The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
14. If answer to the aforesaid questions is in the affirmative then candidates who do not possess Ph.D. Degree in Horticulture will not be permitted to participate in the selection for appointment to the post of Professor (Horticulture). However, if the answer to the aforesaid questions is in the negative, then respondent nos. 6 & 7 shall be permitted to participate in the further process of selection for the post of Professor (Horticulture), as per law.
15. With the aforesaid directions, writ petition stands disposed of. ( Pa n k a j Pu r o h i t , J.) ( M a n o j K u m a r Ti w a r i , J.)
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:UHC:1306-DB
H I GH COURT OF UTTA RA K H A N D A T N A I N I TA L
W r i t Pe t i t i o n Se r v i ce Be n ch N o . 2 5 6 o f 2 0 2 3
2 5 Fe b r u a r y , 2 0 2 6
Deepak Kum ar Rana
… Pet it ioner
Ve r su s
Hem vat i Nandan Bahuguna Gar hwal Universit y
& ot hers
… Respondent s
------------------------------------------------------------------Pr e sen ce : Mr. M.C. Pant , Advocat e for t he pet it ioners.
Dr. Kart ikey Har i Gupt a, learned counsel for t he Universit y
Ms. Anj ali Bhar gawa, learned counsel for UGC
Mr. Prakash Joshi, learned counsel for t he privat e respondent s
------------------------------------------------------------------H o n ’ b l e M a n o j K u m a r Ti w a r i , J.
H o n ’ b l e Pa n k a j Pu r o h i t , J.
JUD GM EN T
( Pe r : H o n ’ b l e M a n o j K u m a r Ti w a r i )
1.
Petitioner is serving as Associate Professor
(Horticulture) in Hemvati Nandan Bahuguna Garhwal
University, Srinagar Garhwal. By means of this writ
petition, petitioner has sought the following reliefs:(i)
Issue a Writ, rule order or direction in the nature of Certiorarimandamus to declare the impugned public notice dated
16.06.2023 (Contained in Annexure No. 1) issued by the
Registrar, HNB Garhwal University whereby he released the
result of scrutiny of applications for the post of faculty
(Professor) Horticulture, shortlisting 2 candidates (Pvt
Respondents) of non-horticulture background for the interview
applying pick and choose policy, alone with all consequential
orders and actions which are offshoots of the impugned order,
the entire process is against statute, arbitrary, is an outcome
of bias and favouritism, illegal, void ab-initio, illogical, highly
irregular and therefore, deserves to be quashed after calling
entire records from the Respondents, along with its effect and
operation also or to mould the relief appropriately, keeping in
view the facts highlighted in the body of the petition.
(ii)
Issue a Writ, rule, order or direction in the nature of
mandamus to direct the Respondents to cancel the
candidature of the Private respondents who are qualified for
the post of Professor and further direct consideration of the
petitioner for the same or to mould the relief appropriately to
safeguard the interest of the Petitioner, keeping in view the
facts highlighted in the body of petition.
(iii)
Issue writ rule or direction in the nature of mandamus
2026:UHC:1306-DB
directing the UGC to monitor the entire selection process and
take appropriate steps to ensure no ineligible candidate is
appointed and further to set up an inquiry against the
Screening Committee and erring officers for the violation of
UGC regulations, keeping in view the facts highlighted in the
body of the writ petition.
2.
In sum and substance, petitioner has
challenged the result declared by the Screening-cum
Scrutiny Committee, whereby respondent nos. 6 & 7 were
shortlisted to be called for interview for appointment on
the post of Professor (Horticulture).
3.
Petitioner contends that respondent nos. 6 & 7
do not have Ph.D. Degree in Horticulture, which is
essential for appointment as Professor (Horticulture).
Petitioner relies upon the resolution passed by Board of
Studies (in short “BoS”) in its meeting held on 12.07.2022
in which it was decided that candidates with Ph.D.
Degree in Horticulture alone would be eligible for
appointment as Professor (Horticulture).
4.
Learned counsel for respondent nos. 6 & 7,
however, submits that since petitioner was not meeting
the condition of ten years service as Associate Professor
for appointment as a Professor (Horticulture) at the
relevant point of time, therefore, in order to derail the
impending selection, petitioner misused his position as
Chairman of BoS and got a resolution passed that
candidates having Ph.D. in Horticulture alone would be
eligible for appointment as Professor (Horticulture). He
submits that BoS is not concerned either with selection
or with the academic qualification needed for
appointment to a teaching post in the University.
5.
Learned counsel for the University has drawn
our attention to Minutes of the Coordination Committee,
which is enclosed as Annexure 3 to the counter affidavit
filed by University. Based on the said document, it is
contended that a Screening-cum-Scrutiny Committee
was constituted, which was empowered to look into the
question of eligibility of candidates for appointment.
Para 6 of Minutes of the Meeting (Annexure 3 to the CA)
is reproduced below:“6.
