Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:286-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
First Appeal No. 327 of 2023
Debleena Dutta, aged about 32 years, Wife of Suman
Kumar Ruj, Resident of Poddar Para, Near Brahman
Bhawan, Jharna, P.O. & P.S.-Jharia, Dist.-Dhanbad,
Jharkhand.
… Petitioner/ Appellant
Versus
Suman Kumar Ruj, aged about 34 years, Son of Ashwini
Kumar Ruj, Resident of M.C. Road, Raniganj, Paschim
Burdhman, P.O. & P.S. – Raniganj, Dist-West
Burdhman.
… … Respondent/Respondent
------CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SUJIT NARAYAN PRASAD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUN KUMAR RAI
------For the Appellant
: Mr. Sanjay Prasad, Advocate
For the Respondent
: Mr. Abhijeet Kr. Singh, Advocate
Mr. Shashank Kumar, Advocate
Mr. Harsh Chandra, Advocate
---------CAV on 18.12.2025
Pronounced on 07/01/2026
Per Sujit Narayan Prasad, J.
1. The instant appeal under Section 19(1) of the Family Court
Act, 1984 is directed against the judgment dated 19th
September, 2023 and decree signed on 3rd October, 2023
passed
by
the
learned
Additional
Principal
Judge,
Additional Family Court No. II, Dhanbad in Original Suit
No. 914 of 2021, whereby and whereunder, the suit filed by
the petitioner-appellant [wife] for dissolution of marriage by
decree of divorce u/s 13(1)(i-a) of Hindu Marriage Act, 1955
against respondent/husband, has been dismissed.
2. The brief facts of the case leading to filing of the divorce
petition by the appellant-petitioner, as taken note in the
2026:JHHC:286-DB
impugned order and as emanated from the plaint, needs to
be referred herein, which reads as under:
3. The appellant has legally married with the respondent and
their marriage was solemnized on 13-03-2020, at Jhari,
Dhanbad, according to Hindu Rites and Customs. After the
marriage both the appellant and respondent had been living
together as wife and husband at M.C. Road, Raniganj,
Burdwan. It is further stated that at the time of marriage
the father of the petitioner had given Rs.4,75,000/ cash
and ornaments as dowry.
4. It is stated that after one day of marriage when the
petitioner-appellant was sleeping in her bedroom, the
respondent started checking the mobile phone of the
petitioner-appellant and while checking some objectionable
photographs were seen by the respondent-husband saved
in mobile of the petitioner-appellant, which by mistake she
could not remove from the google drive of her mobile. It is
further stated that the objectionable photo was transferred
by
the
respondent
petitioner's/appellant‟s
in
mobile
his
phone
mobile
without
from
her
knowledge.
5. It is further stated that the respondent started threatening
to put that objectionable photos on social media platform
and started assaulting brutally, physically and mentally. In
this way the
respondent blackmailed
the
petitioner-
2026:JHHC:286-DB
appellant for several occasions and forced to have sex.
When the petitioner-appellant opposed it, the respondent
showed that objectionable photos to his parents and family
members.
6. It is further stated that after this incident the petitionerappellant informed her father and complaint against her
husband. In view of this, the father of the petitionerappellant came on 10-05-2020 along with his society
members and tried to persuade the respondent not to do
this kind of torture to the petitioner-appellant trying to
settle the dispute but unfortunately matter was not settled.
7. It is further stated that the respondent-husband used to
abuse the father of the petitioner-appellant by using filthy
language and after that the respondent and his family
members snatched the Stridhan of the petitioner-appellant
and thrown out the petitioner-appellant and her father from
the matrimonial house on 10-05-2020 and while leaving,
the respondent forced her to write a letter in Bangla that
"unfortunately she could accept Suman Kumar Ruj as
husband but there is a cordial relationship between two
families and today on dated 10-05-2020 I am leaving with
my father to Maika and from today we both husband and
wife will live separately and I could not claim anything in
future" and by making such fake letter forcibly from the
petitioner-appellant thrown the petitioner-appellant from
2026:JHHC:286-DB
her matrimonial house along with her father and while
leaving
the
in-laws
house,
the
respondent-husband
threatened the petitioner-wife that if she try to come back
to in-laws house again then the respondent will kill the
petitioner-appellant and thereafter she is living in parental
house since 10-05-2020.
8. On the aforesaid ground, the appellant/wife has made a
prayer to pass an order for dissolution of marriage by way
of a decree of divorce.
