The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
25. Although ordinarily High Court while exercising jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, would be loath to interfere with consistent findings of guilt, this Court considers it apposite to set aside the impugned award in the peculiar facts of the present case.
26. Insofar as relief is concerned, the petitioner workman had worked with DTC for around 12 years and he has already expired. Further, the termination dates back to the year 1990. At this juncture, after more than 35 years, this Court is of the opinion that award of a lump-sum compensation will meet the ends of justice. Consequently, DTC is directed to pay a sum of ₹5,00,000/- to the legal heirs of the petitioner within a period of 4 weeks.
27. In view of the aforesaid discussion, the present petition is allowed in the aforesaid terms.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURTOF DELHIAT NEW DELHI
%
#
+
Judgment Reserved on:29.07.2026
Judgment Delivered on:16.09.2026
Judgment Uploaded on:16.09.2026
CNR No.: DLHC010714562005
W.P.(C) 6632/2005
DHARAM PAL
.....Petitioner
versus
DTC
..... Respondent
Advocates who appeared in this case:
For the Petitioner
: Mr. Shanker Raju, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. Nilansh Gaur & Ms. Prerna Deep, Advs.
For the Respondent
: Mr. Uday N. Tiwary & Mr. Akshat Tiwary,
Advs.
Mr. Alok Kumar, D. Asst. for ManagementDTC
CORAM
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
JUDGMENT
1.
By the present petition, the petitioner challenges the award
dated 18.01.2005 (hereafter ‘impugned award’) passed by the learned
Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal-II, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi
in I.D. No. 222/2001 whereby the learned Tribunal noting that the
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
17:38:49
W.P.(C) 6632/2005
enquiry was conducted in consonance with the principles of natural
justice had upheld the punishment of removal imposed on the
petitioner workman.
2.
It bears relevance to note that the petitioner workman expired
during the pendency of the writ petition in the year 2022 and by order
dated 02.06.2023, the legal representatives of the petitioner workman
were brought on record who are pursuing the present petition.
3.
Briefly stated, the petitioner workman was employed with the
management as a conductor in the year 1978. It is the case against the
petitioner workman that on 06.04.1989, while performing duty on
route no. RL-42, when the bus was intercepted by the checking staff at
Delhi Gate at 19:50 hours, it was found that the petitioner workman
had failed to issue tickets to a group of 5 passengers after collecting
due fare from them. It is further the case of the corporation that upon
checking, two sold tickets of ₹2 and ₹1 bearing nos. 97216 and 76809
were found in possession of the petitioner workman with the ticket
blocks. For the said charges, a chargesheet was issued to the petitioner
workman on 20.04.1989.
4.
Thereafter, in the aftermath of the enquiry proceedings, the
petitioner workman was found guilty of the charges and vide order
dated 26.10.1990, the petitioner workman was removed from service.
5.
Subsequently, in the industrial dispute raised by the petitioner
workman, the learned Tribunal, by the impugned award, upon finding
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
17:38:49
W.P.(C) 6632/2005
that the enquiry proceedings were conducted in accordance with the
principles of natural justice, upheld the punishment of removal from
service as awarded to the petitioner workman.
6.
While doing so, the learned Tribunal noted that when the
enquiry proceedings were conducted on 27.06.1989, the petitioner
workman was present along with one Sh. Victor Charles, Labour
Welfare Inspector. The learned Tribunal also took into account the
statements of the checking officials recorded during the course of the
enquiry proceedings and noted that the said officials were cross
examined at length by the workman. It was noted that the enquiry
proceedings contained the signatures of the workman along with the
signature of the Labour Welfare Inspector. Consequently, it was found
that the workman was given full opportunity to defend the case and
the enquiry proceedings were conducted in harmony with the
principles of natural justice. Hence, the impugned award was passed
thereby upholding the punishment of removal from service awarded to
the petitioner workman. Aggrieved by the same, the petitioner
workman has preferred the present petition.
7.
