Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 25thFebruary, 2026
Pronounced on: 01st June, 2026
%
+
RFA 136/2009
KULDEEP SINGH
S/o Sh. Partap Singh,
R/o 249, First Floor, Vivekanand Puri,
Near Sarai Rohilla, Delhi.
.....Appellant
Through: Mr.
Pawanjit
Singh
Bindra,
Sr.Advocate with Mr. Abhishek
Agarwaland Ms. Vinita Sasidharan,
Advocates.
versus
1.
DEVENDER SINGH
S/o Sh. Partap Singh,
R/o 249, First Floor, Vivekanand Puri,
Near Sarai Rohilla, Delhi.
2.
RAJEEV KHATTAR
S/o Sh. H. C. Khattar,
R/o 248, Vivekanand Puri,
Near Sarai Rohilla, Delhi.
Through:
+
....Respondents
Mr. Prag Chawla, Advocate.
RFA 323/2009
DEVENDER SINGH
S/o Sh. Partap Singh,
R/o 249, First Floor, Vivekanand Puri,
Near Sarai Rohilla, Delhi.
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Prag Chawla, Advocate.
versus
1.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
KULDEEP SINGH
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page1 of 35
S/o Sh. Partap Singh,
R/o 249, First Floor, Vivekanand Puri,
Near Sarai Rohilla, Delhi.
2.
PARTAP SINGH
S/o Sh. S. Harwand Singh
R/o A-67, Subadara Colony,
Near Sarai Rohilla, Delhi.
3.
DELHI DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
Through its Vice Chairman
Vikas Sadan, I.N.A Market,
New Delhi
Through:
....Respondents
Mr. Pawanjit Singh Bindra, Senior
Advocate with Mr. Abhishek
Agarwaland Ms. Vinita Sasidharan,
Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
Aforesaid two Regular First Appeals under Section 96 read with
Order XLI of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 („C.P.C.‟) have been
preferred on behalf of the Appellants Mr. Kuldeep Singh and Mr. Devender
Singh (brothers) respectively, against the common Judgment and Decree
dated 18.10.2008, whereby Civil Suit No.18/2004 preferred by Mr. Kuldeep
Singh against Mr. Devender Singh and Mr. Rajeev Khattar, for Possession,
Mesne Profits and Permanent and Mandatory Injunction, has been
dismissed. Likewise, Civil Suit No.19/2004 preferred by Mr. Devender
Singh for cancellation of Conveyance Deed dated 01.03.1995, has also been
dismissed.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page2 of 35
2.
The Plaintiff, Mr. Kuldeep Singh in his Civil Suit No.18/2004, for
Possession and Injunction, had claimed that Plot No.249, admeasuring 160
sq. yards, situated in Vivekanand Puri, Sarai Rohilla, Delhi (hereinafter
referred to as ‘Suit Property’), was part of plots owned by Lakshmi
Cooperative House Building Society Limited, which was allotted to Mr. R.
C. Dhingra s/o Sh. A. N. Dhingra and was registered in his name vide
Registered Lease Deed dated 10.01.1978.
3.
Mr. R. C. Dhingra and Mr. Kuldeep Singh entered into an Agreement
to Sell dated 06.07.1981, in respect of plot, for a valuable consideration. The
possession of the plot was handed over to Mr. Kuldeep Singh on the date of
execution of the Agreement to Sell. All other necessary documents of the
Suit Property, were also transferred and executed in the name of Mr.
Kuldeep Singh. Thus, he became the owner of the Suit Property. Thereafter,
he got the site plan sanctioned and raised super-structure over the Plot of
land. He also got the Suit Property mutated in his name, in the Municipal
Record. The property, so constructed, comprised of Basement, mezzanine
floor, Ground Floor, First Floor and Second Floor.
4.
Thereafter, regular Conveyance Deed dated 01.03.1995 had been
executed in favor of Mr. Kuldeep Singh, and was registered in the Office of
Sub-Registrar on 02.03.1995, to the knowledge of the Defendants. The suit
property had been converted to freehold property and the entire conversion
charges, were paid by the Plaintiff.
5.
Defendant No.1 Mr. Devender Singh was younger brother of Mr.
Kuldeep Singh, and at the time of construction of the building in the Suit
Property, Mr. Devender Singh was residing as tenant in front of Gurudwara
Nanak Piao, Near Rana Pratap Bagh, Delhi.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page3 of 35
6.
In November, 1987, Mr. Devender Singh had a dispute with his
landlord, in respect of the tenanted premises, who insisted that he should
vacate his property. He then approached Mr. Kuldeep Singh and requested
him to let him and his family occupy the Ground Floor and Basement
(hereinafter referred to as suit property) of the property in-question. He
stated that he needed the help only for a short period of time and assured
that he would arrange for an alternate residential accommodation and would
shift out of the Suit Property.
7.
The premises at that time was complete and finished from inside,
though the exterior / outer part of the portion of the Property, was yet to be
plastered. The Plaintiff accepting the request of Mr. Devender Singh and he
out of love, affection and their relationship, permitted him to use and occupy
the suit property, i.e. two bedrooms, drawing, dining, two bathrooms, a
kitchen on the Ground Floor and entire basement, of the Property inquestion.
8.
However, Defendant No.1 Mr. Devender Singh did not take steps to
arrange for any alternate residential accommodation and continued to live in
the Premises of the Plaintiff, as a licensee. The Plaintiff Mr. Kuldeep Singh
along his family has been residing in the Upper Floor of the Property inquestion. Kuldeep Singh installed an electric motor in the Mezzanine Floor
for booting the water supply to the upper floors, but Mr. Devender Singh
started interfering with his rights for using the motor and started obstructing
the rights of the plaintiff.
9.
Mr. Kuldeep Singh, plaintiff orally terminated the license of Mr.
Devender Singh and finally sent a Legal Notice dated 13.09.1993 to vacate
the Suit Premises, which was duly served upon Mr. Devender Singh. After
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page4 of 35
the termination of the licence, the possession of Defendant No.1 in the Suit
Property has become illegal, unauthorized and impermissible under the law.
Thereafter, Defendant No.1 forcibly entered into the Mezzanine Floor,
removed the motor of the Plaintiff and occupied the same on 25.06.1994,
even though he had no right, title or interest.
10.
Furthermore, Defendant No.1 illegally and without the consent of the
plaintiff, handed over the possession of the entire Basement to Defendant
No.2 Mr. Rajeev Khattar on 24.11.1995, for which he charged a monthly
rent of Rs.20,000/-.
11.
Further, Defendant No.1 Devender Singh has been exclusively
enjoying the electricity from the electric meter installed on the ground floor.
He stopped paying the electricity charges and the meter had been
disconnected in 1995. After the disconnection of electricity connection,
there was no supply electricity supplied to the premises in occupation of
Devender Singh and Defendant No.2 Mr. Rajeev Khattar. However, Mr.
