Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
1 / 21
2026:CGHC:561-DB
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CRA No. 62 of 2025
Devchand Dhankar S/o Nemu Ram Dhankar Aged About 22 Years R/o
Anjani, Police Station- Kanker, District- North Bastar Kanker, C.G.
... Appellant
versus
State of Chhattisgarh Through The Station House Officer, Police
Station- Kanker, District- North Bastar Kanker, C.G.
... Respondent
For Appellant :
Mr. Mukesh Shrivastava, Advocate
For State
Mr. Dharmesh Shrivastava, Dy. AG
:
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Shri Arvind Kumar Verma, Judge
(Judgment on Board)
Per Ramesh Sinha, CJ
06/01/2026
1. Challenge in this criminal appeal is to impugned judgment of
conviction and order of sentence dated 12.12.2024 (Annexure ADigitally
signed by
ASHUTOSH
ASHUTOSH MISHRA
MISHRA
Date:
2026.01.10
13:59:39
+0530
1) passed by learned Principal Sessions Judge, North Bastar
2 / 21
Kanker, (C.G.), in ST No.27/2020, whereby the appellant stands
convicted and sentence as under:
Conviction
Sentence
Under Section 302 Rigorous Imprisonment for life with
fine of Rs.500/-, in default of payment
of the IPC.
of fine, 06 month additional RI.
Under Section 201 Rigorous imprisonment for 03 years &
fine of Rs.200/-, in default of payment
of the IPC.
of fine, 01 month additional RI.
2. Case of the prosecution, in brief, is that the complainant Bhagirati
alias Bhagirati Yadav (PW 03) had given a written missing report
Exhibit P-01 in the Police Station- Kanker to the effect that he is a
resident of village- Puriara, his daughter Kumari Bharti Yadav had
left the house on 18/01/2020 at around 11.00 am to go to Sarona
market, but has not returned home till today i.e. 27/01/2020, no
information was received after inquiring at the nearby places and
relatives' places. The prosecution's case further states that, based
on the aforementioned information from the Complainant, a
missing person report, number 07/2020, was registered by the
Kanker Police Station. The case was taken up for investigation.
During the investigation, the investigating officer, Hiteshwari
Chelak, a female head constable (PW 29), obtained the call
details of the mobile phone number 6261964711 of the missing
person/deceased Mrs. Bharti Yadav. While investigating after
getting the call details from the cyber cell, on 05/06/2020, Ishan's
3 / 21
father Bhagrati Yadav, brother Jitendra Yadav and other villagers
came to the police station and told that they were continuously
searching for Bharti Yadav since 18/01/2020. During this, Bharti
Yadav's elder sister Saras Bai Yadav, resident of Aadanbeda,
Police Station- Keshkal, saw Bharti Yadav in the village-Bahigaon
market and on investigation by her, it was found that she was
staying with the accused Devchand Dhankar, resident of Anjani,
on rent in the house of Kumari Taruna Maid of village-Bahigaon.
On 05/07/2020, the family members and villagers went to village
Bahigaon to inquire about Bharti Yadav, where Bharti Yadav was
not found in the rented house. On asking the landlady Taruna, she
stated that two months ago on 02/05/2020 at around 9.30 pm, the
accused told that he had taken Bharti Yadav along with his
Khalasi/accomplice accused Thanwar Yadav.
3. On suspecting the accused Devchand Dhankar, the complainant
came to the police station and told the above fact. On 06/07/2020,
accused Devchand Dhankar was called to the police station and
on detailed questioning, he admitted to killing Bharti Yadav in front
of Bharti Yadav's family members, villagers of village-Puriara,
witnesses Saradhu Ram, Shekhar Yadav and burying her body in
the sand under the Turi river bridge after slitting her throat. M.D.
Deshmukh, Inspector (PW 30) interrogated the accused in front of
witnesses Shekhar Yadav, Saradhu Ram and Devchandra and
recorded his memorandum statement Exhibit P. 09 as above.
4 / 21
4. After knowing the above fact, M.D. Deshmukh, Inspector (PW 30)
gave letter Exhibit P. 40, 49 to Sub-Divisional Officer (Revenue)
Kanker to appoint an Executive Magistrate for the process of
exhumation of the body and to get the post-mortem done by a
lady doctor at the spot after exhumation of the body, in this
context, after getting permission, informed the exhumation team,
the accused, the medical team for post-mortem at the spot, the
Regional Forensic Science Laboratory Jagdalpur for inspection of
the spot and to go to the place where the body was buried along
with other witnesses and take action.
