Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
1 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP No. 13260 of 2024
Reserved on: 01.07.2026
Decided on: 31.07.2026
Uploaded on: 31.07.2026
Dinesh Kumar Sharma
…. Petitioner.
-Versus-
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
…..Respondents.
Coram:
Hon'ble Mr. Justice Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge
Whether approved for reporting?1 Yes.
________________________________________________________
For the petitioner:
Mr. Sanjeev Bhushan, Senior Advocate, with
Mr. Sparsh Bhushan, Advocate.
For the respondents:
Mr. Pushpinder Jaswal, Additional advocate
General, for respondents No. 1 and 2.
Mr. T.S. Chauhan, Senior Advocate, with Mr.
Surya Chauhan, Advocate, for respondent
No. 3.
Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge:
By way of this writ petition, the petitioner has, inter alia,
prayed for the following relief:“(i)
That an appropriate writ, order or directions
may kindly be issued and the respondents may kindly be
directed to conduct the DPC from amongst the eligible
candidates including the petitioner for the post of
Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
Assistant Professor, ENT at IGMC & Hospital, Shimla for
the year 2022 with further directions to promote the
petitioner if found suitable and eligible by the DPC on and
with effect from August, 2022 with all consequential
benefits of pay, arrears, seniority etc. in the interest of law
and justice.”
2.
The case of the petitioner is that he did his Senior
Residency in ENT from Indira Gandhi Medical College & Hospital,
Shimla from 09.01.2017 to 04.02.2020. He was designated as an
Assistant Professor in the said Department w.e.f. 11.12.2020. At the
time of filing of the petition, the petitioner was pursuing his MCH, which
is Three Years Course in Head Neck Surgery and Oncology from AIMS,
Delhi w.e.f. 01.07.2024.
3.
The grievance of the petitioner is that despite initiating the
process for filling up one resultant vacancy of regular Assistant
Professor in the Department of ENT at IGMC & Hospital, Shimla long
back in June, 2022 by way of promotion, for which options were called
and for which he had opted, Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC)
was not being conducted, thereby causing immense and irreparable
loss to the petitioner.
4.
Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner argued that
post of Professor fell vacant in the Department of ENT, which was filled
up by appointing Dr. Jagdeep Singh Thakur, who was promoted to the
3 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
said post from the post of Associate Professor. The resultant vacancy of
Associate Professor was filled by promotion of Dr. Bhushan Lal. He
submitted that in this backdrop, the respondents simultaneously
initiated the process for filling up the resultant vacancy of Assistant
Professor in the Department of ENT. By referring to communication
dated 18.06.2022, Annexure P-2, learned Senior Counsel submitted
that in terms of this communication, the Principal Secretary (Health) to
the Government of Himachal Pradesh wrote to the Director, Health
Services regarding filling up of one resultant vacancy of Assistant
Professor in the Department of ENT at IGMC, Shimla by way of
promotion. He submitted that the Director (Health Services) was called
upon to send service particulars of eligible and willing candidates of five
GDOs./MOs. to the Department at the earliest. He submitted that in
response thereto, Principal, IGMC, Shimla vide communication dated
29.06.2022, submitted the service particulars of the petitioner, who was
serving as a designated Assistant Professor in Department of ENT,
IGMC, Shimla, who, in terms of said communication, was the only
eligible candidate amongst GDOs., for promotion to the post of
Assistant Professor (ENT) in IGMC, Shimla. Learned Senior Counsel
submitted that the petitioner gave his option and willingness for
promotion against the post of Assistant Professor, yet nothing was done
by the respondents. He submitted that the vacancy which had fallen
4 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
vacant on account of promotion of Dr. Bhushan Lal to the post of
Associate Professor, was to be filled in by appointing a person by way
of promotion from the promotee category, in light of the law declared by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in R.K. Sabharwal and others Vs. State of
Punjab and others, (1995) 2 SCC 745. He submitted that in similar
circumstances, post, which had fallen vacant in Tanda Medical College,
i.e., the post vacated by promotee, was filled in by appointing a
promotee and as the petitioner was not being promoted against the
post of Assistant Professor, though he was the senior-most eligible
GDO, the act of the respondents was bad in law and accordingly he
prayed that a mandamus be issued to the respondents to conduct a
DPC of
eligible candidates, including the petitioner for appointment
against the post of Assistant Professor (ENT) from the promotee quota.
5.
