Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Order reserved on: 05.08.2026
Order pronounced on: 14.08.2026
Order uploaded on: 14.08.2026
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010601662024
W.P.(C) 12736/2024 and CM APPL. 53081/2024
DIRECTOR GENERAL OF PRISONS AND
ORS
.....Petitioners
versus
RINKU KUMAR AND ORS
.....Respondents
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010638702024
W.P.(C) 13317/2024, CAV 474/2024, CM APPL. 55663/2024
and CM APPL. 55664/2024
DIRECTOR GENERAL OF PRISONS AND
ORS
.....Petitioners
versus
SUNIL KUMAR AND ORS
.....Respondents
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010656312024
W.P.(C) 13672/2024, CM APPL. 57298/2024 and CM APPL.
57299/2024
DIRECTOR GENERAL OF PRISONS AND
ORS
.....Petitioners
Versus
ANUJ AND ORS
#
+
.....Respondents
CNR No. DLHC010671082024
W.P.(C) 13875/2024, CM APPL. 58075/2024 and CM APPL.
58076/2024
DIRECTOR GENERAL OF PRISONS AND
ORS
.....Petitioners
Versus
SATYAWAN
.....Respondent
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010688742024
W.P.(C) 14183/2024, CM APPL. 59379/2024 and CM APPL.
59380/2024
DIRECTOR GENERAL OF PRISONS AND
ORS
.....Petitioners
versus
ASHISH VERMA
.....Respondent
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010792562024
W.P.(C) 15747/2024 and CM APPL. 66117/2024
DIRECTOR GENERAL OF PRISONS AND
ORS
.....Petitioners
Versus
NAVEEN SHOKEEN
.....Respondent
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010792572024
W.P.(C) 15752/2024 and CM APPL. 66132/2024
DIRECTOR GENERAL OF PRISONS AND
ORS
.....Petitioners
versus
DEEPAK AND ORS
.....Respondents
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010868292025
W.P.(C) 16837/2025 and CM APPL. 69210/2025
DIRECTOR GENERAL OF PRISONS AND
ORS
.....Petitioners
versus
MANDEEP
.....Respondent
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010415192025
W.P.(C) 9441/2025, CM APPL. 39898/2025, CM APPL.
57442/2025 and CM APPL. 78960/2025
GOVT OF NCT OF DELHI AND ORS
.....Petitioners
versus
SHEETAL
.....Respondent
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010430872025
W.P.(C) 9758/2025, CM APPL. 40779/2025 and CM APPL.
12204/2026
GOVT OF NCT OF DELHI AND ORS
.....Petitioners
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
versus
KAMAL DABAS AND ORS
Through:
.....Respondents
Ms. Esha Mazumdar, Mr. Setu Niket, Mr.
Manish Kumar and Mr. Abhishek Kumar
Yadav, Advs for Respondents in W.P.(C)
12736/2024.
Mr. M K Bhardwaj and Ms. Shakshi Saugat,
Advs. for Respondents in W.P.(C)
13317/2024, 13672/2024, 15752/2024 &
16837/2025.
Mr. Avi Karla, Mr. Prateek Lakhra and Mr.
Kartik Nigam, Advs. for Respondents in
W.P.(C)
13875/2024, 14183/2024 &
15747/2024.
Mr. Piyush Pahuja, Mr. Upender Kumar,
Advs. for Petitioners in W.P.(C) 9758/2025.
Mrs. Avnish Ahlawat SC GNCTD Services,
Mr. Nitesh Kumar Singh, Ms. Aliza Alam,
Mr. Mohnish Sehrawat, Advs. for
Petitioners in W.P.(C) 9441/2025 &
9758/2025.
Mr. Yogesh Kumar Mahur, Mr. Harkesh
Parasher, Mr.K. Suryanarayanan, Advs. for
Respondent in W.P.(C) 9441/2025.
Mr. Abbhay Behera, Sr. Adv. with Mr
Yeeshu Jain, ASC with Ms. Jyoti Tyagi, Mr.
Shubham Tanwar, Advs. for Petitioners in
all Writ Petitions.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE SHAIL JAIN
JUDGMENT
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.:
1.
Since the present Writ Petitions involve a common question of
law and arise out of substantially similar facts, they were heard
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
together and are being disposed of by this common judgment. W.P.(C)
Nos. 12736/2024, 13317/2024, 13672/2024, 13875/2024, 14183/2024,
15747/2024 and 15752/2024 assail the common judgment dated
30.04.2024 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal
Bench, New Delhi [„the Tribunal‟]. W.P.(C) No. 16837/2025 assails
the order dated 27.05.2025, W.P.(C) No. 9758/2025 assails the order
dated 25.02.2025, and W.P.(C) No. 9441/2025 assails the order dated
04.03.2025, all passed by the Tribunal in separate Original
Applications.
2.
The principal question which arises for consideration in this
batch of Writ Petitions is whether the services of probationary
employees, appointed pursuant to recruitment conducted by the Delhi
Subordinate Services Selection Board [„DSSSB‟], could have been
dispensed with on the basis of alleged mismatch in biometric
particulars, photographs and/or fingerprints, or allegations of
impersonation in the recruitment process, without holding a regular
departmental inquiry. The ancillary issue is whether the Impugned
Orders of termination are liable to be regarded as orders of
termination simpliciter or whether, having regard to their foundation
and attendant circumstances, they are punitive and stigmatic in nature?
FACTUAL MATRIX:
3.
The facts giving rise to the present batch of Writ Petitions are,
to a large extent, undisputed and may first be noticed in a consolidated
manner.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
4.
The Respondents were selected in various recruitment processes
conducted by the DSSSB pursuant to different advertisements issued
for posts under the Government of National Capital Territory of Delhi
[„GNCTD‟], including Grade-IV (DASS), Stenographer Grade-III,
Warder, Assistant Superintendent and Matron. Upon being declared
successful, their dossiers were forwarded by the DSSSB to the
concerned departments. After completion of the requisite formalities,
including verification of documents and medical examination, orders
of appointment were issued. The Respondents thereafter joined
service and, in terms of the applicable conditions of appointment,
were placed on probation or appointed provisionally, as the case may
be.
5.
Subsequently, complaints were received regarding alleged
impersonation in certain recruitment examinations conducted by the
DSSSB. The concerned authorities thereafter undertook exercises for
verification of the identity of employees who had already joined
service by comparing their biometric and photographic particulars
with the corresponding records preserved by the DSSSB at the
recruitment stage.
