Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 27th January, 2026
Pronounced on: 18th February, 2026
Uploaded on: 18th February, 2026
+
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.M.(BAIL) 1397/2025
PRADEEP
.....Appellant
Through: Ms. Dolly Sharma, Adv.
versus
STATE
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Ritesh Kumar Bahri, APP with
Ms. Divya Yadav & Mr. Lalit Luthra,
Advs.
Insp. Harish Kumar, PS Dwarka,
North.
CRL.A. 1089/2025 & CRL.M.(BAIL) 1648/2025
+
DEEPAK
Through:
.....Appellant
Ms. Manisha Parmar, Mr. Baljeet
Singh Birla, Ms. Anjali, Mr. Devanshu
& Mr. Rahul Yadav, Advs.
Versus
STATE NCT OF DELHI
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Ritesh Kumar Bahri, APP with
Ms. Divya Yadav & Mr. Lalit Luthra,
Advs.
Insp. Harish Kumar, PS Dwarka,
North.
CORAM:
JUSTICE PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUSTICE MADHU JAIN
JUDGMENT
MADHU JAIN, J.
1.
The hearing has been done through hybrid mode.
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
BACKGROUND:
2.
Present appeals have been filed under Section 415 of Bharatiya Nagarik
Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (hereinafter, ‘BNSS’) assailing the impugned
judgment of conviction and order on sentence dated 7th May, 2025 and 17th
May, 2025 respectively passed by the court of Ld. ASJ (Fast Track Court),
South West District, Dwarka Court, New Delhi whereby the Appellants have
been convicted in Sessions Case No. 537/2017 arising out of FIR No.
152/2017 registered at P.S. Dwarka North under Section 302/201/34 of the
Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter ‘IPC’).
3.
By the impugned judgment of conviction and order on sentence, the
appellants have been sentenced to rigorous life imprisonment for the
commission of offence punishable under Section 302 read with Section 34 of
the IPC along with fine of Rs. 50,000/-. In default of payment of the fine, they
have been sentenced to undergo simple imprisonment for a period of 6
months.
BRIEF FACTS:
Facts giving rise to the present appeals are that on 25th May, 2017, an
4.
information vide DD No. 10A was received regarding an unidentified dead
body lying near Orissa Sadan, Sector-16B, Dwarka, on the footpath beside a
drain.
5.
Upon reaching the spot, the police found the dead body of a male aged
about 23–24 years, fair-complexioned, approximately 165 cm tall with a slim
build, lying near tree No. 259. Blood was found oozing from the mouth and
nose of the deceased and injury marks were noticed on his neck. No visible
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
signs of scuffle were found at the spot. Consequently, FIR No. 152/2017 was
registered at PS Dwarka North.
On 26th May, 2017, the deceased was identified by his brother-
6.
Arjun/PW-4, who informed the police that a missing report regarding the
deceased had already been lodged vide DD No. 36-A at PS Ranhola. He
further expressed suspicion against one Pradeep, who resides in the same
vicinity, alleging that his wife, Pooja, shared a close association with him.
7.
It is the case of the prosecution that upon further interrogation, accused/
Appellant- Pradeep made a subsequent disclosure statement and, pursuant
thereto, allegedly got recovered the belt stated to have been used in the
commission of the offence from his house. The co-accused, Deepak, was also
apprehended and interrogated in the present case, and he too is stated to have
made a disclosure statement regarding the commission of the offence.
Pursuant to his disclosure statement, accused Deepak allegedly got recovered
the Swift car bearing registration No. DL-9CAU-1246, stated to have been
used in the commission of the crime.
8.
After completion of investigation, police report along with other
documents were filed before the concerned court and vide order dated 16th
August, 2017, the ld. Metropolitan Magistrate took the cognizance of the case.
Vide order dated 22nd August, 2017, after compliance with the
9.
provisions of Section 207 Cr.P.C., the ld. Metropolitan Magistrate committed
the case to the Court of Sessions for trial.
10.
Vide order dated 11th January, 2018, charges were framed against the
Appellant and the co-accused for the offences punishable under Sections
302/34 IPC and 201/34 IPC, to which they pleaded not guilty and claimed
trial.
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
11.
The prosecution has examined as many as twenty-seven witnesses in
order to prove the charge against the accused/Appellants. While believing the
testimonies of these witnesses, the ld. Trial Court has discussed them as under:
“10. PW-1 Mr. Ravi Kumar, as per the case of the
prosecution, is a witness of last seen evidence.
However, he has not supported the case of the
prosecution in this regard.
11. PW-2 Mr. Jai Bhagwan @ Bittu, as per the
prosecution, is a witness to the circumstances of the
night of the incident. He has also not supported the
case of the prosecution.
12. PW-3 Smt. Pooja is the wife of accused Pradeep.
She has been examined by the prosecution to
establish the motive of the offence and the
circumstances subsequent to the incident, namely,
that accused Pradeep came home on the night of the
incident with blood stains on his hand and clothes
and regarding the recovery of the waist belt (alleged
weapon of offence) at his instance. She has,
however, partially supported the case of the
prosecution, and her testimony shall be appreciated
in detail at a later stage.
13. PW-4 Sh. Arjun is the brother of the deceased
Marshal. He is a witness to the motive of murder
and identification of the dead body of the deceased.
His testimony shall be appreciated in detail later.
14. PW-5 SI Richhpal and PW-6 Ct. Kapil are police
officials of the Traffic Circle, Gurgaon. As per the
prosecution, they had seen the deceased Marshal in
an injured condition in the company of accused
Pradeep and accused Deepak, travelling in a Swift
car being driven by accused Deepak, at the time
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
when accused Deepak was challaned for driving
under the influence of liquor on the night of the
incident. Their testimonies shall also be appreciated
in detail later.
15. PW-7 ASI Sunita is the Duty Officer who
registered the FIR of the present case and also
issued the certificate under Section 65-B of the
Indian Evidence Act.