On the other hand, learned Additional Advocate General,
by relying upon the reply filed by respondents No. 1 and 2, submitted
that after the promotion of Dr. Bhushan Lal against the post of
Associate Professor on 14.08.2022, the Department had sought
necessary options from respondent No. 2, i.e., the Director of Health
Services and the service particulars of the petitioner for consideration of
promotion to the post of Assistant Professor were received. In the
meanwhile, one Dr. Mahender Singh, a Medical Officer (Specialist in
ENT), submitted a representation, stating that the Government had
5 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
recently filled one post of Assistant Professor (ENT) on 28.06.2022 by
promoting Dr. Payal Gupta and, therefore, filling up of another post by
way of promotion, would violate the mandate of Recruitment and
Promotion Rules, in terms whereof, the post of Assistant Professor in
the Specialty was to be filled 50% by way of direct recruitment and 50%
by way of promotion.
6.
Learned Additional Advocate General submitted that as
per Dr. Mahender Singh, the resultant vacancy had to be filled in by
way of direct recruitment. He submitted that the proposal qua the
promotion of the petitioner as also the representation, opposing the
same were under the consideration of the Government and in the
meanwhile, the Director of Health Services submitted service
particulars of Dr. Amit Saini, Medical Officer (Specialist in ENT), who
was senior to the petitioner and after thorough examination of all
relevant facts, including the representation of Dr. Mahender, the
proposal received from the Director of Health Services and in the light
of the judgment passed by this Court in CWP No. 907/2021, the
Department referred the matter to the Advisory Department, i.e.,
Department of Personnel, for its opinion.
7.
The Department of Personnel advised that though the
vacancy had arisen on account of the promotion of a candidate, but in
order to maintain the 50:50 ratio, as per the Recruitment & Promotion
6 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
Rules, the post was required to be filled by way of direct recruitment.
Learned Additional Advocate General submitted that in light of the said
advice of the Department of Personnel, the Department decided to fill
the vacancy which had arisen on account of the promotion of Dr.
Bhushan Lal by way of direct recruitment through the Himachal
Pradesh Public Service Commission and the proposal was referred to
the Finance Department, which remained under active consideration.
He, thus, submitted that in the light of the above, there was no merit in
what was being contended by the petitioner.
8.
During the pendency of the writ petition, CMP No. 27772
of 2025 was filed by the applicant for his impleadment and in terms of
order dated 05.03.2026, the same was allowed and the applicant in the
said miscellaneous application was ordered to be impleaded as
respondent No. 3. Learned Senior Counsel appearing for respondent
No. 3 has also adopted the arguments addressed by learned Additional
Advocate General. He further submitted that the vacancy vacated on
promotion of Dr. Bhushan Lal had to be filled in by way of direct
recruitment, as earlier vacancy had been filled in by way of promotion,
which indeed was a newly created vacancy.
9.
Having heard learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner as
also learned Additional Advocate General and having perused the
Roster Register, which was made available for the perusal of the Court,
7 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
in terms of the directions passed by it, this Court is of the considered
view that there is no merit in the present writ petition.
10.
Facts as they emerge from the pleadings as also the
relevant record produced for the perusal of the Court by the
respondent-State are that in terms of the Himachal Pradesh Medical
Education Service Rules, the post of Assistant Professor (ENT) is to be
filled in 50% by way of promotion and 50% by way of direct recruitment.
11.
The Roster Register, which has been made available for
the perusal of the Court maintained in the respondent-College,
demonstrates that the initial cadre strength of the cadre of Assistant
Professors in the said Department was two. That being the case, there
was no issue with regard to the implementation of the Roster of 50%
appointment by way of promotion and 50% by way of direct recruitment.
In fact, record demonstrates that initially, one Dr. Ramesh Azad was
appointed by way of direct recruitment on 10.06.2005 and Dr. R.S.
Minhas was promoted against the post on 19.11.2008. Dr. Azad was
promoted against the post of Associate Professor on 19.01.2011 and
Dr. Jagdeep Singh Thakur was thereafter recruited by way of direct
recruitment, who joined as such on 30.08.2013. Dr. R.S. Minhas was
promoted against the post of Associate Professor on 31.12.2011 and
Dr. Madhuri Dadwal was promoted against the vacated post on
31.12.2011 itself. Thereafter, Dr. Jagdeep Thakur was promoted as an
8 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
Associate Professor on 01.11.2018 and the resultant vacancy was
again filled up by way of direct recruitment by the appointment of Dr.
Ishan Chauhan on 27.12.2019. Similarly, on promotion of Dr. Madhuri
Dadwal, Dr. Bhushan Lal was promoted against the post of Assistant
Professor on 14.08.2017.
12.
One additional post of Assistant Professor was sanctioned
on 18.04.2022. At the time of the creation of this post, Dr. Bhushan Lal
was occupying one post, having been promoted against the post of
Assistant Professor and Dr. Ishan Chauhan was occupying the post,
having been directly recruited. In terms of the Recruitment and
Promotion Rules, the third post of Assistant Professor was to be filled in
by way of promotion and Dr. Payal Gupta was promoted as Assistant
Professor on 28.06.2022. This is also evident from the Roster Register.
