The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
5. Learned A.G.A. for the State as well does not dispute the above submissions made on behalf of applicants. He also admitted that the present proceedings may also be quashed in terms of the above order order.
6. Once that be so, this Court does not find any occasion for the impugned proceeding to be pursued any further. Consequently, the Sessions Case No. 2618 of 2025, State Vs. Rakesh Yadav and others, arising out of Case Crime No. 809 of 2023, under Section 2(b)(i), 3(1) of U.P. Gangsters and Anti Social Activities (Prevention) Act, Police station Gulariha, District Gorakhpur, pending in the court of learned Additional Session Judge/ Special Judge, Anti Corruption (U.P.S.E.B.), Gorakhpur, so far as it relates to the present applicants, is hereby quashed and the present application filed under Section 528 BNSS is, accordingly, allowed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
APPLICATION U/S 528 BNSS No. - 49391 of 2026
Dhanesh Yadav And Another
.....Applicant(s)
Versus
State of U.P. and Another
.....Opposite
Party(s)
Counsel for Applicant(s)
Counsel for Opposite Party(s)
:
:
Mohd. Shoeb Khan
G.A.
Court No. - 73
HON'BLE DR. GAUTAM CHOWDHARY, J.
1. Heard learned counsel for the applicants, learned A.G.A. for the State and
perused the material brought on record.
2. This application under Section 528 BNSS has been filed quashing of
charge sheet dated 23.05.2024, cognizance/ summoning order dated
01.11.2025 as well as entire proceeding of Sessions Case No. 2618 of 2025,
State Vs. Rakesh Yadav and others, arising out of Case Crime No. 809 of
2023, under Section 2(b)(i), 3(1) of U.P. Gangsters and Anti Social
Activities (Prevention) Act, Police station Gulariha, District Gorakhpur,
pending in the court of learned Additional Session Judge/ Special Judge,
Anti Corruption (U.P.S.E.B.), Gorakhpur.
3. Learned counsel for the applicants submits that the other co-accused,
Bechu Yadav and 2 others, have also approached this Court by filing
Application u/s 528 BNSS No. 47834 of 2026, challenging therein the entire
proceeding initiated against them arising out of same crime, which
applicantion has been allowed by this Court vide order dated 30.10.2026
while quashing the entire proceeding initiated against the said co-accused
persons. Thus, learned counsel submits that the present proceeding initiated
against the applicants, who are before this Court, may also be quashed in
view of the order dated 30.10.2026 passed in the said application.
4. The order dated 30.10.2026 passed in Application u/s 528 BNSS No.
47834 of 2026 (Bechu Yadav and 2 others Vs. State of U.P. and another,
reads as under:
1.Heard learned counsel for the applicants, learned Additional
Government Advocate (A.G.A.) for the State, and perused the
record.
NA528 No. 49391 of 2026
2. The present application has been filed seeking for quashing of
the entire proceedings Session Case No. 2618 of 2025 (State Vs.
Rakesh yadav and others), arising out of Case Crime No. 809 of
2023, under Section 2(b)(i), 3(1) of the Uttar Pradesh Gangsters
and Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 1986, (hereinafter to
be referred to as ?the Act) Police Station Gulriha, District
Gorakhpur, pending before learned Additional Session
Judge/Special Judge P.C. Act (U.P.S.E.B.), Gangster Act,
Gorakhpur as well as to quash the charge sheet dated 23.05.2024
and also the Cognizance/Summoning order dated 01.11.2025
passed in the aforesaid case.
3. The germane facts of the case are that a first information
report has been lodged in Case Crime No. 809 of 2023, under
Section 2(b)(i), 3(1) of the Act, at Police Station Gulriha, District
Gorakhpur, wherein it has been averred that the applicants along
with the co-accused have formed an organized criminal gang,
who are engaged either collectively or individually are
repeatedly indulged in anti-social and violent activities within the
territorial limits of the District for their personal gain. It is
further averred that by unleashing terror, fear in the locality, the
applicants and the co-accused disrupted public peace and
created such panic that innocent members of the public are
deterred from coming forward to depose or lodge complaints
against them through ordinary legal machinery. A gang chart
was prepared, wherein the details of the criminal cases pending
against the applicants have been described. Upon approval of the
Gang chart by the concerned authorities, F.I.R. has been lodged
against the applicants and the co-accused under the Act. The
matter was entrusted for investigation, the investigating officer
after collecting credible evidence oral as well as documentary
evidence, disclosing prima facie complicity of the applicants as
an active member of the gang, the investigation culminated in
submission of charge sheet, upon which learned trial Court took
cognizance vide order impugned and therefore the applicants are
before this Court challenging the entire proceedings as well as
charge sheet and cognizance order, as detailed in the preceding
paragraph.
