The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. Accordingly, the petition is being disposed of requiring the court below, before whom the execution proceedings are pending, to mobilize and to conclude the same and to give it a logical conclusion without granting unnecessary adjournments with most expedition and, in case, adjournments are granted then the same should not be beyond the 5 days at a stretch. In case, anything survives or the occasion so arises, it shall be open for the petitioner to again approach this Court. October 6, 2026 Neeraj (Vikas Budhwar,J.) High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
MATTERS UNDER ARTICLE 227 No. - 13991 of 2026
Dhk Eduserve Limited
.....Petitioner(s)
Versus
Ganga Prasad Memorial Trust And Another
.....Respondent(s)
Counsel for Petitioner(s)
Counsel for Respondent(s)
:
:
Tejas Singh
Court No. - 53
HON'BLE VIKAS BUDHWAR, J.
1. Heard Mr. Tejas Singh, learned counsel for the Decree Holder/Petitioner
and learned counsel for the respondents.
2. The case of the Decree Holder/Petitioner is that it happens to be a
Company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956. Owing to certain
dispute and differences, so arose between the parties, pursuant to agreement
dated 10.12.2018, the matter was referred to arbitration and an award came
to be passed on 07.12.2025 by the Arbitrator in an Arbitration Case No.110
of 2023 (DHK Eduserve Limited Vs. Ganga Prasad Memorial Trust and
another).
3. The Judgment Debtor/Respondents challenged the award dated
07.12.2025 by filing an application under Section 34 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, which was numbered as Miscellaneous Case No.15 of
2026. The Decree Holder also filed an Arbitration Execution Application
No.02 of 2026 ((DHK Eduserve Limited Vs. Ganga Prasad Memorial Trust
and another)). The Judgment Debtor / Respondent filed a petition /
application under Section 34 of the Act, questioning the award dated
07.12.2025 that however on 25.02.2026, the Presiding Officer, Commercial
Court, Varanasi allowed the amendment application (41 ka) fixing the date
27.05.2026 for hearing on petition under Section 34 of the 1996 Act. The
same was challenged by the decree holder while filing matter under Article
227 No.7838 of 2026 in which an interim order came to be passed on
29.05.2026.
4. Thereafter, on 23.06.2026 in Arbitration Case No 2 of 2026, the
A227 No. 13991 of 2026
application No. 25 (Ga) of the Judgment Debtor/Respondent came to be
rejected which was subject matter of challenge in Matters under Article 227
No.9725 of 2026 which came to be disposed of on 24.07.2026.
5. Again on 31.07.2026 another order came to be passed by Commercial
Court, Varanasi in Arbitration Case No.15 of 2026 (New Case No.5 of 2026)
under Section 34 of the Act which was subject matter of challenge at the
instance of the Decree Holder/Petitioner in Matters under Article 227 No.
10752 of 2026, which came to be allowed on 10.08.2026. Apart from the
same, the report of the Munsrim dated 27.08.2026 was also subject matter of
challenge at the behest of the Judgment Debtor/Petitioner being Matters
under Article 227 No. 12972 of 2026 in which interim order came to be
passed on 18.09.2026 and so far as the order dated 21.08.2026 is concerned,
the same was also challenged by the petitioner herein in the matters under
Article 227 No. 12102 of 2026 in which interim order came to be passed on
21.08.2026.
6. The present petition has been preferred with a direction to the Commercial
Court, Varanasi to decide the Arbitration Case No.2 of 2026(DHK Eduserve
Limited Vs. Ganga Prasad Memorial Trust and another). Reliance has also
been placed upon the judgments of the Hon'ble Apex Court in Chopra
Fabricators & Manufacturers (P) Ltd. V. Bharat Pupms &
Compressors Ltd.; 2023 SCC 534 and in M/s. Paramount Propbuild Pvt
Ltd Vs. Uttar Pradesh State Industrial Development Authority And Another
so as to contend that the execution petitions are to be decided expeditiously
without granting unnecessary adjournments.