16. PW-8 ASI Balwant Singh is the photographer of
the Crime Team who had clicked photographs of the
spot.
17. PW-9 Smt. Paramjeet is the mother of the
deceased Marshal, who had lodged the missing
report of her son.
18. PW-10 ASI Sunder Lal was the Duty Officercum-DD Writer on the night intervening
24/25.05.2017, who had recorded DD No. 10A,
which was handed over to SI Rajender.
19. PW-11 HC Pradeep had first noticed the dead
body of the deceased and informed the police
station. He also joined the investigation after SI
Rajender reached the spot and took the rukka to the
police station for registration of the FIR.
20. PW-12 Dr. Neeraj Kumar Garg prepared the
MLC of deceased Marshal.
21. PW-13 Dr. Jatin Bodwal is the doctor who
conducted the post-mortem on the dead body of the
deceased and also gave his subsequent opinion
regarding the alleged weapon of offence, i.e., the
waist belt.
22. PW-14 HC Yogesh deposited the sealed parcel
of the weapon of offence with the autopsy surgeon
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
for subsequent opinion and brought it back after
examination. He also deposited the exhibits of the
case with FSL Rohini for expert opinion.
23. PW-15 ASI Rajbala registered the missing
report of deceased Marshal vide GD No. 36A, which
was marked to HC Balwan.
24. PW-16 HC Rajeev is the concerned MHC(M)
with whom the case property was deposited on
different dates.
25. PW-17 HC Ramesh is the draftsman who
prepared the scaled site plan of the spot.
26. PW-18 Mr. Pawan Singh is the Nodal Officer
who proved the CAF, CDR and Cell ID Charts of
mobile numbers: 9899814316 (accused Pradeep),
9212867268 (PW-4 Arjun), 9891319511 (accused
Deepak), 8744902287 (PW-2 Jai Bhagwan) He also
issued a certificate under Section 65-B of the Indian
Evidence Act.
27. PW-19 Mr. Prakash Saxena is the Nodal Officer
who proved the CAF, CDR and Cell ID Charts of
mobile number 8076328113 (PW-1 Ravi Kumar)
and also issued a certificate under Section 65-B of
the Indian Evidence Act.
28. PW-20 Mr. Ajay Kumar Saxena is the Scientific
Officer who examined the mobile phone make YU of
PW-4 Arjun and submitted his report.
29. PW-21 Mr. Amit Rawat, Assistant Director
(Chemistry), examined the viscera of the deceased
and submitted his report, as per which ethyl alcohol
was found present in the viscera of the deceased.
30. PW-22 Mr. Surender Kumar is the Nodal Officer
who proved the CAF, CDR and Cell ID Charts of
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
mobile numbers 8130903041 and 9205450991,
along with a certificate under Section 65-B of the
Indian Evidence Act.
31. PW-23 ASI Balwan Singh is the police official to
whom the missing report of the deceased Marshal
was marked for inquiry.
32. PW-24 SI Rajender Kumar is the initial
Investigating Officer, to whom DD No. 10A was
marked and who got the FIR registered. He also
remained associated with the investigation.
33. PW-25 Inspector Nirmal Sharma is the
Investigating Officer of the case and has been
examined to prove the investigation conducted by
her.
34. PW-26 Mr. Suresh Kumar Singla, Retired
Principal Scientific Officer, CFSL-CBI, examined
the exhibits of the case and submitted his report,
wherein genetic material of the deceased was found
on the gauze cloth pieces, car registered in the name
of accused Pradeep, and the belt of accused
Pradeep.
35. PW-27 SI Sachin Kumar was the Investigating
Officer of DD No. 5A, PS Vasant Vihar, pertaining
to a quarrel between PW-3 Smt. Pooja and her
brother Suraj.”
12.
In their statements under Section 313 Cr.P.C., the Appellants denied
the prosecution case and alleged that PW-4 Arjun, brother of the deceased,
had an illicit relationship with PW-3- Pooja, wife of Appellant Pradeep, and
had falsely implicated them after eliminating his own brother Marshal. They
claimed manipulation of investigation and FSL reports. Both Appellants
denied recoveries, disclosure statements and forensic evidence, but admitted
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
issuance of traffic challan on the night of incident, presence of deceased
Marshal in the Swift car, injury marks on his person, and his identification by
traffic police officials.
13.
The ld. Trial Court vide the impugned judgment convicted the
Appellants and sentenced them to rigorous life imprisonment. The relevant
paragraph is re-produced hereinbelow:
“151. Therefore, this court is of the opinion that the
prosecution has not been able to prove the offence
punishable U/s 201/34 IPC against the accused
persons.
CONCLUSION
152. In view of the foregoing discussion, accused
Pradeep and Deepak are convicted for the offence
punishable U/s 302 read with Section 34 IPC.
Accused Pradeep and Deepak are, however,
acquitted for the offence punishable U/s 201 read
with Section 34 IPC.”
14.
As can be seen from the above, the ld. Trial Court has held the
Appellants are guilty under Section 302/34 IPC and has convicted them
accordingly. In terms of the impugned order on sentence, the Appellants were
directed to undergo rigorous imprisonment for life. The impugned order on
sentence reads as under:
“12. After giving my thoughtful consideration to the
aforesaid submissions made at bar and also
carefully perusing the observation given by their
lordships in the aforesaid cases and also analyzing
the facts and circumstances of the case, the
circumstances and the manner in which the offence
was committed and the established facts placed on
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
record by the prosecution and their conduct and
behaviour during the trial, I am of the considered
view that the instant case does not fall within the
category of rarest of rare cases. Accordingly, the
convict Pradeep is sentenced as under :Sr.
No.
Offence
1.
Section
302/34 IPC
Substantive
Sentence
Life
imprisonment
(RI)
Fine
Sentence in default
of payment of fine
Rs.50,000/- Six months (SI)
Benefit of Section 428 Cr.P.C. be given to the
convict Pradeep.
13. Convict Deepak is sentenced as under :Sr.
No.