5. Neeraj Kumar, Naib Tehsildar (PW 19), in the context of the letter
received regarding the process of exhumation of the body, went to
the spot on 06/07/2020 along with the medical team, FSL team,
police force of Kanker police station and other independent
witnesses and prepared the site panchnama Exhibit P. 11,
inspected the said site and prepared the site panchnama Exhibit
P. 12, after which the head of the deceased was found buried in
the sand, which was recovered and the recovery panchnama
Exhibit P. 13 was prepared and after exhuming the body from the
place indicated by the accused Devchand Dhankar, the skeleton
of the deceased was taken out and the exhumation panchnama
Exhibit P. 14, site identification panchnama Exhibit P. 15,
identification panchnama Exhibit P. 16 of the clothes, German lid,
ladies bag recovered from near the skeleton at the spot were
prepared.
5 / 21
6. Dr. B. Suri Babu, Joint Director, Regional Forensic Science
Laboratory, Jagdalpur (PW 13) gave the inspection report of the
spot vide Exhibit P. 30 and during his inspection, a DVD
containing photographs of the skeleton recovered from the spot
and the videography of the exhumation proceedings was prepared
by Dilip Jethwa, Head Constable (PW 26) which was seized by
Somendra Sinha, Inspector (PW 22).
7. M.D. Deshmukh, Inspector (PW 30), after examining the skeleton,
mobile phone, clothes and bag recovered from the spot, in the
presence of witnesses Shekhar Yadav and Saradhu Ram, the
complainant Bhagarati Yadav and Jitendra Yadav, identified the
skeleton as belonging to the deceased Bharti Yadav, for which an
identification panchnama (Exhibit P. 02) was prepared. He also
prepared the spot map (Exhibit P. 05) of the incident. Thereafter,
on the production of Neeraj Kumar, Naib Tehsildar (PW 19), the
recovered human skull, 07 pieces of bones, black tangled hair, old
German cover, used ladies bag, two pieces of Micromax company
mobile, one market Mangalsutra, 26 pieces of black coloured
bangles, 01 piece of lipstick in a plastic box, 01 piece of Boroplus,
01 box of Kajal, 01 tweezers, 03 pieces of eyebrow pencil, 02
pieces of medicine tablet Norflox 400 mg, spectacles with plastic
cover, 01 bottle of Cipla syrup, henna, 01 torn packet of Stayfree
were seized and seizure memo Exhibit P. 18 and 20 were
prepared.
6 / 21
8. Neeraj Kumar, Naib Tehsildar (PW 19) served notice Exhibit P. 17
to witnesses Uderam Yadav, Gajendra Yadav, Umendra Yadav,
Shekhar Yadav and Saradhu Ram Gond for the proceedings of
the post-mortem examination on the spot and prepared the postmortem examination examination Exhibit P. 08 in their presence.
M.D. Deshmukh, Inspector (PW 30) prepared the post-mortem
examination application Exhibit P. 26A on the spot and issued duty
certificate Exhibit P. 48 to Hiteshwari Chelak, Head Constable
(PW 29) for getting the above proceedings done. Dr. A.K. Verma
(PW 11) and Dr. Shripa Singh (PW 12) gave the PM Report of the
skeleton of the deceased.
9. M.D. Deshmukh, Inspector (PW 30), on the basis of the above
memorandum statement of the accused, on production of the
accused, prepared search panchnama (Exhibit P 34) of the iron
rod used in the incident as per seizure memo (Exhibit P 35) from
the spot and after seizing the said rod, prepared its identification
panchnama (Exhibit P 04) and after questioning the accused
Thanwar Yadav, recorded his interrogation statement (Exhibit P
10). The DVD of the video prepared in connection with the
memorandum statement of the accused Dhanwar Yadav was
seized under Exhibit P 47 and its certificate under Section 65B of
the Evidence Act (Exhibit P 75) was obtained. The said
Investigating Officer prepared Inquest Intimation Exhibit P. 55,
Rural Inquest Exhibit P. 56 and Inquest Intimation Exhibit P. 55 on
the spot and on the basis of the above mentioned Rural Inquest
7 / 21
Intimation Exhibit P. 57 and on the basis of the Rural Inquest,
registered First Information Report Exhibit P. 58 against the
accused under Sections 302, 201, 34 of the Indian Penal Code
and registered Crime No. 183/2020.