7. I have heard the submission so made across the bar and perused the
record.
8. Plainly and simply the grievance of the Judgment Debtor/Decree
Holder/Petitioner is that the execution petition is pending and it has not been
given a logical end which ought to have been given a logical end.
9". In Chopra Fabricators & Manufacturers (P) Ltd. v. Bharat Pumps
& Compressors Ltd.; 2023 (3) SCC 534, the following was observed as
under:
"1. This is a glaring example of frustrating the arbitration proceedings under the
Arbitration Act. The Award has been passed in the year 1992 and the execution
A227 No. 13991 of 2026
petition is of the year 2003, which is still reported to be pending.
2. It is very unfortunate that even after a period of 30 years, the party in whose favour
the Award is passed is not in a position to enjoy the fruit of the litigation/Award. Even
the execution petition is also pending for more than 19 years.
3. This is a very sorry state of affairs that even the execution proceedings to execute
the Award passed under the Arbitration Act are pending for more than 20 years. If the
Award, under the Arbitration Act, is not executed at the earliest, it will frustrate the
purpose and object of the Arbitration Act as well as the Commercial Courts Act. Even
as per the new Commercial Courts Act, 2015 the commercial dispute is required to be
decided and disposed of at the earliest and within the stipulated time provided under
the Act, namely, one year. There must be number of such proceedings pending in the
courts under the jurisdiction of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad.
4. We direct the Registrar General of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad and
the Lucknow Bench to place on record (i) how many execution petitions to execute the
Award both under the Arbitration Act, 1940 and under the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 are pending in the subordinate courts/executing courts in the
entire State; (ii) how many Section 34 applications are pending in the entire State and
from which year and (iii) how many Section 37 applications are pending before the
High Court and from which year.
5. The aforesaid information in the form of a detailed report shall be placed before
this Court on or before the next date of hearing.
6. Put up on 28.04.2022 on top of the Board.
7. Insofar as the present case is concerned, considering the fact that the Award which
is sought to be executed is of the year 1992 and the execution proceedings are pending
since 2003, we direct the executing court to finally decide and dispose of the execution
petition within a period of four weeks from the date of receipt of the present order."
10. Further in Periyammal (Dead) Through Lrs& Ors V. V. Rajamani &
Anr.Etc.; 2025 INSC 329, the Hon'ble Apex Court observed as under:
"73. It is worthwhile to revisit the observations in Rahul S. Shah (supra) wherein this
Court has provided guidelines and directions for conduct of execution proceedings.
The relevant portion of the said judgment is reproduced below:
"42. All courts dealing with suits and execution proceedings shall mandatorily follow
the below mentioned directions:
42.1. In suits relating to delivery of possession, the court must examine the parties to
the suit under Order 10 in relation to third-party interest and further exercise the
power under Order 11 Rule 14 asking parties to disclose and produce documents,
A227 No. 13991 of 2026
upon oath, which are in possession of the parties including declaration pertaining to
third-party interest in such properties.
42.2. In appropriate cases, where the possession is not in dispute and not a question
of fact for adjudication before the court, the court may appoint Commissioner to
assess the accurate description and status of the property.
42.3. After examination of parties under Order 10 or production of documents under
Order 11 or receipt of Commission report, the court must add all necessary or proper
parties to the suit, so as to avoid multiplicity of proceedings and also make such
joinder of cause of action in the same suit.
42.4. Under Order 40 Rule 1 CPC, a Court Receiver can be appointed to monitor the
status of the property in question as custodia legis for proper adjudication of the
matter.
42.5. The court must, before passing the decree, pertaining to delivery of possession of
a property ensure that the decree is unambiguous so as to not only contain clear
description of the property but also having regard to the status of the property.
42.6. In a money suit, the court must invariably resort to Order 21 Rule 11, ensuring
immediate execution of decree for payment of money on oral application.
