Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:2737
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWPIL No.115 of 2025
Reserved on : 07.01.2026
Decided on : 09.01.2026
Dikken Kumar Thakur & Anr.
...Petitioners.
Versus
The State of Himachal Pradesh & Ors.
…Respondents.
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Vivek Singh Thakur, Judge.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Romesh Verma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting? 1 Yes.
For the petitioners
:
Mr. Ankush Dass Sood, Senior Advocate
with Mr. Nand Lal Thakur, Mr. Mandeep
Chandel, Mr. Ajay Dhiman, Mr. Khem Raj,
Mr. Kiran Kumar, Mr. Ajay Sipahiya, Mr.
Tarun Mehta, Mr. Udit Shaurya Kaushik,
Mr. Aditya Kaushal, Mr. Vishal Verma, Mr.
Vinod Kumar and Mr. Sanjeev Pathania,
Advocates.
For the respondent(s) :
Mr. Shrawan Dogra, Senior Advocate with
Mr. Tejasvi Dogra and Mr. Mohit Sharma,
Advocates, for respondents No. 1 and 4.
:
Mr. Anup Rattan, Advocate General with
Ms. Swati Draik, Deputy Advocate General
and Mr. Shalabh Thakur, Assistant
Advocate General, for respondent-State.
:
Mr. Surinder Sharma, Advocate, for
respondent-State Election Commission.
Vivek Singh Thakur, Judge
Petitioners have approached this Court in public interest
for issuance of directions to the respondents to conduct elections and
Whether the reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment? Yes
-2-
2026:HHC:2737
complete the election process before expiry of term of Panchayati Raj
Institutions in the State of Himachal Pradesh, as provided under Article
243E of the Constitution of India, seeking the following substantive
reliefs: “1.
2.
3.
2.
Issue a writ of mandamus or any other appropriate writ, order
or direction, directing the Respondents to ensure that the
elections to the Panchayati Raj Institutions in the State of
Himachal Pradesh are conducted before the expiry of their
five-year term, as mandated under Article 243-E of the
Constitution of India; and/or
Direct the State Election Commission to forthwith notify the
election schedule and take all consequential steps for holding
free and fair elections to the Panchayati Raj Institutions
without further delay; and/or
Declare that any attempt to continue the existing Panchayati
Raj Institutions beyond their term of five years is
unconstitutional and void ab initio; and/or”
Vide Notification dated 17.11.2025 (Annexure R-2/12) by
By invoking powers conferred under Article 243K(1) and 243ZA(1) of
the Constitution of India, Section 161 of the Himachal Pradesh
Panchayati Raj Act, 1994 (in short ‘PR Act’), Section 281(1) the
Himachal Pradesh Municipal Act, 1994 (in short ‘MC Act’), Section 9(1)
of the Himachal Pradesh Municipal Corporation Act, 1994 (in short
‘Corporation Act’) read with first proviso of Clause 2.1 of the Himachal
Pradesh Panchayats and Municipalities Model Code of Conduct, 2020,
Clause 12.1 of Model Code of Conduct, 2020, was enforced with
immediate effect throughout the State of Himachal Pradesh by State
Election Commission which reads as under:“12.1 The structure, classification or area of the Panchayats and
Municipalities shall not be altered after the issue of
Notification by the State Election Commission enforcing this
clause, till the election process is over.”
-3-
3.
2026:HHC:2737
It is undisputed that terms of Panchayati Raj Institutions in
Himachal Pradesh are going to expire on 31.01.2026, as also evident
from Notification dated 17.11.2025 (Annexure R-2/12). It has been
further notified in this notification that delimitation of Panchayati Raj
Institutions in respect of 3577 Gram Panchayats, 90 Panchayat
Samitis, 11 Zila Parishads and 71 Urban Local Bodies, has been
completed and stands finally notified with further declaration that
electoral rolls of 3548 Gram Panchayats and 70 Urban Local Bodies
(‘ULBs’) have been finally prepared after following due process of law
and, electoral rolls of 29 Gram Panchayats and one ULB is scheduled
to be finalized on 01.12.2025 and 07.12.2025, respectively.
4.
It has been further notified that term of 50 Urban Local
Bodies, 4 Municipal Corporations (Dharamshala, Palampur, Mandi &
Solan) and 5 Nagar Panchayats (Amb, Chirgaon, Kandaghat, Nerwa
and Nirmand) are due to expire on 18.01.2026, 13.04.2026 and
16.04.2026, respectively.
5.
From the material on record, it is apparent that to ensure
conduct of election of Panchayati Raj Institutions before expiry of
tenure of Panchayati Raj Institutions, Director, Panchayati Raj
Department, vide communication dated 14.11.2024, had submitted
tentative time schedule for carrying out various activities, whereby it
was suggested that report to the State Election Commission along with
-4-
2026:HHC:2737
copy of delimitation order would be submitted during 7th July to 10th
July, 2025, after completing all formalities and necessary steps,
including re-organization; bifurcation of existing Panchayats; inviting
creation of new Panchayats; inviting proposals for re-organization,
bifurcation and creation of new Panchayats; submission of proposal to
the Government; publication of proposal for inviting objections and
suggestions; time to decide the objections and suggestions;
communication of final proposal by Deputy Commissioner to
Directorate; final notification of re-organization, bifurcation and creation
of new Panchayats; letter to start process of delimitation of
constituencies of PRIs; delimitation proposals and publication for
inviting objections; final notification after consideration of objections
and suggestion; submission of report to State Election Commission
along with copy of delimitation order; undertaking exercise of
reservation of seats and offices in the PRIs; and with proposal of
issuance of final notification of reservation between 16th July to 21st
September, 2025.
6.
Vide communication dated 02.12.2024, the State Election
Commission had communicated to the Director-cum-Special Secretary,
Department of Panchayati Raj, to complete the entire exercise latest by
30.09.2025 to enable the Commission to start election process in
accordance with order passed by the Apex Court in Special Leave to
Appeal (C) No.26468-26469 of 2024 titled as The State of Punjab &
-5-
2026:HHC:2737
Ors. Vs. Beant Kumar & Anr. along with connected matters vide
order dated 11.11.2024.
7.
Vide communication dated 01.05.2025, Director-cum-
Special Secretary (Panchayati Raj) had asked all the Deputy
Commissioners, Himachal Pradesh, to start delimitation process under
the PR Act and the Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj (Election) Rules,
1994 (in short ‘PR Election Rules’) and to publish the same finally on
or before 31.05.2025.
8.
Vide communication dated 28.02.2025, the Principal
Secretary (Urban Development) to Government of Himachal Pradesh,
requested the State Election Commission to extend the timeline for one
more month to finalize all proposals by submitting that there are several
proposals still under consideration and yet to reach final stage. In
response, Secretary, State Election Commission vide letter dated
22.05.2025 had communicated that no further extension will be
considered by the State Election Commission after 15.04.2025.
9.
Vide communication dated 01.08.2025, preparation of
electoral rolls of PRIs and Municipalities was initiated with direction to
complete the draft by 27.09.2025.
10.
Giving reference, regarding conducting of Census-2027 in
two phases, vide communication dated 10.07.2025, Principal Secretary
(Urban Development), issued a letter to all Deputy Commissioners,
-6-
2026:HHC:2737
Himachal Pradesh, except Lahaul & Spiti and Kinnaur, to postpone
implementation/finalization of issuance of reservation roster of ULBs
election till availability of latest census data.
11.
Vide communication dated 11.07.2025, State Election
Commission had declared the aforesaid communication dated
10.07.2025 void ab initio with further direction to complete the
reservation process in respect of all Nagar Panchayats, Municipal
Councils and Municipal Corporations, and immediately to depute staff
with State Election Commission subject to supervision and control of
State Election Commission so as to do all necessary acts for
conducting the elections.
