Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 16th January, 2026
Date of Decision: 12th February, 2026
Uploaded on: 13th February, 2026
+
W.P.(C) 6398/2017 & CM APPL. 26448/2017
DELHI TRANSPORT CORPORATION
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. L.K. Passi & Ms. Ruby, Advs.
versus
RAM DHARI SINGH
Through:
.....Respondent
Ms. Amita Singh Kalkal, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE SHAIL JAIN
JUDGMENT
SHAIL JAIN, J
1.
The present Writ Petition has been filed by the Petitioner, Delhi
Transport Corporation, under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of
India, assailing the Award dated 8th July, 2016 (hereinafter referred to as the
“Impugned Award”) passed by the learned Presiding Officer, POLC-XVII,
Karkardooma Court, Delhi (hereinafter referred to as the “ Labour Court”)
in LIR No. 6809/16, arising out of an industrial dispute between the
petitioner - Management/Delhi Transport Corporation (hereinafter referred
to as “DTC”) and the respondent–workman, Sh. Ram Dhari Singh.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
2.
The brief factual matrix as emerging from the record shows that the
Respondent-workman, Sh. Ram Dhari Singh, was appointed as a Conductor
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
15:38:57
W.P.(C) 6398/2017
on permanent post with the DTC in the year 1985 and continued in service
until his termination on 29th August, 2003.
3.
A Charge-Sheet dated 23rd July, 2001 was issued to the Respondent
for being unauthorizedly absent from duty w.e.f. 7 th April, 2001 to 23rd July,
2001. Prior thereto, letters dated 19th April, 2001, 4th May, 2001 and 24th
May, 2001 were dispatched directing him either to report for duty or, in case
of illness, to appear before the DTC Medical Board at I.P. Depot for
examination. It is the case of the Petitioner that the Respondent neither
reported for duty nor appeared before the Medical Board. Consequently,
vide Order dated 31st December, 2001, a domestic enquiry was instituted.
The enquiry was conducted on 4th February, 2002.
As per the enquiry proceedings, the Enquiry Officer read over and
explained the contents of the Charge-Sheet to the Respondent. The
Respondent acknowledged receipt of the Charge-Sheet and the report
forming the basis thereof. He declined assistance of a co-worker or labour
welfare inspector and stated that he would defend himself. The Respondent
admitted the charge of unauthorized absence during the course of the
domestic enquiry. It is further recorded in the enquiry proceedings that, in
his defence, he stated that he could not report for duty on account of illness.
The Enquiry Officer submitted his findings dated 7 th February, 2002 holding
the charge proved.
After receipt of the enquiry report, the Disciplinary Authority issued a
Show-Cause Notice dated 4th July, 2003 proposing the penalty of removal
from service. The Respondent submitted his reply dated 13 th August, 2003.
Upon consideration of the enquiry record, the reply to the Show-Cause
Notice, and the past service record, the Disciplinary Authority imposed the
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
15:38:57
W.P.(C) 6398/2017
penalty of removal from service vide order dated 29th August, 2003.
6.
The Petitioner has placed reliance upon the past service record of the
Respondent, which reflects multiple instances of such unauthorized absence.
It is stated that the Respondent had been subjected to several punishments in
the past, including censure, stoppage of increments with cumulative effect,
and reduction in time scale, on account of similar misconduct. Aggrieved by
the order of removal, the Respondent raised an industrial dispute. Vide Order
No. F.24(951)/06/Lab./6075–79, dated 8th August, 2007, issued by the
Government of NCT of Delhi, the following question was referred for
adjudication before the Labour Court:
“Whether the punishment of removal from service imposed upon
Sh. Ram Dhari Singh S/o Sh. Mehanti Singh by the management
vide order dated 29.08.2003 is illegal and/or unjustified, and if
so,to what sum of money as monetary relief along with other
consequential benefits in terms of existing Laws/Govt.
notifications and what other relief is he entitled and what
directions are necessary in this respect ?”
7.
