Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 23.09.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 29.09.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 29.09.2026
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010458302025
W.P.(C) 10213/2025 & CM APPL. 42602/2025
DHRUV MEDICOS PVT LTD
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Preetam Singh, Adv.
versus
DEPUTY COMMISSIONER, CENTRAL GST CIRCLE 5,
AUDIT-I, DELHI & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Arun Khatri, SSC, Mr.
Mudit Gupta, Sr. Standing
Counsel with Mr. K.V. Bhaskar
Reddy,
Assistant
Commissioner, CGST Delhi
East Commissioner and Mr.
Tribhuwan Yadav, Deputy
Commissioner (CGST Division
Laxmi Nagar) , Ms. Anoushka
Bhalla, Adv. , Mr. Pranavjeet,
Adv for CGST.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE BHARAT PARASHAR
JUDGMENT
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.:
1.
Through the present Writ Petition, the Petitioner assails the
proceedings initiated pursuant to the audit conducted in respect of the
Petitioner under the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017
[hereinafter referred to as „CGST Act‟]. The principal challenge in the
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 10213/2025
14:39:14
present proceedings is to the Demand-cum-Show Cause Notice
bearing No. 137 dated 27.06.2025 [hereinafter referred to as
„Impugned SCN‟], issued under Section 74 of the CGST Act.
2.
The Petitioner has also challenged the Audit Report No.
111/2025-2026 dated 29.04.2025 and has sought, inter alia, a
direction to the Respondents to consider the reply dated 18.06.2025
submitted by the Petitioner to the audit objections. The Petitioner has
further sought a direction that the amount of Rs.40,10,153/- deposited
by it through Form GST DRC-03 on 25.03.2025 be not appropriated,
as according to the Petitioner, the said amount was deposited under
coercion.
FACTUAL MATRIX:
3.
In order to appreciate the controversy involved in the present
Petition, the relevant facts, in brief, are required to be noticed.
4.
The Petitioner is a private limited company stated to be engaged
in the business of distribution of medicines. The audit proceedings in
question commenced with the issuance of a Notice of Audit in Form
GST ADT-01 dated 06.09.2024. The said notice was received by the
Petitioner on 09.09.2024. According to the Petitioner, the audit was
initially stated to cover the period from 01.04.2018 to 31.03.2023.
5.
The Petitioner states that, pursuant to the aforesaid notice,
various documents and information were furnished to the Respondents
between November 2024 and January 2025. Further communications
seeking information were received by the Petitioner on 19.01.2025,
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 10213/2025
14:39:14
26.02.2025 and 15.03.2025, to which the Petitioner claims to have
responded by furnishing the information sought.
6.
Thereafter, an onsite audit was conducted at the premises of the
Petitioner between 20.03.2025 and 25.03.2025. The Petitioner alleges
that, during the course of the onsite audit, the audit team sought to
extend the scope of the audit and also sought information pertaining to
periods beyond those mentioned in the original audit notice.
7.
The principal grievance of the Petitioner arising from the onsite
audit concerns a payment of Rs.40,10,153/- made through Form GST
DRC-03 on 25.03.2025. According to the Petitioner, the said payment
was not voluntary and was made under coercion exercised by the audit
team. The Petitioner states that it had requested that a formal
communication or audit memo setting out the alleged liability and the
basis for the demand be furnished before any payment was made.
According to the Petitioner, despite such request, it was required to
make the aforesaid deposit.
8.
The Petitioner thereafter addressed a communication dated
29.03.2025 to the concerned authorities, specifically raising its
grievance regarding the circumstances in which the aforesaid amount
had been deposited. The Petitioner also stated that the payment ought
not to be treated as a voluntary payment or as an admission of
liability. The Petitioner thereafter claims to have met Respondent No.2
on 04.04.2025 and brought to his notice the alleged coercion as well
as the other grievances concerning the conduct of the audit. According
to the Petitioner, an Audit Memo bearing date 28.03.2025 was
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 10213/2025
14:39:14
thereafter supplied to it on 04.04.2025, both through email and by
post.
9.
The said Audit Memo required the Petitioner to deposit an
amount of Rs.75,41,830/-, besides applicable interest and penalty. The
Petitioner states that the Audit Memo did not contain adequate details
or workings explaining the basis on which the alleged liability had
been computed. The Petitioner accordingly addressed communications
dated 09.04.2025 and 11.04.2025 seeking the basis and workings of
the proposed liability and also raising objections to the manner in
which the audit proceedings had been conducted. The Petitioner states
that a further reminder was submitted on 25.04.2025.
10.
In the meantime, an Audit Report dated 29.04.2025 was issued.
The Petitioner states that the amount of Rs.40,10,153/- which had
already been deposited by it through Form GST DRC-03 was
appropriated. The Petitioner further states that the detailed workings
relied upon for arriving at the alleged liability were furnished to it
only on 14.05.2025. According to the Petitioner, the supply of such
material after issuance of the Audit Report deprived it of an effective
opportunity to respond to the audit objections at the audit stage.
