Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURTOF DELHIAT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment Reserved on:30.07.2026
Judgment Pronounced on:16.09.2026
Judgment Uploaded on: 16.09.2026
#
CNR No. DLHC010506002017
+
W.P.(C) 1239/2017 & CM APPL. 5664/2017
DELHI TRANSPORT CORPORATION
.....Petitioner
versus
BALWAN SINGH
......Respondent
Advocates who appeared in this case:
For the Petitioner
:Ms. Manisha Tyagi, Advocate.
For the Respondents
:Mr. K. C. Dubey, Ms. Uma Tarafdar and
Mr. Lenyim Taggu, Advocates.
CORAM
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
JUDGMENT
1.
By the present petition, the petitioner challenges the award
dated 03.08.2016 passed by the learned Presiding Officer,
Karkardooma Courts, Delhi in ID No. 05/2008 whereby the learned
Tribunal though found that the enquiry proceedings were not violative
of the principles of natural justice had modified the punishment from
removal from service to deemed retirement from 26.09.1994.
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
17:38:49
W.P.(C) 1239/2017
2.
Briefly stated, the respondent had joined the services of the
petitioner corporation in the year 1978 as a conductor. It is the case of
the petitioner corporation that on 14.02.1993, when the bus was
checked by the checking staff at around 12:50 am at the bus stop of
Sangaria, three passengers were found to be alighting the bus without
tickets and on enquiry, it was found that they had paid a total fare of
₹24 to the respondent but he had not issued tickets to them. Further, it
is the case against the respondent workman that when the bus was
checked by the checking staff, four other passengers were also found
without tickets who on enquiry stated that they had paid a sum of ₹44
to the respondent workman but he had not issued tickets to them.
3.
Thereafter, chargesheet was issued to the respondent workman
on 26.02.1993. In the aftermath of the enquiry proceedings, the
respondent was found guilty of misconduct and was removed from
service on 26.09.1994. The approval application preferred by the
petitioner management was allowed on 18.07.1995.
4.
The respondent workman had filed a writ petition in the year
1996 challenging his termination, and the same was dismissed as
withdrawn vide order dated 10.08.2007 with liberty to approach the
labour tribunal within a reasonable time.
5.
Thereafter, in the industrial dispute proceedings, the learned
Labour Court vide order dated 04.06.2016 found that the enquiry
proceeding was not in contravention of the principles of natural justice
and it was found that the enquiry report was not perverse. In doing so,
the learned Labour Court noted that the management had examined
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
17:38:49
W.P.(C) 1239/2017
two of the raiding team members who were witnesses of the
misconduct. The learned Labour Court took into account the objection
taken by the respondent workman that the passengers were not
examined and noted that the management had sent letters to the
passengers to appear but they did not appear. The learned Labour
Court also relied upon the decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the
case of State of Haryana v. Rattan Singh : (1977) 2 SCC 491 and
noted that non examination of the passengers by the enquiry officer
does not suffice to cast a dent on the case of the prosecution.
6.
The learned Labour Court further noted that from the enquiry
report, it transpired that the transport inspector had made a statement
before the Enquiry Officer that when he along with other raiding team
members had checked the bus, they had found three passengers
alighting the bus without tickets and upon asking it was found that the
respondent workman had not issued tickets to them. It was noted that
the challan and statements of two passengers bore the signatures of
the respondent. It was further noted that the respondent did not place
any material in his favour to justify his claim that the enquiry officer’s
report was perverse. Consequently, it was found that the enquiry
proceedings were in consonance with the principles of natural justice.
7.
On the aspect of quantum of sentence, the learned Labour Court
noted that respondent had worked with the petitioner corporation for
more than 16 years and as per his service record, no other adverse
entry was ever marked against the respondent. Taking the same into
account, the learned Labour Court noted that while the decision of the
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
17:38:49
W.P.(C) 1239/2017
management to remove the respondent from job was not illegal, the
same was also not justifiable. Consequently, the learned Labour Court
modified the sentence of the petitioner from removal to retirement
from 26.09.1994. The learned Labour Court further directed that all
retiral and consequential benefits like pension (if opted) be given to
the respondent. Aggrieved by the same, the petitioner corporation has
filed the present same.