4. Learned counsel for the applicants has contended that merely
on the basis of case(s) shown against the applicant in the gang
chart, Gangsters Act has been imposed upon the applicants.
Learned counsel further argued that the applicants are neither a
gang leader nor they are member of any gang and that the
applicants never acted or conducted themselves as such. He
further submits that the Act of 1986 merely defines the status of
accused-applicants indulging in a crime, specified in the
definition clause as a "gangster" going by the definition of
"gang" and "gangsters" provided respectively under sub-sections
NA528 No. 49391 of 2026
(b) and (c) of Section 2. Learned counsel thus argued that the Act
of 1986 does not create a crime/offence. Apart from the aforesaid
submission, learned counsel also argued that the gang chart
merely demonstrates the involvement of the applicants in a crime,
as specified under the clauses of Section 2(b) of the Act of 1986
for which punishment is already prescribed. He thus submits that
Gangsters Act has been roped upon the applicants without an
offence being created. It is the settled principle in law that there
can be no punishment without an offence in law. Learned counsel
has placed reliance upon a reported decision of Hon'ble Apex
Court rendered in the matter of Shiv Pratap Singh alias Chinu
Vs. State of U.P. and others passed in Criminal Appeal No. 3979
of 2026: 2026 INSC 894.
5. Learned Additional Government Advocate has vehemently
opposed the application and submitted that the charge sheet has
been filed after a comprehensive and fair investigation which
reveals sufficient credible material substantiating the applicants?
complicity in organized gang activities. It is contended that the
statutory requirements prescribed under the Gangsters Act and
the Rules of 2021 were strictly adhered to; the gang-chart was
prepared collectively incorporating the substantive base cases of
the gang members and was duly approved by the competent
administrative authorities, upon joint satisfaction.
6. Learned A.G.A. further contends that even a solitary criminal
antecedent or collective base cases satisfy the threshold under
Section 2(b) of the Act, and that the learned trial court, having
found a prima facie case disclosing the commission of the
offence, rightly took cognizance and summoned the applicants,
which calls for no interference by this Court, in exercise of
powers conferred under Section 528 BNSS. However, learned
A.G.A. could not dispute the ratio of the Hon'ble Apex Court in
the matter of Shiv Pratap Singh alias Chinu (supra).
7. I have heard learned counsel for the applicants, learned
A.G.A. and perused the material on record.
8. The Hon'ble Apex Court in the matter of Shiv Pratap Singh
alias Chinu (supra) thoroughly analyzed the foundational
architecture of the U.P. Act 1986 Act and in paragraph nos.43,
52, 54 held as under:43. "?.... what is obviously absent in the U.P. Act is a provision
determining the offence as one created under the Act. After
defining gang, which includes commission of the offences listed
under sub-clauses (i) to (xxv) and defining gangster as a member
or leader or organiser of a gang, the punishment is prescribed for
a gangster without an offence being created by statute; which
makes the penal act, stillborn."
NA528 No. 49391 of 2026
"52. Article 20(1) encapsulates the principle of "nullum crimen
nulla poena sine lege", (No crime or punishment can exist
without a penal law); there can be no punishment without an
offence in law. As we found, the Act of 1986 does not create a
crime/offence and it merely defines the status of a person
indulging in a crime, specified in the definition clause, as a
'gangster' going by the definition of 'gang' and 'gangster'
provided respectively under sub-sections (b) and (c) of Section 2.
The status is also determined not by a procedure in the enactment
but a prescription made in the Rules. The power to frame Rules is
found from the Act, in Section 23, which enables the State
Government to make rules for carrying out the purposes of this
Act and to provide any contravention of the Rules to be
punishable with a term of imprisonment not exceeding 6 months,
with or without fine, not exceeding Rs.1,000/-. The Rules
provided for a Gang Chart to be prepared by the police,
recommended through its hierarchy and approved in a joint
meeting of the higher authorities of the Police and the head of the
District Administration. The preparation of the Gang Chart and
the involvement in a crime, as specified under the clauses of
Section 2(b) determines the status of a person, as a gangster, for
which punishment is prescribed, as we time and again observed
in this very same judgment; without an offence being created."