12.
Vide
order dated
08.10.2025, Chief
Secretary
to
Government of Himachal Pradesh, as Chairman, State Executive
Committee, SDMA, Himachal Pradesh, had issued order, citing the
large-scale damages and losses during different heavy spells of rains,
i.e. 26th June, 2025 in Dharamshala and Kullu; 30th June, 2025 and 1st
July, 2025 in various parts of the Mandi district; 5-6 August, 2025 and
13-14 August, 2025, across the State; and 24-26th August, 2025 in
Chamba, Kullu and Lahaul & Spiti districts, on account of 47
cloudbursts, 98 flash floods, 148 major landslides reported from
different parts of the State and loss of 270 lives, full damage of 1817
houses and partial damages of 8323 houses causing total damage to
-7-
2026:HHC:2737
the tune of Rs.5,426/- Crores during Monsoon of 2025, to the following
effect:“NOW THEREFORE, keeping in view the adverse situation of the
damaged roads and public and private property, the undersigned as
Chief Secretary-cum-Chairman of the State Executive Committee
constituted under the Disaster Management Act 20025, in exercise
of the powers conferred on me under sub section (e) of Section 24
of the Act ibid order that elections to the Panchayati Raj Institutions
will be held only after restoration of proper connectivity throughout
the State so that no inconvenience is caused to the general public as
well as the polling personnel, and further no voter loses his right to
vote because of road connectivity issues.”
13.
The said order was issued exercising the powers
conferred under the Disaster Manager Act, 2025 (in short ‘DM Act’).
14.
Respondent-State Election Commission on 10.11.2025
issued directions to all District Election Officers (Panchayat)-cumDeputy Commissioners, Additional Deputy Commissioner, Spiti at
Kaza, District Lahaul & Spiti and all the Assistant District Election
Officers-cum-District Panchayat Officers, to depute responsible officers
to collect various types of election material and ballot papers, required
to conduct elections of Panchayati Raj Institutions, as notified on
different dates for all districts (Annexure P-32).
15.
On 14.11.2025, the State Election Commission issued a
Press Note (Annexure P-35) inviting data for addition in the voters’ list
on or before 01.10.2025, including all persons who had completed 18
years of age on or before 01.10.2025, in the electoral roll .
-8-
16.
2026:HHC:2737
In response to direction to depute the officers/officials for
collecting election materials and ballot papers, officers/officials were
deputed
by
respective
District
Election
Officers-cum-Deputy
Commissioners and they attended the office of State Election
Commission, however, before collecting election material, these
officers were directed by the respective Deputy Commissioners to not
collect the material till further orders.
17.
The State has also issued notification dated 19.11.2025
(Annexure P-37) amending the Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj
(Election) Rules, 1994.
18.
For adjudication of present petition, following provisions of
Constitution of India, the Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act, 1994,
the Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj (Election) Rules, 1994, the
Disaster Manager Act, 2025 (in short ‘DM Act’) and the Census Act,
1948, referred in arguments shall be relevant to be considered, which
read as under:A.
“CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
243B. Constitution of Panchayats.—(1) There shall be constituted
in every State, Panchayats at the village, intermediate and district
levels in accordance with the provisions of this Part.
243D. Reservation of seats.—(1) Seats shall be reserved for—
(a) the Scheduled Castes; and
(b) the Scheduled Tribes,
in every Panchayat and the number of seats so reserved shall bear,
as nearly as may be, the same proportion to the total number of seats
to be filled by direct election in that Panchayat as the population of
the Scheduled Castes in that Panchayat area or of the Scheduled
-9-
2026:HHC:2737
Tribes in that Panchayat area bears to the total population of that area
and such seats may be allotted by rotation to different constituencies
in a Panchayat.
xx
xx
xx
(5) The reservation of seats under clauses (1) and (2) and the
reservation of offices of Chairpersons (other than the reservation for
women) under clause (4) shall cease to have effect on the expiration
of the period specified in article 334.
(6) Nothing in this Part shall prevent the Legislature of a State from
making any provision for reservation of seats in any Panchayat or
offices of Chairpersons in the Panchayats at any level in favour of
backward class of citizens.
243E. Duration of Panchayats, etc.—(1) Every Panchayat, unless
sooner dissolved under any law for the time being in force, shall
continue for five years from the date appointed for its first meeting
and no longer.
(2)
No amendment of any law for the time being in force shall
have the effect of causing dissolution of a Panchayat at any level,
which is functioning immediately before such amendment, till the
expiration of its duration specified in clause (1).
(3)
An election to constitute a Panchayat shall be completed—
(a) before the expiry of its duration specified in clause (1);
(b) before the expiration of a period of six months from the
date of its dissolution:
Provided that where the remainder of the period for which the
dissolved Panchayat would have continued is less than six months,
it shall not be necessary to hold any election under this clause for
constituting the Panchayat for such period.
(4)
A Panchayat constituted upon the dissolution of a Panchayat
before the expiration of its duration shall continue only for the
remainder of the period for which the dissolved Panchayat would
have continued under clause (1) had it not been so dissolved.
B.
THE HIMACHAL PRADESH PANCHAYATI RAJ ACT, 1994
120. Duration of Panchayats.- (1) Every Panchayat shall continue
for five years from the date appointed for its first meeting and no
longer unless sooner dissolved under this Act.
(2)
An election to constitute a Panchayat shall be completed(a) before the expiry of its duration specified in sub-section
(1); and
(b) before the expiration of a period of six months from the
date of its dissolution:
Provided that where the remainder of the period for which the
dissolved Panchayat would have continued is less than six months it
shall not be necessary to hold any election under this clause for
constituting the Panchayat for such period.
-10-
2026:HHC:2737
(3)
A Panchayat constituted upon the dissolution of a Panchayat
before the expiration of its duration shall continue only for the
remainder of the period for which the dissolved Panchayats, would
have continued under sub-section (1) had it not been so dissolved.
xx
xx
xx
128. First meeting and term of office.- (1) First meeting of
Panchayat shall be held on such date as the State Government may
fix by a general or special order.
(2) Unless otherwise provided in the Act the office bearers of
Panchayat shall hold office for five years from the date of the first
meeting and no longer.
(3) If before the expiry of the period prescribed in sub-section (2), the
Panchayat is not re-constituted, it shall stand dissolved on the expiry
of the said period and the provisions of section 140 shall apply thereto
for a period not exceeding six months within which the Panchayat
shall be reconstituted in accordance with the provisions of this Act.
xx
xx
xx
140. Power of State Government to dissolve Panchayats for
default, abuse of power, etc.xx
xx
xx
(3)
On dissolution of Panchayat under sub-section (1), the
following consequences shall ensue, namely:(a) all the office-bearers, shall vacate their offices with effect
from the date of such order;
(b) all powers and duties of the Panchayat shall, until the
Panchayat is reconstituted, be exercised and performed by
such person or committee of persons as the State
Government or the prescribed authority may appoint in this
behalf and where a committee of persons is so appointed, the
State Government or the prescribed authority shall also
appoint a head of such committee; and
(c) where a committee is appointed under clause (b), any
member of such committee duly authorised by it may issue or
institute or defend any action at law on behalf of or against
the Panchayat.
(4) Any person appointed to exercise and perform the powers and
duties of a Panchayat during the period of dissolution may receive
from the Fund of the Panchayat concerned such payment for his
service as the State Government may, by order, determine.
(5) A Panchayat dissolved under sub-section (1) shall be
reconstituted in accordance with the provisions of this Act within six
months of its dissolution. Such reconstituted Panchayat shall function
for the remaining term of the Panchayat:
Provided that if the unexpired period is less than six months
the reconstitution of the Panchayat shall not be done for this period.
