Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on:29th July, 2026
%
Pronounced on:21stAugust,2026
#
CNR No. DLHC011650642010
W.P.(C) 7603/2010
+
DEEPAK KHULLAR
S/o Sh. H.P. Khullar
R/o D-289, Anand Vihar,
Delhi-110092
Through:
.... Petitioner
Mr. Akash Chatterjee, Advocate.
versus
1.
2.
3.
BSES YAMUNA POWER LTD.
(now BSES RAJDHANI POWER LTD.)
BSES Bhawan, Nehru Place,
New Delhi, through its CEO
..... Respondent No. 1
GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI
5, Sham Nath Marg, Delhi,
through its Standing Counsel
.....Respondent No. 2
DVB EMPLOYEE'S TERMINAL BENEFIT
FUND TRUST 2002
Rajghat Power House,
New Delhi
.....Respondent No. 3
Through:
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:05:06
W.P.(C) 7603/2010
Mr. Sandeep Prabhakar, Sr. Advocate
with Mr. Anupam Varma, Mr. Nikhil
Sharma and Ms. S. Akshata,
Advocates for R-1/ BSES.
Mrs. Avnish Ahlawat, Standing
Counsel with Mr. Nitesh Kumar
Singh, Ms. Aliza Alam and Mr.
Mohnish Sehrawat, Advocates for R2 and R-3.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
JUDGMENT
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
The Petition under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India
has been filed on behalf of the Petitioner, Sh. Deepak Khullar, seeking a
Writ of Mandamus directing the Respondent No. 1, BSES Yamuna Power
Ltd. (now described as BSES Rajdhani Power Ltd.), to release pension in his
favour with effect from 01.01.2004, along with arrears and interest, and to
extend the consequential benefit of commutation. A further prayer has been
made for grant of the five-year weightage under Rule 48B of the Central
Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972 (hereinafter referred to as „CCS
Pension Rules‟), continuing monthly pension and costs.
2.
Briefly stated, the Petitioner, Deepak Khullar, was appointed as an
Engineer with the erstwhile Delhi Vidyut Board (hereinafter referred to as
„DVB‟), on 08.06.1987 and was allotted Employee No. 30221. His date of
birth is 01.05.1962. He was residing at D-289, Anand Vihar, Delhi-110092,
though in the subsequent record, his address is shown as D-335, First Floor,
Anand Vihar, Delhi-110092.
3.
At the outset, it is noticed that the Memo of Parties describes the
Respondent No. 1 as "BSES Rajdhani Power Ltd.", whereas the body of the
Writ Petition, the Office Order No. HR/BYPL/2003-04/SVRS-001 dated
18.12.2003 and the entire correspondence on record relate to BSES
Yamuna Power Ltd. The BSES Rajdhani Power Ltd. and BSES Yamuna
Power Ltd. are two distinct distribution licensees which came into existence
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:05:06
W.P.(C) 7603/2010
upon the unbundling of the DVB with effect from 01.07.2002; neither
succeeded the other. The description in the Memo of Parties is evidently an
inadvertent error, and the cause title is read as referring to BSES Yamuna
Power Ltd.
4.
In the early 2000s, the Government of the National Capital Territory
of Delhi (hereinafter referred to as „GNCTD‟) decided to reorganise the
generation, transmission and distribution of electricity in Delhi. The DVB
was thereafter, unbundled and its assets, liabilities, activities and personnel
were transferred to the successor entities. The transfer was made effective
from 01.07.2002 and the Petitioner stood transferred to the Respondent No.
1 as a transferred employee.
5.
The protection assured to the employees during the said process was
not merely an administrative assurance. The Tripartite Agreements dated
28.10.2000 and 09.11.2000, the latter being with the Delhi Vidyut Board
Junior Engineers Association, have been placed on record as Annexure R-4.
They record, in substance, that there would be no retrenchment on account
of restructuring, that the status and service conditions of the existing
employees would not change, and that pension, retirement benefits,
provident fund, leave encashment, gratuity and other terminal benefits
would continue to be secured through the successor entities and the Trust,
under the guarantee of the GNCTD.
6.
