Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:33642
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
Cr.MP No. 2782 of 2025
in
Cr. Appeal No. 352 of 2025
Reserved on: 17.7.2026
Date of decision: 11.8.2026
Uploaded on: 11.8.2026
Dinesh Kumar.
…Applicant/Appellant.
Versus
State of H.P.
…Respondent.
Corum
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Vivek Singh Thakur, Judge.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ranjan Sharma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the Applicant.
Mr.Vivek Chandel, Advocate.
For the Respondent:
Mr.J.S. Guleria, Deputy Advocate General.
Vivek Singh Thakur, Judge
Applicant/applicant has filed this application for enlarging him
on bail by suspending sentence, including fine amount awarded to him for
his conviction vide judgment dated 30.10.2024, passed by Special Judge-
Whether the reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment? Yes
2026:HHC:33642
II Kinnaur at Rampur Bushahr, District Shimla, H.P. in case CIS Regd.
No. NDPS/26/2023, titled as State of H.P. Vs. Khem Raj and others, in
case FIR No. 12/2023, registered in Police Station Brow, District Kullu,
H.P. under Sections 20 and 29 of The Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic
Substances Act, 1985 (for short the ‘NDPS Act’).
2.
Learned counsel for the applicant, referring GD entry No.
008 dated 22.2.2023 recorded at 10:43 A.M. (Ex. P2/PW6) has submitted
that contents of this GD entry clearly depicts that Police party was having
prior information and, therefore, compliance of Section 42 of the NDPS
Act was mandatory, but the prosecution/Investigating Officer has failed to
comply with provisions of Section 42 of the NDPS Act, which is fatal for
the prosecution case and thus on this count applicant/appellant is
definitely going to be acquitted and, therefore, he at least, deserves for
suspension of sentence at this stage.
3.
It has been submitted that in GD entry report, the purpose for
departure of the Police party to lay nakabandi as ‘Khufia Suragh Barari of
madak padarth’.
Therefore, he has contended that there was a prior
information about commission of offence related to narcotic drug and,
therefore, non-compliance of provisions of Section 42 of the NDPS Act is
fatal for prosecution.
4.
It has been contended that in NCB Form (Ex. P4/PW8),
column No. 7 is blank and it has been admitted by the Investigating Officer
2026:HHC:33642
PW13 Inspector Inder Singh that said column is blank and this fact has
also been admitted by PW12 SI Pushp Dev, the then SHO Police Station
Braw, who had filled column No. 9 to 10.
It has been further stated that
contraband was handed over by PW13 Inspector Inder Singh to PW14
ASI Ramesh Chand, who is second Investigating Officer, who, according
to prosecution case, took the contraband alongwith other documents to
the Police Station and produced the same before PW12 SI Pushp Dev,
the then SHO for re-sealing. It has been submitted that no memo of resealing has been prepared or produced in the Court and, therefore, link
witness regarding re-sealing and handing over the re-sealed contraband
with MHC is missing and, therefore, break in link entitles suspension of
sentence awarded to the applicant/appellant.
5.
It has been further submitted that PW5 Smt. Utra Devi, an
independent witness, who was Ward Panch in the concerned Panchayat,
has not supported the prosecution case and was declared hostile and,
therefore, the prosecution story has become doubtful and on this count
also applicant/appellant is entitled for suspension of sentence.
6.
Referring statements of PW6 Constable Baban Singh, it has
been submitted that in case there was no prior information of transporting
contraband in the vehicle, the Police party was expected to search entire
vehicle as well as person of accused, but Police party did not do so and
after recovery of alleged contraband from the vehicle, the said vehicle was
2026:HHC:33642
not checked thoroughly which is unexpected from the Police party and it
also creates doubt about the prosecution story.
7.
It has been further submitted that PW6 Constable Baban
Singh has admitted in his cross-examination that six seals of impression
‘M’ were broken.
8.
It has been submitted that as per prosecution case, case
property was handed over to MHC after re-sealing, but there is no
corresponding entry in the Malkhana register.
9.