The Labour Court framed two issues for consideration: First, whether
the domestic enquiry was fair and in accordance with the principles of
natural justice; and Second, whether the punishment of removal was legal
and justified. By Order dated 19th May, 2016, the Labour Court upheld the
domestic enquiry, holding that the Enquiry Officer had not violated any
principle of natural justice and that the findings recorded in the enquiry
report were not perverse. While deciding the Second issue, the Labour Court
held that the charge of unauthorized absence was proved and that the
removal was not illegal. However, taking into account the Respondent’s
length of service, the Labour Court exercised its powers under Section 11-A
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
15:38:57
W.P.(C) 6398/2017
of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (hereinafter referred to as “ID
Act,1947”) and modified the punishment to deemed retirement with
consequential retiral benefits.
8.
Aggrieved by the modification of punishment despite findings in its
favour on the issue of enquiry and misconduct, the petitioner has approached
this Court under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India.
9.
During the pendency of the present petition, this Court, vide order
dated 20th September, 2017, stayed the operation of the impugned Award
subject to the petitioner depositing 50% of the awarded amount with the
Registrar General of this Court.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF PARTIES
10.
Learned counsel for the Petitioner submits that the impugned Award
warrants interference, as the learned Labour Court, despite deciding both
issues in favour of the Management, has erroneously modified the
punishment.
11.
In elaboration of the aforesaid submission, it is contended that the
Respondent was Charge-Sheeted on 23rd July, 2001 for remaining
unauthorizedly absent from duty for the period from 7th April, 2001 to 23rd
July, 2001. Despite repeated communications directing him to report for
duty or to appear before the Medical Board, and notwithstanding due service
of the Charge-Sheet and subsequent reminders, the Respondent failed to
submit any written reply. However, during the course of the domestic
enquiry, the Respondent admitted the charge of unauthorized absence. A
regular domestic enquiry was conducted in which the charge stood admitted.
Upon consideration of the enquiry report, the Show-Cause Notice and the
Respondent’s reply, the Disciplinary Authority imposed the penalty of
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
15:38:57
W.P.(C) 6398/2017
removal from service by order dated 29th August, 2003.
12.
It is further submitted in this regard that the misconduct was not
isolated but part of a consistent pattern. The Respondent’s service record
reflects more than eight adverse entries and at least four major punishments,
including censure, stoppage of increments with cumulative effect and
reduction in time scale. Despite repeated disciplinary action, his conduct did
not improve. The penalty of removal was thus imposed after due
consideration of his habitual absence and adverse record.
13.
In continuation thereof, learned counsel for the petitioner submitted
that the Labour Court, vide order dated 19th May, 2016, upheld the validity
of the enquiry and found the charge proved, holding that there was no
illegality in the removal. Having so held, it erred in modifying the
punishment solely on the ground of length of service.
14.
In support of the aforesaid contentions, reliance is placed on Bharat
Bhushan v. Delhi Transport Corporation, WP(C) No. 1771/2008, and
Indian Iron & Steel Co. Ltd. v. Their Workmen, AIR 1958 SC 130, to
contend that habitual unauthorized absence reflects lack of devotion to duty
and justifies strict disciplinary action. It is submitted that mere length of
service cannot outweigh repeated misconduct, particularly where earlier
punishments failed to yield improvement.
15.
In view of the above submissions, it is urged that once the enquiry and
findings were upheld and the past record demonstrated habitual negligence,
interference under Section 11-A of the ID Act, 1947 was unwarranted. The
impugned Award, insofar as it modifies the penalty to deemed retirement
with consequential benefits, is therefore liable to be set aside.
16.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the Respondent submits that
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
15:38:57
W.P.(C) 6398/2017
the present Writ Petition is devoid of merit and does not warrant interference
under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India. It is contended that
the Labour Court, having upheld the validity of the domestic enquiry and the
finding of misconduct, rightly exercised its powers under Section 11-A of
the ID Act, 1947.
17.
