Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:1159-DB
Serial No.02
Weekly List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WA No.32/2024
Date of CAV
: 02.12.2024
Date of pronouncement : 16.12.2024
Shri Deipormi Dkhar
..... Appellant
Vs.
1. State of Meghalaya, represented by Chief Secretary, Shillong.
2. The Commissioner and Secretary of Transport, Government of
Meghalaya, Shillong.
3. The Commissioner of Transport, Government of Meghalaya, Shillong.
4. The District Transport Officer, Government of Meghalaya, West Jaintia
Hills District, Meghalaya.
.... Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice I.P. Mukerji, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Appellant
: Mr. S. Sen, Adv with
Mr. R. Majaw, Adv
Mr. S.K. Roy, Adv
For the Respondents
: Mr. A. Kumar, Advocate General with
Mr. N. Syngkon, GA
Ms. A. Thungwa, GA
F
i)
Whether approved for
reporting in Law journals etc.:
Yes
ii)
Whether approved for publication
Yes/No
2024:MLHC:1159-DB
in press:
Note: For proper public information and transparency, any media
reporting this judgment is directed to mention the
composition of the bench by name of judges, while reporting
this judgment/order.
JUDGMENT
(Delivered by the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice)
This appeal is by a weighbridge operator in Amsarin on the JowaiDawki road, Meghalaya. He is in appeal before us from a judgment and
order made by a learned single judge on 20 th May, 2024 dismissing his writ
petition (WP (C) No.8 of 2024).
The
Meghalaya
Installation,
Regulation,
Maintenance
and
Operation of Weighbridge Rules, 2009 and 2015 were made in exercise of
powers of this State under Section 138 read with Section 212(1) of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988. Rules 3 to 6 give power to the State government or any
private individual upon obtaining due permission from the government to
operate a weighbridge. Rule 7 provides for renewal of this permission for a
period of three years.
2024:MLHC:1159-DB
In these Rules, the Commissioner of Transport is nominated as the
authority.
The main question which arose for consideration in the writ and in
this appeal was whether the Commissioner had the power to execute the
agreement dated 1st June, 2022 allowing the appellant to operate the
weighbridge for a period of three years. According to the respondents, no
tender was invited as required under the Rules for operation of the
weighbridge. Permission of the government or authroisation of the Hon’ble
Governor was not obtained in favour of the Commissioner for execution of
the agreement by him.
The facts are these.
On 7th December, 2017 an agreement was executed between the
appellant and the Government of Meghalaya, allowing the appellant to
operate the weighbridge at Amsarin Jowai-Dawki road. It was for three years
and to end on 6th December, 2020.
During the subsistence of the agreement, the Covid pandemic
invaded the country. The agreement was not renewed. On its expiry on 6 th
December, 2020, it was temporarily extended till 31 st December, 2020.
2024:MLHC:1159-DB
Meanwhile, the appellant had filed an application with the respondents for
renewal of the lease. When it was not renewed but merely temporarily
extended till 31st December, 2020, on 4th January, 2021, the appellant filed a
writ petition in this Court (WP (C) No.2 of 2021).
An interesting turn of events took place when the respondent Nos.2
and 3 filed their affidavit-in-opposition in this writ petition. In paragraph 5 of
the affidavit-in-opposition there was an averment to the effect that the
application for renewal of the weighbridge license would be considered
favourably. It appears that this averment in the affidavit-in-opposition was
pointed out to the Court. On 9 th May, 2022 it disposed of the writ petition by,
inter alia, directing that the appellant was at liberty to approach the
respondents with an application for renewal which was to be decided within
one month from the date of the order.
The respondent No.3, Commissioner of Transport, Meghalaya
interpreted this order to mean that the license was to be renewed for a period
of three years.
2024:MLHC:1159-DB
On 30th May, 2022 he asked the appellant to pay the renewal fee for
execution of the agreement and on 1st June, 2022 executed a fresh agreement
renewing his license for a period of three years.
