Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$
*
%
+
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Judgment reserved on: 12.05.2026
Judgment delivered on: 03.07.2026
Judgment uploaded on: As per Digital Signature~
LPA 662/2013
DILBAGH SINGH(SINCE DECEASED)
THROUGH LEGAL HEIRS
versus
....APPELLANTS
DELHI TRANSPORT CORPORATION
.....RESPONDENT
Advocates who appeared in this case
For the Appellants
:
Mr. Arun Bhardwaj, Senior Advocate with
Mr. Pranava Rastogi and Ms. Ashu Tiwari,
Advocates.
For the Respondent
:
Ms. Avnish Ahlawat SC, DTC, Mr. Uday
Singh Ahlawat, Ms. Tania Ahlawat, Mr.
Nitish Kumar Singh, Mr. Nitesh Kumar
Singh, Ms. Aliza Alam and Mr. Mohnish
Sehrawat, Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. KAMESWAR RAO
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA
JUDGMENT
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J.
1.
This intra Court appeal lays a challenge to the order dated
03.05.2013 (impugned order) passed by the learned Single Judge in W.P.(C)
No.1852/2011 filed by the Delhi Transport Corporation (in short
‘Corporation’) whereby the learned Single Judge has allowed the writ
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 662/2013
petition.
2.
The Corporation challenged the award dated 08.04.2010 passed in ID
No.296/2008/1996 by the Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Karkardooma
Courts, Delhi (in short ‘Labour Court’) whereby the industrial dispute with
regard to the termination of Dilbagh Singh has been determined in favour of
the deceased employee with a direction that he should be reinstated.
3.
Suffice to state that the learned Single Judge has set aside the award
dated 08.04.2010 by the impugned order.
4.
During the appeal proceedings, employee –Dilbagh Singh had
expired and in terms of order dated 31.08.2017, his legal hears were brought
on record in his place.
5.
The facts to be noted for the purpose of determination of this appeal
are that the deceased employee was appointed as a driver in the Corporation
in the year 1982. While working so, on 20.08.1987, he was issued a charge
sheet for remaining on leave without pay which had the effect of being
absent from duty between 01.01.1987 to 31.07.1987 which is for a period of
161 days. The deceased employee denied the charges; resulting in the
conduct of departmental proceedings by the Enquiry Officer. The Enquiry
Officer submitted his report to the Disciplinary Authority, who in turn
issued a show cause notice dated 10.02.1988. Pursuant thereto, the deceased
employee was removed from service.
6.
Being aggrieved, the deceased employee raised an Industrial Dispute
No.296/2008/1996 challenging his removal from service. It was the case of
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 662/2013
the deceased employee before the Labour Court that he was constrained to
avail leave on the ground of his and his wife’s illness. He sent the
applications seeking leave to the depot official, which was granted to him
without pay.
7.
The case of the Corporation before the Labour Court was that no
intimation of deceased employee seeking leave was received by the
Corporation and the deceased employee was a habitual absentee.
8.
The Labour Court decided the issue with regard to the validity and
fairness of the enquiry proceedings against the corporation vide order dated
04.06.2009 by holding that the proceedings were conducted in haste. It held
if the enquiry had not been concluded on the same day, the
deceased
employee could have taken steps to produce medical certificates which he
alleged to have submitted in the control room.
9.
In so far as the charge is concerned, the Labour Court held that the
deceased employee was constrained to go on leave due to his illness as well
as the illness of his wife and hence it could not be said that he was
intentionally absent. The Labour Court ordered his reinstatement.
10.
The case of the Corporation before the learned Single Judge was that
the award of the Labour Court is without appreciating the material on
record. It is stated that the Labour Court failed to appreciate that the
respondent had not submitted any leave application. The case of the
Corporation was also by producing the Master Attendance Register as
Ex.MW2/1. Wherein at certain places ‘NA’ was written, which means ‘no
application’. It was the case of the Corporation that the factum of the
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 662/2013
enquiry being concluded within a day is not a ground for holding that the
enquiry has been vitiated, as the deceased employee was given full
opportunity to participate in the enquiry proceedings. It was also stated that
the deceased employee had not sought time either to lead any further
evidence of his own, or to produce any other witness.
11.
The reliance was placed by the Corporation on the judgment of the
Supreme Court in the case of DTC v. Sardar Singh, AIR 2004 SC 4161 to
advance the argument that mere making of leave application is not sufficient
to hold that the leave has been sanctioned, for an employee to avail leave.
12.
