20.01.2015.
The Division Bench, by the said order dated 25.02.2015,
however, observed that since disciplinary power is vested in the Executive
Council of the University, the issue of disciplinary action against the
Signed By:SHAILNDRA
KUMAR
20:43:07
LPA 694/2026
respondent No.1 could be placed before the Executive Council for its
decision. The order dated 25.02.2015, thus, disposed of LPA 106/2015
observing therein that, in alternative to the curative route which can be taken
recourse to in terms of paragraph 8 of the judgment dated 29.01.2014 passed
by the learned Single Judge, the matter of disciplinary action could be
considered by the Executive Council of the University. Paragraph 8 of the
judgment of the learned Single Judge, dated 29.01.2014 is extracted herein
below:
“8. In view of the above, the writ petition has to be allowed on this short
ground. The order of termination has to be set aside. It is ordered
according. The respondents, however, shall be empowered to continue the
disciplinary proceedings, if so permissible in law, subject to necessary
powers being conferred upon it by either a specific general resolution of the
Executive Council. There shall, however, be no orders as to costs.”
f)
The operative portion of the order dated 25.02.2015 passed by the
Division Bench in LPA 106/2015 is also extracted herein below:
“13. Be that as it may, learned counsel for the appellant states that the
appeal may be disposed of clarifying with respect to paragraph 8 of the
decision dated January 29, 2014. The clarification being in consonance
with the reasoning of the decision dated January 29, 2014 passed by the
learned Single Judge; since the disciplinary power is vested in the Executive
Council of the University of Delhi, it may be observed that the issue of
disciplinary action against the respondent could be placed before the
Executive Council of the University of Delhi for its decision. The reason
being, the view taken by the learned Single Judge that the power as per the
rule to take disciplinary action is with the Executive Council; which power
was capable of being delegated but no delegation was shown.
14. We accordingly dispose of the appeal observing that in alternative to the
curative route which could be chartered as per para 8 of the impugned
decision, the matter of disciplinary action could be considered by the
Executive Council of the University of Delhi.”
g)
Signed By:SHAILNDRA
KUMAR
20:43:07
The matter, thereafter, was taken by the appellant – University to the
LPA 694/2026
Hon’ble Supreme Court by instituting Special Leave to Appeal (C) No.
2329/2016 which, too, was dismissed vide order dated 29.02.2016.
h)
It is relevant to point out that pursuant to the order dated 25.02.2015
passed by the Division Bench in LPA 106/2015, the Executive Council of
the University vide its resolution dated 28.05.2015 resolved that the power
to initiate disciplinary action against its employees are delegated to the
Governing Body of the appellant – institute in terms of University NonTeaching Employees (Terms and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2013
(hereinafter referred to as ‘Service Rules, 2013’). In the said resolution in
which it was also noted by the Executive Council that such powers are
already vested with the Governing Bodies of the constituent/affiliated
colleges, including the appellant institute, in terms of Service Rules, 2013.
i)
It is pertinent to note that the Service Rules, 2013 were notified by the
Registrar of the University on 28.09.2013 pursuant to the decision of the
Executive Council of the University vide resolution passed to the said effect
in its meeting held on 17.08.2013. Thus, Service Rules, 2013 were enforced
w.e.f. 17.08.2013 and simultaneously the Service Rules, 1971 were repealed
w.e.f the said date. The notification dated 26.09.2013 issued by the Registrar
of the University is extracted herein below:
“NOTIFICATION
Delhi, the 26th September, 2013
In pursuance of the decision of the Executive Council vide its
Resolution No. 14 dated the 17th August, 2013, the University NonTeaching Employees (Terms & Conditions of Service) Rules 2013 are
hereby notified. A copy of the same is enclosed herewith. These rules come
into force with effect from 17-08-2013
Signed By:SHAILNDRA
KUMAR
20:43:07
LPA 694/2026
The University Non-Teaching Employees (Terms & conditions of
Service! Rules 1971 is hereby repeated.