13.
Now, the point is that after the promotion of Dr. Bhushan
Lal against the post of Associate Professor, who was promoted as such
on 14.08.2022, whereas the contention of the petitioner is that the said
post should be filled in by way of promotion as the post has been
vacated by a promotee, the contention of the State as well as the
private respondent is that in order to maintain the ratio of 50:50, the
post now has to be filled in by way of direct recruitment, otherwise the
same will amount to excess representation of the promotees.
9 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
14.
This Court is of the considered view that as the
Recruitment and Promotion Rules provide for 50% quota, each to the
category of promotees and direct recruits, this quota has to be
harmoniously maintained and the maintenance of this quota will not be
determined by the fact as to how many incumbents of which category at
a particular time are occupying the post. This is for the reason that the
number of posts in the cadre is an odd number.
15.
Had the cadre been of even number, then obviously there
would have been an even distribution of the number of seats amongst
the two categories. However, as the cadre consists of odd number,
therefore, at a particular time, there will be two incumbents of one
category and one incumbent of the other category holding the post.
16.
To maintain the 50:50 ratio, there has to be a rotation in
the category which holds the third post, so that harmony is maintained
with regard to the 50:50 ratio and there is neither any overrepresentation of anyone nor any under-representation of anyone.
17.
In light of the fact that when the third post came into
existence, the same was filled up by way of promotion, now obviously,
resultantly, the next time, when a post becomes available, it has to be
filled in from the other category, that is the category of direct recruits.
18.
In present-like situation where the number of posts is odd,
the general principle that the category which vacates the post will get
10 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
the post shall not be applicable. Otherwise also, here is a case where
we are dealing with recruitment to a post, be it by way of direct
recruitment or promotion, from different sources and not of reservation
per se. Therefore, the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in R.K.
Sabharwal and others Vs. State of Punjab and others (supra), relied
upon by learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner has no applicability in
the facts of this case.
19.
In fact, this issue is not even res integra, as the Division
Bench of this Court in Dr. Nikita Verma Versus State of Himachal
Pradesh and others, CWP No. 907 of 2021, decided on 13.08.2021,
while dealing with a similar situation, was pleased to hold as under:“11.
We have heard learned counsel for the
parties and have also gone through the records of the
case.
12.
Respondents No. 1 and 2 have specifically
submitted that to maintain prescribed ratio of 50:50
between promotee incumbents and direct recruits, roster
provided in explanation to Clause 6 of Chapter 13 of
Handbook
on
Personal
Matters,
VolumeI,
will
be
applicable, which reads as under:
“6. Relative seniority of direct recruits and promotees: (a) Provision in general: The relative seniority of direct
recruits and of promotees shall be determined
according to the rotation of vacancies between direct
recruits and promotees which shall be based on the
11 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
quotas of vacancies reserved for direct recruitment
and promotion respectively in the Recruitment Rules.
Explanation: A roster should be maintained based on the
reservation for direct recruitment and promotion in the
Recruitment Rules. Where the reservation for each
method is 50% the roster will run as follows: (1)
Promotion, (2) Direct Recruitment, (3) Promotion, (4)
Direct Recruitment and so on. Appointment should be
made in 9 accordance with this roster and seniority
determined accordingly.
Illustration: When 75% of the vacancies are reserved for
promotion and 25% for direct recruitment, each direct
recruit shall be ranked in seniority below 3 promotees.
Where the quotas are 50% each, every direct recruit shall
be ranked below a promote. If for any reason, a direct
recruit or a promotee ceases to hold the appointment in
the grade, the seniority list shall not be re-arranged
merely for the purpose of ensuring the proportion referred
to above.”
13.
Respondents have further contended that
column No. 10 of the proforma for R & P Rules was
amended and term ‘posts’ was incorporated in place of
term ‘vacancies’, which as per respondents, necessarily
meant that the roster is to conclude on the post and once
the roster is concluded then the ensuing vacancies shall
be filled from the quota (direct or promotion) in which
vacancy had occurred.
12 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
14.
There is no dispute that cadre strength is
always measured by the number of posts comprising the
cadre and there must be a post in existence to enable the
vacancy to occur. This, however, will not imply that the
application of roster will come to 10 an end on filling of the
entire cadre strength. Application of roster is not the end
but only a mean to achieve the object.
15.