The learned Senior counsel for the petitioner submitted that the
impugned award is perverse and is liable to be set aside. He submitted
that the learned Tribunal failed to take into account that the enquiry
officer only considered the version of the management witnesses
presented during the course of the enquiry proceedings. He submitted
that while the enquiry officer considered the statement of the alleged
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
17:38:49
W.P.(C) 6632/2005
passengers, the said statement was not signed by the petitioner
workman and there was no noting by the checking staff that the
petitioner refused to sign the said statement.
8.
He submitted that the learned Tribunal failed to appreciate the
fact that the enquiry proceedings were vitiated due to violation of
departmental instructions issued by the corporation dated 06.12.1972
and 13.10.1965. He submitted that since the corporation failed to act
on its own instructions, the enquiry officer could not have returned a
finding of guilt in the dearth of evidence.
9.
He further submitted that the present case is not one in relation
to whether the corporation chased the witnesses or not to secure their
presence in the enquiry proceedings. He submitted that the present
case is one where notices were not even served to the passengers to
secure their presence.
10.
He submitted that when the cash was checked, a sum of ₹5.20/-
was found short which further belies the case of the corporation.
11.
He submitted that the learned Tribunal further failed to
appreciate the fact that the waybill carried by the petitioner on the date
of the incident showed closing numerical at 97240 whereas the
unpunched tickets allegedly recovered from the petitioner have
numerical value from 97245 – 97249. He submitted that the challan
issued to the petitioner does not carry the second allegation mentioned
in the chargesheet pertaining to the presence of sold tickets in the
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
17:38:49
W.P.(C) 6632/2005
block of tickets with the petitioner and the said fact was also
highlighted by the petitioner workman during the enquiry proceedings.
12.
In arguendo, he submitted that the punishment awarded to the
petitioner workman is in violation of the circular dated 03.01.1966 as
per which the punishment of dismissal from service is to be awarded
only when the said offence of cheating is committed more than three
times. He submitted that, if at all, the present instance was only the
third instance.
13.
Per contra, the learned counsel for the respondent submitted the
impugned award is well reasoned and warrants no interference by this
Court. He submitted that it is well settled that during domestic
enquiry, strict rules of evidence are not applicable and all material that
is legally probative are permissible.
14.
He submitted that the workman in the present case was given
full opportunity to defend its case and was also given an opportunity
to call his co-worker. He submitted that at the request of the workman,
the enquiry was conducted in the presence of the Labour Welfare
Officer on 27.06.1989.
15.
He submitted that the reliance on the circular dated 13.10.1965
is unfounded as the said circular was amended by circular dated
18.12.1967 as per which the requirement of recording of evidence of
the witnesses at their residence has been deleted. He submitted that it
is well settled that non production of passenger witness is not fatal to
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
17:38:49
W.P.(C) 6632/2005
domestic enquiry. He further submitted that there is also no violation
of the circular dated 06.12.1972 as it has consistently been upheld by
Courts in a catena of decisions that hearsay evidence would be
admissible if it has reasonable nexus.
16.
He submitted that the award of punishment is the discretion of
the disciplinary authority and considering the past record of the
petitioner workman, he was rightly awarded the punishment of
removal from service.
Analysis
17.
At the outset, it is relevant to note that the jurisdiction of the
High Court to issue a writ or direction in exercise of power under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India is supervisory in nature and
the Court ought not to act as an appellate Court. This Court ought not
to rove into the exercise of reappreciation of evidence or substitute its
own view for the view taken by the Labour Court unless the same is
shown to be arbitrary or perverse.
18.
Equally well settled is the fact that in enquiry proceedings, strict
or sophisticated rules of evidence are not applicable and the charges
are required to be proved on the touchstone of preponderance of
probabilities, and not beyond reasonable doubt. What is required to be
seen is that there must be some material on record for the Labour
Court to have reasonably arrived at the conclusion. Consequently, so
long as the view taken by the Labour Court is a plausible one, this
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
17:38:49
W.P.(C) 6632/2005
Court, in exercise of power under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, ought not re-appraise evidence to disturb the findings only
because another view is possible.
