Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Da te of Decision : 23.02.2026
W.P.(C) 9973/2018, CM APPL. 70851/2025
DEEPAK SINGH
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Krishan N. Rana, Advocate
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ANR
Through:
.....Respondent
Ms. Manisha Agrawal Narain, CGSC
alongwith Mr. Nipun Jain, Advocate.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. KAMESWAR RAO
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J. (ORAL)
1.
This petition has been filed by the petitioner with the following
prayers:“a. Issue a Writ Petition (Civil) under Article 226 of
the constitution of India, An appropriate Writ or a Writ
of mandamus, or Directions to the Respondents for:i. Determination of the retirement Pension of Lt.
Narayan Singh Bhisht.
ii. Determination of the family Pension to the Widow
(wife of the Lt. Narayan Singh Bhisht).
iii. Determination of the family Pension to. Narayan
Singh Bhisht Minor son till the Date of petitioner's
Maturity.
iv. Further Directions to Respondents for release of
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
16:57:39
W.P.(C) 9973/2018
Pension (Mentioned in prayer clause i, ii &iii) with
revised Rate's time to time and as per 6th pay
Commission in favor of the petitioner till the age of
maturity, and interest on the pension and on family
pension, till its release.
v. It is further prayed any other order deemed fit and
proper in this regard be also may kindly be Passed in
favour of the petitioner, in the interest of Justice.”
2.
A perusal of the prayers as made in the writ petition shows that same
are primarily for a direction against the respondents for determination of
retirement pension of Narayan Singh Bhisht and consequential family
pension to the widow of the father i.e. the mother of the petitioner and
determination of the pension of Narayan Singh Bhisht, in favour of the
petitioner till the age of majority.
3.
The father of the petitioner Late Narayan Singh Bhisht (Ex. Ct.) was
working with respondent no. 1. Concedingly, the father of the petitioner was
medically boarded after 11 years 11 months and 10 days of service on
03.11.1979. He expired in the year 1984.
4.
The appellant’s case is that he is the only son of his parents, left
behind after their death. He made several correspondences to respondent no.
2, but to no avail. He then filed RTI’s with the respondents with regard to
the pending pension of his father and visited their office various times, with
all requisite documents, as asked by them. His stand regarding the same in
the petition at paragraph 6 onwards reads as under:“6. That the petitioner made several correspondences
with the Respondent No.2 but No Purposeful result
came out, on the other side Respondent no. 1 all the
way advised to contact Treasury, District Magistrate at
District Almora Utrakhand. In response to the letter of
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
16:57:39
W.P.(C) 9973/2018
the Petitioner, Reply from Respondent no. 1 received
wherein, the required information for pension of father
of the petitioner. Detail's not furnished by Respondent
no. 2. The petitioner filed one R.T.I with Respondent
no. 2, no Response received on Required R.T.I.
Intimated R.T.I. transferred to some other office letter
dated 02.03.2015. Copy to the same Annexure P-5.
7. That the petitioner filed another R.T.I and requested
information from the Respondent no. 2 with Regard to
the Pending pension of his father from Respondent
No.2. The same was confirmed by the Respondent No.2
Department and directed to contact Concerned
Account office For Claim of Pension, copy of the
Response letter dated 26.03.2015 Annexure P-6.
8. That the petitioner contacted the concerned pay and
Account office of Respondent no. 2 and inquired with
A.D.M Almora were in it was intimated no information
with regard to the pension of petitioner father received
for Respondent no. 1 were by petitioner written a letter
to Respondent no. 1 but the earlier information by
Respondent no.2 in its earlier reply dated 19.12.2015
Annexure P-7.
9. That the petitioner visited office of the Respondent
no. 2 several time along with all the required
documents but all the time Respondent no.2 Directed to
approach Battalion office at Meghaliya of Respondent
no.l. The petitioner written a letter to the Battaliaon
office Meghaliya of Respondent no.2, in response to the
petitioner's letter Respondent no.2 Meghaliya office
written a letter and directed to approach concerned
treasury office for legitimate entitlement, letter Dated
Oct 2016 Annexure P-8 . Petitioner contacted the
office of the A.D.M treasury where in the local
Administration said No information with Regard to
pension Received from Respondent no.2 and directed
to obtain a letter from Respondent no. 2 or Respondent
no. 2 for release of pension in the name of petitioner
and also furnished complaint detail of revised pension
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
16:57:39
W.P.(C) 9973/2018
Notification from Ministry of Home Affairs. Petitioner
asked local Administration to issue a letter for Demand
of Required Documents from Respondent no.2, but
local Administration refused to issues such letter.