According to the learned counsel for the Corporation, the burden of
proving that the deceased employee was on leave with approval was on him
by producing the leave record, which he has alleged to have submitted with
the Control Room. It is for the reason that, he could not produce the medical
certificates and other documents (except for six days), that the deceased
employee was penalised.
13.
On the other hand, the case of the deceased employee before the
learned Single Judge was that the charge levelled against him that he availed
leave without pay for 161 days and not that he was absent without
permission. The very fact that the charge states that the deceased employee
had availed leave without pay itself mean that such leave was sanctioned,
without pay. In any case, it was urged on behalf of the deceased employee
that he cannot be held guilty of being absent without permission as he was
never charged for the same. The learned counsel for the deceased employee
relied upon the decision in the case of Bhagwan Lal Arya v. Commissioner
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 662/2013
of Police, Delhi & Another, AIR 2004 SC 2131 to submit that absence on
medical grounds cannot amount to grave misconduct. It was also stated that
had the deceased been on unauthorised leave without sanction then
attendance register would have had the remark of being absent as opposed to
the remark ‘leave without pay’ against the name of the deceased employee,
as is the case here.
14.
The learned Single Judge while allowing the petition vide the
impugned order, inter alia, has held as under:“9. Having heard learned counsel for the parties, and
perused the impugned
order dated 04.06.2009 and the
impugned Award dated 08.04.2010, as well as the record,
I am of the view that the impugned order and Award cannot
be sustained. Firstly, I may deal with the order dated
04.06.2009 whereby the preliminary issue with regard to
legality and validity of the
domestic enquiry has been
determined. The Labour Court finds fault with
the
conduct of the enquiry on a single day. However, what has
been not appreciated is that the respondent workman was
specifically asked whether he desired to appoint a defence
assistant, to which he responded in the
negative. The
enquiry proceeded thereafter without his seeking any
adjournment in the matter.
The evidence of the
management witness was recorded. The respondent was
given the opportunity to cross examine the management
witness, but the respondent declined to cross examine him.
Even at that stage he did not seek any adjournment. The
respondent was
also granted opportunity to lead his
evidence. Even at that stage he did
not seek any
adjournment on the ground that he wishes to lead any
evidence. Consequently, his final statement was recorded
by the enquiry officer. Pertinently, in his final statement
he had only stated that his wife was quite unwell. She was
examined by some private doctors and he also resorted to
Ayurvedic treatment. He stated that in his house there is
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 662/2013
no other elder responsible male member, and he was
himself not well for a long time on account of his suffering
from typhoid. He also stated that he had shown his wife
also to the doctors of the DTC. He also stated that he had
submitted medical certificates issued by the
government
hospitals in the control room of the DTC. He stated that he
had to take leave due to his compulsions. He stated that on
this
occasion, he should be pardoned and that he had
nothing more to say.
10. From a perusal of the entire enquiry proceedings, it is
clear that
every possible opportunity was given to the
respondent and it could not
be said that the enquiry
proceedings were conducted in haste or in breach of the
respondent’s rights or in a manner prejudicial to him. The
finding that had the proceedings been adjourned, the
respondent would
have been able to produce other
evidence regarding his leave applications
on medical
ground has no merit because the respondent never sought
that
the alleged leave applications be produced by the
petitioner or that the same be summoned from the control
room or any other place. It was not for the enquiry officer
or the petitioner to cause the production of the so-called
record/documents from the control room or from any other
record. The petitioner had produced through its witness the
record that
it desired to rely upon to prove the charge.
Therefore, this ground
stated in the impugned order to
vitiate the enquiry is patently laconic and rejected.
11. The second ground stated is that the defence of the
respondent was that he was ill with typhoid and that his
wife was also not well. The mere ipsi dixit of the respondent
was not sufficient in this regard. It was for him to
specifically lead evidence to show as to for which period
he was ill and with what ailment. It was for him to show
since when his wife was suffering. Moreover, it was for
him to establish that he had
made leave application in
compliance with the rules for obtaining medical leave for
himself and his wife.
xxx
xxx
xxx
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 662/2013
13. The last ground stated in the impugned order on the
preliminary issue also has no merit. The same is that the
enquiry officer had not collected the Master Attendance
Register (MAR) and the witness Narayan Singh had not
produced the same before the enquiry officer to sustain the
charge. The witness Sh. Narayan Singh had referred to the
MAR and on that basis, he had stated that the respondent
had taken leave without pay of 161 days, out of which 6
leaves were taken by furnishing medical proof of illness
between January 1987 to July 1987. This statement of the
witness was never challenged by the delinquent. He did not
cross examine
the witness to enquire on what basis the
said statement had been made. The respondent accepted
the said statement which was made on the basis of
the
MAR. Therefore, there was no basis to conclude that the
MAR was not produced by the management witness. Even
if it were to be accepted that the said register was not so
produced, the statement of management
witness went
unchallenged and unrebutted. In fact, the respondent never
questioned the said statement even when he gave his own
final closing statement. He sought to explain his absence
as aforesaid and sought pardon.