In furtherance of his submissions, it is submitted that although the
charge of unauthorized absence was held proved, the Labour Court noted
that the Respondent had rendered approximately 18 years of service and that
such length of service was not considered while imposing the penalty of
removal. On that basis, the punishment was held disproportionate and
modified to be deemed retirement. According to the Respondent, the said
exercise of discretion is within jurisdiction and does not suffer from
perversity.
18.
In support of the said contention, it has further submitted that the
issue is covered by the decision of this Court in DTC v. Ranbir Singh, 2023
DHC (W.P.(C) 6392/2017), wherein in similar circumstances the
modification of removal to compulsory retirement, taking into account long
years of service, was upheld. It is contended that the present case stands on
identical footing and, therefore, no interference is called for.
19.
The Respondent submits that his absence was due to illness and that
relevant medical certificates were placed on record. It is contended that
neither his medical explanation nor his 18 years of service were properly
taken into account before the penalty of removal was imposed.
20.
Reliance is also placed, in this context, on the decision of this Court in
Raxa Security Services Ltd. v. Sagar Kumar Mandal, 2023 DHC (W.P.
(C) 8942/2023) , and on the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
15:38:57
W.P.(C) 6398/2017
D.K. Yadav v. J.M.A. Industries Ltd., (1993) 3 SCC 259, to submit that
termination
of
service
has
serious
civil
consequences
and
that
proportionality and fairness must inform disciplinary action.
21.
In culmination of the aforesaid submissions, it is, therefore, contended
on behalf of the Respondent that he is not challenging the impugned Award;
rather, he supports the Award dated 8th July, 2016 and submits that the
Labour Court has exercised its discretion under Section 11-A of the ID Act,
1947 in accordance with settled principles of law. It is further urged that the
present Writ Petition essentially seeks a re-evaluation of the proportionality
of punishment, which falls outside the limited scope of supervisory
jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India.
ISSUE FOR CONSIDERATION
22.
Whether, after upholding the validity of the domestic enquiry and
affirming that the charge of unauthorized absence stood proved, the Labour
Court was justified in exercising its powers under Section 11-A of the ID
Act, 1947 to modify the penalty of removal from service imposed vide order
dated 29th August, 2003 to that of deemed retirement with consequential
retiral benefits?
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS
23.
At the outset, it is necessary to note that the jurisdiction of this Court
under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution is supervisory and not
appellate. This Court does not re-appreciate evidence or substitute its own
view on facts. Interference is warranted only where the Adjudicating
Authority has acted without or in excess of jurisdiction, or where the
impugned Award suffers from patent illegality, perversity, or misapplication
of settled principles. In the context of Section 11-A of the ID Act, 1947, the
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
15:38:57
W.P.(C) 6398/2017
Labour Court may substitute the penalty only upon recording a finding that
the punishment is shockingly disproportionate to the proved misconduct or
that mitigating circumstances exist. In the absence of such a finding, the
exercise of discretion travels beyond the limits of the statute and would
warrant interference in exercise of writ jurisdiction.
24.
The adjudication before the Labour Court proceeded in two parts. The
following issues were framed for determination:
i) Whether the enquiry conducted against the workman in
terms of charge sheet dt. 23.07.2001 was not just, fair,
proper and was not in accordance with the principles of
natural justice, if so its effect? OP
ii) As per terms of reference.
25.
The Labour Court addressed the preliminary issue concerning the
validity of the domestic enquiry conducted pursuant to the Charge-Sheet
dated 23rd July, 2001 relating to unauthorized absence from 7th April, 2001
to 23rd July, 2001. The enquiry proceedings dated 4th February, 2002 were
examined in this regard.
26.
The Labour Court recorded that the workman had duly acknowledged
receipt of the Charge-Sheet along with the accompanying report and had
signed the enquiry proceedings, thereby effectively negating the plea of nonsupply of documents. It is further noted that the Enquiry Officer had offered
the workman the assistance of a co-worker or Labour Welfare Inspector,
which was declined by him, and that representation through an advocate is
not contemplated in domestic enquiries. The allegation that the admission of
guilt had been obtained under coercion was disbelieved, as the Charge-Sheet
had been read over and explained to the workman prior to recording his
admission and no contemporaneous complaint was lodged . The Labour
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
15:38:57
W.P.(C) 6398/2017
Court also found that no medical document pertaining to the relevant period
of absence was produced before the Enquiry Officer and that the documents
subsequently relied upon related to a later period and were therefore
irrelevant.