Offence
1.
Section
302/34 IPC
Substantive
Sentence
Life
imprisonment
(RI)
Fine
Sentence in default
of payment of fine
Rs.50,000/- Six months (SI)
Benefit of Section 428 Cr.P.C. be given to the
convict Deepak.
14. The amount of fine, if recovered, be paid to the
family members of the deceased as compensation
after deducting the expenses of the State. The State
shall be at liberty to file appropriate affidavit
regarding its expenses. In the peculiar
circumstances of the case, I also find the present
case to be a fit case for recommending it to the
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
DLSA South West, with a request to award
compensation, as it may deem fit, to the family of
deceased Marshal in terms of Section 357 Cr.P.C.
15. Fine has not been paid by the convicts.”
15.
The CRL.A 890/2025 and the CRL.A. 1089/2025 were admitted in this
Court vide order dated 7th July, 2025 and 4th August, 2025 respectively.
SUBMISSIONS MADE BY THE APPELLANTS:
16.
Ld. Counsel for the Appellants, Ms. Manisha Parmar along with Ms.
Gauri Sharma, submit that the impugned judgment is unsustainable in law and
on facts. It is submitted that the entire prosecution case rests solely on alleged
last seen evidence and incomplete circumstantial evidence, neither of which
has been proved in accordance with settled principles of criminal
jurisprudence.
17.
Ld. Counsel for the Appellants submits that the prosecution relies on
the theory of last seen though the evidence does not form a complete or
unbroken chain so as to establish the guilt of the Appellants beyond
reasonable doubt.
18.
It is submitted that PW-1 and PW-2 have both turned hostile and have
categorically stated that they have no knowledge whatsoever about the alleged
incident. Their testimonies, therefore, do not advance the case of the
prosecution in any manner.
19.
Ld. Counsel further submits that PW-3, the wife of Appellant- Pradeep,
has also resiled from her earlier statement. In her statement, she admitted that
she was having a close relationship with PW-4- Arjun and that she was in
continuous contact with him. She further admitted that she used to speak to
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
Arjun secretly, which led to acrimony between her and her husband. She
stated that on 24th May 2017, when the Appellants returned home at about
2:00 a.m., there were blood stains on the clothes of her husband, which she
allegedly conveyed to Arjun. She also admitted that she herself washed the
said blood-stained clothes. It is submitted that her testimony is inconsistent,
unreliable and motivated.
20.
It is further submitted that the testimonies of PW-3 and PW-4 are highly
doubtful, particularly with regard to the alleged recovery of the belt at the
instance of Appellant Pradeep from his house. The manner of recovery clearly
indicates an attempt to falsely implicate the Appellant.
21.
The Ld. Counsel submits that Arjun’s testimony is self-contradictory,
as he initially stated that he was in Patna on the relevant date and later
expressed uncertainty regarding his whereabouts. Although he repeatedly
alleged that threats were extended to him by the Appellants, such assertions
are not corroborated by any independent evidence. Thus, neither the
testimony of PW-3 nor PW-4 is sufficient to sustain the conviction of the
Appellants.
22.
Reference is then made to PW-25/K, the FSL report wherein the
samples of the cloth were taken as set out herein below:
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
Parcel No.5 (5A and 5B) cloths belong to Pradeep
Parcel No.6 (6A and 6B) cloths belonging to Deepak
Ex.7 – 1 gauze cloth piece having brownish stains recovered from the
car.
Parcel No.12 – consisting of one black coloured belt Ex.12.
23.
Ld. Counsel for the Appellants submitted that as per the FSL report,
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
except for Ex. 7 and Ex. 12, the DNA analysis did not detect the blood of the
deceased on any of the other articles examined. It is contended that the cloth
piece recovered from the car (Ex. 7) contained the blood of the deceased;
however, the same stands sufficiently explained by the testimony of PW-5, SI
Richhpal, who categorically stated that at the time of issuing the traffic challan
at about 10:30 p.m., the deceased was already injured while travelling in the
Swift car bearing No. DL-9CAU-1246 along with the two Appellants. Thus,
according to ld. Counsel, the presence of blood on the cloth piece recovered
from the car is attributable to the pre-existing injuries of the deceased and
does not incriminate the Appellants.
24.
Ld. Counsel further referred to the MLC and the post-mortem report,
particularly the conclusions recorded therein, to submit that although the
cause of death has been opined as asphyxia, serious doubt exists regarding the
alleged recovery of the belt (Ex. 12), which is stated to have been recovered
four days after the incident. It is contended that the manner of recovery is
doubtful and does not inspire confidence. An additional submission is that the
belt, from its appearance in the photographs on record, does not appear to be
a regularly used article. It is also pointed out that no fingerprint examination
was conducted on the belt.
25.
On behalf of Appellant 1-Pradeep, Ms. Sharma, ld. Counsel submits
that the recovery of belt is shrouded with suspicion inasmuch as the recovery
was done four days later after the incident. Moreover, when the Appellants
had already washed their clothes and there was no possibility of the belt being
recovered in the manner in which the Police claims to have recovered it. There
are enormous suspicious circumstances surrounding the recovery of the belt.
26.
Ld. Counsel argued that the circumstantial evidence relied upon by
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
the prosecution is wholly inadequate to sustain the conviction of the
Appellants. It is further submitted that PW-5, who had seen the Appellants
and the deceased together at the time of the challan, had stated that all three
occupants had attempted to offer money to avoid issuance of the challan.
According to ld. Counsel, this conduct demonstrates that the deceased was
voluntarily travelling with the Appellants and had raised no protest. It is
contended that had the deceased been under any threat or coercion, he could
have informed the police officials present at the spot.
SUBMISSIONS OF RESPONDENT:
27.
On the other hand, Mr. Bahri, ld. APP for the Respondent submits that
the findings recorded by the ld. Trial Court are well-reasoned and based on a
proper appreciation of evidence. He further relies on the ld. Trial Court
judgment, wherein it has been categorically held that the mere fact that the
deceased did not make any statement or express apprehension to the police at
the time of issuance of the traffic challan cannot be construed to mean that
there was no threat to his life.
