Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
W.P.(C) 10758/2025 & CM APPLs. 56314/2025, 65007/2025
DEVANSHU SHARMA
Through:
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
Through:
.....Petitioner
Ms. Bhawana Pandey, Ms. Jia Kapur,
Mr. Manoj Gaud and Mr. Piyush
Ranjan, Advocates with Petitioner
(through VC).
.....Respondents
Mr. Vikas Kumar Sharma, SPC with
Ms. Deeksha Monga, Advocate for
UOI.
Mr. Ashok Singh, Advocate for R-2
to 5 with Mr. Ashutosh Singh P.,
(AM) Legal.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
%
1.
ORDER
02.04.2026
The Petitioner, an employee of RailTel Corporation of India Ltd.,
seeks intervention of this Court against the posting consequence attached to
his promotion from E-3 to E-4. Though the promotion itself is not in issue,
the grievance is that, despite his certified disability and the protections
claimed under the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016 and the
executive instructions relied upon by him, he was posted from the Northern
Region to the Eastern Region and was not accommodated in a non-field
posting at Delhi. He also seeks enforcement of his claim to four additional
casual leaves as a person with disability.
2.
The Petitioner is a person with disability and suffers from “Lobster
Hand Syndrome (Ectrodactyly or Split-Hand).” He holds a disability
W.P.(C) 10758/2025
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 06/04/2026 at 12:25:56
certificate reflecting more than 40% permanent disability in the right hand.
He joined RailTel in December 2012 as Deputy Manager (Technical). He
was initially posted at Panipat. According to him, that was a field posting
which exposed him to serious practical difficulty and even risk in day-to-day
movement and work. In 2013, on his request, he was shifted to the New
Delhi Network Operating Centre. It is asserted that the transfer itself
reflected the Respondents’ recognition that a non-field posting was more
suitable in his case.
3.
In May 2024, the Petitioner was provisionally empanelled for
promotion from E-3 to E-4. On 8th October, 2024, an office memorandum
was issued granting him promotion. That promotion, however, was coupled
with placement in the Eastern Region. The Petitioner contends that this was
not merely a change in designation or level, but effectively amounted to a
withdrawal of the accommodation earlier extended to him. By directing his
transfer out of Delhi to a field posting, the Respondents, in substance, failed
to adequately account for his disability.
4.
The Petitioner wrote on 9th October, 2024 asking that he be exempted
from the transfer and that he be allowed to continue in a suitable non-field
role in or around Delhi. He relied on the disability-related office memoranda
of the Department of Personnel and Training and the Department of Public
Enterprises. He also pointed out that Delhi was materially closer to his
native place at Hathras, U.P. and that his family support structure remained
tied to Delhi. Petitioner asserts that he nevertheless joined at Rourkela on
29th October, 2024 because the promotion order stated that the higher post
would take effect from the date of assumption of charge, and a refusal to
join would have meant foregoing the advancement altogether.
W.P.(C) 10758/2025
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 06/04/2026 at 12:25:56
5.
The
grievance
of
the
Petitioner
is
that,
despite
repeated
representations, reminders, and resort to CPGRAMS, the Respondents
declined to accommodate him in Delhi. He says the Respondents have dealt
with the matter as though it were a routine transfer dispute, whereas his case
stood on a different footing altogether because it involved an employee with
benchmark disability who had already once been shifted from a field
environment to a more suitable station. He also says that the later order
dated 8th August, 2025 posting him to NOC/Kolkata does not answer the real
issue, because the request was not for any non-field post anywhere in India,
but for a posting reasonably proximate to Delhi and Hathras so that he could
function with family support and without recurrent hardship.
Contentions
6.
Ms. Bhawana Pandey, Counsel for the Petitioner, argues that the
Respondents cannot take shelter behind the general principle that transfer is
an incident of service. For a person with disability, the matter must be
examined on a different level. Reliance is placed on the Rights of Persons
with Disabilities Act, 2016, the DoPT Office Memorandum dated 31 st
March, 2014, the DPE communication dated 5th April, 2023, and the
decisions of this Court in V.K. Bhasin v. State Bank of Patiala1 and Ircon
International Ltd. v. Bhavneet Singh.2 These provisions and decisions
require more than a formal acknowledgement of disability. They require the
employer, so far as reasonably possible, to avoid placing a disabled
employee in a position that defeats reasonable accommodation and to prefer
MANU/DE/1013/2005.
