Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:39396
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
FAO (FC) No. 21 of 2026
Reserved on: 09.09.2026
Date of Decision: 16.09.2026
Uploaded on :
Deepika Thapa
16.09.2026
...Appellant
Versus
Abhishek Thapa
...Respondent
Coram
Hon’ble Mr Justice Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge.
Hon’ble Mr Justice Yogesh Jaswal, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1 Yes
For the Appellant
:
Mr. Suraj Kumar, Advocate, vice
Ms. Anjali Soni Verma, Advocate.
For the Respondent
:
Mr. Suneel Awasthy, Advocate.
Yogesh Jaswal, Judge
This appeal has been preferred by the appellantwife against the judgment and decree dated 18.06.2025,
passed by the learned Principal Judge, Family Court, Kangra
at Dharamshala, District Kangra, Himachal Pradesh, in
H.M.A. Petition No. 236-D/III/2024/22, whereby the petition
filed by the husband for dissolution of marriage by a decree of
divorce under Section 13(1)(i-a) of the Hindu Marriage Act,
____________
Whether reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2 2026:HHC:39396
1955 (hereinafter referred to as "the Act") was allowed on the
ground of cruelty.
2.
Brief facts necessary for the adjudication of the
appeal are that the husband filed a petition for dissolution of
marriage against the wife under Section 13(1)(i-a) of the Act,
alleging inter alia that their marriage was solemnized on
21.06.2007 according to Hindu rites and ceremonies. The
parties cohabited for about ten years, and two children were
born out of the wedlock.
3.
It was alleged by the husband that after the
marriage, the behavior of the wife changed completely, as she
acted on the advice of her parents and subjected the husband
and his parents to verbal abuse. Following the birth of their
first child, her behavior deteriorated further, and she began
leaving
the
matrimonial
home
without
the
husband's
consent, returning after two to three days. Upon being
questioned, she threatened to implicate the husband and his
family members in false dowry cases. Though the husband
3 2026:HHC:39396
requested her parents not to interfere in their marital affairs,
her mother similarly threatened him with false litigation.
4.
In April 2018, after a quarrel, the wife left for her
matrimonial home. The husband, accompanied by his
mother, visited her parental home to bring her back, but she
refused and expressed a desire for a divorce. Subsequently, a
complaint under the Protection of Women from Domestic
Violence Act was filed against the husband, which was
compromised in mediation with an agreement that the parties
would reside separately in rented accommodation. The
parties accordingly resided together at Mohli (Khaniyara) for
two months, following which the rented accommodation was
shifted to Patola, Khaniyara, near her mother's residence, at
the wife’s insistence. Owing to the alleged misconduct of the
wife, their son was enrolled in a hostel at Thakurdwara
(Palampur) as agreed in the Lok Adalat, with all fees and
expenses being borne by the husband.
5.
On 13.09.2019, while the husband was at his
office, the wife left the home without informing him and failed
4 2026:HHC:39396
to answer his calls. Upon her return, she engaged in an
argument with the husband and left the house again. The
husband went to her parental home to bring her back, but to
no avail. Further complaints were lodged against him by the
wife in the Women Cell. The wife never returned thereafter
and made no attempt to meet or communicate with her
children since September 2019, even refusing to speak with
them on the phone. On account of these acts, the husband
claimed that he had been subjected to cruelty, that the wife
had left his company with no intention to return, and that the
marriage had broken down irretrievably.
6. The wife contested the petition by raising preliminary
objections
regarding
its
maintainability,
alleging
non-
compliance with the Hindu Marriage and Divorce (Himachal
Pradesh) Rules, 1982. On merits, she denied the allegations,
asserting that she paid due respect to the husband and his
relatives, but it was the husband who remained dissatisfied
with her. She specifically denied threatening to register false
cases or misbehaving with her mother-in-law. She admitted
5 2026:HHC:39396
the filing and subsequent withdrawal of the complaint under
the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act. She
further submitted that the husband is employed as a driver
with the Municipal Corporation, Dharamshala, plies a taxi,
and earns approximately ₹35,000/- per month from all
sources, besides owning substantial ancestral property as the
only son.
7.
On the basis of the pleadings of the parties, the
learned Trial Court framed the following issues::1. Whether the respondent has treated the petitioner
with cruelty, as alleged ? OPP.
2. Whether the petition is not maintainable, as
alleged ? OPR.
3. Whether the petitioner has neglected and treated
the respondent with cruelty, as alleged ? OPR.
4. Relief.
8.