28.
Ld. APP submits that the PW – 5 and PW – 6 (police officers) had
admittedly seen the deceased in the company of the Appellants at the time of
issuance of the challan and that the deceased was already in an injured
condition. This circumstance assumes significance inasmuch as within a few
hours thereafter, the dead body of the deceased was recovered, thereby clearly
establishing a case of last seen evidence. The said circumstance, read
conjointly with other evidence on record, forms a complete chain pointing
towards the guilt of the Appellants.
29.
It is further submitted that the last seen evidence also establishes the
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
motive of the Appellants, as there existed serious family acrimony on account
of an extra-marital relationship between the wife of one of the AppellantPradeep and the brother of the deceased. In this regard, reliance is also placed
upon the testimony of DW-1, the father of the Appellant, who stated that there
was a family function on 28th May and that the deceased had informed the
family members about the illicit relationship. According to the Ld. APP, this
testimony, rather than helping the defence, fortifies the prosecution case by
clearly establishing motive.
30.
Ld. APP further submits that the dead body was recovered from near
Orissa Sadan, Dwarka, whereas the traffic challan was issued in Gurugram,
and the post-mortem report conclusively connects the date and time of death
with the period during which the deceased was last seen in the company of
the Appellants. It is argued that the Appellants have failed to offer any
plausible explanation as to how the deceased sustained injuries while he was
in their company.
31.
It is further contended that the FSL analysis, which establishes the
presence of the DNA of the deceased at two crucial places, namely Ex.7 (cloth
piece recovered from the car) and Ex.12 (the belt), clearly implicates the
Appellants. Ld. APP places reliance on the recovery of the belt at the instance
of the Appellant-Pradeep from his own residence, which further strengthens
the prosecution version.
32.
Ld. APP also relies upon the sequence and timing of events, submitting
that the challan was issued on 24th May 2017 at about 10:30 p.m., followed
by the registration of DD No. 10A on 25th May 2017 at about 6:30 a.m., when
the dead body was recovered from Dwarka. The close proximity between the
last seen circumstance and the recovery of the dead body clearly establishes
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
an unbroken chain of events leading to the death of the deceased.
33.
Lastly, it is submitted that the recovery of the traffic challan from the
pocket of the deceased, coupled with the seizure memos relating to the car,
clearly establishes that the vehicle belonged to the Appellant-Deepak, that the
challan was issued by the concerned SI, and that the Appellants were last seen
in the company of the deceased when he was already in an injured condition.
These circumstances, taken cumulatively, conclusively prove the guilt of the
Appellants and justify the conviction recorded by the ld. Trial Court.
34.
Ld. APP, Mr. Bahri has also submitted that the strong motive need not
exist for convicting the Appellants inasmuch as even with a weak motive,
there can be a conviction. Moreover, mere absence of motive is not sufficient
to result in acquittal. Reliance is placed on the following judgments.
(i)
Subhash Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi), (2025) 8 SCC 440
(ii)
State v. Santosh Kumar Singh, 2006 SCC OnLine Del 1270
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS:
35.
We have heard ld. Counsel for the Appellants and the ld. APP for the
State at length. The prosecution case primarily rests on the theory of last seen
together and the alleged recovery of the car and the belt.
36.
Upon perusal of the MLC and post-mortem report, it is observed that
the deceased had multiple injuries on the neck and that the cause of death has
been opined as asphyxia. The relevant portions of the post-mortem report are
extracted hereinbelow:
“EXTERNAL EXAMINATION: External Injuries
1. Reddish bruise, 3 cm × 2 cm, was present over
the left cheek, 3 cm below the left eye.
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
2. Reddish bruise, 1 cm × 1 cm, was present around
the left eye.
3. Reddish bruise, 0.3 cm × 0.2 cm, was present on
the inner side of the upper lip.
4. Contused lacerated wound, 0.3 cm × 0.2 cm ×
0.1 cm, was present on the inner side of the lower
lip.
5. Transverse ligature mark, 10 cm, in the form of
pressure, was present on the front and both
sides of the neck. In the midline, the ligature
mark was present 5 cm below the chin and 10
cm above the sternal notch, with a width of 2.5
cm. On the right side, it was present 11 cm
below the mastoid with a width of 2.4 cm. On
the left side, it was present 12 cm below the
mastoid with a width of 2.5 cm.
XXXX
NECK
Hyoid Bone / Thyroid Cartilage / Cricoid Cartilage
/ Tracheal Rings & Mucosa / Any Foreign Body in
Trachea:
On incision and dissection of the neck,
extravasation of blood was seen underneath the
ligature mark, involving the underlying tissues of
the neck, muscles, and extending up to the back of
the trachea. The neck muscles were bruised. The
hyoid bone and all cartilages of the neck were
intact. The mucosa of the tracheal lumen was
congested, and the tracheal lumen contained froth.
TIME SINCE DEATH
Approximately 2–3 days prior to the post-mortem
examination.
CAUSE OF DEATH
Death was caused due to asphyxia resulting from
Injury No. 5, which is sufficient to cause death in the
ordinary course of nature. Injury No. 5 was caused
by some ligature material. Injuries No. 1, 2, 3, 4, 6,
and 7 were caused by blunt force impact. All the
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
injuries were antemortem and fresh in duration.
MANNER OF DEATH
Homicide.
INQUEST PAPERS
Total number of inquest papers enclosed: Fifteen
(15), duly signed.”
37.
Upon perusal of the search memos of Pradeep and Deepak, it is the
case of the prosecution that upon the arrest of both the Appellants, the belt
allegedly used in the commission of the offence was recovered at the
instance of Appellant-Pradeep from his house on 28th May, 2017, from a
room on the first floor.
38.