9. Before the learned family court, the respondent-husband
appeared and contested the suit by filing the written
statement stating inter alia that it is admitted fact that the
petitioner-appellant and respondent are legally wedded
husband and wife and the marriage of the petitioner with
respondent was solemnized at Raniganj under the district
of Paschim Burdwan and last residing together at Raniganj.
The respondent-husband has flatly denied the allegation
made by the appellant-wife. It is further stated that the
petitioner-appellant admitted that before getting marriage
she was in relation with other boy and it is matter of
surprise that the petitioner-appellant saved unwanted
photograph in her mobile phone after marriage also and
under influence of someone she has filed the above
mentioned suit.
2026:JHHC:286-DB
10. It is stated that the petitioner-appellant is a working lady
who works in private firm at Dhanbad. It is further stated
that the respondent is ready to accept her as wife after even
knowing every past history of her affair and wants to lead
conjugal life with her as husband and wife.
11. On the basis of pleadings available on record, the learned
Additional Family Court, mainly framed the issue for
consideration as to whether the marriage of the petitioner
and respondent is fit to be dissolved on the ground of
cruelty u/s 13(1) (i-a) of Hindu Marriage Act 1955; and
accordingly evidence was adduced on behalf of parties.
12. The learned Additional Principal Judge, Additional Family
Court-II, Dhanbad after appreciating the evidence adduced
on behalf of parties, came to the conclusion that the
petitioner-wife, the appellant herein, has not been able to
prove her case against the respondent-husband even to the
extent of preponderance of probabilities.
13. Accordingly, the suit for decree of divorce preferred by the
appellant wife was dismissed, against which the instant
appeal has been filed.
Submission of the learned counsel for the appellant-wife:
14. It has been contended on behalf of the appellant that the
factual aspect which was available before the learned family
court supported by the evidences adduced on behalf of the
2026:JHHC:286-DB
appellant has not properly been considered and as such,
the judgment impugned is perverse, hence, not sustainable
in the eyes of law.
15. It has been submitted that the issue of cruelty has not been
taken into consideration in the right perspective.
16. Submission has been made that the judgment passed by
learned court below is perverse in the eye of law as the
husband has committed mental as also the physical cruelty
towards
the
appellant
by
continuous
torturing
the
appellant. After marriage, her husband in her absence
checked her mobile and transferred some objectionable
photographs form her mobile and by showing those
photographs used to assault and threaten her to upload the
same on social media. It has been stated that even those
objectionable photographs were made to seen by her inlaws which caused immense mental cruelty as the things
which are in between the husband and wife, now has been
flashed in the family and society.
17. On the strength of said photographs, submission has been
made that time and again her husband, the respondent
herein, used to threaten her to kill and demanded rupees
five lakhs and in case of non-fulfilment of the same
threatened to upload the said photographs on social media.
It has been submitted that for that her in-laws also used to
abuse and insult her.
2026:JHHC:286-DB
18. Submission has been made that the relationship of
husband and wife is on the thread of trust which itself has
been broken and there is no chance of re-union.
19. Learned counsel for the appellant, based upon the aforesaid
grounds, has submitted that the judgment impugned
suffers from perversity, as such, is not sustainable in the
eyes of law.
Submission of the learned counsel for the respondenthusband:
20. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondentwife,
while
defending
the
impugned
judgment,
has
submitted that there is no error in the impugned judgment.
The learned Additional Principal Judge has considered the
issue of cruelty and having come to the conclusion that no
evidence has been adduced to establish the act of cruelty
has dismissed the suit.
21. Submission has been made that after marriage, the
petitioner-wife kept on talking with another person till late
night and when the respondent/husband came to know
about
illicit
relationship
of
petitioner-appellant
with
another person he asked her about the same and then she
admitted
the
truth
and
stated
that
she
is
having
relationship with another person but she stated that she
will not break her previous relationship.
2026:JHHC:286-DB
22. Submission has been made that even he respecting the
relationship of husband and wife, intends to continue with
her.
The
learned
family
court,
after
taking
into
consideration these aspects of the matter, since has found
no material of cruelty and been refused grant the decree of
divorce, the impugned judgment cannot be said to suffer
from an error.
Analysis:
23. This Court has heard the learned counsel for the parties
and gone through the finding recorded by the learned
Family Judge in the impugned judgment.