11.
Thereafter, the Respondent issued an intimation in Form GST
DRC-01A dated 02.06.2025, intimating the Petitioner of the proposed
liability and calling upon it to make payment, failing which
proceedings under Section 74 of the CGST Act would be initiated.
The Petitioner submitted a detailed reply dated 18.06.2025. The reply,
according to the Petitioner, comprised detailed submissions against
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 10213/2025
14:39:14
each of the audit objections and was accompanied by supporting
documents. The Petitioner also requested an opportunity of personal
hearing.
12.
In the said reply, the Petitioner disputed, inter alia, the
invocation of Section 74 of the CGST Act, the limitation in respect of
the liability pertaining to Financial Year 2017-18, the manner in which
the audit had been conducted, the alleged appropriation of the amount
deposited on 25.03.2025, and the computation of various components
of the proposed tax liability.
13.
The Petitioner also furnished objection-wise submissions in
respect of the various audit findings. According to the Petitioner,
substantial portions of the proposed demand were either unsustainable
on merits, already discharged, incorrectly computed or otherwise
liable to be excluded. The Petitioner thereafter came to be served with
the Impugned SCN dated 27.06.2025 under Section 74 of the CGST
Act.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PARTIES:
14.
Learned counsel for the Petitioner has primarily relied upon
Rule 101(4) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Rules, 2017
[hereinafter referred to as „CGST Rules‟]. It was submitted that the
said provision requires the proper officer to finalize the findings of the
audit after due consideration of the reply furnished by the registered
person.
15.
It was submitted that the expression “shall” occurring in the
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 10213/2025
14:39:14
aforesaid provision makes it mandatory for the proper officer to
consider the reply furnished by the assessee before finalizing the audit
findings. According to learned counsel, the statutory requirement has
not been complied with in the present case since the detailed reply
submitted by the Petitioner has been dealt with in the Impugned SCN
merely by describing it as “non-satisfactory”.
16.
Learned counsel has also drawn the attention of the Court to the
various objections raised by the Petitioner in its reply, including the
objection concerning limitation in respect of Financial Year 2017-18,
the alleged non-voluntary nature of the payment of Rs.40,10,153/-, the
computation of the proposed liability and the other audit objections.
ANALYSIS & FINDINGS:
17.
This Court has considered the submissions advanced by learned
counsel appearing for the Petitioner and has also examined the nature
of the relief sought in the present proceedings.
18.
At the outset, it is necessary to notice the stage at which the
Petitioner has approached this Court. The audit proceedings have
culminated in an Audit Report dated 29.04.2025. Thereafter, the
Respondents issued Form GST DRC-01A dated 02.06.2025 and, upon
consideration of the matter at that stage, have proceeded to issue the
Impugned SCN dated 27.06.2025 under Section 74 of the CGST Act.
19.
Thus, the statutory adjudicatory proceedings contemplated
under the CGST Act have already been set in motion. The Impugned
SCN calls upon the Petitioner to show cause against the proposed
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 10213/2025
14:39:14
demand. The issuance of a show cause notice, by itself, does not
amount to determination of the liability of the Petitioner. The
allegations and proposals contained therein remain to be adjudicated
upon by the competent authority in accordance with law.
20.
The distinction between an audit proceeding and the subsequent
adjudicatory proceeding is material in the present case. The Audit
Report constitutes the outcome of the audit process. However, once
proceedings under Section 74 of the CGST Act have been initiated by
issuance of a show cause notice, the Petitioner has an opportunity to
place before the adjudicating authority all objections which it seeks to
raise against the proposed demand.
21.
The Petitioner has, in fact, already prepared and placed on
record a detailed response setting out its objections to the audit
findings and the proposed liability. The objections raised by the
Petitioner are not confined to the alleged non-consideration of its
reply. The Petitioner has raised several issues on merits as well as
issues relating to limitation, computation, jurisdiction, the manner of
audit and the treatment of the amount deposited on 25.03.2025.
22.
In the present proceedings, however, this Court is not required
to examine the correctness of each of those objections at this stage.
The question before this Court is whether the issuance of the
Impugned SCN warrants interference merely because the Petitioner
contends that its reply to the audit proceedings was not dealt with
adequately.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 10213/2025
14:39:14
23.
Learned counsel for the Petitioner has specifically relied upon
Rule 101(4) of the CGST Rules and has contended that the use of the
expression “shall” therein makes consideration of the reply furnished
by the registered person mandatory.
24.
There can be no dispute with the proposition that a statutory
requirement which obliges the proper officer to consider the reply
furnished by a registered person is required to be complied with.
Equally, however, the question whether the reply furnished by the
Petitioner has been considered, whether the consideration was
adequate, and what effect is required to be given to the objections
raised by the Petitioner are matters which can appropriately be
examined in the course of the adjudicatory proceedings.