The belt was also subjected to examination by the Forensic Science
Laboratory. The result of the analysis shows that blood was detected on
the belt. However, the said report only establishes the presence of blood
and does not by itself prove that the belt was used in the commission of
the offence or explain the manner in which the blood came to be deposited
on it. It is possible that the blood came on the belt when the deceased was
already injured and was sitting in the car with the Appellants. Relevant
portion of FSL report is extracted hereinbelow:
“Parcel ‘12’ : One sealed cloth parcel sealed with
two seals of “PM DDUH” containing exhibit ‘12’
described as ‘Waist belt’ of accused Pradeep.
Exhibit ‘12’ : One black coloured belt.
RESULTS OF ANALYSIS
1. Blood was detected on exhibits ‘1’, ‘3’, ‘4a’, ‘4b’,
‘4c’, ‘4d’, ‘6b’, ‘7’, ‘8’, ‘11’ & ‘12’.
2. Blood could not be detected on exhibit ‘2’, ‘4e’,
‘5a’, ‘5b’, ‘6a’, ‘9’ & ‘10’.
DNA EXAMINATION
Exhibit ‘1’ (Soil material) from scene of crime, ‘3’
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
(Gauze cloth piece), ‘4a’ (Shirt), ‘4b’ (T-shirt), ‘4c’
(Jeans pant), ‘4d’ (Lower) of deceased, ‘6b’ (Shirt)
of accused Deepak, ‘7’ (Gauze cloth piece) from car
No. DL-9C-AC-1246, ‘8’ (Gauze cloth piece) car
No. DL-9C-AC-1246, ‘11’ (Gauze cloth piece) car
No. DL-9C-AC-1246 & ‘12’ (Belt) from accused
Pradeep were subjected to DNA isolation.
DNA was isolated from the source of exhibits ‘1’,
‘3’, ‘4a’, ‘4b’, ‘4c’, ‘4d’, ‘6b’, ‘7’, ‘8’, ‘11’ & ‘12’.
DNA profiles were generated from the source of
exhibits ‘3’, ‘4a’, ‘4c’, ‘4d’, ‘7’, ‘8’, ‘11’ & ‘12’ by
using AmpFl STR Identifiler Plus PCR
amplification kit, whereas the DNA profiles could
not be generated from the source of exhibits ‘1’, ‘4b’
& ‘6b’ which may be due to the degradation of the
sample or which may be presence of inhibitors.
RESULTS OF ANALYSIS
Alleles from the source of exhibit ‘4a’ (Shirt), ‘4c’
(Jeans pant) of deceased are accounted in the
alleles from the source of exhibit ‘3’ (Blood in gauze
piece) of deceased.
Alleles from the source of exhibit ‘7’ (Gauze cloth
piece) car No. DL-9C-AC-1246, ‘8’ (Gauze cloth
piece) car No. DL-9C-AC-1246 & ‘12’ (Belt) from
accused Pradeep are accounted in the alleles from
the source of exhibit ‘3’ (Blood stained gauze cloth
piece) of deceased.”
39.
Moreover, this circumstance does not inspire confidence as the
alleged incident took place on 24th May, 2017, whereas the belt was
recovered only on 28th May, 2017, i.e., after a lapse of four days. It appears
highly improbable that an accused, after allegedly committing murder by
strangulation, would retain the very belt purportedly used in the offence,
keep it in his own house for several days, and neither destroy nor wash it.
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
Such conduct is neither natural nor consistent with ordinary human
behaviour. The recovery of the belt, therefore, remains doubtful and does
not lend any substantive support to the prosecution case as there were no
fingerprints on the belt.
40.
As per the prosecution version, the Swift car bearing No. DL-
9CAU-1246, allegedly used in the commission of the offence, was seized
at the instance of Appellant- Deepak, and blood stains were stated to have
been recovered therefrom. However, as discussed hereinabove, the
presence of blood in the car does not, by itself, establish the involvement
of the Appellants in the offence, as such blood could have been transferred
when the deceased was already injured and was seated inside the vehicle.
Moreover, it is significant to note that had Appellants- Deepak and
Pradeep been involved in the act of strangulation of the deceased, there
would, in the ordinary course of human conduct, be fingerprints or other
forensic traces inside the vehicle. The prosecution has failed to place on
record any fingerprint evidence connecting the Appellants with the
alleged act, thereby rendering this circumstance inconclusive.
41.
The prosecution has also relied upon the theory of last seen
together. According to the prosecution, Appellants- Pradeep and Deepak
had picked up the deceased Marshal from near his house, and at that time
PW-1, Mr. Ravi Kumar, was also travelling with them in their car. It is
further alleged that while inside the vehicle, and in the presence of PW-1,
Appellant Pradeep had slapped the deceased. Thereafter, PW-1 is stated
to have deboarded from the car and proceeded to his house. However, it
is a matter of record that PW-1, Mr. Ravi Kumar, did not support the
prosecution case when he appeared in the witness box and turned hostile.
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
The same is the position with PW-2, Jai Bhagwan @Bitto, who also
resiled from his earlier statement and did not support the version of the
prosecution.
42.
The prosecution further contends that thereafter the Appellants,
along with the deceased, were seen travelling in the same car while under
the influence of alcohol by PW-5, SI Richhpal, and PW-6, Ct. Kapil,
officials of the Haryana Traffic Police, and that a traffic challan was issued
to Appellant-Deepak. It is the case of the prosecution, and also a fact
admitted by the Appellants, that on the night of 24.05.2017 at about 22:43
hours (10:43 p.m.), Appellant Deepak was challaned by the Haryana
Traffic Police. As per the prosecution version, the said challan was
recovered from the possession of Appellant-Deepak.
43.
The prosecution, based upon the last seen theory relies on the fact
that the deceased along with the Appellants was seen travelling in a car
while under the influence of alcohol, and a traffic challan was issued by
the concerned police official, whose statement has been relied upon.
Relevant paras are extracted hereinbelow:
“SC No. 537/17
State vs. Pradeep & Anr.
