Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of reserve: 09th February, 2026
Date of decision: 16th July, 2026
IN THE MATTER OF:
+
CRL.A. 1320/2011
JAGDISH CHANDER
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Jatin Rajput, Mr. Rajesh Kumar
Jha, Mr. Varun Panwar, Mr. Sandeep
Kumar, Mr. Rajendra Pratap Singh
& Mr. Gaurav Sharma, Advs.
versus
STATE
+
.....Respondent
Through:
Mr. Yudhvir Singh Chauhan, APP
for State with SI Naresh Kumar, PS
Anti Corruption Branch.
DHARAMVIR SINGH
Through:
.....Appellant
Bhardwaj, Adv.
CRL.A. 1339/2011
Mr. Ashutosh
(through VC).
versus
STATE GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI
Through:
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
.....Respondent
Mr. Yudhvir Singh Chauhan, APP
for State with SI Naresh Kumar, PS
Anti Corruption Branch.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIMAL KUMAR YADAV
JUDGMENT
VIMAL KUMAR YADAV, J.
1.
The
present
appeals
bearing
number
Crl.A.1339/2011
and
Crl.A.1320/2011 being off-shoot of the common judgment dated 08th
September 2011 (hereinafter referred to as „impugned judgment‟) where the
Appellants were held guilty, convicted and sentenced through order dated
12.09.2011 are hereby disposed of through the instant judgment.
2.
The Appellants were held guilty and convicted and sentenced as
detailed hereunder:S. No.
1.
Name of convict(s) Sentence awarded
Convict Jagdish Chander was sentenced to
Jagdish Chander, S/o undergo Rigorous Imprisonment („RI‟) for a
Sh. Ram Swaroop
period of 8 months and fine of Rs.2,500/(Rupees Two Thousand Five Hundred only)
under Section 7 of Prevention of Corruption
Act, 1988 and in default of payment of fine,
convict was further directed to undergo SI for a
period of three months.
Convict Jagdish Chander was further sentenced
to undergo Rigorous Imprisonment („RI‟) for a
period of 1 year and fine of Rs.2,500/- (Rupees
Two Thousand Five Hundred only) under
Section 13(i)(d) punishable under Section
13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act,
1988 and in default of payment of fine, he was
further
directed
to
undergo
Simple
Imprisonment („SI‟) for a period of three
months.
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
2.
Convict Dharamvir Singh was sentenced to
Dharamvir Singh S/o undergo Rigorous Imprisonment („RI‟) for a
Sh. Jogi Ram
period of 8 months and fine of Rs.2,500/(Rupees Two Thousand Five Hundred only)
U/s 7 of Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988
and in default of payment of fine, convict was
further
directed
to
undergo
Simple
Imprisonment („SI‟) for a period of three
months.
Convict Dharamvir Singh was further
sentenced to undergo Rigorous Imprisonment
(„RI‟) for a period of 1 year and fine of
Rs.2,500/- (Rupees Two Thousand Five
Hundred only) under Section 13(i)(d)
punishable Under Section 13 (2) of the
Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and in
default of payment of fine, convict was further
directed to undergo Simple Imprisonment
(„SI‟) for a period of three months.
3.
The indispensable facts of the case are required to be looked into
before proceeding further, which are as below. On receipt of an information
by the Anti-Corruption Branch of Delhi known as “source information” in
the parlance of anti-corruption agencies, with regard to some malpractices
being done at the Toll Tax Barrier on the Delhi-Haryana Border known as
„Singhu Border” on the G.T. Karnal Road ACB got activated. It was
reported that the staff posted at the Toll Tax Barrier were allowing certain
commercial vehicles to cross the border from the side of Haryana into
Delhi without charging the toll tax payable. A raiding party was thus,
constituted at the Anti-Corruption Branch and raid was carried out. The
source information was confirmed inasmuch as certain drivers of the
commercial vehicles were stopped after the Toll Tax Barrier, in order to
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
check the receipt of toll tax. It was found that some of the vehicles did not
have the toll tax receipts despite the fact that they have already crossed the
toll tax barrier. On this confirmed information, thereafter the raiding party
consisting of Anil Kumar, Pradeep Joy, Ram Dayal, Inspector O.P. Arora,
swooped down to the toll tax barrier where the present two Appellants were
found manning it. The three drivers of the commercial vehicles namely
Abdul Haq driving truck bearing registration number DL-1GB-0503,
another driver driving tempo bearing registration number HR-38-3827 and
one Bahadur Singh transporting a consignment of vegetables in vehicle
bearing registration number HR 06 GA-0225, who all were intercepted and
checked by the raiding party, were also joined in the raid. The statements of
aforesaid three drivers were taken into account and raid conducted at the
Toll Tax, which resulted into recovery of money from Jagdish Chander and
Dharamvir, the Appellants herein.
4.
The requisites of the investigation were carried out which culminated
into a chargesheet. A formal charge was framed against the Appellants
under section 7, 13 (i) (d) and 13(2) Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.
5.
On the strength of 16 witnesses examined, the Anti-Corruption
Branch was able to bring home the case against both the Appellants
inasmuch as the defence put forth by the Appellants and the explanations
furnished by them in their respective statements under Section 313 Cr.P.C.
failed to absolve them of their criminal liability. Thus, through the
impugned judgment and order on sentence as referred above, both the
Appellants were sentenced as noted earlier.
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
6.
The impugned judgment came under challenge by both the
Appellants on the ground that they have been falsely implicated in this case
and that the evidence led on record is not sufficient enough to hold the
Appellants guilty, especially when two out of three independent public
witnesses i.e. drivers who could be and have been treated as „independent
witnesses‟ have turned hostile so-much-so that PW-4 Anil Kumar has
completely erased the case and went to the extent of saying that there was
no Toll Tax Barrier at the border, to pay toll tax to anyone. Apparently, he is
not truthful or that he was used to using the alternative route by passing the
Toll Tax Barrier; a reference of which has come in his deposition.
7.
The learned counsel for the Appellants has assailed the impugned
judgment primarily on three counts that two out of three most vital
independent witnesses have not supported the case at all as the aspect of the
existence of the Toll Tax barrier itself has been put under cloud. No proper
identification of the Appellants/officials manning the barrier is there and
the recovery of money or bribe money is not above board and that there is
no corroborative scientific or technical evidence. As such, the prosecution
has failed to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt in establishing the
crucial aspects of demand and acceptance in the case in hand.
8.
It is argued that the prosecution has failed to establish the
foundational requirement of demand of illegal gratification, which is sine
qua non for conviction under the Prevention of Corruption Act. It is
submitted that the case is not based on a trap, rather it was a post-facto raid.
There is no independent or reliable evidence of prior demand or
acceptance. The alleged demand rests solely on the testimonies of
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
witnesses, which are riddled with inconsistencies. It has been submitted
that the very involvement of the appellants in the current case is
questionable due to the reason that their identification itself is shrouded in
doubt and uncertainty. PW-2 Bahadur Singh who had clearly deposed
about interacting with the appellants to the extent of paying them ₹10 for
passing through the Toll Counter, but when asked to identify the
Appellants, he could not do so properly. The element of certainty and
confidence was amiss. During his Examination-in-Chief, when asked to
identify the accused, he has stated that the person standing at the toll tax
barrier was “similar to the accused persons” and “may be the same” as the
appellants herein.
9.
PW-7 Ram Dayal who had joined as one of the panch witnesses in
the raid, had stated, in both his Examination-in-Chief and Cross
Examination, that none of the complainants/drivers were able to confirm,
let alone identify either of the accused as the officials who were working at
the toll counter and had collected money from the drivers.
10.