24. Before entering into merit of the case it needs to refer
herein that on 15th April, 2025 this Court has passed an
order on basis of the submission of the learned counsel for
both the parties by which the instant case was referred for
mediation to JHALSA with a direction to submit the report
within a period of four weeks, for ready reference the order
dated 15th April, 2025 is being quoted as under:
07/Dated: 15th April, 2025
1. In pursuance of the order dated 20.08.2024, by which
notice was issued upon the sole respondent, the sole
respondent has appeared and is being represented by
Mr. Shashank Kumar at the instance of vakalatnama
filed on his behalf.
2. Learned counsel for both the parties have submitted
that there is chance of settlement and as such, the matter
may be sent to JHALSA.
3. Considering the aforesaid submission, let the matter be
sent to JHALSA for conciliation/mediation.
2026:JHHC:286-DB
4. Let the report be submitted within a period of four
weeks.
5. Let this matter be listed on 10.06.2025.
25. Consequently, the Mediation Report was submitted wherein
it has been reported that the mediation between the parties
failed and the dispute between the parties could not be
settled. Accordingly, the matter was heard on merit.
26. Now coming to the merit of the case, the admitted fact
herein is that the suit for divorce has been filed on the
ground of cruelty i.e., by filing an application under Section
13 (1) (i-a) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955
and
accordingly, issues have been framed and decided against
the petitioner-appellant.
27. The evidence has been led on behalf of both the parties. On
behalf of petitioner-wife, the appellant herein two witnesses
namely, Debleena Dutta, the petitioner herself [PW 1]; and
Bhuwan Chandra Dutta [PW 2]. However, no documentary
evidence has been adduced on her behalf. The respondenthusband has also produced and examined altogether two
witnesses,
namely,
D.W.
1-Suman
Kumar
Rui,
the
respondent-husband and D.W. 2-Ashwini Kumar Rui.
However, some documentary evidence has been produced
on his behalf.
28. This Court, in order to appreciate the testimony available
on record, has gone through the testimonies of the
witnesses.
2026:JHHC:286-DB
29. P.W. 1-Debleena Dutta, the petitioner-wife, the appellant
herein, has stated in his examination-in-chief that she
married with respondent on 13-03-2020 as per Hindu rites
and customs at M.C. Road, Raniganj, West Bengal. After
marriage she came to her sasural. After marriage her
husband
checked
her
mobile
and
transferred
some
objectionable photographs from her mobile set without her
knowledge to his mobile. Thereafter, his behaviour got
changed towards her and he started abusing and assaulted
her
also.
By
showing
the
aforesaid
objectionable
photographs he started torturing her and demanded Rs.
five lakh and threatened that if demand is not fulfilled, all
the photographs shall be uploaded in Social media. The
aforesaid photographs were seen to her in-laws thereafter
her in-laws started torturing her. She was locked in the
room and demanded to bring money from her maika.
Whereupon, she informed the matter to her paralyzed
father and he came to her sasural on 10-05-2020. He tried
to persuade her in-laws but her father was abused and
insulted by them. Her all Stridhan was snatched and they
forcibly took her signature on an agreement to save their
skin and on 10-05-2020 she was driven out from her
matrimonial home.
30. In cross-examination, she has stated that she resided in
her Sasural for two months only. She was in relationship
2026:JHHC:286-DB
prior to marriage with one Satyam Bhadani. She does not
remember as to on which date she was abused and beaten
and demanded Rs. five lakh by her in laws. Regarding
cruelty towards her made by her in-laws she does not
inform the matter to police as because he was not allowed
to go outside the house. She did not make any complain in
Thana regarding the incident occurred on 10-05-2020. An
agreement
was
executed
on
10-05-2020
where
her
signature and the signature of her father were taken
forcibly. Her husband wants to keep her but she does not
want to live with him as because she is regularly threatened
by the respondent. In this regard she did not give any
information to Thana [police station]. Prior to marriage she
was doing job in private company. It is not true that she
was not tortured by her husband and he still wants to keep
her.
31. PW-2-Bhuwan Chandra Dutta, is father of the petitioner
who has supported the evidence of PW-1 in examination-inchief.
32. In cross-examination, he has stated that this case was filed
by her daughter for decree of divorce. After 10-15 days of
marriage his daughter made telephone to her that she is
being harassed in her sasural. The mobile of the daughter
was snatched by the respondent and transferred some
photographs from her mobile to his mobile. No money was
2026:JHHC:286-DB
demanded
by
the
respondent
by
saying
that
the
objectionable photograph will be made in public. The
respondent abused him, in this regard she has not made
any complaint. He knows writing and reading. Bangla
Declaration was script dated 10-05-2020 bearing his
signature as well as signature of his daughter. He does not
have knowledge about Satyam. He does not have knowledge
that his daughter has filed a case for decree of divorce.