xxx
xxx
xxx
16. Though, the respondent claimed to be on medical leave,
he did not comply with the requirements of clause 4 of the
standing orders which provides that an employee shall not
absent himself from duties without having first obtained
permission from the authority or the competent
officer
except in the case of sudden illness. In the cases of sudden
illness, he shall send intimation to the office immediately. If
the illness lasts or is expected to last for more than 3 days
at a time, application for leave should be duly accompanied
by a medical
certificate, from a registered medical
practitioner or the medical
officer of the DTC. The
relevant clause came up for consideration in this Court in
WP(C) 13909/2009 in Rajpal v. The Presiding Officer
Labour Court IX Delhi and Another decided on 09.01.13
and WP(C) 3338/2010 in Management of Delhi Transport
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 662/2013
Corporation v. Workman Amar Singh decided
on
15.03.13.
17. Clearly, the respondent did not comply with the
requirements of the aforesaid standing order. The Labour
Court observes that the photocopy of
the medical
certificate produced by the respondent, did not stand
proved.
In fact, in the proceedings before the Labour
Court -on the issue of fairness of the enquiry, the Labour
Court observed that in the cross
examination of the
workman, it was elicited that no medical certificate had
been produced by the workman. There is also no evidence
on record
from which it appears that the workman had
applied for leave. The only
exception in Para 4 of the
standing orders is a case of sudden illness, in which event
too, the employee must apply for leave if the illness is
expected to last for more than 3 days. Pertinently, this is not
a case of sudden illness as the respondent claims he was
on prolonged illness.
18. The charge sheet further states “Your past record will
be taken into
consideration at the time of passing final
orders in the case? The
respondent had been penalized
twice before for availing excessive leave and, therefore,
looking to his past record it appears that the respondent
was a habitual absentee. The Labour Court having taken
note of the fact that the past record of the respondent was
not in his favour, was not
justified in ordering
reinstatement.
19. The contention of learned counsel for respondent that
the charge sheet issued to the respondent did not level the
charge of unauthorised absence has no merit. The charge
sheet categorically states that the conduct of the respondent
falls within Para 19(h) of the standing orders that state
?Habitual negligence of duties and lack of interest in the
Authority’s work?. Furthermore, the charge sheet also
states that the
respondent’s conduct falls within Para 4
(ii) of the standing orders.
Para 4 (ii) of the standing
orders states Habitual absence without
permission or
sanction of leave and any continuous absence without such
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 662/2013
leave for more than 10 days shall render the employee
liable to be
treated as an absconder resulting in the
termination of his service with
the Organisation. The
breach of the said provisions of the standing orders having
been alleged against the respondent, it demonstrates that he
had been charged with unauthorised absence. Therefore,
this argument of the respondent-that no charge of
unauthorised absence was levelled against the respondent,
appears to be wholly misplaced.
20. I also find no merit in the submission of the respondent
that the
charge sheet having stated that the respondent
was guilty of availing
‘leave without pay’ for 161days
implies that the leave had been sanctioned because leave
cannot be ‘availed of’-unless sanctioned. The respondent
is putting the cart before the horse by advancing the
aforesaid submission. It is not that the leave becomes
authorized and
ceases to be unauthorized because it is
sanctioned as ‘leave without
pay’. Because it is
unauthorized, it is treated as without pay. Obviously, if the
workman absents unauthorisedly and in breach of the
relevant service rules, the management would be entitled to
treat the same as ‘leave without pay’. However, merely
because the same is treated
as ‘leave without pay’, the
same does not stand regularized and does not absolve the
delinquent workman from disciplinary action for going on
unauthorized leave. It is evident that the word ‘availing’ has
been used in the context of its general connotation and not
with the intention to
connote that leave had been duly
sanctioned. Furthermore, the charge sheet stated that the
respondent’s past conduct would be taken into
account
and he had, in fact, been penalised twice on previous
occasions for availing excessive leave.