The object is defined by R & P Rules, wherein
specific quota of 50% each for direct and promotee
candidates has been reserved as source for recruitment
for the post of Assistant Professor. In case the
interpretation adopted by respondents is accepted,
reservation of 50% of the total posts for direct candidates
will never be achieved and practically it shall be 60% in
favour of promotees and 40% for direct recruits. Such an
interpretation, that stares at the face of object sought to
be achieved, cannot be countenanced.
16.
Thus, such an understanding, in our view, is
not legally sustainable for the simple reason that it
impedes at the very basis of Recruitment and Promotion
Rules providing for reservation in the ratio of 50 : 50
between promotees and direct recruits.
17.
While
dealing
with
almost
identical
proposition in State of Punjab and others vs. Dr. R.N.
Bhatnagar and another, (1999) 2 SCC 330, Hon’ble
Supreme Court has held as under:
“11.
On the other hand, the situation which
has fallen for our consideration in the present case in the
light of Article 16(1) is squarely covered by a decision of
this Court in Paramjit Singh's 11 case (supra) as clarified
13 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
by a latter decision in the very same case reported in
[1982] 3 SCC 191. In the aforesaid main case, D.A.
Desai, J, speaking for the bench of two learned Judges of
this Court, had to consider in paragraph 11 of the Report a
recruitment rule which permitted fixed percentage of posts
to be filled up in the given cadre from two different
sources, namely, promotees and direct recruits. Rule 6 of
the Punjab Police Service Rules, 1959, which came for
consideration in that case provided for a method of
recruitment from two different sources i.e. 80% by
promotion from the rank of Inspectors and 20% by direct
recruitment. Examining the working of the aforesaid quota
rule for recruitment in the light of the relevant rotational
scheme of vacancies in the cadre to which such
recruitment was to be made, the following pertinent
observations were made in paragraph 11 of the Report:
(SCC p. 485)
"11. Where recruitment to a cadre is from two
sources and the Service Rules prescribe quota for
recruitment for both sources a question would always
arise whether the quota rule would apply at the initial
stage of recruitment or also at the stage of Confirmation,
Ordinarily, if quota is prescribed for recruitment to a cadre,
the quota rule will have to be observed at the recruitment
stage. The quota would then be co-related to vacancies to
be filled in by recruitment but after recruitment is made
from two different sources they will have to be integrated
into a common cadre and while so doing, the question of
their inter se seniority would surface.,...:.."
14 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
As
there
was
some
doubt
about
the
observations found in the aforesaid paragraph 11 and as
to how the recruitment rule in question was to be operated
in the light of the quota prescribed therein and the
rotational method of achieving the said quota of
recruitment from two sources, a later Bench clarified the
position in the subsequent judgment in the case of
Paramjit Singh (supra). Another bench of two learned
Judges, wherein D.A. Desai, J., was common, clarified
the observation in paragraph 11 of the earlier Report as
under: (SCC pp. 195-96, paras 6 and 7)
“6.
In our opinion there is no ambiguity in
the judgment. Ordinarily speaking, where recruitment is
from two sources with a view to integrating recruits from
both sources after the recruitment seniority is determined
from the date of entry into the cadre except where there
has been a substantial violation of the quota giving
undeserved advantage to one or the other source.
Seniority ordinarily speaking is determined with reference
to the date of entry into the cadre which in service
jurisprudence is styled the date of continues officiation.
These notions of service jurisprudence may have to yield
place to the specific rules and the fact situation with
reference to Rule 10 did compel this Court to depart from
the normal concept in service jurisprudence. However,
introduction of a roster system is very well-known inservice jurisprudence. What this Court meant while saying
that when a quota rule is prescribed for recruitment to a
cadre it meant that quota should be co-related to the
vacancies which are to be filled in. Who retired and from
15 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
what source he was recruited may not be very relevant
because retirement from service may not follow the quota
rule. Promotees who came to the service at an advanced
age may retire, early and direct recruits who enter the
service at a comparatively young age may continue for a
long time. If, therefore, in a given year larger number of
promotees retire and every time the vacancy is filled in by
referring to the source from which the retiring person was
recruited it would substantially disturb the quota rule itself.
Therefore, while making recruitment quota rule is required
to be strictly adhered to. That was what was meant by this
Court when it said : (SCC p. 486, para 14: SCC (L&S) p.
318)
‘The quota rule would apply to vacancies and
recruitment has to be made keeping in view the vacancies
available to the two sources according to the quota.’ The
quota in the present case is 4:1 that is, four promotees to
one direct recruit. Therefore, whenever vacancies occur in
the service the appointing authority has to go on recruiting
according to quota. In other words, whenever vacancies
occur, first recruit four promotees irrespective of the
factors or circumstances causing the vacancies and as
soon as four promotees are recruited bring in a direct
recruit. That was what was meant by this Court when it
said that a roster has to be introduced and this roster
must continue while giving confirmation. The sentence
which seems to have created a difference of opinion
reads as under : (SCC p.486, para 14 : SCC (L&S) p.318)
"A
roster
is
introduced
while
giving
confirmation ascertaining every time which post has fallen
16 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
vacant and recruit from that source has to be confirmed in
the post available to the source."
