Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 10th August 2026
%
#
CNR No. DLHC012080192014
+
MAC.APP. 262/2015
DEVINDER YADAV
.....Appellant
Through:
Mr. Navneet Goyal, Advocate.
versus
PRAVEEN KHANNA & ANR (NATIONAL INSURANCE
COMPANY)
.....Respondents
Through: Ms. Shruti Jain, Advocate for Mr.
Pankaj Seth, Advocate for Insurance
Company.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J (ORAL)
1.
This appeal has been filed seeking enhancement of compensation
awarded vide judgment/award dated 09th July 2014 passed by the Motor
Accident
Claims
Tribunal,
Patiala
House
Courts,
New
Delhi
(‘MACT/Tribunal’) in MACT No.95/2011, awarding compensation of
Rs.7,88,553/- along with 7.5% interest.
2.
The accident in question occurred on 04th April 2010 at about 06:40
a.m., when appellant/injured claimant, was travelling in TSR. When he
reached near K.G. Marg, India Gate Outer Circle, one Santro car bearing
registration no. DL-6CG-8692 (hereinafter, ‘offending vehicle’) driven in a
rash and negligent manner at a high speed, hit the TSR causing the TSR to
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP.262/2015
By:MANISH KUMAR
18:55:06
overturn. Appellant/injured claimant sustained grievous spinal injuries
resulting in 90% permanent physical impairment.
3.
Mr. Navneet Goyal, counsel for appellant/injured claimant, claims
enhancement of compensation on the following counts: first, functional
disability has been assessed at 45%, despite having suffered 90%
permanent physical impairment arising out of a fracture of the spine.
Appellant/injured claimant was 19 years of age, working as a peon at the
time of the accident. Second, that the non-pecuniary damages for loss of
amenities and pain and suffering have been awarded at Rs.50,000/- only,
despite the appellant/injured claimant having suffered 90% permanent
physical impairment. Third, that the attendant charges have not been
awarded despite injuries resulting in paraplegia.
4.
Disability certificate is exhibited as Ex.PW1/2 which states that,
“Mr. Devender Yadav is a case of fracture of D12 vertebra with complete
paraplegia with bowel and bladder involvement. His permanent disability
is 90%”. The impugned award noted in paragraph 17 that appellant/injured
claimant had a long treatment record. MACT considered Ex.PW1/2 and
assessed the functional disability at 45%.
5.
In Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar (2011) 1 SCC 343, the Supreme Court
held that the Tribunal must assess not merely the extent of permanent
disability but its actual impact on the claimant’s earning capacity, which
may differ from the medical percentage of disability. This requires
evaluating the claimant’s pre-accident vocation, the functions affected, and
whether livelihood can still be earned despite the disability. The Court
emphasised that disability and loss of earning capacity are distinct
concepts, except in cases where evidence shows they coincide. Relevant
paragraphs are extracted as under:
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP.262/2015
By:MANISH KUMAR
18:55:06
“11. What requires to be assessed by the Tribunal is
the effect of the permanent disability on the earning
capacity of the injured; and after assessing the loss of
earning capacity in terms of a percentage of the
income, it has to be quantified in terms of money, to
arrive at the future loss of earnings (by applying the
standard multiplier method used to determine loss of
dependency). We may however note that in some cases,
on appreciation of evidence and assessment, the
Tribunal may find that the percentage of loss of
earning capacity as a result of the permanent
disability, is approximately the same as the percentage
of permanent disability in which case, of course, the
Tribunal will adopt the said percentage for
determination of compensation. (See for example, the
decisions of this Court in Arvind Kumar Mishra v. New
India Assurance Co. Ltd. [(2010) 10 SCC 254 : (2010)
3 SCC (Cri) 1258 : (2010) 10 Scale 298] and Yadava
Kumar v. National Insurance Co. Ltd. [(2010) 10 SCC
341 : (2010) 3 SCC (Cri) 1285 : (2010) 8 Scale 567])
12. Therefore, the Tribunal has to first decide whether
there is any permanent disability and, if so, the extent
of such permanent disability. This means that the
Tribunal should consider and decide with reference to
the evidence:
(i) whether the disablement is permanent or
temporary;
(ii) if the disablement is permanent, whether it is
permanent total disablement or permanent partial
disablement;
(iii) if the disablement percentage is expressed with
reference to any specific limb, then the effect of such
disablement of the limb on the functioning of the entire
body, that is, the permanent disability suffered by the
person.
