Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of Decision: 06th August, 2026
#
CNR No. DLHC011210822013
+
W.P.(C) 5276/2013
DELHI TRANSPORT CORPORATION
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Akshat Tiwari & Mr. Uday
N. Tiwary, Adv. through V.C.
versus
MS. SAHAB KAUR & ANR.
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Yudhvir Dalal, Ms.
Sunaina, Mr. Sahil Kumar &
Mr. Anshul, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
J U D G M E N T (ORAL)
AMIT MAHAJAN, J.
1.
By the present petition, the petitioner challenges the award
dated 10.05.2013 (hereafter ‘impugned award’) passed by the
learned Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi
in ID No. 75/2011 to the limited extent that the learned Labour Court
while exercising power under Section 11A of the Industrial Disputes
Act, 1947 (‘ID Act’) ought not to have reduced the punishment of the
deceased workman from termination to compulsory retirement.
2.
Briefly stated, the deceased workman, who is represented
before this Court by his wife and son, was employed as a conductor
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
19:04:20
W.P.(C) 5276/2013
with the petitioner corporation in the year 1983. It is the case against
the deceased workman that he remained absent from work without
permission for a period of approximately 207 days in the period
between June 1991 - December 1991.
3.
Chargesheet is stated to have been issued to the deceased
workman on 19.09.1991 for remaining absent from duty without prior
intimation from 08.06.1991.
4.
Pursuant to the domestic enquiry, the deceased workman was
issued a termination letter on 20.02.1992.
5.
Thereafter, in the industrial dispute raised by the workman, the
learned Labour Court found that since the workman remained absent
for 207 days without sanction of leave, the termination of the
workman on this count was justified. The learned Labour Court,
however, considering the mitigating circumstances, modified the
punishment awarded to the deceased workman from termination to
compulsory retirement.
6.
Aggrieved by that limited aspect, the petitioner corporation has
filed the present petition.
7.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the learned
Labour Court, erred in modifying the punishment awarded to the
workman from termination to compulsory retirement in exercise of
power under Section 11A of the ID Act.
8.
He submits that the misconduct had been duly proved and
absenting from duty unauthorizedly by no stretch of imagination can
be held to be a minor misconduct. He relies upon the judgment passed
by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of DTC v. Sardar Singh :
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
19:04:20
W.P.(C) 5276/2013
(2004) 7 SCC 574 to contend that remaining unauthorizedly absent
from duty is a serious misconduct for which the punishment of
termination is not unjustified. He submits that since the punishment
was proportionate to the misconduct, the punishment ought not to
have been modified.
9.
He further relied upon the case Mahindra and Mahindra Ltd.
v. N.B. Narawade : (2005) 3 SCC 134 to argue that the Labour Court
cannot by way of sympathy alone exercise power under Section 11A
of the ID Act to reduce the punishment.
10.
Per contra, the learned counsel for the respondents submits that
the deceased workman worked with the petitioner corporation for a
period of almost 8 years and his past record is unblemished. He
submits that even though the petitioner has alleged that in the past also
the deceased workman had remained unauthorizedly absent, no action
had been taken by the petitioner corporation on those occasions.
11.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties.
12.
At the outset, it is relevant to note that the jurisdiction of the
High Court to issue a writ or direction in exercise of power under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India is supervisory in nature and
the Court ought not act as an appellate Court. This Court therefore
cannot substitute its own view for the view taken by the Labour Court
unless the same is shown to be arbitrary or perverse.
13.
As noted above, the short question presented before this Court
for adjudication is thus whether the learned Labour Court while
upholding the misconduct was justified in modifying the punishment
from dismissal to compulsory retirement.
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
19:04:20
W.P.(C) 5276/2013
14.
Before this Court adverts to delve into the factual matrix of the
present case, it is apposite to take note of Section 11A of the I.D. Act
which reads as under:
“1[11A. Powers of Labour Courts, Tribunals and National
Tribunals to give appropriate relief in case of discharge or
dismissal of workmen.-- Where an industrial dispute relating to
the discharge or dismissal of a workman has been referred to a
Labour Court, Tribunal or National Tribunal for adjudication
and, in the course of the adjudication proceedings, the Labour
Court, Tribunal or National Tribunal, as the case may be, is
satisfied that the order of discharge or dismissal was not justified,
it may, by its award, set aside the order of discharge or dismissal
and direct reinstatement of the workman on such terms and
conditions, if any, as it thinks fit, or give such other relief to the
workman including the award of any lesser punishment in lieu of
discharge or dismissal as the circumstances of the case may
require:
Provided that in any proceeding under this section the Labour
Court, Tribunal or National Tribunal, as the case may be, shall
rely only on the materials on record and shall not take any fresh
evidence in relation to the matter.].”
15.
From a reading of Section 11A of the ID Act, it is clear that the
learned Labour Court is vested with a discretion to modify the
punishment if the Labour Court is satisfied that the order of discharge
or dismissal was not justified. The same, though not an unbridled
power, authorises the Labour Court to modify the punishment when
the same is disproportionate to the gravity of the misconduct, or there
exists certain mitigating circumstances which persuades the Labour
Court to reduce the punishment.
16.
Adverting now to the facts of the present case, it remains
undisputed that the deceased workman worked with the petitioner
department for more than 08 years before finally being chargesheeted
for remaining unauthorisedly absent. Nothing has come on record to
show that earlier, during the course of the employment, the deceased
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
19:04:20
W.P.(C) 5276/2013
workman was charge sheeted for any other misconduct.
17.
It is the case of the deceased workman that he remained absent
because he was medically unfit. It is also the case of the workman that
subsequently, he reported to work on 21.02.1992 with medical fitness
certificate but the management refused to take him back.
