Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
LPA 65/2024
DELHI TRANSPORT CORPORATION
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Aviral Saxena & Mr. Paritosh
Goyal, Advocates.
versus
RANBIR SINGH
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. R.K. Nain, Mr. Chandan
Prajapati & Mr. Mukul Kumar,
Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TEJAS KARIA
ORDER
03.02.2026
%
CM APPL. 4777/2024 (Condonation of Delay)
1.
For the reasons stated in the Application, the delay of 162 days in
filing the Appeal is hereby condoned. The same is allowed.
2.
The Application stands disposed of.
CM APPL. 4780/2024 (Condonation of Delay)
3.
For the reasons stated in the Application, the delay of 162 days in re-
filing the Appeal is hereby condoned. The same is allowed.
4.
The Application stands disposed of.
LPA 65/2024 & CM APPL. 4779/2024 (Stay)
5.
This is an Intra Court Appeal challenging the order dated 04.01.2023
(“Impugned Order”) passed in W.P. C. 6392/2017 (“Writ Petition”) filed
by the Appellant being aggrieved by the Award dated 04.07.2016
LPA 65/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 07/02/2026 at 12:49:45
(“Award”) passed by the learned Labour Court, whereby in exercise of
power under Section 11A of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (“ID Act”),
the learned Labour Court modified the penalty of termination of the
Respondent by the Appellant to that of retirement.
6.
The Appellant has challenged the Impugned Order on the ground that
the learned Single Judge erred in law by granting relief of 50% of the
pension although the Respondent was on unauthorized leave from
20.09.2007 to 03.09.2008 affecting the day-to-day operations of the
Appellant, which provides essential public service.
7.
The brief facts leading to the filing of the present Appeal are as under:
7.1.The Respondent was appointed as a driver by the Appellant on
20.01.1985. On a report against the Respondent for unauthorized
absence from the duty, a charge-sheet dated 11.09.2008 was
issued to the Respondent for unauthorized absence from service
during the period from 20.09.2007 to 03.09.2008.
7.2.The Respondent failed to submit his reply to the charge-sheet
within the stipulated time. Consequently, the case file was sent to
the Enquiry Officer (North) for conducting a detailed enquiry in
the case. The Enquiry Officer conducted a detailed enquiry after
following the principles of natural justice by giving full
opportunity to the Respondent to be heard and to defend his case.
7.3.On 27.04.2009, during the enquiry proceedings, the Respondent
admitted the charges levelled against him and the Enquiry Officer
submitted an Enquiry Report to the Depot Manager. On
13.05.2009, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the Respondent
for removal from service asking reasons as to why his services
LPA 65/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 07/02/2026 at 12:49:45
should not be terminated. On 18.05.2009, the Respondent
submitted his reply. As the reply was not found to be satisfactory,
the Appellant vide Office Memo dated 20.05.2009 removed the
Respondent from service of the Appellant.
7.4.On 01.06.2009, the Respondent filed an appeal against the
removal before the Regional Manager, which was rejected. Being
aggrieved with the removal, the Respondent filed a statement of
claim before the learned Labour Court on 16.11.2009.
7.5.The learned Labour Court vide order dated 04.07.2016 took a
sympathetic ground and modified the order of removal and held
that the Respondent would be deemed to have retired with effect
from 20.05.2009. Being aggrieved by the order dated 04.07.2016
passed by the learned Labour Court, the Appellant challenged the
same vide Writ Petition.
7.6.The learned Single Judge vide the Impugned Order modified the
order of learned Labour Court and reduced the pension for the
period from 20.05.2009 till 04.07.2016 to 50% in the interest of
justice and granted full pension with effect from 04.07.2016.
Being aggrieved by the Impugned Order, the Appellant has
preferred the present Appeal.
8.
The learned Counsel for the Appellant has submitted that the
Respondent admitted the charges, which were levelled against him. The
Respondent further explained that he availed the leave due to the illness of
his ailing mother and sister-in-law, however, could not inform the Appellant
as no co-worker was living near his residence. It was further submitted that
the Respondent’s past record revealed that there were 14 adverse entries
LPA 65/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 07/02/2026 at 12:49:45
against him, out of which 11 entries were only for unauthorized absence for
which major punishment had been awarded to him. The learned Counsel for
the Appellant submitted that the learned Labour Court vide the Award
observed that principles of natural justice were fully followed during the
domestic enquiry and also found that the unauthorized absence from duty for
about a year shows the complete lack of devotion to duty on part of the
Respondent. The learned Labour Court also observed that there was no
illegality in the removal of the Respondent. However, despite the same, the
learned Labour Court took a sympathetic view considering the length of
service of the Respondent of about 25 years. Accordingly, the learned
Labour Court found that the punishment of removing the Respondent from
service was slightly disproportionate to the proved misconduct and held that
the Respondent would be deemed to have retired with effect from
20.05.2009 and in turn would be entitled to all retirement and consequential
benefits including the pension.
