Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on
Pronounced on
Uploaded on
#
CNR No. DLHC014792862017
+
FAO 89/2018
DEEP CHAND
Through:
: 07.09.2026
: 15.09.2026
: 15.09.2026
.....Appellant
Mr. N.K. Gupta, Advocate
versus
UNION OF INDIA
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Krishna Kumar Sharma,
SPC with Mr. Bhaskar Bhati,
Mr. Nagender, Mr. Shashwat,
Mr. Rajesh and Mr. Ayushma
S., Advocates
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
JUDGMENT
CM APPL. 9228/2018 (seeking condonation of delay of 103 days in
filing the appeal)
1.
By way of the present application, the applicant/ appellant seeks
condonation of delay of 103 days in filing the appeal.
2.
It is stated that the appellant had suffered grievous injuries in
the train accident in question, resulting in the loss of both his legs and
consequent loss of his employment. The appellant has remained
without any source of livelihood since the accident and is stated to be
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:47:52
FAO 89/2018
dependent upon financial assistance from his relatives for meeting his
basic needs and the educational expenses of his children. It is in the
aforesaid circumstances that the appellant has been unable to arrange
the requisite funds for pursuing the present appeal.
3.
At this stage, it is pertinent to note that in “Mohsina vs. Union of
India”1, a Co-ordinate Bench of this Court condoned a delay of 804
days in filing the appeal, taking into account the weak economic
condition of the appellant/ claimant. Similarly, in “Reshma vs. Union
of India”2, this Court condoned a delay of 598 days in filing the
appeal, keeping in view the beneficial nature of the legislation and the
liberal approach required in such matters.
4.
Considering the peculiar facts and circumstances of the present
caseas well as the beneficial nature of the concerned legislation, this
Court finds that the appellants have been able to show sufficient cause
for the delay in filing the present appeal.
5.
In view of the aforesaid, the application is allowed and the delay
of 103 days in filing the appeal is condoned.
6.
The application is disposed of accordingly.
FAO 89/2018
1.
The present appeal has been filed under Section 23 of the
Railway Claims Tribunal Act, 1987 against the judgment dated
21.04.2017 passed by the Railway Claims Tribunal, Principal Bench,
Delhi (hereinafter referred to as the “Tribunal”) in OA(IIu) 238/2016,
whereby the claim application filed by the appellant seeking
(2017) SCC OnLine Del 10003
(2026) SCC OnLine Del 2704
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:47:52
FAO 89/2018
compensation on account of injuries suffered by him came to be
dismissed.
2.
The brief facts necessary for the adjudication of the present
appeal are that on 24.06.2013, the appellant purchased a general class
railway ticket at Wair Railway Station for travelling to Shahibabad
and boarded TrainNo.64151. As averred in the claim application, the
compartment was heavily crowded and, after the train had started, a
sudden jerk and jostling amongst the passengers caused him to fall
from the moving train. He fell on the railway track and sustained
grievous injuries, resulting in amputation of both his legs below the
knee. He was thereafter taken to Dr.Kailash Hospital, Noida.
3.
The claim, however, came to be rejected principally on two
aspects. First, no railway ticket was recovered from the appellant at the
time of the incident. Second, the appellant stated in cross-examination
that he had reached the station at about 2:30 p.m. and had purchased
the ticket thereafter, whereas the ticket produced by him was shown
through CRIS records to have been issued at 07:42 a.m. on the same
date.
4.
Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the Tribunal
approached the evidence too narrowly. It is submitted that the
appellant had suffered bilateral amputation and the non-recovery of the
ticket immediately after the accident could not, by itself, discredit his
case. It is further submitted that the ticket was subsequently produced
before the Tribunal and its issuance stood verified from the CRIS
record. The contemporaneous railway record itself records that the
appellant had “fallen from Train No.64151”. It is thus submitted that
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:47:52
FAO 89/2018
the material on record, when considered as a whole, establishes both
his status as a bona fide passenger and the occurrence of an “untoward
incident” as defined within the Railways Act, 1989 (hereinafter
referred to as the ”Act”).
5.
Learned counsel for the respondent, on the other hand, submits
that no ticket was recovered from the appellant and that the appellant’s
own statement regarding the time at which he purchased the ticket is
inconsistent with the CRIS record. It is also pointed out that the
medical record refers to injuries sustained while crossing the railway
track. According to the respondent, the appellant has therefore failed
to establish that he was travelling as a bona fide passenger or that his
injuries resulted from an accidental fall from the train.
6.
The first aspect which requires consideration is the appellant’s
status as a bona fide passenger. It is trite law that non-recovery of a
ticket, by itself, is not sufficient to deny the status of a bona fide
passenger where the surrounding circumstances support the claim
(Ref: “Union of India v. Rina Devi”3).The mere fact that no ticket was
recovered from him immediately after the incident cannot conclude the
matter as he subsequently produced the journey ticket before the
Tribunal. The ticket was not merely relied upon by the appellant
without verification, the Tribunal itself called for the CRIS record,
which showed that the ticket had in fact been issued at 07:42 a.m. on
24.06.2013. Thus, while there is a discrepancy in the appellant’s
statement that he purchased the ticket after reaching the station at
about 2:30 p.m., there is independent railway material showing that a
(2019) 3 SCC 572
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:47:52
FAO 89/2018
ticket had been issued to him on the very date of the incident.
7.