33. DW-1-Suman Kumar Ruj, is the respondent-husband, who
has stated in his examination-in-chief that he was married
with petitioner with Hindu Rites and customs. After
marriage both husband and wife started to lead conjugal
life in District Raniganj West Burdwan. Petitioner had not
disclosed her previous relationship with one Satayin
Bhadani prior to marriage with him. It is false to say that in
night when petitioner was sleeping her husband transferred
the objectionable photographs from her mobile to his
Mobile. It is false to say that petitioner was abused and by
showing the objectionable photographs he demanded Rs.
Five lakh from her. It is false to say that he threatened the
petitioner to show the objectionable photographs to his
parents, relatives and other members and will defame her.
34. It is also false to say that he had committed sexual
intercourse with petitioner forcibly without her consent. He
has further deposed that after sometime of marriage he
2026:JHHC:286-DB
came to know that petitioner kept on talking late night with
another person and she kept mobile hidden. When he came
to know about the old relationship of petitioner with
another person namely, Satyam Bhadani of Jharia then she
accepted
the
same
and
asked
him
to
continue
in
maintaining her relationship with Satyam Bhadani. He
asked the petitioner to forget Satyam Bhadani and to lead
conjugal life with him but she did not agree and she sent
objectionable photographs with Satyam Bhadani on his
whatsapp. He never misbehaved with the father of the
petitioner. It is false to say that by snatching her
photographs he drove out the petitioner and her father from
his house on 10-05-2020. On 10-05-2020 a declaration
was prepared with the free will of petitioner. In spite of
knowledge of having love affair of petitioner with another
person he is ready to keeps his wife with full dignity and
honour and he is ready to lead conjugal life with her.
35. In cross he has stated that his marriage was performed on
dt. 13-03-2020 at Maliya road, Raniganj. The marriage was
solemnized with consent of both the parties. He used to talk
with his wife on telephone prior marriage. His wife never
disclosed her illicit relation prior to marriage. He has nо
knowledge that prior objectionable photographs were saved
in the mobile set of his wife. After 10-12 days of marriage
his wife went away to her maika as because she did not
2026:JHHC:286-DB
want to live with him. On 21-03-2020 he came to know that
his wife was talking in mid night with another person and
on being asked she admitted her pre relationship.
36. DW-2-Ashwini Kumar Ruj, is father of the respondent who
has supported the evidence of DW-1 in examination-inChief.
37. In cross he has stated that at the time of marriage nothing
was given to respondent on petitioner‟s side. He has no any
knowledge about the love affair of petitioner prior to
marriage. After marriage petitioner resided only two months
in her sasural. His son never tortured to his daughter-inlaw. His son is working in a shop and his monthly income
is Rs. 6-7 thousands. The father of petitioner had come on
10-05-2020 alone. It is not true that they have kicked the
father of petitioner by humiliating him from his house. His
son had gone for bidai of his daughter-in-law, he cannot
say the date and while leaving the house by the petitioner
she herself has written the declaration in which Debleena
Dutta has put her signature and as a witness her father
also put signature.
38. On the basis of the pleading of the parties, the learned
Additional Principal Family Judge had framed issues for
proper determination of the lis, and after due appreciation
of the ocular as well as documentary evidence, the suit filed
by the petitioner-appellant [wife] for dissolution of marriage
2026:JHHC:286-DB
by decree of divorce u/s 13(1)(i-a) of Hindu Marriage Act,
1955 against respondent/husband, has been dismissed,
against which the present appeal has been preferred.
39. It requires to refer herein that since appellate jurisdiction
has been invoked herein, therefore, before entering into
merit of the case, at this juncture it would be purposeful to
discuss the appellate jurisdiction of the High Court.
40. It needs to refer herein that under section 7 of the Family
Courts Act, the Family Court shall have and exercise all the
jurisdiction exercisable by any District Court or any Subordinate Civil Court under any law for the time being in
force in respect of suits and proceedings of the nature
which are described in the explanation to section 7(1).
41. Sub-section (1) to section 19 of the Family Courts Act
provides that an appeal shall lie from every judgment or
order not being an interlocutory order of a Family Court to
the
High
Court
"both
on
facts
and
on
law".
Therefore, section 19 of the Family Courts Act is parallel
to section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the scope of
which has been dealt with by the Hon'ble Apex Court in
series of judgments.
42. The law is well settled that the High Court in a First Appeal
can examine every question of law and fact which arises in
the facts of the case and has powers to affirm, reverse or
modify the judgment under question. In "Jagdish Singh v.
