Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
%
+
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Judgment reserved on: 30.04.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 02.05.2026
W.P.(C) 17736/2025 & CM APPL. 73299/2025
DEEPAK KUMAR & ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Joby P Varghese, Ms.
Rashi and Mr. Aby P Varghese,
Advs.
versus
+
BORDER SECURITY FORCE & ANR. .....Respondents
Through: Mr. Vikram Singh Dalal, Senior
Panel Counsel alongwith Mr.
Pankaj Kumar, and Mr. Satwik
Mitra, Advs.
W.P.(C) 3642/2026 & CM APPL. 17769/2026
DEEPAK KUMAR & ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Joby P Varghese, Ms.
Rashi and Mr. Aby P Varghese,
Advs.
versus
BORDER SECURITY FORCE & ANR. .....Respondents
Through: Mr. Syed Abdul Haseeb, CGSC
with Ms. Nasreen Khatoon, G.P
for UOI with Mr. Muhammad
Aamir Khan and Mr. Syed
Abdur Rahman, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
JUDGMENT
AMIT MAHAJAN, J.
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
18:54:50
W.P.(C) 17736/2025 & W.P.(C) 3642/2026
1.
By the present writ petitions, the Petitioners essentially seek
issuance of a writ in the nature of certiorari thereby setting aside the
decision of the Respondents - rejecting the application of the
respective Petitioners for consideration to the post of Constable (GD)
sports quota – 2025 in the BSF in terms of the advertisement dated
10.10.2025 (in W.P.(C) 17736/2025) and advertisement dated
19.12.2025 (in W.P.(C) 3642/2026).
2.
Succinctly stated, the pertinent facts germane to the
adjudication of the present petitions are as follows:
2.1.
The Petitioners in the respective petitions are stated to be
sportspersons who participated in various junior level National and
State Championships organised by various sports federations in India.
2.2.
By advertisement dated 10.10.2025, Respondent No. 1 invited
online applications towards certain vacancies for the recruitment of
meritorious sportspersons to the post of Constable (General Duty)
under sports quota 2025 in the BSF. The Petitioners in W.P.(C)
17736/2025 also applied in the recruitment process against the
vacancies under respective sporting activities, however, despite the
commencement of physical and medical examination of the
candidates, the Petitioners were not issued admit cards for
participation in the selection process. Upon enquiry, the Petitioners
learnt that their sports certificates were not acceptable and did not
conform to the terms of the advertisement. It is the case of the
Petitioners that they fulfilled the eligibility criteria as stipulated under
the Advertisement dated 10.10.2025, and that certain similarly situated
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
18:54:50
W.P.(C) 17736/2025 & W.P.(C) 3642/2026
candidates with similar certificates were shortlisted, selected and even
appointed as Constable (GD) sports quota by Respondent No. 1.
Aggrieved by the same, the Petitioners filed W.P.(C) 17736/2025.
2.3.
Similarly, another advertisement dated 19.12.2025 was issued
by Respondent No.1 for selection to the post of Constable (GD) under
the sports quota – 2025. Thereafter, the Petitioners in W.P.(C)
3642/2026 submitted their application forms along with supporting
certificates in respect of different sporting activities. The Petitioners
herein were also not issued admit cards by Respondent No. 1 to
participate in the selection process. Akin to the grievance raised by the
Petitioners in W.P.(C) 17736/2025, the Petitioners in W.P.(C)
3642/2026 also contend that they were rejected on the ground that
their certificates did not conform with the conditions stipulated in the
advertisement. They further contend that similarly situated candidates
have been appointed as Constable (GD) under the previous
advertisement. Consequently, the Petitioners filed W.P.(C) 3642/2026.
3.