18.
The learned Labour Court however did not agree with the
defence of the deceased workman and noted that the workman had
failed to show that he remained absent for valid reasons. It was further
noted that remaining absent for 207 days without sanction warranted
punishment. The deceased workman has not challenged the impugned
award.
19.
At the same time, in the opinion of this Court, the learned
Labour Court has not exceeded its jurisdiction in modifying the order
of dismissal to that of compulsory retirement in the facts of the present
case.
20.
The learned counsel for the petitioner corporation has placed
reliance on the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of
DTC v. Sardar Singh (supra) to contend that remaining
unauthorizedly absent from duty is a serious misconduct for which the
punishment of termination is not unjustified. Reliance has also been
placed on the case of Mahindra and Mahindra Ltd. v. N.B.
Narawade (supra) to contend that the Labour Court cannot be swayed
by sympathetic considerations while modifying the punishment
especially when misconduct is proved.
21.
Insofar as reliance on the case of DTC v. Sardar Singh (supra)
is concerned, there can be no quarrel with the proposition that habitual
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
19:04:20
W.P.(C) 5276/2013
and prolonged unauthorised absence from work amounts to
misconduct. The said case however does not delve into the aspect of
proportionality of punishment and also does not lay down a
generalized form of punishment for unauthorised leave for prolonged
periods and is consequently not applicable to the facts of the present
case. In the said case, the workers had unauthorisedly absented
themselves from work and the Labour Court had found that availing
leave without pay did not amount to misconduct. The Labour Court
further noted since the employer had treated absence from duty as
leave without pay, the same amounted to sanction of leave and there
was no misconduct. The Labour Court also refused the approval
sought in terms of Section 33(2)(b) of the ID Act. The employer had
thereafter approached a Coordinate Bench of this Court which found
that the disapproval by the Labour Court was not in order.
Subsequently, a Division Bench of this Court restored the findings of
the Labour Court. On that limited question on misconduct, the
Hon’ble Apex Court found that treating leave without pay did not
amount to sanctioned or approved leave and prolonged absence
without sanctioned leave amounted to misconduct. The Court however
did not go into the question of proportionality of punishment and only
upheld termination as a form of punishment in the facts of that case.
22.
As noted above, the charge of misconduct was found to be
proved against the deceased workman on preponderance of probability
and the said finding has not been challenged by the deceased
workman.
23.
The only question before this Court is whether the learned
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
19:04:20
W.P.(C) 5276/2013
Tribunal rightly exercised its jurisdiction in modifying the punishment
in the present case.
24.
Much emphasis has been laid by the learned counsel for the
petitioner corporation on the case of Mahindra and Mahindra Ltd. v.
N.B. Narawade (supra) to argue that in a similar fashion where
misconduct was proved, the modification in punishment on
sympathetic grounds was found to be incorrect. It has consequently
been urged that the impugned award is liable to be set aside as the
modification in punishment was based on sympathetic grounds and is
disproportionate to the gravity of the misconduct. The ratio in the said
case, in the opinion of this Court, is however not applicable to the
facts of the present case.
25.
Undoubtedly, Labour Courts should refrain from interfering
with the punishments on the basis of bald compassionate
considerations, however, the same does not preclude interference if
the punishment is found to be disproportionate or there exists certain
mitigating circumstances including the past conduct of workman that
persuades the Court to reduce the punishment. In the case of
Mahindra and Mahindra Ltd. v. N.B. Narawade (supra), the
allegation against the workman was that he used abusive language
against a superior officer. The learned Labour Court in that case
however reduced the punishment from termination to reinstatement
with continuity of service with 2/3rd back wages solely for
compassionate reasons without taking into account the gravity of the
misconduct. The same was upheld by the Single and Division Bench
of Bombay High Court noting that the said punishment was
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
19:04:20
W.P.(C) 5276/2013
reformative and would act as a deterrent and that dismissal would be
too harsh considering the length of service put by the employee. While
setting aside the same, the Hon’ble Apex Court noted that the Labour
Court ought not be swayed by compassionate grounds and that Labour
Court did not take into account the fact that the workman therein had
been chargesheeted on previous occasions as well for similar conduct.
26.
In the present case however, as is apparent from a reading of the
impugned award, the learned Tribunal did not modify the punishment
on compassionate grounds and found the punishment to be
disproportionate to the gravity of the misconduct. It was noted that
while the misconduct was proved, during the course of the
proceedings before the learned Labour Court, the workman had
produced a medical certificate to justify his absence. As appreciated
by the learned Labour Court, the said certificate was not contested by
the management to be fake. Holistically, the learned Labour Court
also considered ancillary factors like the deceased workman had
worked with the corporation for past 8 years before finally being
chargesheeted for remaining unauthorisedly absent and had also
expired during the course of the proceedings on account of illness.
The learned Labour Court also noted that the corporation had failed to
produce the attendance record of the deceased workman.
27.
In the present case, though the allegations ought not to be
undermined, this Court finds that the same are not of such nature and
severity which would justify direct termination of services. The
learned Labour Court can thus not faulted for modifying the
punishment as the same appears to be ex facie harsh.
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
19:04:20
W.P.(C) 5276/2013
28.
It cannot also be ignored that more than a decade has passed
since the passing of the impugned award. A reasonable and plausible
view which has been taken by the learned Labour Court, as in the
present case, ought not to be interfered with while exercising
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
29.
The present writ petition thus, being devoid of merit, is
accordingly dismissed.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J
AUGUST 6, 2026
“SK”
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
19:04:20
W.P.(C) 5276/2013
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review