2026:JHHC:286-DB
Madhuri Devi" (2008) 10 SCC 497 the Hon'ble Supreme
Court observed that it is lawful for the High Court acting as
the First Appellate Court to enter into not only questions of
law but questions of fact as well and the appellate Court
therefore can reappraise, reappreciate and review the entire
evidence and can come to its own conclusion. For ready
reference the relevant paragraph of the said judgment is
being quoted as under:
“It is no doubt true that the High Court was exercising
power as the first appellate court and hence it was open
to the Court to enter into not only questions of law but
questions of fact as well. It is settled law that an appeal
is a continuation of suit. An appeal thus is a rehearing of
the main matter and the appellate court can reappraise,
reappreciate and review the entire evidence--oral as well
as documentary--and can come to its own conclusion.”
43. Herein, the learned counsel for the appellant has argued
that the evidence of cruelty has not properly been
considered and as such, the judgment suffers from
perversity, hence, not sustainable in the eyes of law.
44. While on the other hand, argument has been advanced on
behalf of the respondent that the judgment is well
considered and the learned family court has rightly come to
the conclusion by denying the decree of suit of divorce
accordingly,
dismissed
the
interference by this Court.
suit
which
requires
no
2026:JHHC:286-DB
45. From the pleadings available on record and the arguments
advanced on behalf of parties, the issue which requires
consideration is as to:
“Whether the judgment and decree passed by the
learned family court denying the decree of divorce on
the ground of cruelty under Section 13(1)(i-a) of the
Hindu Marriage Act requires interference?”
46. This Court, while appreciating the argument advanced on
behalf of the parties on the issue of perversity, needs to
refer herein the interpretation of the word “perverse” as has
been interpreted by the Hon'ble Apex Court which means
that there is no evidence or erroneous consideration of the
evidence. The Hon'ble Apex Court in Arulvelu and Anr. vs.
State [Represented by the Public Prosecutor] and Anr.,
(2009) 10 SCC 206 while elaborately discussing the word
perverse has held that it is, no doubt, true that if a finding
of fact is arrived at by ignoring or excluding relevant
material or by taking into consideration irrelevant material
or if the finding so outrageously defies logic as to suffer
from the vice of irrationality incurring the blame of being
perverse, then, the finding is rendered infirm in law.
Relevant paragraphs, i.e., paras-24, 25, 26 and 27 of the
said judgment reads as under:
“24. The expression “perverse” has been dealt with in a
number
of
cases.
In Gaya
Din v. Hanuman
Prasad [(2001) 1 SCC 501] this Court observed that the
2026:JHHC:286-DB
expression “perverse” means that the findings of the
subordinate authority are not supported by the evidence
brought on record or they are against the law or suffer
from the vice of procedural irregularity.
25. In Parry's (Calcutta) Employees' Union v. Parry &
Co. Ltd. [AIR 1966 Cal 31] the Court observed that
“perverse finding” means a finding which is not only
against the weight of evidence but is altogether against
the
evidence
itself.
In Triveni
Rubber
&
Plastics v. CCE [1994 Supp (3) SCC 665 : AIR 1994 SC
1341] the Court observed that this is not a case where it
can be said that the findings of the authorities are based
on no evidence or that they are so perverse that no
reasonable person would have arrived at those findings.
26. In M.S. Narayanagouda v. Girijamma [AIR 1977
Kant 58] the Court observed that any order made in
conscious violation of pleading and law is a perverse
order. In Moffett v. Gough [(1878) 1 LR 1r 331] the
Court observed that a “perverse verdict” may probably be
defined as one that is not only against the weight of
evidence
but
is
altogether
against
the
evidence.
In Godfrey v. Godfrey [106 NW 814] the Court defined
“perverse” as turned the wrong way, not right; distorted
from the right; turned away or deviating from what is
right, proper, correct, etc.
27. The expression “perverse” has been defined by
various dictionaries in the following manner:
1. Oxford Advanced Learner's Dictionary of Current
English, 6th Edn.
“Perverse.—Showing
deliberate
determination
to
behave in a way that most people think is wrong,
unacceptable or unreasonable.”
2. Longman Dictionary of Contemporary English,
International Edn.
Perverse.—Deliberately departing from what is normal
and reasonable.
3. The New Oxford Dictionary of English, 1998 Edn.
Perverse.—Law (of a verdict) against the weight of
evidence or the direction of the judge on a point of law.