The explanation offered on behalf of the appellant for the
discrepancy was that he was nervous while answering questions in
cross-examination and had stated the time incorrectly, and the same
cannot be brushed aside without considering the surrounding
circumstances. The appellant had suffered injuries of such severity that
both his legs were amputated and the fact that the ticket was not
produced or recovered immediately after the incident, therefore,
cannot be viewed in isolation. In these circumstances and in view of
the beneficial nature of the concerned legislation, the discrepancy as to
the time of purchase cannot, by itself, displace the other evidence
showing that the appellant possessed a valid journey ticket for the date
in question.
8.
A similar approach was adopted by this Court in “Sh. Prempal
Singh v. Union of India”4, where it was observed that a passenger
travelling alone cannot be expected to preserve evidence as to the
precise manner in which the journey was undertaken and that such an
expectation is itself unreasonable. The Court observed:
“…it cannot be expected for a passenger in a railway journey, who is
travelling alone, to keep evidence of when, where, how and in whose
presence, he/she undertook the journey… the evidence in favour of
the claimants is that the deceased had a valid passenger ticket…
therefore, the clear inference is that the deceased was in a train…”
9.
Similarly, in“Ravikant&Ors. v. Union of India”5, this Court held
that a claim could not be rejected merely because the ticket had not
2018 SCC OnLine Del 9571
2026 SCC OnLine Del 5775
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:47:52
FAO 89/2018
been mentioned in the panchnama or had been produced subsequently,
when its issuance was otherwise verified. The facts here stand on no
weaker footing. The appellant’s ticket was produced before the
Tribunal and the CRIS record confirms its issuance on the date of the
accident. The appellant, therefore, has established his status as a bona
fide passenger.
10.
The other question is whether the injuries suffered by the
appellant arose out of an “untoward incident”. The appellant’s case has
throughout been that he was travelling in Train No.64151 and fell
from the moving train when the compartment was crowded and there
was a sudden jerk and jostling. This assertion receives material support
from the contemporaneous railway record. The Station Master/Dead
and Injured Register records, on the very date of the occurrence and at
about the relevant time, that a person had “fallen from Train No.64151
UP” and had been “injured at KM No.1389/17-19”. This is not a later
statement prepared for the purpose of the claim petition. It is an
official railway record made in the immediate aftermath of the
occurrence.
11.
The reference in the MLR to the appellant having allegedly
sustained injuries “somewhere near Dhanikaur”, and the subsequent
reference in the discharge summary to poly-trauma “while crossing the
railway track”, do not furnish sufficient basis to discard the
contemporaneous railway record, as none of these records were
documented on the basis of an eye-witness account. The medical
documents record the history as given at the time of treatment, they do
not, in the circumstances of the present case, explain away the specific
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:47:52
FAO 89/2018
entry made by the Station Master recording a fall from Train
No.64151.
12.
At this stage, it is pertinent to take into account, the definition of
an “untoward incident” as defined by Section 123 of the Act, which
reads as under:
“(c)“untoward incident” means—
(1)
(i)
the commission of a terrorist act within the meaning
of sub-section (1) of section (3) of the Terrorist and Disruptive
Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987 (28 of 1987); or
(ii)the making of a violent attack or the commission of robbery or
dacoity; or
(iii)the indulging in rioting, shoot-out or arson ,by any person in or
on any train carrying passengers, or in a waiting hall, cloak room or
reservation or booking office or on any platform or in any other
place within the precincts of a railway station; or
(2)the accidental falling of any passenger from a train carrying
passengers.”
The definition includes the “accidental falling of a passenger
from a train carrying passengers” within the expression “untoward
incident”. Once such an incident is established, Section 124-A fastens
liability upon the Railway on the principle of no-fault liability, subject
to the statutory exceptions.
13.
In the present case, the respondent has relied upon the assertion
that the appellant was standing near the gate and fell from the running
train due to his own negligence. Even assuming that the appellant had
been standing near the gate, that circumstance by itself would not take
the occurrence outside Section 124-A. In Rina Devi (supra), the
Supreme Court has made it clear that negligence or contributory
negligence of the passenger does not, by itself, amount to a “selfinflicted injury” within the meaning of the statutory exception. The
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:47:52
FAO 89/2018
expression “self-inflicted injury” contemplates an intentional act and
cannot be equated with every instance of carelessness or negligence.
14.
The material placed before the Tribunal does not establish that
the appellant intentionally exposed himself to the risk with the object
of causing the injury to himself. On the contrary, the evidence shows
that he suffered catastrophic injuries in an occurrence which the
contemporaneous railway record describes as a “fall from Train
No.64151”. The mere allegation that he was standing near the gate,
therefore, cannot absolve the respondent of its statutory liability.
15.
On a consideration of the record as a whole, this Court is
satisfied that the appellant was travelling as a bona fide passenger and
that he sustained injuries on account of an accidental fall from Train
No.64151 on 24.06.2013. The injuries suffered by him are
undoubtedly serious and fall within the category for which statutory
compensation is payable. The absence of the ticket at the time of the
incident, followed by its subsequent production and verification, and
the discrepancies in the medical history, could not have been treated as
sufficient to reject an otherwise corroborated claim.
16.
Accordingly, the impugned judgment is set aside and the matter
is remanded back to the Tribunal, which is requested to assess the
amount of compensation payable to the appellants in accordance with
law and direct the authorities concerned to disburse the same within
two months from the receipt of a copy of this order. For this purpose,
the matter be listed before the Tribunal at the first instance on
07.10.2026.
17.
The appeal is allowed and disposed of in the above terms.
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:47:52
FAO 89/2018
18.
A copy of this judgment be communicated to the learned
Tribunal.
(MANOJ KUMAR OHRI)
JUDGE
SEPTEMBER 15, 2026
na
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:47:52
FAO 89/2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review