Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
#
CNR No. DLHC010484402026
+
W.P.(C) 14866/2026
DELHI DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY THROUGH ITS
VICE CHAIRMAN
.....Petitioner
Through: Ms. Prabhsahay Kaur, Standing
Counsel with Mr. Soumit Ganguli, Mr.
Aditya Verma, Mr. Kamlendu Pandey, Mr.
Siddhanth Makhloga, Advs.
versus
CHHANVEER
.....Respondent
Through:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C. HARI SHANKAR
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NIVEDITA ANIL SHARMA
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
07.10.2026
%
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
1.
This writ petition assails judgment dated 29 May 2026 passed
by the Central Administrative Tribunal1 in OA 4095/2025.
2.
The lis before the Tribunal related to the gradings in the Annual
Performance Appraisal Reports2 of the respondent for the periods 1
April 2021 to 30 December 2021 and 1 April 2024 to 30 June 2024.
1 “the Tribunal” hereinafter
“APARs’ hereinafter
W.P.(C) 14866/2026
KUMAR
17:14:27
3.
For the period 1 April 2021 to 30 December 2021, the
respondent was graded “very good” by the reporting officer, “good”
by
the
reviewing
officer
and
“average”
by
the
Accepting/Countersigning Authority. The benchmark for promotion
to the next grade of Superintending Engineer was “very good”. As
such, the overall gradings of “good” and “average” were below the
prescribed benchmark for promotion and were, therefore, adverse in
impact and consequence.
4.
The respondent, therefore, represented against the aforesaid
APAR on 28 November 2022. Accepting his representation, the
reviewing officer upgraded the overall gradings of the respondent
from “good” to “very good”. The countersigning/accepting authority,
however, continued to retain the grading of “average”.
In other
words, the position that emerged, after the decision on the
respondent’s representation, was that the reporting and reviewing
officers
had
both
graded
him
“very
good”,
but
the
countersigning/accepting authority continued to grade him “average”.
5.
For the next period 31 December 2021 to 31 March 2022,
which is not a period forming subject matter of dispute in the present
case, it is worthwhile to note that the respondent was graded
“outstanding” by the reporting, reviewing as well as accepting
authorities.
6.
The second period in controversy is the period 1 April 2024 to
30 June 2024. During this period, the reporting officer graded the
respondent “outstanding”, the reviewing officer graded him “very
W.P.(C) 14866/2026
KUMAR
17:14:27
good” and the accepting authority/countersigning authority graded
him “good” on the ground that his past performance in the South Zone
was not up to the mark.
7.
Aggrieved
thereby,
the
respondent
submitted
various
representations, which were rejected by communications dated 9
September 2025 and 12 September 2025, without assigning any
reasons.
8.
In these circumstances, the respondent approached the Central
Administrative Tribunal by way of OA 4095/2025, which stands
allowed by the Tribunal by the impugned judgment dated 29 May
2026.
9.
The Tribunal has, in arriving at its decision, relied on the
judgments of the Supreme Court in State of Haryana v. Ashok
Khemka3, SBI v. Kashinath Kher4, State of Uttar Pradesh v.
Yamuna Shankar Mishra5 and Sukhdev v. Commissioner6.
10.
Following these decisions, the Tribunal has observed that it is
permissible for an appointing authority to differ with a reviewing
authority regarding the gradings to be given to an officer, but that such
a difference has to be for valid reasons, set out in writing.
2024 SCC OnLine SC 258
4 (1996) 8 SCC 762
5 (1997) 4
SCC 7
6 (1996) 5 SCC 103
W.P.(C) 14866/2026
KUMAR
17:14:27
11.
The Tribunal has noted that no reasons were provided by the
accepting authority for the period 1 April 2021 to 30 December 2021
in continuing to retain the grading of “average” even after the
reviewing officer had accepted the respondent’s representation and
upgraded his grading from “good” to “very good”.
12.
In so far as the second period in dispute, i.e., 1 April 2024 to 30
June 2024 is concerned, the Tribunal has observed that the
accepting/countersigning authority had placed reliance on what he
perceived to be the unsatisfactory conduct of the respondent for a past
period, reflecting clear non application of mind.