S/D
REGISTRAR”
j)
It appears that a contempt petition was instituted by the respondent
alleging non-compliance of the order dated 25.02.2015 passed by the
Division Bench of this Court in LPA 106/2015 read with the order dated
29.01.2014 passed by the learned Single Judge in W.P.(C.) 2110/2013. Vide
order dated 05.11.2015, the learned Contempt Judge in CONT.CAS(C)
65/2015 directed the appellant – institute to reinstate the respondent No.1 in
service in two weeks with a further observation that in any event the
respondent No.1 was not reinstated, the Acting Director of the appellant
institute would personally remain present in the Court. While passing the
said order dated 05.11.2015, the learned Contempt Judge had also noticed
that the termination order of the respondent No.1 was set aside by the
learned Single Judge and even in the LPA as well as in the clarificatory
application, the order setting aside the termination of services of the
respondent No.1 had not been modified or varied. It is in this background
that vide order dated 05.11.2015, the learned Contempt Judge directed the
appellant – institute to reinstate the respondent No.1 in service.
k)
Instead of reinstating the respondent No.1 in service, the appellant –
institute preferred LPA 155/2016 which, too, was dismissed by a Division
Bench of this Court vide order dated 22.08.2016.
The petitioner’s
application for review of the order dated 22.08.2016 was also dismissed by
the Division Bench by means of the order dated 04.10.2016.
Signed By:SHAILNDRA
KUMAR
20:43:07
LPA 694/2026
l)
It is only thereafter that vide order dated 05.12.2016, the appellant –
institute reinstated the respondent No.1 in service; however, he was
immediately
placed
under
suspension.
On
05.12.2016
itself
a
communication was made by the Governing Body of the appellant – institute
seeking approval of the Executive Council of the University of the
disciplinary action taken by the Governing Body against the respondent
No.1. The Executive Council considered the matter and passed a resolution
on 28.02.2017/07.03.2017 resolving that the Executive Council affirms that
the competent appointing and disciplinary authority of the non-teaching
employees of the appellant – institute since 21.01.1955 is the Governing
Body in terms of the resolution dated 21.01.1955. The Executive Council
also resolved that in view of the order passed by this Court in LPA 106/2015
dated 25.02.2015 it endorses the decision taken by the Governing Body
dated 08.01.2013 being the appointing and disciplinary authority to
terminate the services of the respondent No.1.
The resolution dated
28.02.2017/07.03.2017 passed by the Executive Council of the University is
extracted hereunder:
“The Executive Council, for removal of any doubt whatsoever, affirms that
the competent appointing and disciplinary authority of the non-teaching
employees of the Vallabhbhai Patel Chest Institute (VPCI) since 21.01.1955
is its Governing Body, vide EC Resolution No. 13(266) dated 21.01.1955.
Further, in view of the orders passed by the Hon'ble High Court in LPA No.
106/2015 dated 25.02.2015, the Executive Council endorses the decision
taken by the Governing Body of VPCI, dated 08.01.2013 being the
appointing and disciplinary authority, to terminate the services of Sh. C.
Ramesh.”
m)
After the said resolution dated 28.02.2017/07.03.2017 was passed by
the Executive Council of the University, the impugned order dated
Signed By:SHAILNDRA
KUMAR
20:43:07
LPA 694/2026
02.05.2017 was issued terminating the services of the respondent No.1 with
immediate effect. The order dated 02.05.2017 further provides that since the
disciplinary action, as taken by the Governing Body has been approved by
the Executive Council, the proposed payment of 25% of back wages to the
respondent would be withdrawn and the period from 18.02.2013 to
04.12.2016 would be treated as deemed suspension for which subsistence
allowance at the rate of 75% of the pay and allowances of the last pay drawn
for this period would be paid.
n)
It is this order dated 02.05.2017 terminating the services of
respondent No.1 which became the subject matter of challenge before the
learned Single Judge in the underlying W.P.(C.) 10595/2018, which has
been allowed by the impugned judgment dated 28.04.2026 by the learned
Single Judge. The learned Single Judge has, as already observed above,
quashed the order of terminating the services of respondent No.1, dated
02.05.2017 and has granted certain consequential reliefs to the respondent
No.1.
4.
Challenging this judgment dated 28.04.2026 passed by the learned
Single Judge, the instant Letters Patent Appeal has been preferred.
LEGAL PROVISIONS
5.
Before considering and reflecting upon the competing submissions
made by learned counsel representing the respective parties, we may note
certain statutory/legal provisions which are relevant for appropriate decision
of this appeal.