By order dated 24.11.2025, this Court permitted the Petitioners
in W.P.(C) 17736/2025 to participate in the further selection process
as sports quota candidates subject to the outcome of the Petition. Vide
order dated 08.04.2026, this Court recorded the submission made on
behalf of the Petitioners in W.P.(C) 17736/2025 that out of 05
Petitioners, 03 Petitioners have been qualified and with respect to the
remaining
Petitioners,
W.P.(C)
17736/2025
is
rendered
infructuous.
4.
The learned counsel for the Petitioners submitted that the
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
18:54:50
W.P.(C) 17736/2025 & W.P.(C) 3642/2026
rejection of the candidature of the Petitioners in the respective
petitions is discriminatory and violative of Article 14 of the
Constitution of India. He submitted that the Petitioners in the
respective petitions meet the eligibility criteria stipulated under the
respective advertisements.
5.
He submitted that the selective acceptance of certificates from
the same federation for other candidates while rejecting those of the
Petitioners is manifestly arbitrary. He submitted that without any
verification of the authenticity and recognition of the certificates
submitted by the Petitioners, summary rejection of their candidature is
wholly arbitrary. He submitted that once Respondent No. 1 previously
accepted similar certificates from the same federation for other
candidates who have not only been allowed to participate but have
also been appointed, the sudden deviation and exclusion of the
Petitioners herein is violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of
India.
6.
Per contra, the learned counsel on behalf of the Respondents
submitted that the Petitioners were not issued admit cards on account
of
the
non-fulfilment
of
the
conditions
stipulated
in
the
advertisements. He submitted that the applications of the Petitioners in
W.P.(C) 17736/2025 was rejected during the scrutiny stage in terms of
Clause 4 and 4b(iii) of the Advertisement dated 10.10.2025. He
submitted that the Sports federation of the respective petitioners in
W.P.(C) 17736/2025 which organised the concerned Youth Games
and issued the certificates is neither recognised by the Ministry of
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
18:54:50
W.P.(C) 17736/2025 & W.P.(C) 3642/2026
Youth Affairs and Sports as National Sports Federation nor
recognised by affiliated member of Indian Olympic Association.
7.
He submitted that in the previous recruitment cycle, some
candidates may have been inadvertently considered due to lack of
robust verification mechanism, however, the said instances, if at all,
were purely inadvertent and do not confer any enforceable right on the
Petitioners. He further submitted that the Respondents are examining
the veracity of such instances, if any, pertaining to previous
recruitments as has been claimed by the Petitioners. He assured that
that if any such case comes forth post the verification, appropriate
action, wherever warranted, will be taken in accordance with law. He
however submitted that the same does not create any right in favour of
the present Petitioners whose candidature does not satisfy the
stipulated eligibility criteria prescribed in the advertisements. He
consequently submitted that the present petitions are liable to be
dismissed.
8.
Upon considering the rival submissions made by both the
parties, in essence, the grievance of the Petitioners’ pertains to a denial
of opportunity to them to participate in the selection process to the
post of Constable (GD) sports quota – 2025. The principal plank of
the Petitioners case is one of parity. It has been asserted that the
primary ground for the denial of opportunity to the Petitioners was
that the certificates submitted by them did not conform to the criteria
prescribed in the advertisement, however, several similarly situated
candidates with similar certificates were shortlisted and even
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
18:54:50
W.P.(C) 17736/2025 & W.P.(C) 3642/2026
appointed to the said post in the previous recruitment cycle.
Consequently, it has been emphasised that the exclusion of the
Petitioners is violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
9.