13.
The Tribunal has further observed that, if the countersigning or
accepting authority chooses to disagree with the reviewing or
reporting officer, the disagreement has to be informed by reasons.
Equally, any adverse decision on the representation by the officer has
to be reasoned. A cryptic rejection is not in compliance with the law.
14.
The Tribunal has also noted that no contemporaneous material
was placed before it by the DDA to indicate that there was any
inadequacy in the performance of the respondent, as would justify the
grading given to the respondent by the accepting/countersigning
authority.
15.
For the period 31 December 2021 to 31 March 2022, the
Tribunal has further observed that, once the reviewing authority, who
had initially graded the respondent as good, himself deemed it
W.P.(C) 14866/2026
KUMAR
17:14:27
appropriate to upgrade the grading to “very good” on the respondent’s
representation,
there
was
no
justification
for
the
accepting/countersigning authority to persist with the grading of
“average”, without any reasons provided in that regard.
16.
Aggrieved by the decision of the Tribunal, the DDA has
approached this Court by means of the present writ petition.
17.
We have heard Ms. Prabhsahay Kaur, learned Standing Counsel
for the DDA.
18.
Ms. Kaur has submitted that the performance of the respondent
was such that justified the gradings given to the respondent by the
countersigning authority. She also points out that the principles of
natural justice were duly complied with, as the respondent was even
granted a personal hearing on the representations made by him.
She
further submits that, in such cases, Courts and Tribunal are expected
to adopt a stance of circumspection not to interfere with the gradings
given by the officers who would be best equipped to decide on the
performance of the officer concerned.
19.
As the Tribunal has correctly observed, there is no gainsaying
the position that there is a degree of inherent restraint on judicial
interference in the matter of gradings given in ACRs or APARs. At
the same time, such gradings can perilously affect the career of an
officer, and the Supreme Court has, time and again, emphasised the
importance which is to be accorded while granting such gradings and
the responsibility of the officer entailed with the task of doing so.
W.P.(C) 14866/2026
KUMAR
17:14:27
20.
The following passages from Yamuna Shankar Mishra
expound the legal position clearly:
“4.
In S. Ramachandra Raju v. State of Orissa7, this Court
underlined the need to write confidential reports objectively, fairly
and dispassionately in a constructive manner either
commenting/downgrading the conduct, character, efficiency or
integrity of the officer in that behalf. It is stated in para 11 that from
the year 1973-74, the performance of the duty by the appellant
therein was consistently as “satisfactory” to “fair” except for the
year 1987-88 in which year he dropped down suddenly as an
average or below average teacher. In that behalf it was held that
“when he was a responsible teacher and he had cordial relations
with the student community, and was taking pains to impart lessons
to the students, would it be believable that he avoids to take classes
and drops down “if not watched”? When anterior to or subsequent
to 1987-88 he was a man of ability and integrity, the same whether
would become “below average” only for the Academic Year 198788 without discernible reasons, it would speak volumes about the
objectivity of assessment by the reporting officer i.e. the Principal.