10.
During the investigation, Inspector M.D. Deshmukh (PW 30)
sent a letter to the Tehsildar Kanker regarding providing the map
of the incident site from the Patwari. The Patwari map of the
incident site was prepared by the Patwari (Exhibit P. 21) and its
Panchnama (Exhibit P. 22). Dr. A.K. Markam (PW 10) took blood
samples of the deceased's parents for DNA testing to confirm that
the human skeleton recovered from the incident site belonged to
the missing deceased Bharti Yadav, Exhibit P. 24 and 25, which
were seized by Inspector M.D. Deshmukh (PW 30).
11.
The seizure was made by Dr. Kiran Patil (PW 14) as per
Exhibit P. 47. The seized human skeleton and the blood sample
collected above were sent to Medical College, Jagdalpur for
preservation for DNA testing. Dr. Kiran Patil (PW 14) preserved
the above mentioned parts for DNA testing as per Exhibit P. 31
and 32.
12.
During the investigation, Inspector M.D. Deshmukh (PW 30)
seized the truck vehicle number CG 17 H 2650 used in the
incident along with its keys and documents as per the seizure
memo, Exhibit P. 41. The said investigator obtained the CDR
report
of
accused
Devchand
Dhankar's
mobile
number
8 / 21
9399494865 and the deceased's mobile number 6261964711 and
a certificate under Section 65 of the Evidence Act in this regard.
Also, a certificate under Section 65 of the Evidence Act was
obtained regarding the confession made by accused Thanwar
Yadav regarding the crime and the videography/photography done
at the scene of the incident.
13.
The DNA profile prepared for DNA testing and the seized
articles were sent for chemical testing through Superintendent of
Police Kanker to Regional Forensic Science Laboratory Jagdalpur
as per Exhibit P. 64 and 69 and receipt was obtained Exhibit P. 63
and 68 and subsequently DNA test report Exhibit P. 65 and
chemical test report Exhibit P. 70 were received. During the
investigation, the accused were arrested under arrest sheet
Exhibit P. 52 and 54. Statements of the complainant and other
witnesses were recorded. After completion of the investigation, a
case was registered against the accused under sections 302, 201,
34 of the Indian Penal Code for the crime of murder of Bharti
Yadav and destruction of evidence. The charge sheet was
presented in the Court of Chief Judicial Magistrate Kanker, District
North Bastar Kanker, from where the said case has been
transferred to the Sessions Court for trial.
14.
The accused were charged with the offences under Sections
302/34, 201 of the Indian Penal Code, the charge sheet was read
out to the accused and explained to them, the accused denied the
charges and requested for trial.
9 / 21
15.
Prosecution in order to prove its case examined total 31
witnesses. Statement of appellant (accused) was also recorded
under Section 313 of CrPC in which he denied all incriminating
evidence appearing against him, pleaded innocence and false
implication. However, no evidence was adduced by him in his
defence.
16.
After
hearing
learned
counsel
for
the
parties
and
appreciating the evidence available on record, the trial Court vide
impugned
judgment
convicted
and
sentenced
the
accused/appellant in the manner as described in Para-1 of this
judgment. Hence this appeal.
17.
Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the theory of
last seen together has not been proved and even the dead body
which was recovered was the skeleton of the dead body which
was not identifiable. He would next contend that the appellant has
been convicted only on the basis of circumstantial evidence,
however, the chain of circumstances are missing. He would next
contend that there are major contradiction and omission in the
statement of the memorandum and seizure witnesses. He would
next contend that there is no motive or intention of the appellant
for committing murder of the deceased.
In support of his
contention he placed reliance upon the law laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of State of Himachal
Pradesh Vs. Raj Kumar {(2014) 14 SCC 39} and in the matter of
10 / 21
Sharad Birchandani Sarda Vs. State of Maharashtra {(1984) 4
SCC 116} and would submit that the appeal deserves to be
allowed and the impugned judgment deserves to be set aside.
18.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the State supporting the
impugned judgment would submit that based on material/evidence
available on record, trial Court has rightly passed the impugned
order/judgment and convicted the appellant for the aforementioned
offence/crime. Hence, present appeal being sans merits is liable to
be dismissed.
19. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record of the trial Court including the impugned judgment.