[(6) Notwithstanding anything contained in this section, when on
account of the reason that the whole of the Sabha area of the Gram
-11-
2026:HHC:2737
Panchayat ceases to be the Sabha area either due to its declaration
as Municipal area or its inclusion in the existing Municipal area for
providing better facilities to the public of the said area and also in the
public interest, the State Government shall, by an order published in
the Official Gazette, dissolve the Gram Panchayat from a date
specified in the order.
C.
THE HIMACHAL PRADESH PANCHAYATI RAJ (ELECTION)
RULES, 1994
2. Definitions.- (1) In these rules, unless, there is anything repugnant
in the subject or contextxx
(b)
xx
xx
“Constituency” means a territorial constituency of a Gram
Sabha, Panchayat Samiti or Zila Parishad, as the case may,
for the representation of which a member is to be elected or
has been elected and in relation to Pradhan or Up-Pradhan
of a Gram Panchayat, shall mean the whole of Gram Sabha
area;
D.
THE DISASTER MANAGEMENT ACT, 2005
2. Definitions.—In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires,—
xx
xx
xx
(d)
“disaster” means a catastrophe, mishap, calamity or grave
occurrence in any area, arising from natural or man made causes, or
by accident or negligence which results in substantial loss of life or
human suffering or damage to, and destruction of, property, or
damage to, or degradation of, environment, and is of such a nature
or magnitude as to be beyond the coping capacity of the community
of the affected area;
xx
xx
xx
14. Establishment of State Disaster Management Authority.—(1)
Every State Government shall, as soon as may be after the issue of
the notification under sub-section (1) of section 3, by notification in
the Official Gazette, establish a State Disaster Management Authority
for the State with such name as may be specified in the notification
of the State Government.
(2)
A State Authority shall consist of the Chairperson and such
number of other members, not exceeding nine, as may be prescribed
by the State Government and, unless the rules otherwise provide, the
State Authority shall consist of the following members, namely:—
(a) the Chief Minister of the State, who shall be Chairperson,
ex officio;
(b) other members, not exceeding eight, to be nominated by
the Chairperson of the State Authority;
-12-
2026:HHC:2737
(c) the Chairperson of the State Executive Committee, ex
officio.
(3)
The Chairperson of the State Authority may designate one of
the members nominated under clause (b) of sub-section (2) to be the
Vice-Chairperson of the State Authority.
(4)
The Chairperson of the State Executive Committee shall be
the Chief Executive Officer of the State Authority, ex officio:
Provided that in the case of a Union territory having
Legislative Assembly, except the Union territory of Delhi, the Chief
Minister shall be the Chairperson of the Authority established under
this section and in case of other Union territories, the Lieutenant
Governor or the Administrator shall be the Chairperson of that
Authority: Provided further that the Lieutenant Governor of the Union
territory of Delhi shall be the Chairperson and the Chief Minister
thereof shall be the Vice-Chairperson of the State Authority.
(5)
The term of office and conditions of service of members of the
State Authority shall be such as may be prescribed.
xx
xx
xx
20. Constitution of State Executive Committee.—(1) The State
Government shall, immediately after issue of notification under subsection (1) of section 14, constitute a State Executive Committee to
assist the State Authority in the performance of its functions and to
coordinate action in accordance with the guidelines laid down by the
State Authority and ensure the compliance of directions issued by the
State Government under this Act.
(2)
The State Executive Committee shall consist of the following
members, namely:—
(a) the Chief Secretary to the State Government, who shall
be Chairperson, ex officio;
(b) four Secretaries to the Government of the State of such
departments as the State Government may think fit, ex
officio.
(3)
The Chairperson of the State Executive Committee shall
exercise such powers and perform such functions as may be
prescribed by the State Government and such other powers and
functions as may be delegated to him by the State Authority.
(4)
The procedure to be followed by the State Executive
Committee in exercise of its powers and discharge of its functions
shall be such as may be prescribed by the State Government.
xx
xx
xx
22. Functions of the State Executive Committee.—(1) The State
Executive Committee shall have the responsibility for implementing
the National Plan and State Plan and act as the coordinating and
monitoring body for management of disaster in the State.
xx
xx
xx
(2)
Without prejudice to the generality of the provisions of subsection (1), the State Executive Committee may—
-13-
xx
2026:HHC:2737
xx
xx
(a) coordinate and monitor the implementation of the National
Policy, the National Plan and the State Plan;
xx
xx
xx
(h) give directions to any Department of the Government of
the State or any other authority or body in the State regarding
actions to be taken in response to any threatening disaster
situation or disaster;
xx
xx
xx
24. Powers and functions of State Executive Committee in the
event of threatening disaster situation.—For the purpose of,
assisting and protecting the community affected by disaster or
providing relief to such community or, preventing or combating
disruption or dealing with the effects of any threatening disaster
situation, the State Executive Committee may—
(a) control and restrict, vehicular traffic to, from or within, the
vulnerable or affected area;
xx
xx
xx
(e)
give direction to the concerned Department of the
Government of the State, any District Authority or other authority,
within the local limits of the State to take such measure or steps for
rescue, evacuation or providing immediate relief saving lives or
property, as may be necessary in its opinion;
xx
xx
xx
(l)
take such steps as the Central Government or the State
Government may direct in this regard or take such other steps as are
required or warranted by the form of any threatening disaster
situation or disaster.
xx
xx
xx
CHAPTER X
OFFENCES AND PENALTIES
51. Punishment for
reasonable cause—
obstruction,
etc.—Whoever,
without
(a) obstructs any officer or employee of the Central
Government or the State Government, or a person
authorised by the National Authority or State Authority or
District Authority in the discharge of his functions under this
Act; or
(b) refuses to comply with any direction given by or on
behalf of the Central Government or the State Government
or the National Executive Committee or the State
Executive Committee or the District Authority under this
Act,
shall on conviction be punishable with imprisonment for a term which
may extend to one year or with fine, or with both, and if such
-14-
2026:HHC:2737
obstruction or refusal to comply with directions results in loss of lives
or imminent danger thereof, shall on conviction be punishable with
imprisonment for a term which may extend to two years.
xx
xx
xx
55. Offences by Departments of the Government.—(1) Where an
offence under this Act has been committed by any Department of the
Government, the head of the Department shall be deemed to be
guilty of the offence and shall be liable to be proceeded against and
punished accordingly unless he proves that the offence was
committed without his knowledge or that he exercised all due
diligence to prevent the commission of such offence.
(2)
Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1), where
an offence under this Act has been committed by a Department of the
Government and it is proved that the offence has been committed
with the consent or connivance of, or is attributable to any neglect on
the part of, any officer, other than the head of the Department, such
officer shall be deemed to be guilty of that offence and shall be liable
to be proceeded against and punished accordingly.
E.
THE CENSUS ACT, 1948
4. Appointment of census staff.—(1) The Central Government may
appoint a Census Commissioner to supervise the taking of the
census throughout the area in which the census is intended to be
taken, and 6 [Directors of Census Operations] to supervise the taking
of the census within the several States.
(2)
The State Government may appoint persons as censusofficers 7 [with such designations as that Government may deem
necessary] to take, or aid in or supervise the taking of, the census
within any specified local area and such persons, when so appointed,
shall be bound to serve accordingly.
(3)
A declaration in writing, signed by any authority authorised by
the State Government in this behalf, that any person has been duly
appointed a census-officer for any local area shall be conclusive
proof of such appointment.
(4)
The State Government may delegate to such authority as it
thinks fit the power of appointing census-officers conferred by subsection (2).