6.
Where discrepancies were noticed, the concerned employees
were called upon to furnish their explanations and, in appropriate
cases, were afforded further opportunities for verification. Upon such
consideration, the competent authorities formed the opinion that the
concerned employees were not suitable for retention in Government
service and accordingly proceeded to dispense with their services
under Rule 5(1) of the Central Civil Services (Temporary Service)
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
Rules, 1965 [„CCS (Temporary Service) Rules‟]. The legality of the
said action constitutes the principal controversy in the present batch of
Writ Petitions.
A.
Prison Department Matters [W.P.(C.) Nos. 12736/2024,
13317/2024, 13672/2024, 13875/2024, 14183/2024, 15747/2024 and
15752/2024]
7.
The seven Petitions in this category concern appointments made
in the Prison Department of the GNCTD. The Respondents therein
were appointed during the years 2020-2021 to the posts of Assistant
Superintendent, Warder and Matron pursuant to selections conducted
by the DSSSB under Post Codes 62/15, 63/15, 84/17, 85/17 and
86/17.
8.
Following complaints regarding impersonation in the relevant
recruitment examinations, the Petitioners undertook biometric and
photographic verification of the temporary employees appointed
against the aforesaid post codes. Three verification exercises were
conducted: the first between 23.11.2021 and 03.12.2021 at Prison
Headquarters, Tihar; the second on 09.02.2022 at the office of the
DSSSB; and the third on 28.04.2022 at the office of the DSSSB. The
third exercise was notified as the final opportunity for the concerned
employees to undergo verification.
9.
It is the case of Petitioners that the biometric particulars of
several employees did not correspond with the records preserved by
the DSSSB. Show cause notices were thereafter issued, to which the
concerned employees furnished replies disputing the discrepancies
and asserting that they were the candidates who had participated in the
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
recruitment process. The competent authority considered the material
placed before it, including the explanations furnished by the
employees, and issued orders dated 30.11.2023 and 01.12.2023 under
Rule 5(1) of the CCS (Temporary Service) Rules, bringing their
services to an end.
10.
The affected employees challenged the said orders before the
Tribunal by instituting separate Original Applications, including O.A.
Nos. 3902/2023, 3960/2023, 3990/2023, 3910/2023, 3992/2023,
3991/2023 and 3961/2023. Interim protection was granted during the
pendency of the proceedings. By the common judgment dated
30.04.2024, the Tribunal allowed the Original Applications, quashed
the orders of termination, made the interim protection absolute and
granted consequential benefits.
B.
W.P. (C.) No. 16837/2025
11.
W.P.(C.) No. 16837/2025 arises from O.A. No. 2597/2024 and
concerns the appointment of the Respondent as Warder (Male) under
Post Code 62/15. He was appointed on 02.06.2020.
12.
The DSSSB subsequently issued Office Memoranda dated
30.07.2021 and 14.09.2022 prescribing a Standard Operating
Procedure [„SOP‟] for verification of the identity of nominated
candidates. The SOP contemplated verification, in the first instance,
on the basis of the photograph and signature available in the
recruitment records and, where necessary, biometric verification with
the assistance of the DSSSB.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
13.
It is the Petitioners‟ case that the Respondent‟s credentials were
verified in accordance with the aforesaid procedure and that the
biometric verification did not establish a match. His services were
thereafter brought to an end under Rule 5(1) of the CCS (Temporary
Service) Rules. He challenged the said action in O.A. No. 2597/2024,
which was allowed by the Tribunal by order dated 27.05.2025,
resulting in the filing of the present Petition.
C.
DASS Recruitment Matters
i.
W.P.(C.) No. 9441/2025
14.
W.P.(C.) No. 9441/2025 concerns recruitment to the post of
Grade-IV (DASS) pursuant to Advertisement No. 01/2017 issued by
the DSSSB. The Respondent was provisionally appointed after being
declared successful, subject to verification of his eligibility,
documents, character and other prescribed conditions.
15.
The Respondent was subjected to biometric and photographic
verification on different occasions. It is the Petitioner‟s case that the
Respondent did not successfully clear the verification and was absent
from one of the scheduled exercises despite being afforded an
opportunity. A further opportunity was thereafter afforded. The
Petitioners also rely upon a communication dated 07.07.2023, stated
to contain an admission that another person had appeared on the
Respondent‟s behalf in the written examination, as well as upon the
verification report dated 01.09.2023 recording mismatch in the
fingerprint and photographic comparison.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
16.
The Respondent‟s services were dispensed with by order dated
12.09.2023, which was challenged in O.A. No. 3239/2023. The same
was allowed by the Tribunal by order dated 04.03.2025. The said
order is assailed in the present Petition.
ii.
W.P.(C.) No. 9758/2025
17.
W.P.(C.) No. 9758/2025 concerns recruitment pursuant to
Advertisement Nos. 01/2017 and 02/2018 issued by the DSSSB for
the posts of Grade-IV (DASS), Junior Assistant and Stenographer
Grade-III. The Respondents were provisionally appointed subject to
verification of their eligibility and compliance with the applicable
conditions of appointment.
18.
Biometric and photographic verification of the Respondents
was conducted on different dates during 2021 and 2022. It is the
Petitioners‟ case that discrepancies were noticed between the
particulars obtained during verification and the biometric records
preserved by the DSSSB. The services of the Respondents were
thereafter brought to an end by notices dated 05.09.2023 issued under
Rule 5(1) of the CCS (Temporary Service) Rules. During this period,
the probation of certain Respondents had also been extended from
time to time.
19.
The Respondents challenged the said action in O.A. No.
2846/2023. By order dated 25.02.2025, the Tribunal allowed the
Original Application, quashed the orders of termination and made the
interim protection earlier granted in their favour absolute. The said
order is under challenge in the present petition.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
20.
It may also be noticed that while deciding O.A. Nos.
2597/2024, 3239/2023 and 2846/2023, the Tribunal substantially
relied upon the reasoning adopted in the common judgment dated
30.04.2024 rendered in O.A. Nos. 3902/2023 and connected matters.
It is these four orders of the Tribunal which are under challenge before
this Court in the present batch of Writ Petitions.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES:
21.
Contentions on behalf of the Petitioners:
21.1. It was submitted that the Tribunal erred in treating the orders of
termination as punitive merely because the competent authority had
considered the material arising from the biometric and photographic
verification and the explanations furnished by the Respondents. The
relevant test, according to the Petitioners, is whether the material was
treated as the foundation for a finding of misconduct, or merely as
material relevant to the assessment of suitability for continued
retention in service.