27.
On the basis of the aforesaid discussion, the Labour Court answered
the preliminary issue in favour of the management in the following terms:
“In view of above discussion, the enquiry issue is decided in
favour of management and against claimant by holding that
Enquiry Officer had not violated any principle of natural justice
and that his report is not perverse.”
The Labour Court thus upheld the enquiry as fair and proper and found no
infirmity in the report of the Enquiry Officer.
28.
Having upheld the enquiry, the Labour Court proceeded to consider
Issue No. 2 relating to the legality and proportionality of the punishment.
The workman attributed his absence to illness. The management, however,
relied upon the admitted fact that the workman had remained unauthorizedly
absent from 7th April, 2001 to 23rd July, 2001 despite repeated directions to
report for duty or appear before the Medical Board, and further relied upon
his adverse past service record. The Labour Court recorded that the charge
of unauthorized absence stood proved and that the workman had been
punished on several earlier occasions for similar misconduct.
29.
In support of its finding that habitual unauthorized absence reflects
lack of devotion to duty and warrants disciplinary action, the Labour Court
placed reliance upon Bharat Bhushan v. Delhi Transport Corporation
(W.P.(C) No. 1771/2008), decided on 25th October, 2010, wherein it was
held as follows:
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
15:38:57
W.P.(C) 6398/2017
16. In the case of DTC v. Sardar Singh 2004 SCC (L&S) 946,the
Apex Court at page 950 in para 9 has observed as under:
9. When an employee absents himself from duty, even without
sanctioned leave for a very long period, it prima facie shows
lack of interest in work. Para 19(h) of the Standing Orders as
quoted above, relates to habitual negligence of duties and lack
of interest in the authority's work. When an employee absents
himself from duty without sanctioned leave, the authority can,
on the basis of the record, come to a conclusion about the
employee being habitually negligent in duties and an exhibited
lack of interest in the employer's work. Ample material was
produced before the Tribunal in each case to show as to how
the employees concerned were remaining absent for long
periods which affects the work of the employer and the
employee concerned was required at least to bring some
material on record to show as to how his absence was on the
basis of sanctioned leaves and as to how there was no
negligence. Habitual absence is a factor which establishes lack
of interest in work. There cannot be any sweeping
generalization. But at the same time some telltale features can
be noticed and pressed into service to arrive at conclusions in
the departmental proceedings.
17. In the case of Indian Iron Steel Company Vs. Their Workmen,
AIR 1958 SC 130, it was held:
“Mere fact that the workman applied for leave is no ground for
excusing him when the leave was refused.”
18. In view of the settled law as well as on the facts and
circumstances in the matter, I am of the considered view that
the Tribunal was justified by not interfering with the
punishment imposed by the respondent and this Court does not
find any valid ground mentioned in the writ petition to interfere
with the same. The writ petition is dismissed. No orders as to
cost.
...[emphasis supplied]
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
15:38:57
W.P.(C) 6398/2017
30.
This Court takes note of the fact that the Petitioner–Corporation is a
public transport undertaking discharging essential public functions.
Unauthorized absence of operational staff such as Conductors has a direct
bearing on service delivery and public convenience. In such an organisation,
operational discipline maintains a direct nexus with public interest and
service continuity. Prolonged unauthorized absence, therefore, cannot be
regarded as a mere private lapse devoid of institutional consequence.
31.
Notwithstanding the proved misconduct and the adverse past record,
the Labour Court, taking into account that the respondent had rendered
approximately 18 years of service, held the punishment of removal to be
slightly disproportionate and modified it to that of deemed retirement with
consequential retiral benefits and interest.