MANU/DE/4750/2024.
W.P.(C) 10758/2025
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 06/04/2026 at 12:25:56
a station that allows such employee to function with dignity and practical
support.
7.
It is further submitted that the obligation to provide reasonable
accommodation is not merely advisory but has binding force, particularly in
light of Section 20 of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016.
Having once been accommodated in a non-field posting at Delhi on account
of his disability, the subsequent transfer to a distant field posting effectively
withdraws that accommodation to the Petitioner without justification. The
Respondents have failed to consider the Petitioner’s benchmark disability,
the practical difficulties of field duties, and his need for family support.
8.
It is further submitted that this Court has the territorial jurisdiction to
entertain the present petition. The Petitioner asserts that he is an ordinary
resident of Delhi, his family continues to reside here, and the Respondent
No. 2 has its registered and Northern Region offices within the jurisdiction
of this Court. The impugned order also emanates from the Respondents’
office at Delhi. Therefore, a substantial part of the cause of action arises
within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court.
9.
The Respondents have shifted their stand from time to time. In one
place, they describe the order dated 8th October, 2024 as a “promotion-cumtransfer” order. In another, they say it was merely a “promotion posting”.
Therefore, the Respondents are trying to recast the nature of the impugned
action to suit the occasion. The later posting to Kolkata was passed after the
writ petition had already been entertained and was intended only to blunt the
force of the grievance, while leaving the real complaint unanswered.
10.
The Respondents’ narrative that the posting in the Eastern Region
arose on account of vacancy created by another employee’s refusal is
W.P.(C) 10758/2025
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 06/04/2026 at 12:25:56
disputed. This explanation has been introduced for the first time in the
counter affidavit and is contradicted by the Respondents’ own records,
which demonstrate that vacancies existed in the Northern Region and that
similarly placed, and even junior, employees were accommodated therein.
11.
The subsequent posting to Kolkata does not address the grievance of
the Petitioner but, in fact, aggravates it, as Kolkata is even farther from his
native place and support system. This subsequent action underscores the
Respondents’ failure to apply the principles of reasonable accommodation in
a meaningful manner.
12.
The Petitioner, being a person with benchmark disability, is also
entitled to four additional casual leaves in terms of the applicable Office
Memoranda. Reliance is placed on the DoPT Office Memorandum dated
19th November, 2008, read with the DPE communication dated 13 th
November, 2024, to contend that such benefit stands extended to employees
of Central Public Sector Enterprises as well.
13.
Per Contra, Mr. Ashok Singh, Counsel for the Respondents No. 2 to
5, contest the petition on both maintainability and merits. First, the
Petitioner is now posted in Odisha and that Delhi has been invoked only
artificially. Union of India has been unnecessarily impleaded because
RailTel is a separate company and service decisions of the kind involved
here are not taken by the Ministry in day-to-day administration.
14.
The Petitioner’s case is much simpler than he presents it to be. The
Petitioner was appointed to a transferable technical post. His disability was
pre-existing. He accepted the terms of service with full knowledge that he
could be posted anywhere in India. The earlier accommodation at Delhi was
only an administrative adjustment made on request when a vacancy was
W.P.(C) 10758/2025
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 06/04/2026 at 12:25:56
available. That, according to the Respondents, cannot ripen into a permanent
right to remain in Delhi or to demand promotion in Delhi. It is further
contended that the Petitioner is capable of discharging his duties and that his
disability does not preclude him from holding a field assignment.
15.
The promotion granted to the Petitioner was inseparably linked to the
vacancy against which it arose. The Respondents rely on the promotion
order dated 9th May, 2024 to contend that one Nagendra Singh, who was
senior in merit and serving in the Northern Region, was posted on promotion
to the Eastern Region but declined the same on account of unwillingness to
relocate. The Petitioner, being in the waiting panel, was considered against
that very vacancy and promoted accordingly. The Petitioner, having
accepted the benefit of such promotion, is estopped from questioning the
transfer attached to it and cannot seek to retain the promotion while altering
the station of posting. He had the option to decline the promotion, as was
done by the said employee, but chose not to do so. In this regard, the
relevant extract of the waiting list panel dated 28th May, 2024, reads:
Waiting list Panel dated 28.05.2024
Technical Department – Promotions from E-3 to E-4 Level
Pay Scale Change: ₹60,000–1,80,000 → ₹70,000–2,00,000
16.