21.2. It was submitted that the Respondents were temporary
Government servants on probation and their services were governed
by Rule 5(1) of the CCS (Temporary Service) Rules. The said
provision does not require a regular departmental inquiry where the
competent authority, without adjudicating upon any charge of
misconduct or imposing a penalty, forms the opinion that a
probationer ought not to be retained in service. The Petitioners
accordingly contended that the absence of a departmental inquiry, by
itself, could not render the orders of termination punitive.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
21.3. According to the Petitioners, the competent authority did not
undertake any adjudication to determine whether the Respondents
were guilty of impersonation. No charge was framed, no finding of
guilt was recorded and no disciplinary penalty was imposed. The
material gathered during verification was considered only for the
purpose of determining whether the Respondents were suitable for
continued retention in service. The fact that their explanations were
not accepted could not, by itself, convert such assessment into an
adjudication of misconduct.
21.4. Reliance was placed upon the distinction between “motive” and
“foundation” recognised by the Supreme Court, particularly in
Radhey Shyam Gupta v. U.P. State Agro Industries Corporation
Ltd.1. It was submitted that an employer may take into consideration
material which creates a doubt regarding the suitability of a
probationer without making such material the foundation of a punitive
order. Where the employer does not determine the truth of the
allegation or record a finding of misconduct, but merely decides not to
continue the employee, the allegation operates only as a motive for the
termination.
21.5. Reliance was also placed upon Pavanendra Narayan Verma v.
Sanjay Gandhi P.G.I. of Medical Sciences2, to contend that the Court
is required to examine not merely the form of the order but also its
substance. According to the Petitioners, however, the present orders,
when examined in substance, do not disclose any adjudicated finding
(1999) 2 SCC 21
AIR 2002 SC 23
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
of misconduct and therefore remain orders of termination simpliciter.
21.6. It was accordingly contended that the Tribunal erred in treating
the biometric discrepancies and the consideration of the Respondents‟
explanations as determinative of the character of the termination.
These circumstances, according to the Petitioners, constituted the
material on the basis of which suitability was assessed; they did not
amount to a determination that the Respondents had committed the
misconduct of impersonation. The Petitioners therefore submitted that
the Tribunal could not have required a departmental inquiry merely
because the competent authority had considered adverse material
before exercising the power under Rule 5(1).
21.7. It was further submitted that the fact that the alleged irregularity
related to the recruitment examination, and therefore preceded the
Respondents‟ entry into service, was also material. It was contended
that the termination was not imposed as a punishment for misconduct
committed during service, but resulted from the competent authority‟s
assessment that the Respondents ought not to be retained in
Government service.
21.8. The Petitioners also challenged the Tribunal‟s direction
requiring or contemplating a fresh biometric and photographic
verification exercise. It was submitted that the Respondents had
already been afforded opportunities for verification and that the
competent authority had considered the material generated during
those exercises. A further verification, according to the Petitioners,
could not be treated as a condition precedent to the exercise of the
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
power under Rule 5(1).
21.9. In relation to W.P.(C.) No. 16837/2025, learned counsel
additionally relied upon the DSSSB‟s SOP and submitted that the
procedure had been evolved specifically to enable the user
departments to verify the identity and credentials of candidates
nominated for appointment. It was contended that the Respondent‟s
appointment was provisional and subject to verification of his
credentials and that the verification undertaken pursuant to the SOP
was therefore part of the mechanism governing his appointment. Upon
the verification disclosing a mismatch, the competent authority was
entitled to conclude that the Respondent could not be retained in
service. The action, according to the Petitioners, was consequently
referable to the conditional nature of the appointment and not to the
imposition of a disciplinary penalty.
21.10. As regards W.P.(C.) No. 9441/2025, it was submitted that the
material against the Respondent was not confined to the biometric and
photographic verification. Reliance was particularly placed upon the
communication dated 07.07.2023, which, according to the Petitioners,
contained an admission that another individual had appeared in the
written examination on the Respondent‟s behalf. It was contended
that, when considered with the verification material, this furnished
sufficient basis for the competent authority to conclude that the
Respondent was not entitled to continue in service. According to the
Petitioners, the order dated 12.09.2023 was therefore an order giving
effect to the discovery that the Respondent was not the candidate who
had participated in the recruitment examination, and not a punishment
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
imposed upon him for misconduct.
21.11. It was further submitted that an appointment obtained through
impersonation could not confer an enforceable right to continuation in
Government service. It was contended that, in such circumstances, the
question was whether the Respondent was entitled to the appointment
in the first place, rather than whether a disciplinary penalty ought to
be imposed upon him.
21.12. In relation to W.P.(C.) No. 9758/2025, it was submitted that the
Respondents‟ appointments
were provisional
and subject to
verification of their credentials. The Petitioners contended that the
subsequent extension of the period of probation did not confer any
independent right to continuation in service contrary to the terms
governing the appointments. The results of the verification exercises,
according to the Petitioners, were therefore relevant to the competent
authority‟s assessment of whether the Respondents ought to be
retained.
21.13. It was further submitted that the Tribunal, while deciding O.A.
No. 3239/2023, had substantially relied upon the reasoning contained
in the common judgment dated 30.04.2024 in O.A. No. 3902/2023
and connected matters. It was pointed out that the said judgment was
already under challenge before this Court in W.P.(C.) No. 12736/2024
and that its operation had been stayed by order dated 11.09.2024. On
this basis, it was urged that the order dated 04.03.2025, having
proceeded substantially on the reasoning of the judgment whose
operation had been stayed, was liable to be set aside.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
21.14. It was thus submitted that the Tribunal had incorrectly treated
an assessment of suitability as an adjudication of misconduct.
According to them, the impugned orders were issued in exercise of the
power under Rule 5(1), without recording a finding of guilt or
imposing a disciplinary penalty, and therefore could not be
characterised as punitive or stigmatic merely because adverse material
had been considered before the decision to terminate was taken.
22.
Contentions on behalf of the Respondents:
22.1. Per contra, learned counsel for the Respondents supported the
orders passed by the Tribunal and submitted that, notwithstanding
their form, the Impugned Orders were founded upon the allegation
that the Respondents had impersonated other candidates and/or
procured appointment through unfair means. According to the
Respondents, the competent authorities had not merely assessed their
suitability but had reached a factual conclusion regarding the
genuineness of their candidature. Such a conclusion, it was contended,
amounted in substance to a finding of misconduct and could not have
been recorded without following the procedure prescribed by law.
