Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on
Pronounced on
Uploaded on
%
+
: 27.01.2026
: 10.04.2026
: 10.04.2026
FAO 359/2025
DHANANJAY RATHI & ORS.
.....Appellants
Through: Mr. Jayant Mehta, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Tanuj Gulati, Mr. Abhishek Garg,
Mr.Saksham Verma, Mr.Yogesh,
Mr.Udan, Mr.Aman, Mr.Dipanshu,
Mr. Lokesh Kr. and Mr.Harsh Rai,
Advocates
versus
GREEN ACRE FARMS PVT LTD THROUGH ITS AUTHORIZED
REPRESENTATIVE & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr.Dayan Krishnan, Sr. Advocate,
Mr.Manish Jha, Sr. Advocate with
Mr.Rajat Juneja, Mr.Devna Soni and
Mr.Ashish Garg, Advocates
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
JUDGMENT
CM APPL.81666/2025
1.
Allowed, subject to all just exceptions.
2.
This application is disposed of.
FAO 359/2025 & CM APPL.81667/2025 [for ad-interim injunction]
1.
The appellants, who were the defendants before the Trial Court, seek
to impugn order dated 06.10.2025, whereby their application filed under
Order XXXIX Rule 4 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:16:51
FAO 359/2025
Pg. 1 of 11
1908, was dismissed. The impugned order has been passed in the context of
a suit filed by the respondents/plaintiffs seeking specific performance of an
agreement/MOU dated 09.04.2021, along with reliefs of perpetual and
mandatory injunction.
2.
For the sake of convenience, the appellants are hereinafter referred to
as the „Defendants‟ and respondents as „Plaintiffs‟.
3.
In the suit, the Plaintiffs have alleged to have entered into an
agreement dated 09.04.2021 (“the Agreement”), with the late Mr. Deepak
Rathi, who is stated to be the predecessor-in-interest of the defendants. It is
their case that Mr. Deepak Rathi is the father of defendant nos. 1, 2, and
husband of defendant no.3, and the predecessor-in-interest of the remaining
defendants.
4.
The Agreement pertained to the following lands.
a.
Agricultural land as measuring 2 Bighas 5 Biswas and 7
Biswansi, comprised in Khasra Nos. 763 Min (0-18-3), 767
Min (0-18-3) and 768 Min (0-9-1), situated in the Revenue
Estate of Village Ghitorni, Tehsil Vasant Vihar, New Delhi
(Specifically referred to as Land Parcel 1 and marked in orange
color in the site plan); and
b.
Agricultural land measuring 2 Bighas 16 Biswas and 16
Biswansi, comprised in Khasra Nos. 245/1/2 Min (0-9-1),
246/1/2 Min (0-18-3), 249/1 Min (0-12-12) and 249 Min (017), situated in the Revenue Estate of Village Aya Nagar,
Tehsil Mehrauli, New Delhi. (Specifically referred to as Land
Parcel 2 and marked in orange color in the site plan).
The above two parcels of land comprise of the Suit Property.
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:16:51
FAO 359/2025
Pg. 2 of 11
5.
As per the Agreement, Plaintiffs agreed to construct a motorable road
on the Subject Land, extending from the existing 60 feet wide Anandgram
Road till the lands of the plaintiffs, for common use of the parties.
6.
Plaintiffs and Defendants are stated to be residing in Khasra Nos.
741,742,740/1,740/2,739/1,739/2, 744, and 745 and 763, 767, 768, 762, 769
of land parcel 1, and, of Land parcel 2 - 245/1/2, 246/1/2, 249 and 249,
respectively. According to the Plaintiffs, the Suit Land was acquired by
them to enjoy easementary rights on their aforesaid residential property,
which had motorable access only through the proposed road to be
constructed on the part of Suit Land. Late Mr. Deepak Rathi too could use
the proposed road to access his residence. Parties, therefore, for common
use, purpose and convenience, decided to construct the proposed common
motorable road in the manner set out in the Agreement.
7.
As per the alleged Agreement, the following was, inter alia, agreed
upon between the contracting parties:
i.