SN
Emp ID
Name
Region
Posted on Promotion
100152
Mr. Ashsh Khandelwal
NR
WR
100269
Mr. Navanit
ER
ER
100053
Mr. Pranay Mandai
ER
ER
100182
Mr. Devanshu Sharma
NR
ER
100047
Mr. Surajit Roy
ER
ER
100232
Mr. Yakoob Shah
SR
SR
Mr. Singh further submits that there was no vacancy in the Northern
W.P.(C) 10758/2025
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 06/04/2026 at 12:25:56
Region at the relevant level. No candidate from the waiting panel was
accommodated in the Northern Region in E-4 on the technical side. If the
Petitioner were now to be shifted to Delhi at the promoted level, it would
disturb the position of the senior candidate and lead to inequitable
consequences. The matters of transfer and posting fall within the domain of
the employer, and it is well settled that transfer is an incident of service with
which courts ought not to interfere in the absence of mala fides or violation
of statutory rules. Further, during the pendency of the present proceedings,
the Petitioner has already been shifted from Rourkela to NOC/Kolkata by
order dated 8th August, 2025, which is a non-field posting, indicating that the
organisation has attempted to accommodate the Petitioner to the extent
feasible.
17.
On the leave issue, the Respondents maintain that the DoPT Office
Memorandum dated 19th November, 2008 applies to Central Government
employees and not, by itself, to employees of RailTel as a CPSE. The
Petitioner has mixed up unrelated instructions and is attempting to derive an
entitlement where none exists.
Analysis
18.
The objection to territorial jurisdiction does not persuade the Court to
non-suit the Petitioner at the threshold. The Petitioner was serving in Delhi
when the order dated 8th October, 2024 was issued. RailTel’s corporate
office is at New Delhi. The Petitioner’s request for exemption from the
transfer consequence of promotion was addressed there. The rejection
communicated through CPGRAMS also emerged from that administrative
structure. It cannot therefore be said that no part of the cause of action arose
within the jurisdiction of this Court.
W.P.(C) 10758/2025
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 06/04/2026 at 12:25:56
19.
Turning to the main issue, the Court is unable to accept the
Petitioner’s submission that the present case can be approached as though it
involved an ordinary transfer, standing apart from the promotion granted to
him. The difficulty for the Petitioner lies precisely there. The record does
not show a routine rotational transfer imposed upon an employee who was
otherwise continuing in the same post. It shows a promotion-linked
placement against a specific vacancy in another region. The office order
dated 9th May, 2024, placed on record by the Respondents, shows that in the
main panel for promotion from E-3 to E-4, Nagendra Singh, who was then
serving in the Northern Region, was posted on promotion to the Eastern
Region. His letter dated 15th May, 2024 declining that promotion is also on
record, and it leaves no doubt that he was unwilling to relocate out of DelhiNCR. The Petitioner does not figure in that main panel. He appears only
later, in the provisional waiting list dated 28 th May, 2024. It is only
thereafter that the office memorandum dated 8th October, 2024 came to be
issued in his favour, granting him promotion with posting in the Eastern
Region. That sequence lends substantial support to the Respondents’ case
that the Petitioner’s promotion did not arise against some interchangeable
vacancy at large, but against the very opening created when the main-panel
candidate declined relocation to the Eastern Region.
20.
Once the matter is seen in that light, the nature of the Petitioner’s case
becomes clearer. He seeks to retain the promotion, but asks the Court to
sever from it the regional placement attached to the vacancy against which
he was promoted. That is a far more difficult submission than a challenge to
a routine transfer. In service law, a posting made as an incident of promotion
stands on a different footing from an ordinary rotational transfer, because it
W.P.(C) 10758/2025
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 06/04/2026 at 12:25:56
is tied to cadre management, availability of vacancies, and comparative
claims within the zone of consideration. Courts are slow to recast that
structure by judicial direction, unless a clear statutory infraction,
demonstrable mala fides, or patent perversity is shown. Here, the
contemporaneous documents relied upon by the Respondents show that the
vacancy in the Eastern Region first went to a candidate senior in merit, that
he refused to move, and that the Petitioner then accepted advancement
against that very vacancy. In that backdrop, the Petitioner’s request cannot
be treated as a simple plea for a more convenient posting. It is, in substance,
a request that the Court preserve the benefit of promotion while reworking
the vacancy position and posting consequence on which that promotion was
granted. That is precisely the area in which judicial restraint is ordinarily
called for.
