Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
#
CNR No. DLHC010458292026
+
W.P.(C) 14101/2026, CM APPL. 65990/2026, CM APPL.
65991/2026 & CM APPL. 65992/2026
DIRECTOR GENERAL DOORDARSHAN & ORS.
Through:
.....Petitioners
Mr. Sahil Bhalaik, Adv.
versus
RAJ KISHORE SINGH
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Prem Chand with Mr. P.C.
Das, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C. HARI SHANKAR
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NIVEDITA ANIL SHARMA
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
06.10.2026
%
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
1.
This writ petition assails judgment dated 09 October 2025
passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal1 in OA 2025/2017. The
Tribunal has, by the impugned judgment, allowed the claim of the
respondent for stepping up of his pay in the post of Assistant
Engineer2 to be at par with the one R. K. Sharma.
2.
We may reproduce the reasoning of the Tribunal, as contained
in para 6 of the impugned judgment, thus:
“the Tribunal” hereinafter
“AE” hereinafter
Signed By:YOGESH W.P.(C) 14101/2026
KUMAR
10:25
“6.
Following are the admitted facts :-
(i)
Applicant was initially appointed as EA on 12.01.1984,
promoted to the post of Sr. EA on 27.10.1987 and as AE on
28.06.1994 whereas one Shri R.K. Sharma was initially appointed
as EA on 13.03.1985, promoted to the post of Sr. EA on
30.09.1989 and as AE on 14.11.1994, thus, it is an admitted fact
that the applicant remains senior to Shri R.K. Sharma at every
stage of his service carrier.
(ii)
It is also an admitted fact that the Shri R.K. Sharma was
drawing higher pay comparing to the applicant. Present case is not
the case where pay of junior was wrongly fixed, rather it is the case
of respondent that Shri R.K. Sharma is getting salary as per his
entitlement. Therefore, the anomaly remains that the applicant
despite being senior is getting a lesser salary than Shri R.K.
Sharma.
(iii) FR-22 provides that the stepping up should be done in case
the conditions specified therein are fulfilled i.e. both the junior and
senior officers should 37 belong to the same cadre and the post in
which they were promoted or appointed should be identical and in
the same cadre.
(iv)
It is not the case of the respondents that Shri R.K. Sharma
was getting higher salary because of the additional emoluments
being attached to the nature of work and the duties being
discharged at the junior position.
(v)
The only reason to oppose the claim of pay parity of the
applicant with his junior given by the respondents is that Shri R.K.
Sharma had given his option for fixation of his pay from March,
1995 at the time of his promotion to the post of AE from
14.11.1994. Resultantly, the pay of Shri R.K. Sharma was fixed as
Rs.2975/- w.e.f. 01.03.1995 with date of next increment as
01.03.1996. However, pay of the applicant was fixed as Rs.2900/from the date of his promotion to the post of AE i.e. 28.06.1994
with date of next increment as 01.06.1995. Thus, the sole reason
for pay anomaly is exercise of option at the time of pay fixation to
the post of AE by the applicant and Shri R.K. Sharma.
(vi)
The applicant, in the present case, is claiming affirmative
relief of equality as enshrined under Article 14 of the Constitution
of India. The applicant is claiming stepping up of his pay at par
with his junior Shri R.K. Sharma, who has been drawing more pay
than the applicant under F.R.22.
Signed By:YOGESH W.P.(C) 14101/2026
KUMAR
10:25
(vii) The facts of the present case are not covered under
instances/events mentioned under para 3 of DOP&T OM
No.4/3/2017-Estt(Pay-I) dated 26.10.2018 on the subject “Stepping
up of pay – Consolidated guidelines- reg.” Rather, the present case
is fallen under the eventualities discussed in para 2 of the said OM
dated 26.10.2018 issued by the DOP&T.
(viii) The principle of parity/equality at work place in same cadre
would entitle the applicant for stepping up of his pay at par with his
junior Shri R.K. Sharma.”
3.
In the feeder post of Senior Engineering Assistant, it is not in
dispute that the respondent and R.K. Sharma were drawing the same
pay.
4.
The Tribunal has, in the impugned judgment, placed reliance on
the following para from the judgment of the Supreme Court in Union
of India v. P. Jagdish3:
“7.