Pursuant to the restructuring arrangements, the DVB Employee‟s
Terminal Benefit Fund Trust, 2002 (hereinafter referred to as „the Trust‟)
was constituted vide Trust Deed dated 26.03.2002, a copy of which is
Annexure R-5. The corpus was stated to be Rs. 1,329 crores, contributed for
securing the pensionary and terminal liabilities of the existing pensioners
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:05:06
W.P.(C) 7603/2010
and the transferred employees. The Trust and the Respondent No. 1 have,
however, placed different constructions on the extent to which the said fund
could be utilised for employees who separated under a special scheme. That
dispute inter se the Respondents is material only to the extent, that it cannot
prejudice an employee who acted upon the Scheme offered by the
Respondent No. 1.
7.
The Delhi Electricity Reform (Transfer Scheme) Rules, 2001, also
protected the continuity of service and required the transferee to stand in the
place of the DVB in relation to statutory and employment-related schemes,
including pension, gratuity and other terminal benefits. Rule 6(9)
contemplated appropriate arrangements for funding terminal benefits to the
extent they remained unfunded on the date of transfer. The record thus,
discloses a deliberate legislative as well as contractual effort to preserve the
service-related benefits of the employees notwithstanding the change in the
employing entity.
8.
On 18.12.2003, the Respondent No. 1 issued Office Order No.
HR/BYPL/2003-04/SVRS-001
introducing
the
Special
Voluntary
Retirement Scheme, 2003 (hereinafter referred to as „SVRS-2003‟). The
Scheme was not an ordinary request for voluntary retirement under Rule
48A. It was a time-bound package offered by the successor Distribution
Company to its regular transferred employees and was to operate on the
terms set out in the Office Order, which is Annexure P-1.
9.
Clause 1.1 of SVRS-2003 is the starting point. It provides that
“the Scheme shall apply to all the regular employees of BYPL, who
have completed 10 years of service from the date of joining Delhi Vidyut
Board (DVB) or have attained the age of 40 years as on the date of this
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:05:06
W.P.(C) 7603/2010
Office Order.” Clause 1.2 permitted an eligible employee to seek special
voluntary retirement by making a written request to the Competent
Authority within the prescribed period. The express eligibility threshold
was, therefore, ten years of service from joining the DVB or forty years of
age, and not twenty years of qualifying service as contemplated under Rule
48A.
10.
Clauses 1.3.1 and 1.3.2 excluded employees serving under
uncompleted bonds and persons who were not regular employees.
Clause 5.1 required three months‟ notice but expressly preserved the right
of the Company to relieve an employee even from the date of acceptance.
Clause 7.1 kept the Scheme open from 22.12.2003 at 09:30 a.m. till
31.12.2003 at 05:00 p.m., while Clause 9.1 required an eligible employee to
apply in the prescribed format during the said period. These provisions
disclose a self-contained mechanism for a special exit, with acceptance
remaining in the hands of the Competent Authority.
11.
The financial inducement was equally significant. Clause 2.1.1
offered compensation of sixty days‟ salary, comprising basic pay and
dearness allowance as applicable on 31.12.2003, for each completed year of
service, subject to the alternative computation in Clause 2.1.2 and the
applicable ceiling. Clause 2.1.3 contemplated enhancement depending upon
the number of optees. Clause 3.1 separately provided an early bird incentive
of Rs. 10,000/- for an Application made on 22.12.2003 and Rs. 5,000/- for
an Application made on 23.12.2003. The Scheme was thus, plainly designed
to induce an early and irrevocable separation.
12.
Clause 4.1 grouped the other retirement benefits. It provided for
earned leave encashment under Clause 4.1.1; gratuity under Clause 4.1.4;
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:05:06
W.P.(C) 7603/2010
pension under Clause 4.1.5; medical benefits under Clause 4.1.6 and any
other benefit applicable on retirement under Clause 4.1.7. Clause 4.1.5 used
clear language, namely, “Pension as per rules payable by DVB Pension
Trust.” Pension was, therefore, placed in the list of benefits available upon
an accepted retirement; it was not expressed as a benefit available only after
satisfaction of a further twenty-year condition.
13.
Clause 4.2 provided that “all above Terminal benefits under para 4.1
above except 4.1.2, 4.1.3 and 4.1.7 shall be paid by the Pension Trust, which
the employee will have to directly claim from the Trust.” The same Clause
assigned the remaining payments to BYPL. The allocation of the paying
Agency does not dilute the benefit promised under Clause 4.1.5. read with
Clause 4.2; the Scheme assured pension and specified the mechanism by
which it was to be claimed; it did not authorise the Respondent No. 1 to
deny the benefit altogether by invoking an eligibility condition not stated in
SVRS-2003.