If the Tribunal concludes that there is no permanent
disability then there is no question of proceeding
further and determining the loss of future earning
capacity. But if the Tribunal concludes that there is
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP.262/2015
By:MANISH KUMAR
18:55:06
permanent disability then it will proceed to ascertain
its extent. After the Tribunal ascertains the actual
extent of permanent disability of the claimant based on
the medical evidence, it has to determine whether such
permanent disability has affected or will affect his
earning capacity.
13. Ascertainment of the effect of the permanent
disability on the actual earning capacity involves three
steps. The Tribunal has to first ascertain what
activities the claimant could carry on in spite of the
permanent disability and what he could not do as a
result of the permanent disability (this is also relevant
for awarding compensation under the head of loss of
amenities of life). The second step is to ascertain his
avocation, profession and nature of work before the
accident, as also his age. The third step is to find out
whether (i) the claimant is totally disabled from
earning any kind of livelihood, or (ii) whether in spite
of the permanent disability, the claimant could still
effectively carry on the activities and functions, which
he was earlier carrying on, or (iii) whether he was
prevented or restricted from discharging his previous
activities and functions, but could carry on some other
or lesser scale of activities and functions so that he
continues to earn or can continue to earn his
livelihood.”
(emphasis added)
6.
In Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar (supra), the Court summarized the
principles, which are extracted as under:
“19. We may now summarise the principles discussed
above:
(i) All injuries (or permanent disabilities arising from
injuries), do not result in loss of earning capacity.
(ii) The percentage of permanent disability with
reference to the whole body of a person, cannot be
assumed to be the percentage of loss of earning
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP.262/2015
By:MANISH KUMAR
18:55:06
capacity. To put it differently, the percentage of loss of
earning capacity is not the same as the percentage of
permanent disability (except in a few cases, where the
Tribunal on the basis of evidence, concludes that the
percentage of loss of earning capacity is the same as
the percentage of permanent disability).
(iii) The doctor who treated an injured claimant or
who examined him subsequently to assess the extent of
his permanent disability can give evidence only in
regard to the extent of permanent disability. The loss of
earning capacity is something that will have to be
assessed by the Tribunal with reference to the evidence
in entirety.
(iv) The same permanent disability may result in
different percentages of loss of earning capacity in
different persons, depending upon the nature of
profession, occupation or job, age, education and
other factors.”
(emphasis added)
7.
In the opinion of this Court, the testimony of appellant/injured
claimant must be sustained, considering the nature of his injuries.
Considering that he had been diagnosed with paraplegia with bowel and
bladder movement with 90% permanent physical disability, it would be in
the fitness of things that the permanent disability is considered at 90%
itself. Considering that the claimant would not have any opportunity to get
involved in any vocation, whatsoever, aside from working as a peon, which
was his vocation at the time of the accident.
8.
Considering the nature of his injuries, non-pecuniary compensation
awarded for pain and suffering and loss of amenities is highly inadequate
and ought to be enhanced to Rs.2,00,000/- each.
9.