2026:JHHC:286-DB
4. The New Lexicon Webster's Dictionary of the
English Language (Deluxe Encyclopedic Edn.)
Perverse.—Purposely
deviating
from
accepted
or
expected behavior or opinion; wicked or wayward;
stubborn; cross or petulant.
5. Stroud's Judicial Dictionary of Words & Phrases,
4th Edn.
“Perverse.—A perverse verdict may probably be defined
as one that is not only against the weight of evidence but
is altogether against the evidence.”
47. Herein, cruelty has been taken by the appellant as the main
ground for dissolution of marriage.
48. So far the allegation of cruelty is concerned, it requires to
refer herein the definition of „cruelty’ as has been defined by
Hon‟ble Apex in the judgment rendered in Dr. N.G.
Dastane Vs. Mrs. S. Dastane [(1975) 2 SCC 326], wherein
it has been held that the Court is to enquire as to whether
the charge as cruelty, is of such a character, as to cause in
the mind of the petitioner, a reasonable apprehension that,
it will be harmful or injurious for him to live with the
respondent.
49. The cruelty has also been defined in the case of Shobha
Rani Vs. Madhukar Reddi [(1988) 1 SCC 105], wherein
the wife alleged that the husband and his parents
demanded dowry. The Hon‟ble Apex Court emphasized that
“cruelty” can have no fixed definition.
50. According to the Hon’ble Apex Court, “cruelty” is the
“conduct in relation to or in respect of matrimonial conduct
in respect of matrimonial duties and obligations”. It is the
2026:JHHC:286-DB
conduct which adversely affects the spouse. Such cruelty
can
be either “mental” or “physical”, intentional or
unintentional. For example, unintentionally waking your
spouse up in the middle of the night may be mental cruelty;
intention is not an essential element of cruelty but it may
be present. Physical cruelty is less ambiguous and more “a
question of fact and degree.”
51. The Hon’ble Apex Court has further observed therein that
while dealing with such complaints of cruelty that it is
important for the Court to not search for a standard in life,
since cruelty in one case may not be cruelty in another
case. What must be considered include the kind of life the
parties are used to, “their economic and social conditions”,
and the “culture and human values to which they attach
importance.”
52. The nature of allegations need not only be illegal conduct
such as asking for dowry. Making allegations against the
spouse in the written statement filed before the court in
judicial proceedings may also be held to constitute cruelty.
53. In V. Bhagat vs. D. Bhagat (Mrs.), (1994)1 SCC 337, the
wife alleged in her written statement that her husband was
suffering from “mental problems and paranoid disorder”.
The wife’s lawyer also levelled allegations of “lunacy” and
“insanity” against the husband and his family while he was
conducting cross-examination. The Hon‟ble Apex Court
2026:JHHC:286-DB
held these allegations against the husband to constitute
“cruelty”.
54. In Vijay kumar Ramchandra Bhate v. Neela Vijay
Kumar Bhate, (2003)6 SCC 334 the Hon’ble Apex Court
has observed by taking into consideration the allegations
levelled by the husband in his written statement that his
wife was “unchaste” and had indecent familiarity with a
person outside wedlock and that his wife was having an
extramarital affair. These allegations, given the context of
an educated Indian woman, were held to constitute
“cruelty” itself.
55. The Hon‟ble Apex Court in Joydeep Majumdar v. Bharti
Jaiswal Majumdar, (2021) 3 SCC 742, has been pleased
to observe that while judging whether the conduct is cruel
or not, what has to be seen is whether that conduct, which
is sustained over a period of time, renders the life of the
spouse so miserable as to make it unreasonable to make
one live with the other. The conduct may take the form of
abusive or humiliating treatment, causing mental pain and
anguish, torturing the spouse, etc. The conduct complained
of must be “grave” and “weighty” and trivial irritations and
normal wear and tear of marriage would not constitute
mental cruelty as a ground for divorce.
56. Cruelty” has an inseparable nexus with human conduct
and is always dependent on social strata or milieu to which
2026:JHHC:286-DB
parties
belong,
their
ways
of
life,
relationship,
temperaments and emotions that are conditioned by their
social status, reference be made to the judgment rendered
by the Hon‟ble Apex Court in the case Vishwanath
Agrawal v. Sarla Vishwanath Agrawal, (2012) 7 SCC
288.