19.
The
petitioner
has
essentially
challenged
the
enquiry
proceedings against himself on the ground that certain DTC circulars,
that is, Circulars dated 06.12.1972 and 13.10.1965, have purportedly
been violated. Before proceeding further, it is imperative to take note
of the substance of the said circulars. Circular dated 06.12.1972
provides that the alleged statement of any passenger that is not
countersigned by the workman cannot be considered by the enquiry
officer during the course of the enquiry proceedings. Circular dated
13.10.1965 provided for a mechanism to record the evidence of the
witness at the address given by him in case there is a failure on the
part of the witness to come forth and the case is being delayed. DTC
has contested that the latter circular has since been amended and the
provision of recording of evidence at residence stands deleted. Insofar
as non-compliance of the former is concerned, it is pertinent to note
that non-compliance with departmental instructions does not ex facie
vitiate enquiry proceedings [Ref. State of Haryana v. Rattan Singh :
(1977) 2 SCC 491; Mahesh Chand v. DTC :W.P.(C) 2399/2007].
Furthermore, as held in the case of State of Haryana v. Rattan Singh
(supra), it is well-settled that examination of passengers is not
necessary and a finding of guilt can be returned even in absence
thereof on the basis of hearsay evidence. Pertinently, in that case, no
statement of the passengers was recorded at all, despite which, the
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
17:38:49
W.P.(C) 6632/2005
Hon’ble Apex Court upheld the finding of guilt on basis of hearsay
evidence of checking staff. The relevant portion of the judgment is as
under:
“3. The principal ground on which the courts below have declared
the termination bad is that none of the 11 passengers have been
examined at the domestic enquiry. Secondly, it has been
mentioned that there is a departmental instruction that checking
inspectors should record the statements of passengers, which was
not done in this case. The explanation of the State, as borne out by
the record, is that the inspector of the flying squad had said that
they had paid the fares but they declined to give such written
statements. The third ground which weighed with the courts was,
perhaps, that the co-conductor in the bus had supported with this
evidence, the guiltlessness of the respondent.
4. It is well settled that in a domestic enquiry the strict and
sophisticated rules of evidence under the Indian Evidence Act may
not apply. All materials which are logically probative for a prudent
mind are permissible. There is no allergy to hearsay evidence
provided it has reasonable nexus and credibility. It is true that
departmental authorities and Administrative Tribunals must be
careful in evaluating such material and should not glibly swallow
what is strictly speaking not relevant under the Indian Evidence
Act. For this proposition it is not necessary to cite decisions nor
text books, although we have been taken through case-law and
other authorities by counsel on both sides. The essence of a judicial
approach is objectivity, exclusion of extraneous materials or
considerations and observance of rules of natural justice. Of
course, fairplay is the basis and if perversity or arbitrariness, bias
or surrender of independence of judgment vitiate the conclusions
reached, such finding, even though of a domestic tribunal, cannot
be held good. However, the courts below misdirected themselves,
perhaps, in insisting that passengers who had come in and gone
out should be chased and brought before the tribunal before a
valid finding could be recorded. The ‘residuum’ rule to which
counsel for the respondent referred, based upon certain passages
from American Jurisprudence does not go to that extent nor does
the passage from Halsbury insist on such rigid requirement. The
simple point is, was there some evidence or was there no evidence
— not in the sense of the technical rules governing regular court
proceedings but in a fair commonsense way as men of
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
17:38:49
W.P.(C) 6632/2005
understanding and worldly wisdom will accept. Viewed in this
way, sufficiency of evidence in proof of the finding by a domestic
tribunal is beyond scrutiny. Absence of any evidence in support
of a finding is certainly available for the court to look into
because it amounts to an error of law apparent on the record. We
find, in this case, that the evidence of Chamanlal, Inspector of
the Flying Squad, is some evidence which has relevance to the
charge levelled against the respondent. Therefore, we are unable
to hold that the order is invalid on that ground.”
(emphasis supplied)
20.