9.
It was further submitted on behalf of the Appellant that the learned
Single Judge while agreeing with the submissions of the Appellant regarding
the unauthorized absence of the Respondent, further modified the order
dated 04.07.2016 overlooking the material facts and evidence on record and
directed the payment of 50% of the pension for the period from 20.05.2009
to 04.07.2016 and full pension with effect from 04.07.2016. Accordingly,
the learned Single Judge failed to appreciate that power under Section 11A
of the ID Act has to be exercised judiciously and the learned Labour Court
was expected to interfere under Section 11A of the ID Act only when it was
satisfied that the punishment imposed by the management was wholly and
shockingly disproportionate to the degree of the guilt of the workman
LPA 65/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 07/02/2026 at 12:49:45
concerned. It was submitted that considering the nature of the duties
attached to the post of the driver of a bus and his past record of unauthorized
leave, the learned Single Judge failed to consider that the power under
Section 11A of the ID Act is very limited.
10.
It was submitted on behalf of the Appellant that the learned Single
Judge erred in not considering the ratio laid down in Standard Chartered
Bank v. R. P. Srivastava, 2021 SCC OnLine SC 830, where the Hon’ble
Supreme Court had upheld the employer’s dismissal order issued after a
domestic enquiry and clarified that the scope of judicial review of domestic
enquiry is limited to ensuring that the enquiry process adheres to proper
procedure and complies with the principles of natural justice. Further, it
emphasized that the learned Labour Court’s decision should not be based
upon mere assumption and cannot arbitrarily overturn the management’s
decision despite the broad jurisdiction under Section 11A of the ID Act and
cautioned against the careless and whimsical exercise of this authority. The
relevant extract is reproduced as under:
“10. However, in the instant case, the Tribunal converted itself
into a Court of Appeal and has not only revisited the evidence in toto
but has proceeded on the assumption that the management has to
prove the charges beyond reasonable doubt and despite the material
evidence of three officers, who were abused by respondent-workman
in drunkenness condition, have been completely disowned on the
premise that one Watchman (DW-1) and an ex-employee of the
Bank(DW-2) have stated in their deposition that such incident has
not occurred and to justify it, a document was placed on record i.e.
the attendance register of the time in question and to confront it
further with the fact that the delinquent had not appeared in the
domestic enquiry and still a finding has been recorded by the
Tribunal that such incidence has not occurred is something which
has appeared from blue and without there being any iota of the
factual foundation, the interference made by the tribunal in the
LPA 65/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 07/02/2026 at 12:49:45
finding of guilt recorded in the course of enquiry is not only
perverse but is unsustainable in law.
11.
The scope of judicial review in the matter of domestic enquiry
is to examine whether the procedure in holding domestic enquiry
has been violated or the principles of natural justice has been
complied with, or any perversity in the finding of guilt recorded
during the course of domestic enquiry has been committed. The
basic error which was committed by the Tribunal in its impugned
Award has not been appreciated even by the High Court and
dismissed the writ petition without appreciating the finding recorded
in the domestic enquiry keeping into consideration the principles
laid down by this Court of preponderance of probabilities while
holding guilt in the domestic enquiry and exceeded in its jurisdiction
defined under Section 11-A of the Act 1947. To the contrary, the
officers with whom the alleged occurrence of gross misconduct has
been committed have been put to notice that their allegation on the
face of it is unfounded, baseless and has not at all occurred which is
something beyond imagination. More so, when it was established
during the course of enquiry after affording an opportunity of
hearing to the delinquent respondent, enquiry officer held the
charges proved and confirmed by the disciplinary authority followed
with the penalty of dismissal upon the respondent.
*****
******
******
18.