14.
The Petitioner fulfilled the stated conditions. He applied for
retirement under SVRS-2003 on 31.12.2003, within the validity period. His
Application was accepted by the Competent Authority on the same date, and
the acceptance Order released him from the service of the Respondent No. 1
w.e.f. 31.12.2003, after handing over charge. The relationship of
employment thus came to an end not by resignation or abandonment, but by
an accepted separation under the very Scheme which contained the pension
promise.
15.
The Statement of Terminal Benefits placed on record, shows the date
of appointment of the Petitioner as 08.06.1987, the date of separation as
31.12.2003 and the length of qualifying service, including weightage if any,
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:05:06
W.P.(C) 7603/2010
as 16 years. It records his average basic pay for the last ten months as Rs.
10,525/- and his last basic pay drawn as Rs. 10,700/-. Significantly, the
columns for pension before commutation, amount of pension commuted and
reduced monthly pension after commutation, record Rs. 0.00. The document
is contemporaneous evidence that pension and commutation were not paid at
all.
16.
The payments that were made, did not cure the said omission. The
record discloses payment of ex-gratia of Rs. 5,88,082/-, Early Bird Incentive
of Rs. 7,500/-, gratuity of Rs. 1,36,104/-, leave encashment of Rs. 1,67,295/, service gratuity of Rs. 2,13,896/-, interest at 8% on leave encashment and
gratuity of Rs. 1,01,133/- and interest on service gratuity of Rs. 99,818/-.
These figures are separately identified in the Counter-Affidavit of the
Respondent No. 1. None of them is described as arrears of pension or
commuted pension.
17.
The terminal dues were ultimately paid on 31.03.2008 pursuant to the
Orders dated 02.07.2007, 08.10.2007 and 25.01.2008 passed in W.P.(C)
5198-99/2005, the Judgment dated 02.07.2007 being reported as 142 (2007)
DLT 65. The Order dated 25.01.2008 concerned the interim disbursement of
gratuity, leave encashment and commutation wherever applicable. The
Petitioner was accordingly, paid the amounts referred to above, but no
pension was released and no commutation could be made, as the pension
column continued to show nil.
18.
It is pertinent to advert to the correspondence immediately preceding
the exercise of option by the Petitioner. Vide letter No. BSES/HR/200304/2/62 dated 19.12.2003, marked as Annexure P-4 and Annexure R-6, the
Respondent No. 1 informed the Trust of SVRS-2003 and stated that gratuity,
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:05:06
W.P.(C) 7603/2010
pension and other benefits were payable by the Trust, as per the Rules
applicable to retiring employees. The Letter then set out Rule 48B and
sought confirmation that the qualifying service could be increased by a
period not exceeding five years, subject to the ceiling of thirty-three years
and the condition that the employee was not taken beyond the date of
superannuation.
19.
The Trust replied vide letter No. SECY/ETBF/104 dated 29.12.2003,
marked as Annexure R-7. The confirmation was in these terms: "It is
confirmed that five-year weightage could be given to all those employees
who are opting for SVRS under the above-mentioned orders and are eligible
under the provision of Rule 48-B of C.C.S. Pension Rules." This was not a
post-litigation explanation. It was the response of the Trust to the query of
the employer, made while the employees were still deciding whether to
leave service.
20.
The Respondent No. 1 thereafter issued Circular No. HR/2003-
04/BYPL/SVRS/C-001 dated 29.12.2003, marked as Annexure P-3 and
Annexure R-8. The Circular expressly referred to the Office Order dated
18.12.2003, recorded that clarification had been sought from DVB ETBF
2002 regarding the five-year weightage under Rule 48-B, and reproduced
the confirmation of the Trust verbatim "for benefit of all". It was distributed
to the management, finance, human resources and field offices and on all
Notice Boards. It is difficult to treat such a document as irrelevant to the
meaning on which the employees were invited to act.
21.
The chronology is significant. The Respondent No. 1 sought the
clarification on 19.12.2003; the Trust confirmed the availability of
weightage on 29.12.2003; the Respondent No. 1 circulated that
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:05:06
W.P.(C) 7603/2010
confirmation on the same date; and the Petitioner submitted his
Application on 31.12.2003.
22.