The learned counsel for Appellants has placed heavy reliance on
PW-4 Anil Kumar, who has completely turned hostile and has denied the
prosecution‟s case in toto, so much so that he has categorically deposed in
his Examination-in-Chief that there was no Toll Tax barrier on the route
and as such there was no occasion or reason to pay, nor did he pay any
amount to any person. He alleged that his signatures were obtained on
some papers by ACB personnel forcibly. He stuck to his guns even in his
cross-examination as well, wherein he reaffirms his deposition made during
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
the examination-in-chief. The relevant part of his Examination-in-Chief is
reproduced hereunder:
“ I do not remember the exact date however it was 5-6 years back
I was coming to Delhi in my tempo number HR-38-3827 I was
coming from Kondali. There was no toll tax on the way to Delhi.
Officials of AC Branch met me at Tikari. They enquired from me
if I had paid toll tax I told them since there was no barrier on the
way I had not paid toll tax to anyone. The officials of AC Branch
got my signatures forcibly on some papers.”
PW-4 Anil Kumar has thus, attempted to blast off the very
foundation of the case and in a way has tried to take away the genesis itself.
11.
It has been further argued by the learned counsel for the Appellants
that this deposition by PW-4 Anil Kumar, who was among the three people
who did not have the toll receipts despite crossing the toll counter/border,
completely demolishes the prosecution‟s version regarding one of the key
transactions i.e. the demand of illegal money. PW-7 Sh. Ram Dayal has
also expressed his ignorance regarding the amount allegedly recovered by
the Raiding party. In his cross-examination, he once again confirmed that
the drivers could not identify the appellants as the officials present at the
toll counter. He has reaffirmed his earlier deposition of being unaware of
the amount that was recovered by the Raiding Party.
12.
Learned counsel for the appellants has submitted that such
statements made on key and material aspects, strikes at the root of the
prosecution‟s case regarding identification and recovery.
13.
The learned counsel for the Appellants has further drawn attention to
the contradictions in the prosecution‟s case concerning the aspect of
recovery, which according to him further dents the prosecution‟s version. It
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
is submitted that as per the prosecution, the alleged illegal gratification
consisted of Rs. 50/- purportedly paid by the complainant Abdul Haq (PW15) to accused Jagdish Chander and Rs. 10/- each allegedly paid by the
other drivers to accused Dharamvir Singh. However, the recovery affected
during the raid is wholly inconsistent with this version, inasmuch as only
Rs. 30/- was recovered from accused Jagdish Chander and Rs. 120/- from
accused Dharamvir Singh could not be reconciled. There is no cogent
explanation on record as to how the specific amounts allegedly paid by the
drivers are reflected in the amounts recovered, nor is there any evidence to
show segregation or identification of the alleged bribed currency notes
from any other currency notes that may have been in possession of the
accused persons in the ordinary course of their duties/life. The learned
counsel for the appellants has further submitted that the impugned
judgment itself records a clear inconsistency between the alleged demand
and the recovery, yet fails to address or explain the same. While the
prosecution‟s case, as noted in the judgment, is that Rs. 50/- and Rs. 10/each were allegedly demanded and accepted, whereas the recovery
recorded is Rs. 30/- from accused Jagdish Chander and Rs. 120/- from
accused Dharamvir Singh. The learned Trial Court has nonetheless treated
such recovery as corroborative of demand and acceptance, without
establishing any linkage between the amounts allegedly paid and those
recovered. The absence of any reasoning on this crucial aspect, despite it
being apparent on the face of the record, renders the finding on recovery
incompatible to the record, incomplete and unreliable. Albeit, it cannot be
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
ruled out that the Appellants must be having some money belonging to
them, but other possibilities cannot be ruled out either.
14.
It has been further argued by the learned counsel for the Appellants
that the impugned judgment, while appreciating the evidence of various
prosecution witnesses, has failed to reconcile material inconsistencies
arising from that very record it relies upon. It has been further submitted by
the learned counsel for the Appellants that the impugned judgment, on one
hand, notices that PW-2 Bahadur Singh was uncertain in his identification
and that PW-7 Ram Dayal did not support the prosecution on the aspect of
identification and recovery, yet proceeds to hold that identity of both
accused persons stands conclusively established. Further, no reasons have
been assigned as to how an equivocal identification (“similar” and “may be
the same”) made by PW-2 and a complete lack of identification by PW-4
could together satisfy the standard of proof beyond reasonable doubt. This
selective reliance, without proper reconciliation of contradictions noted in
the judgment itself, vitiates the finding on identity.
15.
It has also been contended that the impugned judgment fails to
properly appreciate the effect of hostile and non-supporting witnesses,
despite recording their testimony. The judgment notes that PW-4 Anil
Kumar turned hostile and denied the prosecution‟s case, and that PW-7 did
not support the prosecution on material particulars.
16.
The learned Trial Court, as such, has neither analysed the evidentiary
value of these testimonies nor indicated which portions, if any, were being
relied upon. There is no discussion as to why the exculpatory portions of
such testimony were discarded.
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
17.
It has also been argued that the impugned judgment proceeds on an
erroneous legal approach by invoking the presumption under Section 20 of
the Prevention of Corruption Act without first recording a clear and
independent finding on the proof of demand. The judgment states that the
prosecution succeeds once it is shown that the public servant has accepted
some money which is not legal remuneration, and thereafter, shifts the
burden upon the accused. It has been however argued by the learned
counsel for the appellants that the impugned judgment does not separately
analyse whether demand, as a foundational legal requirement, stands
proved beyond reasonable doubt, especially in light of the inconsistencies
evident in the testimonies of PW-2, PW-4 and PW-7. This approach, as
reflected from the reasoning in the judgment itself, results in a premature
shifting of burden and affects the legality of the conclusion reached.
18.
Lastly, it has been submitted that the impugned judgment arrives at
the conclusion of guilt without adequately dealing with the Appellant‟s
version. The Appellant‟s plea that they had not demanded or accepted any
illegal gratification and had been falsely implicated has, though been noted
in the judgment but, the same has been rejected summarily without any
substantive analysis. The judgment does not examine whether the
deficiencies and inconsistencies in the prosecution evidence, as recorded
within it, lend any support to the appellant‟s version or create a reasonable
doubt. The conclusion that the prosecution has proved its case beyond
reasonable doubt is, thus, not supported by a comprehensive evaluation of
the material on record. In view of the above, it has been vehemently argued
by the learned counsel for the appellants that the prosecution has failed to
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
prove demand and acceptance beyond reasonable doubt, and the benefit of
doubt must, therefore, necessarily be extended to the accused persons.
19.
Per contra, it has been argued by the prosecution that the essential
ingredients of the offences under Sections 7 and 13 of the Prevention of
Corruption Act, stand duly established through consistent ocular and
recovery evidence. It is submitted that the complainant Sh. Abdul Haq
(PW-15) has categorically deposed that accused Jagdish Chander
demanded and accepted a sum of Rs. 50/- from him and deliberately
refrained from issuing any toll tax receipt. His testimony further establishes
that upon being stopped by the Anti-Corruption Branch, he immediately
disclosed the said fact and subsequently identified both accused persons at
the Toll Tax Barrier. The said testimony, reproduced hereunder, as per the
prosecution is clear, direct and inspires confidence as regards demand and
acceptance.
“when I reached Singhu border at toll tax counter, two persons
were standing there and one of them stopped me by danda and
another came to me and demanded Rs. 50/. Accused Dharam Vir
(witness pointed out towards this accused) was holding danda.