So far as the second question is concerned it depends upon
the applicability of the principle of stepping up. Admittedly, the
respondents had been promoted earlier to the category of Head
Clerks and some of their juniors who were continuing as Senior
Clerks against the identified posts carrying special pay of Rs 35
per month on being promoted to the post of Head Clerks later than
the respondents got their pay fixed at a higher level than the
respondents. Under the provisions of Fundamental Rules to
remove the anomaly of a government servant promoted or
appointed to a higher post earlier drawing a lower rate of pay in
that post than another government servant junior to him in the
lower grade and promoted or appointed subsequently to the higher
post, the principle of stepping up of the pay is applied. In such
cases the pay of the senior officer in the higher post is required to
be stepped up to a figure equal to the pay as fixed for the junior
officer in that higher post. The stepping up is required to be done
with effect from the date of promotion or appointment of the junior
officer. On refixation of the pay of the senior officer by applying
the principle of stepping up, the next increment of the said officer
would be drawn on completion of the requisite qualifying service
with effect from the date of te refixation of pay. This principle
AIR 1997 SC 1783
Signed By:YOGESH W.P.(C) 14101/2026
KUMAR
10:25
becomes applicable when the junior officer and the senior officer
belong to the same category and the post from which they have
been promoted and in the promoted cadre the junior officer on
being promoted later than the senior officer gets a higher pay. This
being the principle of stepping up contained in the Fundamental
Rules and admittedly the respondents being senior to several other
Senior Clerks and the respondents having been promoted earlier
than many of their juniors who were promoted later to the post of
Head Clerks, the principle of stepping up should be made
applicable to the respondents with effect from the date their juniors
in the erstwhile cadre of Senior Clerks get promoted to the cadre of
Head Clerks and their pay was fixed at a higher slab than that of
the respondents. The stepping up should be done in such a way that
the anomaly of juniors getting higher salary than the seniors in the
promoted category of Head Clerk would be removed and the pay of
the seniors like the respondents would be stepped up to a figure
equal to the pay as fixed for their junior officer in the higher post
of Head Clerk. In fact the Tribunal by the impugned order has
directed to apply the principle of stepping up and we see no
infirmity with the same direction subject to the aforesaid
clarifications. This principle of stepping up which we have, upheld
would prevent violation of equal pay for equal work but grant of
consequential benefit of the difference of salary would not be
correct for the reason that the respondents had not worked in the
post to which 35% [sic Rs 35 as] special pay was attached in the
lower cadre. But by reason of promotion the promotee-juniors who
worked on the said posts, in fact, performed the hard duties and
earned special pay. Directions to pay arrears would be deleterious
to inculcation of efficiency in service. All persons who were
indolent to share higher responsibilities in lower posts, on
promotion would get accelerated arrears that would be deleterious
to efficiency of service. Therefore, though direction to step up the
pay on notional basis is consistent with Article 39(d) of the
Constitution, it would be applicable only prospectively from the
date of the promotion and the fixation of the scale, stepping up of
the scale of pay would be prospective to calculate future
increments on the scale of pay in promotional post only
prospectively. The appeal is dismissed but in the circumstances
there would not be any order as to costs.”
(Emphasis supplied)
5.
The Tribunal has also placed reliance on an Office
Memorandum4 dated 26 October 2018 issued by the Department of
“OM” hereinafter
Signed By:YOGESH W.P.(C) 14101/2026
KUMAR
10:25
Personnel and Training5, which holds that, where the anomaly in pay
has arisen because of the application of FR 22(I)(a)(1)6, the senior in
the promotional post would be entitled to stepping up of pay at par
with his junior.
6.
Aggrieved by the aforesaid decision, the judgment of the
Tribunal, Doordarshan has filed the present writ petition. We have
heard Mr. Bhalaik, learned Counsel for the petitioner and Mr. Prem
Chand, learned Counsel for the respondent.
“DOPT” hereinafter
22(1) The initial pay of a Government servant who is appointed to a post on a time- scale of pay is
regulated as follows:
(a) (1) Where a Government servant holding a post, other than a tenure post, in a substantive or
temporary or officiating capacity is promoted or appointed in a substantive, temporary or officiating
capacity, as the case may be, subject to the fulfilment of the eligibility conditions as prescribed in
the relevant Recruitment Rules, to another post carrying duties and responsibilities of greater
importance than those attaching to the post held by him, his initial pay in the time-scale shall be
fixed by giving one increment in the level from which the Government servant is promoted and he
or she shall be placed at a cell equal to the figure so arrived at in the level of the post to which
promoted or appointed and if no such cell is available in the level to which promoted or appointed,
he shall be placed at the next higher cell in that level.
Save in cases of appointment on deputation to an ex-cadre post or to a post on ad hoc
basis or on direct recruitment basis, the Government servant shall have the option, to be exercised
within one month from the date of promotion or appointment, as the case may be, to have the pay
fixed under this rule from the date of such promotion or appointment or to have the pay fixed
initially at the next higher cell in the level of the post to which he or she is promoted on regular
basis and subsequently, on the date of accrual of next increment in the level of the post from which
Government Servant is promoted, his pay shall be re-fixed and two increments (one accrued on
account of annual Increment and the second accrued on account of promotion) shall be granted in
the level from which the Government Servant is promoted and he or she shall be placed at a cell
equal to the figure so arrived, in the level of the post to which he or she is promoted; and if no such
cell is available in the level to which he or she is promoted, he or she shall be placed at the next
higher cell in that level.
