Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CRM-M-73084-2025 (O&M)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
CRM-M-73084-2025 (O&M)
Dharam Singh Chhoker
….Petitioner
Versus
Directorate of Enforcement
….Respondent
The date when the judgment is reserved
23.02.2026
The date when the judgment is pronounced
08.04.2026
The date when the judgment is uploaded on the website
08.04.2026
Whether only operative part of the judgment is pronounced
or whether the full judgment is pronounced
Full
The delay, if any, of the pronouncement of full judgment, Not Applicable
and reasons thereof
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TRIBHUVAN DAHIYA
Present:
Mr. Vikram Chaudhri, Senior Advocate, with
Ms. Hargun Sandhu, Advocate, and
Mr. Rishab Tewari, Advocate, for the petitioner.
Mr. Zoheb Hossain, Special Counsel,
(through video conferencing), with
Mr. Lokesh Narang, Senior Panel Counsel,
Mr. Kaushlendra Vikram, Advocate,
Ms. Shubhleen Dhariwal, Advocate,
Mr. Rajeev, Advocate, and
Mr. Lehar Saraf, Advocate, for the respondent-ED.
TRIBHUVAN DAHIYA, J.
The petition has been filed seeking regular bail to the petitioner
in prosecution complaint No.COMA 09 of 2024, dated 27.06.2024, and
MANINDER
2026.04.08 10:14
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
CRM-M-73084-2025 (O&M)
supplementary prosecution complaint No.COMA 12 of 2025, dated
01.07.2025, in ECIR/GNZO/20/2021 dated 16.11.2021, for commission of
offence under Section 3, punishable under Section 4 of the Prevention of
Money Laundering Act, 2002 (for short, ‘the PMLA’), arising out of
scheduled/predicate offence in case FIR No.0011, dated 14.01.2021,
registered under Sections 120-B, 406, 420, 467, 468 and 471 IPC at Police
Station Sushant Lok, Gurugram.
2.
As per allegations in the FIR, M/s Sai Aaina Farms Pvt. Ltd.
(SAFPL), presently known as M/s Mahira Infratech Pvt. Ltd., is controlled by
the Chhoker family, led by petitioner Dharam Singh Chhoker and his sons
Sikander Singh and Vikas Chhoker. The companies of Chhoker family are
known by the name of Mahira Group. SAFPL is one of the several companies
under the Mahira Group. It undertook the project of building flats at Sector
68, Gurugram, under the affordable group housing project and applied for
relevant license/permission to the Department of Town and Country Planning
(DTCP), which issued license no.106/2017 to it in 2017 based on the
documents/bank guarantees provided. The license was to build around 1500
flats in about ten acres of land; the project was to be completed by 2021-22.
After obtaining license, the SAFPL started the bookings and collected around
₹363 crores from 1500 home buyers. Despite receiving substantial part of
payments from the home buyers, the construction work remained too slow to
meet the promised deadlines. There were allegations of diversion and
misutilisation of funds. The petitioner with co-accused statedly collected,
siphoned off and laundered proceeds of crime amounting ₹616 crore. It is also
alleged that forged bank guarantees had been submitted by the SAFPL to
MANINDER
2026.04.08 10:14
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
DTCP against External Development Charges and Internal Development
CRM-M-73084-2025 (O&M)
Work, and the accused/petitioner directly or indirectly indulged in criminal
conspiracy, cheating and forgery leading to commission of offences alleged.
2.1.
This led to registration of the aforementioned FIR against the
SAFPL, Sikander Singh and Vikas Kumar, Director-Promoters, along with
other Directors and officers of the Company. On these revelations, an
Enforcement
Case
information
Report
(ECIR)
bearing
no.
ECIR/GNZO/20/2021, dated 16.11.2021, was registered at Gurugram Zonal
Office of the respondent-Directorate of Enforcement (for short, ‘the ED’)
under the PMLA, as it was found that prima facie case for commission of
offence of money laundering was made out against the petitioner and other
accused on the basis of aforementioned FIR pertaining to the scheduled
offences.