FIR No. 152/17
PS: Dwarka (North)
U/s: 302/201/34 IPC
Date: 21.08.2019
PW-5: SI Richhpal
No. 970
Crime Branch, Sector 10,
Gurgaon, Haryana
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
Examination-in-Chief:
On 24.05.2017, I was posted as ASI in Traffic East
at Gurgaon. On that day, I was on duty at Signature
Tower Crossing, Highway, Gurgaon, to check
drunken driving. At about 10:00–10:30 p.m. on
24.05.2017, one Swift car bearing No. DL-9C-AB1246 came from the side of Jaipur and was moving
towards Delhi. We stopped the said vehicle.
Constable Kapil was with me.
Thereafter, the driver of the vehicle, namely
Deepak, was checked by an alcohol meter and the
reading was found to be 54 mg/100 ml. We then
obtained the driving licence of Deepak and issued a
challan. A copy of the challan was given to Deepak
after obtaining his signatures.
Thereafter, the driver Deepak went away in the said
vehicle, wherein two other persons were seated.
Among them, Pradeep was seated on the seat
adjacent to the driver’s seat, and another person,
namely Marshal, was seated on the back seat of the
car. Marshal was having injury marks on his face.
I inquired from Deepak about the injury marks on
Marshal, and Deepak told me that “isne daru pee
rakhi hai, pad gaya tha.”
I had issued the challan for offences under Sections
188/185 of the Motor Vehicles Act.
XXX
SC No. 537/17
State vs. Pradeep & Anr.
FIR No. 152/17
PS: Dwarka (North)
U/s: 302/201/34 IPC
Date: 21.08.2019
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
PW-6: Ct. Kapil
No. 3318 GGN
Posted at Deepa Mor, Sector 17–18,
Gurgaon, Haryana
(Recalled for cross-examination)
Cross-examination by Sh. Naveen Gaur, Ld.
Counsel for both accused:
No talk regarding giving of money by any occupant
of the car took place. (Vol.) Again said, accused
Deepak had offered money to ASI Richhpal for not
issuing any challan. Accused Pradeep had also so
offered. The person sitting on the back seat of the
car had also so offered.
The challan was issued at a distance of about 2 feet
from the said car. ASI Richhpal was standing there.
On that day, we may have stopped a minimum of 50–
60 vehicles. Tests from the alcohol meter of drivers
of vehicles were conducted. There are about 200–
250 pipes in a packet used in the alcohol meter
which are issued for testing. No identification mark
is put on the pipe after testing.
It is incorrect to suggest that on every pipe, the
challan number is written. I was not there, so I do
not know about it.”
44.
Upon a careful perusal of the said statement, this Court finds serious
infirmities in the prosecution version. If, as alleged, the deceased had
already been assaulted or was in danger, there was no plausible reason for
the deceased not to seek immediate assistance from the police officials
present at the spot. In cases involving alleged assault, kidnapping, or
imminent danger, it would have been natural and expected conduct to
inform the police and seek help. Once the deceased and Appellants
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
encountered the police, if the deceased was under any coercion or threat,
the same would have been clearly discernible. The deceased would have
also given some indication that he was under some threat from the
Appellants.
45.
Contrary thereto, the statement of PW-6 indicates that the deceased
himself attempted to bribe the police official at the time of the challan.
This conduct creates serious doubt regarding the prosecution’s version
and weakens the credibility of the last seen theory. The circumstances, as
emerging from the evidence on record, do not inspire confidence and fall
short of establishing an unbroken chain of circumstances pointing
exclusively towards the guilt of the Appellants.
46.
It is also significant to note that the traffic challan was issued to
Appellant Deepak at Signature Park, Gurugram, Haryana at about 22:43
hours on the night of 24.05.2017. The dead body of the deceased was
thereafter recovered from near Orissa Sadan, Sector-16B, Dwarka, New
Delhi at about 06:30 a.m. on 25.05.2017. There is a substantial time gap
between the last seen and recovery of the body. In the absence of evidence
establishing that the deceased remained in the continuous and exclusive
company of the Appellants after the issuance of the challan, the possibility
of intervention by third parties or other supervening circumstances cannot
be ruled out. The doctrine of last seen together requires a proximity of
time between the sighting and the death, which is not established in the
present case, on facts.
47.
Equally, if the Appellants were indeed perpetrators of a homicidal
act, it would be wholly unnatural for them to voluntarily expose
themselves to police scrutiny at a drunken driving checkpoint and
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
continue travelling openly with the deceased in an injured condition and
then plan to murder him. Such conduct is inconsistent with ordinary
human behavior and militates against the prosecution narrative.
48.
In so far as motive is concerned, this Court finds that the
prosecution has failed to establish the same. According to the prosecution
itself, the wife of Appellant Pradeep was allegedly having an affair with
Arjun, the brother of the deceased. In such circumstances, it is difficult to
comprehend how the Appellants would have any motive to kill Marshall,
the brother who was also known to them and who was the brother of
Arjun. The prosecution has not been able to explain why the Appellants
would seek to eliminate the deceased when the alleged dispute, if any, was
with his brother. Consequently, the existence of motive remains doubtful.
49.
Therefore, these circumstances create a serious doubt regarding the
prosecution version. This Court observes that it is impermissible to rely
upon selective statements or selective pieces of evidence in an attempt to
complete the chain of circumstances. A conviction cannot be founded on
a fragmented appreciation of evidence, as reliance on isolated or cherrypicked material does not, in law, constitute a complete and unbroken
chain. The prosecution case, when examined in its entirety, is replete with
lacunae and gaps, and the individual circumstances sought to be relied
upon do not seamlessly interlink or point towards the guilt of the
Appellants. The dots, as sought to be connected by the prosecution,
remain disjointed and incapable of forming a coherent narrative. The
recovery of the belt is doubtful, the forensic and medical opinions fall
short of being conclusive, and the last seen theory is riddled with
inconsistencies and inherent improbabilities.
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
50.