Both the persons present in the court today, correctly identified
are the same persons who stopped me and demanded rs. 50/-. I
gave Rs. 50/- to accused Jagdish Chander (witness pointed out
towards this accused) as I asked for the receipt for that amount
but accused Jagdish told me that there was no need for the receipt
and he asked me to go. Thereafter I entered Delhi”
20.
Learned APP for the state further relies upon the testimony of
Pradeep Joy examined as PW-6 (Panch Witness) and Inspector O.P. Arora
examined as PW-16 (Raid Officer), who have corroborated the version of
the complainant on all material particulars. Both PW-6 and PW-16 have
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
consistently deposed that upon reaching the Toll Tax Barrier, the accused
persons were identified by the drivers as the individuals who had taken
money without issuing receipts, and upon search, an amount of Rs. 30/was recovered from accused Jagdish Chander and Rs. 120/- from accused
Dharamvir Singh. The prosecution relied upon the testimonies of PW-6 and
PW-7 in order to establish that the recovery of money from the accused
persons and that too immediately after their identification by the two
witnesses, which constitutes a strong incriminating circumstance. It is
further argued that the testimony of PW-2 Bahadur Singh, though partially
resiling when asked to personally confirm the identity of Jagdish, but still
supports the prosecution‟s case to the extent that, despite being unsure
about the exact amount that was recovered, he admitted recovery of the
tainted money from the accused persons. In his cross-examination, he
corroborates the identification of accused Jagdish Chander by driver Abdul
Haq and of accused Dharamvir by driver Anil Kumar. On this aspect it has
been submitted by the learned APP that even a hostile witness does not
efface the evidentiary value of the portion of testimony which supports the
prosecution and corroborated by other evidence. The prosecution also
places reliance on the testimony of PW-3 (Panch Witness Anil Kumar),
who has affirmed that the accused persons were identified by the drivers
and that cash was recovered from their possession pursuant to the raid. The
recovery memos Ex. PW3/A and PW3/B stand duly proved and thereby
lending credibility to the recovery proceedings and in turn to the case of the
prosecution.
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
21.
It is submitted that once acceptance of money other than legal
remuneration is established, the statutory presumption under Section 20 of
the Prevention of Corruption Act arises against the accused persons. The
accused have failed to furnish any plausible explanation for the possession
of the recovered money. Mere denial in statements under Section 313
Cr.P.C. is insufficient to rebut the statutory presumption.
22.
The prosecution further contends that minor discrepancies, such as
variation in exact denominations due to lapse of memory and passage of
time, do not go to the root of the case. The core base, namely demand,
acceptance, and recovery, stands proved beyond reasonable doubt.
Accordingly, it is urged that both accused persons have been rightly
convicted and the appeals are, therefore, liable to be dismissed.
23.
It has been further submitted by the prosecution, that the legal
framework governing the offence under Section 7 of the Prevention of
Corruption Act has been correctly identified and applied by the learned
Trial Court, and that once the said framework is juxtaposed with the factual
matrix on record, the culpability of the accused persons stands established.
The learned Trial Court, in paras 19 and 20 of the judgment, has delineated
the essential ingredients of the offence, namely, that the accused must be a
public servant and that he must have accepted or obtained gratification
other than legal remuneration in the discharge of his official functions, the
relevant paras of which are reproduced hereunder:
“19. Before an offence is held to fall under Section 7 of the Prevention
of Corruption Act, 1988, the following requirements are required to
be satisfied:
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
1. The accused at the time of an offence was or accepted
to be a public servant.
2. That he accepted or obtained, or agreed to accept, or
attempted to obtain from some person a gratification;
3. That such gratification was not a legal remuneration
due to him and that he accepted the gratification in
question as a motive or reward for;
a) Doing or forbearing to do official act;
b) Showing or forbearing to show favour or disfavour
to someone in exercise of his official functions;
c) Rendering or attempting to render, any service or
dis-service to someone.
20. Thus all that the prosecution has to establish is that the accused
was a public servant and that he had obtained illegal gratification or
showing or forbearing to show in exercise of the official functions
favour or disfavour”
24.
Building upon this formulation, the prosecution contends that the
requirement is not of proving something abstract, but rather of
demonstrating, on the basis of evidence, that the money received by the
accused was not sanctioned by law and was obtained in connection with the
official duties. It is submitted that both accused persons have been shown,
through official records namely Ex. PW-5/D which is the Attendance
Register for the dates 01.03.2002 to 03.05.2002 along with Ex. PW-5/X-4
and Ex. PW-5/X-5, which are the service records (Bio-data) of the
Appellants, which show the appellants to be functioning at the Toll Tax
Barrier in their capacity as public servants. The deposition of PW-15,
supported by other witnesses, establishes that money was, in fact, received
by the Appellants in the course of such duty. According to the prosecution,
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
once these two elements co-exist i.e. a) status as a public servant and b)
receipt of money not legally due, then the offence stands attracted, and the
Trial Court has rightly proceeded on this legal proposition.
25.
It has also been contended that the impugned judgment rightly draws
an inference from the conduct of the accused persons in permitting the
vehicles to cross the toll barrier without following due procedure, and that
such conduct constitutes an abuse of official position for illicit gains within
the meaning of the statute. The prosecution submits that the role of the
accused persons, at the toll tax barrier, was integrally connected with
regulating the passage of vehicles upon payment of lawful toll, and that any
deviation from this process, particularly when the money is charged but no
receipt is issued, amounts to showing undue favour in the exercise of
official functions for personal monetary gains. Learned Trial Court has
rightly rejected the plea that the vehicles may have been using alternate
routes to bypass the toll barrier or that the accused had no role in that. A
finding has been recorded that the complainant was allowed to pass through
the barrier on the “responsibility” of the accused without issuance of
receipt. The prosecution argues that this finding is significant, as it
establishes a direct nexus between the money received and the official act
performed, namely, allowing passage of the vehicle. Such a nexus,
according to the prosecution, is sufficient to bring the act within the ambit
of corrupt conduct, as it demonstrates that the accused persons acted in a
manner inconsistent with their official duties and conferred an undue
benefit upon the drivers in exchange for money which went into their
pockets.
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
26.
Having considered rival submissions and on perusal of the record, it
appears that the prosecution has been to some extent able to establish the
essential ingredients of the offences under Sections 7 and 13 of the
Prevention of Corruption Act, particularly the foundational requirements of
demand, acceptance and recovery, and the reasoning adopted in the
impugned judgment cannot be faulted.
27.
At the outset, the contention advanced by the learned counsel for the
appellants that the prosecution has failed to establish demand of illegal
gratification, requires careful evaluation. The prosecution primarily relies
upon the testimony of Abdul Haq (PW-15), who has categorically deposed
regarding demand of Rs. 50/- by accused Jagdish Chander and the role of
accused Dharamvir at the spot who both were acting in tandem with each
other. This testimony, if taken in isolation, does satisfy the requirement of
direct evidence of demand to an extent. However, the evidentiary weight of
such testimony must be tested against the surrounding circumstances and
other prosecution evidence. It is evident from the record that Anil Kumar
(PW-4) has completely denied the prosecution‟s case and Bahadur Singh
(PW-2), on the other hand, has expressed uncertainty in identification of
the accused/appellants, while Ram Dayal (PW-7) has not supported the
prosecution on identification at all. Thus, while demand is asserted through
PW-15, the corroborative structure expected in a non-trap case appears to
have a setback and gets weakened. The question, therefore, is not whether
who and how demand and recovery have been reposed, but whether it is
proved beyond reasonable doubt in light of inconsistencies, which assumes
significance in corruption cases. It has been held in State of Lokayuktha
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
police, Davanagere v. C.B. Nagaraj 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1175, relevant
portion of which has been reproduced hereunder:
“the observation of the High Court to this extent is correct that
just because money changed hands, in cases like the present, it
cannot be ipso facto presumed that the same as pursuant to a
demand, for the law requires that for conviction under the Act,
an entire chain- beginning from demand, acceptance and
recovery has to be completed”
28.