2.2.
During investigation, it came to the notice of the ED that there
were various other complaints pending against the Mahira Group of
companies with respect to the same project, and other FIRs have also been
registered against the petitioner and other Directors. Four FIRs were taken on
record by the ED for comprehensive investigation, which are - (i) FIR No.175,
dated 18.05.2022, under Section 10 of the Haryana Development and
Regulation of Urban Areas Act, 1975, Sections 120-B, 201, 420, 467, 468 and
471 IPC, registered at Police Station Rajendra Park, Gurugram; (ii) FIR
No.151, dated 31.05.2023, under Sections 420, 467, 468 and 471 IPC,
registered at Police Station Rajendra Park, Gurugram; (iii) FIR No.152, dated
01.06.2023, under Sections 420, 467, 468 and 471 IPC, registered at Police
Station Rajendra Park, Gurugram; and (iv) FIR No.151, dated 05.07.2023,
under Sections 120-B, 420, 467, 468 and 471 IPC, registered at Police Station
MANINDER
2026.04.08 10:14
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
Sushant Lok, Gurugram. But the petitioner could not be arrested.
CRM-M-73084-2025 (O&M)
2.3.
During the investigation by the ED, the facts regarding
involvement of the petitioner came to light which have been explained in
detail in the reply filed on its behalf; the relevant extract whereof reads as
under:
80.
Dharam Singh Chhoker was/is the director in the below
mentioned companies for the time period mentioned below:
Sr. No.
Company Name
Designation
Date of
Appointment
at Current
Designation
Date of
cessation
(if
applicable)
DS Estates &
Construction
Private Limited
Director
02.07.2007
30.09.2009
Mahira Homes
Private Limited
Director
17.11.2016
15.11.2017
DS Homes
Construction
Private Limited
Director
31.08.2012
15.03.2017
Director
02.12.2019
10.07.2021
DSC Estate
Developers
Private Limited
Director
03.11.2010
18.12.2014
DS Homes
Private Limited
Director
04.06.2020
10.07.2021
Mahira Buildtech Director
Private Limited
17.11.2016
19.04.2018
81.
The above-mentioned companies are the associate
concerns of Mahira Group. M/s Mahira Homes Pvt Ltd is the
holding company of all the project companies i.e. being
developed by M/s Sai Aaina Farms Pvt Ltd, M/s Mahira
Buildtech Pvt Ltd and M/s Mahira Buildwell Pvt Ltd. which are
developing the projects at Sector 68, Sector 103 and Sector 104
of Gurugram, respectively.
82.
It is further pertinent to mention herein that the project
companies i.e. M/s Sai Aaina Farms Pvt Ltd, M/s Mahira
MANINDER
2026.04.08 10:14
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
Buildtech Pvt Ltd and M/s Czar Buildwell Pvt Ltd provided the
CRM-M-73084-2025 (O&M)
loans and advances to M/s DS Home Construction Pvt Ltd. The
details of the same are as under (Balance sheets for F.Y. 2019-20,
2020-21 and 2021-22 of M/s Sai Aaina Farms Pvt Ltd (RUD FPC), Balance Sheets of M/s Mahira Buildtech Pvt Ltd and M/s
Czar Buildwell Pvt Ltd:
83.
Name of Company
As on
31.03.2020
As on
31.03.2021
As on
31.03.2022
M/s Sai Aaina
Farms Pvt. Ltd.
26,53,72,994
29,83,14,602
48,63,98,102
M/s Mahira
6,70,27,827
Buildtech Pvt. Ltd.
12,89,95,377
31,23,03,604
M/s Czar Buildwell
Pvt. Ltd.