7.
The sentence cannot be read in isolation. It
has to be read with the earlier sentence that the quota
rule would apply to the vacancies and recruitment has to
be made keeping in view the vacancies available to the
two sources according to the quota. The Court then
proceeded to say that if the quota rule is strictly adhered
to there will be no difficulty in giving confirmation keeping
in view the quota rule even at the time of confirmation."
The
aforesaid
decision
which
squarely
applies to the facts of the present case, therefore, leaves
no room for doubt that when under the recruitment Rule 9
in question there is no reservation of any given category
of candidates like SCs, STs or BCs to the posts in the
cadre of Professors, appointments to the posts in the
cadre have to be made in the light of the percentage of
vacancies in the posts to be filled in by promotees or
direct recruits. The quota of percentage of departmental
promotees and direct recruits has to be worked out on the
basis of the roster points taking into consideration
vacancies that fall due at a given point of time. As stated
earlier, as the roster for 3 promotees and one direct
recruit moves forward, there is no question of filling up the
vacancy created by the retirement of a direct recruit by a
direct recruit or the vacancy created by a promotee by a
promotee. Irrespective of the identity of the person
retiring, the post is to be filled by the onward motion of 3
promotees and one direct recruit Consequently, learned
counsel for the appellant and learned senior counsel for
17 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
the intervenor were right when they contended that the High
Court in its impugned judgment had patently erred in invoking
the ratio of decision of this Court in R.K. Sabharwal's case
(supra) which was rendered in an entirely different context for
resolving an entirely different controversy which did not arise
on the facts of the present case. They were also right in
contending that the ratio of the decision of this Court in
Paramjit Singh's case (supra) read with the decision of this
Court in the same case reported in [1982] 3 SCC 191 would
get squarely attracted in the facts of the present case. Once
that conclusion is reached, the result becomes obvious.
Whenever in the cadre of Professors of Ophthalmology
vacancies arise for being filled in at any given point of time,
those vacancies in the posts have to be filled in by operating
the roster in such a way that available vacancies get filled up
by allotting 75% of them to departmental promotees and 25%
to direct recruits………”
18.
The above noted exposition keeps none in the
realm of doubt as to how the roster is to be applied in respect
of appointment to the posts in a particular cadre which admits
of entry from different source.
19.
We are also dealing with the fact situation where
the source of recruitment to the post of Assistant Professor in
Himachal Pradesh Medical Education Service is from two
sources i.e. direct 15 recruitment and by way of promotion in
the ratio of 50 : 50. Thus, we have no hesitation to hold that in
such situation each ensuing vacancy in the cadre shall be filled
by applicable roster and not otherwise.
18 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
20.
In the Department of Radiology, IGMC,
Shimla, undisputedly, out of first 4 posts, 2 were filled by
promotee candidates and next 2 were filled by direct
recruits. It is stated that the appointments to first 4 posts
were not made in accordance with applicable roster as
first 2 posts went to promotees and next 2 posts went to
direct recruits, whereas the 2nd post should have gone to
direct recruit, 3rd post to promotee and then 4th post
again to direct recruit. Be that as it may, the appointments
to first 4 posts in the manner noted above, will not be of
much relevance for deciding the issue before us. Such
factor may be relevant for deciding the dispute, if any, as
to inter se seniority between the incumbents holding first 4
posts, with which we are not presently concerned.
21.
There is no dispute that 5th post again went
to promotee candidate. Though, by filling of 5th post, the
appointments to entire cadre strength were made but
what remained to be achieved was the fulfilment of
quota/reservation in the ratio of 50 : 50 between
promotees and direct recruits. In this manner, the
promotees got 16 60% reservation against prescribed
50% quota and direct recruits could get only 40% instead
of 50% quota. In case the vacancy now available is again
filled by promotee candidate, the discrimination already
meted to direct recruits shall be perpetuated. On the other
hand, the appointment on existing vacant post by direct
recruit shall achieve the fulfillment of the respective quota
of 50% prescribed for direct recruits and in future
adherence to exposition in State of Punjab and others vs.
Dr. R.N. Bhatnagar and another (supra) shall serve the
19 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
ends of applicable R & P Rules and in this manner, the
balance shall also be maintained between the promotes
and direct recruits in achieving their respective quota of
reservation to the extent of 50% each.
22.