Pension was not released after the separation of the Petitioner. He
gave his Representations dated 06.12.2004, 28.07.2005, 25.02.2006 and
08.05.2006, placed on record as Annexure P-5 (Colly), wherein he referred
to the ten-year eligibility in SVRS-2003, the Rule 48-B correspondence,
the confirmation of the Trust and the practice followed by NDPL. The
formal rejection was communicated vide letter No. DM(HR)CSO/200506/1798 dated 29.08.2005, Annexure P-6, on the stated ground that he
had not rendered twenty years of service.
23.
The rejection was reiterated vide Letter dated 12.05.2006 written by
Mr. Udit Mehta, Deputy Manager (HR). The said letter acknowledged that
employees who had completed ten years from joining the DVB or had
attained forty years of age were eligible to apply, but drew a distinction
between eligibility to apply and entitlement to pension. It was further stated
that the five-year weightage applied only to employees having twenty years
of qualifying service and that the Petitioner was, therefore, ineligible.
24.
The question which falls for consideration is whether the said post-
separation construction can displace the Scheme and the contemporaneous
correspondence of the Respondents themselves.
25.
It is submitted on behalf of the Petitioner that Clause 4.1.5 is an
express term of the package which became enforceable when the Petitioner
accepted SVRS-2003, surrendered his continuing employment and was
released thereunder. The Respondent No. 1 cannot rely upon the Scheme to
secure the exit of the Petitioner and thereafter, disown the pensionary benefit
which formed part of the consideration for that exit. The words “as per
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:05:06
W.P.(C) 7603/2010
rules”, regulate the manner of computation and payment; they do not
introduce a further eligibility condition, which the Scheme itself does not
state.
26.
It is further submitted that Rule 49(2)(b) provides for proportionate
pension where a Government servant retires with qualifying service of not
less than ten years, but less than the full qualifying service. It is submitted
that SVRS-2003 supplies the entitlement, and Rule 49(2)(b), read with the
Scheme, supplies a rational and lawful basis for quantifying it. Rule 48B, it
is submitted, then permits addition of upto five years, subject to the
prescribed ceiling and the date of superannuation.
27.
It is further asserted that, if the five-year weightage were found
applicable, the Petitioner's qualifying service would exceed twenty years.
The said contention, however, is considered separately while examining the
applicability of Rule 48-B.
28.
The Petitioner has also placed the matter in a broader constitutional
context. It is submitted that pension is not a bounty or charity, but is
deferred remuneration and a right earned through service. Reliance is placed
on D.S. Nakara vs. Union of India, (1983) 1 SCC 305, and on Articles 14, 16
and 21 of the Constitution of India.
29.
It is further submitted that ex-gratia was compensation for premature
separation, whereas gratuity, leave encashment, service gratuity and pension
answer distinct fields; payment of one cannot be treated as an implied
surrender of the other.
30.
The Respondent No. 1, in its Counter-Affidavit, has submitted that
the Petitioner had only about sixteen to sixteen and a half years of service
and could not have retired under Rule 48A, which requires twenty years of
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:05:06
W.P.(C) 7603/2010
qualifying service. Rule 48B, according to the Respondent No. 1, is merely
an adjunct to Rule 48A and cannot be pressed into service to create the
eligibility, which is absent at the threshold. Reliance is placed on Bank of
India vs. K. Mohandas, (2009) 5 SCC 313.
31.
It is further submitted that Clause 4.1.5 speaks of “pension as per
rules” and that the Trust is the body responsible for payment. It is contended
that Rule 49 is quantificatory in character and cannot itself confer eligibility.
Reliance is also placed on the fact that the Petitioner has received ex-gratia,
the Early Bird Incentive, gratuity, leave encashment, service gratuity and
interest, and the claim for pension is characterised as an impermissible dual
benefit. The delay in approaching this Court, the earlier VRS litigation and
the Orders of the Apex Court in the proceedings arising therefrom, are also
relied upon, in opposition.
32.
The Respondent No. 1 has further relied upon North Delhi Power Ltd.
vs. Govt. of NCT of Delhi, 142 (2007) DLT 65, to submit that the special
schemes were contractual and that any liability for a benefit outside the
ordinary Pension Rules, could not be imposed upon the Trust. Reference is
also made to Govt. of Delhi vs. North Delhi Power Ltd., 2015 SCC OnLine
Del 11559, and to the proposition that Rule 49 does not dispense with the
qualifying conditions for ordinary voluntary retirement. The submission, in
substance, is that the Petitioner cannot use the Scheme and Rule 48B to
rewrite the CCS Pension Rules.