Before proceeding further, it will be appropriate to take note of
the certificates adduced by the respective Petitioners, which came to
be rejected by the BSF. A chart with the said particulars has been filed
by the respective Petitioners in the respective petitions. The relevant
details are as under:
W.P.(C) 17736/2025
Sports Certificate
Name
Sports
Petitioner No. 2
Racewalk 20
Km
(Individual
Event)
17th Youth Games National Championship- 2025
held at Pedem Sports Complex, Mapusa, Goa in June
2025 organized by FIT INDIA ‘Youth Games
Development Federation’ –Goa
Petitioner No. 4
Football
17th National Championship held at Delhi Public
School, Uttar Pradesh organized by the ‘National
Sports Federation of India’
(Team
Event)
Petitioner No. 5
Football
17th National Championship held at Delhi Public
School, Uttar Pradesh organized by the ‘National
Sports Federation of India’
(Team
Event)
Petitioner No. 1
Shot Put
(Individual
Event)
Petitioner No. 2
W.P.(C) 3642/2026
19th National Championship- 2025 held at Prakash
Sports Academy, Haridwar, Uttrakhand on 27th-28th
December 2025 organized by ‘National Sports
Federation of India’
Athletics
5km
(Individual
Event)
Petitioner No. 3
Volleyball
19th National Championship- 2025 held at Prakash
Sports Academy, Haridwar, Uttrakhand on 27th-28th
December 2025 organized by ‘National Sports
Federation of India’.
19th National Championship- 2025 held at Prakash
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
18:54:50
W.P.(C) 17736/2025 & W.P.(C) 3642/2026
Petitioner No. 4
(Team
Event)
Sports Academy, Haridwar, Uttrakhand on 27th-28th
December 2025 organized by ‘National Sports
Federation of India’.
Handball
19th National Championship- 2025 held at Prakash
Sports Academy, Haridwar, Uttrakhand on 27th-28th
December 2025 organized by ‘National Sports
Federation of India’.
(Team
Event)
Petitioner No. 5
Athletics
1500m
(Individual
Event)
Petitioner No. 6
Hurdle 400m
(Individual
Event)
Petitioner No. 7
Volleyball
(Team
Event)
Petitioner No. 8
Handball
(Team
Event)
Petitioner No. 9
MSC 3000m
(Individual
Event)
10.
19th National Championship- 2025 held at Prakash
Sports Academy, Haridwar, Uttrakhand on 27th-28th
December 2025 organized by ‘National Sports
Federation of India’.
19th National Championship- 2025 held at Prakash
Sports Academy, Haridwar, Uttrakhand on 27th-28th
December 2025 organized by ‘National Sports
Federation of India’.
17th Youth Games National Championship - 2025
held at Pedem Sports Complex, Mapusa, Goa in June
2025 organized by FIT INDIA ‘Youth Games
Development Federation-Goa’.
19th National Championship- 2025 held at Prakash
Sports Academy, Haridwar, Uttrakhand on 27th-28th
December 2025 organized by ‘National Sports
Federation of India’.
19th National Championship- 2025 held at Prakash
Sports Academy, Haridwar, Uttrakhand on 27th-28th
December 2025 organized by ‘National Sports
Federation of India’.
The Petitioners are essentially aggrieved by non-issuance of
admit cards to them on account of the sports certificates produced by
them not meeting the eligibility criteria in terms of the respective
advertisement.
11.
Undisputedly, selection process is guided by the terms
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
18:54:50
W.P.(C) 17736/2025 & W.P.(C) 3642/2026
encapsulated in the advertisement. Clause 7 of Advertisement dated
10.10.2025, which is also incorporated in Advertisement dated
19.12.2025, stipulated that candidates will be issued admit cards for
recruitment process if their documents are found in order on scrutiny.
12.
The order of preference as encapsulated in Clause 4(b)(iii) of
the advertisement dated 10.10.2025 reads as under:
13.
The order of preference as encapsulated in Clause 4(b)(iii) of
the advertisement dated 19.12.2025 reads as under:
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
18:54:50
W.P.(C) 17736/2025 & W.P.(C) 3642/2026
14.
The Respondents have relied on the aforesaid clauses to contest
that for a candidate to be eligible for recruitment, the games ought to
be conducted by a Sports Association/Federation which is duly
affiliated/ recognised by Indian Olympic Association or by Ministry
of Youth Affairs and Sports as National Sports Federation. As
submitted by the learned counsel for the Respondents, the certificates
submitted by the Petitioners failed to meet the prescribed criteria as
their certificates have not been issued by Federations as the same are
neither recognised by the Ministry of Youth Affairs and Sports as
National Sports Federation nor recognised by/ affiliated member of
Indian Olympic Association.