Rajeev Khattar had been illegally supplying the electricity to Mr. Devender
Singh, through the meter installed in Property No.248, Vivekanand Puri,
Sarai Rohilla, Delhi.
12.
The Plaintiff has further asserted that Devender Singh is liable to pay
a sum of Rs.35,000/- per month for illegal use and occupation of the Suit
Property and Defendant No.2 Mr. Rajeev Khattar is also liable to pay
Rs.20,000/- per month for use and occupation of the Basement of the Suit
Property, which is being used by him for commercial purposes. He is storing
plastic and other inflammable articles, which are hazardous to the persons
living in the building and those who are in the vicinity.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page5 of 35
13.
The Plaintiff submitted that Devender Singh had instituted Civil Suit
No.21/1992 for Injunction against him, but realizing that there was no case,
it was dismissed by learned Civil Judge, Delhi on 18.08.1997.
14.
The Plaintiff further asserted that vide mala fide and ulterior motives,
Defendants have displayed a Board in front of the Property in question,
declaring it to be the disputed property, against which there is a stay by the
Court. These acts of the Defendants were detrimental to the interest of the
Plaintiff, as it lowered the value of the suit property, in the eyes of general
public. The Plaintiff, Kuldeep Singh requested the Defendants to remove the
Board, but to no avail.
15.
The Plaintiff asserted that his sons and daughters have grown, with
the passage of time. The stairs on the ground floor leading to the upper
floors do not have railing and are unsafe. The outer front portion of the suit
property is still not plastered. The Plaintiff intends to fix iron railings on the
staircase and also get the house plastered. He had brought mason and other
workers, to carry out the necessary work, on 20.12.1999. However, they
were intimidated by Devender Singh and Rajeev Khattar, and the mason and
the workers were pushed out of the Property.
16.
Hence, the Plaintiff filed the Suit for Possession of the Suit Property
and Decree in the sum of Rs.2,40,000/- as mesne profits for user and
occupation charges of the suit property i.e. Basement, Mezzanine Floor and
the Ground Floor of Property in question at the rate of Rs.20,000/- per
month for the period 24.12.1998 to 24.12.1999 and sought further mesne
profits till the possession of the Suit Property is handed over to the Plaintiff.
17.
Plaintiff also sought relief of Permanent Injunction for restraining the
Defendants from interfering the rights of the Plaintiff to carry out the repairs
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page6 of 35
and also for Mandatory Injunction to remove the Board from the front
portion of the Ground Floor of the Suit Property.
18.
The defendant, Devender Singh in his Written Statement, took the
preliminary objection that he has filed Suit No.1445/2000 against the Mr.
Pratap Singh (father of Mr. Kuldeep Singh and Mr. Devender Singh) as well
as DDA, for Declaration and Cancellation of Conveyance Deed dated
01.03.1995, on the basis of which, Mr. Kuldeep Singh, plaintiff is claiming
title in the Suit Property. In view of pendency of this Suit, the present Suit
filed by Mr. Kuldeep Singh, is liable to be stayed.
19.
Defendant No.1, Devender Singh has submitted that he is in
possession of Ground Floor and Basement i.e. the suit property, since
27.11.1987. The Suit has been filed on January, 2000 and therefore, is
barred by limitation. Moreover, he is in lawful use and possession of the
Suit Property for a period of more than 12 years and his possession is
hostile and uninterrupted, due to which he had become the owner of the
property in his possession. He also claimed that the property had not been
valued properly for the purpose of court fee and jurisdiction.
20.
On merits, it is admitted that the Plaintiff Mr. Kuldeep Singh,
Defendant No.1 Mr. Devender Singh and their father Mr. Pratap Singh and
other family members, constituted three partnership firms- (1) M/s Hind
Express Transport Company (2) Hind Express Transport Service (3) M/s
Blue Roadways. All these were being run under three Partnership Deeds, but
the same were in joint family businesses and all partners had contributed the
funds, for the running of the business.
21.
The business was mainly of transport and the parties had purchased
number of trucks. They acquired various movable and immovable
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page7 of 35
properties. One of the said property so acquired, was the property in
question. The Plot underneath was purchased from the joint funds, earned
through the partnership business of all the three partners, in the year 1981.
Similarly, Plot No. AG-18, Sanjay Gandhi Transport Nagar, Delhi, was
allotted to the Firm M/s Hind Express Transport Company, by MCD.
22.
After purchasing the property in question, Plaintiff, Defendant No.1
and their father Mr. Pratap Singh, raised the construction on the Plot, from
their joint funds from the partnership businesses. Devender Singh, defendant
also made some contribution. The construction was completed in November
1987, after which Mr. Devender Singh shifted to the Ground Floor and the
Basement, while the Plaintiff started residing in the upper portion.
23.
Later, due to unavoidable circumstances, parties could not continue
their businesses for long. Consequently, Mr. Pratap Singh, their father,
suggested for a Family Settlement, for which purpose he deputed Mr. Pritpal
Singh and Mr. Jagdish Chand Vasudeva, as to mediators.
24.
In consultation with these two mediators, Mr. Pratap Singh settled all
the disputes between Plaintiff and Defendant No.1, vide Settlement dated
31.08.1990, which was duly signed and executed on 16.11.1990. By virtue
of this Settlement, Defendant No.1 Mr. Devender Singh got Office along
with the Buildings at Meerut, Bareilly, Shahzanpur and Dabar and some of
the Trucks. Besides this, he also got half share in the plot in Sanjay Gandhi
Transport Nagar, as well as the Basement and Ground Floor of the Property
in question and thus, he became its sole owner.
25.
Later, in the year 1992, Plaintiff Mr. Kuldeep Singh, in collusion with
their father Mr. Partap Singh, tried to dispossess Mr. Devender Singh from
the properties, which came to his share. A Suit for Injunction bearing Suit
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page8 of 35
No. 21/1992 was filed by the Defendant. In the Written Statement filed in
that Suit, plaintiff and father denied the execution of Family Settlement.
However, during the pendency of the Suit, Plaintiff and Mr. Partap Singh
executed the Agreement to Sell, General Power of Attorney, Special Power
of Attorney, etc., on 09.07.1993, in respect of the suit property.
26.
Since the Property was purchased and constructed out of family
business and as mentioned above, in the said documents, name of Plaintiff
was mentioned, on account of love and affection. These circumstances
clearly reflect that Defendant, Mr. Devender Singh is in possession of the
Suit Property in his own right, title and interest and is not a licensee, as
falsely claimed by the plaintiff, Mr. Kuldeep Singh.
27.
Mr. Devender Singh denied that he had any dispute with his erstwhile
owner and claimed that he had voluntarily vacated the earlier tenanted
premises. It is denied that he shifted into the premises on the permission of
the Plaintiff, but alleged that he had occupied the Property in his own right
and title. He denied that he ever gave any assurance to the Plaintiff to vacate
the premises, at any point of time. He also denied that his licence got
terminated, vide Notice dated 13.09.1993. It is claimed that the Notice was
duly replied by him, though the same has not been intentionally disclosed.