21.
The Petitioner has pointed to instances where other employees,
including those junior to him, are alleged to have been accommodated in the
Northern Region. However, that circumstance, cannot negate the fact that
the Petitioner’s own promotion arose against a specific vacancy in the
Eastern Region. As mentioned above, cadre management decisions are
shaped by the timing of vacancies, the nature of posts, and the comparative
position of employees at different stages of the process. The existence of
isolated instances of retention or accommodation elsewhere does not
establish that a corresponding vacancy was available for the Petitioner at the
relevant time, nor does it warrant a judicial reconfiguration of the vacancy
against which his promotion was granted.
22.
The present petition, in substance, seeks to preserve the benefit of
advancement while restructuring the vacancy position against which that
W.P.(C) 10758/2025
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 06/04/2026 at 12:25:56
advancement was granted. In an exceptional case, disability-protective
instructions may justify intervention where the employer has acted
mechanically or without regard to the employee’s condition. Indeed, the
DoPT and DPE instructions invoked by the Petitioner are meant to ensure
preference, sensitivity, and reasonable accommodation. However, they do
not confer an absolute right to a posting of choice. Nor do they permit the
Court to direct that a promotion accepted against one vacancy be notionally
relocated to another region altogether.
23.
It must also be emphasized that this Court is unable to accept the
Respondents’ attempt to treat the Petitioner’s disability as insignificant to
merit serious consideration. That line of argument was both unnecessary and
misconceived. A person holding a valid disability certificate is not required
to
demonstrate
complete
incapacity
before
seeking
reasonable
accommodation. Nor can it be said that, merely because the disability
existed at the time of entry into service, the employee must thereafter accept
every posting consequence without complaint. Disability rights cannot be
read in that narrow way. The Petitioner was entitled to have his condition
considered with real sensitivity and not as an afterthought. But once that is
acknowledged, the question still remains whether the facts of the present
case justify the specific mandamus sought. In the opinion of the Court, they
do not. The Respondents were bound to consider accommodation; they were
not bound to place the Petitioner at the exact station of his choice. The
record shows that the Petitioner’s difficulty was not ignored altogether, and
the later non-field posting at NOC/Kolkata reflects at least some attempt at
accommodation within the organisational structure. That may not satisfy the
Petitioner’s preference for Delhi, but it weakens the case for judicial
W.P.(C) 10758/2025
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 06/04/2026 at 12:25:56
intervention commanding a particular posting.
24.
The Petitioner may be right in saying that Kolkata is not Delhi, and
that, from his point of view, it does not meet the need for proximity to
Hathras and Shahdara. But the law does not permit the Court to convert that
preference into a binding command to the employer.
25.
The decision in V.K. Bhasin do not compel a different result. The
decision emphasise that disability-related protections are real and that a
transfer decision may be interfered with where statutory safeguards are
treated as irrelevant. That principle is not in doubt. The difficulty here is
factual, not conceptual. This is not a case where the employer ignored
disability altogether and simply insisted upon a routine transfer in the face of
a binding exemption. It is a case where promotion arose against a vacancy in
another region, the Petitioner accepted that advancement, and the employer
later adjusted him from a field to a non-field post though not at the station he
preferred. The decision in Bhavneet Singh does not help the Petitioner’s
case either. There, the transfer was set aside for want of a justified
administrative basis despite availability of other employees. Here, the
posting flows from a specific vacancy against which the Petitioner was
promoted after a senior declined it. The impugned action is thus vacancylinked, not a standalone transfer, and cannot be recast in the same manner.
26.
The prayer for a direction that the Petitioner be transferred from the
Eastern Region to the Northern Region at Delhi in a non-field is declined.
However, in relation to the Petitioner’s claim for four additional casual
leaves, liberty is granted to the Petitioner to submit a fresh representation,
enclosing the office memoranda and communications on which he relies,
within two weeks from today. If such a representation is made, Respondent
W.P.(C) 10758/2025
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 06/04/2026 at 12:25:56
no. 2 shall consider and dispose of the same by a reasoned order within six
weeks thereafter.
27.
The writ petition is disposed of in the above terms. Pending
applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
APRIL 2, 2026/as
W.P.(C) 10758/2025
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 06/04/2026 at 12:25:56
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review