15.
Pertinently, the record indicates that on 21.11.2025 in W.P.(C)
17736/2025, this Court had directed the Respondents to verify from
the Organisers as to whether the certificates of the concerned
Petitioners relate to championships which satisfy the advertised
criteria. Pursuant to the same, letter dated 10.12.2025 was issued to
Youth Games Development Federation (through its Founder and
General Secretary namely Mr. Jeetendra Gurjar) in this respect. By
way of reply dated 11.12.2025, Youth Games Development
Federation clarified that the Sports Certificate issued under FIT IndiaYouth Games National Championship is not recognised by the
aforesaid organisations.
16.
A similar letter was addressed to National Sports Federation of
India (through its President) on 10.12.2025. By reply dated
10.12.2025, it was clarified that the said organisation is not affiliated
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
18:54:50
W.P.(C) 17736/2025 & W.P.(C) 3642/2026
with the Indian Olympic Association and also not recognised by the
Ministry of Youth Affairs & Sports. It was further stated that National
Sports Federation of India does not endorse use of the certificates for
any selection criteria where Government recognised sports are
mandatory.
17.
It is however the case of the Petitioners that the stand of the
Respondents is wholly arbitrary as the Respondents have selected
several other candidates who possess similar certificates issued by the
same sports organizations in previous recruitment cycles.
18.
The controversy thus presented by the Petitioners before this
Court is not whether the certificates per se conformed to the
conditions stipulated in the criteria but that several similarly situated
candidates with similar certificates were shortlisted and appointed in
the previous recruitment cycle.
19.
In that regard, it is apposite to mention that Article 14 of the
Constitution of India cannot be invoked to perpetuate an irregularity.
It has consistently been held that if a benefit has erroneously been
conferred, others cannot claim the same benefit as a matter of right.
The principle of equality as embodied under Article 14 of the
Constitution of India does not provide for a multiplication of errors.
20.
In the present case, as argued on behalf of the Respondents, the
ineligibility of the Petitioners finds its genesis from the terms of the
advertisement. The argument of parity thus though appears worthy in
the first blush cannot stand closer scrutiny.
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
18:54:50
W.P.(C) 17736/2025 & W.P.(C) 3642/2026
21.
While this Court cannot ascertain at this stage if similarly
situated candidates were granted appointments in the previous
recruitment process, even if this Court were to take the argument of
the Petitioners at face value and consider it at the highest that certain
candidates
with
deficient
applications
were
appointed, such
appointments, if contrary to the terms of advertisement, would be
improper.
22.
In that regard, the learned CGSC has fairly stated that the
Respondents are examining the veracity of such instances, if any,
relating to previous recruitments as claimed by the Petitioners. It has
also been assured that should any such inadvertent or erroneous
appointment be found in the previous recruitment process, appropriate
action, wherever warranted, would be strictly taken in accordance with
law.
23.
On such a conspectus of facts, if this Court were to accede to
the prayer made by the Petitioners, it would be akin to countenancing
a course of action that is at odds with Article 14 of the Constitution of
India.
24.
In such circumstances, the Petitioners, in the opinion of this
Court, cannot successfully invoke Article 14 of the Constitution of
India to seek extension of parity for an alleged irregular benefit.
25.
For the reasons as stated above, the present writ petitions are
devoid of merit and are accordingly dismissed.
26.
Pending applications also stand disposed of.
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
18:54:50
W.P.(C) 17736/2025 & W.P.(C) 3642/2026
27.
A photocopy of the Order passed today be kept in the connected
matter.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J
MAY 02, 2026
‘KDK’
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
18:54:50
W.P.(C) 17736/2025 & W.P.(C) 3642/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review