On the aspect of identification of the accused persons, the
prosecution has placed their reliance upon the identification by PW-15 who
in his Examination-in-Chief, clearly identified the appellants as the two
persons who were operating/ present at the toll counter and in his cross
examination he went a step further in confirmation by stating that the
appellants were present at the toll counter at the time of the incident. The
relevant part of PW-15‟s cross examination is reproduced hereunder:
“I was alone in the truck and there was no helper. Sometime I
used to pass through that toll tax both the accused persons were
standing on the front side towards the driver side. At the time,
only both these two accused persons were present and no other
person was present again said the two persons were sitting inside
the booth and these two accused were standing near the toll tax. I
did not complaint to those two persons sitting in the booth
regarding non issuing of receipt as I was not knowing about that.
I am driver for the last 12 years. I had earlier paid the amount at
other toll tax booth and obtained the receipts and also from this
toll tax booth. The accused persons were standing out from the
booth and they asked for money and I paid them and at that time
nobody was present.”
29.
To this effect the deposition of PW-15 has been supported by the
versions deposed by Pradeep Joy (PW-6) who had confirmed in both his
examination-in-chief and his cross-examination that the drivers had
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
identified the appellants as well. Inspector O.P. Arora (PW-16) who also
deposed about the identification of the appellants by the drivers at the toll
tax counter. However, the learned counsel for the Appellants has rightly
pointed out that PW-2, a material witness, was unable to confidently
identify the accused and described them only as “similar” and “may be the
same”, whereas PW-7 did not support identification as he had stated in his
cross-examination, as reproduced hereunder:
“it is incorrect to suggest that the drivers identified the accused
Jagdish and Dharambir as to be the officials who had not given
toll tax receipts despite taking the bribe of Rs. 50/- and Rs 10/each”
30.
The impugned judgment nevertheless concludes that identity stands
proved. From an adjudicatory standpoint, identification must inspire
confidence and be free from doubt, particularly where conviction is sought
to be based on oral testimony.
31.
On the aspect of identification, the prosecution relies upon a
combination of documentary proof regarding duty and the testimonies of
various witnesses. The record shows that Sh. K.S. Sharma, examined as
PW-9 (posted as Assistant Commissioner of Toll Tax department, MCD at
the time of the offence) has produced the service record (bio-data) of
Jagdish Chander which has been brought on record as Ex PW-5/X-4 and
Ex PW 5/X-5 and PW-11 has also deposed positively towards the fact that
accused Dharamvir posted as a Toll tax peon at the Singhu Border on the
date of the offence, which can be seen in his examination-in-chief, relevant
portion of which has been reproduced hereunder:
“On 3-5-2002 I was posted as Administrative Officer in Toll
tax Narela Zone MCD, Delhi and on that day I was present in
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
my office. I directed accused Dharambir present in court today
who was posted as Toll Tax Peon at the Singhu Boarder to call
the Sh. Anand Singh, TTI with the Attendance Register and
accordingly, he came to my office with the said register.”
32.
These pieces of evidence, put together provide some positive
corroboration towards establishing the fact that the accused were posted at
the toll tax barrier/counter at the relevant time. The service record (bio
data) provided by PW-9 satisfies the requirement of the accused‟s status as
public servants and their presence at the Toll Tax Barrier/Counter in an
official capacity. However, it must be clarified that such evidence is limited
to proving presence and official capacity on the conjoint reading of
evidence to the extent of proving that the accused were the very persons
who were stationed and thus, possibly engaged in the act of demanding or
accepting illegal gratification from the drivers. It is an established principle
that the proof of status or presence cannot be elevated to proof of
culpability in an offence under the Prevention of Corruption Act. The
identification of the accused as the perpetrators of the alleged act must be
independently established through reliable and consistent evidence. In the
present case, the evidentiary position on identification, albeit, is not
uniform but if considered in its entirety then fortifies against the appellants.
The complainant Sh. Abdul Haq (PW-15) has identified the accused
persons and attributed specific roles to them, however, this version is not
corroborated by all the material witnesses. PW-2 Bahadur Singh, though
claiming to have interacted at the toll barrier, expressed uncertainty in
identifying the accused thereby introducing some element of uncertainty in
the identification. PW-7 Ram Dayal, who was part of the raiding process,
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
does not support the prosecution on the aspect of identification and has
stated that the drivers did not identify the officials at the toll barrier as the
persons who had taken money from them. This directly weakens the
prosecution‟s case on a core aspect. Further, the testimonies of PW-3
(panch witness), PW-6 (panch witness), and PW-16 (Raid Officer) do not
constitute independent identification of the accused in the act of demand or
acceptance. Their evidence is essentially derivative in nature as they do not
claim to have witnessed the original transaction, nor do they provide any
direct account of the accused demanding or accepting money. Their role is
confined to the events subsequent to interception and the process of
recovery. Thus, their testimonies cannot cure the deficiencies arising from
the inconsistent or weak identification by the primary witnesses. However,
the official records are significant to the limited extent of establishing the
posting, designation, and official presence of the accused at the toll tax
barrier on the relevant date. Such records are essentially administrative in
nature and while they may corroborate the accused‟s official capacity and
deployment at the spot, they cannot, by themselves, bridge the evidentiary
gap in establishing the identity of the persons who allegedly engaged in the
incriminating conduct complained of by the prosecution witnesses.
33.
In such circumstances, the evidence relating to identification remains
fractured and seems to lack the kind of certainty and consistency required
in criminal proceedings. While the presence of the accused at the Toll Tax
Barrier is established through PW-9 and PW-11, the crucial link connecting
them to the alleged act of illegal gratification does not seem to be
conclusively proved. The mere fact of posting or presence at the site, under
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
law, cannot bridge this evidentiary gap or substitute the requirement of
clear and cogent identification of the accused as the perpetrators of the
alleged offence.
34.
In view of the above, the aspect of identification cannot be assessed
in isolation by discarding the entirety of the prosecution evidence merely
on account of certain inconsistencies. The complainant (PW-15) has
positively and unequivocally identified both accused persons and attributed
specific roles to them in the alleged transaction. His testimony, therefore,
constitutes direct and ocular evidence on the point of identity. PW-2, while
not giving a firm identification, has not denied the presence of the accused,
his description that the person present was “similar” or “may be the same”
reflects a somewhat qualified identification. This hesitation, when viewed
in context, is not devoid of explanation, as the incident pertains to the year
2002 whereas his Examination-in-Chief was conducted in 2008, after a
lapse of approximately six years. It is a matter of common human
experience that memory, particularly with respect to facial recognition
arising out of brief and isolated interactions, is susceptible to fading over
time. Such passage of time, therefore, reasonably accounts for the lack of
precision in his identification, without rendering his testimony wholly
unreliable. Further, the evidence of PW-6 and PW-16 indicates that upon
being taken back to the toll barrier, the drivers identified the accused
persons as those who had taken money without issuing receipts. Though
this form of identification is not independent in the strict sense and is
derivative of what was pointed out by the drivers, it nonetheless lends a
measure of corroboration to the version of PW-15 regarding the presence
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
and role of the accused at the relevant point of time. At the same time, the
absence of clear and unequivocal identification by PW-2 and the lack of
support from PW-7 cannot be ignored, as they introduce an element of
uncertainty which the Court is bound to consider. Accordingly, the
identification evidence presents a mixed evidentiary picture. On one hand,
there is positive identification by PW-15, supported to a limited extent by
the surrounding circumstances. The testimony of other witnesses, on the
other hand, contains hesitation and inconsistency and lack of support. The
position that emerges is that identification is corroborated to the extent that
it must be weighed along with the other evidence on record, particularly on
the aspects of demand, acceptance, and recovery, before arriving at a final
conclusion on guilt.