25.
In the present case, it cannot be said, at this stage, that the audit
authorities have wholly ignored the existence of the reply furnished by
the Petitioner. The impugned proceedings specifically refer to the
reply dated 18.06.2025 and record the conclusion that the same was
not satisfactory.
26.
The mere fact that the reply has been dealt with in one sentence
cannot, by itself, result in this Court entering into an adjudication of
the underlying tax liability or quashing the subsequent show cause
notice. Whether the manner in which the reply has been dealt with
satisfies the statutory requirement, and whether the objections raised
by the Petitioner warrant acceptance, rejection or partial acceptance,
are matters which can be examined by the competent Adjudicating
Authority.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 10213/2025
14:39:14
27.
The Petitioner would, therefore, be entitled to place before the
Adjudicating Authority its complete reply and all the objections which
it has raised in the present proceedings. This would include its
objections concerning the audit process, the alleged failure to consider
its reply at the audit stage, the alleged coercion in respect of the
payment of Rs.40,10,153/-, the question of appropriation of the said
amount, the alleged limitation in respect of Financial Year 2017-18,
the computation of the proposed liability, as well as all other
objections which may otherwise be available to the Petitioner in law.
28.
It is clarified that this Court has not examined the merits of any
of the aforesaid objections. No opinion is being expressed as to
whether the payment of Rs.40,10,153/- was voluntary or was made
under coercion. Likewise, this Court has not examined the Petitioner's
contention regarding limitation, the alleged jurisdictional objection to
the audit, the correctness of the computation of the proposed demand,
or the validity of the audit findings. All such issues are left open for
consideration by the competent authority in accordance with law.
29.
The Petitioner shall, therefore, be at liberty to place its
objections before the Adjudicating Authority in response to the
Impugned SCN. The Adjudicating Authority shall consider the
objections raised by the Petitioner independently and in accordance
with law. The fact that the present Court is relegating the Petitioner to
the statutory adjudicatory mechanism shall not be construed as an
expression of opinion by this Court on any of the substantive
objections raised by the Petitioner.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 10213/2025
14:39:14
30.
The Petitioner has also sought a direction concerning the
amount of Rs.40,10,153/- deposited through Form GST DRC-03. The
Petitioner contends that the amount was deposited under coercion and
should not be appropriated. Since the question as to the nature and
legal effect of the said payment is itself one of the issues raised by the
Petitioner in relation to the proposed liability, the same can also be
placed before and considered by the Adjudicating Authority in the
course of the proceedings arising from the Impugned SCN.
31.
At this stage, therefore, this Court does not consider it
appropriate to interdict the statutory adjudicatory process merely
because the Petitioner disputes the manner in which its reply was dealt
with at the preceding audit stage. The appropriate course would be to
permit the statutory authority before whom the Section 74 proceedings
are pending to examine the entire matter, including the objections
raised by the Petitioner.
CONTEMPT PROCEEDINGS:
32.
It is noticed that, during the pendency of the present
proceedings, an allegation was raised regarding violation of an interim
order dated 27.07.2025, pursuant to which notice was issued to
Respondent No.5 requiring his personal appearance and also calling
upon him to show cause as to why contempt proceedings ought not to
be initiated.
33.
Respondent No.5 has submitted his response to the said notice
and has explained that the order dated 24.07.2025 was not within his
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 10213/2025
14:39:14
notice when the notice requiring his personal appearance was issued.
34.
In view of the fact that the Petitioner is being relegated to the
statutory remedy before the Adjudicating Authority and keeping in
view the explanation furnished by Respondent No.5, this Court does
not consider it appropriate to continue the contempt proceedings
arising out of the aforesaid notice.
35.
Consequently, the contempt proceedings are closed.
CONCLUSION:
36.
For the reasons recorded above, no interference is warranted by
this Court at the present stage with the Impugned SCN dated
27.06.2025. The Petitioner shall be at liberty to raise, before the
Adjudicating Authority, all objections available to it in law, including
those raised in the present Writ Petition and in its reply dated
18.06.2025.
37.
It is made clear that the observations contained in the present
judgment are confined to the issue of entertainability of Writ Petition
at the stage of the Impugned SCN. This Court has not expressed any
opinion on the merits of the audit objections, the proposed tax
liability, the question of limitation, the alleged coercion in respect of
the payment made on 25.03.2025, the appropriation thereof, or any
other substantive objection raised by the Petitioner. All such issues are
left open for consideration by the competent authority in accordance
with law.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 10213/2025
14:39:14
38.
The Adjudicating Authority shall consider the objections raised
by the Petitioner in accordance with law and independently on their
own merits.
39.
With the aforesaid observations, the present Writ Petition, along
with the pending application, is disposed of.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
BHARAT PARSHAR, J.
SEPTEMBER 29, 2026
sp/pal
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 10213/2025
14:39:14
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review