Signed By:SHAILNDRA
KUMAR
20:43:07
LPA 694/2026
(a) Provisions of Service Rules, 1971
6.
Rule 69 of the Service Rules, 1971 describes the authority to institute
disciplinary proceedings against non-teaching employees which reads as
under:
“69. Authority to institute proceedings:
1. The Executive Council or any other authority empowered by it by
general or special order may:(a) institute disciplinary proceedings against any employee;
(b) direct a disciplinary authority to institute disciplinary
proceedings against an employee on whom that disciplinary
authority is competent to impose under these rules any of the
penalties specified in rule 67.
2: A disciplinary authority competent under these rules to impose any
of the penalties specified in clauses (i) to (iii) of rules 67 may institute
disciplinary proceedings against any employee for the imposition of any
of the penalties specified in clauses (iv) to (vi) of rule 67
notwithstanding that such disciplinary authority is not competent under
those rules to impose any of the latter penalties.
(The Vice-Chancellor and in his absence the Pro-Chancellor,
may institute disciplinary proceedings against any employee).”
(b) Provisions of Service Rules, 2013
7.
Rule 58 of Service Rules, 2013 empowers the Executive Council of
the University to delegate any power exercisable by it under the said rules to
be exercisable by such officer or authority as may be specified in a general
or special order to be passed in this regard. Rule 58 of the Service Rules,
2013 reads as under:
“58. Delegation of Powers:
Signed By:SHAILNDRA
KUMAR
20:43:07
LPA 694/2026
The Executive Council may by general or special order, direct that any
power exercisable by it under these rules except the powers (under rule 57
of these rules) shall, subject to such conditions, if any, as may be specified
in the order be exercisable also by such officer or authority as may be
specified in the order.”
8.
Rule 64 of the Service Rules, 2013 describes the appointing authority
and appellate authority of various categories of employees of the University
and also those of the constituent/affiliated colleges. Rule 64 of Service
Rules, 2013 is extracted herein below:
“64. Appointing Authority, Disciplinary Authority and Appellate
Authority
(i) The Appointing Authority, Disciplinary Authority and Appellate
Authority in respect of employees of the University/Colleges, other than
teachers are specified in the table below.
(ii) The Executive Council may impose on an employee of the
University/College any of the penalties specified in Rule 63. (iii) Without
prejudice to the provisions of sub-Rule
(ii), the following are the Disciplinary Authorities who may impose on an
employee, the penalties specified under Rule 63:
(a) Employees of the University:
Description
of service
Appointing
Authority
Group
C
Staff
(including
erstwhile
Group
D
staff)
Group B
Registrar
Group A
Signed By:SHAILNDRA
KUMAR
20:43:07
Pro Vice
Chancellor
Executive
Council
LPA 694/2026
Disciplinary Authority competent to
impose penalties
Authority
Penalties
(Major/Minor)
Registrar
All
Appellate
Authority
Registrar
Minor
Pro Vice
Chancellor
Vice
Chancellor
All
Pro Vice
Chancellor
Vice
Chancellor
Executive
Council
Executive
All
Minor
Pro Vice
Chancellor
Executive
Council
Council
Note : Disciplinary sub-committee constituted by E. C. Resolution No. 229 dated
07/03/1987 will assist the Disciplinary Authority.
(b) Employees of the Constituent/Affiliated Colleges other than
Government Maintained Institutions
Description
of service
Appointing
Authority
Group C Staff
(including
erstwhile
Group
D
staff)
Group B
Governing
Body
Governing
Body
Governing
Body
Group A
Disciplinary Authority competent
to impose penalties
Authority
Penalties
(Major/Minor)
Governing Body
All
Appellate
Authority
Governing Body
All
Governing Body
Governing Body
All
Governing Body
Governing Body
Note: In case of an officer drawn from the Central Pool is posted to work with the
College, the disciplinary authority in his/her case would as provided under Table
(a) above.”
(c) Ordinance
9.
For the purposes of providing for certain matters relating to the affairs
of the University and its affiliated and constituent colleges, the Executive
Council of the University has been vested with power to make Ordinances
under Section 30/31 of the Delhi University Act, 1922. In exercise of the
said powers, Ordinance XX has been framed governing colleges and
institutions maintained by the University.