This conduct is much to be desired. This case would establish as a
stark reality that writing confidential reports bears onerous
responsibility on the reporting officer to eschew his subjectivity
and personal prejudices or proclivity or predilections and to make
objective assessment. It is needless to emphasise that the career
prospects of a subordinate officer/employee largely depends upon
the work and character assessment by the reporting officer. The
latter should adopt fair, objective, dispassionate and constructive
commends/comments in estimating or assessing the character,
ability, integrity and responsibility displayed by the
officer/employee concerned during the relevant period for the
above objectives if not strictly adhered to in making an honest
assessment, the prospect and career of the subordinate officer
would be put to great jeopardy. The reporting officer is bound to
lose his credibility in the eyes of his subordinates and fail to
command respect and work from them. The constitutional and
statutory safeguards given to the government employees largely
became responsible to display callousness and disregard of the
discharge of their duties and make it impossible for the superior or
controlling officers to extract legitimate work from them. The
writing of the confidentials is contributing to make the
subordinates work at least to some extent. Therefore, writing the
confidential reports objectively and constructively and
communication thereof at the earliest would pave way for amends
(1994) 28 ATC 443
W.P.(C) 14866/2026
KUMAR
17:14:27
by erring subordinate officers or to improve the efficiency in
service. At the same time, the subordinate employee/officer should
dedicate to do hard work and duty; assiduity in the discharge of the
duty, honesty with integrity in performance thereof which alone
would earn his usefulness in retention of his service. Both would
contribute to improve excellence in service. In that case, on account
of the vague remarks made for the year 1987-88, the appellant
therein was compulsorily retired from service. This Court, after
looking into the entire record, set aside the order. … In Delhi
Transport Corpn. v. D.T.C. Mazdoor Congress8, to which one of
us, K. Ramaswamy, J., was a member, the Constitution Bench had
held that the Sword of Damocles hanging over the head of a public
servant would inevitably create a sense of insecurity. The unbridled
wide discretionary powers would conceivably be abused. Thereby
this Court laid emphasis that:
“… An assurance of security of service to a public
employee is an essential requisite for efficiency and
incorruptibility of public administration. It is also an
assurance to take independent drive and initiative in the
discharge of the public duties to actuate the goals of social
justice set down in the Constitution.”
In para 275 at pp. 740-41, it is further pointed out that:
“… Courts should take note of actualities of life that
persons actuated to corrupt practices are capable to
manoeuvre with higher echelons in diverse ways and also
camouflage their activities by becoming sycophants or
cronies to the superior officers. Sincere, honest and devoted
subordinate officers are unlikely to lick the boots of the
corrupt superior officer. They develop a sense of self-pride
for their honesty, integrity and apathy and inertia towards
the corrupt and tend to undermine or show signs of
disrespect or disregard towards them. Thereby, they not
only become inconvenient to the corrupt officer but also
stand as an impediment to the ongoing smooth symphony
of corruption at a grave risk to their prospects in career or
even to their tenure of office. The term ‘efficiency’ is an
elusive and relative one to the adept capable to be applied
in diverse circumstances. If a superior officer develops
liking towards sycophant, though corrupt, he would tolerate
him and find him to be efficient and pay encomiums and
corruption in such cases stand no impediment. When he
finds a sincere, devoted and honest officer to be
inconvenient, it is easy to cast him/her off by writing
confidential reports with delightfully vague language
imputing to be ‘not up to the mark’, ‘wanting public
relations’ etc. At times they may be termed to be ‘security
8 1991 Supp (1) SCC 600
W.P.(C) 14866/2026
KUMAR
17:14:27
risk’ (to their activities). Thus, they spoil the career of the
honest, sincere and devoted officers. Instances either way
are galore in this regard. Therefore, one would be
circumspect, pragmatic and realistic to these actualities of
life while angulating constitutional validity of wide,
arbitrary, uncanalised and unbridled discretionary power of
dismissal vested in an appropriate authority either by a
statute or a statutory rule.”
5.
In State Bank of India v. Kashinath Kher, this Court
pointed out that:
“… The object of writing the confidential report is twofold,
i.e., to give an opportunity to the officer to remove
deficiencies and to inculcate discipline. Secondly, it seeks
to serve improvement of quality and excellence and
efficiency of public service. This Court in Delhi Transport
Corpn. pointed out the pitfalls and insidious effects on
service due to lack of objectives by the controlling officer.
Confidential and character reports should, therefore, be
written by superior officers higher above the cadres. The
officer should show objectivity, impartiality and fair
assessment without any prejudices whatsoever with the
highest sense of responsibility alone to inculcate devotion
to duty, honesty and integrity to improve excellence of the
individual officer. Lest the officers get demoralised which
would be deleterious to the efficacy and efficiency of public
service. Therefore, they should be written by a superior
officer of high rank. Who are such high rank officers is for
the appellants to decide. The appellants have to prescribe
the officer competent to write the confidentials. There
should be another higher officer in rank above the officer
who has written confidential report to review such report.