The Plaintiffs/First Party were to construct and develop the subject
land into a motorable common road/rasta at their own cost and
expense;
ii.
The said road was to be used as a common access by both parties,
with perpetual and uninterrupted right of way for ingress and
egress to their respective lands;
iii.
neither party was to obstruct, interfere with, or create any thirdparty rights in the subject land inconsistent with its use as a
common road; and
iv.
upon completion of construction of the road, the Second Party was
to execute necessary documents for transfer of Land Parcel No. 1
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:16:51
FAO 359/2025
Pg. 3 of 11
in favour of the Plaintiffs/First Party.
8.
Soon after the signing of the Agreement, Mr. Deepak Rathi passed
away on 01.06.2021, however, the Plaintiffs, acting on the Agreement, and
in consideration of the promised transfer of Land Parcel No 1 in their
favour, constructed and developed a common motorable road/rasta
extending from the existing 60 feet wide Anandgram road till the lands of
the Plaintiffs for the common benefit of them and the Defendants on the Suit
Land, between May to October 2022, when the construction was completed.
Plaintiffs claim to have spent an expense of around Rs.80,00,000/- on the
construction of the road.
9.
It is claimed by the Plaintiffs that the parties started using the road in
question as a common facility in terms of the Agreement. However, upon
the Plaintiff requesting the Defendants to execute the necessary documents
for transfer Land Parcel No. 1 in their favour, the Defendants started making
unreasonable demands from the Plaintiffs in breach of the Agreement.
10.
It is further alleged by the Plaintiffs that Defendants started
obstructing the use of the road by the Plaintiff. It is alleged that the hired
anti-social elements of the Defendants obstructed the Plaintiffs and
complaints were filed on several occasions on to local police on 27.02.2023
and thereafter on 04.03.2023, 07.03.2023 and 15.03, 2023.
11.
It is further alleged in the suit that the Defendants actions are in
breach of the Agreement and it is apprehended by the Plaintiffs that the
Defendants might completely block the Plaintiffs from using the road in
question or they might create third party rights in the Land Parcel No 1,
thereby depriving the Plaintiffs of the Suit Land.
12.
In these circumstances the suit has been filed by the Plaintiffs seeking
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:16:51
FAO 359/2025
Pg. 4 of 11
the relief of specific performance of the Agreement dated 09.04.2021, along
with perpetual and mandatory injunctions.
13.
The Defendants have vehemently opposed the claims made in the
plaint, so much so that The Agreement itself has been alleged to be forged
and fabricated. The Defendants have denied the signatures of Late Mr.
Deepak Rathi on the Agreement and have alleged that the Plaintiffs have
forged the Agreement in order to illegally usurp the Suit Land. It is claimed
that Mr. Deepak Rathi was suffering from Covid-19 in the pandemic around
the time when the alleged Agreement is claimed to have been signed.
14.
Defendant has relied upon a forensic report dated 17.04.2023 from
Truth Labs, which is a private forensic agency which has opined that Mr.
Deepak Rathi’s signature on the Agreement appears to be electronically
reproduced. The Defendants use the said forensic report in support of their
allegation of forgery and fabrication.
15.
Defendants have also questioned the incredulity of the Agreement
contending that the Land Parcel No 1 being of substantially higher value,
could not have been agreed to be transferred for a meagre amount of Rs.
80,00,000, the consideration amount mentioned as the cost of construction,
which was for the purpose of specific performance only.
16.
In their written statement, the Defendants have also contended that the
Agreement being unregistered cannot be enforced.
17.
The Defendants have denied that the road has been constructed by the
Plaintiffs, and have rather claimed that the same was done by them, on
which considerable amounts have been spent. The Defendants have relied
upon some quotations from a contractor to show the road construction work
undertaken by them, thereby refuting the claim to the contrary made by the
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:16:51
FAO 359/2025
Pg. 5 of 11
Plaintiffs.
18.