Issue No. 1 was answered in the affirmative,
whereas Issues No. 2 and 3 were answered in the negative.
Consequently, the petition was allowed, and a decree of
6 2026:HHC:39396
divorce dissolving the marriage under Section 13(1)(i-a) of the
Act was granted in favor of the husband.
9.
The wife has assailed the impugned judgment and
decree on the ground that it is the result of misappreciation
of evidence. It is contended that the husband failed to prove
Issue No. 1 by leading cogent evidence, and that the learned
Trial Court failed to appreciate that it was the husband who
forced her to leave the matrimonial home by subjecting her to
physical abuse and verbal mistreatment. It is further
submitted that the learned Trial Court failed to properly
consider the provisions of Section 13(1) of the Act and
overlooked the fact that it was the husband who had been
demanding dowry and maltreating the wife.
10.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and
have also gone through the records carefully.
11.
The
undisputed
facts
are
that
the
marriage
between the parties was solemnized on 21.06.2007 as per
Hindu rites and customs. It is also undisputed that the
parties lived together as husband and wife for about ten
7 2026:HHC:39396
years, and out of this wedlock, two children, a son and a
daughter were born.
Before proceeding ahead of the matter, it would be
pertinent to mention here that during the pendency of the
present appeal, the matter was referred for mediation before
Mr. Rajesh K. Sharma, learned Mediator, to explore the
possibility of an amicable settlement between the parties.
During the mediation proceedings, the parties have reached a
stage of deadlock. The order of
learned Mediator
dated
07.08.2026 is reproduced as under:“Parties are present today, after having interacted
with the parties for about more than one hour with
the able assistance of their learned counsels, parties
have reached a stage of deadlock after having
discussed all possible proposals.
In this background, I am also of the considered view
that no useful purpose will be served by carrying
mediation proceedings any further. As such,
mediation is closed, having been failed.
Registry of the Hon’ble Court is requested to place
the main case alongwith mediation file before the
Hon’ble Court for further appropriate orders, on the
date already fixed.”
In order to prove his case, the husband (PW-1)
filed his affidavit, wherein he reiterated the allegations made
8 2026:HHC:39396
in the petition. He stated that the marriage between the
parties was solemnized on 21.06.2007 according to Hindu
rites and customs. He deposed that after some time of
marriage, the behavior of the wife changed towards him and
his family members. She stopped listening to them and even
failed to care for the children. When objected to, she used to
hurl abuses and pick up quarrels, frequently misbehaving
with him and other family members. She eventually left the
matrimonial home in September 2019 and never returned. He
stated that he and his family members tried to call her back,
but without success. Notably, the testimony of the husband
on these counts remained unchallenged. He was not crossexamined
by
the
wife
despite
being
afforded
ample
opportunities, and ultimately, her right to cross-examine him
as well as his witnesses, was closed by the order of the
learned Trial Court.
His witness, Meena Thapa (PW-2), who is the
mother of the husband, stated that the behavior of the wife
towards her and the husband was adverse. She deposed that
9 2026:HHC:39396
the wife did not care for her children and, when objected to,
would pick up quarrels. She further stated that the wife left
the matrimonial home of her own accord in the year 2019
and has not returned since then. Her statement likewise
remained unchallenged, as she was not subjected to any
cross-examination by the wife.
The
wife
(RW-1),
in
her
examination-in-chief
tendered by way of affidavit, stated that false allegations had
been leveled against her by the husband. She deposed that
she had never humiliated the husband or his parents, that
her behavior towards them was good, and that she had
faithfully discharged her matrimonial duties. She asserted
that she was subjected to harassment on account of demands
for dowry, that aspertions were cast against her character,
and that she was subjected to beatings before being thrown
out of her matrimonial home by the husband, following which
she reported the matter to the police. However, in her crossexamination, she conceded that no dowry was demanded or
taken at the time of marriage and clearly admitted that no
10 2026:HHC:39396
medical record had been produced on record to substantiate
the allegation of beatings.
Statement of RW-2, Mamta Thapa, maternal aunt
(masi) of the wife is not confidence inspiring, as she in her
cross-examination specifically stated that she was not aware
as to the behavior of the husband and his family members
towards the wife. She has also stated in clear terms that at
the time of marriage, no dowry was given. No doubt, she in
her examination-in-chief claimed that the wife had been
subjected to beatings by the husband, but she admitted that
no medical evidence was there on record in support of these
assertions. Then, she was also not aware of any complaint
under Domestic Violence Act having ever been filed by the
wife against the husband and his family members, but
confirmed that a compromise was executed between the
parties, following which they resided together in rented
accommodation as per the directions of the Court. She
further expressed ignorance as to whether the wife neglected
her domestic duties by not cooking food for the husband,
11 2026:HHC:39396
whether she subjected the husband to physical beatings and
verbal abuse, or whether she refused to communicate with
her children.