Screening of applications must be ensured as per
provisions of UGC Regulations on Minimum Qualifications for
2026:UHC:1306-DB
Appointment of Teachers and Other Academic Staff in
Universities and Colleges and Measures for the Maintenance
of Standards in Higher Education, 2018 dated 18th July 2018
and its subsequent amendments including University Grants
Commission (Minimum Qualifications for Appointment of
Teachers and other Academic Staff in Universities and
Colleges and other Measures for the Maintenance of
Standards in Higher Education), 2021 dated 11th October,
2021.”
6.
Learned counsel for University further submits
that the decision taken in the meeting of the
Coordination Committee, referred to above, was ratified
by the Committee in its meeting held on 17.04.2023, and
the Executive Council of the University approved the
decision taken by the Coordination Committee in its
meeting held on 30.05.2023.
7.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
then submits that petitioner was replaced as Chairman
of BoS by Professor J.S. Chauhan, Dean of School of
Agriculture & Allied Science, and the re-constituted BoS
also approved the decision taken by BoS under the
Chairmanship of petitioner, in its meeting held on
23.01.2023. Learned counsel further submits that the
Academic Council as well as the Executive Council
approved the decision taken by BoS on 12.07.2022.
8.
Learned counsel for respondent nos. 6 & 7,
however, submits that the contention raised on behalf of
petitioner that BoS, Headed by Professor J.S. Chauhan,
ratified the earlier decision taken by BoS is not correct.
He refers to Annexure 4 to the writ petition for
contending that School of Agriculture & Allied Science
was Headed by Professor J.S. Chauhan, and Professor
J.S. Chauhan never replaced petitioner in BoS. He
further points out that petitioner was Member of School
Board, while Professor J.S. Chauhan held the position of
Chairman in the BoS at the time when the decision,
relied by him was taken.
9.
From the aforesaid discussion, it is apparent
that the issue involved in this writ petition is regarding
competence of Board of Studies to take the decision, as
was taken in its meeting held on 12.07.2022. In other
words, whether BoS was competent to take decision
regarding qualification needed for appointment to a
2026:UHC:1306-DB
teaching post and whether petitioner misused his
position to derail the impending selection, as he had not
completed required ten years service as Associate
Professor.
10.
Learned counsel for the petitioner contends
that as per Clause 3(f) of the Ordinance, BoS was well
within its right to take the decision as was taken in the
meeting dated 12.07.2022.
11.
Learned counsel for private respondents,
however, submits that Board of Studies was not
competent to go into the question of eligibility of a
candidate and this aspect can only be gone into by the
Screening-cum-Scrutiny Committee. He submits that
since petitioner was Heading BoS at the relevant point of
time and he was not having requisite ten years of service
as Associate Professor (Horticulture), therefore, with a
view to scuttle the impending selection, he prevailed
upon the BoS to declare Ph.D. Degree in Horticulture as
the essential qualification for appointment as Professor
(Horticulture). He submits that the said decision by BoS
was beyond the scope of its powers, thus is without
jurisdiction.
12.
Whether BoS was justified in laying down
qualification needed for appointment as Professor
(Horticulture) or not, is to be decided with reference to
the relevant statutory provisions applicable to HNB
Garhwal University. There is another aspect, which can
only be examined by the Vice Chancellor, namely,
whether the decision, as was taken by BoS, was taken
bonafidely or with ulterior motive of derailing the
impending selection, as alleged by counsel appearing for
the private respondents.
13.
We, therefore, relegate the matter to the Vice
Chancellor of the University to examine the following
issues in the light of relevant statutory provisions and/or
decisions taken by the Executive Council:(i)
Whether BoS had taken the decision that
candidates with Ph.D. Degree in Horticulture
alone would be eligible for appointment as
2026:UHC:1306-DB
Professor (Horticulture);
(ii)
Whether BoS was justified in taking the
decision regarding the academic qualification
needed
for
appointment
as
Professor
(Horticulture);
(iii)
Whether the decision regarding eligibility of a
person for appointment to the post of Professor
(Horticulture) was taken after initiation of
selection process in question; and
(iv)
Whether there is no other Committee/Body in
place in the University, which can go into the
question of academic qualification needed for
appointment to a teaching/non-teaching
position.
14.
If answer to the aforesaid questions is in the
affirmative then candidates who do not possess Ph.D.
Degree in Horticulture will not be permitted to participate
in the selection for appointment to the post of Professor
(Horticulture). However, if the answer to the aforesaid
questions is in the negative, then respondent nos. 6 & 7
shall be permitted to participate in the further process of
selection for the post of Professor (Horticulture), as per
law.
15.
With the aforesaid directions, writ petition
stands disposed of.
( Pa n k a j Pu r o h i t , J.)
( M a n o j K u m a r Ti w a r i , J.)
25.02.2026
Aswal
NITI RAJ
SINGH
ASWAL
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND,
ou=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND,
2.5.4.20=eacc6757ee7881e933ff8934f0747700
5aa85f9802a3a08b08d1369512ea30f3,
postalCode=263001, st=UTTARAKHAND,
serialNumber=44EB54CBF00B7698CB6F10C2C
E3D26F5C22DACF4F4610C1FE58A58531726FB
B0, cn=NITI RAJ SINGH ASWAL
Date: 2026.03.11 09:16:30 -07'00'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review