28.
It is further denied that he forcibly occupied the Mezzanine Floor, as
alleged by the Plaintiff. It was asserted that in fact, there was no Mezzanine
Floor in the Property, but it is a part of the Basement. He further asserted
that the motor was out of order and Plaintiff himself removed it, to get
another motor installed in his portion.
29.
He further denied that he had sublet any portion of the Basement to
Defendant No.2 Mr. Rajeev Khattar, on 24.11.1995, or that he was charging
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page9 of 35
Rs.20,000/- per month as rent from him. He claimed that the entire
Basement and the Ground Floor continue to be in his exclusive use and
possession and no part has been sublet to anyone, including Defendant No.2.
30.
Defendant No.1 Mr. Devender Singh further asserted that he has filed
Suit No.1445/2000 for Cancellation of Convenience Dated 01.03.1995 in
favour of the Plaintiff. He denied that he had been exclusively enjoying the
Electricity Meter from Connection K. No.1352733 or that there was no
supply of electricity to his portion. In fact, he claimed that Plaintiff, in order
to force him to vacate the premises, did not deposit the electricity charges,
after receiving the share from him and made misrepresentation and
succeeded in getting the electricity connection, which was in his name,
disconnected.
31.
Defendant No.1 has obtained a separate Electricity Connection in his
name. It is denied that Defendant No.2 has been illegally supplying
electricity to Defendant No.1 through his meter. Defendant No.1 further
claimed that because he is occupying the Suit Property in his own right, he
is not liable to pay any mesne profits to the Plaintiff. Furthermore,
Defendant No.2 is not in possession of any part of the Suit Property.
32.
It is further stated that the House Tax Bills are being issued in the
name of Mr. R. C. Dhingra, who was the Original Allottee. Defendant No.1
claimed that he was always ready and willing to pay his share of the House
Tax, but on account of non-payment of share by the Plaintiff, substantial
House Tax arrears have accumulated. The Conveyance Deed is absolutely
false and is a result of fraud played by the Plaintiff on Defendant No.1.
33.
It is denied that the market rate of rent of the premises located in
similar vicinity on the Ground Floor, can fetch about Rs.15,000/- per month
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page10 of 35
or that the Basement can get Rs.20,000/- per month. It is denied that he is
liable to pay Rs.35,000/- per month, for user and occupation charges of the
Suit Property.
34.
He further denied that he was using the Basement for commercial
purposes, for storing articles allegedly hazardous to the life of the people
living in the basement of the property in question. It is claimed that the
Plaintiff has no Right to make any additions or alterations in the portion
owned by him. No Mason or worker was ever brought by the Plaintiff on
20.12.1999, and there was no question of the labor being pushed out on
20.12.1999. The Plaintiff cannot be allowed to invade the rights of
Defendant No.1, under the garb of alleged repair work intended to be carried
out by him. It is submitted that the Suit is mala fide and is liable to be
dismissed.
35.
The Defendant also filed Suit No.1445/2000 (re-numbered as Suit
No.19/2004) for cancellation of the Conveyance Deed dated 01.03.1995
before the High Court, which got transferred to the District Court, on the
change of pecuniary jurisdiction.
36.
The Defendant in his independent Suit, reiterated the averments as
disclosed in the Written Statement and about the Settlement dated
31.08.1990. He also claimed about the execution of Agreement to Sell,
G.P.A., etc. dated 09.07.1993 executed in favour of the Plaintiff by
Defendant No.2, in respect of the suit property, which are in his possession.
It is claimed that the Suit Property was purchased from the family business
and pursuant to the Settlement, the Suit Property had come to his share. He
sought cancellation of the Conveyance Deed dated 01.03.1995 in favour of
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page11 of 35
the Plaintiff, in respect of the Property in question and a Declaration that he
be declared as the owner of the Property in question.
37.
The Plaintiff Mr. Kuldeep Singh and Defendant No.2 Mr. Rajeev
Khattarin their Replication as well as the Written Statements filed in Suit
No.1445/2000 repelled the contentions of the Defendant Mr. Devender
Singh. It was explained that Mr. R.C. Dhingra entered into an Agreement to
Sell dated 06.07.1981 with Mr. Kuldeep Singh. The possession of the plot
was handed over to Mr. Kuldeep Singh, on the date of the execution of the
Agreement.
38.
He reaffirmed his assertions that Mr. Devender Singh had merely
been given a permissive use of the Suit property.
39.
Plaintiff also took to the objection that the Suit filed by Mr. Devender
Singh challenging the Conveyance Deed was barred by limitation and under
Order II Rule 2 of CPC. It was also barred under Order XXIII Rule 1(4) of
CPC as an earlier Suit No.21/1992 filed by Mr. Devender Singh claiming
title to the Property in question, had been withdrawn by him
unconditionally, by claiming that there was a Settlement inter-se the
properties. The objection has also been taken that the Suit was barred by
Benami Transaction (Prohibition) Act.
40.
On merit, the Plaintiff re-affirmed his assertions as taken in the
Plaint.
41.
Issues in Suit No.18/2004 filed by Mr. Kuldeep Singh, were framed as
under:
1. Whether this court has pecuniary jurisdiction to try and
entertain the present suit?
(OPD)
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page12 of 35
2. Whether the suit is liable to be stayed in view of the
preliminary objection no. 2 of the written statement?(OPD)
3. Whether the defendant no. 1 has become the owner of the
suit premises by way of adverse possession as so alleged in
preliminary objection no. 4 of the written statement?(OPD)
4. Whether the suit has not been properly valued for the
purposes of court fees and jurisdiction as so alleged in
preliminary objection no. 5 of the written statement?(OPD)
5. Whether the suit is barred by limitation as so alleged in
preliminary objection no. 4 of the written statement?(OPD)
6. Whether the plaintiff has got no cause of action to file the
present suit?
(OPD)
7. Whether the plaintiff is the owner of the suit property?
(OPP)
8. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree of possession of
the suit property?
(OPP)
9. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree in the suit of
Rs.2,40,000/- as mesne profits for the period 24.12.1998 to
24.12.1999?
(OPP)
10. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the pendente lite and
future mesne profits at the rate of Rs.35,000/- per month as so
prayed in the prayer clause of the suit?
(OPP)
11. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the permanent
injunction against the defendants as so prayed?
(OPP)
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page13 of 35
12. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the mandatory
injunction against the defendants as so prayed in the suit?
(OPP)
13. Relief.”
42.
Issues framed in the Suit No.19/2004 filed by Mr. Devender Singh, are
as under:
“1. Whether the suit is barred by limitation?
(OPD)
2. Whether the present suit is barred under order 2 Rule 2
CPC and under Order 23 Rule 1 (4) (b) of the CPC in view of
suit no. 21/92 instituted by the plaintiff in the court of Senior
Civil Judge, Delhi titled as Devender Singh Vs. Kuldeep Singh
and Ors?