22.2. It was submitted that the Respondents had successfully
undergone the recruitment process, had been declared successful, and
had thereafter been appointed following scrutiny of their dossiers and
verification of their credentials by the concerned authorities. It was
contended that their identity had consequently been verified at
multiple stages of the recruitment and appointment process and could
not subsequently be displaced merely on the basis of a later biometric
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
exercise without a proper examination of the entire material.
22.3. In relation to the Prison Department matters, attention was
drawn to the safeguards employed by the DSSSB during the
recruitment examination, including verification of photographs, admit
cards and identity documents, taking of photographs and biometric
particulars, verification of signatures and thumb impressions, and the
use of videography and CCTV recordings. It was submitted that the
recruitment process thus contained contemporaneous material capable
of independently establishing the identity of the candidates who
appeared in the examination.
22.4. It was further submitted that the reliability and conclusiveness
of the subsequent biometric verification were specifically disputed.
According to the Respondents, the biometric exercise produced
varying facial and fingerprint matching results and was therefore not,
by itself, capable of conclusively establishing impersonation. It was
contended that the authorities ought to have considered the other
contemporaneous material, including photographs, videography,
CCTV footage, thumb impressions, signatures and specimen
handwriting, before drawing any adverse conclusion.
22.5. It was further submitted that the Respondents had sought expert
examination of the relevant material, including by an appropriate
forensic agency, but such comprehensive verification was not
undertaken. It was also contended that the biometric reports and other
material relied upon by the authorities were not initially furnished to
the Respondents, thereby depriving them of an effective opportunity
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
to meet the case against them.
22.6. It was submitted that the Respondents had consistently denied
the allegation of impersonation and had offered to establish their
identity by reference to the original recruitment records and by
providing fresh specimen handwriting and thumb impressions for
comparison.
According
to
the
Respondents,
the
authorities
nevertheless proceeded to draw an adverse conclusion without
undertaking the verification sought by them. The constitution of
committees in certain cases to examine the relevant material, it was
submitted, itself demonstrated that the issue required proper
evaluation and could not be conclusively determined on the basis of
an isolated machine-generated result.
22.7. It was accordingly contended that, by relying upon the alleged
biometric discrepancies to terminate the Respondents‟ services, the
Petitioners had effectively recorded a finding that the Respondents
had obtained appointment through impersonation or unfair means.
Such a finding, according to the Respondents, had serious civil
consequences and could not be reached behind their back or without
affording them a reasonable opportunity to test the material relied
upon.
22.8. It was submitted that the distinction between a termination
founded upon suitability and one founded upon misconduct was well
settled. While antecedent circumstances may constitute the motive for
deciding not to retain a probationer, the position is different where the
employer proceeds on the basis that the employee has committed a
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
specific act of misconduct. Once the allegation of impersonation
became the foundation of the decision to terminate, the Petitioners
could not circumvent the safeguards applicable to disciplinary action
merely by invoking Rule 5(1) or describing the order as one of
termination simpliciter.
22.9. Reliance was placed upon the judgment of this Court in Union
of India & Ors. v. Sanjeev Kumar & Anr.3. It was submitted that the
said decision concerned employees who had already entered service
and whose services were subsequently terminated on the basis of
material alleging irregularity/impersonation in the recruitment
process. According to the Respondents, this Court held that where
such material constituted the basis for termination and the employee
was not afforded a proper opportunity to meet it, the termination could
not be sustained merely by invoking Rule 5 of the CCS (Temporary
Service) Rules. It was contended that the principle was directly
applicable to the present cases.
22.10. As regards the Petitioners‟ reliance upon the probationary and
temporary status of the Respondents, it was submitted that the limited
right of a probationer to continue in service was not disputed. The
contention, however, was that such status does not authorise a punitive
or stigmatic termination without adherence to the procedure
prescribed by law. According to the Respondents, the absence of a
vested right to the post cannot dispense with procedural fairness where
the termination is founded upon misconduct.
W.P.(C.) No. 15248/2022 decided on 18.07.2024
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
22.11. It was further submitted that the fact that the alleged irregularity
occurred at the stage of recruitment did not alter the character of the
action once the Petitioners chose to rely upon it for terminating
persons who had already entered Government service. The relevant
consideration, according to the Respondents, was whether the
allegation was merely an antecedent circumstance taken into account
while assessing suitability or had become the foundation for bringing
the existing service to an end.
22.12. The Respondents also disputed the Petitioners‟ reliance upon
the provisional or conditional nature of their appointments. It was
submitted that, after selection, scrutiny of dossiers, verification of
credentials and entry into service, the terms of appointment could not
be invoked to bypass a fair procedure where the authorities sought to
terminate the Respondents on the allegation that their appointments
had been procured through impersonation.
22.13. It was further submitted that the Respondents had rendered
service for several years before the orders of termination were passed.
According to them, the lapse of time between the recruitment process
and the termination, coupled with the serious consequences of an
allegation of impersonation, reinforced the necessity of properly
establishing the allegation before their existing service could be
brought to an end.
22.14. In relation to W.P.(C.) No. 16837/2025, it was submitted that
the DSSSB‟s verification procedure could facilitate verification of
identity but could not dispense with a fair adjudication where the
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
material was sought to be used to sustain an allegation of
impersonation against a person who had already entered service.
22.15. As regards W.P.(C.) No. 9441/2025, the Respondent disputed
the Petitioners‟ reliance upon the communication dated 07.07.2023
and submitted that the circumstances in which the communication was
made and the explanation subsequently furnished required proper
consideration. It was contended that, even if the material raised a
serious doubt regarding the candidature, such doubt could not by itself
justify a stigmatic termination without an effective opportunity to
establish the Respondent‟s case and without properly determining the
allegation of impersonation.
22.16. Insofar as W.P.(C.) No. 9758/2025 is concerned, the
Respondents submitted that the biometric discrepancies did not
establish impersonation and that they had consistently denied the
allegation. It was further contended that the extension of probation
could not be treated as an admission of any defect in their candidature.
If the Petitioners intended to rely upon the alleged discrepancies as
proof of misconduct, the Respondents submitted, the same had to be
established in accordance with law.
22.17. It was therefore submitted that the controversy was not confined
to the suitability of the Respondents as probationers. According to the
Respondents, once the Petitioners proceeded on the basis that the
Respondents had obtained appointment through impersonation or
unfair means, the resulting termination was punitive in substance and
could not be sustained without first establishing the allegation in
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
accordance with law and after affording the Respondents an effective
opportunity to meet the material relied upon.
ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION:
23.
In view of the rival submissions and the material placed on
record, the following questions arise for determination:
23.1. Whether the orders terminating the services of the Respondents
under Rule 5(1) of the CCS (Temporary Service) Rules were, in
substance, orders of termination simpliciter based upon an assessment
of their suitability and genuineness of appointment, or were punitive
orders founded upon a finding of misconduct, thereby attracting the
procedural safeguards applicable to disciplinary proceedings?
23.2. Whether the material relied upon by the Petitioners, including
the
biometric
and
photographic
verification
and
the
other
identification material available on record, was sufficient to sustain
the conclusion that the Respondents had failed to establish that they
were the candidates who had participated in the recruitment process
and were selected for appointment?
23.3. Whether the Tribunal, in quashing the orders of termination,
failed to properly appreciate the nature and effect of the material
relied upon by the competent authorities and thereby arrived at
findings which are legally unsustainable?
ANALYSIS & FINDINGS:
24.
This Court has carefully considered the submissions advanced
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
on behalf of the parties and perused the material on record.
25.
The controversy in the present batch essentially concerns the
legal consequence of the biometric and photographic verification
undertaken by the Petitioners after the Respondents had entered
service. The Tribunal proceeded on the premise that the Respondents
had acquired valid appointments and that the subsequent verification
exercise was, in substance, an attempt to establish that they had
committed the misconduct of impersonation in the recruitment
examination. The Petitioners, on the other hand, contend that the
verification exercise was undertaken to ascertain a more fundamental
question, namely, whether the persons who had entered service were
in fact the candidates who had participated in the recruitment process
and whose candidature had resulted in their selection and
appointment.
26.
The distinction is material. An appointment to a post pursuant
to a recruitment process necessarily attaches to the candidature of the
person who participated in that process and was selected thereunder.
The identity of the candidate is, therefore, not a collateral
circumstance but forms part of the foundation of the appointment
itself.
27.
If, subsequent to appointment, material emerges which raises a
serious and substantiated doubt as to whether the person who entered
service is the same person whose candidature was considered and
selected, the competent authority is entitled to examine the validity of
the appointment itself. Such an enquiry is conceptually distinct from
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
an enquiry into whether the concerned person deliberately
impersonated another candidate or committed any other act of
misconduct.
28.
The distinction assumes particular significance in the present
batch. The case of the Petitioners is not that the Respondents
committed any misconduct in the discharge of their duties after
entering service. The controversy originates from the recruitment
process itself and concerns the identity of the persons who participated
in that process and were thereafter appointed. The question, therefore,
is anterior to the question of disciplinary culpability.
29.
The Tribunal, however, proceeded substantially on the basis
that the Petitioners were required to establish, through a regular
disciplinary enquiry, that each of the Respondents had committed the
act of impersonation before his or her services could be brought to an
end. In doing so, the Tribunal did not sufficiently distinguish between
a finding that a person has committed misconduct and a determination
that the person holding an appointment has not established that he or
she was the candidate selected through the recruitment process.
30.
The
distinction
between
cancellation
of
appointment,
termination simpliciter and punitive termination is well settled. A
probationer or temporary Government servant does not acquire an
indefeasible right to continue in service merely by virtue of having
been appointed. Where the applicable service conditions permit, the
competent authority may discontinue such an employee on the ground
of unsuitability, without holding a regular disciplinary enquiry,
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
provided that the action is not founded upon a determination of
misconduct. In this batch, the Respondents are proved to have passed
the recruitment examination. In fact, some impersonators wrote
recruitment examinations on behalf of the Respondents.
31.
Rule 5(1) of the CCS (Temporary Service) Rules, insofar as
relevant, reads as under:
“5. Termination of temporary service.
(1) (a) The services of a temporary Government servant shall be liable
to termination at any time by a notice in writing given either by the
Government servant to the appointing authority or by the appointing
authority to the Government servant;
(b) the period of such notice shall be one month.
Provided that the services of any such Government servant may be
terminated forthwith and on such termination, the Government
servant shall be entitled to claim a sum equivalent to the amount of his
pay plus allowances for the period of the notice at the same rates at
which he was drawing them immediately before the termination of his
services, or as the case may be, for the period by which such notice
falls short of one month.
NOTE:- The following procedure shall be adopted by the appointing
authority while serving notice on such Government servant under
clause (a).
(i) The notice shall be delivered or tendered to the Government
servant in person.
(ii) Where personal service is not practicable, the notice shall be
served on such Government servant by registered post,
acknowledgement due at the address of the Government servant
available with the appointing authority.
(iii) If the notice sent by registered post is returned unserved it shall
be published in the Official Gazette and upon such publication, it shall
be deemed to have been personally served on such Government
servant on the date it was published in the Official Gazette.”
32.
The present cases, however, cannot be determined merely by
examining the form in which the competent authorities described their
orders. The Court is required to examine the substance of the action
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
and, more importantly, the nature of the right which the competent
authority was seeking to bring to an end.
33.
The appointment documents assume significance in this regard.
A substantial number of the Respondents were appointed against
temporary posts. Clause 3 of the offer of appointment expressly
stipulated:
“The post is temporary. In the event of its becoming permanent, his
claim for appointment thereto in substantive capacity will be
considered in accordance with the rules in force.”
34.
The appointment orders further stipulated that the appointment
was provisional and subject to verification of the candidate's character
and antecedents by the competent authority. The relevant condition
reads:
“The appointment is provisional & subject to Verification of
Character & Antecedents from the Competent Authority.”
35.
These conditions cannot be treated as surplusage. They make it
clear that the appointment was not unconditional or insulated from
subsequent verification. The Respondents‟ continuance in service was
subject to the conditions incorporated in their respective offers and
appointment orders. Consequently, the fact that they had entered
service did not preclude the competent authority from undertaking
verification relevant to the genuineness of their candidature and the
validity of the appointment.
36.
The provisional nature of the appointment is particularly
relevant in the present context. The verification undertaken by the
Petitioners was not an enquiry into the conduct of the Respondents
while in service. It was directed towards determining whether the
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
persons who had been appointed were, in fact, the candidates whose
candidature had been processed and selected. Where the answer to
that foundational question is rendered doubtful by the verification
material, the consequence is not necessarily one of disciplinary
punishment.