20. Perusal of the statement of the accused would show that the
accused made a voluntary disclosure statement Ex. P/9, wherein
he categorically narrated the manner of commission of the offence,
the weapon used, and the place where the dead body and
incriminating articles were concealed. Though a confession made
to a police officer is inadmissible under Sections 25 and 26 of the
Evidence Act, the information leading to discovery of a fact, given
by the accused, is clearly admissible under Section 27 of the
Indian Evidence Act.
21. The prosecution has proved that the accused made a voluntary
disclosure statement, recorded vide Exhibit P/09, wherein he
disclosed the manner of commission of the offence, the weapon
used, and the place where the dead body and incriminating articles
were concealed. Though the confession made to a police officer is
11 / 21
inadmissible per se, the portion of the statement leading to
discovery of facts is clearly admissible under Section 27 of the
Indian Evidence Act.
22. Pursuant to the said disclosure, recoveries were effected strictly in
accordance with law, thereby rendering the admissible portion of
the statement highly incriminating against the accused. The
recovery of the dead body and skeletal remains is duly proved
through cogent documentary and oral evidence. The search and
recovery of the skull were carried out vide Search Panchanama
(Exhibit P/12) and Recovery Panchanama of Skull (Exhibit P/13).
Thereafter, the dead body was exhumed in accordance with due
legal procedure, as evidenced by the Dead Body Exhumation
Panchanama (Exhibit P/14). The identification of the recovered
skeletal
remains
was
proved
through
the
Identification
Panchanama of Skeleton and German Lid (Exhibit P/16), wherein
the relatives of the deceased identified the remains and articles
belonging to the deceased. Further, the legality of the exhumation
stands fortified by Memo to SDM for dead body exhumation
(Exhibit P/40) and Memo for grant of permission for exhumation
(Exhibit P/40A).
23. Thus, the recovery of the dead body at the instance of the
accused stands firmly established and constitutes a vital
incriminating circumstance. The seizure of incriminating articles
pursuant to the disclosure of the accused is proved through
multiple seizure memos, namely Property Seizure Memo (Exhibit
12 / 21
P/18), Property Seizure Memos (Exhibits P/19 & P/20), Property
Seizure Memo (Exhibit P/33), Property Seizure Memo (Exhibit
P/35) and Property Seizure Memo (Exhibit P/39). These seizure
memos were proved by reliable witnesses and no material infirmity
has been shown in the seizure proceedings.
24. Ku. Taruna Sahu (PW-1) has stated that she knows the accused
Devchand Chankar but do not recognize the other accused. She
also knows the deceased, Bharti Yadav, whom the accused
Devchand Dhankar had introduced as Dimple Yadav. The accused
Devchand Dhankar lived as a tenant in her house. She is teacher
at the Secondary School, Pipra Development Block, Keshkal. Her
house is located near the National Highway in Bahigaon. Her
house is divided into four and five parts, two of which were rented
out. In one of the rented blocks, the accused Devchand Dhankar
and his wife, whom he introduced as Dimple, lived together as
tenants for approximately two months. The rented house consisted
of three rooms, charging a monthly rent of ₹1,200. She inquired
about Devchand Dhankar's rent before paying him rent, and he
told her that he worked as a driver. She then asked for his Aadhaar
card, after which she rented the house to him. She further stated
that the accused told her that she will do farming work at his home
in village Anjani and the accused Devchand Dhankar and his wife
left her rented house, saying that they did not take the household
items that day. After having dinner at around 9-10:00 pm, the
accused Devchand Dhankar and his wife told her that a truck is
13 / 21
parked in front and they are going in that. While staying in her
house on rent, the accused used to leave his wife Bharti Yadav
and go for work in the truck and used to come and go in between.
The statement of Ku. Taruna Sahu supported the prosecution case
regarding the conduct of the accused and the surrounding
circumstances, which clearly point towards his complicity in the
offence.
25. Bhagrati (PW-3), who is the father of the deceased. He in his
statement has stated that he knows the accused Devchand
Dhankar, but he do not recognize the other accused. He also
knows the deceased, Bharti Yadav; she was his daughter. He has
eight children, two boys and six girls. Bharti Yadav was his
youngest daughter, who had studied till the fifth grade. About a
year ago, his daughter, the deceased, left home without informing
him. He searched nearby and at relatives' homes, but could not
find her. Then, he filed a written complaint at the Kanker police
station, which is Ex.P.-1. The lockdown was going on and after a
few days, his daughter Sarasbai, who had gone to village
Adanbeda, district Kondagaon, told him over the phone that she
had seen the deceased Bharti Yadav in village Adanbeda, go there
and find out. Then he went to village Anjani to the parents of
accused Devchand, but they told him that they do not have any
information. After two-three days, he again went to village Anjani
and enquired from the parents of accused Devchand that where is
your son accused Devchand. Then accused Devchand had come
14 / 21
to his house in village Anjani. When he asked him, he told that
Bharti has not gone with him. Then he asked the accused whether
you were living in Bahigaon. Then the accused told that he was
living in Bahigaon. Then he took his phone number from him and
went to Bahigaon and called on the same number which was
picked up by the accused and the accused showed him his house.