In light of above discussion, we have no
hesitation to hold that the action of respondents No. 1 and
2 to initiate the process for filling up of vacancy to the post
of Assistant Professor in the Department of Radiology,
IGMC, Shimla by promotion is wrong, illegal, arbitrary and
in violation of Articles 14 & 16 of the Constitution of India.
Accordingly, the process so issued by respondents 1 and
2 by issuance of letter dated 6.2.2021 (Annexure P-3) and
letter dated 15.2.2021 (Annexure P-4) is quashed and
setaside. It is held that the existing vacancy to the post of
Assistant 17 Professor in the Department of Radiology,
IGMC, Shimla is required to be filled by initiation of
process for direct recruitment from the eligible candidates.
23.
The petition is accordingly disposed of in the
aforesaid terms, so also the pending miscellaneous
applications, if any, leaving the parties to bear their own
costs.”
20.
In fact, this view has again been reiterated by the Hon’ble
Division Bench in LPA No. 112 of 2021, titled Dr. Arun Singh Thakur
Versus State of H.P. and others, decided on 12.06.2024. Following
findings returned in the said judgment are also relevant:“21.
In view of above noted exposition of law,
there can be no doubt as to how the roster is to be
20 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
applied in respect of appointment to the posts in a
particular cadre which admits of entry from different
sources.
22.
In the given case, we are dealing with the fact
situation where the source of recruitment to the post of
Assistant
Professor
in
Himachal
Pradesh
Medical
Education Service is from two sources i.e. direct
recruitment and by way of promotion in the ratio of 50:50.
Thus, we have no hesitation to hold that in such a
situation each ensuing vacancy in the cadre shall be filled
by applying roster and not otherwise.
23.
This is precisely what has been held by a
Division Bench of this Court, in which one of us (Justice
Tarlok Singh Chauhan) was member, in CWP No.
907/2021, titled as Dr. Nikita Verma vs. State of H.P.,
decided on 13.8.2021.
24.
Learned counsel for the petitioner would then
argue that the learned Single Judge has erred in not
deciding the case on the basis of R.K. Sabharwal vs.
State of H.P., 1995(2) SCC 745, which provides for
reservation as understood in article 16(4) of the
Constitution of India.
25.
However, we find no merit in this arguments
more particularly, when an identical issue has already
been considered by learned Division Bench of this Court
in Ram Sarup Kalia vs. State of H.P., Latest HLJ 2005
(HP) (DB) 520, wherein it was observed as under:“29.
From
a
perusal
of
the
various
judgments of the Apex Court the position which clearly
emerges, is that the State can lay down a policy with
21 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
regard to promotion. The State also has the power to
amend the policy with regard to promotion. The State also
has the power to amend the policy even if it to the
detriment of certain class of employees. The only valid
ground to challenge such a policy is that the same
violates the mandate of Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India.
30. The judgments relied upon by the
petitioners turned on the words of the rules, which were to
be interpreted in each of those cases. From a perusal of
the judgments of the Apex Court cited above, it cannot be
said that the Supreme Court has held that in every case,
where quota is prescribed for recruitment from two or
more sources, it should always be related to vacancies
and in no case can it be applied to post. This would
depend on the rules in each case and the circumstances
under which the rule has been framed. In fact, the
Supreme Court itself in R.K. Sabharwal’s case has
deprecated the practice of operating a roster ever after
the quota has been reached. It has also stated that
concept of vacancies has no reliance in operating the
percentage of reservation. The argument of the petitioners
is that this judgment only relates to cases of reservations
and not to cases of recruitment from two 16 different
sources. The answer to this argument lies in the
observation of the Apex Court case in All India Judges’
Association case wherein the Supreme Court has again,
in no uncertain terms stated that wherever, there is a
roster once the quota is filled then the roster should not be
applied any further.”
22 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
26.
It is not in dispute that Civil Appeal No. 3606
of 2008 that was filed against the aforesaid judgment has
been dismissed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court on
27.4.2017.
27.
It would be noticed that this Court while
distinguishing the judgment rendered by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in R. N. Bhatnagar’s case (supra), held
that it cannot be said that in every case, where quota is
prescribed for recruitment from two or more sources, it
should always be related to ‘vacancies’ and in no case
can it be applied to ‘post’, rather, this would depend on
the rules in each case and the circumstances under which
the rule has been framed.
28.
Even otherwise, this issue too has been
considered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Srikant
Roy’s case (supra), wherein in paras 19 to 21, it was
observed as under:19.