37.
The jurisprudence relating to “motive” and “foundation”
remains relevant while examining whether the action is punitive. In
Radhey Shyam Gupta (supra), the Supreme Court recognised that
material concerning the suitability of a probationer may constitute the
motive for discontinuance, so long as the employer does not
adjudicate upon the truth of an allegation of misconduct and found the
order upon such adjudication. Likewise, in Pavanendra Narayan
Verma (supra), the Supreme Court emphasised that the substance of
the order and the basis of the decision, rather than its mere form or
nomenclature, must be examined to determine whether the action is
punitive.
38.
This Court has applied the same principle in the context of Rule
5 of the CCS (Temporary Service) Rules. In Government of NCT of
Delhi and Anr. v. Dalbir Singh4, it was held that a preliminary
exercise undertaken to ascertain whether a probationer ought to be
retained in service does not, by itself, render the subsequent
discontinuance punitive. Similarly in Govt. of NCT of Delhi and Ors.
v. Virender5 , this Court reiterated that the circumstances which lead
the competent authority to form an opinion regarding suitability do
W.P.(C.) 6596/2023 decided on 06.09.2023
W.P.(C.) 12696/2023 decided on 28.02.2024
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
not, without more, convert an order of discontinuance into a punitive
termination.
39.
These principles, however, do not mean that an employer may
avoid a disciplinary enquiry merely by describing an action as one of
suitability. The substance of the decision remains determinative. The
question in the present case is therefore whether the competent
authorities adjudicated the Respondents‟ guilt for impersonation or
whether they acted upon material which rendered the genuineness of
their candidature and consequently the validity of their appointments
doubtful.
40.
The distinction between the two enquiries may be stated
succinctly. An enquiry into whether the person appointed is the
candidate selected concerns the foundation of the appointment. An
enquiry into whether that person deliberately impersonated another
candidate concerns culpability for misconduct but the same is not
connected with discharge of duty by the employee.
41.
The use of expressions such as “impersonation”, “unfair means”
or “mala fide intention” in the notices or communications issued
during the verification exercise cannot, therefore, be viewed in
isolation. The Court must ascertain whether the competent authority
actually adjudicated upon such allegations and imposed a punishment
on the basis of a finding of guilt, or whether those expressions were
used while recording the circumstances which led the authority to
conclude that the candidature and identity of the person in service had
not been satisfactorily established.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
42.
The material concerning identity must also be considered
cumulatively. Photographs, signatures, videography, CCTV footage
and biometric particulars are all relevant forms of identification
material,
though
they do
not
possess
identical
evidentiary
characteristics. A photograph records visual appearance at a particular
point in time, whereas fingerprints and thumb impressions constitute
biometric identifiers capable of direct comparison with the
corresponding records generated during the recruitment process.
43.
The significance of biometric verification is further enhanced
where the discrepancy is not confined to a single exercise. An isolated
mismatch may warrant further examination. Repeated mismatches,
particularly where the concerned person has been afforded further
opportunities to establish his or her identity, constitute materially
different circumstances. At the same time, this Court is not holding
that every biometric mismatch, considered in isolation, is conclusive.
The circumstances in which the verification was undertaken, the
reliability of the material, the number of verification exercises, the
other identification material available and the explanation furnished
by the concerned employee are all relevant.
44.
The Respondents were, in the cases under consideration,
afforded opportunities to participate in the verification exercises and
to explain the discrepancies noticed. The question is not whether
every conceivable procedure could have been adopted, but whether a
regular disciplinary enquiry was an indispensable precondition to the
competent authority examining the genuineness of the appointments.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
45.
The decision of this Court in Sanjeev Kumar (supra), relied
upon by the Respondents, does not warrant a different conclusion.
That case concerned employees whose termination was expressly
founded upon allegations that they had adopted unfair means in the
recruitment examination by arranging for another person to
impersonate them. The Court found the action to be stigmatic and took
note, inter alia, of the fact that the forensic material relied upon had
not been properly tested through a departmental enquiry and
constituted the principal material for establishing the alleged
misconduct.
46.
The factual foundation in the present batch is materially
different. The Petitioners are not relying upon a solitary forensic
opinion as proof of a completed act of misconduct. In the cases
concerning the Prison Department, the material includes biometric
verification undertaken on repeated occasions and comparison of the
fingerprints/thumb impressions recorded at the recruitment stage with
those subsequently obtained from the concerned employees. The
question is consequently whether such material was capable of
supporting the conclusion that the identity of the persons holding the
appointments had not been satisfactorily established.
47.
It follows that the absence of a regular departmental enquiry
cannot, by itself, invalidate the action taken by the competent
authorities. Such an enquiry would be necessary if the object were to
impose a disciplinary penalty upon a finding that a Respondent had
committed misconduct. It would not necessarily be required where the
competent authority is determining whether the foundational condition
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
of the appointment, namely, that the person appointed is the candidate
selected through the recruitment process, stands established.
48.
The fact that the Respondents had already joined service or had
rendered service for a period of time does not alter this position.
Length of service may have relevance to the consequences that follow,
but it cannot retrospectively establish the identity of the person who
participated in the recruitment process.
49.
The Tribunal was, therefore, required to examine the
verification material and determine whether the competent authorities
had acted upon material relevant to the validity of the appointments.
In exercising judicial review, the Tribunal was not required to
substitute its own factual assessment for that of the competent
authority merely because another view could possibly be taken.
Equally, it was required to intervene if the conclusion was
unsupported by the record, arbitrary or legally impermissible.
50.
The jurisdiction of this Court under Articles 226 and 227 of the
Constitution is similarly supervisory and not appellate. Interference is
warranted where the Tribunal proceeds upon an erroneous legal
premise, ignores material evidence or reaches a conclusion which is
unsustainable on the record. In the present batch, the principal error in
the Impugned Orders is that the Tribunal proceeded on the assumption
that the Petitioners had necessarily adjudicated the guilt of the
Respondents for impersonation, without first examining the anterior
question of whether the Respondents had established that they were
the candidates whose candidature had resulted in their appointments.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
51.
This Court is, therefore, of the view that the Petitioners were
entitled to undertake verification for determining whether the persons
who had entered service were the persons selected through the
recruitment process. Where, upon consideration of the material
available, the competent authority was not satisfied that such identity
had been established, the absence of a disciplinary enquiry for proving
the separate allegation of impersonation could not, by itself, invalidate
the action.
52.
It is equally important to clarify what this Court is not holding.