32.
The operative portion of the Award reads as follows:
“Taking into account 18 years length of service of the
claimant, the order dated 29.08.2003 passed by the
management for terminating him from service is slightly
modified to the extent that the claimant shall be deemed to
have retired on 29.08.2003. All retiral and consequential
benefits like pension (if he had opted for the same) and
others be given to him. The management is directed to pay
the said benefits to the claimant within a month from the
date of publication of the award failing which it shall be
liable to pay interest @ 9 per cent per annum from today
till realization. Award is passed accordingly.”
...[emphasis supplied]
33.
The Labour Court, having upheld the validity of the domestic enquiry
and recorded a categorical finding that the Respondent remained
unauthorizedly absent from 7th April, 2001 to 23rd July, 2001, and having
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
15:38:57
W.P.(C) 6398/2017
also considered his adverse past service record, those findings have not been
independently assailed before this Court. The Respondent has neither
challenged the order affirming the enquiry nor demonstrated any perversity,
absence of evidence, or jurisdictional infirmity in the finding of misconduct.
The finding of proved misconduct has thus attained finality.
34.
In these circumstances, the only question that arises for consideration
is whether the Labour Court was justified in interfering with the punishment
of removal in exercise of its power under Section 11-A of the ID Act, 1947,
and substituting the same with deemed retirement along with consequential
retiral benefits.
35.
Section 11A of the ID Act, 1947 reads as under:
[11.A. Powers of Labour Courts, Tribunal and National Tribunal
to give appropriate relief in case of Discharge or dismissal of
workman.- Where an industrial dispute relating to the discharge
or dismissal of a workman has been referred to a Labour Court,
Tribunal and National Tribunal for adjudication proceeding, the
Labour Court, Tribunal and National Tribunal, as the case
may be, is satisfied that the order of discharge or dismissal was
not justified, it may, by its award, set aside the order of
discharge or dismissal and direct reinstatement of the workman
on such terms and conditions, if any, as it thinks fit, or give
such other relief to the workman including the award of any
lesser punishment in lieu of discharge or dismissal as the
circumstances of the case may require; Provided that in any
proceeding under this section the Labour Court, Tribunal and
National Tribunal, as the case may be, shall rely only on the
materials on record and shall not take any fresh evidence in
relation on the matter]
...[emphasis supplied]
36.
A plain reading of Section 11-A of the ID Act, 1947 shows that
where an industrial dispute relating to discharge or dismissal is referred
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
15:38:57
W.P.(C) 6398/2017
for adjudication, the Labour Court is empowered, if it is satisfied that the
order of discharge or dismissal is “not justified”, to set aside such order
and grant appropriate relief, including reinstatement or award of a lesser
punishment. The provision, however, does not in express terms lay down
the criteria for determining when a punishment is to be regarded as “not
justified”. The parameters governing the exercise of this power have,
therefore, been structured through authoritative judicial interpretation.
37.
It is well settled that the expression “not justified” in Section
11-A of the ID Act, 1947 does not confer unrestricted appellate power
upon the Labour Court. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has consistently held
that even where the domestic enquiry is fair and misconduct stands
proved, interference with punishment is warranted only if it is so
disproportionate to the gravity of the misconduct as to shock the
conscience of the Court, or where legally relevant mitigating
circumstances exist. The Labour Court must record cogent reasons
demonstrating such disproportion. Mere substitution of its own view on
grounds of sympathy or leniency is impermissible.
38.
In light of the above settled principles governing the scope of
interference under Section 11-A of the ID Act, 1947, the legal position is
no longer res integra. In Bharat Forge Co. Ltd. v. Uttam Manohar
Nakate, (2005) 2 SCC 489, and M.P. Electricity Board v. Jagdish
Chandra Sharma, (2005) 3 SCC 401, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
held that the power under Section 11-A (or analogous provisions) cannot
be exercised on irrational, extraneous, or merely compassionate
considerations. Although the Labour Court has jurisdiction to interfere
with the quantum of punishment, such discretion must be exercised
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
15:38:57
W.P.(C) 6398/2017
judiciously and within settled parameters. Interference is permissible only
where the punishment is wholly or shockingly disproportionate to the
gravity of the proved misconduct.The principle was reiterated in J.K.