(OPD)
3. Whether defendants no. 1 and 2 are not owners of the suit
property and the plaintiff was in occupation only on license
basis?
(OPP)
4. Whether by virtue of family settlement dated 30.8.1990, the
plaintiff became owner of basement and ground floor in the
suit property No. 249, Vivekanand puri, Sarai Rohilla, Delhi?
5. Whether the suit is hit by provisions of Benami Transaction
(Prohibition) Act?
(Onus of proof on the parties)
6. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the relief of declaration?
(OPP)”
43.
These two Suits were consolidated by the learned Trial Court, vide
Order dated 21.07.2004 and the Suit No.18/2004 was taken as the lead
case and the common evidence was recorded in both cases.
44.
Mr. Kuldeep Singh examined himself as PW-1 and proved the
Perpetual Lease Deed as Ex.PW-1/1;Agreement to Sell as Ex.PW-1/2: Will
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page14 of 35
dated 06.07.1981, as Ex.PW-1/3;certified copy of Mutation as Ex.PW1/4;Legal Notice dated 13.09.1993 as Ex.PW-1/5; Reply to the Notice as
Ex.PW-1/6; certified copy of Suit No.21/1992 and Order dated 18.09.1997
were collectively exhibited as Ex.PW-1/7; certified copy of Civil Suit
No.1145/2000 as Ex.PW-1/8; certified copy of Registered cancellation of
45.
GPA dated 24.08.1993 as Ex.PW-1/9; certified copy of Registered
cancellation of Willas Ex.PW-1/10; and certified copy of the Affidavit of
Mr. R. C. Dhingra as Ex.PW-1/11.
46.
Mr. Kuldeep Singh also examined PW-2Mr. Pratap Singh, father of
Plaintiff and Defendant No.1, who corroborated the testimony of Mr.
Kuldeep Singh in toto.
47.
Devender Singh examined himself as DW-1 and deposed about the
defence taken by him in his Suit / Written Statement. The copy of
Agreement to Sell, was Ex.PW-1/D1 (Ex.DW-1/1).
48.
He also examined DW-2Mr. Jagdish Chander Vasudev; DW-3Mr.
Surjeet Singh and DW-4Mr. Seva Singh, who are the signatories to Family
Settlement Ex.DW-1/1.They corroborated the testimony of Devender Singh.
49.
Learned Additional District Judge ,on consideration of the evidence
of the parties, observed that admittedly Plaintiff Mr. Kuldeep Singh,
Defendant No.1 Mr. Devender Singh and their father Mr. Partap Singh, were
having three partnership businesses.
50.
The Plaintiff had claimed that he had paid a sum of Rs.1,00,000/- to
the original owner Mr. R. C. Dhingra, but had explained that the money was
paid from the Account of their father Mr. Partap Singh, though the money
belonged to him. This was contradicted by PW-2 Mr. Pratap Singh, who in
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page15 of 35
his cross-examination stated that Plaintiff Mr. Kuldeep Singh had paid only
Rs.20,000/-, and Rs.80,000/- had been arranged by him, from a financer.
51.
It was also noted that Defendant No.1, Devender Singh was in
possession of the suit property, since 27.11.1987. Admittedly, there was
Family Settlement Ex.PW-1/D1 (Ex.DW-1/1), where Mr. Pratap Singh had
executed GPA, in favour of Mr. Devender Singh in respect of the suit
property, which was duly registered. Also, Will was executed by Mr.
Kuldeep Singh, pursuant to Agreement Ex.PW-1/D1 (Ex.DW-1/1). The
plaintiff, got cancelled the GPA, Will on 24.08.1993, vide registered
documents, on account of unavoidable circumstances and reasons.
52.
Further, PW-2 Mr. Partap Singh (father) had admitted in his
testimony that he along with his brothers and cousins, had tried to resolve
the dispute between the Plaintiff and Defendant No.1. According to him,
Mr. Devender Singh, at the time of Settlement, had agreed to pay the price
of suit property, though no price was fixed by the biradari, but later he
backed out.
53.
Lastly, it was held that the only evidence to show that Defendant No.1
had inducted Defendant No.2 as a sub-tenant, was only oral and not
supported by any document and did not find any corroboration from any
independent source.
54.
It was thus, held that the Plaintiff Mr. Kuldeep Singh was unable to
produce any cogent and convincing evidence to show that the Property in
question, which was registered in his name, had been purchased out of his
personal funds or that he had the right to enjoy the Property, to the exclusion
of others including Defendant No.1 Mr. Devender Singh.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page16 of 35
55.
It was further held that the Plaintiff was unable to prove that the
Basement in question, had been let out by Defendant No.1 Mr. Devender
Singh to Defendant No.2,for consideration entitling him to the damages.
Accordingly, by observing that the plaintiff had failed to prove the source
of funds from where the property in question had been purchased, the Suit
of the Plaintiff Mr. Kuldeep Singh was dismissed.
56.
Likewise, in the Suit No.19/2004 filed by Mr. Devender Singh for
Cancellation of the Conveyance Deed dated 01.03.1995 in the name of the
Plaintiff, it was held that registered documents of title Ex.PW-1/2 and 3 had
been executed in favour of Mr. Kuldeep Singh and Mr. Partap Singh, who
were held to be the owners of the Property in question, though it was
clarified that the Suit No.18/2004,the relief had been denied to the Plaintiff
Mr. Kuldeep Singh, because he had failed to prove the source of funds from
where the property in question had been purchased.
57.
The Family Settlement dated 31.08.1990 was not-registered and
therefore, it was held that it did not create any right in favour of Mr.
Devender Singh. It was held that Mr. Devender Singh cannot be held to be
the owner of the property in question, by virtue of Family Settlement dated
31.08.1990.It may be looked into for collateral purposes, which reflected
that Mr. Devender Singh was in settled possession of the suit property, a fact
not denied by Mr. Kuldeep Singh and Mr. Pratap Singh.
58.
The defense taken by Mr. Devender Singh of having become owner
by adverse possession, was also rejected. It was thus, held that the since the
Conveyance Deed dated 01.03.1995, had been duly executed in the name of
Kuldeep Singh, Devender Singh was not entitled to any relief or
Declaration for Cancellation of the Conveyance Deed.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page17 of 35
59.
Suit No.18/2004 filed by Mr. Kuldeep Singh for Possession and
mesne profits was accordingly dismissed. Likewise, Suit No.19/2004 filed
by Mr. Devender Singh for challenging the Conveyance Deed in favour of
Mr. Kuldeep Singh, was also dismissed.
RFA No.136/2009: filed by Kuldeep Singh against dismissal of his Suit
No.18/2004 for Possession and Permanent and Mandatory Injunction:
60.