The Court is not recording a finding that any particular Respondent
has committed the criminal offence of impersonation or has been
proved guilty of any disciplinary misconduct. The present proceedings
do not require, and do not justify, such a finding. The Court is
concerned with the legal consequence of the failure to establish the
foundational identity underlying the appointment.
53.
The aforesaid principles shall now be applied to the individual
matters, since the factual material and the circumstances relied upon
by the competent authorities are not identical in every case.
W.P.(C.) Nos. 12736/2024, 13317/2024, 13672/2024, 13875/2024,
14183/2024, 15747/2024 and 15752/2024
54.
These seven Writ Petitions arise from the common judgment
dated 30.04.2024 passed by the Tribunal. The Respondents had been
appointed to various posts in the Prison Department and were
continuing as probationers when the orders dated 30.11.2023 and
01.12.2023 were issued.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
55.
The record discloses that the verification exercise was not
confined to a single comparison. Verification was undertaken on three
occasions, and while a substantial number of candidates were found to
have matching credentials, the biometric particulars of the concerned
Respondents did not correspond with those preserved in the DSSSB
records.
56.
The Respondents were also afforded opportunities to explain
the discrepancies. Following the initial verification, show cause
notices were issued; replies were furnished; and further opportunities
for
biometric
and
photographic
verification
were
afforded.
Memoranda dated 09.09.2022 were thereafter issued calling upon the
concerned employees to explain the discrepancies, and their responses
were considered before action was taken.
57.
The Tribunal nevertheless treated the exercise principally as an
enquiry into alleged impersonation. It was influenced, inter alia, by
references in the notices and memoranda to mismatch of biometric
and photographic particulars as being prima facie indicative of
impersonation, as well as by references in the orders to unfair means
or mala fide intention in the recruitment examination.
58.
The relevant question, however, was whether those references
demonstrated an adjudication of guilt or merely described the
circumstances which led the competent authorities to doubt the
genuineness of the candidature. The termination notice in the case of
Rinku Kumar is illustrative. It records the biometric mismatch on
more than one occasion, the opportunity afforded to the Respondent to
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
explain the discrepancy and the subsequent verification which again
resulted in a mismatch. The competent authority thereafter concluded
that the Respondent‟s retention in Government service was not
desirable.
59.
The repeated verification exercises are significant. The
Respondents were afforded more than one opportunity to establish
their identity, yet the discrepancy continued to emerge from the
verification material. The competent authority considered the
explanations furnished before taking action. In these circumstances,
the record does not justify treating the exercise as though the
Petitioners had conducted a disciplinary adjudication and recorded a
finding of guilt for impersonation.
60.
The references in the notices to unfair means or mala fide
intention do not alter this conclusion. The decisive consideration is the
substance of the decision. The competent authorities acted upon the
verification material and the inability to satisfactorily establish the
identity of the persons holding the appointments. The absence of a
disciplinary enquiry to establish a separate allegation of culpable
impersonation could not, therefore, be treated as fatal.
61.
The Respondents‟ reliance upon photographs, signatures,
videography and other material, and their request for further expert
examination, does not warrant a different conclusion. The competent
authority was entitled to consider the entire identification material
available to it. In writ jurisdiction, this Court is not required to
undertake a fresh biometric or technical examination unless the
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
conclusion reached is unsupported by the record, arbitrary or perverse.
62.
The Tribunal consequently erred in treating the action as
necessarily punitive and in proceeding on the premise that the
Petitioners were first required to establish the precise act of
impersonation through disciplinary proceedings. The relevant enquiry
was whether the Respondents had established that they were the
candidates selected through the recruitment process. On the material
placed before the competent authorities, that question could
legitimately be examined through the verification exercise.
63.
The common judgment dated 30.04.2024 is, therefore,
unsustainable to the extent it proceeds on the premise that a regular
disciplinary enquiry was an indispensable precondition to the action
taken in these cases.
W.P.(C.) No. 16837/2025 – Mandeep
64.
W.P.(C.) No. 16837/2025 arises from O.A. No. 2597/2024 and
requires separate consideration on account of the particular
verification procedure relied upon by the Petitioners.
65.
The Respondent, Mandeep, was selected for appointment to the
post of Warder (Male) under Post Code 62/15 and was appointed on
02.06.2020. His services were thereafter brought to an end by notice
dated 30.11.2023 issued under Rule 5(1) of the CCS (Temporary
Service) Rules.
66.
The Petitioners rely upon the SOP issued by the DSSSB
through Office Memoranda dated 30.07.2021 and 14.09.2022. The
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
procedure contemplated verification of the nominated candidate with
reference to the photograph and signature contained in the recruitment
records and, where the appointing authority remained dissatisfied with
the identity or credentials, biometric verification with the assistance of
the DSSSB.
67.
The record placed before the Tribunal shows that the
Respondent was afforded repeated opportunities for verification. The
Petitioners specifically contend that biometric verification was
conducted on five occasions and that the Respondent failed to obtain a
matching result.
68.
The Tribunal, however, followed its earlier decision in Rinku
Kumar and connected matters and treated the language of the notice as
establishing a punitive and stigmatic termination. For the reasons
already recorded, similarity in the language employed in the notices
cannot by itself determine their legal character.
69.
The repeated verification exercises were directly relevant to the
foundational question whether the Respondent was the candidate
selected through the recruitment process. The Tribunal did not
adequately undertake that enquiry and instead treated the references to
unfair means and mala fide intention as necessarily constituting a
finding of misconduct.
70.
The order dated 27.05.2025 passed by the Tribunal in O.A. No.
2597/2024 is accordingly liable to be set aside.
W.P.(C.) No. 9441/2025 – Sheetal
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
71.
W.P.(C.) No. 9441/2025 stands on a somewhat different factual
footing. The Respondent, Sheetal, was appointed to the post of GradeIV (DASS) pursuant to Advertisement No. 01/2017. Her appointment
was provisional and subject to verification of the prescribed
credentials and conditions.
72.
The record relied upon by the Petitioners discloses that the
Respondent was subjected to biometric and photographic verification
on more than one occasion. The first verification was conducted on
30.07.2021. She did not appear for the subsequent exercise scheduled
on 11.11.2022 despite reminders. A further and final opportunity was
afforded on 07.07.2023, when she appeared and was again found to
have mismatched biometric and photographic particulars.
73.