8.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the
impugned award is perverse and is liable to be set aside. She
submitted that the learned Labour Court categorically found that the
enquiry proceeding was not violative of the principles of natural
justice.
9.
She submitted that despite the same, the learned Labour Court
erroneously modified the punishment from removal to deemed
retirement. She submitted that the learned Labour Court ought not to
interfere with punishment imposed on the workman unless the same is
shockingly disproportionate. She submitted that in the present case,
the learned Labour Court modified the punishment simply on
sympathetic grounds and the same is not permissible.
10.
She relied upon the decisions passed by the Hon’ble Apex
Court in the cases of Depot Manager, A.P. SRTC v. B. Swamy :
(2007) 12 SCC 40 and U.P. SRTC v. Suresh Chand Sharma: (2010)
6 SCC 555 and argued that the learned Labour Court cannot be
weighed by sympathetic reasons while determining the proportionality
of punishment.
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
17:38:49
W.P.(C) 1239/2017
11.
Per contra, the learned counsel for the respondent workman
submitted that the impugned award is well reasoned and warrants no
interference by this Court. He relied upon the decision passed by a
Division Bench of this Court in the case of DTC v. Shyam Singh :
LPA No. 211/2012 and submitted that in terms of Section 11A of the
ID Act, the Labour Court is well within its jurisdiction to determine if
the punishment is justified and modify the same if the same is not
proportionate.
12.
He submitted that the learned Labour Court rightly exercised
jurisdiction and modified the punishment of the respondent in the facts
of the present case.
13.
By order dated 21.02.2017, this Court had stayed the execution
of the impugned award till the next date of hearing subject to deposit
of a sum of ₹5,00,000/- with the Registrar General of this Court. The
said sum had been deposited by the petitioner. The interim stay was
neither extended nor vacated.
Analysis
14.
At the outset, it is relevant to note that the jurisdiction of the
High Court to issue a writ or direction in exercise of power under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India is supervisory in nature and
the Court ought not to act as an appellate Court. This Court ought not
to rove into the exercise of reappreciation of evidence or substitute its
own view for the view taken by the Labour Court unless the same is
shown to be arbitrary or perverse.
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
17:38:49
W.P.(C) 1239/2017
15.
Equally well settled is the fact that in enquiry proceedings, strict
or sophisticated rules of evidence are not applicable and the charges
are required to be proved on the touchstone of preponderance of
probabilities, and not beyond reasonable doubt. What is required to be
seen is that there must be some material on record for the Labour
Court to have reasonably arrived at the conclusion. Consequently, so
long as the view taken by the Labour Court is a plausible one, this
Court, in exercise of power under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, ought not re-appraise evidence to disturb the findings only
because another view is possible.
16.
The present petition has been preferred by the DTC challenging
the modification of punishment awarded by the learned Labour Court.
As per the counter affidavit of the respondent workman, he did not
challenge the finding of misconduct on account of paucity of funds.
While this Court is only tasked to assess the quantum of punishment to
be awarded to the respondent, considering that the same is inextricably
linked with the finding of misconduct and further considering that the
respondent workman was unable to challenge the same given the
impugned award was partially in his favour, this Court deems it
apposite to briefly examine the merits of the dispute before
determining the adequacy of the punishment awarded to the
respondent.
17.
Adverting thus to the merits of the present case, the record
reveals that on 14.02.1993, when the checking staff inspected the bus,
a total of seven passengers were found to be travelling ticketless who
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
17:38:49
W.P.(C) 1239/2017
stated that they had, in aggregate, paid a sum of ₹66/- to the
respondent but he did not issue tickets to them. The record reveals that
challan was issued to the respondent under his signatures and the
statement of the passenger recorded at the time of checking also
contained the signatures of the respondent. The respondent was also
supplied a copy of the chargesheet and he also furnished his reply to
the same. The respondent’s evidence before the learned Tribunal also
reveals that he was supplied all the documents during the course of the
enquiry. A perusal of the record reveals that the respondent
participated in the proceedings and sufficient opportunity was given to
him to defend his case. The respondent’s evidence before the learned
Labour Court further reveals that he actively cross examined the
raiding team members, however, nothing came on record to absolve
the respondent from the charge of misconduct on a preponderance of
probabilities. While no passenger was examined during the course of
the enquiry proceedings and the case of the management was
essentially helmed on the evidence of the checking staff, the same
does not suffice to hold that the enquiry proceedings was based on no
evidence.