[4A. Staff of every local authority to he made available for taking
census.—Every local authority in a State shall, when so directed by
a written order by the Central Government or by an authority
appointed by that Government in this behalf, make available to any
Director of Census Operations such staff as may be necessary for
the performance of any duties in connection with the taking of
census.]
Apart from above, following Rules have also been referred:-
-15-
(a).
2026:HHC:2737
Rule 4 of H.P. Election Rules provides limit of
constituencies of the Gram Sabha; Rule 5 provides proposal open for
inspection in the office of the Gram Panchayat, Panchat Samiti within
the territorial jurisdiction by affixing a copy of the same at two
conspicuous places within such Sabha area for inviting public
objections thereon within 7 days.
(b).
Rule 6 provides disposal of objections and passing of final
order within 7 days.
(c).
Rule 8 provides delimitation of constituencies of a
Panchayat Samiti, proposal of de-limitation, inviting objections and
deciding the objections by the Deputy Commissioner in the same
manner like Gram Sabha.
(d).
Similarly Rule 9 provides de-limitation of constituencies,
publication of de-limitation of Constituencies of Zila Parishad and
deciding of objections in same manner.
(e).
Rule 10 provides appeal from order of the Deputy
Commissioner to the Divisional Commissioner within 10 days which
shall be decided after giving opportunity of being heard to appellant
within 15 days and final publication of de-limitation under Rule 11.
(f).
Panchayats.
Rule 28 provides procedure for reservation of seats in the
-16-
19.
2026:HHC:2737
Referring provisions of Article 243E of the Constitution, it
has been contended on behalf of the petitioners that allowing to
continue the existing Panchayati Raj Institutions (‘PRIs’) beyond their
term of 5 years, is unconstitutional and void ab initio.
20.
Learned counsel for the petitioners to substantiate the plea
has relied upon directions passed by Apex Court in Special Leave to
Appeal (C) No.26468-26469 of 2024 titled as The State of Punjab &
Ors. Vs. Beant Kumar & Anr. along with connected matters vide
order dated 11.11.2024, whereby taking into consideration the
Constitutional Scheme mandates, directions passed by a Division
Bench of Punjab and Haryana High Court to State of Punjab to notify
the election programmes in respect of all Municipal Corporations,
Municipalities and Nagar Panchayats in a time-bound manner, was
upheld, and State Election Commission, Punjab and State of Punjab
was directed to commence the election process within two weeks and
to complete the same within eight weeks thereafter, with rider that no
further extension shall be granted.
21.
Reliance has also been placed on behalf of the petitioners
on the judgment passed in Constitutional Bench of the Apex Court in
Kishansing Tomar vs. Municipal Corporation of the City of
Ahmedabad & Ors., reported in (2006) 8 SCC 352, Suresh Mahajan
vs. State of Madhya Pradesh & Anr., reported in (2022) 12 SCC 770
-17-
2026:HHC:2737
and Rahul Ramesh Wagh vs. State of Maharashtra & Ors., reported
in (2022) 12 SCC 798.
22.
Following paragraphs of Kishansing Tomar (supra) are
relevant to be referred:“21.
It is true that there may be certain man-made calamities, such
as rioting or breakdown of law and order, or natural calamities which
could distract the authorities from holding elections to the
Municipality, but they are exceptional circumstances and under no
circumstance the Election Commission would be justified in delaying
the process of election after consulting the State Govt. and other
authorities. But that should be an exceptional circumstance and shall
not be a regular feature to extend the duration of the Municipality.
Going by the provisions contained in Article 243-U, it is clear that the
period of five years fixed thereunder to constitute the Municipality is
mandatory in nature and has to be followed in all respects. It is only
when the Municipality is dissolved for any other reason and the
remainder of the period for which the dissolved Municipality would
have continued is less than six months, it shall not be necessary to
hold any elections for constituting the Municipality for such period.
xx
xx
xx
25.
From the reading of the said provisions it is clear that the
powers of the State Election Commission in respect of conduct of
elections is no less than that of the Election Commission of India in
their respective domains. These powers are, of course, subject to the
law made by Parliament or by State Legislatures provided the same
do not encroach upon the plenary powers of the said Election
Commissions.
26.
The State Election Commissions are to function independent
of the concerned State Governments in the matter of their powers of
superintendence, direction and control of all elections and
preparation of electoral rolls for, and the conduct of, all elections to
the Panchayats and Municipalities.
27.
Article 243 K (3) also recognizes the independent status of
the State Election Commission. It states that upon a request made in
that behalf the Governor shall make available to the State Election
Commission "such staff as may be necessary for the discharge of the
functions conferred on the State Election Commission by clause (1).
It is accordingly to be noted that in the matter of the conduct of
elections, the concerned government shall have to render full
assistance and co-operation to the State Election Commission and
respect the latter's assessment of the needs in order to ensure that
free and fair elections are conducted.
-18-
2026:HHC:2737
28.
Also, for the independent and effective functioning of the
State Election Commission, where it feels that it is not receiving the
cooperation of the concerned State Government in discharging its
constitutional obligation of holding the elections to the Panchayats or
Municipalities within the time mandated in the Constitution, it will be
open to the State Election Commission to approach the High Courts,
in the first instance, and thereafter the Supreme Court for a writ of
mandamus or such other appropriate writ directing the concerned
State Government to provide all necessary cooperation and
assistance to the State Election Commission to enable the latter to
fulfil the constitutional mandate.”
23.
Following paragraphs of Suresh Mahajan (supra) are also
relevant to be referred:“9.
Despite such constitutional mandate, the reality in the State
of Madhya Pradesh as of now, is that, more than 23,263 local bodies
are functioning without the elected representatives for last over two
years and more. This is bordering on break down of rule of law and
more so, palpable infraction of the constitutional mandate qua the
existence and functioning of such local self-government, which
cannot be countenanced.
10.
The fact that the State legislature has effected amendments
in the concerned enactment(s) authorizing the State Government to
determine the number and extent of wards to be constituted in the
local bodies within the State also cannot be a tangible or legitimate
ground to not notify the election programme within the time-frame
specified by the Constitution and the law made by the Legislature in
that regard.
11.
In any case, the ongoing activity of delimitation or formation
of ward cannot be a legitimate ground to be set forth by any authority
much less the State Election Commission - to not discharge its
constitutional obligation in notifying the election programme at the
opportune time and to ensure that the elected body is installed before
the expiry of 5 (five) years term of the outgoing elected body. If there
is need to undertake delimitation - which indeed is a continuous
exercise to be undertaken by the concerned authority - it ought to be
commenced well-in-advance to ensure that the elections of the
concerned local body are notified in time so that the elected body
would be able to take over the reigns of its administration without any
disruption and continuity of governance (thereby upholding the tenet
of Government of the people, by the people and for the people). In
other words, the amendment effected to the stated enactments
cannot be reckoned as a legitimate ground for protracting the issue
of election programme of the concerned local bodies.
12.
Therefore, we direct the State Election Commission by way of
interim order, to issue election programme without any further delay
on the basis of the wards as per the delimitation done in the
-19-
2026:HHC:2737
concerned local bodies when the elections had become due
consequent to expiry of 5 (five) years term of the outgoing elected
body or before coming into force of the impugned Amendment Act(s)
whichever is later. On that notional basis, the State Election
Commission ought to proceed without any exception in respect of
concerned local bodies where elections are due or likely to be due in
the near future without waiting even for the compliance of triple test
by the State Government for providing reservation to Other Backward
Classes. We have no manner of doubt that only such direction would
meet the ends of justice and larger public interests consistent with
the constitutional mandate that the local self-government must be
governed by the duly elected representatives uninterrupted except in
case of its dissolution before expiry of the term on permissible
grounds.
13.