Kuldeep Singh, aggrieved by the dismissal of his Suit No.18/2004
filed the Regular First Appeal bearing No.136/2009.
61.
The grounds of challenge are that the learned ADJ erroneously held
that Appellant Kuldeep Singh was unable to discharge the onus of proving
that the amount for purchasing the Property in question, was from his
personal Account, in as much as, the best evidence for proving the title of a
person over a property, is the title Document itself.
62.
Learned ADJ, despite holding that the Appellant was the owner of the
Property in question, has wrongly denied the relief of Possession, only on
the ground of not being able to prove the source of fund, from which the he
had purchased the Suit Property. It has been wrongly observed that the three
Partnership Firms were running, at the time of purchase of the Property in
question, when admittedly M/s Hind Express Transport Services was
formed subsequently, on 01.04.1984.
63.
The Conveyance Deed dated 01.03.1995 Ex.PW-1/1;Agreement to
Sell Ex.PW-1/2; Will dated is 06.07.1981 Ex.PW-1/3 executed by Mr. R. C.
Dhingra in favour of the Plaintiff; along with the Mutation Certificate
Ex.PW-1/4; and House Tax Receipt Ex.PW-1/8 were duly accepted by the
learned ADJ, despite which the issue of ownership and possession has been
erroneously decided against the Appellant.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page18 of 35
64.
Learned ADJ has wrongly observed that the Plaintiff was unable to
prove the ownership of the Property in question, even though the requisite
documents have been duly proved. It was also noted that the funds for
purchase of property in question were taken from the joint funds earned by
the three family partnership businesses, even though the onus of proving that
the Property was purchased from joint funds, was on Devender Singh and
not on the Plaintiff, Kuldeep Singh.
65.
Furthermore, learned ADJ failed to observe that alleged Family
Settlement dated 31.08.1990 Ex.DW-1/1, allegedly signed on 16.11.1990,
was not signed by Kuldeep Singh or his father, Pratap Singh. It is further
asserted that it has not been considered that Agreement to Sell dated
09.07.1993 were got signed from Mr. Kuldeep Singh or their father Mr.
Pratap Singh, under force and coercion.
66.
Learned ADJ got confused in differentiating between the Agreement
09.07.1993
Ex.PW-1/D1and
the
alleged
Family
Settlement
dated
31.08.1990 Ex.DW-1/1.
67.
Furthermore, the alleged Agreement dated 31.08.1990 and GPA
executed by Pratap Singh in favor of Devender Singh and the Will executed
by Kuldeep Singh in favor of Devender Singh, were duly cancelled by them
by executing registered cancellation of GPA dated 24.08.1993 Ex.PW-1/9;
cancellation of Will Ex.PW-1/10 and Affidavit of Mr. R. C. Dhingra Ex.PW1/11.
68.
It has not been considered that the license of Devender Singh, was
terminated vide Notice dated 13.09.1993 Ex.PW-1/5 and thereafter, he has
been in illegal and un-authorized occupation of the Suit Property.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page19 of 35
Furthermore, the unregistered Family Settlement dated 31.08.1990, did not
create any rights in favour of Mr. Devender Singh.
69.
Learned Trial Court wrongly held that the Suit of Mr. Kuldeep Singh,
was barred by limitation. The impugned Judgment of the learned ADJ was
therefore, liable to be set aside.
RFA No.323/2009: filed by Devender Singh against dismissal of his Suit
No.19/2004 for Cancellation of Conveyance Deed dated 01.03.1995, in
favour of the Plaintiff, Kuldeep:
70.
Mr. Devender Singh has challenged the impugned Judgment,
dismissing his Suit for Cancellation of Conveyance Deed dated 01.03.1995,
on the grounds that learned ADJ found that the Suit Property had been
purchased from the funds of the partnership business, being carried out by
the family members and therefore, Mr. Devender Singh ought to have been
declared an owner of half share of Property, especially when Mr. Kuldeep
Singh, failed to prove the source of income from where the Property was
purchased and constructed.
71.
Furthermore, learned ADJ had relied upon the Settlement Ex.DW-1/1,
but held that the same cannot be relied upon, since it was not a registered
Document, but can be considered for collateral purposes. On the basis of the
Settlement, Mr. Kuldeep Singh had executed Agreement to Sell Ex.PW1/D1 and also Will dated 09.07.1993 in favour of the Appellant Devender
Singh. Their father had also executed GPA dated 09.07.1993 in favour of
Devender Singh. Therefore, learned ADJ fell in error in not declaring Mr.
Devender Singh as the owner of half share of the property in question.
72.
It is asserted that the unregistered, irrevocable Power of Attorney
along with Agreement to Sell and Will for consideration, creates right and
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page20 of 35
title in favour of the parties, in whose favour the documents have been
executed. This aspect has not been considered by the learned ADJ.
Moreover, in the Agreement to Sell, the consideration had been mentioned
as love and affection, which clearly indicated that the documents had been
executed pursuant to Family Settlement dated 31.08.1990, Ex.PW-1/1. The
irrevocable Power of Attorney cannot be cancelled, but was allegedly
cancelled by Kuldeep Singh, vide documents Ex.PW-1/8 and 9.
73.
Despite there being cogent evidence, learned ADJ erred in holding
that the Appellant is not the owner, to the extent of half share of the Suit
Property, on an assumption though not admitting, that Mr. Devender Singh
had agreed to pay the price in the presence of biradari, but in that
eventuality Mr. Kuldeep Singh could have recovered the money from Mr.
Devender Singh, but could not have instituted the Suit for Possession, by
claiming Mr. Devender Singhas a licensee.
74.
Mr. Kuldeep Singh had asserted that Mr. Devender Singh had been
inducted as a licensee and given possession of the Property to live therein,
whereas it was mentioned in the Agreement to Sell that he had sold the
property for consideration of love and affection. Kuldeep Singh was thus,
taking a contrary stand, which should have been decided in favour of the
Appellant, by declaring him as half owner and by declaring the Conveyance
Deed in favour of Kuldeep Singh, as null and void.
75.
Hence, the prayer was made that the impugned Judgment, dismissing
the Suit of Mr. Devender Singh for cancellation of Conveyance Deed dated
01.03.1995 be set aside.
76.
Written Submissions were filed by Mr. Kuldeep Singh as well as by
Mr. Devender Singh, in support of their respective Appeals. The grounds
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page21 of 35
raised were essentially the same, as agitated in the grounds of their
respective Appeals.
Submissions heard and record perused.
77.
The Plaintiff, Mr. Kuldeep Singh had filed a Suit for Possession,
Mesne Profits, Permanent and Mandatory Injunction in respect of the suit
property against Mr. Devender Singh, his own brother.
78.
The case of the Plaintiff was that he was the owner of the Property.