31,75,94,871
80,49,56,004
-
From the above table, it is clearly seen that the loans and
advances taken by M/s DS Home Construction Pvt Ltd from
above mentioned project companies, has been increasing year on
year and the same has not been used for the construction of the
projects of home buyers for which it was collected and the same
were siphoned off. M/s Sai Aaina Farms Pvt Ltd, M/s Mahira
Buildtech Pvt Ltd, M/s Czar Buildwell Pvt Ltd and its associated
persons by conniving with M/s DS Home Construction Pvt Ltd
siphoned off the above money of home buyers in the form of
loans and advances and used this money for unintended purpose
i.e. for purchasing the properties in its name or in the name of
M/s DS Home Construction Pvt Ltd and other associate
concerns/persons for personal gains or for personal expenditure
like for purchasing the vehicles, jewellery, wedding expenses etc
instead of constructing the flats of affordable housing projects of
Mahira Group.
84.
A number of transactions were made from the accounts of
M/s DS Home Construction Pvt Ltd, during the period of 2020,
when Shri Dharam Singh Chhoker was one of the directors and
having the significant influence over the affairs of the company.
MANINDER
2026.04.08 10:14
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
In this regard, the payments were made to M/s Hazoorilal
CRM-M-73084-2025 (O&M)
Jewellers Pvt Ltd from the account of M/s DS Home
Construction Pvt Ltd (Account no. 50200003495224, maintained
with HDFC Bank) during the directorship period of Dharam
Singh Chhoker: … (Cash returned about 9.01 Crores in JulyAugust 2020]
85.
The above fact of returning the cash has also been
confirmed by Shri Sandeep Narang, Director M/s Hazoorilal
Jewellers Pvt Ltd during his statement recording under section
16 of PMLA, 2002 on 26.07.2023.
86.
Further, during the custodial interrogation, Shri Dharam
Singh Chhoker was confronted with Shri Sandeep Narang
(director of M/s Hazoorilal Jewellers Pvt Ltd), wherein Shri
Sandeep Narang stated that Shri Dharam Singh Chhoker came to
his shop for buying the jewellery and in this regard Shri Sandeep
Narang also submitted the invoices to that effect.
87.
It is pertinent to mention herein that the bogus purchases
were done to the tune of Rs. 56 Crore (approx.) by M/s Sai Aaina
Farms Pvt Ltd and M/s D S Home Construction Pvt Ltd after
receiving the payments from home buyers for Project Mahira
Homes 68, Gurugram. Wherein the payments were transferred to
the entities through banking transactions and further cash amount
were received back by Chhoker family. The cash amounts
received by the Chhoker families in lieu of the bogus billings,
were utilized for their cash expenses as evident in the excel file
"cement vendor2" retrieved from the laptop (make Dell, ModelP87G, SN-GF42902) which was seized at S. No. B-17 of RUD B
to the panchnama drawn during the search operation on
31.07.2023 at premises of 301, Third Floor, Global Foyer Mall,
Gurugram. A detailed investigation in respect of these bogus
billings has been elaborated in the First Prosecution Complaint.
88. to 98.
99.
xxx
xxx
During the investigation, it is gathered that Shri Dharam
Singh Chhoker was actively involved in the day-to-day affairs of
MANINDER
2026.04.08 10:14
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
M/s DS Home Construction Pvt Ltd. In this regard, Shri Dharam
CRM-M-73084-2025 (O&M)
Singh Chhoker signed the balance Sheets of M/s DS Home
Construction Pvt Ltd for the period of F.Y. 2019-20, which
indicates that he was completely in knowledge of the transactions
and day to day affairs, being carried out in M/s D S Home
Constructions Pvt Ltd.
2.4.
Further, it has also been mentioned in the reply that the petitioner
evaded the process of law during the earlier stages of investigation and failed
to appear despite multiple summons having been issued to him, followed by
six non-bailable warrants issued by the Special Court, Gurugram, which are
part of the judicial records. List of those summons and warrants against the
petitioner are as under:
List of summons given to the petitioner
MANINDER
2026.04.08 10:14
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
Sr. No.