33.
In Rejoinder, the Petitioner has disputed that he waived any accrued
right, by accepting the payments. It is pointed out that the service gratuity
was not stated in SVRS-2003 to be a substitute for pension; that he was
never told that pension would be unavailable, and that the Respondents
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:05:06
W.P.(C) 7603/2010
cannot take advantage of their own delayed payment of terminal dues. It is
reiterated that any dispute between the Respondent No. 1 and the Trust over
reimbursement or funding, is an inter se dispute and cannot be converted
into a defence against the claim of the employee.
34.
The Judgment dated 23.05.2023 of the Coordinate Bench of this
Court in Kewal Krishan & Ors. vs. Delhi Vidyut Board & Anr., W.P.(C)
14448/2006, was assailed in LPA No. 575/2023, titled BSES Rajdhani
Power Ltd. vs. Kewal Krishan & Ors., wherein its operation came to be
stayed on 05.09.2023. The Appeal has since been decided vide Judgment
dated 24.12.2025, whereby the Division Bench affirmed the entitlement of
the SVRS-2003 optees to pension while modifying the directions as to
quantum, liability and costs; and the Review preferred thereagainst stands
dismissed vide Judgment dated 10.07.2026. The interim Order has
consequently worked itself out.
Submissions heard and the record perused.
35.
The case of the Petitioner is that he was a regular employee; he had
joined the DVB on 08.06.1987 and had therefore completed well over ten
years of service as on 18.12.2003; and he was also over forty years of age,
his date of birth being 01.05.1962. He applied within the window prescribed
by Clause 7.1, his Application was accepted on 31.12.2003, and he was
released with effect from that date.
36.
The Statement of Terminal Benefits records his qualifying service
as sixteen years, which is in excess of ten years and less than twenty. He
thereby, satisfied the only eligibility conditions stated in Clause 1.1 and
acquired the benefit listed in Clause 4.1.5.
37.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:05:06
The Scheme needs to be read as a whole. Clause 1.1 identifies the
W.P.(C) 7603/2010
employees whom the employer invited to seek the special retirement; Clause
4.1.5 identifies pension as one of the benefits of an accepted retirement; and
Clause 4.2 identifies the Trust as the paying agency. The words "as per
rules" naturally refer to the manner in which pension is calculated,
sanctioned and paid. They cannot be converted into a concealed condition
that an employee must first satisfy the twenty-year threshold of a different
Rule under which he did not retire.
38.
That construction is not res integra. The distinction between a special
voluntary retirement scheme, framed as a self-contained package to induce
an early exit, and ordinary voluntary retirement governed by the general
pension provisions, has engaged the Apex Court on more than one occasion.
The same approach has been adopted by the Apex Court while construing
comparable special voluntary retirement schemes.
39.
The sole question for determination in the present Writ Petition is
whether the Petitioner, who was released from service under SVRS-2003
upon completion of more than ten but less than twenty years of qualifying
service, is entitled to pension in terms of Clause 4.1.5 of the said Scheme, or
whether the expression "as per rules" occurring therein imports the twentyyear threshold of Rule 48-A of the CCS Pension Rules so as to deny him the
benefit altogether.
40.
The controversy falls for determination principally on the Scheme, the
statutory framework, the correspondence between the Respondent No. 1 and
the Trust, the Statement of Terminal Benefits, the rejection letters and the
authorities placed before this Court.
41.
In the case of National Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Kirpal Singh, (2014) 5
SCC 189, the Apex Court distinguished a special voluntary retirement
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:05:06
W.P.(C) 7603/2010
scheme from ordinary voluntary retirement under a general pension
provision requiring twenty years of qualifying service. It was observed that a
provision for payment of pension is a beneficial provision, which ought to
receive a liberal interpretation so as to serve the object underlying such a
scheme.
42.
This question as raised in the present Petition, has been answered in
the Judgment in Kewal Krishan & Ors. vs. Delhi Vidyut Board & Anr.,
W.P.(C) 14448/2006, decided on 23.05.2023, Neutral Citation No. 2023:
DHC:3552, wherein the Coordinate Bench of this Court, considered SVRS2003 and held that employees who had completed ten years of service and
had been released thereunder could not be denied pension on the ground that
they had not completed twenty years of qualifying service under Rule 48-A.
43.