The Defendants have objected to the ex-parte interim order passed by
the Trial Court- alleging haste shown by the Trial Court. It is their case that
the notice in the suit was issued on 25.03.2023 for 27.03.2023. Service was
not effected upon the Defendants whereas the Trial Court recorded deemed
service of the Defendants on the ground of alleged refusal of service by the
Defendants. According to the Defendants, the Trial Court ought to have
ordered issuance of fresh process on the Defendants rather than recording
deemed service at the very first instance. In this regard, reliance is placed on
Dorab Cawasji Warden vs Coomi Sorab Warden & Or s1.
19.
Countering the Defendant‟s allegation, Mr. Krishanan, learned Senior
counsel, who appears on behalf of the Plaintiffs, submits that the defendants
have suppressed various material facts from this court inasmuch as though
the reliance has been placed on the written statement, however, the same
itself has not come on record of the Trial Court as the same was filed beyond
the permissible time and application for condonation of delay is still pending
consideration. It was next submitted that the Defendants have failed to
challenge the ex parte order and the present appeal is filed to circumvent the
hurdle of limitation by now seeking vacation of the ex parte injunction order
dated 27.03.2023.
20.
On merits, it is contended that the plaint was accompanied by
photographs of the constructed road. The Defendants‟ reliance on the report
of Truth Labs was also assailed on the ground that the same being procured
by the Defendnat from a private lab and the conclusion arrived whereof are
contested by the Plaintiffs. Reliance is also placed on Mariam Fasihuddin v.
(1990) 2 SCC 117
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:16:51
FAO 359/2025
Pg. 6 of 11
State of Karnataka2, where the Supreme Court observed that a paid report
from a private laboratory is unsafe and untrustworthy. Lastly, on a demurrer,
it is contended that though the written statement has not come on record,
even the WhatsApp chats filed along with the written statement would show
that the understanding between the parties was for entering into some kind
of argument with respect to construction of a road. Clause (2) of MOU
provided that the original agreement was kept by the Defendants. Referring
to Section 2(d) of the Indian Contract Act 1872, it was stated that the sale
consideration was in fact the cost of the construction of the motorable
road/rasta itself.
21.
In rejoinder, Mr. Mehta has referred to an earlier suit CS(OS)
2488/2014, (renumbered as Civil Suit No.59396 of 2016) filed by the
Plaintiffs against Late Mr. Deepak Rathi, in relation to the Suit Land and
some other parcels of land in the vicinity. In the said suit the Plaintiffs had
alleged to have entered into an agreement dated 21.02.2013 with Mr.
Deepak Rathi, for exchange of land parcels inter-se between the parties. The
suit was resisted by Mr. Deepak Rathi, forcing the Plaintiff to withdraw the
suit. Mr. Mehta would argue that the present suit is a second attempt to
usurp the Suit Land by the Plaintiffs, having failed in the first attempt, as
stated above. It is argued that the Plaintiffs have been using forged
documents to illegally usurp the Suit Land.
22.
To counter the Plaintiff‟s argument that the ex-parte injunction order
dated 27.03.2023 has not been challenged by the Defendants, it is submitted
by the Defendants that they had sought vacation of injunction order under
Order 39 Rule 4 of the Code of Civil Procedure,1908, which is a remedy
(2024) 11 SCC 733
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:16:51
FAO 359/2025
Pg. 7 of 11
permissible in law.
23.
After examining the rival contentions, this Court does not find any
infirmity in the impugned order.
24.
The original interim injunction order was passed ex-parte on
27.03.2023 restraining the Defendants from creating any interruption in the
access of the plaintiffs to their respective lands and also restrained any
construction or creating any third party interest in the suit land. In this
order, the Trial Court prima facie found merit in the case set up by the
Plaintiffs asserting their rights under the Agreement. The Court, balancing
the convenience of the parties, came to the conclusion that pending the
adjudication of the suit, the use of the disputed road should not be denied to
the Plaintiff. After examining the provisions of the Agreement, and the
material on record, the trial court concluded that the Plaintiffs had
constructed the road under the Agreement, and were entitled to its use
without any interference from the Defendants. The Trial Court recorded, the
following findings:
i.