Clause 2 of Ordinance XX
applicable to the appellant – institute provides that subject to the control and
supervision to be exercised by the Executive Council, the Governing Body
of the appellant – institute will manage the affairs of the institute and shall
Signed By:SHAILNDRA
KUMAR
20:43:07
LPA 694/2026
have certain powers and functions which are described therein. Clause 2(f)
of Ordinance XX applicable to the appellant – institute vests the authority
with the Governing Body of the appellant – institute to appoint, suspend or
terminate the services of administrative and other non-academic staff of the
institute in respect of whom such powers may have been delegated by the
Executive Council. Sub-Clause (h) of Clause 2 of Ordinance XX applicable
to the appellant – institute also vests in the Governing Body such powers
and functions as may be assigned to it by the Executive Council of the
University. Clause 2(f) and (h) of Ordinance XX as applicable to the
appellant – institute are extracted herein below:
“Ordinance XX
2. Subject to the general control and supervision of the Executive Council,
the Governing Body will manage the affairs of the Institute and shall have
the following powers and fuctions:
(a) ***
***
***
(b) ***
***
***
(c) ***
***
***
(d) ***
***
***
(e) ***
***
***
(f) - to appoint, suspend or terminate the services of the administrative and
other non-academic staff of the Institute in respect of whom such powers
may have been delegated by the Executive Council and to determine the
emoluments and conditions of service:
Provided, however, that the qualifications for appointment, emoluments,
and conditions of service of such persons shall be in accordance with those
laid down by the Executive Council for similar posts in the University.
(g) ***
***
***
(h) to exercise such other powers and functions, as may be assigned to them
by the Executive Council.”
Signed By:SHAILNDRA
KUMAR
20:43:07
LPA 694/2026
ANALYSIS & CONCLUSION
10.
Learned counsel for the appellant has laid emphasis on two grounds.
He has, firstly, drawn our attention to the resolution of the Executive
Council of the University, dated 21.01.1955 and has stated that the said
resolution confers the power to initiate disciplinary action against the
administrative, clerical and other staff of the appellant – institute, on the
Governing Body and therefore, since in the present matter the disciplinary
action against the respondent no.1 was initiated by the Governing Body,
there is no discrepancy in the action of the appellant – institute; however,
learned Single Judge has ignored the aforesaid aspect of the matter.
11.
The aforesaid submission made by the learned counsel for the
appellant is highly misconceived. For appreciating as to what the resolution
dated 21.01.1955 was, we may state, as is apparent from a perusal of the
document enclosed with this appeal which is available on pages 194 to 197,
that by the said resolution Ordinance for administration of appellant –
institute was framed. The Ordinance framed vide the said resolution dated
21.01.1955 provides that there shall be a Governing Body constituted for the
management and administration of the appellant – institute, which shall
comprise of certain members given therein. Clause 2 of the said Ordinance,
as was framed vide resolution dated 21.01.1955, provides that the Governing
Body will manage the affairs of the institute, subject to general control and
supervision of the Executive Council and shall have certain powers and
functions prescribed therein. The resolution dated 21.01.1955 passed by the
Signed By:SHAILNDRA
KUMAR
20:43:07
LPA 694/2026
Executive Council of the University by which the Ordinance for
administration of appellant – institute was framed, is extracted hereunder:
E.C – 13
_______
21.1.55
266. Ref: E.C. No. 241 dated 17-12-54
The Council considered and accepted the report of the Committee
appointed by the Council, to consider the question of the administration of
the V.P. Chest Institute. (Appendix XII)
It was resolved that the following Ordinance be made: Ordinance for the Administration of the Vallabhbhai Patel Chest Institute
1.There shall be a governing Body constituted for the management and
administration of the V.P. Chest Institute.
E.C – 13
_______
21.1.5
The Governing Body shall be constituted as follows: 1. Chairman – Vice Chancellor or a person nominated by him.
2. Treasurer of the University (ex-officio)
3. Director of the Institute (ex-officio) – Member Secretary.
4. One member of the Executive Council nominated by the Executive
Council.
5. Dean, Faculty of Medical Science.
6. One member nominated by the Ministry of Health, Government of India.
7. One member nominated by the Ministry of Finance, Government of
India.
8. One Assistant Director of the Institute, by rotation, according to
seniority for a period of two years.