In the instant case, after we have gone through the record, we
find that the Tribunal has converted itself into a Court of Appeal as
an appellate authority and has exceeded its jurisdiction while
appreciating the finding recorded in the course of domestic enquiry
and tested on the broad principles of charge to be proved beyond
reasonable doubt which is a test in the criminal justice system and
has completely forgotten the fact that the domestic enquiry is to be
tested on the principles of preponderance of probabilities and if a
piece of evidence is on record which could support the charge which
has been levelled against the delinquent unless it is per se
unsustainable or perverse, ordinarily is not to be interfered by the
Tribunal, more so when the domestic enquiry has been held to be
fair and proper and, in our view, the Tribunal has completely
overlooked and exceeded its jurisdiction while interfering with the
finding recorded during the course of enquiry in furtherance of
LPA 65/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 07/02/2026 at 12:49:45
which, the respondent was dismissed from service and the High
Court has also committed a manifest error while passing the
judgment impugned.”
11.
The learned Counsel for the Appellant also relied upon the decision in
LIC of India v. R. Dhandapani, (2006) 13 SCC 613, wherein it is held that:
“7.
It is not necessary to go into detail regarding the power
exercisable under Section 11-A of the Act. The power under the said
Section 11-A has to be exercised judiciously and the Industrial
Tribunal or the Labour Court, as the case may be, is expected to
interfere with the decision of the management under Section 11-A of
the Act only when it is satisfied that punishment imposed by the
management is wholly and shockingly disproportionate to the
degree of guilt of the workman concerned. To support its conclusion
the Industrial Tribunal or the Labour Court, as the case may be, has
to give reasons in support of its decision. The power has to be
exercised judiciously and mere use of the words “disproportionate”
or “grossly disproportionate” by itself will not be sufficient.
8.
In recent times, there is an increasing evidence of this,
perhaps well-meant but wholly unsustainable, tendency towards a
denudation of the legitimacy of judicial reasoning and process. The
reliefs granted by the courts must be seen to be logical and tenable
within the framework of the law and should not incur and justify the
criticism that the jurisdiction of the courts tends to degenerate into
misplaced sympathy, generosity and private benevolence. It is
essential to maintain the integrity of legal reasoning and the
legitimacy of the conclusions. They must emanate logically from the
legal findings and the judicial results must be seen to be principled
and supportable on those findings. Expansive judicial mood of
mistaken and misplaced compassion at the expense of the legitimacy
of the process will eventually lead to mutually irreconcilable
situations and denude the judicial process of its dignity, authority,
predictability and respectability. (See Kerala Solvent Extractions
Lid. v. A. Unnikrishnan².)
9.
Though under Section 11-A, the Tribunal has the power to
reduce the quantum of punishment it has to be done within the
parameters of law. Possession of power is itself not sufficient; it has
to be exercised in accordance with law.”
LPA 65/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 07/02/2026 at 12:49:45
12.
Further, the learned Counsel for the Appellant relied upon the
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Uttar Pradesh State Road
Transport Corporation v. Gajadhar Nath, (2022) 3 SCC 190, wherein it is
held that:
“when a proper enquiry has been held by the employer, and the
finding of misconduct is a plausible conclusion flowing from the
evidence, adduced at the said enquiry, the Tribunal has no
jurisdiction to sit in judgment over the decision of the employer as
an appellate body.”
13.
The learned Counsel for the Appellant submitted that the learned
Single Judge failed to appreciate that the unauthorized absence of about one
year sufficiently proved the absolute lack of devotion on part of the
Respondent towards his duty and hence did not deserve any relief either by
the learned Labour Court or by the learned Single Judge. The learned Single
Judge also overlooked the fact that the Appellant followed the rules under
Delhi Road Transport Authority (Conditions of Appointment and Services)
Regulations, 1952 concerning the disqualification of the employee /
workman by conducting a fair and impartial enquiry before terminating the
Respondent. The relevant rules are reproduced as under:
“Under Para 15(1) of D.R.T.A. (Conditions of Appointment &
Service, 1952, the following standing orders are issued, governing
the conduct of the Authority’s Employees. A breach of these orders
by any employee will amount to misconduct and make him liable to
disciplinary action referred to in para 15(2) of the said regulations:4. Absence without permission
(i) An employee shall not absent himself from his duties without
having first obtained the permission from the Authority or the
competent officer except in the case of sudden illness. In the case of
sudden illness, he shall send intimation to the office immediately. If
the illness lasts or is expected to last for more than 3 days at a time,
LPA 65/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 07/02/2026 at 12:49:45
application for leave should be duly accompanied by a medicate
certificate from a registered medical practitioner or the Medical
Officer of the D.T.S. In no case shall an employee leave station
without prior permission.