Resultantly, appointments made prior to
2004 were governed by the Rules as applicable at the
relevant time. As per that dispensation, the direct recruits
quota was 33% of the total posts. That was obviously in
excess of 25% now specified in the amended Rules (as
amended on 17 20.08.2004 pursuant to the decision of
this Court). Notably, the State of Jharkhand had filed an
affidavit in C.A.No.1867/2006 before this Court in which it
has been stated that no vacancy against 25% quota for
direct recruitment existed in the State of Jharkhand at that
time. This affidavit was filed on 26th August 2008 after the
amended Rules were notified and came into force w.e.f.
20th August 2004. Thus, notification for filling up of 34
23 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
posts of Additional District Judge through Limited
Competitive Examination from amongst the members of
Jharkhand Subordinate Judges having more than 5 years
of experience and 18 posts from merit-cum-seniority basis
amongst the Civil Judge (Senior Division), was issued in
2008 on the basis that no vacancy against the posts of
direct recruit quota was available. That stand is reiterated
even now in the affidavit filed by the High Court. The High
Court in the impugned judgment has committed manifest
error in not considering these relevant facts about the
vacant posts for direct recruits as on 20.08.2004 - before
recording a finding against the High Court and the State
Government and to reject their stand that no vacancy
against the quota of direct recruit was available as on
30.04.2008.
20.
Indeed, the High Court in the
impugned judgment has adverted to the decision of this
Court in All India Judges’ Association & Ors. Vs Union of
India & Ors.[1] which has enunciated the principle of
roster and the ratio to be followed for the post of
Additional District Judge. Indisputably, pursuant to the
decision of this Court the Rules were amended, which
came into effect from 20th August 2004. In paragraph 27
to 29 of the said decision, this Court has considered the
question regarding the 18 method of recruitment to the
post in the cadre of Higher Judicial Service i.e. District
Judges and Additional District Judges. The same reads
thus:
“27.
Another question which falls for
consideration is the method of recruitment to the posts in
24 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
the cadre of Higher Judicial Service i.e. District Judges
and Additional District Judges. At the present moment,
there are two sources for recruitment to the Higher
Judicial Service, namely, by promotion from amongst the
members of the Subordinate Judicial Service and by
direct recruitment. The subordinate judiciary is the
foundation of the edifice of the judicial system. It is,
therefore, imperative, like any other foundation, that it
should become as strong as possible. The weight on the
judicial system essentially rests on the subordinate
judiciary. While we have accepted the recommendation of
the Shetty Commission which will result in the increase in
the pay scales of the subordinate judiciary, it is at the
same time necessary that the judicial officers, hardworking as they are, become more efficient. It is
imperative that they keep abreast of knowledge of law
and the latest pronouncements, and it is for this reason
that the Shetty Commission has recommended the
establishment of a Judicial Academy, which is very
necessary. At the same time, we are of the opinion that
there has to be certain minimum standard, objectively
adjudged, for officers who are to enter the Higher Judicial
Service as Additional District Judges and District Judges.
While we agree with the Shetty Commission that the
recruitment to the Higher Judicial Service i.e. the District
Judge cadre from amongst the advocates should be 25
per cent and the process of recruitment is to be by a
competitive examination, both written and viva voce, we
are of the opinion that there should be an objective
method of testing the suitability of the subordinate judicial
25 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
officers for promotion to the Higher Judicial Service.
Furthermore, there should also be an incentive amongst
the relatively junior and other officers to 19 improve and to
compete with each other so as to excel and get quicker
promotion. In this way, we expect that the calibre of the
members of the Higher Judicial Service will further
improve. In order to achieve this, while the ratio of 75 per
cent appointment by promotion and 25 per cent by direct
recruitment to the Higher Judicial Service is maintained,
we are, however, of the opinion that there should be two
methods as far
as appointment by promotion is
concerned: 50 per cent of the total posts in the Higher
Judicial Service must be filled by promotion on the basis
of principle of merit-cum-seniority. For this purpose, the
High Courts should devise and evolve a test in order to
ascertain and examine the legal knowledge of those
candidates and to assess their continued efficiency with
adequate knowledge of case-law. The remaining 25 per
cent of the posts in the service shall be filled by promotion
strictly on the basis of merit through the limited
departmental competitive examination for which the
qualifying service as a Civil Judge (Senior Division)
should be not less than five years. The High Courts will
have to frame a rule in this regard.
28.
As a result of the aforesaid, to
recapitulate, we direct that recruitment to the Higher
Judicial Service i.e. the cadre of District Judges will be:
(1)(a) 50 per cent by promotion from amongst the Civil
Judges (Senior Division) on the basis of principle of meritcumseniority and passing a suitability test; (b) 25 per cent
26 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
by promotion strictly on the basis of merit through limited
competitive examination of Civil Judges (Senior Division)
having not less than five years’ qualifying service; and (c)
25 per cent of the posts shall be filled by direct
recruitment from amongst the eligible advocates on the
basis of the written and viva voce test conducted by
respective High Courts. 20 (2) Appropriate rules shall be
framed as above by the High Courts as early as possible.