2. Subject to the general control and supervision of the Executive Council,
the Governing Body will manage the affairs of the Institute and shall have
the following powers and functions: (a) to organise the teaching and research in the Institute and determine the
staff and other requirements for the same. The Governing Body may
Signed By:SHAILNDRA
KUMAR
20:43:07
LPA 694/2026
constitute an Advisory Committee to advise it on matters of special interest
which the Institute wishes to investigate. The Advisory Committee may
include persons who are not connected with the University.
(b) subject to the control of the Academic Council, to prescribe the rules
for admission of the students, residents and (sic) resident, and the fees to
be paid by them,
(c)to frame the Budget of the Institute and submit the same for approval to
the Executive Council, and incur expenditure within the limits fixed in the
budget approved by the Executive Council,
(d) to appoint administrative, clerical and other staff of the Institute
including those to whom academic and teaching (sic) are assigned,
provided that the appointment of (sic) with teaching functions will be
subject to their recognition by the University.
(f) to exercise such other powers and functions as may be assigned to them
by Executive Council.
266. A. Ref: E.C. No. 234
Consideration of the Constitution of the Governing Body (sic) Shri
Guru Tegh Bahadur Khalsa College, and the observations (sic).
E.C – 13
_______
21.1.5
The Governing Body shall be constituted as follows: -The Governing Body shall be constituted as follows: 1. Chairman – Vice Chancellor or a person nominated by him.
2. Treasurer of the University (ex-officio)
3. Director of the Institute (ex-officio) – Member Secretary.
4. One member of the Executive Council nominated by the Executive
Council.
5. Dean, Faculty of Medical Science.
6. One member nominated by the Ministry of Health, Government of India.
7. One member nominated by the Ministry of Finance, Government of
India.
8. One Assistant Director of the Institute, by rotation, according to
seniority for a period of two years.
Signed By:SHAILNDRA
KUMAR
20:43:07
LPA 694/2026
2. Subject to the general control and supervision of the Executive Council,
the Governing Body will manage the affairs of the Institute and shall have
the following powers and functions: (a) to organise the teaching and research in the Institute and determine the
staff and other requirements for the same. The Governing Body may
constitute an Advisory Committee to advise it on matters of special interest
which the Institute wishes to investigate. The Advisory Committee may
include persons who are not connected with the University.
(b) subject to the control of the Academic Council, to prescribe the rules
for admission of the students, residents and non-residents, and the fees to
be paid by them,
(c)to frame the Budget of the Institute and submit the same for approval to
the Executive Council, and incur expenditure within the limits fixed in the
budget approved by the Executive Council,
(d) to appoint administrative, clerical and other staff of the Institute
including those to whom academic and teaching functions are assigned,
provided that the appointment of persons with teaching functions will be
subject to their recognition by the University.
(f) to exercise such other powers and functions as may be assigned to them
by Executive Council.
E.C – 13
_______
21.1.55
College on the previous comments of the Council was deferred, pending
the College supplying legible copies for members.
267. The Council sanctioned an additional post of Assistant for the
Confidential Branch of the Registrar’s office owing to increase in the work
of Examinations.
T.P.S. IYER
Registrar
Secretary
12.
Signed By:SHAILNDRA
KUMAR
20:43:07
G.S. MAHAJANI
Vice-Chancellor
Chairman.”
We may clarify that the said resolution dated 21.01.1955 was passed
LPA 694/2026
by the Executive Council framing the aforesaid Ordinance on Ref.: E.C. No.
241 dated 17.12.1954 and though in the document which has been enclosed
by the appellant along with the appeal at pages 194 to 197, the date 21-1-5
appears, however, the same seems to be typographical error for the reason
that at the last page of this document at page 197 of the appeal, the date
mentioned is 21.01.1955.
13.
Clause 2 of the afore-quoted Ordinance framed by the Executive
Council of the University vide its resolution dated 21.01.1955, vests certain
powers and functions with the Governing Body, sub-clause ‘d’ whereof
provides that the Governing Body shall be vested with the power to appoint
administrative, clerical and other staff of the appellant – institute, including
those to whom academic and teaching functions are assigned, provided that
the appointment of persons with teaching functions will be subject to their
recognition by the University. Sub-clause ‘f’ provides that the Governing
Body shall exercise such other powers and functions as may be assigned to
them by the Executive Council.