42.7. In a suit for payment of money, before settlement of issues, the defendant may be
required to disclose his assets on oath, to the extent that he is being made liable in a
suit. The court may further, at any stage, in appropriate cases during the pendency of
suit, using powers under Section 151 CPC, demand security to ensure satisfaction of
any decree.
42.8. The court exercising jurisdiction under Section 47 or under Order 21 CPC, must
not issue notice on an application of third party claiming rights in a mechanical
manner. Further, the court should refrain from entertaining any such application(s)
that has already been considered by the court while adjudicating the suit or which
raises any such issue which otherwise could have been raised and determined during
adjudication of suit if due diligence was exercised by the applicant.
42.9. The court should allow taking of evidence during the execution proceedings only
in exceptional and rare cases where the question of fact could not be decided by
resorting to any other expeditious method like appointment of Commissioner or
calling for electronic materials including photographs or video with affidavits.
42.10. The court must in appropriate cases where it finds the objection or resistance
or claim to be frivolous or mala fide, resort to sub-rule (2) of Rule 98 of Order 21 as
well as grant compensatory costs in accordance with Section 35-A. 42.11. Under
Section 60 CPC the term "? in name of the judgment-debtor or by another person in
trust for him or on his behalf" should be read liberally to incorporate any other
A227 No. 13991 of 2026
person from whom he may have the ability to derive share, profit or property.
42.12. The executing court must dispose of the execution proceedings within six
months from the date of filing, which may be extended only by recording reasons in
writing for such delay.
42.13. The executing court may on satisfaction of the fact that it is not possible to
execute the decree without police assistance, direct the police station concerned to
provide police assistance to such officials who are working towards execution of the
decree. Further, in case an offence against the public servant while discharging his
duties is brought to the knowledge of the court, the same must be dealt with stringently
in accordance with law.
42.14. The Judicial Academies must prepare manuals and ensure continuous training
through appropriate mediums to the court personnel/staff executing the warrants,
carrying out attachment and sale and any other official duties for executing orders
issued by the executing courts." (Emphasis supplied)
74. The mandatory direction contained in Para 42.12 of Rahul S. Shah (supra)
requiring the execution proceedings to be completed within six months from the date
of filing, has been reiterated by this Court in its order in Bhoj Raj Garg v. Goyal
Education and Welfare Society & Ors., Special Leave Petition (C) Nos. 19654 of
2022.
75. In view of the aforesaid, we direct all the High Courts across the country to call
for the necessary information from their respective district judiciary as regards
pendency of the execution petitions. Once the data is collected by each of the High
Courts, the High Courts shall thereafter proceed to issue an administrative order or
circular, directing their respective district judiciary to ensure that the execution
petitions pending in various courts shall be decided and disposed of within a period of
six months without fail otherwise the concerned presiding officer would be answerable
to the High Court on its administrative side. Once the entire data along with the
figures of pendency and disposal thereafter, is collected by all the High Courts, the
same shall be forwarded to the Registry of this Court with individual reports.
76. Registry is directed to forward one copy each of this judgment to all the High
Courts at the earliest.
77. The Registry shall notify this matter once again after seven months only for the
purpose of reporting compliance of the directions issued by us referred to above."
11. In the opinion of Court, once an execution petition / application has been
filed before a competent Court and there is no legal impediment then the
same should be given a logical end without granting unnecessary
adjournments so as to ensure confidence and to uphold the majesty of the
A227 No. 13991 of 2026
Court, particularly, when once the orders are in favour of a particular party
but the same is not given its logical conclusion and the party in whose favour
the orders have been passed, is deprived of the fruits then the said partakes
the character of erosion of justice.
12. Accordingly, the petition is being disposed of requiring the court below,
before whom the execution proceedings are pending, to mobilize and to
conclude the same and to give it a logical conclusion without granting
unnecessary adjournments with most expedition and, in case, adjournments
are granted then the same should not be beyond the 5 days at a stretch. In
case, anything survives or the occasion so arises, it shall be open for the
petitioner to again approach this Court.
October 6, 2026
Neeraj
(Vikas Budhwar,J.)
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review