For, until the triple test formality is completed “in all respects”
by the State Government, no reservation for Other Backward Classes
can be provisioned; and if that exercise cannot be completed before
the issue of election programme by the State Election Commission,
the seats (except reserved for the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled
Tribes which is a constitutional requirement), the rest of the seats
must be notified as for the General Category.
xx
xx
xx
19.
In view of the above, we have no hesitation in directing the
Madhya Pradesh State Election Commission to proceed on notional
basis and issue election programme in respect of concerned local
body by reckoning the delimitation/formation of wards thereof as on
the date when the election of the concerned local body had “in fact”
become due or before coming into force of the (impugned)
Amendment Act, which is under-challenge before this Court in the
present proceedings, whichever is later.
20.
The State election Commission must do so not later than two
weeks from today. The State Government shall extend adequate
logistical support to the State Election Commission for accomplishing
the task in terms of this order.”
24.
Following paragraphs of Rahul Ramesh Wagh (supra) are
also relevant to be referred: “6.
However, we called upon the learned counsel for the
Maharashtra State Election Commission to explain as to why the
elections in large number of local bodies (around 2486) across the
State of Maharashtra, though overdue, and in some cases even
overdue for two years, have not been taken forward despite the
peremptory direction given by this Court vide successive orders,
including dated 03.03.20222. The response of the State Election
Vikas Kishanrao Gawali v. State of Maharashtra, (2022) 12 SCC 795
-20-
2026:HHC:2737
Commission was that it had taken steps in right earnest until the
Amendment Act(s) came into force; and further until the delimitation
is done by the State Government under the stated Amendment
Act(s), it was not possible for it to proceed in the matter.
7.
In the background of this submission, we observe and hold
that the process of delimitation being a continuous exercise may be
continued by the State of Maharashtra, subject to the outcome of
these petitions, but that would be relevant only for future elections
after such exercise is completed. For that, the elections of local
bodies (around 2486) which had become due on expiry of five years
term and required to be conducted before expiry of such term in terms
of Article 243-E and 243-U of the Constitution of India, including
Sections 6 and 6(B) read with Section 452A(2) of the Maharashtra
Municipal Corporation Act and related provisions in other enactments
governing elections of local bodies, the conduct of elections of such
local bodies cannot brook any delay. This mandate is exposited by
the Constitution Bench of this Court in Kishansing Tomar v.
Ahmedabad Municipal Corpn.3, SCC paras 12 to 14 and 22 to 28, in
particular.
8.
Accordingly, the election programme of such local bodies
must proceed and the State Election Commission is obliged to notify
the election programme within two weeks from today in respect of
such local bodies including to continue with the process from the
stage as on 10.3.2022, on the basis of the delimitation done prior to
coming into force of the Amendment Act(s) w.e.f. 11.03.2022. In other
words, the delimitation as it existed prior to 11.03.2022 in respect of
concerned local bodies be taken as notional delimitation for the
conduct of overdue elections and to conduct the same on that basis
in respect of each of such local bodies.
9.
Insofar as providing reservation for scheduled castes and
scheduled tribes, the mandate of the Constitution and statutory
provision must be followed; and in so far as other backward classes,
compliance of triple test as predicated by this Court in Vikas
Kishanrao Gawali v. State of Maharashtra4 must be adhered to.
Absent such compliance, no reservation can be provided in the local
bodies for that category which may go for elections with immediate
effect in terms of this order.”
25.
In response to petition by the State of Himachal Pradesh,
referring destructions in natural calamities during Monsoon in 2025
stated, in order dated 08.10.2025 issued by Chairman, SDMA,
Himachal Pradesh (Chief Secretary to Govt. of H.P.), it has been
(2006) 8 SCC 352
(2021) 6 SCC 73
-21-
2026:HHC:2737
contended that reliance placed upon by the petitioners on Article 243E
of the Constitution is narrow and isolated and it cannot override a
Central Statute (DM Act) enacted specifically to address emergent
situations involving public safety with further submission that State is
also on verge of entering harsh winter season having severe effect in
some District, like Lahaul & Spiti, Kinnaur, Kullu, Chamba, Shimla and
upper regions of Mandi. It was further submitted that decision of SDMA
does not extend the term of Panchayati Raj Institutions indefinitely and
State is committed for holding elections at earliest feasible date.
26.
It has been further contended that order dated 08.10.2025
issued by Chairman, SDMA, H.P., is legal and valid, and the Chairman
was competent to issue the said order in view of provisions of Section
2(d), 14, 20, 22(h), 24(e), 24(l) as well Section 72 of the DM Act, with
further submission that Section 72 of the DM Act clearly provides that
provisions of the Act shall have overriding effect over any other law in
force and the said statutory supremacy has neither been assailed by
the petitioners nor taken into account at the time of filing the petition.
27.
It has been also contended that in view of Section 51 and
55 of DM Act, officers of the State as well as State Election Commission
are constrained to abide by the orders passed by the SDMA to avoid
punishment provided for violation of notification/orders issued/passed
under the DM Act.
-22-
28.
2026:HHC:2737
It has been contended that, on account of destruction
caused by natural calamities, even in Kishansing Tomar’s case (supra),
the Apex Court recognized the justification for delay in election process
in exceptional circumstances, such as those prevailing in Himachal
Pradesh.
29.
It has been further contended on behalf of the respondent-
State that necessary exercise of re-organization and delimitation of
Panchayats under the P.R. Act has already been undertaken for all
districts. However, the same remains pending in respect of Panchayat
Samiti Fatehpur, Panchayat Samiti Bamson, and one Zila Parishad
seat in Hamirpur due to specific legal and administrative reasons, and
that the delay in conducting the elections is not intentional.
30.
Judgment dated 05.12.2025 passed by this Division Bench
in CWP No.13810 of 2025 titled as Devinder Singh Negi vs. State of
Himachal Pradesh & Ors. has also been cited as cause of delay to
finalize the delimitation of Zila Parishads for quashing of amendment in
Rule 9(2) of PR Election Rules and setting aside notification dated
31.05.2025, notifying the delimitation of constituencies of Zila Parishad,
Shimla.
31.
By referring para 63 of judgment in Devinder Singh Negi’s
case (supra), it has been contended this Division Bench has observed
that State Election Commission cannot thrust upon its decision by
-23-
2026:HHC:2737
issuing notification dated 17.11.2025 in view of order dated 08.10.2025
issued by Chairman, SDMA.
32.
It has been further contended that in view of order dated
19.11.2025 passed in CWP No.6074 of 2025, delimitation notification
of Nagar Panchayat Nagrota Surian has also been set aside with
direction to the State to consider the objection of the people of the area
within specified time.
33.
It has been further contended that there are several other
decisions of the Court in various writ petitions, whereby constitution of
Municipal Corporation Baddi, re-organization of Nagar Panchayat
Swarghat, Nagar Panchayat Kunihar, Nagar Panchayat Jwala Ji etc.
has been set aside with direction to the State to consider the objections
by the habitants of the area in a time-bound manner. Therefore, delay
has been justified.
34.
Reliance has also been placed on judgment passed by
Coordinate Division Bench on 06.01.2021 passed in CWP No.5987 of
2020 along with connected matters titled as Manish Dharmaik vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh & Ors., whereby it has been directed that
notification reserving offices in the Gram Panchayats in the State for
various categories in elections to Panchayati Raj Institutions required
to be published and placed in public domain on the website of State
Election Commission at least three months prior to the commencement
-24-
2026:HHC:2737
of election process to enable timely adjudication of disputes pertaining
to application/rotation of election reservation roster, and therefore, it
has been contended that it would not be possible to complete the entire
process of elections of Panchayati Raj Institutions before expiry of term
of Panchayati Raj Institutions.