35.
On the issue of recovery, the prosecution has relied upon the
testimonies of PW-3, PW-6 and PW-16 to establish that Rs. 30/- and Rs.
120/- were recovered from the accused persons. There is no dispute that
recovery has been proved in a formal sense through seizure memos (Ex.
PW-3/A and Ex. PW-3/B) and supporting witnesses. However, the ld
counsel for the appellants has highlighted a material inconsistency between
the amounts allegedly paid (Rs. 50/- and Rs. 10/- each) and the amounts
recovered. This discrepancy is evident on record and is also noticed in the
impugned judgment. From a legal standpoint, recovery assumes evidentiary
significance only when it can be linked to the alleged demand and
acceptance. In the absence of such linkage, recovery by itself is not
sufficient to sustain conviction. The learned Trial Court has treated
recovery as corroborative without addressing this inconsistency or
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
establishing a nexus, which weakens the evidentiary value of recovery as a
circumstance proving guilt.
36.
Insofar as the aspect of recovery is concerned, it stands established
on record that certain amounts, namely ₹30/- from one accused and ₹120/from the other, were recovered in the presence of PW-3, PW-6 and PW-16
and duly seized through memos. To that extent, the factum of recovery is
not in dispute. However, the evidentiary value of such recovery must be
assessed not in isolation, but in conjunction with its nexus to the alleged
demand and acceptance. The prosecution‟s case, as reflected in the record,
is that a total amount of ₹70/- (₹50/- from PW-15 and ₹10/- each from the
other drivers) was allegedly demanded and paid. The recovery of ₹120/from one of the accused and ₹30/- from the other (which is about double
the amount allegedly paid to the accused) does not, on the face of it,
correspond to the prosecution version. This discrepancy is not merely
arithmetic but goes to the root of whether the recovered amounts can be
treated as the same money allegedly paid by the drivers. It could have been
argued on behalf of the appellants, that the mismatch between the alleged
payments and the amounts recovered weakens the inference that the
recovered money represents illegal gratification received in the course of
the alleged transaction. In the absence of any segregation or identification
of the specific amounts allegedly paid, the possibility that the recovered
sums formed part of money already in possession of the accused in the
ordinary course of their duties cannot be excluded. This assumes greater
significance in the present case, which is not a pre-arranged trap but a postfacto raid. There were no pre-raid formalities such as marking or recording
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
the numbers of currency notes, no application of phenolphthalein powder,
and no contemporaneous mechanism to trace the movement of specific
currency from the complainants to the accused. Further, apart from the oral
assertions of PW-15 and PW-2 that the amounts paid by them were taken
by the accused, there is no independent evidentiary material linking the
recovered currency to those alleged payments. In the absence of such
linkage, recovery remains a neutral fact-consistent both with the
prosecution case and with the possibility of lawful or unrelated possession.
As recovery by itself cannot substitute proof of demand and acceptance,
nor can it sustain a conviction unless it forms part of a complete and
reliable evidentiary chain. In the present case, the Trial Court has treated
recovery as corroborative without adequately addressing the inconsistency
in amounts or establishing a clear nexus between the recovered sums and
the alleged illegal gratification. Accordingly, while the recovery is formally
proved, its probative value as an incriminating circumstance is substantially
diminished. The discrepancy in amounts, the absence of pre-raid
safeguards, and the lack of identifiable linkage between the recovered
money and the alleged transaction introduce a reasonable doubt as to
whether the recovery can be treated as evidence of illegal gratification. In
such circumstances, recovery cannot be relied upon as a decisive factor in
establishing the guilt of the accused.
37.
Another side of the coin is that the complainant dodged the barrier or
by passed it from some other route and on being caught he spun this tale.
He is apparently lying as Toll Tax barrier was there as can be seen from the
evidence of Sh. R.M. Bajaj (PW-11) who was posted as Administrative
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
Officer in Toll Tax Narela Zone MCD who not only says about the
existence of Toll Barrier but deposed about the Appellants being deputed
there. It is a matter of common knowledge that state borders have Toll
Barriers. The place in question is the border between Haryana and Delhi, so
it can be concluded that PW-4 was lying and the barrier was there.
38.
The testimony of PW-4, who has been declared hostile, assumes
considerable significance in the overall evidentiary assessment of the
prosecution case. It is settled law that the evidence of a hostile witness is
not to be rejected in total and may be relied upon to the extent it finds
corroboration from other material on record. In the present case in hand,
PW-4 has not merely resiled on peripheral aspects, but has gone to the root
of the prosecution story by denying the very existence of the toll tax
counter, disputing any payment of money, and further alleging that his
signatures were obtained forcibly by the Anti-Corruption Branch officials.
Such a version, if not accepted in its entirety, nevertheless introduces a
serious element of doubt with respect to the manner in which the alleged
transactions were recorded and documented during the raid proceedings.
He is apparently lying as Toll tax Barrier was there. The prosecution case
rests upon three alleged instances of illegal collection of money and the
complete disowning of one such transaction by a material witness
effectively weakens the continuity and uniformity of the prosecution
narrative. The learned Trial Court, though noticing that PW-4 had turned
hostile, has not undertaken any analysis as to the evidentiary impact of such
hostility on the prosecution‟s case as a whole. In a case dependent upon
multiple interlinked factual assertions forming a chain of circumstances,
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
the failure to examine how the collapse of one link affects the integrity of
the entire chain, renders the appreciation of evidence incomplete. The
absence of any reasoning as to why the testimony of PW-4 was either
partially relied upon or wholly discarded, and how the remaining evidence
compensates for this deficiency, creates a lacuna in the evaluation of
evidence as a whole.
39.
At the same time, the specific assertions made by PW-4 in his
deposition, particularly his claim that there was no toll tax barrier on the
route and that he had not paid any amount to any person, require to be
tested on the touchstone of probability, surrounding circumstances, and the
entirety of the evidence on record. The route in question is a principal entry
corridor into Delhi, where toll tax collection is ordinarily effected through
designated barriers situated on major roadways. Prima facie, it would
appear improbable that a regular or habitual user of such a route would
neither encounter a toll tax barrier nor be aware of its existence. However,
this improbability must be balanced against the material emerging from the
cross-examination of PW-2, who has stated that there exists a by-pass route
passing through Singhu, which diverges prior to the Toll Tax Counter and
rejoins the main G.T. Road at a point before the location where the AntiCorruption Branch officials were intercepting vehicles and certainly after
the Toll Tax Barrier. The same can be seen on an examination of the site
plan that is on record as Ex. PW-5/A. This disclosure assumes significance
as it introduces a plausible alternative route which could, in theory, enable
a driver to avoid the toll barrier altogether. The relevant portion of PW-2‟s
Cross-Examination is reproduced hereunder:
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
“It is correct that there is a bye-pass passes through the Singhu
Village which started prior to the Toll Tax Counter/ Barrier and
ousted on the main GT Road prior to the place where AC Branch
Officials were stopping the vehicles. It is incorrect to suggest that
number of drivers take that route to avoid the payment of toll tax.
I do not know if any such vehicles pass through that way. I do not
know how much penalty is imposed for not paying the toll tax”
40.
