Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 1st October, 2026.
Uploaded on: 5th October, 2026.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010477452026
W.P.(C) 14697/2026 & CM APPL. 68758-59/2026
DEVENDRA
.....Petitioner
Through: Ms. Ashtha Shrivastav, Mr. Ajay
Pratap Singh, Mr. Rohit Pandey, Ms.
Aryama Dubey, Mr. Hridyesh Singh,
Mr. Adhyayan Gupta, Mr. Utkarsh
Chauhan, Mr. Aditya Tiwari, Ms.
Mahak & Ms. Tannu Agarwal, Advs.
versus
NEW DELHI MUNICIPAL COUNCIL (NDMC)
& ANR.
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Sanjay Kumar Pathak, Standing
Counsel with Mr. Sunil Kumar Jha,
Mr. M.S. Akhtar and Mr. Sanjeet
Kumar Pawari, Advs. for R-3.
CORAM:
JUSTICE PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUSTICE DINESH BHATT
Prathiba M. Singh, J. (Oral)
1.
This hearing has been done through hybrid mode.
2.
The present petition has been filed by the Petitioner-Mr. Devendra
Kumar under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, inter alia, seeking
issuance of an appropriate writ directing the Respondents to consider and
decide the representation of the Petitioner dated 15th April, 2016 and the
subsequent reminder letter dated 26th May, 2016 for transfer of the Pan Thara
license bearing EPID No. 0003758 in accordance with law.
3.
The Petitioner has filed multiple writ petitions in respect of this very
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
18:15:59
W.P.(C) 14697/2026
vending site. The last writ petition was filed being W.P.(C) 8005/2025 titled
‘Devendra v. New-Delhi Municipal Council & Anr.’ which was decided vide
order dated 16th February, 2026.
4.
The Petitioner’s kiosk was sealed on 11th July, 2018. The Petitioner had
challenged the sealing by filing writ petition being W.P. (C) 8328/2018 titled
‘Devendra v. New Delhi Municipal Council (NDMC) & Ors.’ wherein vide
judgment dated 13th September, 2018, a Co-ordinate Bench of this Court
directed as under:
“4. Having regard to the observations made by the
Supreme Court of India in the case of Dharam Chand
(supra), we are of the considered view that there is no
illegality or infirmity in the order of sealing passed by
the NDMC. However, we find that post the order of
sealing, the NDMC has not made any alternate
allotment to the legal heirs of the deceased. Learned
counsel for the respondent/NDMC has clarified that the
alternate allotment could not have been made on
account of the ongoing fight between the legal heirs.
Counsel further submits that the request for alternate
allotment by the legal heirs of late Smt. Shyama Devi
would be considered within a period of six weeks after
considering the rival claims of Devender and Devi
Prasad and any other person who asserts his/her right
over the kiosk. However, we make it clear that we have
not expressed any opinion with regard to the dispute and
as to who would be surviving legal heir of late Smt.
Shyama Devi. Needless to say that in case either of the
two parties has produced documents in their support, an
order would be passed after hearing both the sides and
thereafter an alternate allotment would be made.”
5. Thereafter, as per the Petitioner, he submitted an application dated 9th
October, 2018 regarding determination of legal heir of Smt. Shyama Devi i.e.,
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
18:15:59
W.P.(C) 14697/2026
the original owner, However, NDMC vide order dated 14th February, 2019
cancelled the license of the Petitioner under the Public Premises (Eviction of
Unauthorised Occupants) Act, 1971. The Petitioner challenged the same in
W.P.(C) 5312/2019 titled ‘Devendra v. New Delhi Municipal Council &
Ors.’ wherein the New Delhi Municipal Council (hereinafter, ‘NDMC’) was
initially directed to decide the application of the Petitioner for mutation.
Thereafter, vide order dated 20th March, 2025, W.P.(C) 5312/2019 was
disposed of in the following terms:
“3. The present writ petition has been filed challenging
the order dated 14th February, 2019, wherein, the
application of the petitioner for transfer/regularization
of license of the Pan Thara, Opposite Gate No. B,
Supreme Court, near College of Arts, Tilak Marg, had
been rejected.
4. This Court notes that during the pendency of the
present petition, a speaking order dated 23rd April,
2024, has been passed by respondent no.1 New Delhi
Municipal Council (“NDMC”), wherein, it has been
decided by the Deputy Director (Estate-01) NDMC, that
since there are disputes regarding legal heirs of Late
Smt. Shyama Devi, the order dated 14th February, 2019
of NDMC, still stands and the representation of the
petitioner herein, regarding regularization of the
subject Pan Thara in favour of the petitioner, has been
rejected.
5. Accordingly, the present petition, along with the
pending applications, stands disposed of with liberty to
the petitioner to challenge the speaking order dated 23rd
April, 2024, passed by the Deputy Director (Estate-01)
NDMC”
6.
The order dated 23rd April, 2024 passed by the NDMC came to be
challenged in W.P.(C) 8005/2025. The said order dated 23rd April, 2024
refusing the mutation was upheld by this Court vide order dated 16th February,
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
18:15:59
W.P.(C) 14697/2026
2026 and the following observations were made:
“15. Heard. The stand of Mr. Devi Prasad clearly as per
the counter affidavit filed in the earlier writ petitions is
that he is the legal heir who is entitled to be substituted
in place of his mother i.e., Ms. Shyama Devi. If either
the Petitioner or Mr. Devi Prasad wants to seek transfer
of the title under a partnership, they ought to jointly
make an application to the NDMC, which has not been
done in the present case.