Plea of the applicant that ‘khufia Suragh Barari’ means prior
information of the offence is misconceived. The word Suragh Barari or
‘Sugaagh Baraari’ is a Persian origin Urdu and Hindi phrase, which means
investigation/research or the act of tracking and tracing. It stems from the
root word Suraagh, which means clue, trace or footprint and is often used
in a detective or police context. Therefore, Suragh Barari does not mean
the prior information of commission of offence. It is general search or
endevour to obtain secret information apprehending possibility of
commission of offence at some place or area. It is not specific information
disclosing that person ‘A’ and ‘B’ or ‘C’ is committing the offence under
NDPS Act by selling/supplying or transporting the contraband in a
particular manner which may be through vehicle or otherwise and on
receiving such specific information from informer or reliable source that
‘A’ or ‘B’ or ‘C’ or ABC were transporting contraband in vehicle XYZ and
2026:HHC:33642
are coming from station S1 to S2 at a probable time, it shall be a specific
prior information in which case compliance of Section 42 of the NDPS Act
shall be mandatory.
10.
However, in present case, it is apparent that there was no
specific prior information but the Police party was leaving the Police
Station for inquiry, investigation, research, tracking or tracing regarding
commission of offence related to narcotic drug, meaning thereby Police
party was on patrolling for getting clue, trace or foot print of commission of
offence related to NDPS Act.
11.
Though PW-5 Smt. Utra Devi has been declared hostile,
however in her examination-in-chief she has corroborated the presence of
Police, accused as well as her presence on 22.2.2023 at 7:00 P.M. on the
spot with further disclosure that she had arrived on the spot on receiving
telephonic call made by Police with request to reach on the spot.
She
has admitted that her signatures were taken by the Police on papers. She
has further stated that she cannot tell that from which vehicle charas was
recovered. This witness has admitted her signatures on the documents
and she has also corroborated presence of Police party, accused and
vehicles on the spot at relevant date and time.
12.
As per prosecution story PW13 Inspector Inder Singh
handed over the case property to PW14 ASI Ramesh Chand, therefore,
there was no dispatch of the contraband to the Police Station by PW13
2026:HHC:33642
Inspector Inder Singh, rather he had handed over the contraband to PW14
ASI Ramesh Chand, who went to Police Station alongwith case property
and produced the parcel for re-sealing before PW12 SI Pushap Dev. In
such eventuality, whether column No. 7 was required to be filled or not, is
again a debatable issue.
13.
PW3 Constable Devender handed over parcel to PW14, who
inturn produced it before the SHO for re-sealing, therefore, PW13 First
Investigating Officer did not dispatch the contraband to Police Station,
thus there was no occasion for him to record date and time of sending
contraband to the Police Station. In absence of any question put to this
witness regarding blank column No. 7, the opportunity to explain the fact
on record on query raised by the defence, has been denied.
14.
Ex. P6/PW8 is GD entry, wherein it has been clearly stated
that PW13 Inspector Inder Singh ANTF Kullu had handed over the parcel
to Second Investigating Officer, but not to SHO and Second Investigating
Officer had produced the same at 1:50 A.M after arrest of accused at
12.45 A.M. and alongwith documents, parcel was placed before PW12 SI
Pushap Dev for re-sealing.
GD entry Ex. P1/PW8 is with respect to
compliance of all necessary formalities after receiving contraband
alongwith documents by PW12 SI Pushap Dev from PW14 ASI Ramesh
Chand. GD entry No. 12 (Ex. P8/PW8) is a link evidence with respect to
contraband which was taken to CJM Rampur for conducting proceedings
2026:HHC:33642
with reference to Section 52A of the NDPS Act. Sending of contraband to
State Forensic Laboratory has been depicted in GD entry No. 004 (Ex.
P9/PW8) and registration of FIR Ex.P1/PW12 is also corroborating the
prosecution case.
15.
The fact that independent witness was declared hostile for
not supporting the prosecution case, the entire prosecution case does not
shatter as on the basis of reliable, cogent and convincing evidence of
Police Officials only, a person can be convicted.
16.
Deposit of case property after re-sealing in Malkhana has
been duly reflected in the relevant GD entry.
17.
No enmity of Police party with applicant has been
established on record.
Therefore, taking into consideration the entire
material on record and judgment passed by the Trial Court, it appears that
there is no fair chance of acquittal on the grounds raised by the counsel
for the applicant/appellant.
18.
Observation made in this application shall be confined for the
purpose of adjudication of this application only and it shall not be
precedent or findings to be relied upon in collateral proceedings. Each
case for suspension of sentence has to be heard and decided on the
basis of material before the Presiding Officer.
2026:HHC:33642
19.
In view of aforesaid discussion, we are of the considered
opinion that at this stage, applicant/appellant is not entitled for suspension
of sentence and accordingly, the application is dismissed.
(Vivek Singh Thakur),
Judge.
(Ranjan Sharma),
Judge.
11th August, 2026
(Keshav)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review