Then on meeting the landlord of the accused and enquiring, he told
him that the accused had brought a girl named Bharti, then we
caught the accused Devchand and took him to Kanker police
station and handed him over.
Perusal of the statement would
show that he being a close relative of the deceased, has proved
the identity of the deceased and the circumstances preceding the
incident. His testimony inspires confidence and remains unshaken
in cross-examination.
26. Statements of Shekhar Yadav (PW-8) and Saradhu Ram (PW-9)
have corroborated the prosecution version with respect to the
disclosure statement of the accused, the recovery proceedings,
and the seizure of incriminating articles. Their evidence is
consistent, natural, and free from material contradictions.
27. The testimonies of these witnesses, when read conjointly, form a
coherent and trustworthy chain of evidence. There is no reason to
discard their statements merely on the ground of minor
inconsistencies, which are natural and do not go to the root of the
case.
15 / 21
28. From perusal of the above statements the prosecution has
established a complete and unbroken chain of circumstances,
namely:
• The conduct and last-seen circumstances proved
through prosecution witnesses;
• The voluntary disclosure statement of the accused;
•
Recovery of the dead body and incriminating
articles at the instance of the accused;
• Seizure memos duly proved;
• Corroboration by independent witnesses.
29. In case at hand, there is no direct eye-witness of commission of
murder of the deceased and conviction of appellant rests mainly on
circumstantial evidence i.e. recovery of dead body of deceased at
the instance of the accused/appellant from the River situated in
Village Puriyara.
30. It is well settled law that in a case of circumstantial evidence, the
Court is required to be more cautious while analyzing the evidence
available before it. Whenever any case is decided only on the
basis of circumstantial evidence, following conditions are required
to be fulfilled :(1) the circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt
is to be drawn should be fully established. The
circumstances concerned 'must or should' and not 'may
be' established.
(2) the facts so established should be consistent only
with the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused, that is to
16 / 21
say, they should not be explainable on any other
hypothesis except that the accused is guilty.
(3) the circumstances should be of a conclusive nature
and tendency.
(4) they should exclude every possible hypothesis
except the one to be proved, and (5) there must be a
chain of evidence so complete as not to leave any
reasonable ground for the conclusion consistent with the
innocence of the accused and must show that in all
human probability the act must have been done by the
accused."
31. In case of Anuj Kumar Gupta v State of Bihar reported in (2013)
12 SCC 383, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed thus:"18. In such circumstances, in the absence of any
convincing
explanation
offered
on
behalf
of
the
appellant-accused as to under what circumstances he
was able to lead the police party to the place where the
dead body of the deceased was found, it will have to be
held that such recovery of the dead body, which is a very
clinching circumstance in a case of this nature, would act
deadly against the appellant considered along with rest
of the circumstances demonstrated by the prosecution to
rope in the appellant in the alleged crime of the killing of
the deceased. Therefore, once we find that there was
definite admission on behalf of the appellant by which
the prosecuting agency was able to recover the body of
the deceased from a place, which was within the special
knowledge of the appellant, the only other aspect to be
examined is whether the appellant came forward with
any convincing explanation to get over the said
admission. Unfortunately though the above incriminating
17 / 21
circumstance was put to the appellant in the Section 313
CrPC questioning where he had an opportunity to
explain, except a mere denial there was no other
convincing explanation offered by him.
19. Thus, we reach a conclusion that the said
circumstance of recovery of the body of the deceased
from the place called Maldiha Dhar (a river stream) at
the instance of the appellant as spoken to by PW 9, is
supported by the evidence of PW 4; we have to only see
whether rest of the circumstances considered by the trial
court, as well as the High Court, were sufficient to
confirm the ultimate conviction of the appellant and the
sentence imposed on him. On this aspect when we
perused the judgment of the trial court, as well as the
High Court, the following circumstances have been
found to be established:"
32. In case at hand also, the incriminating circumstances were
explained to the appellant in terms of Section 313 CrPC and was
given an opportunity to respond, but except for denial and false
implication, there was no other convincing explanation given by
him.