Date of Issue
Status of Compliance
27.07.2023
No Compliance
28.07.2023
No Compliance
29.07.2023
No Compliance
30.07.2023
No Compliance
01.08.2023
No Compliance
04.08.2023
No Compliance
08.08.2023
No Compliance
10.08.2023
No Compliance
17.08.2023
No Compliance
28.08.2023
No Compliance
05.09.2023
No Compliance
21.10.2023
No Compliance
07.05.2024
No Compliance
10.05.2024
No Compliance
17.05.2024
No Compliance
CRM-M-73084-2025 (O&M)
27.11.2024
No Compliance
09.12.2024
No Compliance
List of warrants of arrest issued against the petitioner
Date of warrant Report of this office
of arrest
04.10.2023
20.03.2024
2.5.
Date of attempts
made by police
authorities
Made attempts on 09.03.2024 Request letter dated
and 11.03.2024 after the
11.03.2024 was
decision of High Court.
issued.
However, he was not found
at the house.
Report dated
Made attempts on 28.03.2024 03.04.2024, not
and 04.04.2024, not found at found at residence
even after multiple
home as he was not there
attempts.
since 26.02.2024.
06.04.2024
As per directions of Hon’ble Supreme Court,
Dharam Singh Chhoker appeared on 12.04.2024.
30.05.2024
Made efforts 2-3 times to
execute the arrest warrant at
his house. But not found.
Made efforts 9-10
times to execute the
arrest warrants but
not found at his
house, his villageSamalkha etc.
09.01.2025
Made efforts 2-3 times to
execute the arrest warrant at
his house. But not found.
Made efforts 9-10
times to execute the
arrest warrants but
not found at his
house, his villageSamalkha etc.
24.01.2025
Made efforts 2-3 times to
execute the arrest warrant at
his house. But not found.
Made efforts 9-10
times to execute the
arrest warrants but
not found at his
house, his villageSamalkha etc.
At that stage, a writ petition, CWP-25140-2024, was filed before
this Court by one Virender Singh son of Bharat Singh Chhoker, who was
MANINDER
2026.04.08 10:14
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
aspiring to contest election to the Haryana Legislative Assembly from the
CRM-M-73084-2025 (O&M)
constituency from where the petitioner had contested, seeking the latter's
arrest. The petition was allowed by the Division Bench vide judgment and
order dated 23.10.2024, by directing as under:
35.
For all the above stated reasons, this Court finds merit in
the instant petition, and, is constrained to allow it. Consequently,
the instant petition is allowed to the extent that the Enforcement
Directorate is directed to, unless the order passed by this Court
on 28.05.2024 upon CRM-M-26190-2024, thus is either stayed
or quashed by the Apex Court, thus forthwith arrest respondent
No.5-Dharam Singh Chhoker.
2.6.
After the direction by the Division Bench, again an application
was filed by the ED seeking issuance of open-ended non-bailable warrants
against the petitioner. The Special Judge issued the same vide order dated
24.01.2025, by observing as under:
However, keeping in view the observations of the Hon'ble High
Court in the matter in hand in CWP No.25140 of 2024(O&M)
titled as Virender Singh Versus State of Haryana and another, date
of decision 23.10.2024, to facilitate the officers of applicantDirectorate of Enforcement to arrest the respondents from other
State,
fresh
open-ended
non-bailable
warrants
against
respondents-Dharma Singh Chhoker and Vikas Chhoker be
issued, if so desired.
2.7.
In these circumstances, the ED officials found the petitioner at
Shangri-La Hotel, New Delhi, on the evening of 04.05.2025. On being shown
the warrants of arrest, he tried to flee from there and could only be
apprehended after hot pursuit from near the entrance of the Hotel with the help
of personnel from the Delhi Police and the hotel security staff. A scuffle
ensued between him and the ED officials who had come to arrest him; there
are allegations and counter-allegations of manhandling and beatings etc. Both
MANINDER
2026.04.08 10:14
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
CRM-M-73084-2025 (O&M)
sides have lodged FIRs against each other in this regard and the cases are
pending adjudication.
2.8.
The petitioner challenged his arrest before this Court by filing
CRWP No.5261 of 2025, which was rejected vide judgment dated 11.09.2025.