xxx
xxx
xxx
24. It is not clear from the order in Sukhbir Singh (supra)
what the
duration of absence, or past record of the
appellant was. In the present case, the Labour Court itself
observes that the medical certificate
produced by the
respondent workman does not stand proved. In any event,
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 662/2013
the respondent was given sufficient opportunity to produce
the leave
applications duly accompanied with medical
certificates and the same have not been produced before
this Court either
25. In Sardar Singh (supra), the court observed that
‘Conclusions
regarding negligence and lack of interest
can be arrived at by looking into the period of absence,
more particularly, when same is unauthorized. Burden is
on the employee who claims that there was no negligence
and/or lack of interest to establish it by placing relevant
materials. Clause
(ii) of Para 4 of the Standing Order
shows the seriousness attached to
habitual absence. In
clause (i) thereof, there is requirement of prior
permission. Only exception made is in case of sudden
illness. There also
conditions are stipulated, nonobservance of which renders the absence unauthorized.’
26. It appears that the Labour Court while passing the
impugned order and
the impugned award has acted
merely out of sympathy than on any legal basis. In Amar
Singh (supra), on this aspect, this Court had observed as
follows: ‘Misplaced sympathy does more harm to the cause
of the workmen generally,
than the good that it may
apparently do to the delinquent workman who is before
the industrial tribunal. What is the message being sent to
the
larger body of workmen by the industrial tribunal
when it adopts such an approach? It is that one can get
away with indiscipline, inefficiency, disloyalty and
disobedience to one’s employer and one’s employment.
Such
misconduct pulls down the employer organization
and puts undue strain on the others serving the
organization. Why should the other large body of
workers, who sincerely slog it out to serve the employer,
suffer by having to take on the burden of the good-fornothing bad apples and black sheep within the
organisation?
By showing misplaced sympathy, the
industrial tribunal indirectly breeds inefficiency within the
organisation. It brings a bad name to the organization, and
hardly ever
reforms the delinquent workman who is
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 662/2013
emboldened further after tasting success, despite his
misconduct. Courts and Tribunals do possess the power
to exhibit compassion and sympathy but if the same is
shown in undeserving cases, the results can be disastrous.
It is high time, we became more efficient as a nation. We
can ill afford indiscipline or inefficiency, particularly in
Industry and Commerce, if we have to successfully compete
in a liberalized world with other nations. Our
teaming
population which has till now been very patient,
accommodating and forgiving is becoming more and more
demanding and rightly so. It
is for us to fulfill the
legitimate aspiration of our people. To achieve the same,
our workforce must adopt a more responsible attitude, and
we must do our bit to discourage and punish indiscipline
and inefficiency.”
15.
Before us, Mr. Arun Bhardwaj, learned Senior Counsel appearing for
the legal heirs of deceased employee would reiterate the submissions as
were advanced before the learned Single Judge. It is his submission that the
learned Single Judge has erred in holding that the every possible opportunity
was given to the deceased employee to defend himself. According to him,
the enquiry proceedings were conducted in a haste manner by breaching the
rights of deceased employee. According to him, prejudice was caused to the
deceased employee when the enquiry proceedings were conducted and
concluded on the same day without calling upon the deceased employee to
produce his leave applications for his absence for 161 days. He has also
stated that the learned Single Judge has erred by placing the onus on the
deceased employee to produce the leave applications submitted by him for
his and wife’s illness. According to him, the onus was on the Enquiry
Officer to call for the record as the record was in the custody of the
Corporation.
Moreover, the deceased employee being a driver is not
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 662/2013
expected to produce the record, because of lack of knowledge of the
procedure governing the enquiry proceedings.
16.
That apart, it is his submission by not allowing the deceased employee
to appoint the defence assistant, the Enquiry Officer himself has acted as a
prosecutor. Further the finding that the deceased employee has accepted the
statement of Narain Singh, who produced the Master Attendance Register is
clearly erroneous. The respondents were still required to prove the veracity
of the attendance register. It is also stated that the Labour Court did not
adopt the casual approach. The conclusion of the Labour Court was drawn
on the basis of the evidence and record. He submitted that the medical
certificates were on the record of the Corporation and to say that the
deceased employee was not able to prove that he was unauthorisedly absent
is contested.
17.
Lastly, it is his submission that the deceased employee having worked
for a period of five years, was entitled to be reinstated with back wages and
benefits. In support of his submission, he has relied upon the Standing
Orders(SO) as well as the judgment of this Court in the case of Roop Chand
v. Delhi Transport Corporation, 2015:DHC:7020 and that of the Supreme
Court in the case of Union of India & Another v. Ram Lakhan Sharma,
(2018)7 SCC 670.
18.