18.
In that regard, the Hon’ble Apex Court, while dealing with the
question pertaining to the sufficiency of evidence in departmental
enquiry, and the question of non-examination of passengers, in the
case of State of Haryana v. Rattan Singh : (1977) 2 SCC
491 observed as under:
“4. It is well settled that in a domestic enquiry the strict and
sophisticated rules of evidence under the Indian Evidence Act may
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
17:38:49
W.P.(C) 1239/2017
not apply. All materials which are logically probative for a
prudent mind are permissible. There is no allergy to hearsay
evidence provided it has reasonable nexus and credibility. It is
true that departmental authorities and Administrative Tribunals
must be careful in evaluating such material and should not glibly
swallow what is strictly speaking not relevant under the Indian
Evidence Act. For this proposition it is not necessary to cite
decisions nor text books, although we have been taken through
case-law and other authorities by counsel on both sides. The
essence of a judicial approach is objectivity, exclusion of
extraneous materials or considerations and observance of rules of
natural justice. Of course, fairplay is the basis and if perversity or
arbitrariness, bias or surrender of independence of judgment
vitiate the conclusions reached, such finding, even though of a
domestic tribunal, cannot be held good. However, the courts below
misdirected themselves, perhaps, in insisting that passengers who
had come in and gone out should be chased and brought before the
tribunal before a valid finding could be recorded. The ‘residuum’
rule to which counsel for the respondent referred, based upon
certain passages from American Jurisprudence does not go to that
extent nor does the passage from Halsbury insist on such rigid
requirement. The simple point is, was there some evidence or was
there no evidence — not in the sense of the technical rules
governing regular court proceedings but in a fair commonsense
way as men of understanding and worldly wisdom will accept.
Viewed in this way, sufficiency of evidence in proof of the finding
by a domestic tribunal is beyond scrutiny. Absence of any
evidence in support of a finding is certainly available for the
court to look into because it amounts to an error of law apparent
on the record. We find, in this case, that the evidence of
Chamanlal, Inspector of the Flying Squad, is some evidence which
has relevance to the charge levelled against the respondent.
Therefore, we are unable to hold that the order is invalid on that
ground.
5. Reliance was placed, as earlier stated, on the non-compliance
with the departmental instruction that statements of passengers
should be recorded by inspectors. These are instructions of
prudence, not rules that bind or vitiate in the violation. In this
case, the Inspector tried to get the statements but the passengers
declined, the psychology of the latter in such circumstances being
understandable, although may not be approved. We cannot hold
that merely because statements of passengers were not recorded
the order that followed was invalid. Likewise, the re-evaluation of
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
17:38:49
W.P.(C) 1239/2017
the evidence on the strength of co-conductor's testimony is a matter
not for the court but for the Administrative Tribunal. In conclusion,
we do not think the courts below were right in overturning the
finding of the domestic tribunal.”
(emphasis supplied)
19.
Consequently, merely because the case of the management was
helmed on the evidence of the checking staff will not make the
enquiry proceedings defective. The only aspect that is required to be
considered is whether there was some evidence or no evidence. In the
present case, as is apparent from the record and as appreciated by the
learned Labour Court, the Traffic Inspector had categorically deposed
that when he along with other raiding team members had checked the
bus of the respondent, seven passengers were found without ticket
who stated that they had paid the fare to the respondent and were still
not issued tickets. The same was duly corroborated by the statement of
the passenger recorded at the time of checking. The respondent was
supplied all the documents and was given full opportunity to defend
his case. On the touchstone of preponderance of probabilities thus, the
misconduct was rightly appreciated to have been proved.
20.
This Court now proceeds to examine whether the learned
Labour Court while finding that the enquiry was in consonance with
the principles of natural justice was justified in modifying the
punishment from dismissal to retirement.