Along with this petition, he filed a regular bail petition also, CRM-M-279722025, which was disposed of granting him liberty to approach the Court of
Session. Accordingly, he filed an application for regular bail before the
Sessions/Special Judge which was dismissed vide order dated 16.12.2025.
2.9.
It also needs a mention that cognizance of the offence was taken
by the Special Judge vide order dated 05.12.2024. The same was challenged
by the petitioner’s son by filing CRM-M-29954-2025 on the ground that
pre-cognizance hearing was not afforded to the accused before passing the
order which violated the mandate of Section 223(1) BNSS. The petition was
allowed by this Court vide judgment dated 29.07.2025 with the following
directions:
9.
In view thereof, the impugned orders, dated 22.11.2024
and 05.12.2024, are set aside directing the Special Judge under
the PMLA to pass a fresh order after affording an opportunity of
hearing to the petitioner in terms of first proviso to Section 223(1)
BNSS, within a period of eight weeks of receiving a certified
copy of this order.
In compliance thereof, the Special Judge afforded opportunity of hearing to
the petitioner and was asked to address arguments. However, as apparent from
the order dated 04.09.2025, the arguments were not advanced on the ground
that one of the Compact Discs (CDs) furnished to the petitioner was blank and
did not contain any document; a complete copy of the documents was
therefore asked for by him. The request was opposed by the Special Public
MANINDER
2026.04.08 10:14
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
CRM-M-73084-2025 (O&M)
Prosecutor on the ground that all the documents had been duly handed over to
the petitioner’s counsel; the said CD was also given to him on 19.08.2025 but
no objection was raised at that time. However, the Special Judge ordered that
‘[w]hatsoever may be the reason of not arguing the matter today, the fact
remains that documents are required to be supplied before advancing
arguments’. And the matter was adjourned to 23.09.2025 for arguments on the
point of taking cognizance. On the next date of hearing, 30.09.2025, again a
request was made on behalf of the petitioner that the matter was lengthy and,
therefore, arguments would not conclude in a day, and two consecutive dates
should be fixed for the purpose. It was thus adjourned to 09.10.2025. The case
was again taken up for hearing by the Special Judge on 18.10.2025, and the
learned counsel for the petitioner/accused persons again came up with the
same plea that all the documents had not been supplied by the ED, therefore,
arguments could not commence. But the Court directed to start the arguments
and the same were advanced in part on behalf of the ED, and concluded on
12.11.2025. Finally, the Special Judge pronounced the order taking
cognizance of the offence on 08.01.2026. [Copies of the aforementioned short
orders of the Special Judge have been shown to the Court during the course
of arguments.]
3.
In this factual background, learned senior counsel for the
petitioner contended that the petitioner is a senior citizen, aged about sixtyfour years, and is in custody since 04.05.2025. He has been a member of the
Legislative Assembly in the State of Haryana, and has deep roots in the
society. It cannot be believed that he would not cooperate with the ongoing
investigation, and/or misuse his liberty of bail in any manner. He has appeared
MANINDER
2026.04.08 10:14
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
before the ED on 05, 07, 08, 10 and 11.10.2023, 12.04.2024 and 04.05.2024,
CRM-M-73084-2025 (O&M)
and can be bound with any condition for further appearance as and when
required, if necessary. Accordingly, the petitioner is not a flight risk. He cannot
tamper with the evidence either, as all the evidence is documentary in nature
which is already in custody of the ED. The witnesses cannot be influenced, as
the same are mostly Government officials. Besides, his son Sikander Singh,
allegedly the principal accused, has already been released on regular bail by
this Court, vide order dated 31.01.2025 passed in CRM-M-57948-2024.
3.1.
Secondly, there is no likelihood of commencement of trial, and
much less of its conclusion in near future. This is because the prosecution
complaint filed on 27.06.2024 is against three persons and two companies, it
relies upon 31 witnesses and 154 documents running into thousands of pages.