Likewise, in Assistant General Manager vs. Radhey Shyam Pandey,
(2020) 6 SCC 438, a three-Judge Bench of the Apex Court held that a
voluntary retirement scheme framed pursuant to a Government-approved
exercise, under which pension was extended as a special measure upon a
shorter period of service, was binding upon the employer, which could not
resile therefrom by taking shelter under its own Pension Rules prescribing a
longer qualifying period which it had not amended.
44.
That Judgment was assailed in LPA No. 575/2023, which was decided
by the Division Bench on 24.12.2025. The Scheme there considered
identical provisions which fall for consideration in the present Petition.
45.
The Division Bench held that "qualifying service", as defined in Rule
3(q) of the CCS Pension Rules, means service rendered while on duty, and
is not confined to service rendered after an employee became a member of
the Trust Fund. It was observed that the employees had been permitted to
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:05:06
W.P.(C) 7603/2010
retire voluntarily on completion of ten years of service from the date of
joining the Board, which period would otherwise have been twenty years,
and that there was accordingly no reason why the service rendered by them,
admittedly in excess of ten years, should not constitute qualifying service
under Rule 3(q).
46.
It was further held that a provision of general application must
concede to a special provision, and that SVRS-2003, which permitted
voluntary retirement on completion of ten years of service or on attainment
of forty years of age as on 18.12.2003, prevails over Rules 48-A and 49 of
the CCS Pension Rules, which govern employees not covered by the
Scheme.
47.
Upon a conjoint reading of Clauses 1.1, 1.2 and 4 of SVRS-2003 with
Rules 3(q), 48-A, 48-B and 49, the Division Bench concluded employees
who had completed between ten and twenty years of service reckoned from
the date of joining the Board are entitled to proportionate pension.
48.
As to liability, the Division Bench held that the liability to pay
pension for the period upto the date on which the employee attains sixty
years of age, shall be on the SVRS RTBF, 2004, which shall be reimbursed
by the DVB Pension Trust, and that the remaining part of the pension shall
be paid by the appropriate authority under the CCS Pension Rules or the
applicable law. As to interest, the direction of the learned Single Judge for
payment of interest at twelve per cent per annum was not sustained, and in
its place the costs were enhanced to Rs. 50,000/- payable to each of the writ
petitioners, expressly by way of recompense for the loss of interest.
49.
The decision in Bank of India vs. K. Mohandas, (2009) 5 SCC 313,
arose under statutory Service Regulations governing bank officers, and does
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:05:06
W.P.(C) 7603/2010
not detract from the position settled by the Division Bench in respect of
SVRS-2003. The facts involved therein are distinguishable.
50.
The Petitioner has additionally pressed for the benefit of the five-
year weightage under Rule 48-B, relying upon the letter dated 19.12.2003,
the confirmation dated 29.12.2003 of the Trust and the Circular of even date.
The said correspondence is relevant, and has been noticed hereinabove, as
demonstrating the understanding on which the employees were invited to
act. However, Rule 48-B, on its own terms, operates in respect of a
Government servant retiring under Rule 48(1)(a) or Rule 48-A of the
CCS Pension Rules, Clause (k) of Rule 56 of the Fundamental Rules or
Clause (i) of Article 459 of the Civil Service Regulations; and the
confirmation of the Trust dated 29.12.2003 was itself in terms conditional,
being confined to employees "eligible under the provision of Rule 48-B of
C.C.S. Pension Rules".
51.
It would be neither appropriate nor necessary to travel beyond the
relief so moulded. The entitlement of the Petitioner arises from Clause 4.1.5
of SVRS-2003, and is accordingly held to be to proportionate pension,
computed in accordance with Rule 49(2)(b) of the CCS Pension Rules
upon the qualifying service reckoned in terms of Rule 3(q).
52.
The plea of dual benefits, also fails to persuade. Ex-gratia under
Clause 2.1 was the consideration for the premature separation, and the early
bird amount was a separate inducement under Clause 3.1. Gratuity and leave
encashment are distinct terminal benefits, while service gratuity was paid as
an interim or consequential amount in the terminal dues exercise. Pension
under Clause 4.1.5 is a recurring benefit founded on service. SVRS-2003
placed these benefits in separate Clauses and contains no provision making
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:05:06
W.P.(C) 7603/2010
pension conditional upon surrender or repayment of the other benefits. The
receipt of the said amounts by the Petitioner is, therefore, no answer to the
claim for pension. It may, however, be noticed that the Petitioner has
himself stated in his Rejoinder that he is willing to have any amount found
to have been paid to him without authority adjusted against his pensionary
arrears. Liberty is accordingly reserved to the paying Agency to make such
adjustment in accordance with law.