that the balance of convenience lies in favour of the Plaintiffs
as they have acted upon the Agreement dated 09.04.2021;
ii.
that there is nothing on record, at this stage, to show that the
Defendants had approached any legal authority when the
alleged development/construction activity was undertaken by
the Plaintiffs;
iii.
that there is no material on record to indicate that the
Defendants had taken any steps to challenge the Agreement as
being false or fabricated;
iv.
that the order dated 27.03.2023 only granted motorable access
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:16:51
FAO 359/2025
Pg. 8 of 11
over the suit land and preserved the property, and did not
warrant interference at this stage; and
v.
that no change in circumstances or undue hardship, as required
under Order XXXIX Rule 4 of The code of Civil Procedure,
1908, was made out so as to justify variation or vacation of the
injunction.
25.
The Trial Court leaned in favour of maintaining status quo regarding
the use of the road by the parties, rather than denying the Plaintiffs such use,
for which the Trial Court did not have any reasons to reach such conclusion.
The order was passed ex-parte so the Trial Court rightly proceeded based on
the material available on record.
There is no reason for this Court to
conclude otherwise.
26.
It is contended by the Defendants that the Trial Court showed undue
haste in passing the interim order dated 27.03.2023 ex-parte. However, it is
pertinent to note that the order was passed ex-parte, based on the service
report, received by the Trial Court. In the impugned order dated 06.10.2025
rejecting the Defendant‟s application under Order 39 Rule 4 of the Code of
Civil Procedure,1908, it is recorded by the Trial Court that mere bald denial
by the Defendants of service is not sufficient to conclude that service was
not effected. The trial court observed that the address of the Defendants
provided in the plaint was not denied by the Defendants. There was no
reason offered by the Defendants explaining why service could not be have
been effected on the given addresses. For the said reason the Trial Court‟s
finding regarding service cannot be faulted with.
27.
While deciding the Defendants application under Order 39 rule 4, the
Trial Court has observed that the Defendants allegation of forgery regarding
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:16:51
FAO 359/2025
Pg. 9 of 11
the Agreement, is a triable issue, that will require adjudication. The Trial
Court in its discretion has chosen not to give much weightage to the forensic
opinion by a private lab, at this stage, and weighing the evidence, has found
prima facie merit in the Plaintiffs case.
28.
Mr. Deepak Rathi, whose signatures are alleged to be forged, is
unfortunately dead, the issue would require the parties to lead credible and
conclusive evidence, to prove their respective contentions. There is nothing
legally wrong in the Trial Court‟s discretion in not discarding the Agreement
at this interim and preliminary stage.
29.
The Trial Court has referred to the material in support of its prima
facie finding regarding construction of road by the Plaintiff and the monies
spent by them. The Defendants rival claim would require a detailed trial and
it can‟t be ignored that the written statement of the Defendant is not on
record yet.
30.
In the opinion of this Court, the Trial Court has no reason to vacate
the interim injunction order dated 27.03.2023 merely based on the
unsubstantiated denials of the Defendants, at this pre-trial stage.
31.
As stated above, the Trial Court has decided to grant discretionary
relief of interim injunction, based on the existence of the triple test i.e.,
prima facie case, balance of convenience and irreparable loss.
32.
The Defendants have not been able to demonstrate absence of any of
the above three conditions. The Trial Court has prima facie found merit in
favour of the Plaintiffs. Since the Plaintiffs demonstrated use of the road
since May 2021, the Trial Court found the balance of convenience in favour
of the Plaintiffs. Yielding to the easementary rights of the Plaintiffs, in the
discretion of the Trial Court, denial of use of the common road, would result
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:16:51
FAO 359/2025
Pg. 10 of 11
in irreparable loss.
33.
In view thereof, this Appellate Court has no reason to interfere with
the discretion exercised by the Trial Court. There is no legal infirmity in the
impugned order.
34.
Accordingly, the present appeal is hereby dismissed alongwith the
application.
(MANOJ KUMAR OHRI)
JUDGE
APRIL 10, 2026
pmc
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:16:51
FAO 359/2025
Pg. 11 of 11
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review