The Supreme Court in Laxman Prasad v. State of M.P., (2023) 6
SCC 399, has reiterated the settled principle that in a case resting on
circumstantial evidence, the chain of circumstances must be complete in
all respects and must not only point towards the guilt of the Appellants
but also exclude every other possible hypothesis of innocence. The
relevant paragraph is extracted hereinbelow:
“The present one is a case of circumstantial
evidence. The prosecution led evidence to establish
three links of the chain : (i) motive, (ii) last seen,
and (iii) recovery of weapon of assault, at the
pointing out of the appellant. The High Court, while
dealing with the evidence on record, agreed with the
finding of motive and the last seen, however, insofar
as the recovery of the weapon of assault and
bloodstained clothes were concerned, the High
Court in para 18 of the judgment held the same to
be invalid and also goes to the extent to say that the
recovery which has been made does not indicate
that the appellant has committed the offence. Still, it
observed that looking to the entire gamut and other
clinching evidence against the appellant of last seen
and motive, affirmed the conviction.
3. We do not find such conclusion of the High Court
to be strictly in accordance with law. In a case of
circumstantial evidence, the chain has to be
complete in all respects so as to indicate the guilt of
the accused and also exclude any other theory of the
crime. The law is well settled on the above point.
Reference may be had to the following cases:
(i) Sharad
Birdhichand
Maharashtra ;
Sarda v. State
of
(ii) Shailendra Rajdev Pasvan v. State of Gujarat3.
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
4. Thus, if the High Court found one of the links
to be missing and not proved in view of the settled
law on the point, the conviction ought to have been
interfered with.
5. Accordingly, we allow this appeal and set aside
the conviction and sentence of the appellant. The
appellant is already on bail, his bail bonds are
cancelled and sureties if any, stand discharged.”
51.
A similar observation has been made by the Supreme Court in State
of Punjab v. Kewal Krishan, (2023) 13 SCC 695 : 2023 SCC OnLine SC
746, wherein it was held as under:
“18. This is a case based on circumstantial
evidence. It is trite law that to convict an the
accused on the basis of circumstantial evidence,
the prosecution must prove beyond reasonable
doubt each of the incriminating circumstances on
which it proposes to rely; the circumstance(s)
relied upon must be of a definite tendency
unerringly pointing towards the accused's guilt
and must form a chain so far complete that there
is no escape from the conclusion that within all
human probability it is the accused and no one else
who had committed the crime and they (it) must
exclude all other hypothesis inconsistent with his
guilt and consistent with his innocence.”
52.
A further reiteration of the settled principles governing
circumstantial evidence is found in Raju v. State of Rajasthan, (2024) 14
SCC 444, wherein it was observed as under:
“12. In Babu v. State of Kerala [Babu v. State of
Kerala, (2010) 9 SCC 189 : (2010) 3 SCC (Cri)
1179] , it is observed and held in paras 22 to 24 as
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
under: (SCC pp. 199-200)
“22. In Krishnan v. State [Krishnan v. State, (2008)
15 SCC 430 : (2009) 3 SCC (Cri) 1029] , this Court
after considering a large number of its earlier
judgments observed as follows: (SCC p. 435, para
15)
‘15. … This Court in a series of decisions has
consistently held that when a case rests upon
circumstantial evidence, such evidence must
satisfy the following tests:
(i) the circumstances from which an inference of
guilt is sought to be drawn, must be cogently and
firmly established;
(ii) those circumstances should be of definite
tendency unerringly pointing towards guilt of the
accused;
(iii) the circumstances, taken cumulatively, should
form a chain so complete that there is no escape
from the conclusion that within all human
probability the crime was committed by the
accused and none else; and
(iv) the circumstantial evidence in order to sustain
conviction must be complete and incapable of
explanation of any other hypothesis than that of
the guilt of the accused and such evidence should
not only be consistent with the guilt of the accused
but should be inconsistent with his innocence.
(See Gambhir v. State
of
Maharashtra [Gambhir v. State of Maharashtra,
(1982) 2 SCC 351 : 1982 SCC (Cri) 431] .)’
23. In Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of
Maharashtra [Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State
of Maharashtra, (1984) 4 SCC 116 : 1984 SCC (Cri)
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
487] while dealing with circumstantial evidence, it
has been held that the onus was on the prosecution
to prove that the chain is complete and the infirmity
or lacuna in prosecution cannot be cured by false
defence or plea. The conditions precedent before
conviction could be based on circumstantial
evidence, must be fully established. They are: (SCC
p. 185, para 153)
‘153. … (1) the circumstances from which the
conclusion of guilt is to be drawn should be fully
established.
… the circumstances concerned “must” or
“should” and not “may be” established;
***
(ii) the facts so established should be consistent only
with the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused, that
is to say, they should not be explainable on any other
hypothesis except that the accused is guilty;
(iii) the circumstances should be of a conclusive
nature and tendency;
(iv) they should exclude every possible hypothesis
except the one to be proved; and
(v) there must be a chain of evidence so complete as
not to leave any reasonable ground for the
conclusion consistent with the innocence of the
accused and must show that in all human
probability the act must have been done by the
accused.’
A similar view has been reiterated by this Court
in State of U.P. v. Satish [State of U.P. v. Satish,
(2005) 3 SCC 114 : 2005 SCC (Cri) 642]
and Pawan v. State of Uttaranchal [Pawan v. State
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
of Uttaranchal, (2009) 15 SCC 259 : (2010) 2 SCC
(Cri) 522] .
24.
In Subramaniam v. State
of
T.N. [Subramaniam v. State of T.N., (2009) 14 SCC
415 : (2010) 1 SCC (Cri) 1392] , while considering
the case of dowry death, this Court observed that the
fact of living together is a strong circumstance but
that by alone in absence of any evidence of violence
on the deceased cannot be held to be conclusive
proof, and there must be some evidence to arrive at
a conclusion that the husband and husband alone
was responsible therefor. The evidence produced by
the prosecution should not be of such a nature that
may make the conviction of the appellant
unsustainable. (See Ramesh Bhai v. State of
Rajasthan [Ramesh Bhai v. State of Rajasthan,
(2009) 12 SCC 603 : (2010) 1 SCC (Cri) 662].)”