10.That on dated 18.03.2016 the petitioner received a
letter from the office of Respondent no. 2, certain
documents were asked from the petitioner. The
petitioners full filled all the required documents with
its settlement of the claim with the divisional
Magistrate Almora Uttrakhand copy is Annexure P-9.
But No response received either from Respondent no. 1
or from the office of Divisional Magistrate for pending
pension of his father either from respondent no.l or
respondentno.2.
11.That petitioner approached office of the Respondent
no. 1 and Respondent no.2 local Administration office
but till date No response given to the petitioners
request, claim, and grant of pension and release of
pension in favor of the petitioner.”
5.
The counter-affidavit filed by the respondents reveals that an invalid
pension of Rs.78/- per month was granted to the father of the petitioner
w.e.f. 03.11.1979.
6.
It is the case of the respondents that the father of the petitioner was
unmarried at the time when he was proceeded on invalid pension w.e.f.
03.11.1979. He had nominated his mother, namely Motima Devi, for grant
of relief from BSF Benevolent Fund. He has also declared that after his
death, contributory family pension may be granted to his mother but the case
of the respondents was that the mother does not come within the definition
of ‘family’ for the purpose of family pension. After his retirement, no
representation was received by the department from the father of the
petitioner, stating that he has not received any invalid pension granted to
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
16:57:39
W.P.(C) 9973/2018
him. No information was received from him even about his marriage with
Gangotri Devi nor did he apply for changing his nominee. It is also their
case that the petitioner, in the present case, has not submitted any succession
certificate, issued from the competent Court, which is mandatorily to be
provided in case when the retiree had not submitted any particulars of the
claimant while he was still alive.
7.
Even during his lifetime i.e. till his death on 05.05.1984 and even till
the death of the mother of the petitioner on 03.08.1984, no litigation was
initiated by the father/mother for making any claim with regard to the claim
as sought to be made by the petitioner. The claim of the petitioner for
pension arrears is clearly time barred.
8.
The stand of the respondents in paragraphs 11 onwards is the
following:“11. It is to mention that Rule 54(6)(ii) of the Family
Pension Rule, 1964 provides that a widow may get
family pension till her death or remarriage, whichever
is earlier, and son of a deceased pensioner may get
family pension till he attains the age of 25 year. Copy
of the relevant portion of the Family Pension Rule is
attached as Annexure R-5.
12. On 19.03.2019, when the present petition was
heard, the respondents herein were provided the
necessary documents/information that was required to
process his claim. On receiving the requisite
documents from the Petitioner, the family pension case
of the Petitioner was forwarded to pension sanctioning
authority i.e. Pay & Account Division (PAD) BSF, New
Delhi vide 75 Bn L/No. HA/F-Pen/Deepak/75
Bn/2019/7385 dated 12.07.2019 which is annexed and
marked as 'Annexure R-6'. It is also submitted that
being a Sanctioning Authority, PAD BSF New Delhi
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
16:57:39
W.P.(C) 9973/2018
issues PPO to the concerned State Pension Releasing
Authority. Accordingly, the PAD BSF New Delhi had
issued a PPO in favour of Ex CT Narayan Singh Bisht
to the concerned State Pension Releasing Authority in
this case of retiree i.e. the Accountant General (A&E)II, Allahabad, Uttar Pradesh which is annexed herein
and marked as 'Annexure-R-7'.
13. Further PAD BSF, New Delhi (EOP North Section)
vide letter No. PAD/29-4345/75 BN SF/PAO-CentreEOP/2019/5735-36 dated 10th Nov' 2019 and letter
No. PAD/29-4345/75 BN SF/PAO-Centre-EOP/
2020/09-10 dated 14th Jan' 2020 and 75 BnBSF letter
No. Estt/75Bn/Writ-Petition (Pension)/2020/2710-14
dated 21/03/2020, approached the Accountant General
(A&E)-11, Allahabad, Uttar Pradesh for the following
information with regard to the pension of the retiree:
(a) The amount of pension already paid.
(b) Date up to which pension is paid.
(c) If pension is never paid, then reason for not
paying the pension.
d) If pension stopped, then reason for stopping of
the pension.
Copy of these letters annexed herein and marked as
Annexure R-8 (Colly).
14. Subsequently, when the above requisite information
was not received from Accountant General (A&R)-Il,
Allahabad (UP) despite repeated requests, the same
facts were apprised to the Hon'ble Court on hearing
date 12.03.2020. The same is annexed and marked as
'Annexure-R-9. However, after hearing, Hon'ble Court
adjourned this matter for 01.09.2020 with the
following directions:8. The Accounting General of Border Security
Force, Allahabad, Uttar Pradesh, is directed to,
within two weeks of receipt of this order, furnish
the requisite information sought with respect to
Late Narain Singh Bisht, Ex-Constable.