To that extent, the absolute improbability of PW-4‟s version is
diluted, inasmuch as the existence of such a by-pass renders it possible,
though not necessarily probable, that a driver may not encounter the toll
counter on a given occasion. However, the mere existence of an alternate
route does not, by itself, lend complete credibility to PW-4‟s assertion. His
deposition goes further to deny not only the transaction but even the
existence of the toll barrier, without offering any explanation as to why he
chose such a route, whether he habitually used it, or whether it offered any
advantage in terms of distance, time, or accessibility. The absence of any
such explanation renders his version incomplete and lacking in contextual
support. Moreover, PW-2 himself, despite acknowledging the existence of
the by-pass, has deposed that he did encounter the Toll Tax Barrier, paid the
demanded amount, and was not issued a receipt.
41.
Similarly, PW-15 has also deposed about the existence of the toll
barrier and the interaction with the accused at that location. Thus, the
evidence on record presents a situation where, notwithstanding the
theoretical availability of an alternate route, two witnesses who were also
users of the same corridor have affirmed the existence of the toll
infrastructure and the occurrence of the transaction at that point. In
contrast, PW-4‟s version stands isolated in its complete denial of both the
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
barrier and the transaction. In these circumstances, while the testimony of
PW-4 cannot be discarded out rightly and it does introduce an element of
inconsistency in the prosecution‟s case, its evidentiary weight must be
assessed in the light of its internal limitations and lack of explanatory
support. The existence of the by-pass prevents treating his version as
inherently impossible. However, the absence of any cogent reason for his
alleged use of such route, coupled with the consistent version of other
witnesses regarding the toll barrier, diminishes its value as a reliable
rebuttal. His testimony, therefore, operates not as a conclusive negation of
the prosecution case, but as a factor requiring cautious evaluation of the
overall evidence, without displacing the core version emerging from PW15 and PW-2.
42.
On the aspect of statutory presumption under Section 20, the
prosecution has contended that once acceptance of money other than legal
remuneration is shown, the burden shifts upon the accused. The impugned
judgment adopts this reasoning. However, it is settled that such
presumption arises only after the prosecution establishes foundational facts,
including demand and acceptance. In the present case at hand, while
acceptance is sought to be inferred from recovery and testimony of PW-15,
the inconsistencies in identification, hostile witness testimony, and
mismatch in recovery amounts create doubt as to whether these
foundational facts have been firmly established.
43.
The learned counsel for the Appellant‟s contention that the impugned
judgment fails to properly consider their version, also merits consideration.
Their version is the denial of demand and acceptance by the appellants and
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
the suggestion of false implication by the complainants. The impugned
judgment has rejected the defence without detailed analysis of whether the
inconsistencies in prosecution evidence lend support to the possibility of
false implication. While mere denial is insufficient, the law requires that
where the prosecution evidence itself contains inconsistencies, the
appellant‟s version need not be independently proved but only needs to
raise a reasonable doubt. In Vibhav v. State of Maharashtra, 2025 8 SCC
315, it was held as reproduced below:
“31. In law, there is a significant difference in the evidentiary
burden to be discharged by the prosecution and the accused.
Whereas, the former is expected to discharge its burden beyond
reasonable doubt, the latter is only required to prove a defence on
the anvil of preponderance of probabilities. If the accused leads
defence evidence in the course of a criminal trial, the same ought
to be tested as probable or improbable in the facts and
circumstances of the case.”
44.
In totality of the facts and circumstances, the present case hinges
upon whether the prosecution evidence, taken as a whole, inspires
confidence and establishes guilt beyond reasonable doubt. While there is
evidence in support of demand, acceptance and recovery, the same is
accompanied by material inconsistencies relating to identification, recovery
linkage, and supporting witnesses. The reasoning in the impugned
judgment does not fully reconcile these aspects. Therefore, each of these
elements must be carefully weighed to determine whether the threshold of
proof required in criminal law stands satisfied.
45.
It would also be worth noting that the case at hand originates from
what is described as “source information,” which, as per the record, was
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
neither reduced into a detailed written form nor subjected to any
demonstrable prior verification. The Raid Officer (PW-16) has deposed
only in general terms that information was received to the effect that toll
staff were collecting money without issuing receipts. It is conceivable that
such source information may have been based on prior complaints, general
inputs, or past patterns of conduct. However, no such underlying material
has been brought on record. There is no indication of the precise contents
of the information, the identity or credibility of the source, or any
contemporaneous record reflecting the same. Equally, there is no evidence
of any preliminary inquiry or verification having been undertaken to test
the veracity of the „source information‟ before proceeding with the raid.
The relevant part of the Raid Officer Inspector O.P. Arora‟s (PW-16)
Cross-Examination is reproduced hereunder:
“we received the information in the morning at about 9:30 AM.
That information was not reduced into writing”
46.
In the absence of such foundational material, the source information
remains confined to a broad and unparticularized allegation, incapable of
lending substantive support to the prosecution case. As elucidated in
Neeraj Dutta v. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi), 2023 4 SCC 731, while a
prosecution under the Prevention of Corruption Act is not rendered invalid
merely because it is not preceded by a formal complaint or a pre-arranged
trap, the burden upon the prosecution correspondingly intensifies. It must
then establish, through cogent and reliable evidence, the essential
ingredients of demand and acceptance either by direct proof or by a
complete and unbroken chain of circumstantial evidence.
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
47.
In the present case, the source information serves only as a triggering
mechanism for the raid and does not assume the character of evidence
capable of corroborating the prosecution‟s version. The absence of any
documented, specific, or verifiable basis at the inception stage assumes
significance when the entire prosecution case is built upon a post-facto
reconstruction of events based on statements of intercepted drivers. In such
a scenario, where the origin of the case itself lacks demonstrable
substantiation on record, the Court is required to scrutinize the subsequent
evidence with heightened care and caution. The lack of clarity and details
surrounding the source information thus constitutes a relevant factor in
assessing whether the prosecution has been able to establish its case beyond
reasonable doubt.
48.
Upon careful examination of the evidence on record and the facts of
the case, can a conclusive view be drawn that the prosecution has
succeeded in establishing the foundational facts of demand and acceptance
of illegal gratification in a manner that satisfies the threshold of proof
required under law? The testimony of PW-15 (Abdul Haq) assumes central
importance in this regard. His deposition is clear, specific and consistent on
all material particulars, that he was stopped at the Toll Tax counter, that a
sum of ₹50/- was demanded from him by one of the accused, that the
amount was paid, and that no receipt was issued despite request. His
version is not only direct evidence of demand and acceptance but also
carries inherent credibility, as it is based on his immediate personal
interaction with the accused at the relevant time and place. There is nothing
on record to suggest any motive for false implication, nor has any material
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
contradiction been elicited in his cross-examination which would discredit
his testimony on these core aspects. This version of PW-15 does not
receive material corroboration from other witnesses. PW-2 (Bahadur
Singh), who has, in his examination-in-chief, deposed to a substantially
similar transaction involving demand of ₹10/-, payment thereof, and nonissuance of receipt, but falters on the aspect of identity. The significance of
this corroboration lies not merely in repetition, but in its independent
origin. Both PW-15 and PW-2 are separate drivers, with seemingly no prior
connection or familiarity with one another, and their depositions converge
on the essential features of the occurrence i.e. demand of money at the toll
barrier, acceptance by the personnel present, and absence of any official
receipt. Such convergence of independent testimonies on material
particulars lends a high degree of assurance to the prosecution‟s case and
reduces the likelihood of fabrication or coincidence. It also reflects a
pattern of conduct rather than an isolated or accidental incident, thereby
strengthening the inference that the amounts were not collected as lawful
toll but as unauthorized gratification. However, despite this evidence, the
aspect of identity not fortified in the testimony of PW-2 Bahadur Singh and
complete turn around by PW-4 Anil Kumar.