57. The Hon‟ble Apex Court in the case of K. Srinivas
Rao v. D.A. Deepa, (2013) 5 SCC 226 has observed that
cruelty is evident where one spouse so treats other and
manifests such feelings in other, as to cause reasonable
apprehension in mind of other that it would be harmful or
injurious to reside with other spouse and cruelty may be
physical or mental. It has further been observed that
staying together under the same roof is not a precondition
for mental cruelty. Spouse can cause mental cruelty by his
or her conduct even while he or she is not staying under
the same roof.
58. In matrimonial relationship cruelty mean absence of
mutual respect and understanding between spouses which
embitters relationship. Sometimes it may take form of
violence, or at times may just be an attitude or approach.
Silence in some situations may also amount to cruelty
reference
be
made
to
the
case
Kumar v. Julmidevi, (2010) 4 SCC 476.
of
Ravi
2026:JHHC:286-DB
59. For considering dissolution of marriage at instance of a
spouse who alleges mental cruelty, result of such mental
cruelty must be such that it is not possible to continue with
matrimonial relationship reference may be taken from the
judgment rendered by the Hon‟ble Apex Court in the case of
Joydeep Majumdar v. Bharti Jaiswal Majumdar, (2021)
3 SCC 742.
60. Further the word „cruelty‟ is used relation to human
conduct or human behaviour. It is the conduct in relation
to or in respect of matrimonial duties and obligations. It is
a course of conduct and one which is adversely affecting
the other. The cruelty may be mental or physical,
intentional or unintentional. There may be cases where the
conduct complained of itself is bad enough and per se
unlawful or illegal. Then the impact or the injurious effect
on the other spouse need not be enquired into or
considered. In such cases, the cruelty will be established if
the conduct itself is proved or admitted, reference in this
regard be made to the judgment rendered by the Hon‟ble
Apex Court in the case of Vinita Saxena v. Pankaj
Pandit, (2006) 3 SCC 778.
61. Further,
in
the
case
of
Manish
Tyagi v. Deepak
Kumar, (2010) 4 SCC 339 the Hon‟ble Apex Court has
categorically observed that to constitute „cruelty‟, it is
enough that conduct of one of parties is so abnormal and
2026:JHHC:286-DB
below
accepted
norm
that
other
spouse
could
not
reasonable be expected to put up with it. Conduct is no
longer required to be so atrociously abominable which
would cause reasonable apprehension that it would be
harmful of injurious to continue cohabitation with another
spouse. Hence, it is not necessary to establish physical
violence. Continued ill-treatment, cessation of marital
intercourse, studied neglect, indifference may lead to
inference of cruelty.
62. The word “cruelty” under Section 13(1)(i-a) of the Act has
got no static connotation, and therefore, gives a very wide
discretion to the Court to apply it liberally and contextually.
What is cruelty in one case may not be the same for
another and has to be applied from person to person while
taking note of the attending circumstances. Harm or injury
to health, reputation, the working-career or the like, would
be important considerations in determining whether the
conduct of the defending spouse amounts to cruelty. It has
to be shown that the defending spouse has treated him
with cruelty to cause reasonable apprehension in his/her
mind that it will be harmful or injurious to live with the
contesting spouse.
63. This Court, based upon the aforesaid discussions on the
issue of cruelty, has gone through the testimony of
witnesses and found from the testimony of appellant-wife
2026:JHHC:286-DB
[PW 1] that she has deposed that she was being blackmailed on the ground of her past history. Even the
objectionable photographs of her with another person,
which was procured by the respondent-husband without
her consent, was made available to her in-laws, the fatherin-laws; mother-in-laws and brother-in-law. It has been
submitted that on that pretext the husband and in-laws
started to torture her. She was locked in the room and
threatened to bring money from her father otherwise the
said objectionable photographs shall be up-loaded. They
called her father and also insulted him on that pretext.
64. Submission has been made that such intimidation and
infliction of emotional and psychological distress using her
past history to blackmail itself constitute cruelty in
particular mental cruelty, which is self-sufficient ground for
divorce, but that aspect of the matter has not been taken
into consideration by learned family court.
65. Further submission has been made that as per Hindu
Marriage Act, 1955, regularly subjecting a spouse to
threats, including emotional blackmail is well recognized as
ground of divorce. Herein, the conduct of the respondenthusband assassinated the dignity and reputation of the
appellant-wife by divulging her past conduct to her in-laws
and on the ground, she is being tortured.
2026:JHHC:286-DB
66. While on the other hand, the respondent-husband has
stated that prior to the marriage, the respondent-husband
had talk with appellant but she never disclosed about her
previous relationship with another person namely, Satayin
Bhadani. Even after marriage, she did not tell about the
same. He came to know about her relationship when the
appellant kept on talking late night with a person and she
kept her mobile hidden. Submission has been made that
the allegations leveled made by the appellant-wife is totally
false. It has been submitted that even after knowing the
character, it is the respondent-husband who always
showed his desire to reside with her respecting the
relationship of husband and wife.