21.
Before this Court adverts to delve into the merits of the
modification of the punishment, it is apposite to take note of Section
11A of the ID Act which reads as under:
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
17:38:49
W.P.(C) 1239/2017
“11A. Powers of Labour Courts, Tribunals and National Tribunals
to give appropriate relief in case of discharge or dismissal of
workmen.-- Where an industrial dispute relating to the discharge
or dismissal of a workman has been referred to a Labour Court,
Tribunal or National Tribunal for adjudication and, in the course
of the adjudication proceedings, the Labour Court, Tribunal or
National Tribunal, as the case may be, is satisfied that the order of
discharge or dismissal was not justified, it may, by its award, set
aside the order of discharge or dismissal and direct reinstatement
of the workman on such terms and conditions, if any, as it thinks fit,
or give such other relief to the workman including the award of any
lesser punishment in lieu of discharge or dismissal as the
circumstances of the case may require:
Provided that in any proceeding under this section the Labour
Court, Tribunal or National Tribunal, as the case may be, shall
rely only on the materials on record and shall not take any fresh
evidence in relation to the matter..”
22.
A bare reading of Section 11A of the ID Act makes it manifest
that where an industrial dispute relating to discharge/dismissal of
workman is before a Labour Court, then such Court upon being
satisfied that the order of discharge/dismissal is not justified, set aside
the order and modify the relief to award a lesser punishment. While
the provision does not highlight the circumstances where a
punishment may be regarded as not justified and the discretion is
vested with the Labour Court, such discretion is not unbridled and
ought to be exercised only when the punishment imposed by the
management is disproportionate to the degree of guilt of the concerned
workman [Ref. LIC of India v. R. Dhandapani : (2006) 13 SCC 613].
23.
On the aspect of quantum of sentence, the punishment of
removal from service was modified to retirement with effect from
26.09.1994 noting that the workman had worked with the corporation
for more than 16 years and as per his service record, no other adverse
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
17:38:49
W.P.(C) 1239/2017
entry other than the present one was marked to the workman’s
account.
24.
Even the factual matrix being thus, and there being no adverse
entry in the record of the workman given the duration of the
workman’s service, this Court is unpersuaded by the rationale adopted
by the learned Tribunal in modifying the sentence.
25.
As relied upon by the petitioner corporation, in the case of
Depot Manager, A.P. SRTC v. B. Swamy : (supra), the workman
conductor was alleged to have issued tickets of lower denomination to
16 illiterate passengers and pocketed the extra amount collected from
each of the passengers. After the conduction of the enquiry
proceedings, the workman therein was removed from service. The
Labour Court taking into account the misconduct of the workman
found that the punishment of removal from service was justified. The
challenge under Article 226 of the Constitution of India before the
High Court of Andhra Pradesh was also dismissed. Thereafter, in the
challenge before the Division Bench, it was noted that workman
therein was a senior employee and the incident appeared to be
accidental in his entire service record. It was noted that the
management had not brought any other material on record to show
that the workman therein had ever been involved in any such
irregularity before. Consequently, the Division Bench found the
termination of the workman therein to be unjustified and the same was
set aside.
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
17:38:49
W.P.(C) 1239/2017
Thereafter, in the challenge before the Hon’ble Apex Court, the
order of the Division Bench of the High Court was set aside and the
order of removal from service was restored. While doing so, the
Hon’ble Apex Court noted that merely because this was the first
occasion where the workman therein was caught was no ground to
hold that the alleged act was accidental.
26.
Similarly, in the case of U.P. SRTC v. Suresh Chand Sharma
(supra), the Hon’ble Apex Court was faced with identical facts where
the allegation against the workman therein was that he had failed to
issue tickets after collecting the fare from the passengers on two
instances. In that case even though the learned Labour Court had
affirmed the punishment of removal on finding that the enquiry
proceedings were in consonance with the principles of natural justice,
the Hon’ble High Court at Nainital had allowed the petition preferred
by the workman on the ground that the passengers found without
ticket were not examined and the cash was not checked. Thereafter, in
the challenge preferred by the corporation before the Hon’ble Apex
Court, while relying upon its earlier decision in the case of State of
Haryana vs. Rattan Singh (supra), the Hon’ble Apex Court noted that
the non-examination of passengers did not vitiate the enquiry report.