It appears from the cause papers that there was lack of inter
department information sharing and a communication gap.
Inspite of the agreement dated 1st June, 2022 having been executed
by the respondent No.3, the Deputy Secretary of the Transport department
wrote to the Commissioner of Transport on 14th July, 2023 that approval had
been granted for execution of the agreement only till 30th September, 2023.
The appellant was aggrieved by this decision.
On 31st August, 2023, he filed another writ petition in this Court
(WP (C) No.299 of 2023). A learned Single Judge hearing the writ on 28 th
September, 2023 passed an interim order directing that status quo be
maintained with regard to the weighbridge license. This interim order was
extended from time to time.
On 1st March, 2024 the respondents withdrew the decision dated
14th July, 2023.
2024:MLHC:1159-DB
According to the appellant, the effect of withdrawal of the decision
dated 14th July, 2023 was that the agreement of 1st June, 2022 executed by
the Commissioner of Transport revived together with all the rights under it.
However, according to the respondents this renewed lease agreement was
non-est as the Commissioner has no power to sign it. The original agreement
expired on 6th December, 2020. The appellant had no right to operate the
weighbridge.
On 1st February, 2024, the respondents withdraw all official staff
employed in the weighbridge.
The appellant says that the respondents wrongfully started
operating another weighbridge through those personnel 2 km from the
location of the appellant’s weighbridge.
This prompted the appellant to file the third writ petition (WP (C)
No.8 of 2024) in this Court.
Mr. S. Sen, learned advocate appearing for the appellant contended
that the personnel withdrawn from his client’s weighbridge should be
immediately restored back to him, the government weighbridge 2 km away
2024:MLHC:1159-DB
was illegal and should be shut down and the personnel deployed there should
be returned to his weighbridge.
The appellant did not withdraw the second writ petition at that
point of time.
The third writ petition (WP (C) No.8 of 2024) was dismissed by a
learned single Judge of this Court by a judgment and order made on 20 th
May, 2024. The second writ petition (WP (C) No.299 of 2023) was also
disposed of by this Court.
The weighbridge operator, the writ petitioner appeals to this Court
against the said judgment and order.
It is noteworthy that in the impugned judgment and order, the
learned single Judge accepted the argument made on behalf of the
respondents that the Commissioner had no power to renew the lease
agreement from 2022 to 2025. The execution of the fresh lease agreement of
1st June 2022 for a period of three years by the Commissioner was held to be
unauthorised. Having held so, the learned Judge proceeded to criticize the
subsequent actions and conduct of the respondents in temporarily renewing
the lease agreement on 14th July, 2023 up to 30th September, 2023 and
2024:MLHC:1159-DB
thereafter, on 16th January, 2024 withdrawing the renewal made on 14th July,
2023, which had the effect of the appellant continuing to carry on operation
of the weighbridge. The learned Judge also did not appreciate the subsequent
withdrawal of the personnel from the weighbridge. Nevertheless, in view of
his lordship’s finding recorded above, the writ petition was dismissed.
In order to understand the issues involved in the writ petition and
in this appeal, the grounds taken by the respondents need to be properly
appreciated. They are as follows.
The permission of the government was not taken under Rules 3, 6
and 7 of the Meghalaya Installation, Regulation, Maintenance and Operation
of Weighbridge Rules, 2009. Such permission could only be accorded by the
Secretary to the Transport department. There was no recital in the agreement
dated 1st June, 2022, that permission of the government had been obtained.
Although the agreement was in the name of the Hon’ble Governor,
the Commissioner was not authorised by him to sign the agreement under
Article 299 of the Constitution of India read with the rule of executive
business of the Government of Meghalaya. Only the minister is the
authorised signatory in the name of the Governor.
2024:MLHC:1159-DB
The government is not bound by the acts of an unauthorised officer.
The alleged agreement dated 1st June, 2022 was executed without
issuance of tender.