(ii) Habitual absence without permission or sanction of leave and
any continuous absence without such leave for more than 10 days
shall render the employee liable to be treated as an absconder
resulting in the termination of his service with the organisation.
*****
***** ******
15 – Conduct, Discipline and Appeal:1. Conduct – The Delhi Road Transport Authority may from time to
time issue standing orders governing the conduct if this orders. The
breach of such orders will amount to ‘MISCONDUCT’ and make
him liable to disciplinary action referred to Para 15(2) of the said
regulations.
(1) (A) Suspension pending enquiry or criminal investigation etc –
The appointing authority of any officer delegated with powers by the
appointing authority in this behalf may place an employee under
suspension.
(i) Where a disciplinary proceedings are pending against him is
contemplated or is pending;
(ii) Where the criminal proceedings in respect of any offense is
under investigation or trial;
A statement setting out in detail the reasons for such suspension
shall be supplied to the employee within a week from the date of
suspension.
(2) (B) An employee who is placed under suspension under sub
clause (1) (A) shall during the period of such substances allowing at
the rate indicated suspension shall be paid in clause 15 (4) (a) (b).
The employee is liable for disciplinary action referred to Para 15(2)
of the said regulations for ‘MISCONDUCT’ in case of breach of
standing orders issued under para 15(1) of DRTA (Conditions of
Appointment & Service) Regulations 1952. They are:19. General Provisions: Without prejudice to the provisions of the
foregoing Standing Orders, the following acts of commission and
omission shall be treated as mis-conduct.
LPA 65/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 07/02/2026 at 12:49:45
(a) ……….
(b) Theft, fraud or dishonesty in connection with the Authority
business or property;
(c) Willful damage or loss to Authority’s goods or property;
(d)………..
(e)………..
(f) Habitual breach of any rules, law, instructions or orders etc.
applicable to the employees of the Authority
(g)………
(h) Habitual negligence of duties and lack of interest in the
Authority’s work.
(i)……..
(j)……..
(k) Any offence involving moral turpitude which is punishable under
the I.P.C.
(l)………
(m) Any other activity not specifically covered above, but which is
prima facie detrimental to the interests of the organization
1. Discipline (a) – The following penalties may for misconduct for a
good or sufficient reason may be imposed on the employee of the
Delhi State Transport Authority.
(i) Censor including reprimand and warning;
(ii) Withholding of increment or promotion including stoppage at an
efficiency bar;
(iii) Reduction to a lower post or timescale or to a lower stage in a
timescale;
(iv) Recovery from pay or the security or any other dues of the whole
or part of any pecuniary loss caused to the Delhi Road Transport
Authority by negligently default or breach of orders. The term
pecuniary loss shall include damage to or loss of stores expressly
entrusted to the person concerned for custody;
(v) Suspension;
(vi) Removal from the services of Delhi Road Transport Authority;
(vii) Dismissal from the service of Delhi Road Transport Authority
(viii) Fines as provided in Payment of Wages Act.”
14.
Accordingly, it was submitted that the learned Single Judge
committed an error by not considering that the Respondent did not have a
clean track record and was found guilty of misconduct in the past as well.
LPA 65/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 07/02/2026 at 12:49:45
The learned Counsel for the Appellant submitted that the learned Single
Judge failed to appreciate the ratio laid down by this Court in Bharat
Bhushan v. D.T.C, (W.P.(C) No. 1771/2008), wherein it is held that:
“16. In the case of DTC Vs. Sardar Singh, 2004 SCC (L&S) 946,
the Apex Court at page 950 in para 9 has observed as under:
“9. When an employee absents himself from duty, even
without sanctioned leave for a very long period, it prima
facie shows lack of interest in work. Para 19(h) of the
Standing Orders as quoted above, relates to habitual
negligence of duties and lack of interest in the authority’s
work. When an employee absents himself from duty
without sanctioned leave, the authority can, on the basis
of the record, come to a conclusion about the employee
being habitually negligent in duties and an exhibited lack
of interest in the employer’s work. Ample material was
produced before the Tribunal in each case to show as to
how the employees concerned were remaining absent for
long periods which affects the work of the employer and
the employee concerned was required at least to bring
some material on record to show as to how his absence
was on the basis of sanctioned leave and as to how there
was no negligence. Habitual absence is a factor which
establishes lack of interest in work. There cannot be any
sweeping generalisation. But at the same time some
telltale features can be noticed and pressed into service
to arrive at conclusions in the departmental
proceedings.”
17.