In cases where an ad hoc promotion is followed by regular appointment without break,
the option is admissible from the date of initial appointment or promotion to he exercised within
one month from the date of such regular appointment.
In cases where an officer has retired as ad hoc before being regularised to that post and
later on has been assessed during the process of regularisation and found fit by the competent
authority along with his or her juniors, who are still in service and are eligible to avail of the option
facility from a date on which the retired employee was still in service, the same option facility shall
also be extended to the retired employee, to be exercised within three months from the date when
his or her junior became eligible to avail of option facility and in cases where such retired employee
was himself the junior most, he or she may exercise the option facility within three months from the
date when his or her immediate senior became eligible to avail of option facility:
Provided that where a Government servant is immediately before his promotion or
appointment on regular basis to a higher post, drawing pay at the maximum of the level of the lower
post, his initial pay in the level of the higher post shall be fixed at the cell equal to the figure so
arrived at in the level of the post to which promoted or appointed by increasing his pay in respect of
the lower post held by him on regular basis by an amount equal to the last increment in the level of
the lower post and if no such cell is available in the level to which he is promoted or appointed, he
shall be placed at the next higher cell in that level.
Signed By:YOGESH W.P.(C) 14101/2026
KUMAR
10:25
7.
Mr. Bhalaik submits that the OM dated 26 October 2018, on
which the Tribunal placed reliance, is not applicable, as para 5 makes
it clear that the OM applies only from 1 January 2016, whereas the
promotion of the respondent as AE took place much prior thereto in
1994.
8.
We had drawn the attention of Mr. Bhalaik to a recent decision
of Supreme Court in Jai Prakash Singh v. The State of Uttar
Pradesh7, in which the Supreme Court has held as under:
15.
It is fundamental that a senior officer cannot be paid less
than a junior officer holding the same post. The position regarding
fixation of pay of the appellant and Dr. Pradeep Kumar is so
grossly anomalous that the same violates Article 14 of the
Constitution of India as well as the provisions in Article 39(d) of
the Constitution. Undisputed facts are that both the appellant as
well as Dr. Pradeep Kumar were serving as Readers in the
Department of Education and that the appellant had obtained M.
Phil and Ph. D degrees prior to Dr. Pradeep Kumar obtaining the
same. A junior receiving a higher pay compared to the pay of the
senior has to be justified with reference to valid factors. No
demonstrable difference in qualifications for the post, source of
recruitment, experience, responsibility and accountability is placed
on record which could be proffered as a justification for denying
equal pay to the appellant for equal work of equal value. The
Government Orders, relied upon by Ms. Goel, embody policy
decisions of the Government; however, the same have to yield to
the over-arching principles of equality and equal pay for equal
work enshrined in the Constitution to the extent they are
inconsistent therewith. We, thus, see no valid reason to uphold the
impugned order of the High Court. The same stands set aside.
9.
Mr. Bhalaik submits that the judgment in Jai Prakash Singh is
clearly distinguishable, as the Supreme Court had proceeded on the
premise that both the officers in that case were holders of the same
Civil Appeal No.4559/2026 dated 16 September 2026
Signed By:YOGESH W.P.(C) 14101/2026
KUMAR
10:25
educational qualification. However, Mr. Bhalaik has very fairly drawn
our attention to the OM dated 4 November 1993 issued by the DOPT,
which deals with stepping up of pay. We deem it appropriate to
reproduce the OM in its entirety, thus:
“No. 4/7/92-Estt.(Pay-I)
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
DEPARTMENT OF PERSONNEL & TRAINING
New Delhi, the 4-11-1993
OFFICE MEMORANDUM
Subject:-
Stepping up of pay.
Cases for stepping up of the pay of seniors in a pay scale
that of juniors are generally considered if the following conditions
are satisfied:(a)
both the junior and senior officer. should belong to
the same cadre and the posts in which they have been
promoted or appointed should be identical and in the same
cadre;
(b)
the scales of pay of the lower and higher posts in
which the junior and senior officer: are entitled to draw pay
should be identical;
(c)
the anomaly should be directly as a result of the
application of FR 22-C. For example, if even in the lower
post the junior officer draws from time to time a higher rate
of pay than the senior by virtue of grant of advance
increments or on any other account the above provisions
will not be invoked to step up the pay of senior officer.
2.