RW-3, Saraswati Thapa, who is the sister of the
wife, clearly admitted in her cross-examination that although
the wife was allegedly beaten up in the year 2018, no medical
examination was conducted. She conceded that no dowry was
given at the time of marriage. She identified her signatures on
Ext. RW-3/A. Crucially, she admitted that the wife used to
leave the matrimonial home without informing the husband,
and that the husband along with his mother had visited her
parental home to bring her back. She further admitted that
the children resided with the husband, who pays for their
maintenance, and that following a compromise, the parties
lived separately in a rented accommodation for four months.
She also admitted that the wife did not cook food for the
husband and frequently left the home without informing him.
This is in all the evidence adduced by the parties.
12 2026:HHC:39396
Against this background evidence, the first ground
“desertion” needs to be examined.
If a spouse abandons the other spouse in a state of
temporary passion, for example, anger or disgust, without
intending permanently to cease cohabitation, it would not
amount to desertion. For the offence of desertion, so far as
the deserting spouse is concerned, two essential conditions
must be there:
(i)
The factum of separation; and
(ii)
The
intention
to
bring
cohabitation
permanently to an end (animus deserendi)
Similarly, two elements are essential so far as the
deserted spouse is concerned:
(i)
Absence of consent; and
(ii)
Absence of conduct giving reasonable
cause
to
the
spouse
leaving
the
matrimonial home to form the necessary
intention.
13 2026:HHC:39396
Desertion is a matter of inference to be drawn
from the facts and circumstances of the case.
The inference may be drawn from certain facts
which may not in another case be capable of leading to the
same inference, that is to say, the facts have to be viewed as
to the purpose which is revealed by those acts or by conduct
and expression of intention, both anterior and subsequent to
the actual acts of separation. If there had been a separation,
the essential question always is whether that act could be
attributable to an animus deserendi. The offence of desertion
commences when the fact of separation and the animus
deserendi co-exist. But, it is not necessary that they should
commence at the same
time. The defacto separation may
have commenced without the necessary animus or it may be
that the separation and the animus
desrendi coincide
in
point of time.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Adhyatma
Bhattar Alwar v. Adhyatma Bhattar Sri Devi (2002) 1
14 2026:HHC:39396
SCC 308 while
dealing with the concept of desertion in
matrimonial law held as under:‘Desertion’ in the context of matrimonial law represents a
legal conception. It is difficult to give a comprehensive
definition of the term. The essential ingredients of this
offence in order that it may furnish a ground for relief are :
1. The factum of separation; 2. The intention to
bring cohabitation permanently to an end animus deserndi;
3. The element of permanence which is a prime condition
requires that both these essential ingredients should continue during the entire statutory period; The clause lays
down the rule that desertion to amount to a matrimonial offence must be for a continuous period of not less than two
years immediately preceding the presentation of the petition. This clause has to be read with the Explanation. The
Explanation has widened the definition of desertion to include ‘wilful neglect’ of the petitioning spouse by the respondent. It states that to amount to a matrimonial offence
desertion must be without reasonable cause and without
the consent or against the wish of the petitioner. From the
Explanation it is abundantly clear that the legislature intended to give to the expression a wide import which includes willful neglect of the petitioner by the other party to
the marriage. Therefore, for the offence of desertion, so far
as the deserting spouse is concerned, two essential conditions must be there, namely, (1) the factum of separation,
and (2) the intention to bring cohabitation permanently to
an end (animus deserendi). Similarly, two elements are essential so far as the deserted spouse is concerned: (1) the
absence of consent, and (2) absence of conduct giving reasonable cause to the spouse leaving the matrimonial home
to form the necessary intention aforesaid. The petitioner for
divorce bears the burden of proving those elements in the
two spouses respectively and their continuance throughout
the statutory period.
15 2026:HHC:39396
25.
Undisputedly, the burden of proving desertion-the
“factum” as well as the “animus deserendi” is on the husband
which is required to be proved beyond reasonable doubt, to
the satisfaction of the Court. In other words, even if the wife,
where she is the deserting spouse does not prove just cause
for her living apart, the husband has still to satisfy the Court
that the desertion was without just cause.
26.