33. Instead, the accused made a confessional letter (Ex. P/9),
wherein he furnished specific information regarding the place of
concealment of the dead body and incriminating articles. Pursuant
to this disclosure, recoveries were effected strictly in accordance
with law, including the recovery of the skull and skeletal remains,
which were subsequently identified and subjected to forensic
examination. The recovery proceedings are duly proved through
contemporaneous documents and witness testimony.
18 / 21
34. The fact that the accused alone had the knowledge of the place
where the dead body and articles were concealed lends
considerable credibility to the prosecution case. The disclosure
statement, to the extent it led to the discovery of material facts,
thus stands corroborated by subsequent recoveries and scientific
evidence. This admissible portion of the statement forms a vital link
in the chain of circumstances and directly connects the accused
with the commission of the offence. The defence has not been able
to demonstrate that the disclosure was involuntary or that the
recoveries were fabricated. Mere denial or bald suggestions in
cross-examination do not weaken the evidentiary value of a
discovery duly proved under Section 27 of the Evidence Act.
35. The Supreme Court in the matter of Mehboob Ali and Another v
State of Rajasthan (2016) 14 SCC 640 had an occasion to deal
such mental state of fact wherein the Court observed that for
application of Section 27 of the Evidence Act, the admissible
portion of confessional statement has to be found as to a fact
which were the immediate cause of the recovery, only that would
be part of legal evidence and not the rest. Section 27 of the
Evidence Act refers to the 'Fact'. The word 'Fact' has been defined
in Section 3 of the Evidence Act which is reproduced hereunder:“Fact”—“Fact” means and includes—
(1) any thing, state of things, or relation of things,
capable of being perceived by the senses;
19 / 21
(2) any mental condition of which any person is
conscious.
Illustrations
(a) That there are certain objects arranged in a certain
order in a certain place, is a fact.
(b) That a man heard or saw something, is a fact.
(c) That a man said certain words, is a fact.
(d) That a man holds a certain opinion, has a certain
intention, acts in good faith, or fraudulently, or uses a
particular word in a particular sense, or is or was at a
specified time conscious of a particular sensation, is a
fact.
(e) That a man has a certain reputation, is a fact.”
36. The DNA examination report issued by the State Forensic Science
Laboratory (Ex. P/65) establishes that the biological samples
recovered from the skeletal remains are genetically linked to the
parents of the deceased. As per the DNA profiling conducted using
standard and accepted scientific procedures, including PCR
amplification and STR analysis. The DNA report clearly opines
that the genetic markers of the skeletal remains are consistent with
those of the biological parents, thereby conclusively establishing
that the recovered skeletal remains are that of the deceased
Bharati Yadav. The report further records that the DNA profiles
matched at multiple loci, eliminating the possibility of coincidental
20 / 21
similarity or substitution. The scientific opinion is categorical and
leaves no scope for ambiguity or doubt regarding the identity of the
deceased. The defence has not been able to point out any
procedural irregularity, contamination, or scientific infirmity in the
collection, sealing, transmission, or examination of the samples.
The DNA report has been proved by competent scientific authority
and has remained unchallenged in material particulars. Being a
form of scientific evidence of a conclusive nature, the DNA report
carries a very high probative value and firmly corroborates the
prosecution version regarding the identity of the dead body.
Accordingly, this Court holds that the DNA evidence conclusively
establishes the identity of the deceased and provides decisive
scientific support to the prosecution case.
37. Cumulatively effect of the above circumstances found proved
against the appellant i.e. recovery of dead body at the instance of
accused/appellant and complicit conduct, is that they form a
complete chain which points unerringly that none other than
accused-appellant himself has committed the crime in question.
38. For the foregoing discussion and reasons, we are in agreement
with the conclusion arrived at by the trial Court. The impugned
judgment of conviction and order of sentence passed by the trial
court against the appellant does not require any interference. It is
hereby affirmed. The appeal being meritless is liable to be and is
hereby dismissed.
21 / 21
39. Let a copy of this judgment and the original record be transmitted
to the trial Court concerned forthwith for necessary information and
compliance.
Sd/(Arvind Kumar Verma)
Judge
Ashu
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review