49.
The contention that PW-2‟s testimony is weakened by his hesitation
on identification does not materially affect the evidentiary value of his
deposition on demand and acceptance. His uncertainty pertains to facial
identification after a lapse of approximately six years between the incident
(2002) and his deposition (2008), a factor which is judicially recognized as
capable of affecting memory, particularly in cases involving brief and sole
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
interaction with stranger. Such hesitation does not amount to a
contradiction of the occurrence itself. On the contrary, PW-2 has
consistently maintained that money was demanded from him, paid, and no
receipt was issued. Therefore, his testimony, when confined to these
aspects, remains reliable and corroborative. The law does not require
perfect recollection or photographic memory; it requires that the testimony,
read as a whole, inspires confidence on material facts, which in the present
case it does to some extent. It was held in Balu Sudam Khalde & Anr. v.
State of Maharashtra, (2023) 13 SCC 365 as reproduced hereunder:
“25. The appreciation of ocular evidence is a hard task.
There is no fixed or strait jacket formula for appreciation of
the ocular evidence. The judicially evolved principles for
appreciation of ocular evidence in a criminal case can be
enumerated as under:
“I. While appreciating the evidence of a witness, the
approach must be whether the evidence of the witness read as
a whole appears to have a ring of truth. Once that impression
is formed, it is undoubtedly necessary for the Court to
scrutinise the evidence more particularly keeping in view the
deficiencies, drawbacks and infirmities pointed out in the
evidence as a whole and evaluate them to find out whether it
is against the general tenor of the evidence given by the
witness and whether the earlier evaluation of the evidence is
shaken as to render it unworthy of belief.
II. If the court before whom the witness gives evidence
had the opportunity to form the opinion about the general
tenor of evidence given by the witness, the appellate court
which had not this benefit will have to attach due weight to
the appreciation of evidence by the trial court and unless
there are reasons weighty and formidable it would not be
proper to reject the evidence on the ground of minor
variations or infirmities in the matter of trivial details.
III. When eyewitness is examined at length it is quite
possible for him to make some discrepancies. But courts
should bear in mind that it is only when discrepancies in the
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
evidence of a witness are so incompatible with the credibility
of his version that the court is justified in jettisoning his
evidence.
IV. Minor discrepancies on trivial matters not touching
the core of the case, hypertechnical approach by taking
sentences torn out of context here or there from the evidence,
attaching importance to some technical error committed by
the investigating officer not going to the root of the matter
would not ordinarily permit rejection of the evidence as a
whole.
V. Too serious a view to be adopted on mere variations
falling in the narration of an incident (either as between the
evidence of two witnesses or as between two statements of the
same witness) is an unrealistic approach for judicial scrutiny.
VI. By and large a witness cannot be expected to possess a
photographic memory and to recall the details of an incident.
It is not as if a video tape is replayed on the mental screen.
VII. Ordinarily it so happens that a witness is overtaken
by events. The witness could not have anticipated the
occurrence which so often has an element of surprise. The
mental faculties therefore cannot be expected to be attuned to
absorb the details.
VIII. The powers of observation differ from person to
person. What one may notice, another may not. An object or
movement might emboss its image on one person's mind
whereas it might go unnoticed on the part of another.
IX. By and large people cannot accurately recall a
conversation and reproduce the very words used by them or
heard by them. They can only recall the main purport of the
conversation. It is unrealistic to expect a witness to be a
human tape recorder.
X. In regard to exact time of an incident, or the time
duration of an occurrence, usually, people make their
estimates by guesswork on the spur of the moment at the time
of interrogation. And one cannot expect people to make very
precise or reliable estimates in such matters. Again, it
depends on the time-sense of individuals which varies from
person to person.
XI. Ordinarily a witness cannot be expected to recall
accurately the sequence of events which take place in rapid
succession or in a short time span. A witness is liable to get
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
confused, or mixed up when interrogated later on.
XII. A witness, though wholly truthful, is liable to be
overawed by the court atmosphere and the piercing crossexamination by counsel and out of nervousness mix up facts,
get confused regarding sequence of events, or fill up details
from imagination on the spur of the moment. The
subconscious mind of the witness sometimes so operates on
account of the fear of looking foolish or being disbelieved
though the witness is giving a truthful and honest account of
the occurrence witnessed by him.
XIII. A former statement though seemingly inconsistent
with the evidence need not necessarily be sufficient to amount
to contradiction. Unless the former statement has the potency
to discredit the later statement, even if the later statement is
at variance with the former to some extent it would not be
helpful to contradict that witness.”
50.
The hostility of PW-4 and the limited support from PW-7 must also
be assessed in their proper legal context. It is well settled that the testimony
of a hostile witness is not to be discarded in its entirety and that the
prosecution case does not fail merely because some witnesses do not
support it. Evidence brought on record may be examined and relied upon,
subject to those portions being credible and consistent with the overall
prosecution narrative. In the present case, even if PW-4‟s denial is taken at
face value, it only affects one of the alleged transactions and does not
undermine the consistent and corroborated accounts of PW-15 and PW-2.
Similarly, PW-7‟s lack of support on certain aspects such as the number of
drivers that accompanied the raiding party to the toll counter/ gate, the
amount that was recovered and whether the drivers were able to positively
identify the accused; do not negate the direct evidence of demand and
acceptance given by the primary witnesses. Criminal adjudication does not
proceed on a rule of numerical sufficiency but on the quality and reliability
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
of evidence. Where the core substratum of the prosecution case is
supported by credible and consistent testimony, the absence of uniform
corroboration from every witness is not fatal. In Vadivelu Thevar and anr
v State of Madras, AIR 1957 SC 614, it was held as under:
16. “It is not necessary specifically to notice the other
decisions of the different High Courts in India, in which the
court insisted or corroboration of the testimony of a single
witness, not as a proposition of law, but in view of the
circumstances of those cases. On a consideration of the
relevant authorities and the provisions of the Evidence Act,
following propositions maybe safely started as firmly
established:
16.1 As a general rule, a court can and may act on the testimony of
a single witness, not uncorroborated. One credible witness
outweighs the testimony of a number of other witnesses of
indifferent character.
16.2 Unless corroboration is insisted upon by statute, courts
should not insist on corroboration except in cases where the
nature of the testimony of the single witness itself requires as
a rule of prudence, that corroboration should be insisted
upon, for example in the case of a child witness, or of a
witness whose evidence is that of an accomplice or of an
analogous character.
16.3 Whether corroboration of the testimony of a single witness is
or is not necessary, must depend upon facts and
circumstances of each case and no general rule can be laid
down in a matter like this and much depends upon the judicial
discretion of the Judge before whom the case comes.”
51.
Further, the surrounding circumstances reinforce the prosecution
version. The interception of vehicles shortly after crossing the toll barrier
without receipts, the immediate disclosure by the drivers that money had
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
been paid, and their consistent narration upon being taken back to the toll
counter, to some extent, provide contextual support to the direct evidence
of demand and acceptance. These circumstances, though not independently
sufficient, may operate cumulatively with the ocular testimony to form a
coherent chain of events in the current case. In light of the above, the
prosecution has not merely raised a suspicion or probability, but has
somewhat established through direct and corroborated evidence that money
was demanded and accepted without issuance of receipt, and that such
collection was not part of lawful remuneration. The essential requirement
of proving demand and acceptance, as mandated under Sections 7 and 13 of
the Prevention of Corruption Act, thus stands satisfied on the face of it.