He has explained that the erstwhile owner was Mr. R.C. Dhingra, who had
been allotted the Property in question, on 07.11.1977 by Lakshmi
Cooperative House Building Society Ltd., vide Perpetual Lease Deed
10.01.1978, Ex.PW-1/1. Mr. R.C. Dhingra entered into an Agreement to
Sell, General Power of Attorney, Will, Receipt of payment of Rs.1,00,000/dated 06.07.1981, which are Ex.PW-1/3 (Colly.).
79.
The Plaintiff has explained in his cross-examination, that the entire
sale consideration was Rs.1,00,000/-, which was acknowledged vide
Receipt, Ex.PW-1/3. Thereafter, the registered Conveyance Deed dated
01.03.1995, Ex.PW-1/1, was registered in favour of Mr. Kuldeep Singh, the
Plaintiff.
80.
These documents established that the Property in question was
purchased by the Plaintiff, Mr. Partap Singh initially under an Agreement to
Sell from the erstwhile owner, Mr. R.C. Dhingra and thereafter, a
Conveyance Deed dated 01.03.1995, was duly executed in his favour.
81.
The Defendant No. 1, Mr. Devender Singh while not questioning the
authenticity of these documents, has asserted that the sale consideration of
Rs.1,00,000/- had been paid from the funds of the Partnership Firms, and
therefore, it was a joint Property. It was explained by him that at the relevant
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page22 of 35
time, there were three Partnership Firms, namely, M/s Hind Express
Transport Company; Hind Express Transport Service and M/s Blue
Roadways. The Plaintiff and the Defendant along with the father, mother
and other family members, were the partners in the Partnership Firms.
82.
While it was not denied that the Partnership Firm-Hind Express
Transport Service came into existence in April, 1984 even then, there were
Family Partnership Firms were running. It was claimed that the sum of
Rs.1,00,000/- as sale consideration was paid from the account of the
Partnership Firms. Though the conveyance Deed was registered in the name
of Mr. Kuldeep Singh, he was not his exclusive Property.
83.
The Plaintiff in his cross-examination, had admitted that the sum of
Rs.1,00,000/- had been taken from the account of their father, Mr. Pratap
Singh. However, PW-2, Mr. Pratap Singh in his cross-examination, asserted
that Rs.20,000/- was paid by Mr. Kuldeep Singh, while balance Rs.80,000/had been raised by him from a financer.
84.
The Plaintiff, Mr. Kuldeep Singh as well PW-2, may have explained
that source from where the money was arranged, but merely because the
money came from the father or even if it is accepted that it came from the
Partnership Firms, though neither admitted nor proved, then too, merely the
payment of the money from the funds of father or the Firms, would not
make it a Joint Property.
85.
Therefore, even if the money had been paid by the father of the
Plaintiff, it does not establish that it became the family property. The father
may have
helped the son and given money to him, but that per se is no
ground to claim that the Suit Property belonged equally to the Plaintiff and
the Defendant.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page23 of 35
86.
In the case of Binapani Paul vs.Pratima Ghosh and Others,(2007) 6
SCC 100, it was held that after referring to various Judgments, the Supreme
Court of India concluded that the source of money can never be the sole
consideration though, it may be a relevant factor. Likewise, in the case of
Smt. P. Leelawati (D) by LRs vs. Shankarnarayaa Rao (D) by LRs, AIR
2019 SC 1938 the property had been purchased in the name of the
Defendant though, the funds were paid from the joint account. Similar
question of the exclusive ownership of the Defendant, arose in respect of the
property, which was exclusively owned by him, but the funds had been paid
from the Joint Account. The question arose whether it would make the
Property benami or that the property was not exclusively owned by the
Defendant. In this context, the entire law was discussed and it was held that
in order to ascertain it was attended to be a joint property, the motive for
giving the money and the possession of the parties and the relationship
between the claimant and the alleged owner, the custody of the title
documents after sale and the conduct of the parties concerned in dealing
with the property, would be significant. It was thus, held that mere source of
money being from a Joint Account, would neither make it a Joint Family
Property or a benami property purchased for the benefit of the family.
87.
Similar facts have arisen in the present case, wherein the money may
have been given by the father, but the fact remains that it was the exclusive
property of the Plaintiff, as all the documents i.e. initially the Agreement to
Sell and subsequently, the Conveyance Deed was executed in his name on
01.03.1995.
88.
In this context, it may be relevant to mention here that admittedly, the
Defendant No. 1 came in possession of the Suit Property i.e. in November,
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page24 of 35
1987 despite which, the Conveyance Deed had been exclusively executed in
the name of the Plaintiff, on 01.03.1995. If it was not the individual property
of the Plaintiff, there is no reason why the Conveyance Deed would not have
been executed in their joint name.
89.
Not only this, the Property was mutated in the name of Mr. Kuldeep
Singh vide Letter dated 22.05.1992by the MCD, Ex.PW-1/4. Moreover, it is
Mr. Kuldeep Singh, who had been admittedly paying the house tax in
respect of the property in question.
90.
Not only the conduct of the parties, but also the execution of the
documents exclusively in favour of the Plaintiff, prove that he was the
exclusive owner of the Property in question, the authenticity of which, has
not been questioned by the Defendant.
91.
The second pertinent aspect, which emerges is that it is admitted by
the Plaintiff, Kuldeep Singh in his testimony as PW-1, as well as, by PW-2,
Pratap Singh, their father that prior to the acquisition of this Property in
1981, they were all residing in the rented premises. The Plaintiff has
explained that while the construction was being carried out by him on this
plot of land, he ran short of money, while the internal construction had been
done, but the plastering and other finishing work was left to be done.
92.
However, on the request of Devender Singh, he was allowed to
occupy the room on the ground floor in November, 1987, a fact which is
admitted by the Defendant in his testimony. Thereafter, the basement and
the ground Floor got completed. It is admitted by the Defendant in his Reply
dated 10.10.1993,Ex.PW-1/6 that he occupied the Basement and the Ground
Floor w.e.f. 01.01.1988.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page25 of 35
93.
The Defendant, therefore, has not been able to establish that his
shifting to the premises, was in the capacity of an owner, but his own
admissions show that he shifted into the suit property, with the consent and
permission of the Plaintiff and his occupation was in the capacity of a
licensee/a permissive user on account of the consent of the Plaintiff.
94.
It has again emerged in the testimony of the parties that their dispute
inter se started in the year 1987. The Defendant has submitted that
thereafter, there was a Family Settlement dated 31.08.1990, Ex.DW-1/1,
which was signed on 16.11.1990 by the father, Mr. Pratap Singh, at Point
„A‟, whereby the suit property was given in the ownership of the Defendant,
while the Plaintiff was given the upper floor of the property in question. The
other businesses were also divided amongst the two brothers.
95.
Pertinently, the Defendant, Mr. Devender Singh had filed a Suit No.
21/1992, claiming title over the Suit Property on the basis of the Family
Settlement dated 31.08.1990, but the Suit was withdrawn on 18.09.1997.