35.
Referring provisions of Sections 120, 128 and 140(3) to (6)
of the PR Act, it has been contended that situation like present one has
already been contemplated in the PR Act and combined reading of the
Sections provide that in case election of Panchayati Raj Institutions is
not conducted before expiry of its term/duration, then such election has
to be conducted within six months after expiry of term/duration and for
intervening period, the respondent-State is competent to appoint a
person or Committee of persons to exercise and perform the duties of
such Panchayati Raj Institutions.
36.
It has been further submitted that immediately after
passing of judgment in Devinder Singh Negi’s case (supra), vide
communication dated 20.12.2025, all Deputy Commissioners have
been directed to start fresh delimitation, which shall be completed
within a timeframe provided in the PR Act.
37.
With aforesaid submission, following tentative time
schedule, for delimitation and reservation, has been projected by
respondent-State as under: -
-25-
2026:HHC:2737
Activity
Date
Letter to DCs for delimitation of 20.12.2025
constituencies/wards of PRIs
Period required for DCs for Approximately
publication of delimitation proposals 10.01.2026
Period for filing objections
upto
7 days from date of
publication – Approximately
upto 17.01.2026
Period required to inquire and 7 days after the last date of
consider objections by DCs
inviting
objections
–
24.01.2026
For filing appeal before Div. Comm.
10 days upto 04.02.2026
Period to hear and decide the 15 days
Appeal by Divisional Commissioner
19.02.2026
Final publication
5 days
24.02.2026
Time period required for reservation 30 days by 24.03.2026
38.
In response to petition, the State Election Commission has
also placed on record various documents, communication and orders
to indicate that the State Election Commission has taken all necessary
steps well within time to ensure conduct of elections of Panchayati Raj
Institutions before expiry of term of Panchayati Raj Institutions.
39.
Learned counsel for respondent No.2-State Election
Commission, apart from the steps taken by the State Election
Commission for conducting the elections within the time provided under
the Constitution, has submitted that he has instructions to communicate
that 100 days’ time to be taken for conducting elections, after final
publication of the Electoral Rolls on Form-15 and Form-17 by
submitting two plans ‘A’ and ‘B’, which reads as under:-
-26-
2026:HHC:2737
“A.
Time line for conduct of general elections to PRIs as per
delimitation completed in accordance with directions issued by
Panchayati Raj Department vide letter dated 01.05.2025:
Days required
Sr. Exercise to be undertaken
No.
Final publication of electoral rolls on Form- 1 day
15 and Form-17
Downloading of electoral rolls of 22000 10-15 days
wards of PRIs/ULBs
Printing/stitching/transportation of Voter List 25-30 days
Notice for Election Programme
7 days
Election Process
3–35 days
Counting of PS/ZP election and notification 3-5 days
of results
Total time required
76-93 days (Say
100 days)
* HP School Education Board conducts exams for Matriculation and
+2 in the month of February and March.
* School premises and teaching staff will be required for the conduct
of elections.
* HP Assembly Session usually takes place in the month of March
and District administration and fileed officers have to remain present
in the offices to deal with assembly business.
* The PRIs institutions wherein delimitation is not finalized, the
Commission may be allowed to conduct the elections of these
institutions as per earlier finally notified delimitation.
* Therefore, as per proposal A the commission will be in a position to
conduct the elections in April, 2026 in respect of all PRIs and
Municipal bodies.
B.
Time line for conduct of general elections to PRIs if
delimitation is undertaken afresh as per schedule given by the
Department of Panchayati Raj in its reply to CWP.
Days required
Sr. Exercise to be undertaken
No.
Delimitation and Reservation of Upto 24th March, 2025
Wards
Verification of Electors
15 days
Mapping/Shifting of elector
10 days
Updation of Voter List
40 days
Downloading of electoral rolls of 10-15 days
22000 wards of PRIs/ULBs
Printing of Voter List
25-30 days
Notice for Election Programme
7 days
Election Process
30-35 days
Counting of PS/ZP election
3-5 days
-27-
Total time required
2026:HHC:2737
140-157 days (Say 160
days) after 24th March,
* As per proposal B the commission will be in a position to conduct
the elections in August, 2026
* In view of monsoon season in Himachal Pradesh and disasters the
Commission will have to take all precautionary measures in respect
to safety and security of voters and polling personnel etc.
* Besides, the Census Department will start census operation from
01.05.2026 in Himachal Pradesh. Since field machinery for conduct
to census and elections are the same, therefore, it will be difficult for
the State Election Commission to conduct elections during this
period.”
40.
It is apparent from the submission and information placed
on record by learned counsel for the State Election Commission that in
case electoral rolls are published today and roster of the constituencies
of Panchayats is also published, immediately then it would take about
100 days to complete the election process and, in such manner,
election would be conducted in the month of March, 2026. It is also
noticeable that in the month of March, normally Legislature Assembly
Session is scheduled and Board examinations for Matriculation and +2
are to be conducted in the months of February and March. Therefore,
it would be difficult to conduct the elections in the months of February
and March, 2026. Thus, elections may be conducted in April, 2026.
41.
According to State Election Commission, in case
delimitation is taken afresh, as per schedule given by Department of
Panchayati Raj in its reply filed to the writ petition, delimitation and
reservation of Wards shall be completed by 24.03.2025 and thereafter,
about 160 days would be required for conducting elections and in such
-28-
2026:HHC:2737
eventuality, elections for Panchayati Raj Institutions can be conducted
in August, 2026. However, it has also been pointed out that in August
2026 it would again be monsoon season in Himachal Pradesh, and
census operation is also scheduled to commence from 01.05.2026 in
the State. Since the field machinery for conducting elections and
census is the same, therefore, it would be difficult to conduct elections
in May or thereafter.
42.
It has been also contended on behalf of respondent that in
view of provisions of Section 4 and 4A of the Census Act, 1948, the
State is empowered to take, aid for census by appointing any person,
apart from the Government official or officer and, therefore, initiation of
census from 01.05.2026, shall not cause any hinderance in conducting
the election during the months of May and June 2026, as proposed by
the respondent-State, in aforesaid facts and circumstances, i.e. within
six months period after expiry of tenure of Panchayati Raj Institutions,
as provided under the PR Act.
43.
Learned counsel for the petitioners in rebuttal has
submitted that statutory order, cannot overrule the constitutional
machinery, and therefore, order passed by Chief Secretary in the
capacity of Chairman. SDMA, cannot supersede the decision/direction
of the State Election Commission to proceed further to conduct the
elections, particularly when there is no material to justify the order
passed by the SDMA, whereas after the disasters, public life has
-29-
2026:HHC:2737
achieved normalcy and Government functions with huge gathering, like
3-year celebration, in the most affected District Mandi, are being
organized without any problem of road connectivity and transport
facility.
44.
It has been further submitted that after normalcy in the life,
fairs, marriage ceremonies and other social gatherings are also being
celebrated by the public at large throughout Himachal Pradesh,
including area badly affected by calamity.
45.
Learned counsel for the petitioners has also submitted that
Election Commission is ready with its material and voters list, but
Government machinery has failed to cooperate and to provide proper
assistance to the Election Commission to conduct election of
Panchayati Raj Institutions, before expiry of duration, despite the fact
that disaster is not continuing and connectivity has been completely
restored.
46.
It has been further submitted on behalf of petitioners that
judgement passed in Devinder Singh Negi’s case (supra) is being used
as a shield by the respondents for justifying the delay, whereas even
before passing of the said judgement, State machinery was acting in a
manner, so as to cause delay in conduct of election of Panchayati Raj
Institutions, as evident from the action of Director, Panchayati Raj as
-30-
2026:HHC:2737
well as Director, Urban Department, and also order dated 08.10.2025
issued by the Chief Secretary (Chairman, SDMA).