The appointing authority or any equivalent officer would be
competent to approve the confidential reports or character
rolls. This procedure would be fair and reasonable. The
reports thus written would form the basis for consideration
for promotion. The procedure presently adopted is clearly
illegal, unfair and unjust.”
In U.P. Jal Nigam v. Prabhat Chandra Jain9, this Court had held
that while writing the confidential reports, if the officials were to be
downgraded from the previous reports,
9 (1996) 33 ATC 217
W.P.(C) 14866/2026
KUMAR
17:14:27
“… As we view it the extreme illustration given by the
High Court may reflect an adverse element compulsorily
communicable, but if the graded entry is of going a step
down, like falling from ‘very good’ to ‘good’ that may not
ordinarily be an adverse entry since both are a positive
grading. All that is required by the authority recording
confidentials in the situation is to record reasons for such
downgrading on the personal file of the officer concerned,
and inform him of the change in the form of an advice. If
the variation warranted be not permissible, then the very
purpose of writing annual confidential reports would be
frustrated. Having achieved an optimum level the employee
on his part may slacken in his work, relaxing secure by his
one-time achievement. This would be an undesirable
situation. All the same the sting of adverseness must, in all
events, not be reflected in such variations, as otherwise they
shall be communicated as such. It may be emphasised that
even a positive confidential entry in a given case can
perilously be adverse and to say that an adverse entry
should always be qualitatively damaging may not be true.
In the instant case we have seen the service record of the
first respondent. No reason for the change is mentioned.
The downgrading is reflected by comparison. This cannot
sustain. Having explained in this manner the case of the
first respondent and the system that should prevail in the Jal
Nigam, we do not find any difficulty in accepting the
ultimate result arrived at by the High Court.”
6.
In Sukhdeo v. Commr. Amravati Division10 , this Court
has pointed out that:
“It is settled law that when the Government resorts to
compulsorily retire a government servant, the entire record
of service, particularly, in the last period of service is
required to be closely scrutinised and the power would be
reasonably exercised. In State Bank of India v. Kashinath
Kher, this Court had held that the controlling officer while
writing confidential and character roll report, should be a
superior officer higher above the cadres of the officer
whose confidential reports are written. Such officer should
show objectivity, impartiality and fair assessment without
any prejudice whatsoever with highest sense of
responsibility to inculcate in the officers devotion to duty,
honesty and integrity so as to improve excellence of the
individual officer, lest the officers get demoralised which
would be deleterious to the efficacy and efficiency of public
10 1996 SCC (L&S) 1141
W.P.(C) 14866/2026
KUMAR
17:14:27
service. In that case it was pointed out that confidential
reports written and submitted by the officer of the same
cadre and adopted without any independent scrutiny and
assessment by the committee was held to be illegal. In this
case, the power exercised is illegal and it is not expected of
from that high responsible officer who made the remarks.
When an officer makes the remarks he must eschew making
vague remarks causing jeopardy to the service of the
subordinate officer. He must bestow careful attention to
collect all correct and truthful information and give
necessary particulars when he seeks to make adverse
remarks against the subordinate officer whose career
prospect and service were in jeopardy. In this case, the
controlling officer has not used due diligence in making
remarks. It would be salutary that the controlling officer
before writing adverse remarks would give prior sufficient
opportunity in writing by informing him of the deficiency he
noticed for improvement. In spite of the opportunity given if
the officer/employee does not improve then it would be an
obvious fact and would form material basis in support of
the adverse remarks. It should also be mentioned that he
had given prior opportunity in writing for improvement and
yet was not availed of so that it would form part of the
record.”
7.
It would, thus, be clear that the object of writing the
confidential reports and making entries in the character rolls is to
give an opportunity to a public servant to improve excellence.