The verification report dated 01.09.2023 records that the
biometric particulars of the person who appeared in the CBT/Skill
Test did not correspond with those of the person subsequently
subjected to verification. The Petitioners rely, in particular, upon a
fingerprint match of 0.0% and an image match of 36.03%.
74.
The Petitioners also rely upon the communication dated
07.07.2023 which, according to them, records that another person had
appeared in the written examination on behalf of the Respondent. The
circumstances surrounding that communication have been disputed. It
is unnecessary, however, for this Court to determine whether the
communication establishes the criminal offence of impersonation or
disciplinary misconduct. Its relevance lies in whether it constituted
material which the competent authority was entitled to consider while
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
determining the genuineness of the candidature.
75.
The repeated biometric mismatch, the failure to appear at one of
the scheduled verification exercises, the mismatch recorded upon the
final opportunity and the communication dated 07.07.2023 constituted
material relevant to determining whether the person holding the
appointment was the candidate selected through the recruitment
process. The provisional nature of the appointment further reinforces
the authority of the competent authority to undertake such verification.
76.
The Tribunal, while allowing O.A. No. 3239/2023, substantially
followed the reasoning contained in the common judgment dated
30.04.2024. Having found the foundational premise of that judgment
unsustainable, the Impugned Order dated 04.03.2025 also cannot be
sustained.
W.P.(C.) No. 9758/2025 – Kamal Dabas and connected Respondents
77.
W.P.(C.) No. 9758/2025 arises from O.A. No. 2846/2023. The
Respondents were selected pursuant to Advertisement Nos. 01/2017
and 02/2018 for various posts, including Grade-IV (DASS), Junior
Assistant and Stenographer Grade-III. Their appointments were
provisional and subject to verification of their credentials.
78.
The record discloses that biometric and photographic
verification was conducted on 11.11.2021. The Petitioners rely upon
the report which recorded, inter alia, a fingerprint match of 49.88%
and an image match of 91.01% in the case of Komal Dabas, and a
fingerprint match of 0.0% and an image match of 92.71% in the case
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
of Sandeep Kumar. A further verification exercise was conducted on
11.11.2022, and the Petitioners contend that the Respondents
continued to fail the fingerprint verification despite the additional
opportunity.
79.
The fact that the probation of certain Respondents was extended
on subsequent occasions does not, by itself, establish the validity of
their candidature. Nor does it preclude subsequent verification where
the appointment itself was provisional and subject to verification.
80.
The termination notices dated 05.09.2023 were issued under
Rule 5(1) of the CCS (Temporary Service) Rules. The Petitioners‟
case is that the action was necessitated because the biometric
verification did not satisfactorily establish that the Respondents were
the candidates who had participated in the recruitment process. The
Tribunal, however, principally followed its earlier reasoning without
independently examining the cumulative effect of the verification
material and the opportunities afforded to the Respondents.
81.
Applying the principles already recorded, the Tribunal was
required to determine whether the material before the competent
authority was capable of supporting the conclusion that the
Respondents had failed to establish their identity as the selected
candidates. The absence of a disciplinary enquiry could not, without
first examining the nature of the action, be treated as determinative of
its validity.
82.
The order dated 25.02.2025 passed in O.A. No. 2846/2023 is
accordingly liable to be set aside.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
NATURE & CONSQUENCE OF THE RELIEF:
83.
There is, however, one further aspect which requires
clarification. The Tribunal has used the expression “termination”
while describing the orders challenged before it. The use of that
expression does not, in the circumstances of the present cases, require
this Court to affirm the action as a termination founded upon
misconduct.
84.
As already held, this Court is not recording a finding that the
Respondents have been proved guilty of impersonation or of any
disciplinary misconduct. The present cases concern the validity of the
appointments themselves, having regard to the material which
emerged during verification regarding the identity of the persons who
participated in the recruitment process.
85.
Consequently, the appropriate legal characterisation of the
action is cancellation of the appointments, rather than termination by
way of punishment for misconduct. The distinction is substantive and
not merely semantic. Cancellation proceeds on the basis that the
foundational requirement of establishing that the person appointed
was the candidate selected through the recruitment process has not
been satisfactorily established. It does not amount to a finding that the
concerned person committed misconduct during service.
86.
This Court, in exercise of its jurisdiction under Articles 226 and
227 of the Constitution, is accordingly entitled to mould the relief and
modify the orders of the Tribunal and the consequential orders of the
competent authorities to the extent necessary to give effect to the
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
aforesaid distinction. The orders shall, therefore, be treated as orders
cancelling the appointments of the concerned Respondents on account
of the failure to establish the foundational identity underlying those
appointments, and not as orders imposing a disciplinary punishment
by way of termination
87.
The consequence of cancellation in the present circumstances
also requires to be expressly delineated. Since this Court is not
recording a finding of disciplinary or criminal guilt against the
Respondents, cancellation of the appointments shall not be treated as a
disqualification for future recruitment or employment under the
Government. The Respondents shall remain entitled to participate in
future recruitment processes, subject of course to their satisfying the
eligibility conditions applicable to such recruitment and to any
independent action permissible in law.
88.
Nothing contained in this judgment shall, however, preclude the
competent authority or any other authority from taking such
independent disciplinary or criminal action as may be permissible in
law, if considered warranted on the basis of material concerning
impersonation, use of unfair means or any other offence or
misconduct. Any such action shall have to be initiated and concluded
in accordance with the procedure prescribed by law and this judgment
shall not be construed as expressing any opinion on the merits of such
allegations.
CONCLUSION:
89.
For the aforesaid reasons, the questions framed in paragraph 23
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
are answered in favour of the Petitioners. The Tribunal erred in
treating the action taken by the Petitioners as necessarily punitive
without first examining the anterior question whether the Respondents
had established that they were the candidates who had participated in
the recruitment process and whose candidature had resulted in their
selection.
90.
Accordingly, the Impugned Orders of the Tribunal dated
30.04.2024, 27.05.2025, 04.03.2025 and 25.02.2025, challenged in the
present batch, are set aside. However, it is declared that the
appointment of the Respondents shall stand cancelled.
91.
Consequently, the interim orders passed by the Tribunal in the
respective Original Applications, insofar as they continued the
Respondents in service, shall stand vacated. The Respondents shall
not be entitled to consequential benefits flowing solely from the orders
of the Tribunal which have been set aside by this Court.
92.
All the present Writ Petitions are accordingly allowed in the
aforesaid terms.
93.
The pending applications also stand closed.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
SHAIL JAIN, J.
AUGUST 14, 2026
jai/pal
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:46:13
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review