However, the aspect of identity being not certain puts a spanner in
the free flowing wheels of evidence. It has come in evidence that two more
people were present on the Toll Tax barrier, sitting in a cabin there. Who
were these persons? Is it not possible that those two persons were the actual
culprits, that is why PW-2 is unsure about the identity of the Appellants.
The testimony of PW-9 may be taken in consideration on this count, as was
noted earlier, which talks about Appellant Dharamvir being posted at
Singhu Border as Toll Tax Peon.
52.
A crucial aspect of the prosecution‟s case requires to be looked into
with greater scrutiny, that is, whether the two accused/Appellants, Jagdish
Chander and Dharamvir Singh, were in fact posted at the Singhu Border
Toll Tax Barrier on the date of the incident and whether or not it was
within the scope of their official duties to collect toll tax from commercial
vehicles and issue receipts for the same. In order to ascertain this issue, it is
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
required to examine the evidence led by the prosecution through PW-8 O.P.
Tomar (Executive Engineer), PW-9 K.S. Sharma (Assistant Commissioner,
Toll Tax Department, MCD), and PW-10 Anand Singh (Retired Head
Clerk/TTI), along with the documentary record produced by them.
53.
PW-8 O.P. Tomar has merely deposed that he supplied the service
records (bio-data) of accused Dharamvir Singh to the Investigating Officer.
Beyond producing the said record, his testimony does not throw any light
upon the exact place of posting of either of the appellants on the date of the
incident, nor does it establish the nature of their duties at the relevant Toll
Tax Barrier. Similarly, PW-9 K.S. Sharma has deposed only to the extent
that he forwarded the service records (bio-data) of Jagdish Chander and
Dharamvir Singh to the Investigating Officer vide forwarding letters Ex.
PW-9/A and Ex. PW-9/B. His testimony is equally silent pertaining to the
actual presence of the appellants at the Singhu Border Toll Tax Barrier on
03.05.2002. PW-10 Anand Singh has stated that on 03.05.2002 he was
working as TTI in the Toll Tax Department and that accused Dharamvir
Singh had informed him that he had been called by the Administrative
Officer. However, the significance of his testimony is confined only to the
furnishing of the attendance register for the dates 01.03.2002 to 03.05.2002
(Ex. PW-5/E). A careful examination of the said attendance register does
not conclusively establish the presence of either of the appellants at the
Toll Tax Barrier on the date of the alleged incident. Insofar as Jagdish
Chander is concerned, the register reflects an entry which appears to have
been written and then subsequently struck off at one place, and lightly
erased at another, the indentations of which remain visible, thus, creating
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
uncertainty regarding the authenticity and reliability of the entry itself.
Insofar as Dharamvir Singh is concerned, no clear entry reflecting his
presence on the relevant date is discernible from the attendance register. On
the contrary, the register contains consistent entries of several other
employees whose attendance appears regularly recorded on multiple dates.
The absence of similarly clear entries pertaining to the appellants assumes
significance and renders the attendance record inconclusive on the issue of
their presence at the Toll Tax Barrier on 03.05.2002. The quarterly
transfer/posting order dated 29.04.2002 indicates that both the appellants
were posted within the Narela Zone. However, such posting order merely
establishes their broader area of deployment and does not specifically
demonstrate that they were posted at the Singhu Border Toll Tax Barrier
itself on the date of the incident.
54.
A perusal of the service records (bio-data) brought on record reveals
that Jagdish Chander was working as a regular Beldar and was posted at
G.T. Road T.T. Post and his duties were limited to checking toll tax
receipts of commercial vehicles and diverting commercial vehicles towards
the Toll Tax Barrier for the payment of toll tax. Dharamvir Singh on the
other hand, was working as a daily-rated Beldar and his duties primarily
consisted of performing indoor work or performing the duties of Toll Tax
Peons who happened to be on leave. Whether a daily rated Beldar is a
public servant in strict sense of the word. Significantly, neither of the
service records indicates that either appellant was authorised or entrusted
with the collection of toll tax from vehicles or with the issuance of toll tax
receipts. In the absence of any such material which places the appellants at
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
the toll tax border when the raid was conducted puts a question mark and it
would be unsafe to presume that the appellants were exercising powers i.e.
collecting the toll tax money and issuance of toll tax receipts.
55.
Cumulatively, the evidence led by the prosecution leaves the issue of
the Appellant‟s actual deployment at the Toll Tax Barrier on the relevant
date shrouded in uncertainty. The documentary evidence does not
conclusively establish their presence at the Toll Tax Barrier, while the
service records themselves indicate that the duties assigned to them did not
encompass the collection of toll tax or issuance of receipts. Apart from
PW-15 Abdul Haq, whose testimony stands as the solitary unequivocal
identification of the appellants, the remaining evidence on identification is
far from satisfactory. PW-2 Bahadur Singh remained uncertain and was
only able to describe the accused as being “similar” or “may be the same”,
whereas PW-7 Ram Dayal did not support the prosecution on the aspect of
identification at all. In such circumstances, a serious doubt arises as to
whether the Appellants were, in fact, the persons who demanded and
accepted the alleged illegal gratification. Such doubt strikes at the very
foundation of the prosecution‟s case and must necessarily operate to the
benefit of the appellants. It becomes all the more relevant when it is
reflected in evidence that two more persons were sitting in the Toll Booth,
who were those persons is anybody‟s guess. However, one thing is certain
that a „Beldar‟/Toll Tax Peon cannot be entrusted with the responsibility of
issuing Toll Tax Receipt. There must be and seemingly there were more
responsible officials entrusted with the job of issuance of Toll Tax
Receipts, who were present there.
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
The ACB seems to have acted in haste as they straightaway took
action on the source information in a casual manner. The ACB should have
verified the source information and a more structured and systematic raid
should have been carried out where demand and acceptance can be
ascertained with the involvement of panch witness/ raiding officials at the
time when such demand was actually made and illegal gratification was
accepted instead of acting post facto. This inherent weakness ultimately
manifested itself in a weak case.
As such, in view of the discussion in the foregoing paragraphs, it
emerges that the evidence on record about the complicity of the Appellants
is weak and not convincing enough. Their identity is also shrouded in the
mist of doubt on account of the shaky testimony of the prime witnesses that
is the drivers, except one Abdul Haq. Then again an alternative route has
been shown to exist through which the Toll Tax Barrier can be bypassed. In
such circumstances, another dimension of doubt and suspicion seeps in the
case of prosecution that those drivers who were found without Toll Tax
Receipt by the ACB team, could have used that alternative route and when
they found themselves caught by ACB team, they cooked up a story to save
their skin. It can be visualised that the drivers when stopped had all the
reasons to become apprehensive that some action would be initiated against
them, so they blamed the Toll Tax Staff, that is, the Appellants, who
incidentally were not empowered to issue tax receipts, though could have
collected the money and let go of the drivers. In that eventuality, where was
the responsible officials of the Toll Tax Barrier, what they were doing and
what kind of supervision and control was there? A Toll Tax Barrier on a
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
State border cannot be left at the mercy of Toll Tax Peon/daily-rated Beldar
without any supervision so as to give them a free hand to do whatever they
liked. The Senior Officers should have been examined on these aspects. In
view of these facts and circumstances and taking into account the case in
it‟s entirely, it is unsafe to hold the Appellants guilty. As a result, they are
given the benefit of doubt and acquitted. Their appeals accordingly, stand
allowed.
Bail bonds stand discharged and pending application(s), if any, stand
disposed off together with the appeals.
VIMAL KUMAR YADAV, J.
JULY 16, 2026/bj/ps/ij
Crl.A. 1320/2011 & Crl.A.1339/2011
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
13:02:07
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review