Further, the Hon’ble Apex Court went on to observe that even if the
case involved misappropriation of a petty amount, the punishment of
dismissal from service was appropriate. The Hon’ble Apex Court
observed as follows:
“21. We do not find any force in the submissions made by Dr.
J.N. Dubey, learned Senior Counsel for the employee that for
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
17:38:49
W.P.(C) 1239/2017
embezzlement of such a petty amount, punishment of dismissal
could not be justified for the reason that it is not the amount
embezzled by a delinquent employee but the mens rea to
misappropriate the public money.
22. In Municipal Committee, Bahadurgarh v. Krishnan Behari
[(1996) 2 SCC 714 : 1996 SCC (L&S) 539 : AIR 1996 SC 1249]
this Court held as under : (SCC p. 715, para 4)
“4. … In a case of such nature—indeed, in cases involving
corruption—there cannot be any other punishment than
dismissal. Any sympathy shown in such cases is totally
uncalled for and opposed to public interest. The amount
misappropriated may be small or large; it is the act of
misappropriation that is relevant.”
Similar view has been reiterated by this Court in Ruston &
Hornsby (I) Ltd. v. T.B. Kadam [(1976) 3 SCC 71 : 1976 SCC
(L&S) 381 : AIR 1975 SC 2025] , U.P. SRTC v. Basudeo
Chaudhary [(1997) 11 SCC 370 : 1998 SCC (L&S) 155] , Janatha
Bazar (South Kanara Central Coop. Wholesale Stores Ltd.) v.
Sahakari Noukarara Sangha [(2000) 7 SCC 517 : 2000 SCC (L&S)
962] , Karnataka SRTC v. B.S. Hullikatti [(2001) 2 SCC 574 : 2001
SCC (L&S) 469 : AIR 2001 SC 930] and Rajasthan SRTC v.
Ghanshyam Sharma [(2002) 10 SCC 330 : 2003 SCC (L&S) 714] .
23. In NEKRTC v. H. Amaresh [(2006) 6 SCC 187 : 2006 SCC
(L&S) 1290 : AIR 2006 SC 2730] and U.P. SRTC v. Vinod Kumar
[(2008) 1 SCC 115 : (2008) 1 SCC (L&S) 1] this Court held that
the punishment should always be proportionate to the gravity of
the
misconduct.
However,
in
a
case
of
corruption/misappropriation, the only punishment is dismissal.”
(emphasis supplied)
27.
It is against this backdrop that the modification in punishment
awarded by the learned Tribunal ought to be examined.
28.
This Court is neither unmindful of the width of the jurisdiction
conferred on the learned Tribunal by virtue of Section 11A of the
Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 nor the principle that in exercise of
power under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, this Court ought
to be slow to substitute its own view for the view taken by the learned
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
17:38:49
W.P.(C) 1239/2017
Tribunal. In the facts of the present case where the misconduct was
upheld, the learned Tribunal should not have roved into any
sympathetic considerations while determining the quantum of
punishment. However, in the present case, the only alteration made by
the learned Labour Court was to modify the punishment from removal
to deemed retirement from 26.09.1994 thereby granting only retiral or
pensionary benefits to the respondent. On this account, this Court does
not deem it apposite to interfere with the impugned award to remove
the pensionary benefits granted to the respondent at this juncture after
almost a decade.
29.
However, considering the peculiar facts of the present case, this
Court deems it expedient to limit the total pensionary relief to be
granted to the respondent at ₹5,00,000/-.
30.
The sum of ₹5,00,000/- thus deposited with the Registrar
General of this Court pursuant to order dated 21.02.2017, is directed to
be released in favour of the respondent within a period of 4 weeks.
31.
The impugned award is partially modified in the aforesaid
terms. Pending application also stands disposed of.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J
SEPTEMBER 16, 2026
DU
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
17:38:49
W.P.(C) 1239/2017
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review