14.
Thus, the reliance placed by the learned counsel for the appellant on
the resolution dated 21.01.1955 is absolutely misplaced for the reason that
so far as appointment in the appellant – institute on various administrative,
clerical and other staff is concerned, the said power is available with the
Governing Body; however, it does not vest any power or authority to take
disciplinary action against the employees of the appellant – institute. There
is no document or material available on record whereby the Executive
Council has assigned the powers to take disciplinary action in the Governing
Signed By:SHAILNDRA
KUMAR
20:43:07
LPA 694/2026
Body of the appellant – institute. In the absence of any specific power to
initiate disciplinary action and also in absence of any assignment of any
such power by the Executive Council in the Governing Body as per the
resolution dated 21.01.1955, the submission made on behalf of the appellant
– institute that it is the Governing Body which possesses the power to
initiate disciplinary action, is untenable.
15.
The aforesaid aspect of the matter has been elaborately considered by
the learned Single Judge in the impugned judgment, where referring to the
1955 resolution, the learned Single Judge has returned a finding that the said
resolution does not in express terms designate the Governing Body as the
disciplinary authority, nor does it empower the Governing Body to institute
disciplinary proceedings for imposition of major penalty upon the
employees who are governed by the subsequent statutory regime, namely
Service Rules, 1971 wherein the authority competent to initiate such
proceedings has been prescribed.
16.
In addition to what has already been observed by the learned Single
Judge, we may refer to the provisions of Rule 69 of the Service Rules, 1971,
which has already been quoted above in a preceding paragraph of this
judgment.
Rule 69 specifically vests authority to institute disciplinary
proceedings in the Executive Council or any other authority empowered by
the Executive Council by general or special order. As has already been
observed above, there is no document or material available, whereby
Executive Council has empowered any authority other than itself to institute
disciplinary proceedings against the employees of the appellant – institute.
Signed By:SHAILNDRA
KUMAR
20:43:07
LPA 694/2026
The appointment of the respondent no.1 in the appellant – institute was
made on 09.06.2001 on the post of Assistant Registrar (Group-A) and at that
time, the rules regulating the appointment and other conditions of service
which were in vogue were the Service Rules, 1971 and therefore, all servicerelated matters which are specifically provided for in the Service Rules,
1971 are to be dealt with strictly in accordance with the provisions contained
in the said rules and not otherwise.
17.
Since Rule 69 of Service Rules, 1971 vests the authority to institute
disciplinary proceedings against the employees of the appellant – institute in
the Executive Council, in absence of any assignment of such power to any
other body including the Governing Body, we are in complete agreement
with the learned Single Judge who has rightly arrived at the conclusion that
it is the Executive Council, who was empowered to institute disciplinary
proceedings and not the Governing Body.
18.
We may also refer to the decision taken by the Executive Council vide
its resolution dated 28.02.2017/07.03.2017, wherein it has been stated that
the competent appointing and disciplinary authority of non-teaching
employees of the appellant – institute is its Governing Body since
21.01.1955 vide resolution of the Executive Council No. 13 (266) dated
21.01.1955. We have already discussed in detail as to what exactly was the
resolution No. 13 (266) dated 21.01.1955 of the Executive Council of the
University. By the said resolution, the Ordinance for administration of
Vallabhbhai Patel Chest Institute was framed, the relevant provision
whereof does not vest any authority in the Governing Body of the appellant
Signed By:SHAILNDRA
KUMAR
20:43:07
LPA 694/2026
– institute to initiate disciplinary proceedings against its employees. Thus,
the resolution dated 28.02.2017/07.03.2017 of the Executive Council
appears to be based on complete misreading of the resolution dated
21.01.1955 and therefore, the said resolution so far as it endorses the
decision taken by the Governing Body of the appellant – institute dated
08.01.2013 dismissing the respondent no.1 from service, is also completely
illegal and against the legal provisions discussed above.
19.
Since the order dated 02.05.2017 terminating the services of the
respondent no.1 is based on the resolution of the Executive Council dated
28.02.2017/07.03.2017 which we have found to be untenable, the order
dated 02.05.2017 also cannot be permitted to be sustained. Thus, in this
respect as well, the findings recorded by the learned Single Judge in the
impugned judgment, in our opinion, do not suffer from any illegality or
irregularity so as to call for any interference by us in this appeal.