The supplementary prosecution complaint has been filed on 01.07.2025
against seven individuals, including the petitioner, and three companies; there
are 22 other prosecution witnesses and 302 documents running into more than
four thousand pages have been relied upon. In total, there are 53 witnesses
who are to be examined. Besides, the order passed by the Special Judge taking
cognizance of the offence, dated 05.12.2024, was set aside by this Court vide
judgment dated 29.07.2025, and the matter was remitted for fresh
consideration after affording pre-cognizance hearing to the petitioner.
Thereupon, the cognizance has been taken vide order dated 08.01.2026, but
the same is also under challenge before this Court. Accordingly, there is no
possibility of the trial commencing for quite some time. These facts entitle the
petitioner to be released on bail. Strong reliance has been placed on law laid
down in V. Senthil Balaji v. Deputy Director, Directorate of Enforcement,
2024 SCC Online SC 2626, to contend that the petitioner’s long incarceration
MANINDER
2026.04.08 10:14
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
violates his Fundamental Right to life. Learned senior counsel has also relied
CRM-M-73084-2025 (O&M)
upon Padam Chand Jain v. Enforcement Directorate, 2025 SCC Online SC
1291, holding that conditions under Section 45 PMLA cannot override the
constitutional safeguards, and prolonged incarceration cannot be permitted. In
that case also, around 50 witnesses were required to be examined and the main
evidence was documentary in nature, which had already been seized by the
prosecuting agency. Further, learned senior counsel has referred to Arvind
Dham v. Directorate of Enforcement, 2026 SCC Online SC 30, which holds
that all economic offences cannot be classified into one group; and in case the
State or the prosecuting agency has no way to protect Fundamental Right of
the accused to speedy trial enshrined in the Constitution, the plea of bail
should not be opposed by them on the ground that crime committed is serious.
4.
Per contra, learned counsel for the ED contended that there is no
thumb rule that after any particular period of incarceration the accused would
be entitled to bail without complying with the mandatory requirements under
Section 45 PMLA. Gravity of offence is also a relevant factor in considering
grant of bail. And in the instant case, the petitioner is accused of duping
thousands of home buyers and siphoning off hundred of crores of rupees for
personal gains and expenditure, apart from purchasing properties in the name
of his companies and other associate concerns. Secondly, the petitioner cannot
draw parity with the co-accused, Sikander Singh, who has been granted bail
by this Court vide order dated 31.01.2025. It is because the order has been
passed on certain incorrect facts and the ED has challenged the same before
the Supreme Court by filing SLP, wherein notice has been issued to the
petitioner, vide order dated 25.07.2025, and is pending for final adjudication.
Besides, there is no law that bail is to be granted on the basis of parity. Thirdly,
MANINDER
2026.04.08 10:14
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
the petitioner’s conduct also needs to be considered by the Court. There has
CRM-M-73084-2025 (O&M)
been repeated non-compliance of the summons issued to him for appearance;
details of seventeen such summons have been given in the reply. Apart from
that, despite issuance of about a dozen non-bailable warrants, he could not be
arrested. It was with great difficulty and following directions by this Court
that he was arrested from a hotel on 04.05.2025; at that time, he tried to flee
and could be apprehended with great difficulty. There is every likelihood that
on being released on bail, he would disappear to avoid the process of law.
Fourthly, it cannot be said that trial will take long time to conclude as there
are only two prosecution complaints with actually 48 witnesses, since 5 of the
total 53 witnesses cited in both the complaints are common; 07 of these are
officials, and there is likelihood that 5 of the witnesses can be dropped by the
ED. Besides, it is the petitioner who is delaying the commencement of trial.
Initially, cognizance of the offence was taken on 05.12.2024, which was
challenged before this Court, and the order was set aside on 29.07.2025.
Despite a clear direction by the Court to pass a fresh order regarding
cognizance within two months, the petitioner kept on delaying the hearing on
cooked-up grounds. Finally, the cognizance was again taken by the Special
Judge on 08.01.2026, which was again challenged by him before this Court.