53.
In Nandu Singh v. State of M.P., (2022) 19 SCC 301, the Supreme
Court reiterated that while absence of motive by itself may not be fatal to
the prosecution, in a case resting on circumstantial evidence, absence of
motive is a relevant circumstance which weighs in favour of the accused,
particularly where the other links in the chain are not conclusively
established. The relevant paragraph is extracted hereinbelow:
“10. In Anwar
Ali v. State
of
H.P. [Anwar
Ali v. State of H.P., (2020) 10 SCC 166 : (2021) 1
SCC (Cri) 395] , this Court made the legal position
clear in the following words : (SCC p. 190, para 24)
“24. Now so far as the submission on behalf of the
accused that in the present case the prosecution has
failed to establish and prove the motive and
therefore the accused deserves acquittal is
concerned, it is true that the absence of proving the
motive cannot be a ground to reject the prosecution
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
case. It is also true and as held by this Court
in Suresh Chandra Bahri v. State of Bihar [Suresh
Chandra Bahri v. State of Bihar, 1995 Supp (1) SCC
80 : 1995 SCC (Cri) 60] that if motive is proved that
would supply a link in the chain of circumstantial
evidence but the absence thereof cannot be a ground
to reject the prosecution case. However, at the same
time,
as
observed
by
this
Court
in Babu [Babu v. State of Kerala, (2010) 9 SCC 189
: (2010) 3 SCC (Cri) 1179] , absence of motive in a
case depending on circumstantial evidence is a
factor that weighs in favour of the accused. In paras
25 and 26, it is observed and held as under : (Babu
case [Babu v. State of Kerala, (2010) 9 SCC 189 :
(2010) 3 SCC (Cri) 1179] , SCC pp. 200-201)
‘25. In State of U.P. v. Kishanpal [State of
U.P. v. Kishanpal, (2008) 16 SCC 73 : (2010) 4
SCC (Cri) 182] , this Court examined the
importance of motive in cases of circumstantial
evidence and observed : (SCC pp. 87-88, paras 3839)
“38. … the motive is a thing which is primarily
known to the accused themselves and it is not
possible for the prosecution to explain what actually
promoted or excited them to commit the particular
crime.
39. The motive may be considered as a
circumstance which is relevant for assessing the
evidence but if the evidence is clear and
unambiguous and the circumstances prove the guilt
of the accused, the same is not weakened even if the
motive is not a very strong one. It is also settled law
that the motive loses all its importance in a case
where direct evidence of eyewitnesses is available,
because even if there may be a very strong motive
for the accused persons to commit a particular
crime, they cannot be convicted if the evidence of
eyewitnesses is not convincing. In the same way,
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
even if there may not be an apparent motive but if
the evidence of the eyewitnesses is clear and
reliable, the absence or inadequacy of motive
cannot stand in the way of conviction.”
26. This Court has also held that the absence of
motive in a case depending on circumstantial
evidence is a factor that weighs in favour of the
accused.
(Vide Pannayar v. State
of
T.N. [Pannayar v. State of T.N., (2009) 9 SCC 152
: (2009) 3 SCC (Civ) 638 : (2010) 2 SCC (Cri)
1480] )’ ”
XXX
13. The circumstances on record do not make a
complete chain to dispel any hypothesis of
innocence of the appellant. The prosecution having
failed to establish through clear, cogent and
consistent evidence, the chain of events, on the basis
of which the guilt of the appellant could be
established, the courts below were not right in
accepting the case of prosecution and convicting the
appellant.
14. We, therefore, accept the appeal; set aside the
orders passed by the courts below and acquit the
appellant of the charges levelled against him. The
appellant be set at liberty forthwith unless his
custody is required in connection with any other
crime.”
54.
The reliance placed by the ld. APP on the judgments do not come
to the aid of the prosecution. A careful reading of the said judgments
makes it abundantly clear that the emphasis therein is on the existence of
a complete, cogent, and unbroken chain of circumstantial evidence, which
is not there in the present case.
55.
Upon an overall evaluation of the evidence on record, it is clear that
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
the prosecution has failed to establish a complete and coherent chain of
circumstances leading to the death of the deceased. The time gap between
the alleged last seen circumstance and the recovery of the dead body, the
fact that material witnesses have turned hostile, and the conduct of the
deceased in not informing the police despite the alleged presence of
danger and injury, seriously undermine the prosecution version. The
continued absence of fingerprint evidence, the alleged recovery of an
unwashed belt bearing blood stains even after a lapse of several days, and
the absence of any motive to kill deceased Marshal, collectively create
serious hurdles for the prosecution in establishing a complete and
unbroken chain of circumstances and have given rise to grave doubt in the
mind of this Court. It is trite law that suspicion, however grave or strong,
cannot take the place of proof beyond reasonable doubt.
CONCLUSION:
56.
This Court is of the view that the circumstances on record do not
make a complete chain to dispel the hypothesis of innocence of the
Appellants. The prosecution having failed to establish through clear,
cogent and consistent evidence, the chain of events, on the basis of which
the guilt of the Appellants could be established. The ld. Trial Court erred
in accepting the case of the prosecution and convicting the Appellants.
57.
We, therefore, accept the appeal and set aside the orders passed by
the ld. Trial Court and acquit the Appellants of the charges levelled against
them. The Appellants be set at liberty forthwith unless their custody is
required in connection with any other offence. Pending applications, if
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
any, also stand disposed of.
58.
Copy of this order be sent to the Jail Superintendent, for
information and compliance.
MADHU JAIN
JUDGE
PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUDGE
FEBRUARY 18, 2026
b/RM
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:09:04
CRL.A. 890/2025 & CRL.A. 1089/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review