Arguments and discussion:
Learned Advocate General relies upon Article 299 of the
Constitution of India. It is an acknowledged fact that only the person
authorised by the President of India and the Governor can execute contracts
on behalf of the Government of India and the State, respectively. Any other
person executing a contract document would render it invalid and
unenforceable against the government. The contract has to be in the name of
the President of India or the Governor and signed by an authorised signatory.
Even if there is a genuine concluded contract but not signed by an authorised
person, it would not bind the government. This protection or safeguard is
provided in the Constitution to prevent unauthorised persons from binding
the government to contracts and to ensure a systematic procedure for
execution of government contracts. Even when a contract was novated, the
said procedure had to be followed [see Bhikraj Jaipuria v. Union of IndiaAIR 1962 SC 113, Union of India v. N.K. Private Limited-(1973) 3 SCC 388,
2024:MLHC:1159-DB
Joshi Technologies International, INC v. Union of India-(2015) 7 SCC 728
and Glock Asia Pacific Limited v. Union of India-(2023) 8 SCC 226] cited by
the learned Advocate General.
The other case cited by the learned Advocate General was
Kmenlang Suiam v. State of Meghalaya reported in (2012) 1 GLR 445, which
states that under Rules, 4, 5 6 and 7 of the said Rules, permission from the
State government is required before grant of a weighbridge license.
Needless to mention the appellant based his case on the validity of
the agreement dated 1st June, 2022, the wrongful acts of the respondents in
issuing the notices dated 14th July, 2023 and 16th January, 2024 and thereafter
withdrawing its personnel from the weighbridge.
Timber Kashmir Private Ltd. v. Conservator of Forests, Jammu
reported in (1976) 4 SCC 497 cited by Mr. Sen, learned counsel for the
appellant does not help him because the proposition laid down in that case is
something different. It states that if a government lease is valid, the
documents referred to, in it could be of evidentiary value regarding sanction.
In that case there was no dispute regarding the validity of the lease but the
authority of the Commissioner executing the lease was denied. In our case
2024:MLHC:1159-DB
the grant and validity of the lease is questioned. So this case has no
application to the facts and circumstances of that case.
Mr. Sen also argued that there was another class of contracts
known as statutory contracts, citing Gujarat State Financial Corporation vs.
Lotus Hotels Pvt. Ltd. (1983) 3 SCC 379 and India Thermal Power Ltd. vs.
State of M.P. reported in (2000) 3 SCC 379. The subject lease fell into this
class and its execution governed by the statute. I do not know how these
cases help the appellant because even assuming that under the said statute
and rules, this contract was executable, nevertheless being executed by the
government as a party, it had to comply with the requirements of Article 299
of the Constitution.
In paragraph 5 of the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the
respondents in the first writ petition, it was clearly stated that should the
appellant make an application for renewal of the license, it would be
considered by the respondents. The tenor of the statement in this paragraph
suggested that this application would receive favourable consideration by the
respondents. Paragraph 5 of the affidavit is set out below:
2024:MLHC:1159-DB
“5. That the statements made in para 8 are correct with regard to
mention about provision of Rule and the petitioner is advice to
approach the Transport Department for favourable renewal which
will be considered taking in to view the provisions of Rule 7 of the
Meghalaya Installation, Regulation, Maintenance and Operation of
Weighbridge Rules, 2009 and Point 2 (iii) of the Meghalaya State
Policy for Weighbridges, 2018 and after proper scrutiny of records
and documents related to payment of all Government dues. In fact
it is also stated that recently the Government has accepted petition
for extension of lease Agreement in respect of Majai Weighbridge,
East Khasi Hills District.”
On this affidavit being placed before the Court, the writ petition
was disposed of, on the submission of learned counsel for the appellant/writ
petitioner based on his understanding that the appellant’s agreement was to
be renewed.