As regards the issue of attendant charges, reliance may be placed
upon the decision of Supreme Court in Kajal v. Jagdish Chand, (2020) 4
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP.262/2015
By:MANISH KUMAR
18:55:06
SCC 413, which was a case involving injuries sustained by a minor child,
which had rendered her bedridden for life. Her disability was assessed at
100%, noting that she was left with a very low IQ, severe weakness in all
four limbs, hysteria and urinary incontinence. In order to award just
compensation, while assessing compensation towards attendant charges,
the Supreme Court applied the multiplier method, recognizing it to be
reasonable and realistic method. Relevant paragraphs are extracted as under
for ease of reference:
“Attendant charges
22. The attendant charges have been awarded by the
High Court @ Rs 2500 per month for 44 years, which
works out to Rs 13,20,000. Unfortunately, this system
is not a proper system. Multiplier system is used to
balance out various factors. When compensation is
awarded in lump sum, various factors are taken into
consideration. When compensation is paid in lump
sum, this Court has always followed the multiplier
system. The multiplier system should be followed not
only for determining the compensation on account of
loss of income but also for determining the attendant
charges, etc. This system was recognised by this Court
in Gobald
Motor
Service
Ltd. v. R.M.K.
Veluswami [Gobald Motor Service Ltd. v. R.M.K.
Veluswami, AIR 1962 SC 1]. The multiplier system
factors in the inflation rate, the rate of interest payable
on the lump sum award, the longevity of the claimant,
and also other issues such as the uncertainties of life.
Out of all the various alternative methods, the
multiplier method has been recognised as the most
realistic and reasonable method. It ensures better
justice between the parties and thus results in award of
“just compensation” within the meaning of the Act.
23. It would be apposite at this stage to refer to the
observation
of
Lord
Reid
in Taylor v. O'Connor [Taylor v. O'Connor, 1971 AC
115 : (1970) 2 WLR 472 (HL)] : (AC p. 128)
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP.262/2015
By:MANISH KUMAR
18:55:06
“Damages to make good the loss of dependency
over a period of years must be awarded as a lump
sum and that sum is generally calculated by
applying a multiplier to the amount of one year's
dependency. That is a perfectly good method in
the ordinary case but it conceals the fact that
there are two quite separate matters involved —
the present value of the series of future payments,
and the discounting of that present value to allow
for the fact that for one reason or another the
person receiving the damages might never have
enjoyed the whole of the benefit of the
dependency. It is quite unnecessary in the
ordinary case to deal with these matters
separately. Judges and counsel have a wealth of
experience which is an adequate guide to the
selection of the multiplier and any expert evidence
is rightly discouraged. But in a case where the
facts are special I think that these matters must
have separate consideration if even rough justice
is to be done and expert evidence may be valuable
or even almost essential. The special factor in the
present case is the incidence of income tax and, it
may be, surtax.”
24. This Court has reaffirmed the multiplier method in
various
cases
like MCD v. Subhagwanti [MCD v. Subhagwanti, AIR
1966 SC 1750], U.P. SRTC v. Trilok Chandra [U.P.
SRTC v. Trilok Chandra, (1996) 4 SCC 362], Sandeep
Khanuja v. Atul
Dande [Sandeep
Khanuja v. Atul
Dande, (2017) 3 SCC 351]. This Court has also
recognised that Schedule II of the Act can be used as a
guide for the multiplier to be applied in each case.
Keeping the claimant's age in mind, the multiplier in
this case should be 18 as opposed to 44 taken by the
High Court.
25. Having held so, we are clearly of the view that the
basic amount taken for determining the attendant
charges is very much on the lower side. We must
remember that this little girl is severely suffering from
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP.262/2015
By:MANISH KUMAR
18:55:06
incontinence, meaning that she does not have control
over her bodily functions like passing urine and faeces.
As she grows older, she will not be able to handle her
periods. She requires an attendant virtually 24 hours a
day. She requires an attendant who though may not be
medically trained but must be capable of handling a
child who is bedridden. She would require an attendant
who would ensure that she does not suffer from
bedsores. The claimant has placed before us a
notification of the State of Haryana of the year 2010,
wherein the wages for skilled labourer is Rs 4846 per
month. We, therefore, assess the cost of one attendant
at Rs 5000 and she will require two attendants which
works out to Rs 10,000 per month, which comes to Rs
1,20,000 p.a., and using the multiplier of 18, it works
out to Rs 21,60,000 for the attendant charges for her
entire life. This takes care of all the pecuniary
damages.”