16. Insofar as sealing is concerned, the same was
already the subject matter of W.P.(C) 8885/2018 and
W.P.(C) 8328/2018 which has been disposed of vide
order dated 13th September, 2018. In the present case,
the only question is in respect of whether the impugned
speaking order is valid or not. The impugned speaking
order records as under:
“The brief facts of the case are that
(i)In the year 1976, Smt. Shyama Devi was
allotted a Piao at Akbar Road, New Delhi. In
the year 1982-83, she was shifted by the Civil
Engineering Department of the NDMC to a
Model Pan Thara, in lieu of the Piao operated
by her, i.e., the subject Pan Thara and since
then she was running the business in the
subject Pan Thara.
(ii)With the approval dated 08.07.1985, given
by the then administrator, the subject Thara
was regularized from the date of allotment of
site in 1976 at a nominal fees of Rs.75/-.
(iii)A writ petition being WP(C) No.
10998/2017 was filed by Sh. Devi Prasad
claiming himself to be the sole Legal Heir of
allottee Smt. Shyama Devi.
(iv)As per record a request dated 09.10.2017
was also received from the petitioner
(Devendra) claiming himself to be the
grandson of the allottee Smt. Shyama Devi
being the son of her son namely Sh. Praveen
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
18:15:59
W.P.(C) 14697/2026
requesting for transfer of the subject Pan
Thara on legal heir basis after the demise of
the allottee on 13.07.2017.
(v)Accordingly personal hearings were given
on various dates to Sh. Devendra Kumar i.e.,
present petitioner and one Sh. Devi Prasad
i.e., petitioner in the writ petition being
WP(C) No. 10998/2017. Both the claimants
filed their respective representations
alongwith bulky record alleging the claim of
each other to be false.
(vi)The subject Pan Thara was inspected on
06.02.2018 by the then Jt. Director (Estate-I)
alongwith Sh. Manoj Kumar Junior Assistant
(Estate-I) and Sh. Kabir Saini (Clerical
Assistant (Estate-1). The petitioner was found
present in the subject Pan Thara.
(vii)After perusal of the records filed by both
the claimants it is revealed that the allottee
Smt. Shyama Devi was survived by number of
legal heirs.
(viii)The allottee and her family members
were involved in multiple litigations since at
least 1999 and have also filed number of
police complaints against each other.
Whereas, in compliance of the order dated
02.01.2018 passed in writ petition being
WP(C) No. 10998/2017 the representations of
the both the claimants were considered and
an opinion was sought from the Law
Department of NDMC on 08.06.2018. The
Law Department informed about the
judgment dated 29.07.2015 in the case of
Dharam Chand Vs. Chairman NDMC and
accordingly, the subject Pan Thara was
sealed on 13.07.2018. Aggrieved by the said
sealing Sh. Devendra filed WP(C)
No.8328/18 & Sh. Devi Prasad also filed
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
18:15:59
W.P.(C) 14697/2026
WP(C) No. 8885/18.
xxx
xxx
xxx
While, Devendra, petitioner herein, claims to
be the grandson of the original allottee i.e,
late Smt. Shyama Devi and her legal heir, and
his claim is disputed by Sh.Devi Prasad
(Respondent No.3 herein), who claims to be
the sole surviving son of late Smt. Shyama
Devi and has fi led his counter affidavit before
this Hon'ble Court. In fact, in his counter, he
(Sh. Devi Prasad) has claimed that Devendra
and Sh . Praveen Kumar (Respondent No. 4)
are hand in gloves with each other. Since, the
policy dated 16.08.2016, specifically states
that if there are disputes between the legal
heirs, and which are not settled within 90 days
of issuance of the circular, the license will be
automatically be cancelled.
xxx
xxx
xxx
In that light, since , there are disputes regard
i ng who is the legal heirs of late Smt.Shyama
Devi , the order dated 14.02. 2019 of NDMC
still stands and the representation of Sh.
Devendra is rejected accordingly.”
17. As can be seen from the impugned speaking order,
the claims of Mr. Devi Prasad and Mr. Devendra i.e.,
the Petitioner herein are conflicting with each other and
the NDMC cannot be blamed.
18. It is for the legal heirs to sort out their inter-se
differences and then approach the NDMC which
unfortunately, they have not done for the last several
years. If the disputes are not getting resolved, the
Petitioner ought to avail of his legal remedies and
obtain a decree of declaration in accordance with law.
In the absence of the same, the Kiosk cannot obviously
be transferred to the Petitioner.
19. In view thereof, there is infirmity in the impugned
speaking order dated 23rd April, 2024.
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
18:15:59
W.P.(C) 14697/2026
20. The petition is accordingly dismissed. All pending
applications, if any, are disposed of.
21. Needless to add, if the Petitioner has any other legal
remedies in respect of inter-se disputes, he is free to
avail of the same and thereafter approach the NDMC, if
permissible in law.”
7.
It is the case of the Petitioner now that an MoU has been entered into
between the family members. The said MoU is dated 14th March, 2026
between Mr. Devendra, Mr. Praveen Kumar and Ms. Devi Prasad. There are
various litigations which are stated to have been pending between the parties.
It is recorded therein that Mr. Devi Prasad and Mr. Devendra have signed the
MoU. However, there is no signature by Mr. Praveen Kumar.
8.
Ld. Counsel for the NDMC now submits that the NDMC has decided
to take action under the Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorised
Occupants) Act, 1971 for eviction of the Petitioner.
9.
Under these circumstances since, the MoU is not duly signed by all
parties, no directions can be issued and no relief can be granted in favour of
the Petitioner.
10.
Petition is accordingly dismissed. Pending applications, if any, are also
disposed of.
PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUDGE
DINESH BHATT
JUDGE
OCTOBER 1, 2026
dj/ck
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
18:15:59
W.P.(C) 14697/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review