Thus, while the said circular encapsulates a rule of prudence,
the entirety of the enquiry cannot be vitiated on this count. Be that as
it may, it is peculiar that there is no particular explanation for absence
of endorsement qua petitioner’s signature and the impact thereof shall
be considered in the subsequent paragraphs.
21.
On merits, the finding of guilt is hedged on the evidence of the
management witnesses, who have categorically deposed that they
found 5 passengers travelling without ticket and affirmed that the
concerned passengers had corroborated the fact of non-issuance of
ticket in their statements.
22.
Perusal of the impugned award reflects that the learned Tribunal
has essentially limited itself to fairness of enquiry and assuaged itself
by recording that the enquiry proceedings bear the petitioner’s
signatures and he was afforded an opportunity to examine the
management witnesses who supported the allegations levelled against
him. It is imperative to note that merely because an enquiry is fair, the
same does not galvanise the findings from judicial scrutiny and it is
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
17:38:49
W.P.(C) 6632/2005
incumbent on the Tribunal to assess if the finding of guilt is justifiable
or if the same is perverse or arbitrary.
23.
The petitioner has pointed out certain glaring infirmities in
DTC’s case, which have not been considered by the learned Tribunal.
First, there is an apparent discrepancy in the challan given by the
checking officials and the challan available with the management.
Despite both the challans being available on record, no deference was
paid to the evident additions in the challan available with management
qua two used tickets being found in the petitioner’s possession, which
gave rise to the second charge of reselling tickets against him. Such an
embellishment
cannot
be
countenanced,
and
therefore,
the
consideration of this Court is hereby restricted to only the first charge
of non-issuance of ticket.
Second, it is also peculiar to note that even though the way bill
was closed at 97240, the unpunched tickets taken by checking staff are
from 97245 till 97249, which also casts doubt on the allegations
leveled against the petitioner.
Third, the most clinching infirmity of all is the fact that when
the cash was checked, instead of finding excess cash, a sum of ₹5.20/was found short instead. The shortage of cash is clearly inconsistent
with the case put up by DTC. Though DTC has sought to contest that
the workman had admitted receipt of ₹10 for issuance of 5 tickets in
his reply, it is pertinent to note that he had also mentioned therein that
he had issued the requisite tickets. Further, he had stated that he had
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
17:38:49
W.P.(C) 6632/2005
received ₹10/- from another passenger for 2 tickets, but was
intercepted from issuing tickets. He has further asserted there that the
unpunched tickets were taken forcibly.
24.
In such circumstances, on a holistic appraisal of facts, the
absence of endorsement on the passenger’s statements as to why the
petitioner did not sign the same casts further shadow on the veracity of
allegations, especially considering the complaint filed by one copassenger Ram Singh against the checking officials, which was
brushed aside by the Enquiry Officer. Pertinently, in the complaint,
the said passenger had mentioned that he had boarded the bus along
with his wife on the relevant day, and the checking staff had stopped
the conductor from giving tickets and misbehaved with the conductor
as well. Though finding of guilt can be sustained in absence of cash
verification, as there are serious unexplained inconsistencies and
infirmities in DTC’s case, this Court finds that DTC has failed to
prove the guilt on threshold of preponderance of probabilities.
25.
Although ordinarily High Court while exercising jurisdiction
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, would be loath to
interfere with consistent findings of guilt, this Court considers it
apposite to set aside the impugned award in the peculiar facts of the
present case.
26.
Insofar as relief is concerned, the petitioner workman had
worked with DTC for around 12 years and he has already expired.
Further, the termination dates back to the year 1990. At this juncture,
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
17:38:49
W.P.(C) 6632/2005
after more than 35 years, this Court is of the opinion that award of a
lump-sum compensation will meet the ends of justice. Consequently,
DTC is directed to pay a sum of ₹5,00,000/- to the legal heirs of the
petitioner within a period of 4 weeks.
27.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, the present petition is
allowed in the aforesaid terms.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J
SEPTEMBER 16, 2026
“SS”
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
17:38:49
W.P.(C) 6632/2005
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review