Instances have come to the notice of this Department
requesting for stepping up of pay due to the following reasons:(a)
where a senior proceeds on Extra Ordinary Leave
which results in postponement of Date of Next Increment in
the lower post, consequently he starts drawing less pay than
his junior in the lower grade itself. He, therefore, cannot
claim pay parity on promotion even though he may be
promoted earlier to the higher grade;
(b)
If a senior foregoes/refuses promotion leading to his
junior being promoted/appointed to the higher post earlier,
Signed By:YOGESH W.P.(C) 14101/2026
KUMAR
10:25
junior draws higher pay than the senior. The senior may be
on deputation while junior avails of the ad-hoc promotion
in the cadre. The increased pay drawn by a junior either due
to ad-hoc promotion in the cadre. The increased pay drawn
by a junior either, due to ad-hoc officiating/regular service
rendered in the higher posts for periods earlier than the
senior, cannot therefore, be as anomaly in strict sense of the
term.
(c)
If a senior joins the higher post later than the junior,
for whatsoever reasons, whereby he draw less pay than the
junior, in such cases senior cannot claim stepping up of pay
at par with the junior.
(d)If a senior is appointed later than the junior in the lower
post itself whereby he is in receipt of lesser pay than the
junior, in such cases also the senior cannot claim pay parity
in the higher post though he may have been promoted
earlier to the higher post.
(e)
When a person in promoted form lower to a higher
post his pay is fixed with reference to the pay drawn by him
in the lower post under FR 22-C and he is likely to get
more pay than a direct appointed whose pay is fixed under
different set of rules. For example a UDC on promotion to
the post of Assistant gets his pay fixed under FR-22C with
reference to the pay drawn in the post of UDC, whereas the
pay of Assistant (DR) is fixed normally at the minimum
under FR 22-B(2). In such cases, the senior direct recruit
cannot claim pay parity with the junior promoted from a
lower post to higher post as seniority alone is not a criteria
for allowing stepping up.
(f)
Where a junior gets more pay due to additional
increments earned on acquiring higher qualifications.
3.
In the instances referred to in paragraph 2 above, a junior
drawing more pay than the senior will not constitute an anomaly.
In such cases, stepping up of pay will not, therefore, be admissible.
4.
In so far as persons serving in the Indian Audit and
Accounts Department are concerned, these orders have been issued
after consultation with the Comptroller and Auditor General of
India.
5.
Hindi version will follow.
Sd/-
Signed By:YOGESH W.P.(C) 14101/2026
KUMAR
10:25
(MRS/ REVATHY IYER)
DEPUTY SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF INDIA”
10.
Having heard Mr. Bhalaik, we do not find this to be a case
deserving of interference by us in exercise of the extraordinary
jurisdiction vested in us by Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
11.
It is not in dispute that the anomaly in pay, between the
respondent and R.K. Sharma arose, in the present case, because R. K.
Sharma had opted for fixation of his pay at the time of his promotion
to the post of AE with effect from 14 November 1994, however, after
he drew his next increment, whereas the respondent’s pay was fixed
with effect from 28 June 1994 and his next increment was made
available to him thereafter.
12.
This is a clear instance of a discrepancy in pay arising as a
consequence of applicability of FR-22A, which permits an officer to
opt, at the stage of his promotion, to draw the pay of the higher post
either before or after he draws his next increment. The discrepancy in
pay having arisen between the respondent and R. K. Sharma having
arisen on this core, it is directly relatable to the FR 22(I)(a)(1). The
DOPT OM dated 4 November 1993 supra to which our attention was
drawn by Mr. Bhalaik clearly sets out, in the opening paragraph, the
various circumstances in which stepping up of pay is generally
considered. Though, Mr. Bhalaik seeks to rely on the words “generally
considered” to state that these instructions are not binding, it is clear
that, having been issued by the DOPT, which is the nodal authority for
service issues relating to the government servants under the Allocation
of Business Rules framed under Article 77 of the Constitution of
Signed By:YOGESH W.P.(C) 14101/2026
KUMAR
10:25
India, the OM would be binding on the petitioner.
13.
All three criteria envisaged in clauses (a) to (c) in the opening
paragraph of the DOPT OM dated 4 November 1993 are applicable.
14.
We are also of the view that the enunciation of the law in para
15 of Jai Prakash Singh is absolute in terms and disapproves of any
situation in which a junior in a higher post would draw a pay lower
than the senior.
15.
In that view of the matter, we do not deem this to be a case
deserving of interference under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India.
16.
The writ petition is accordingly dismissed in limine.
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
NIVEDITA ANIL SHARMA, J.
OCTOBER 6, 2026/yk
Signed By:YOGESH W.P.(C) 14101/2026
KUMAR
10:25
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review