9. The respondent if so desire, to file counter
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
16:57:39
W.P.(C) 9973/2018
affidavit within six weeks from today.
10. Rejoinder, if any, be filed within six weeks
thereafter.
11. Counsel for the parties to serve the order on
the Accounting General of Border Security Force,
Allahabad, Uttar Pradesh.”
15. It is submitted that in the Court Order 12.03.2020,
word 'Accounting General of Border Security Force,
Allahabad, Uttar Pradesh' have been inadvertently
mentioned in place of Accountant General (A&E)-II,
Allahabad (UP). AG (A&E)-II (UP) is a separate
organization having duty to release pension to the
retirees of the respective state, through concerned
Treasury Office (in this case, Treasury Office Almora,
Uttrakhand) in accordance with the PPO issued by the
department, in which such retirees had served.
Accordingly, in this issue the Respondent submitted an
application vide diary No. 1347452/2022 before the
Hon'ble Court seeking appropriate orders for
modification of order dated 12.03.2020 passed by the
Hon'ble Court on the petition, by issuing directions to
"Account General (A&E)-II, Allahabad, Uttar Pradesh
instead of "Accounting General of Border Security
Force, Allahabad, Uttar Pradesh.'
16. The Accountant General (A&E)-11, Allahabad,
Uttar Pradesh vide letter No. Pension(Central) /L.I.D1058/253 dated 05/08/2020 (annexed and marked as
'Annexure-R-10') requested to forward PPO Order
Numbers and documents for further necessary action.
However, 75 Bn BSF vide L/No. Estt/75 Bn/WritPetition (Pension)/2021/8141-42 dtd 03 Dec 2021
approached Accountant General (A&E)-11, Allahabad,
Uttar Pradesh to provide all necessary documents at
the earliest to avoid any legal complications at the
later stage. (Annexed herein as "Annexure R-11").
17. Thereafter, Accountant General (A&E)-II.
Allahabad. Uttar Pradesh vide L/No. Pension
(Central)/40 dated 11/04/2022. requested the
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
16:57:39
W.P.(C) 9973/2018
Petitioner i.e. Sh Deepak Singh S/o Late Nayayan
Singh Bist to provide PPO and available connected
documents under intimation to 75 Bn BSF, (Annexed as
"Annexure R-12").
18. In the meantime, 75 Bn BSF vide L/No. 3971-76
dated 27/05/2022 has forwarded old PPO No. BSF3949 dated 27 Oct 1979 to the Accountant General
(A&E)-II. Allahabad, Uttar Pradesh vide L/No. Estt/75
Bn/Writ-Petition (Pension)/2022/3971-76 dated 27
May 2022 (annexed and marked as 'Annexure-R-13').
19. Thereafter. Accountant General (A&E)-II,
Allahabad, Uttar Pradesh vide L/No. Pension Central
Group /Group-11/LID-12703/288 dated 27/07/2022
(annexed and marked as "Annexure R-14'), again
requested the Petitioner i.e. Sh Deepak Singh S/o Late
Nayayan Singh Bist to provide any documents/
correspondence of their office in which the PPO No. or
Co No. mentioned.
20. It is submitted that the Respondents have made
various correspondences with State Pension Releasing
Authority Accountant General (A&E)-II, Allahabad,
Uttar Pradesh to release the due invalid pension to the
petitioner i.e. Late CT Narayan Singh Bist from the
date of stoppage of pension to upto 05/05/1984 (i.e.
date of death, Death certificate annexed as 'Annexure
R-15') and family pension to Smt. Gangotri Devi W/o
Late CT Narayan Singh Bist from 05/05/1984 to
03/08/1984 (i.e. date of death, Death certificate
annexed as 'Annexure R-16') and thereafter Sh Deepak
Singh from 03/08/1984 to 12/02/2007 (i.e. date of
death of his mother upto his age 25 years, School
Certificate of the petitioner showing Age & relation
annexed as 'Annexure R-17'). However, neither any
fruitful reply received from the Accountant General
(A&E)-11, Allahabad, Uttar Pradesh nor any action to
release the due pension benefits to the Petitioner has
been intimated, till date.”
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
16:57:39
W.P.(C) 9973/2018
9.
The stand which has been taken by the respondents would reveal that
the son/petitioner shall not be entitled to the claim of pension, as made by
him in the petition. In any case, a son is not entitled to family pension
beyond the age of 25 years and more so, when the employee namely
Narayan Singh Bisht had not made any claim nor the petitioner has shown
the entitlement of his father for pension, any payment in favour of the
petitioner cannot be granted.
10.
The petition being without any merit, is dismissed.
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J
FEBRUARY 23, 2026/sr
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
16:57:39
W.P.(C) 9973/2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review