In the case of Indian Iron Steel Company Vs. Their Workmen,
AIR 1958 SC 130, it was held: “Mere fact that the workman applied
for leave is no ground for excusing him when the leave was
refused.”
15.
The learned Counsel for the Appellant also submitted that the
Appellant being a large corporation, the Impugned Order will be a precedent
and has caused grave inconvenience and hardship to the Appellant. In view
of the same, it is prayed that the Impugned Order be set aside.
LPA 65/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 07/02/2026 at 12:49:45
16.
We have considered the submissions made by the learned Counsel for
the Appellant.
17.
Section 11A of the ID Act provides as under:
“11A. Powers of Labour Courts, Tribunals and National Tribunals
to give appropriate relief in case of discharge or dismissal of
workmen.— Where an industrial dispute relating to the discharge or
dismissal of a workman has been referred to a Labour Court,
Tribunal or National Tribunal for adjudication and, in the course of
the adjudication proceedings, the Labour Court, Tribunal or
National Tribunal, as the case may be, is satisfied that the order of
discharge or dismissal was not justified, it may, by its award, set
aside the order of discharge or dismissal and direct reinstatement of
the workman on such terms and conditions, if any, as it thinks fit, or
give such other relief to the workman including the award of any
lesser punishment in lieu of discharge or dismissal as the
circumstances of the case may require:
Provided that in any proceeding under this section the Labour
Court, Tribunal or National Tribunal, as the case may be, shall rely
only on the materials on record and shall not take any fresh
evidence in relation to the matter”
18.
The learned Single Judge has after considering the factual matrix and
the submissions made by the Parties, concluded that the direction of
payment of full pension to the Respondent for the period between
20.05.2009 till the date of passing of the Award was unsustainable as the
Respondent having remained on leave without sanction did not deserve to
receive full pension from the date of his initial termination. Accordingly, in
the interest of justice, it was directed that the Respondent will be paid only
50% of the pension for the period between 20.05.2009 till the date of
Award, i.e., 04.07.2016 and will be entitled to receive full pension with
effect from 04.07.2016.
LPA 65/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 07/02/2026 at 12:49:45
19.
It is a settled law that the power under Section 11A of the ID Act has
to exercised judiciously and only when the learned Labour Court is satisfied
that the punishment imposed by the management was wholly and shockingly
disproportionate to the degree of guilt of the workman concerned. The
learned Labour Court has exercised the power under Section 11A of the ID
Act considering the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case especially
the long service of 25 years rendered by the Respondent.
20.
Accordingly, such exercise of power by the learned Labour Court
under Section 11A of the ID Act cannot be considered to be a whimsical
exercise of the power. In support of the decision to exercise power under
Section 11A of the ID Act, the learned Labour Court has given the reasons,
which appear to be justified.
21.
The learned Single Judge has further modified the Award by reducing
the pension during the pendency of the proceedings before the learned
Labour Court to 50% considering the overall facts and circumstances of the
case and in the interest of justice. Accordingly, the Appellant has partially
succeeded before the learned Single Judge.
22.
As the power under Section 11A of the ID Act is discretionary and the
said discretion exercised by the learned Labour Court is already modified in
the Impugned Order, no further interference is required in the Award as well
as the Impugned Order. The findings arrived at by the learned Labour Court
and the learned Single Judge are proportionate to the degree of guilt of the
Respondent and, accordingly, are in accordance with the law laid down in
relation to the provisions of Section 11A of the ID Act.
23.
As the Show Cause Notice only alleged the unauthorized leave from
20.09.2007 to 03.09.2008, the argument of the Appellant that the past record
LPA 65/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 07/02/2026 at 12:49:45
of the Respondent ought to have been taken into consideration, is not
sustainable. The learned Labour Court as well as the learned Single Judge
have considered the overall facts and circumstances of the case, especially
the long service of 25 years rendered by the Respondent, and have arrived at
the conclusion that the penalty of termination of the Respondent by the
Appellant be converted to that of retirement and the Respondent be granted
relief of 50% of the pension for the period from 20.05.2009 till 04.07.2016
and full pension with effect from 04.07.2016.
24.
Accordingly, no interference is warranted with the Award as well as
the Impugned Order and the present Appeal stands dismissed. There should
be no order as to costs.
DEVENDRA KUMAR UPADHYAYA, CJ
TEJAS KARIA, J
FEBRUARY 3, 2026
ap
LPA 65/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 07/02/2026 at 12:49:45
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review