(emphasis added)
10.
Considering that appellant/injured claimant was paraplegic for his
life, requirement of an attendant would be essential. Accordingly, in view
of the decision in Kajal (supra), attendant charges shall be awarded by
considering minimum wages of a skilled worker of UP as on the date of
accident at Rs.3,290/- and a multiplier of ‘18’ shall be considered, since he
was 19 years of age on the date of accident. Therefore, attendant charges
shall be awarded at Rs. 7,10,640/- (Rs. 3,290 x 12 x 18).
11.
Ms. Shruti Jain, Advocate for the Insurance Company enters
appearance at a later stage.
12.
It may also be noted that future prospects have been awarded at 50%,
which shall be awarded at 40% in view of the decision in National
Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi (2017) 16 SCC 680, considering that
deceased was employed in a private job.
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP.262/2015
By:MANISH KUMAR
18:55:06
13.
Accordingly, the revised compensation shall be as under:
Heads
Sr.
No.
Awarded by the
Tribunal
Awarded by this
Court
PECUNIARY LOSS
1.
2.
Rs. 2,345/Rs. 20,000/-
Rs. 2,345/Rs. 20,000/-
Rs. 10,000/-
Rs. 10,000/-
Nil
Rs. 4,500/-
Rs. 7,10,640/Rs. 4,500/-
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
Add: Future prospects (F)
Rs. 2,250/Multiplier (G)
Functional disability (H)
45%
Loss of income (I)
Nil
Loss of future income/future
Rs.6,56,208/earnings [(E + F) x 12 x G x
H] = (J)
NON-PECUNIARY LOSS
Rs. 1,800/18
90%
Nil
Rs. 12,24,720/-
11.
12.
Pain and suffering (K)
Loss of amenities of life and
disfigurement (L)
Total compensation (A + B +
C + D + J + K + L) = M
Interest awarded
Rs. 50,000/Rs. 50,000/-
Rs. 2,00,000/Rs. 2,00,000/-
Rs. 7,88,553/-
Rs. 23,67,705/-
7.5%
7.5%
3.
4.
5.
13.
14.
Expenditure on treatment (A)
Expenditure on conveyance
(B)
Expenditure on special diet
(C)
Attendant Charges (D)
Income of injured (E)
Directions
14.
For aforesaid reasons, compensation has been enhanced by Rs.
15,79,152/- (‘enhanced amount’).
15.
It is therefore directed that enhanced amount along with accrued
interest be deposited before the MACT within a period of four weeks. It is
directed that a lump sum amount of Rs.5,00,000/- shall be released in
favour of claimant from the deposit of enhanced amount within a period of
two weeks thereafter. Remaining enhanced amount, along with accrued
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP.262/2015
By:MANISH KUMAR
18:55:06
interest till date, shall be kept in Fixed Deposit Receipts (FDRs) of Rs.
25,000/- each for periods of 3 month, 6 months, 9 months and so on, in
succession as maybe calculated. Interest accruing on said FDRs shall be
credited to the designated Savings Bank Account of claimant. The amount
of FDRs on maturity would be released to the Savings Bank Account of
claimant upon due verification.
16.
The originally awarded amount shall continue to be released in
favour of the claimant in terms of the directions passed by the MACT vide
impugned award.
17.
Appeal is disposed of in the above terms.
18.
Pending applications, if any, are rendered infructuous.
19.
Copy of this judgment be sent to the concerned MACT/bank for
information and compliance.
20.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
(ANISH DAYAL)
JUDGE
AUGUST 10, 2026/ak/sp
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP.262/2015
By:MANISH KUMAR
18:55:06
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review