Rule 7 is specific that permission would be renewable every three
years. It necessarily implies that a renewal would be for a period of three
years. If after the order disposing of the first writ petition, the Commissioner
went ahead and executed the agreement dated 1st June, 2022 for three years, I
see nothing wrong in his conduct. Otherwise, the respondents would be in
breach of the express or implied assurance given to the Court that the lease
agreement would be renewed.
If the Commissioner had power in 2017 to execute the agreement,
he also had the power in 2022. In fact, the Meghalaya State Policy for
2024:MLHC:1159-DB
Weighbridges, 2018, authorised the Commissioner of Transport to sign the
lease agreement. This policy was issued by the Governor. In my opinion, no
further authority under Article 299 of the Constitution of India was needed
by the Commissioner from the Governor to execute this agreement. The
Commissioner had stated in the recital of the lease agreement that it was
being executed in the name of the Governor.
In my interpretation of the rules, the proviso to Rule 3 only
required the permission of the government to grant a lease to a private
person. Once the lease had been granted no permission was again required
for its renewal under Rule 7. In our case, seeking permission from the
government would have been an idle formality because the above State
policy authorised the Commissioner to execute the agreement.
If an authorised person tries to execute an agreement, binding the
government, the government can rely on Article 299 of the Constitution and
avoid it. But the case is entirely different when the government had full
consent to the agreement but later tries to wriggle out of it on the ground that
the requirements of Article 299 had not been complied with. It should not be
allowed to do so. It is estopped from making this contention. More
2024:MLHC:1159-DB
importantly, the other party to the contract, if innocent, should not be made
victim of any procedural error at the end of the administration.
Furthermore, the initial agreement had to be executed upon a
tender being floated. There is no requirement for any tender at the time of
renewal of the lease because this is against the concept of renewal which has
to be made in favour of the same person.
Now, this decision to withdraw the notice of 14th July, 2023 was in
my opinion violative of the order of the learned Single Judge made on 28 th
September, 2023 directing status quo in relation to the weighbridge, in WP
(C) No.299 of 2023, because simultaneously with the withdrawal of the
notice of 14th July, 2023, the government started contending that the original
lease had not been renewed. Acting in furtherance thereof, they withdrew the
personnel from the appellant’s weighbridge making it inoperational, altering
the status quo.
As the government was bound by the lease agreement executed on
1st June, 2022, as I have held, issuance of the notice of 14th July, 2023,
thereafter revoking it and removing the personnel from the appellant’s
2024:MLHC:1159-DB
weighbridge were all wrongful and illegal acts. So it is obliged to carry out
the said agreement and restore the staff of the appellant’s weighbridge.
As far as setting up of another weighbridge at Amjeha by the
government 2 km away from the appellant’s weighbridge and the rights and
remedies of the parties in relation to this act of the government, I observe
that this is not the subject-matter of this writ petition. Whether the appellant
will take civil action alleging breach of contract or take out any other
proceedings in the nature of writ or otherwise is up to the appellant. I say
that I have not gone into the merits of that matter and leave is given to the
appellant to take such action that he may be available to him or as he may be
advised in an appropriate jurisdiction.
In those circumstances, I declare and direct as follows:
(a) The lease agreement of 1st June, 2022 is legal, valid and binding
on the respondents;
(b) The decisions embodied in the notices dated 14 th July, 2023 and
16th January, 2024 are declared invalid and set aside ab initio;
2024:MLHC:1159-DB
(c) The respondents are directed to restore the staff provided by
them to the appellant’s weighbridge within two weeks from
communication of this order;
(d) The respondents should provide full assistance to the appellant
to operate the weighbridge during the operation of the lease dated
1st June, 2022;
(e) With regard to setting up of another weighbridge by the
respondents 2 km away from the site of the present weighbridge at
Amjeha, the appellant is at liberty to take such action that may be
available to him in accordance with law; and
(f) The impugned judgment and order dated 20th May, 2024 is set
aside.
(g) This appeal is allowed.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(I.P. Mukerji)
Chief Justice
LAMPHRANG KHARCHANDY
Date: 2024.12.16 19:12:34 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review