Synthetics Ltd. v. K.P. Agrawal, (2007) 2 SCC 433, in the following
terms:
27. In this case, we have already found that the charge
established against the employee was a serious one. The Labour
Court did not record a finding that the punishment was harsh
or disproportionately excessive. It interfered with the
punishment only on the ground that the employee had worked
for four years without giving room for any such complaint. It
ignored the seriousness of the misconduct. That was not
warranted. The consistent view of this Court is that in the
absence of a finding that the punishment was shockingly
disproportionate to the gravity of the charge established, the
Labour Court should not interfere with the punishment. We,
therefore, hold that the punishment of dismissal did not call for
interference.”
...[emphasis supplied]
39.
The principle was authoritatively reaffirmed in L&T Komatsu Ltd. v.
N. Udayakumar, (2008) 1 SCC 224, where the Hon’ble Supreme Court
reversed interference with dismissal in a case where the workman had
remained absent on several occasions and had been found guilty of habitual
absenteeism. The Court held that although Section 11-A of the ID Act,
1947 vests discretion in the Labour Court to interfere with punishment,
such discretion is not unbridled and must be exercised strictly within settled
judicial parameters. Interference is permissible only where the punishment
is wholly or shockingly disproportionate to the degree of guilt of the
workman concerned. The Tribunal must record reasons in support of such
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
15:38:57
W.P.(C) 6398/2017
conclusion. While reiterating these limits on the exercise of discretion
under Section 11-A of the ID Act, 1947, the Court placed reliance on LIC
of India v. R. Dhandapani, (2006) 13 SCC 613, observing as under:
9. In LIC of India v. R. Dhandapani [(2006) 13 SCC 613 :
AIR 2006 SC 615] , it was held as follows;
“It is not necessary to go into detail regarding the power
exercisable under Section 11-A of the Act. The power under
said Section 11-A has to be exercised judiciously and the
Industrial Tribunal or the Labour Court, as the case may be, is
expected to interfere with the decision of a management under
Section 11-A of the Act only when it is satisfied that
punishment imposed by the management is wholly and
shockingly disproportionate to the degree of guilt of the
workman concerned. To support its conclusion the Industrial
Tribunal or the Labour Court, as the case may be, has to give
reasons in support of its decision. The power has to be
exercised judiciously and mere use of the words
‘disproportionate’ or ‘grossly disproportionate’ by itself will not
be sufficient. In recent times, there is an increasing evidence of
this, perhaps well-meant but wholly unsustainable, tendency
towards a denudation of the legitimacy of judicial reasoning and
process. The reliefs granted by the courts must be seen to be
logical and tenable within the framework of the law and should
not incur and justify the criticism that the jurisdiction of the
courts tends to degenerate into misplaced sympathy, generosity
and private benevolence. It is essential to maintain the integrity
of legal reasoning and the legitimacy of the conclusions. They
must emanate logically from the legal findings and the judicial
results must be seen to be principled and supportable on those
findings. Expansive judicial mood of mistaken and misplaced
compassion at the expense of the legitimacy of the process will
eventually lead to mutually irreconcilable situations and denude
the judicial process of its dignity, authority, predictability and
respectability. (See Kerala Solvent Extractions Ltd. v. A.
Unnikrishnan [(1994) 1 Scale 631] .) Though under Section 11A, the Tribunal has the power to reduce the quantum of
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
15:38:57
W.P.(C) 6398/2017
punishment it has to be done within the parameters of law.