In the instant case, the separation in fact and
animus deserendi, i.e. the desertion on the part of the wife
with an intention of bringing cohabitation permanently to an
end stands proved.
Although, she was within her right to
establish that she was subjected to beatings by the husband
and demands of dowry were also raised, but her statement
coupled with the statements of her witnesses is not worth
inspiring confidence to prove this fact. Even in the reply, she
did not specify the date(s), month and year in which she had
been harassed and subjected to beatings by the husband. No
doubt, it has come on record that a complaint under
Domestic Violence Act has been filed by the wife and
16 2026:HHC:39396
similarly, the matter stood reported before the Women Cell,
but admittedly, the same were withdrawn by the parties
having been compromised.
Her allegations that she was
subjected to muscular beatings and thereafter turned out of
matrimonial home have not been proved on record for the
reason that no medical expert or medical record was
produced.
Even from the evidence adduced before the
learned Trial Court by the wife, it is not made out that it was
the husband and his parents, who had turned the wife out of
the matrimonial home after subjecting her to beatings. The
sole testimony of the wife in this regard cannot be taken as a
gospel truth, particularly when both the witnesses examined
by her in the case, as discussed above, are not confidence
inspiring. Whereas, on the other hand, the husband has been
able to prove that the parties have factually separated. The
wife right from the year 2019 had deserted him and did not
resume the marital ties.
since
the
year
There has been no cohabitation
and
the
permanently end the cohabitation.
wife
had
intended
to
17 2026:HHC:39396
27.
From
the
evidence
on
record
including
the
statement of wife itself, it is apparent that the husband and
wife are living separately since September, 2019.
The wife
has not given any cogent explanation as to why she was living
separately.
Her case that she had been harassed and
subjected to beatings and thereafter turned out of the
matrimonial home, has already been held above to be not
confidence inspiring. Once she has not given any explanation
for living separately, it is clear that she has deserted her
husband.
Faced with this situation, it was vociferously
argued by the learned counsel for the wife that it was the
husband who was at fault, as he was not ready and willing to
take the wife back. This cannot be accepted, as it has been
clearly held above that the wife herself had deserted the
husband.
28.
In so far as the ground ‘cruelty’ is concerned,
doubtless, the burden is on the husband to establish his
case. Ordinarily, the burden lies on the party which denies
it. The principle accords with commonsense as it is so much
18 2026:HHC:39396
easier to prove a positive than a negative. The husband,
therefore, must prove that the wife had treated him with
cruelty. Cruelty is of two types, physical cruelty and mental
cruelty.
Then, as per the above findings, it has been held
that the wife without any rhyme or reason has refused to
cohabit with her husband for about two years prior to the
filing of the petition, this amounts to cruelty. For taking this
view, we are guided by the judgment rendered by this Court
in case titled as Bhikam Ram v Satya Devi, 2011(2)
Shim.L.C.342, wherein it has been held that when a wife
without any rhyme and reason refused to cohabit with her
husband for more than five years, this itself amounts to
cruelty.
29.
In the case at hand, from the facts which are
established, it is evident that the parties are living separately
since September, 2019. They have not cohabited with each
other.
The marriage appears to have been irretrievably
broken down and there seems to be no chance of the parties
reconciling or living together.
19 2026:HHC:39396
30.
It was laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Durga Prasanna Tripathy vs Arundhati Tripathi AIR
SC
that
where
there
is
an
irretrievable
breakdown of marriage, with a view to put a quietus to
litigation inter se and bitterness between the parties, decree
of divorce on the ground of desertion can be passed. The wife
has not given cogent and reasonable explanation as to why
she is living separately. She deserted the husband for more
than five years and has not given any cogent explanation why
she is not living with her husband.
Furthermore, her
allegations regarding harassment and demands of dowry have
not been proved on record.
31.
The wife having left her matrimonial home without
any justifiable cause, coupled with her conduct of not even
communicating with her children, certainly amounts to
mental cruelty towards the husband and his family members.
The assertions of the husband that the wife used to abuse
and misbehave with him and his parents, and continuously
threatened to implicate them in false criminal cases, have
20 2026:HHC:39396
remained unchallenged on record due to the lack of crossexamination. Consequently, the ground of cruelty under
Section 13(1)(i-a) of the Act stands duly proved.
32.
In the light of above discussion, we find no merit in
the appeal and the same is accordingly dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand
disposed of.
(Ajay Mohan Goel)
Judge
(Yogesh Jaswal)
Judge
16th September, 2026 (mamta)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review