47.
It has been further contended that, in case, delay is being
caused because of the judgement passed in Devinder Singh Negi
(supra), then petitioners would be praying to recall the said judgement
and to issue direction the respondents to conduct the election
immediately.
48.
After taking into consideration the provisions of the
Constitution and the pronouncement of Apex Court referred supra and
also issue involved in Devinder Singh Negi’s case (supra), we are of
the opinion that observation made by this Division Bench in Devender
Negi’s case that State Election Commission cannot thrust upon its
decision by issuing notification dated 17.11.2025 is obiter dicta and
requires to be ignored. Further, in the said judgment, it is nowhere
directed by the Court to conduct election after fresh delimitation of the
Wards of the Zila Parishad. It is noticeable that present delimitation
conducted by the respondents is based upon census of 2011.
Delimitation of wards for past election conducted in 2020 was also on
the basis of Census 2011, and therefore, for setting aside and quashing
of delimitation notification dated 31.05.2026, the election can easily be
conducted on the basis of past delimitation. Hence, there is no reason
for delaying with elections of Panchayati Raj Institutions by referring
judgment passed in Devinder Singh Negi’s case (supra).
-31-
49.
2026:HHC:2737
In fact, none of the component of the State, including the
State Election Commission has to thrust its decision upon others, but
all limbs of the system involved in governance, should act harmoniously
in consultation with each other by taking decisions after due
consolidation and consideration of facts and circumstances, instead of
deciding unilaterally causing tug-of-war between them, hampering the
interest of larger public and violation of Constitutional mandate.
50.
It is also noteworthy that judgement was passed on
05.12.2025, whereas Government through Deputy Commissioners, in
November 2025, had caused termination of process being continued
by the State Election Commission by directing the Deputy
Commissioners to depute officials to collect elections material and
ballot papers as the officials deputed to collect the said material were
directed, at the last moment, not to collect the election material, despite
the fact that officials so deputed had reached the destination to collect
the material.
51.
In the judgement passed in Devinder Singh Negi’s case
(supra), it has nowhere been stated to conduct the election or delay the
election for re-delimitation of Zila Parishads in Himachal Pradesh in
view of quashing of Rule 9(2) of PR Election Rules, but the authorities
have been directed to do needful, as expeditiously as possible, which
includes not only steps for the re-delimitation of Zila Parishads Wards,
but also option of conducting election on the basis of past delimitation
-32-
2026:HHC:2737
of Zila Parishads Wards, because delimitation in previous election was
on the basis of Census of 2011 and present delimitation is also based
on Census of 2011 and thus, the data for delimitation would remain the
same.
52.
Even otherwise, orders passed by the Court in certain
matters, delimitation and creation of Municipal Corporation Baddi,
Nagar Panchayats Kunihar, Swarghat, Jhadhutta, Jwala Ji, Nagrota
Surian and Panchayat Sumiti, Fatehpur, Nargota Surian as well as
delimitation of Wards of Zila Parishad, cannot be used as a shield to
justify inaction on the part of State, because the aforesaid cases, not
more than dozen, cannot be said to have caused delay in finalizing the
roster point of reservation in Panchayati Raj Institutions throughout
Himachal Pradesh, because it is itself the case of respondents that the
delimitation of Panchayati Raj Institutions had been completed on
31.05.2025. Even if period of natural calamity from July and August,
2025, is excluded, then also there was sufficient time to continue and
complete the exercise of determining reservation roster to ensure
election of Panchayati Raj Institutions before expiry of duration of
Panchayats.
53.
Plea of the respondent-State that it intends to act in
compliance of direction issued in Manish Dharmaik’s case (supra) to
publish the reservation roaster at least three months prior to
commencement of election process, also does not appear to be bona
-33-
2026:HHC:2737
fide, because in case respondent-State was so keen to follow the said
directions, the reservation roster had to be notified and published in the
month of September 2025, but the material on record reflects that
firstly, Director, Urban Development, in July, 2025, tried to hamper the
preparation and publication of rosters by issuing letter dated
10.07.2025, and thereafter, despite objection of the State Election
Commission to this letter and continuous requests made to all
concerned, no steps were taken for finalizing the reservation roster in
September 2025. To cover-up the inaction of the State, office order
dated 08.10.2025 is appears to have been issued and further, the delay
is not because of any judgement passed by the Court, but because of
the attitude and intention of the officers of the State, reflecting the
intention of the Government.
54.
Section 120 of PR Act mandates that Panchayat shall
continue for 5 years, but no longer thereafter, which indicate that no
Panchayat can continue after completion of 5 years from the date
appointed for its first meeting. It also provides that election to constitute
a Panchayat shall be completed before the expiry of specified duration
as well as before expiration of period of six months from the date of its
dissolution.
55.
Section 128(3) of the PR Act provides that in case
Panchayat is not reconstituted, before expiry of the prescribe period, it
shall stand dissolved on expiry of the said period and provisions of
-34-
2026:HHC:2737
Section 140 of PR Act shall apply thereto, but for a period not exceeding
six months within which Panchayat shall be reconstituted in accordance
with provisions of this Act.
56.
In regard to aforesaid provisions, Section 140(3) to Section
140(6) of the PR Act would be relevant, in which Section 140(3)(b)
provides that until reconstitution of the Panchayat, all powers and
duties of Panchayat shall be exercised and performed by a person or
Committee of persons appointed by State Government or prescribed
authority in this behalf and Panchayat dissolved shall be reconstituted
within six months of its dissolution.
57.
It is apparent from the aforesaid provisions of PR Act that
on expiry of duration Panchayati Raj Institutions shall be deemed to
have been dissolved, because it is specifically provided that Panchayat
shall continue no longer after 5 year from the date appointed for its first
meeting. These provisions also indicates that from the date of
dissolution, including the deemed dissolution on expiry of term, the
reconstitution of Panchayat shall be completed before expiry of period
of 6 months from the date of dissolution. Thus, the Rule is to conduct
election/reconstitution of Panchayati Raj Institutions before expiry of
tenure of 5 years and the reconstitution of Gram Panchayat after expiry
of duration, but within six months thereafter, is an exception. It cannot
be claimed as a matter of right, by the Government to decide to
reconstitute the Panchayat after the expiry of duration, but within six
-35-
2026:HHC:2737
months thereafter. Therefore, the claim of the respondent-State that it
has a right and authority to defer reconstitution of election for one or
other reason within six months after expiry of duration, is not legal,
justified, and sustainable.
58.
Though, the DM Act is special Statute enacted to deal with
emergent situations for disaster management, as evident from the
provision of the Act, however, it is a Statute enacted by Legislation on
the basis of power flowing from the Constitution. A statutory provision
and order passed thereunder cannot override or supersede the
constitutional provisions as well as constitutional machinery like
Election Commission. Status of Election Commission is well recognized
and in case of conflict between the statutory provisions/order and the
constitutional
provisions
and
orders
passed
by
constitutional
machinery, the Constitutional provisions and order
passed by
Constitutional Machinery shall prevail and, therefore, observations in
this regard made in Devinder Singh Negi’s case (supra) are to be read
accordingly and therefore, the same cannot be used for undermining
the status of Election Commission, and therefore, order passed by the
Chairman, SDMA, shall not have overriding impact upon the functioning
of the Election Commission. Thus, Election Commission can proceed
further ignoring the order dated 08.10.2025, but definitely taking into
consideration the factual matrix and the situation prevailing in the State
of Himachal Pradesh. It is apt to record that nothing has been placed
-36-
2026:HHC:2737
on record by the respondent-State to justify the observations made in
the order dated 08.10.2025 so as to reflect that the after-effects of the
calamities existing as on date with such gravity and magnitude that it
would not be possible to conduct elections to the Panchayati Raj
Institutions in Himachal Pradesh.