However, there is no stay on further proceedings, and the trial can proceed
which will soon be concluded. In these circumstances, the period of delay in
taking the cognizance needs to be excluded from the total period of
incarceration undergone by the petitioner. Even otherwise, he has not been in
custody for a period long enough to entitle him to bail without complying with
the mandatory requirements under Section 45 PMLA. And the material
brought on record by the ED clearly establishes that he has committed the
MANINDER
2026.04.08 10:14
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
alleged offences. Lastly, it has been submitted that judgments relied upon by
CRM-M-73084-2025 (O&M)
learned senior counsel for the petitioner are on different facts, and the
petitioner cannot seek bail by relying upon the same. In support of the
submissions he has placed reliance upon the judgment Union of India v.
Kanhaiya Prasad, 2025 SCC Online SC 306, holding that ‘…the two
conditions mentioned in Section 45 are mandatory, and that while considering
the bail application, the said rigours of Section 45 have to be reckoned by the
court to uphold the objectives of the PMLA.’
5.
Submissions made by learned counsel for the parties have been
considered.
6.
It is apparent on record that the petitioner is accused of siphoning
off hundreds of crores of rupees of home buyers who booked flats in the
affordable group housing project being developed by the SAFPL. He has been
Director of at least six Mahira Group companies, which are developing the
housing projects. This includes M/s Mahira Home Pvt. Ltd. which is the
holding company of the companies developing the project in question.
Besides, he has been at the helm of affairs of M/s DS Homes Construction
Private Limited and signed its balance sheets for the financial year 2019-20;
it is one of the companies through which the home buyers’ money has
allegedly been misused. There have been other monetary transactions illegally
transferring this money to group companies controlled by the petitioner and
his family members. Coupled with these facts, it needs to be noted that he has
repeatedly avoided summons issued by the Special Court for joining the
investigation; details of seventeen such summons have been mentioned in
para 2.4 above. Also, non-bailable warrants of arrest were issued against him
a number of times, but he could not be arrested. Finally, pursuant to directions
MANINDER
2026.04.08 10:14
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
issued by the Division Bench in CWP No.25140 of 2024 and the consequent
CRM-M-73084-2025 (O&M)
non-bailable warrants, he could be taken in custody on 04.05.2025. That was
only after his outrageous attempt to flee from the scene was foiled by the ED
officials with the help of Delhi Police and security staff of the hotel from
where he was arrested. Keeping these facts in view, no exception can be taken
to the assertion by the ED that he is a flight risk.
7.
Still further, it cannot be lost sight of that the initial order of
learned Special Judge taking cognizance of the offence, dated 05.12.2024, was
set aside by this Court vide judgment dated 29.07.2025, accepting the petition
filed by co-accused Sikander Singh. The matter was remanded for fresh
consideration, and the learned Judge could finally hear and decide the issue
vide order dated 08.01.2026, taking cognizance of the offence again. The trial
is now set to commence and there is no foreseeable hindrance to it. The period
of petitioner’s incarceration cannot be viewed in isolation, and has to be seen
in the light of circumstances whereunder the order taking cognizance has been
passed by the learned Judge, as detailed in paragraph 2.9 above. Accordingly,
it is not a case that delay in commencement of trial can be attributed to the
ED; instead, the indication is otherwise. Besides, looking at the number of
complaints - 2, number of accused - 15, as also the number of witnesses - 48,
of whom five may be dropped by the ED, it cannot be said trial of the case
will be delayed inordinately. Further, the petitioner is in custody since
04.05.2025, and the maximum sentence prescribed for the offence under
Section 4 PMLA is seven years. In the facts and circumstances of the case, the
period of custody can also not be termed substantial that would entitle the
petitioner to bail dehors merits of the case which require compliance of the
mandatory requirements under Section 45 PMLA as a precondition. However,
MANINDER
2026.04.08 10:14
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
no attempt has been made on behalf of the petitioner to establish that he meets
CRM-M-73084-2025 (O&M)
those requirements. Additionally, in the light of these facts the petitioner
cannot be admitted to bail only because co-accused has been granted the
concession by a coordinate Bench vide order dated 31.01.2025. In this
context, the assertion by the ED can also not be ignored that the order has been
passed upon certain incorrect facts and is already under challenge before the
Supreme Court.