Article 51-A(j) enjoins upon every citizen the primary duty to
constantly endeavour to prove excellence, individually and
collectively, as a member of the group. Given an opportunity, the
individual employee strives to improve excellence and thereby
efficiency of administration would be augmented. The officer
entrusted with the duty to write confidential reports, has a public
responsibility and trust to write the confidential reports objectively,
fairly and dispassionately while giving, as accurately as possible,
the statement of facts on an overall assessment of the performance
of the subordinate officer. It should be founded upon facts or
circumstances. Though sometimes, it may not be part of the record,
but the conduct, reputation and character acquire public
knowledge or notoriety and may be within his knowledge. Before
forming an opinion to be adverse, the reporting officers writing
confidentials should share the information which is not a part of
the record with the officer concerned, have the information
confronted by the officer and then make it part of the record. This
amounts to an opportunity given to the erring/corrupt officer to
correct the errors of the judgment, conduct, behaviour, integrity or
conduct/corrupt proclivity. If, despite being given such an
W.P.(C) 14866/2026
KUMAR
17:14:27
opportunity, the officer fails to perform the duty, correct his
conduct or improve himself, necessarily the same may be recorded
in the confidential reports and a copy thereof supplied to the
affected officer so that he will have an opportunity to know the
remarks made against him. If he feels aggrieved, it would be open
to him to have it corrected by appropriate representation to the
higher authorities or any appropriate judicial forum for redressal.
Thereby, honesty, integrity, good conduct and efficiency get
improved in the performance of public duties and standard of
excellence in services constantly rises to higher levels and it
becomes a successful tool to manage the services with officers of
integrity, honesty, efficiency and devotion.”
(Emphasis supplied)
21.
We are of the view that the Tribunal is correct in the approach
that it has adopted and the final opinion at which it has arrived.
22.
The
accepting/counter signing authority has given no
justification for continuing to retain the grading of “average” for the
period 1 April 2021 to 30 December 2021, even after the reviewing
authority had accepted the respondent’s representation and upgraded
his grading to “very good”. We may note, in this regard, that even
while entering “average” as the overall gradings in the first instance,
the accepting/counter signing authority provided no independent
reasons but merely concurred with the view of the reviewing
authority.
If, therefore, even after the reviewing authority had
upgraded the gradings given by him to “very good”, the accepting
authority had decided to continue with the gradings of “average”, the
decision had to be informed by reasons.
No such reasons being
forthcoming, and no other cognate material being before the Tribunal
on the basis of which a grading of “average” could be sustained, the
Tribunal was correct in setting aside the overall grading of “average”
granted to the respondent in his APAR for the period 1 April 2021 to
W.P.(C) 14866/2026
KUMAR
17:14:27
30 December 2021 and restoring the grading granted by the reviewing
authority consequent to acceptance of the respondent’s representation.
23.
In so far as the second period of 1 April 2024 to 30 June 2024 is
concerned, the position is even worse. The accepting/counter signing
authority entered the grading of “good” on the basis of what he
regarded as unsatisfactory past performance of the respondent in the
South Zone which, according to him, was not up to the mark.
24.
This is clearly reflective of total non-application of mind and
basic want of knowledge of how to enter gradings in ACRs. It is well
settled that performance of an officer, for grading him in his
ACRs/APARs, has to relate to the period under consideration in the
ACRs/APARs. The past performance of the officer can form no part
of the consideration of the reporting, reviewing or countersigning
Authority.
25.
“A”, in “ACRs”, stands for “Annual”. ACRs are, therefore,
written annually, and have to relate to the performance of the officer
during the year for which the ACR is being written.
26.
No independent reason was provided by the Accepting/Counter
Signing authority for the overall grading of “good” granted to the
respondent for the period 1 April 2024 to 30 June 2024.
27.
The rejections of the respondent’s representations were also
completely unreasoned.
W.P.(C) 14866/2026
KUMAR
17:14:27
28.
In these circumstances, given the law declared in the judgments
cited supra, as well as the reasons provided by the Tribunal in the
impugned judgment with which we entirely agree, we do not find this
to be a case deserving of interference within the parameters of Article
226 of the Constitution of India.
29.
The writ petition is accordingly dismissed in limine.
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
NIVEDITA ANIL SHARMA, J.
OCTOBER 7, 2026
dsn
W.P.(C) 14866/2026
KUMAR
17:14:27
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review