Once the defendant, Devender Singh himself had abandoned his claim of
execution of this alleged Settlement, he cannot again agitate any right title
under the said Family Settlement, Ex.DW-1/1.
96.
Furthermore, the perusal of the Family Settlement shows that it was a
document prepared by Sardar Pratap Singh, their father in the presence of
two Mediators, Mr. Pritpal Singh and Mr. Jagdish Chander Vasudev. In the
cross-examination, it has been admitted that this document was not signed
by either the Plaintiff and the Defendant. The father may be having a say in
the matters of the sons on account of his status, but this Agreement, Ex.DW1/1 was admittedly neither signed by the Plaintiff, Kuldeep Singh nor by
Devender Singh.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page26 of 35
97.
The Settlement may have been an expression of the intention of the
father, Mr. Pratap Singh, in order to settle the businesses and the properties
inter se the two brothers, but it does not have any legal sanctity for the
simple reason that it merely expressed their intention, and also, it was
indicated that this Settlement was subject to submission of the proper
documents concerned. Therefore, this document, Ex.DW-1/1 was not a
document which created any right, title and interest in favour of the parties,
which could have been done only after execution of the documents of
transfer of the Property, which admittedly never happened.
98.
Also, the father Pratap Singh had no ownership in the property in
question, and therefore his good intention of settling the disputes interse the
two brothers, could not have any legal implication. Therefore, the
Defendant, Mr. Devender Singh cannot make any claim on the basis of this
document, Ex.DW-1/1.
99.
The next significant documents relied upon by the Defendant, are the
Agreement to Sell, General Power of Attorney, SPA etc., dated 09.07.1993,
Ex.DW-1/1 (colly.) executed in favour of Devender Singh by Kuldeep
Singh. Furthermore, though the General Power of Attorney and the Will
were registered documents, but they merely conferred a right on Devender
Singh, to get the Sale Deed registered in his favour, on the basis of these
documents, but do not per se confer any ownership rights on him.
100. The other pertinent fact is that immediately thereafter, the SPA,
registered General Power of Attorney and the registered Will dated
09.07.1993, were cancelled by the Plaintiff, vide Cancellation Deeds, which
are Ex.PW-1/8, Ex.PW-1/9 and Ex.PW-1/10.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page27 of 35
101. The Plaintiff in his deposition, has explained that there was a
Criminal Complaint made against Kuldeep Singh and father, Pratap Singh
and Devender Singh had threatened them to either execute the documents or
else he would get them implicated. It was under force and coercion that
these Agreement to Sell etc., Ex.PW-1/D1, were executed in favour of Mr.
Devender Singh but soon thereafter, were cancelled.
102. In these circumstances, when though an Agreement to Sell, GPA,
SPA and Will were executed, but they stand revoked and therefore, the
Defendant, Mr. Devender Singh cannot claim any ownership in his favour.
103. Another significant aspect is that he had filed a Suit No. 21/1992 in
the High Court for cancellation of the Conveyance Deed in favour of the
Plaintiff, but had subsequently withdrawn the Suit on 18.08.1997. The
Defendant has again sought to challenge the Conveyance Deed in favour of
the Plaintiff by way of the present Suit No.19/2004, which he cannot do;
firstly, on the ground that the claim got barred by limitation and secondly,
that under Order 23 Rule 1 CPC, once the Suit is withdrawn without any
permission, the Suit on the same cause of action, cannot be filed. His Suit
No. 21/1992 was, therefore, rightly dismissed by the learned Additional
District Judge.
104. It is further established from the testimony of the Defendant, who
admitted to have come in possession in 1987 and finally occupied the
property on 27.11.1987.The documents, which had been relied upon by him
i.e. the Settlement, Ex.DW-1/1 and the Agreement to Sell etc., Ex.PW-1/D1,
do not confer any right of ownership in favour of Mr. Devender Singh. He
also cannot claim any right of continued possession, once the permission has
been withdrawn by Mr. Kuldeep Singh, the owner of the Property.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page28 of 35
105. Mr. Devender Singh also sought to defend his possession by claiming
that his possession was open, hostile and adverse to that of the Plaintiff.
106. The legal position regarding the essentials to be established for
acquisition of title by adverse possession are well settled by a long line of
the decisions of the Supreme Court and the High Courts in the country.
Adverse possession it is well settled, implies that it commenced in wrong
and is maintained against right. The very concept underlying adverse
possession is that the person in possession must claim to be so of right as
against the true owner. It must be nec vi, nec claim, nec precario. It must be
adequate in continuity and publicity to the extent of showing that it is averse
to the competitor. It must be hostile and under a claim or color of title. It
must be actual, open, uninterrupted notorieus, exclusive and continuous and
it must run over the entire statutory period of. 12 years. Any person who
bases his claim to title by adverse possession should be hostile to the real
owner with the attributes of notoriety, exclusivity and continuity over the
statutory period.
107. In S. M. Itarim vs. Mst. Bibi Skina, AIR 1964 SC 1254, the Hon'ble
Supreme Court declared that adverse possession must be adequate in
continuity, in publicity and extent and that a plea is required to at least show
as to when possession became adverse so that the starting point of limitation
against the party affected by the same can be determined.
108. In Annasaheb Bapusaheb Patil and Others Vs. Balwant @ Balasahet
Babusaheb Patil (dead) by LRs & heirs etc. AIR 7995 Supreme Court 895,
their lordships described the meaning of the expression adverse possession
and the pre-requisite for proving the same in the following words:
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page29 of 35
"Article 65 of the Schedule to the Limitation Act,
1963 prescribes that for possession of immovable
property or any interest therein based on title, the
limitation of 12 years begins to run from the date of
the defendant's interest becomes adverse to the
plaintiff. Adverse possession means a hostile
assertion i.e. a possession which is expressly or
impliedly in denial of title of the true owner. Under
Article 6, burden is on the defendants to prove
affirmatively. A person who bases his title on
adverse possession must show by clear and
unequivocal evidence that possession was hostile to
the real owner and amounted to a denial of his title
to the property claimed. In deciding whether the
acts, alleged by a person constitute adverse
possession, regard must be had to the animus of the
person doing those acts, which must be ascertained
from the facts and circumstances of each case. The
person who bases title on the adverse possession,
therefore, must show by clear and unequivocal
evidence that possession was hostile to the real
owner and amounted to a denial of his title to the
property claimed".