53.
The allocation of liability inter se the Respondents cannot be placed
at the door of the Petitioner, and in any event now stands governed by the
Judgment dated 24.12.2025. The Trust was created with a substantial corpus
for pension and terminal liabilities. If the Trust considers that the particular
payment must ultimately be funded by the Respondent No. 1 or through an
additional contribution, that is an inter se matter to be worked out in
accordance with the governing arrangements and the directions of the
Division Bench. It cannot be pressed into service to deny the Petitioner the
pension which the Respondent No. 1 offered, upon which it accepted his
separation, and which it represented would be payable through the Trust.
54.
The objection of delay and laches is equally unpersuasive. The
Petitioner pursued the matter through Representations, and the denial was
repeated in the year 2006. Pension is a recurring service-related benefit and
its non-payment, gives rise to a continuing grievance. In any event, the
Petition remained pending after the pleadings stood completed in the year
2013, for reasons not attributable to the Petitioner, and the objection of
laches is, in these circumstances, without substance.
55.
In the considered opinion of this Court, the rejection communicated
vide letter No. DM(HR)CSO/2005-06/1798 dated 29.08.2005, and reiterated
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:05:06
W.P.(C) 7603/2010
vide letter dated 12.05.2006, proceeded upon a legally erroneous premise. It
treated Rule 48-A as the exclusive source of pension and denied the benefit
expressly promised under Clause 4.1.5 by importing a twenty-year threshold
which SVRS-2003 was designed to render unnecessary for those opting out.
Such a construction preserves that part of the package which is favourable to
the employer and discards that part which was acted upon by the employee.
It is contrary to SVRS-2003, and stands negatived by the Judgment in
Kewal Krishan & Ors. (supra).
Conclusion and Relief:
56.
The Writ Petition is accordingly, allowed. The letter No.
DM(HR)CSO/2005-06/1798 dated 29.08.2005 and the further rejection
communicated vide letter dated 12.05.2006, are set aside. The Petitioner is
held entitled to proportionate pension under Clause 4.1.5 of SVRS-2003
read with Rule 49(2)(b) of the CCS Pension Rules, with effect from
01.01.2004, being the date following his release from service.
57.
The qualifying service of the Petitioner shall be reckoned in terms of
Rule 3(q) upon the service rendered by him from 08.06.1987 until
31.12.2003. The pension shall be computed upon the average emoluments of
Rs. 10,525/- recorded in the Statement of Terminal Benefits, subject to
verification of the precise service computation and the applicable Rules.
58.
The liability to pay pension for the period upto the date on which the
Petitioner attained the age of sixty years, i.e. 30.04.2022, shall be on the
SVRS Retirees' Terminal Benefit Fund, 2004, which shall be reimbursed
by the Respondent No. 3/DVB Employee's Terminal Benefit Fund Trust,
2002; and the pension for the period thereafter, shall be paid by the
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:05:06
W.P.(C) 7603/2010
appropriate authority in accordance with the CCS Pension Rules or the
applicable law. The Respondent No. 1 shall forthwith furnish the complete
service particulars of the Petitioner to the paying Agency and shall render all
assistance necessary for computation and release.
59.
A complete due-and-drawn statement setting out the monthly pension
and the arrears from 01.01.2004 shall be prepared and furnished to the
Petitioner. Commutation of pension, if and when applied for by the
Petitioner, shall be considered and dealt with in accordance with the
Central Civil Services (Commutation of Pension) Rules, 1981.
60.
Further, in terms of the Judgment in Kewal Krishan & Ors. (supra),
in place of interest on the arrears, the Petitioner shall be paid costs
quantified at Rs. 50,000/-, payable by the Respondent No. 1.
61.
The exercise of computation and disbursement shall be completed
within three months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this
Judgment. The Petitioner shall thereafter, continue to receive monthly
pension in accordance with law.
62.
The Respondents shall be at liberty to work out, inter se, the ultimate
accounting of the amounts payable, but no such exercise shall delay or
diminish the pensionary entitlement of the Petitioner.
63.
The Writ Petition is allowed in the above terms, along with pending
Applications, if any.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
AUGUST 21, 2026/RS
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:05:06
W.P.(C) 7603/2010
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review