59.
It is also relevant to observe that it is apparent from the
record that State Election Commission, consisting of State Election
Commissioner is appointed by the Governor in terms of Article 243K of
the Constitution to give effect the constitutional mandate of the
Constitution, which includes conducting elections for reconstitution of
Panchayati Raj Institutions, whereas State Disaster Management
Authority is the creation of the Act and the Secretaries and Directors of
the Panchayati, Raj and Urban Development are representing
Executive and elected Government is representing the Legislature.
60.
We the people of India have adopted a system, wherein
neither Legislature nor Executive or Judiciary is supreme, but it is the
Constitution and only the Constitution, which has to prevail in all
eventualities. Constitutional mandate is that for the purpose of
conducting elections to the Panchayat, everyone has to act in
superintendence and control of Election Commission, as directed by it
in pursuance to the power vested by the Constitution in the Election
Commission. Therefore, action of the Director, Urban Development,
Director, Panchayati Raj, Deputy Commissioners of the State, as well
-37-
2026:HHC:2737
as the Chief Secretary, acting as Chairman of SDMA, is contrary to the
Constitutional Scheme. No doubt, for taking a decision, Election
Commission has to consult other components of the State, and also
has to consider all relevant factors, including the natural calamities and
other problems to be faced by the stakeholders, involved in conducting
the election, but the fact remains that with respect to the conduct of
elections, decision of Election Commission, unless manifestly arbitrary,
irrational, unconstitutional or mala fide, has to be abide by all.
61.
The election of Panchayati Raj Institutions cannot be
deferred on account of pendency of creation or re-organization of
Panchayats as well as Urban Local Bodies in small pockets, in two or
three Districts, i.e. Solan, Bilaspur and Kangra. Connectivity problem
can also not be a reason to defer the election in entire State. The
election in rest of the Himachal Pradesh can be and should have been
conducted before expiry of the duration, and now at the earliest.
62.
The entire material on the record creates doubt about the
conduct of the officials and officers of respondent-State, giving an
impression that Government is not keen to conduct the election well in
time, but rather intending to defer the same for indefinite period for
reasons known to them.
63.
It is true that in Beant Kumar’s case (supra) and
Kishansingh Tomar’s case (supra), the reconstitution of Panchayati Raj
-38-
2026:HHC:2737
Institutions/Urban Local Bodies was pending for 2 or more than 2 years,
but it cannot claimed that, in present case, for expression of intention
of the respondent-State to reconstitute the Panchayati Raj Institutions
within six months after expiry of the duration, no direction to reconstitute
Panchayati Raj elections, as prayed in present petition, is required to
be passed. For the material on record, we are of the considered
opinion, that unless appropriate direction is not passed, there is every
possibility of deferring the conduct of election for further period.
64.
The aforesaid impression is also fortified from the fact that
respondent-State has given Proposals in the reply to complete action
on its part with respect reconstitution of Panchayati Raj Institutions by
end of March 2026, whereas Election Commission is claiming that
election process can be completed thereafter in the month of August
2026 only but again with certain reservations with regard to completion
of election process by August 2026, because of initiation of census in
month of May and apprehending heavy rains in the monsoon season.
65.
It has been also stated that it is not possible to reconstitute
the Panchayati Raj Institutions by conducting elections from January to
March, 2026, as delimitation, creation and re-organization process of
certain institutions, which will have bearing on determination of roster
point, on the basis of areas and population to be included in various
Wards, is pending completion after issuance of direction dated
22.12.2025 to Deputy Commissioners to initiate and complete the
-39-
2026:HHC:2737
delimitation process in the light of judgment passed in Devinder Singh
Negi’s case (supra). Another reason for difficulty to conduct election in
March is that there would be Board examination in the month of March.
66.
Though it has been asserted on behalf of respondent-
State that election would be conducted before the expire of six months
after dissolution of Panchayati Raj Institutions, but in the material on
record, it appears that elections would be possible in the month of
March and April 2026. It would also be apt to observe here that it is not
necessary to involve teachers only in conducting the elections process,
rather employees of other departments, who have no role in conducting
the examination of students in schools or educational institutions, can
be deputed as a major group of employees to be deployed for
conducting the elections.
67.
In present case, neither Secretary nor Director concern or
Chief Secretary, ever consulted the Election Commission, but they took
decisions, issued letters, past orders, unilaterally.
68.
In order dated 08.10.2025 issued by SDMA, no factual
matrix has been reflected, except the numerical detail of affected
persons, families, villages and houses, at the time of natural calamity,
but without verifying or discussing their condition at the time of issuance
of the order. The State Election Commission, instead of calling all
stakeholders on one table for discussing and deciding the issue of
-40-
2026:HHC:2737
reconstitution of Panchayati Raj Institutions, has issued letters
declaring the letters and orders of the Executive as null and void. For
duty cast upon Election Commission under the provisions of the
Constitution, the Election Commission should have acted as elder
brother and other limbs of the State should have cooperated with the
Election Commission in order to take appropriate decision for
conducting the elections. All of them should have functioned
harmoniously without involving in tug-of-war. It has hampered the
public interest in violation of Constitutional mandate.
69.
In the schedule placed on record by the respondent-State,
it has been depicted that for completion of role on its part for
reconstitution of Panchayati Raj Institutions, final publication of the
delimitation of Wards shall be completed by 24.02.2026, and thereafter,
30 days’ time has been shown to be taken for determining reservation
roster. In fact, apart from the certain Panchayati Raj Institutions, Nagar
Panchayats, one Municipal Corporation and delimitation of 12 Zila
Parishads, entire exercise has been completed by the State as well as
State Election Commission. Electoral role is also ready for publication
to invite objections and for applications to include the name of left out
voters. Therefore, the exercise to determine the reservation roster in all
other areas, where delimitation is already complete and has not to be
undertaken afresh, respondent-State should carry on exercise of
determination
of
reservation
roster
and
publication
therefor
-41-
2026:HHC:2737
simultaneously. The final re-publication of delimitation is also not to be
made in the entire Himachal Pradesh, but with respect to the above
referred Panchayati Raj Institutions and ULBs and thus, the reservation
roster with respect to such small number of institutions can be
determined in a short period, to say within less than a week, and
therefore, it would be easily possible to publish reservation roster on or
before 28.02.2026.
70.
Similarly, time to be taken by the Election Commission,
about 90 to 140 days, as reflected in Proposal A and B referred supra
is also exaggerated for the same reason, as exercise pending
completion is with respect to small pockets, whereas for the rest of the
State, the said exercise has already been done and the election after
publication of reservation roster can be conducted and completed by
the Election Commission within about eight weeks.
71.
In view of above discussion, State Election Commission,
Panchayati Raj Department, Urban Development Department and
SDMA, are directed sit together, decide together and march together,
harmoniously to act in consonance with constitutional mandate for
reconstitution of Panchayati Raj Institutions and ULBs by completing all
process by the respondent-State’s Departments by 28.02.2026 and
thereafter, conduct of elections within eight weeks thereafter, i.e. or or
before 30.04.2026. In this exercise, State Election Commission,
through State Election Commissioner, shall perform duty of elder
-42-
2026:HHC:2737
brother and all others shall act in aid of Election Commission to conduct
the elections in compliance of aforesaid directions and in consonance
with Constitutional mandate.
72.
The petition is disposed of in above terms, so also the
pending application(s), if any.
(Vivek Singh Thakur)
Judge
9th January, 2026
(Pardeep)
(Romesh Verma)
Judge.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review