20.
Learned counsel for the appellant, secondly, has also laid emphasis on
the order dated 25.02.2015 passed by the Division Bench of this Court in
LPA 106/2015, whereby the appeal was disposed of with the observation
that the appellant – institute can take recourse to alternative to the curative
route which could be chartered as per paragraph 8 of the decision of learned
Single Judge dated 29.01.2014. We have already extracted the operative
portion of the order dated 25.02.2015 passed by the Division Bench, as also
paragraph 8 of the order dated 29.01.2014 passed by the learned Single
Judge, in one of the preceding paragraphs of this judgment.
21.
Signed By:SHAILNDRA
KUMAR
20:43:07
The resolution dated 28.02.2017/07.03.2017 passed by the Executive
LPA 694/2026
Council based on which the order terminating the services of respondent
no.1 was passed, refers to the resolution dated 21.01.1955, however instead
of assigning the power of initiation of disciplinary proceedings against the
employees of the appellant – institute, the said resolution only states that the
power to institute disciplinary proceedings have all along been vested with
the Governing Body of the appellant – institute right from the year 1955 by
the Executive Council since the passing the resolution dated 21.01.1955.
The resolution dated 21.01.1955, as already discussed above, in no manner
empowers the Governing Body by which the Ordinance for administration
of appellant – institute was framed. The said Ordinance framed by the said
resolution dated 21.01.1955 nowhere empowers the Governing Body of the
appellant – institute to initiate the disciplinary proceedings against its
employees and therefore, such submission based on the order of the Division
Bench dated 25.02.2015 does not, in any manner, help the cause being
pleaded on behalf of the appellant – institute.
22.
We may also refer to the subsequent Service Rules framed in the year
2013 which were notified vide notification dated 26.09.2013 and had come
into force w.e.f. 17.08.2013. The Service Rules, 2013 do not have any
application to the facts of the present case for the reason that disciplinary
proceedings against the respondent no.1 were instituted prior to
promulgation of the said rules, i.e. on 21.01.2011. Otherwise, even Rule 64
of the Service Rules, 2013, which prescribes the appointing authority,
disciplinary authority and appellate authority, clearly stipulates that the
disciplinary authority in respect of Group-A officers of the appellant –
institute will be the Vice-Chancellor/Executive Council and accordingly,
Signed By:SHAILNDRA
KUMAR
20:43:07
LPA 694/2026
submission made on behalf of the appellant – institute based on the
provisions of Service Rules, 2013 is misplaced. Such submission is not
acceptable also for the reason that Rule 58 of Service Rules, 2013 empowers
the Executive Council of the University to delegate its powers by a general
or special order; however, no such general or special order is available on
record of this appeal, whereby the Executive Council has delegated its
power to institute disciplinary proceedings to the Governing Body of the
appellant – institute.
23.
The learned Single Judge has considered all the aforesaid aspects of
the matter and has rightly quashed the order dated 02.05.2017 whereby the
services of the respondent no.1 were terminated, and further the Executive
Council resolution dated 28.02.2017/07.03.2017 has been rightly held to be
inapplicable in so far as it endorsed the decision of the Governing Body
dated 08.01.2013.
24.
For all the aforesaid reasons, we do not find any good ground to
interfere with the impugned judgment dated 28.04.2026 passed by the
learned Single Judge in W.P.(C) 10595/2018.
25.
Resultantly, the appeal is hereby dismissed.
26.
Having regard to the facts and circumstances of the case, especially
the fact that the respondent no.1 seems to have been unnecessarily dragged
into multiple litigations for about 12 years though the order of dismissal was
set aside way back on 29.01.2014, it would be appropriate to impose a cost
of Rs.50,000/-, which shall be paid by the appellant – institute to the
Signed By:SHAILNDRA
KUMAR
20:43:07
LPA 694/2026
respondent no.1 within a period of six weeks, failing which the cost shall be
recoverable as arrears of land revenue.
27.
Application(s), if any, stand disposed of.
DEVENDRA KUMAR UPADHYAYA, CJ
TEJAS KARIA, J
SEPTEMBER 07, 2026
N.Khanna/“shailndra”
Signed By:SHAILNDRA
KUMAR
20:43:07
LPA 694/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review