"54. A 'gangster' is defined under the Act and the determination
of who a gangster is, for the purpose of punishment, is as
prescribed in the Rules, left to the ipsi dixit of the Executive. The
creation of crime, or to make an act or omission subject to penal
consequences as an offence, is essentially a legislative function
and it cannot be thrown away and left to sprout in the thickets of
subordinate legislation. As we noticed, the provisions of the Act
could lead to a detention of the accused without trial for long,
which is akin to a statute enjoining preventive detention. Though
preventive detention has been held to be permissible even in the
teeth of Article 21, the same is hedged with safeguards, which are
held to be sacrosanct and even a minor procedural violation
would entail release of the detenu. The safeguards in preventive
detention are numerous, since it is the subjective satisfaction of
the Administration and the Police that leads to a detention, the
period in which such detention continues being the exclusive
premise of the State Government, who also has the authority to
release the detenu at any point of time. The period provided in
which such detention order has to be forwarded to the State
Government; the materials to be supplied to the detenu; the right
of representation to the various authorities, at every stage, as
granted to the detenu; the reference to an Advisory Board
constituted by statute and the decision to be arrived there at
within a time frame, mitigates and erases to an extent the rigour
& malice of subjectivity, which subjectivity pervades a preventive
NA528 No. 49391 of 2026
detention order. The subject enactment, the U.P. Act not only
permits detention for a period without anything more than the
inclusion in a Gang Chart but also enables a trial and
punishment on the basis of the very same Gang Chart, in addition
to the pre-trial incarceration, but without an offence being
created by the Act itself. It is akin to the English proverb: 'Give a
dog a bad name and hang him'.
9. The Hon'ble Apex Court has authoritatively held that the Act
suffers from an incurable statutory defect by prescribing penal
consequences for being a "gangster" under Section 3 without
actually enacting, creating, or defining an independent
substantive offence under the statute. The executive apparatus
and subordinate rules cannot be permitted to supply or
manufacture a penal offence where the parent statute has failed
to create the same. Furthermore, the practice of preparing an
omnibus gang chart wherein cases are collectively incorporated
and approved routinely by executive authorities without
establishing independent statutory culpability cannot validate an
otherwise unconstitutional prosecution. When the foundational
statute itself has been declared "stillborn" for the purposes of
prosecuting individuals under Sections 2 and 3 of the Act,
initiating or continuing criminal trials solely grounded on the
inclusion of an accused in an administrative gang-chart is
impermissible and amounts to a sheer abuse of the process of law
and therefore, in the light of the law laid down by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Shiv Pratap Singh alias Chinu (supra), this
Court finds that the continuation of criminal proceedings against
the applicants under the provisions of the Act cannot be legally
sustained, having no statutory base to stand on and thus the same
is liable to be quashed.
10. In view of the above, the entire proceedings of Session Case
No. 2618 of 2025 (State Vs. Rakesh yadav and others), arising
out of Case Crime No. 809 of 2023, under Section 2(b)(i), 3(1) of
the Uttar Pradesh Gangsters and Anti-Social Activities
(Prevention) Act, 1986, Police Station Gulriha, District
Gorakhpur, pending before learned Additional Session
Judge/Special Judge P.C. Act (U.P.S.E.B.), Gangster Act,
Gorakhpur as well as the charge sheet dated 23.05.2024 and also
the Cognizance/Summoning order dated 01.11.2025 passed in the
aforesaid case are hereby quashed, as against the applicants.
11. Accordingly, the instant application is allowed.
12. It is clarified that this order shall not affect, impede, or
prejudice any pending trial, investigation, or proceedings against
the applicants in the underlying base case(s) under the general
penal law, which shall proceed to their logical conclusion on
their own merits in accordance with law."
NA528 No. 49391 of 2026
5. Learned A.G.A. for the State as well does not dispute the above
submissions made on behalf of applicants. He also admitted that the present
proceedings may also be quashed in terms of the above order order.
6. Once that be so, this Court does not find any occasion for the impugned
proceeding to be pursued any further. Consequently, the Sessions Case No.
2618 of 2025, State Vs. Rakesh Yadav and others, arising out of Case Crime
No. 809 of 2023, under Section 2(b)(i), 3(1) of U.P. Gangsters and Anti
Social Activities (Prevention) Act, Police station Gulariha, District
Gorakhpur, pending in the court of learned Additional Session Judge/
Special Judge, Anti Corruption (U.P.S.E.B.), Gorakhpur, so far as it relates
to the present applicants, is hereby quashed and the present application filed
under Section 528 BNSS is, accordingly, allowed.
7. It is clarified that this order shall not affect, impede, or prejudice any
pending trial, investigation, or proceedings against the applicants in the
underlying base case(s) under the general penal law, which shall proceed to
their logical conclusion on their own merits in accordance with law.
(Dr. Gautam Chowdhary,J.)
November 4, 2026
Mustaqeem./Rahul
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review