Possession of power is itself not sufficient; it has to be exercised
in accordance with law. The High Court found that the
Industrial Tribunal had not indicated any reason to justify
variations of the penalty imposed. Though learned counsel for
the respondent tried to justify the award of the Tribunal and
submitted that the Tribunal and the learned Single Judge have
considered the case in its proper perspective, we do not find any
substance in the plea. Industrial Tribunals and Labour Courts
are not forums whose task is to dole out private benevolence to
workmen found by the Labour Court/Tribunal to be guilty of
misconduct. The Tribunal and the High Court, in this case, have
found a pattern of defiance and proved misconduct on not one
but on several occasions. The compassion which was shown by
the Tribunal and unfortunately endorsed by the learned Single
Judge was fully misplaced.”
...[emphasis supplied]
40.
The ratio emerging from the aforesaid decisions is unequivocal. Once
the domestic enquiry is upheld and misconduct stands proved, interference
with the quantum of punishment under Section 11-A of the ID Act, 1947 is
permissible only upon a clear finding that the penalty is shockingly
disproportionate or that legally relevant mitigating circumstances exist.
Sympathy, length of service, or benevolent considerations cannot, by
themselves, justify substitution of penalty.
41.
Reverting to the facts of the present case, the Labour Court upheld
the enquiry as fair and proper and recorded a categorical finding that the
Respondent had remained unauthorizedly absent for a prolonged period and
had a history of similar misconduct. The only ground on which the
punishment of removal was modified was the length of service rendered by
the Respondent. Significantly, no finding was recorded that the penalty was
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
15:38:57
W.P.(C) 6398/2017
shockingly disproportionate, nor was any mitigating circumstance relating
to the misconduct itself identified. The jurisdictional precondition for
exercise of power under Section 11-A was therefore not satisfied.
42.
The past service record of the Respondent discloses repeated
instances of unauthorized absence, evincing a sustained pattern of habitual
indiscipline rather than an isolated lapse. The material particulars of his
prior misconduct are set out hereunder:
(i) The service record of Respondent discloses more than eight
adverse entries pertaining to unauthorized absence, along with at
least four instances of major punishment imposed for similar
misconduct.
(ii) The Respondent remained unauthorizedly absent w.e.f. 30 th
August, 1996, for which he was awarded the penalty of censure.
(iii) He again absented himself unauthorizedly from 1 st July, 1997 to
31st October, 1997, resulting in the punishment of “stoppage of one
due increment with cumulative effect”.
(iv) In the year 1999, he remained absent without information for 39
days, for which two due increments were stopped.
(v) Despite the aforesaid punishments, he continued in similar
conduct and remained unauthorizedly absent from 1 st June, 1998 to
31st May, 1999 for 223 days, attracting the major penalty of
reduction of two stage in the time scale of Conductor for a period of
two years.
43.
In view of the aforesaid misconduct, the present charge was not an
isolated lapse but part of a continuing pattern of repeated unauthorized
absence for which the Respondent had been punished on multiple prior
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
15:38:57
W.P.(C) 6398/2017
occasions. The management progressively imposed stricter penalties,
including censure, stoppage of increments and reduction in time scale,
thereby affording repeated opportunities for reform; yet, despite more than
eight adverse entries and at least four major punishments, no improvement
followed. The recurring misconduct establishes habitual indiscipline. In
these circumstances, the penalty of removal cannot be termed shockingly
disproportionate.
44.
Learned counsel for the Respondent relies upon Delhi Transport
Corporation v. Ranbir Singh (W.P.(C) 6392/2017), decided on 04th
January, 2023. The said decision is clearly distinguishable. In Ranbir
Singh(supra), although the workman had not submitted leave applications
in the prescribed format, the Enquiry Officer noted that he had furnished
leave applications along with medical certificates from private doctors
though not in the prescribed format and had offered an explanation for his
prolonged absence arising out of compelling family circumstances. These
factors were taken into consideration while exercising powers under
Section 11-A of the ID Act, 1947, and the High Court found such limited
interference not to be perverse. In the present case, however, the Labour
Court has specifically recorded that no medical document relating to the
period of absence from 07th April, 2001 to 23rd July, 2001 was produced
before the Enquiry Officer, and that the medical papers subsequently relied
upon pertained to a later period. Despite repeated directions to resume duty
or appear before the Medical Board, the Respondent failed to do so. The
Labour Court itself recorded that the charge of unauthorized absence stood
proved and found no infirmity in the order of removal. Further, the
Respondent’s past service record discloses repeated instances of similar
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
15:38:57
W.P.(C) 6398/2017
misconduct with prior penalties, establishing habitual indiscipline. In the
absence of any comparable mitigating circumstance, the ratio of Ranbir
Singh does not advance the respondent’s case.