On the other hand, Ms. Avnish Ahlawat, learned Standing Counsel
for the Corporation would contest the submission made by Mr. Bhardwaj by
stating that proper opportunity was given to the deceased employee to prove
his innocence in the departmental proceedings. She stated that the deceased
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 662/2013
employee did not produce the leave applications along with the medical
certificates to justify his absence from duty for 161 days. The conclusion
drawn by the Labour Court was clearly perverse, being contrary to record.
19.
In so far as the conclusion of the learned Single Judge, more
particularly, on the issue that the deceased employee was denied the support
of a defence assistant is concerned, paragraph 10 of the order dated
04.06.2009 passed by the Labour Court inter alia, reads as follows:“… One Chander Prakash was the Enquiry Officer. No
doubt the workman has participated at the fore view of the
proceedings, it gives an impression that that the workman
was explained the charges and was also asked to have the
help of the defence assistant, which he declined”.
20.
The above order really proves that the deceased employee was
accorded the opportunity of appointing a defence assistant, which he
declined. Hence, in that sense, there was no violation of principles of
natural justice.
21.
In so far as the statement of department witness Narain Singh, on
which reliance was placed by the learned Single Judge shows that the
Labour Court in the very same paragraph of order dated 04.06.2009 noted as
follows:“… One Narain Singh is examined. He has spoken with
regard to the master attendance register to show that the
workman was leave on 161 days without pay and six days
leave for which he produced medical certificate. This
witness was not cross examined by the workman. Statement
of the workman was also recorded which is the defence
evidence and the evidence was concluded on the same day”.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 662/2013
22.
The Labour Court records the stand of the workman /deceased
employee in paragraphs 8 and 9 in the following manner:“8. Workman in his affidavit at Ex. WW 1/A contended that
enquiry is bad for the reasons that he was not explained of
the procedure. There was no welfare officer nor a defence
assistant. No list of documents, witnesses were given.
Management has not filed any documentary evidence to
prove the charge. Further he deposes that leave without pay
is not a misconduct. The enquiry was conducted in haste.
The enquiry report is perverse. In the cross examination he
admits having received the charge sheet and the report at
exhibits WW1/M-1 and M-2. He admits having participated
in the enquiry.
9. WW-1 was further examined and he deposes that he has
sent the medical certificates through one Raj Singh and also
the leave applications. In the evidence of MW-1, I find that
the original attendance register is produced at Ex.MW 1/1
and the leave applications at Ex.MW1/2. In the cross
examination it is elicited that no medical certificate
produced by the workman”
23.
Based on the aforesaid position, the Labour Court formed the
following view:“a)That the entire enqiry [sic. enquiry] was conducted and
concluded on the of the same day.
b) The defence of the workman was that the workman was
ill for typhoid and that his wife was also ill.
c) The report at Ex.WW1/M-4 shows that the enquiry officer
only relied on the non production of the documentary
evidence by the workman. His explanation that he was
treated by the DTC doctors and other government hospitals
and that he gave the certificates to the control room was to
never considered.
d) Only if the enquiry officer had not concluded the
proceedings on the same day, workman would have
produced or had taken steps to summons those documents
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 662/2013
from control room.
e) The enquiry was conducted in a haste.
f) That no presenting officer is appointed.
g) The enquiry officer had not collected the master
attendance register and witness Narain Singh has not
produced the same before the enquiry officer to sustain the
charges.”
24.
The Labour Court resultantly answered the reference in favour of the
workman.
25.
Regrettably, we may state that the conclusion drawn by the Labour
Court has no basis. The conclusion is despite the deceased employee had
refused to take the help of the defence assistant; and also refused to cross
examine Narain Singh – department witness. He had also not sought time
from the Enquiry Officer to produce evidence on his behalf. There was no
alternative with the Enquiry Officer but to proceed with the proceedings.
26.
No doubt, the stand that the enquiry proceedings have been completed
in a day’s time, looks appealing on a first blush, but such a plea needs to be
seen and considered in the facts of each case. Surely, the facts which have
emerged in the present case, as noted above, do show a proper opportunity
was given to the employee to defend himself. He had not sought time to
produce the documents/evidence/witness in his favour.
27.
We must also say that a reference has been made by the learned
Single Judge in paragraph 18 of the impugned order that according to the
chargesheet the deceased employee was penalised twice before, for availing
excessive leave. In that sense, the deceased employee was a habitual
absentee. In the facts of this case, we are of the view that the conclusion
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 662/2013
drawn by the learned Single Judge in the impugned order, as noted by us,
against the award of the Labour Court cannot be faulted.
28.
Accordingly, the appeal being devoid of any merit is dismissed.
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J
JULY 03, 2026
M
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 662/2013
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review