8.
The observations in V. Senthil Balaji case (supra) relied upon by
learned senior counsel for the petitioner are not in sync with the facts of the
case, and no benefit can be drawn by him on that basis. It was a case where
there were more than 2000 accused, and 550 prosecution witnesses had been
cited. The Court found that even on the issue of framing charge, a large
number of accused would have to be heard and there was no likelihood of the
trial being concluded within three to four years. In these circumstances the
Court observed that the appellant’s continued detention would be an
infringement of his Fundamental Right to speedy trial guaranteed under
Article 21. The observations to that effect are as follows:
15.
We have already narrated that there are three scheduled
offences. In the main case (CC Nos. 22 and 24 of 2021), there are
about 2000 accused and 550 prosecution witnesses cited. Thus, it
can be said that there are more than 2000 accused in the three
scheduled offences, and the number of witnesses proposed to be
examined exceeds 600.
16.
xxx
xxx
17.
Thus, on the issue of framing of charge or discharge, a
large number of accused will have to be heard. The trial of the
scheduled offences will be a warrant case. Therefore, even if the
trials of the scheduled offences are expedited, the process of
framing charges may take a few months as many advocates
MANINDER
2026.04.08 10:14
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
representing more than 2000 accused persons will have to be
CRM-M-73084-2025 (O&M)
heard. There are bound to be further proceedings arising out of
orders on charge. After that, more than 600 witnesses will have
to be examined. Documentary and electronic evidence is relied
upon in the scheduled offences. Even if few witnesses are
dropped, a few hundred witnesses will have to be examined.
Presence of all the accused will have to be procured and their
statements under Section 313 of the Criminal Procedure Code,
1973 will have to be recorded. Therefore, even in ideal
conditions, the possibility of the trial of scheduled offences
concluding even within a reasonable time of three to four years
appears to be completely ruled out.
18 to 28
29.
xxx
xxx
As stated earlier, the appellant has been incarcerated for 15
months or more for the offence punishable under the PMLA. In
the facts of the case, the trial of the scheduled offences and,
consequently, the PMLA offence is not likely to be completed in
three to four years or even more. If the appellant's detention is
continued, it will amount to an infringement of his fundamental
right under Article 21 of the Constitution of India of speedy trial.
No doubt the proposition of law laid down is that long incarceration and no
possibility of conclusion of trial in a reasonable time, violates the accused’s
Fundamental Right to life, but either of these conditions is not met in the
petitioner’s case, as already discussed herein before.
9.
The other judgments relied upon by learned senior counsel for
the petitioner also do not advance his case in any manner. In Padam Chand
Jain case (supra), bail was granted keeping in view multiple factors thousands of documents, around fifty witnesses, non-implication of the
Minister as an accused for whose benefit the monetary transactions in the case
had taken place, and grant of bail to the appellant therein in the predicate
MANINDER
2026.04.08 10:14
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
offence. These distinctive factors are missing in the petitioner’s case.
CRM-M-73084-2025 (O&M)
Similarly, in Arvind Dham case (supra), out of twenty-eight individuals, only
the appellant had been arrested and remained in custody for more than sixteen
months. Besides, cognizance of the prosecution case had not been taken and
the proceedings were at the stage of scrutiny of documents. There were 210
witnesses to be examined, and it was concluded that trial was not likely to
commence in near future. Also, on filing of the prosecution complaint, the
Special Judge had issued notice to all the proposed accused under proviso to
Section 223 BNSS. The order was challenged by the ED before the High
Court, resulting in stay of proceedings before the Special Judge for over eight
months. The delay was, therefore, held to be attributable to the ED and not the
appellant. These factors are also non-existent in the petitioner’s case.
10.
In view of the discussion, this Court is not inclined to grant bail
to the petitioner at this stage, and the petition stands dismissed.
(TRIBHUVAN DAHIYA)
JUDGE
08.04.2026
Maninder
Whether speaking/reasoned
Whether reportable
MANINDER
2026.04.08 10:14
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
:
:
Yes
No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review