45.
Learned counsel for the Respondent has further relied upon Raxa
Security Services Limited v. Sagar Kumar Mandal in (W.P.(C)
8942/2023) and D.K. Yadav v. J.M.A. Industries Ltd., (1993) 3 SCC 259,
to contend that termination of service, having serious civil consequences
for livelihood, must conform to standards of fairness and proportionality.
The principle is unexceptionable; however, the reliance is misplaced. Both
decisions concerned termination without adherence to due process,
particularly in cases of deemed abandonment without a proper enquiry. In
the present case, a Charge-Sheet was issued, a domestic enquiry was
conducted, the respondent participated and admitted the charge, and the
enquiry has been upheld as fair and proper. The finding of misconduct
stands concluded and is not under challenge on grounds of procedural
infirmity. Once procedural fairness stands satisfied, Article 21 cannot be
invoked to dilute the consequences of proved misconduct. The only issue
before this Court is whether the punishment is shockingly disproportionate
within the meaning of Section 11-A of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.
46.
The decisions relied upon do not advance the respondent’s case.
The legal position regarding the scope of interference under Section 11-A
of the ID Act, 1947 in cases of habitual unauthorized absence stands
squarely reinforced by this Court in Delhi Transport Corporation v.
Mahender Singh, W.P.(C) 10360/2016, decided on 7th January, 2025,
where, despite the enquiry being upheld and repeated absence with prior
penalties being proved, the Labour Court had interfered on the ground of
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
15:38:57
W.P.(C) 6398/2017
long service; this Court set aside the Award, holding that in the absence of
a finding of shockingly disproportionate punishment or legally relevant
mitigating
circumstances,
interference
under
Section
11-A
is
impermissible. The relevant observations are extracted hereunder:
23. Given the fact that the absences of the
Respondent/Workman were frequent, continuous and
for long durations and the documents submitted by the
Respondent/Workman were all seeking leave on his
own behalf for various ailments and not on behalf of
his wife, the contentions of the Respondent/Workman
are without any merit. In addition, in these
circumstances, it cannot be said that the absence from
duty was not willful.
24. In view of the judgments of the Supreme Court in
Bharat Forge case and L&T Komatsu case, this Court
is unable to agree with the Impugned Award, which is
accordingly, set aside. The Enquiry Report of the
Petitioner/DTC is affirmed.
...[emphasis supplied]
47.
In view of the foregoing discussion, the Labour Court, having upheld
the enquiry and recorded a clear finding that the misconduct stood proved
along with an adverse past record, could not have interfered with the
punishment imposed, in the absence of a specific finding that the penalty of
removal was shockingly disproportionate to the gravity of the misconduct or
that any legally relevant mitigating circumstances existed warranting such
interference. Modification solely on the ground of length of service amounts
to sympathetic substitution dehors Section 11-A of the ID Act, 1947. The
jurisdictional precondition that the punishment was “not justified” was never
satisfied; the interference is therefore unsustainable.
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
15:38:57
W.P.(C) 6398/2017
48.
Accordingly, this Court finds merit in the present Writ Petition. The
impugned Award, insofar as it modifies the punishment of removal, is set
aside. The Order of removal dated 29th August, 2003 passed by the
petitioner stands affirmed.
49.
In terms of the aforesaid observation, Writ Petition along with
pending application, if any, stands disposed of. No order as to costs.
SHAIL JAIN
JUDGE
FEBRUARY 12, 2026/rm
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
15:38:57
W.P.(C) 6398/2017
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review