109. In Konda lakshmana Bapuji v. Govt. of A.P. and others, 2002 (3) SCC
258 the apex court declared that onus of proof to establish acquisition of title
try prescription lies on the party who makes any such assertion. The court
further held that time for the purpose of adverse possession, would start
running from the date, both, the actual possession and assertion of title, are
shown to exist. The court explained that mere possession of land, however,
long it may be, would not ripen into title unless the possessor has animus
possidendi to hold the land adverse to the title of the true owner and that an
assertion of title by adverse to the title of clear and unequivocal through, not
necessarily addressed to the real owner. Consequently, where at the
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page30 of 35
commencement of the possession there is no animus possidendi, the period
relevant for the plea of adverse possession commences from the date when
both, the actual possession and assertion of title by the possessor, are shown
to exist. In the peculiar facts of the case before their lordship it was held that
the defendants had pleaded adverse possession for the first time only in the
written statement, filed in the suit the court accordingly excluded the period
till the date of the filing of the written statement from reckoning on the
ground that there was no animus possidendi during the said period nor had
the defendant claimed any title to the land in dispute adverse to the
Defendant. The following passage is in this connection apposite:
"Mere possession of the land, however long it may be,
would not ripen into possessory title unless the
possessor has animus possidendi to hold the land
adverse to the title of the true owner. It I true that
assertion of title to the land in dispute by the possessor
would I an appropriate case be sufficient indication of
the animus possidendi to hold adverse to the title of the
true owner. But such an assertion of title must be clear
and unequivocal through it need not be addressed to
the real owner. For reckoning the statutory period to
perfect title by prescription both the possession as well
as the animus possidendi must be shown to exist.
Where, however; at the commencement of the
possession there is no animus possidendi, the period
for the purpose of reckoning adverse possession will
commence from the date when both, the actual
possession and assertion of title by the possessor are
shown to exist".
110. To the same effect is the decision of Supreme Court in Karnataka
Board of Wakf v. Government of India and others, 2004 (970) SCC 779
where the court summed up to legal position in the following passage:
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page31 of 35
"It is well settled principle" that a party claiming
adverse possession must prove that his possession is
"nec vi, nec clam, nec precario", that is, peaceful, open
and continuous. The possession must be adequate in
continuity, in publicity and in extent to show that their
possession is adverse to the true owner. It must start
with the wrongful dispossession of the rightful owner
and be actual, visible, exclusive, hostile and continued
over the statutory period. Physical fact of exclusive,
hostile and the animus possedendi to hold as owner in
exclusion to the actual owner are the most important
factors that are to be accounted in cases of this nature.
Plea of adverse possession is not a pure question of
law but a blended one of fact and law. Therefore, a
person who claims adverse possession should show:
(a) on what date he carne into possession, (b) what
was the nature of his possession, (c ) whether the
factum of possession was known to the other party, (d)
how long his possession has continued, and (e) his
possession was open and undisturbed. A person
pleading adverse possession has no equities in his
favour. Since, he is trying to defeat the rights of the
true owner it is for him to clearly plead and establish
all facts necessary to establish his adverse possession".
111. In this regard, reliance may also be placed upon the decision of the
Apex Court in Ravinder Kaur Grewal & Ors. V. Manjit Kaur & Ors.,(2019)
8 SCC 729, wherein the Court held that a claim of adverse possession can
succeed when the claimant establishes the essential ingredients of nec vi, nec
clam and nec precario, i.e., possession must be continuous, open and
notorious, and hostile to the title of the true owner. Further, it was held as
under:
"We hold that a person in possession cannot be ousted
by another person except by due procedure of law and
once 12 years’ period of adverse possession is over,
even owner’s right to eject him is lost and the
possessory owner acquires right, title and interest
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page32 of 35
possessed by the outgoing person/owner as the case
may be against whom he has prescribed."
112. However, in the present case, there is nothing to show that the
Defendant, Devender Singh ever acquired the ownership rights on the basis
of the Agreement to Sell etc., executed in his favour in July, 1993, as no
Sale Deed was, admittedly executed in his favour on the basis of Agreement
to Sell.
113. Thereafter, the Suit had been filed on 24.12.1999, by the plaintiff
claiming possession. Therefore, Mr. Devender Singh has not been able to
show that he had started claiming hostile, adverse and open title, for a
consistent period of 12 years before filing of the Suit on 24.12.1999, against
Mr. Kuldeep Singh. The learned District Judge had rightly held that Mr.
Kuldeep Singh was unable to establish his title in the suit Property by way
of adverse possession.
114. Once, it was held by the learned ADJ that the Plaintiff, Mr. Kuldeep
Singh was the owner and that Mr. Devender Singh had not been able to
establish his proprietary rights in the Property, the dismissal of the Suit for
possession by merely observing that Mr. Devender Singh was in the settled
possession of the Suit Property, is patently incorrect. The said findings are
completely erroneous as the long settled possession of the Defendant, was
throughout permissive and in the capacity of a licensee and did not confer
any proprietary rights. Therefore, the learned ADJ fell in error in dismissing
the Suit of the Plaintiff, for Possession.
115. Therefore, the dismissal of the Suit No. 18/2004 filed by the
Plaintiff, is hereby, allowed. The impugned Judgment dated 18.10.2008 is
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page33 of 35
set-aside and the decree of possession in respect of the Suit Property, is
hereby passed in favour of Mr. Kuldeep Singh and against Mr. Devender
Singh. Further, Mr. Devender Singh is also restrained from preventing the
Plaintiff in installing the iron railing on the staircase leading from the
ground floor, to his portion.
116. The Plaintiff has also sought the user occupation charges
@Rs.35,000/- per month, pendente lite, from the pendency of the Suit till
the possession is handed over by the Defendant. It has been explained by
him that the Basement had been rented out by Mr. Devender Singh to the
Defendant No. 2, Mr. Rajeev Khattar, for Rs.20,000/- per month though, he
was unable to produce any receipt or cogent evidence in respect thereof. Mr.
Devender Singh in his testimony, had also denied having rented out the
Basement for Rs.20,000/- per month.
117. In view of the aforesaid, the claim of the Plaintiff for Rs.35,000/- per
month for user and occupation charges, has not been rebutted by any cogent
evidence. Considering the relationship and the long possession of the
Defendant, he is directed to pay Rs.5,000/- per month since 1993 till the
decree and thereafter, Rs.10,000/- per month, with an interest of 5% p.a.
from the date of institution of the Suit, till the handing over of the
possession of the suit property to the plaintiff, Kuldeep Singh.
Conclusion:
118. The RFA No. 136/2009 filed by Mr. Kuldeep Singh is hereby,
allowed
and the Suit No. 18/2004 of the Plaintiff for possession,
Permanent and Mandatory Injunction as well as mesne profits/user and
occupation charge in the sum of Rs.5,000/- per month since 1993 till the
decree and thereafter, Rs.10,000/- per month, with an interest of 5% p.a.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page34 of 35
from the date of institution of the Suit, till the handing over of the
possession of the suit property to the plaintiff, Kuldeep Singh, is decreed.
119. The RFA No. 323/2009 filed by Mr. Devender Singh, to challenge
the dismissal of his Suit No. 19/2004 for cancellation of Conveyance Deed,
is hereby, dismissed.
120. The Appeals are disposed of accordingly. The pending Applications
are disposed of, accordingly.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
JUNE 1, 2026/R/RS
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RFA 136/2009 & RFA 323/2009
Page35 of 35
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review