29.
Experience has shown that there
has been a constant discontentment amongst the
members of the Higher Judicial Service in regard to their
seniority in service. For over three decades a large
number of cases have been instituted in order to decide
the relative seniority from the officers recruited from the
two different sources, namely, promotees and direct
recruits. As a result of the decision today, there will, in a
way, be three ways of recruitment to the Higher Judicial
Service. The quota for promotion which we have
prescribed is 50 per cent by following the principle
“meritcum-seniority”, 25 per cent strictly on merit by
limited departmental competitive examination and 25 per
cent by direct recruitment. Experience has also shown
that the least amount of litigation in the country, where
quota system in recruitment exists, insofar as seniority is
concerned, is where a roster system is followed. For
example, there is, as per the rules of the Central
Government, a 40-point roster which has been prescribed
which deals with the quotas for Scheduled Castes and
Scheduled Tribes. Hardly, if ever, there has been a
litigation amongst the members of the service after their
27 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
recruitment as per the quotas, the seniority is fixed by the
roster points and irrespective of the fact as to when a
person is recruited. When roster system is followed, there
is no question of any dispute arising. The 40-point roster
has been considered and approved by this Court in R.K.
Sabharwal v. State of Punjab. One of the methods of
avoiding any litigation and bringing about certainty in this
regard is by specifying quotas in relation to posts and not
in relation to the vacancies. This is the basic principle on
the basis of which the 40-point roster works. We direct the
High Courts to suitably amend and promulgate seniority
rules on the basis of the roster principle as approved by
this Court in R.K. Sabharwal case as early as possible.
We hope that as a 21 result thereof there would be no
further dispute in the fixation of seniority. It is obvious that
this system can only apply prospectively except where
under the relevant rules seniority is to be determined on
the basis of quota and rotational system. The existing
relative seniority of the members of the Higher Judicial
Service has to be protected but the roster has to be
evolved for the future. Appropriate rules and methods will
be adopted by the High Courts and approved by the
States, wherever necessary by 31-3-2003.” (emphasis
supplied)
21. Once it is found that no post against the
quota of direct recruitment was available as on 30th April,
2008, no fault can be found with the selection process
commenced by the High Court for appointment in the
cadre
of
Jharkhand
Superior
Judicial
Service
by
promotion on the basis of merit through Limited
28 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
Competitive Examination. The High Court in the impugned
judgment has glossed over the effect of filling up the
vacancies in the ratio of 25:25, which inevitably will
exceed the quota of posts for direct recruits as on
30.04.2008. That would disturb the roster point and is
impermissible in terms of Rule 8 as amended.
29.
Before parting we need to observe that we
are really at complete loss as to on what basis the
petitioner has been agitating firstly before the learned writ
court and now before this court when the Rules are
absolutely clear, which provide for ratio of 50:50 between
promotee incumbents and direct recruits.
30.
Once there are two posts, obviously, one post
would come to each category and any other interpretation
would only lead to absurdity and discrimination, which has
to be avoided 22 and above all, would only lead to unjust
results, which could never have been intended by the
rule-makers.
31.
In view of aforesaid discussions and for the
reasons stated hereinabove, we find no merit in the
instant appeal and the same is accordingly dismissed,
with costs of Rs. 25,000/- to be paid to the H.P. High
Court Advocates Welfare Fund. Pending application(s), if
any, also stands disposed of.”
21.
Therefore, in light of the above discussion, this Court has
no hesitation in holding that the resultant vacancy, which is available on
account of promotion of Dr. Bhushan Lal, is to be filled in by way of
direct recruitment and not by way of promotion. In case this post is
29 ( 2026:HHC:31910 )
offered to a promotee, then the same will amount to over representation
of the promotees. As the additional post at the first instance, was filled
in by way of promotion, the resultant vacancy which has arisen in the
Department, has to be offered to a direct recruit. The resultant vacancy
need not be on account of the promotion of the incumbent who was
appointed by way of promotion on the additional post because in order
to maintain the ratio of 50:50 for recruitment in the Cadre to the
categories of promotees and direct recruits, the next resultant vacancy,
be it a vacancy created by promotee or direct recruit, has to be offered
to a direct recruit.
22.
Accordingly, in light of the above discussions, as this
Court does not find any merit in the present writ petition, the same is
dismissed. Interim stands vacated. Pending miscellaneous applications,
if any, also stand disposed of. Roster Register and the relevant record
stand returned to the office of learned Advocate General.
(Ajay Mohan Goel)
Judge
July 31, 2026
(bhupender)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review