67. This Court, on appreciation of
the testimonies of the
witnesses as also the argument advanced on behalf of the
parties and case laws on the principle of cruelty, has found
that it is in admission that the appellant-wife, before her
marriage was in touch of another person. The respondenthusband has alleged that she used to talk with another
person in night, which the appellant-wife denies. Contrary,
it is the case of the appellant that her husband, the
respondent herein, transferred some objectionable photos
from the Google Drive, which she forget to delete after her
marriage and on the basis of that photographs, he used to
humiliate her and also blackmailed her. Not only that the
2026:JHHC:286-DB
respondent-husband, in order to humiliate his own wife,
transferred those photographs in his Whatsapp and showed
to his father and other family members. In turn, the family
members of the respondent-husband used to humiliate and
torture her. Though allegation of physical assault has also
been made but no concrete piece of evidence has been
adduced in that regard. It further appears that even the
father of the appellant-wife was called for and the
respondent-husband
and
his
family
members
also
humiliated him.
68. It
is
well
settled
principle
of
cruelty
as
discussed
hereinabove that harm or injury to reputation would be
important considerations in determining whether the
conduct of the defending spouse amounts to cruelty or not
and it has to be shown that the defending spouse has
treated them with cruelty to cause reasonable apprehension
in mind that it will be harmful or injurious to live with the
contesting spouse.
69. As discussed hereinabove the cruelty can be physical or
mental, intentional or unintentional, and is a subjective
concept that varies in each case depending on the facts and
circumstances.
70. On the basis of the aforesaid settled position of law, it is
considered view of this Court that in the case at hand, it is
mental cruelty that has been meted out to the appellant-
2026:JHHC:286-DB
wife so that it is next to impossible to live together with her
respondent/ husband.
71. It needs to reiterate herein that so far mental cruelty is
concerned,
it
refers
to
infliction
of
emotional
or
psychological distress on one spouse by the other spouse. It
includes behavior or conduct that is of such a nature that it
makes it impossible for the victim spouse to live with the
other spouse. Mental cruelty can take various forms, such
as constant humiliation, verbal abuse, harassment, neglect,
threats, or persistent indifference towards the well- being of
the other spouse.
72. From the discussions made hereinabove, it is evident that
by showing those objectionable photographs to his family
members by the respondent-husband and on the basis of
that she was being humiliated by the family members of the
respondent-husband, which is nothing but the character
assassination of the wife by her own husband.
73. It is well settled that spouse‟s chastity and extra-marital
relationships are a grave assault on the spouse‟s honour
and dignity.
74. On the basis of the discussion made hereinabove, this
Court is of the considered view that the conduct of the
respondent-husband has showed that it is the humiliation
caused by him and his family members that has caused
mental agony to the appellant to such an extent that it is
2026:JHHC:286-DB
almost impossible for the appellant-wife to live with the
respondent-husband where the thread of trust has already
been broken. Relationship of wife and husband is based on
the trust and respect to have upon each other and if it is
broken it is non-repairable as the trust is the foundation of
marriage. Marriage is a relationship built on mutual trust,
companionship and shared experiences.
75. This Court, after discussing the aforesaid factual aspect
along with the settled legal position as discussed and
referred hereinabove in the preceding paragraphs and
adverting to the consideration made by the learned Family
Judge in the impugned judgment and decree has found
therefrom that the issue of element of cruelty by the
appellant-wife has not been properly considered by the
learned Family Judge.
76. Accordingly, issue as framed by this Court is decided in
favour of the appellant-wife.
77. This Court, on consideration of the aforesaid discussion, is
of the view that the impugned judgment and decree passed
by the learned Additiional Family Judge is coming under
the fold of perversity, since, the conscious consideration
has not been made to the evidences available on record, as
would be evident from the impugned judgment.
78. Consequent to the aforesaid, the judgment dated 19th
September, 2023 and decree signed on 3rd October, 2023
2026:JHHC:286-DB
passed
by
the
learned
Additional
Principal
Judge,
Additional Family Court No. II, Dhanbad in Original Suit
No. 914 of 2021 denying the decree of divorce in favour of
appellant-wife on the ground of cruelty under Section 13(1)
(i-a) of the Hindu Marriage Act, is hereby quashed and set
aside.
79. Accordingly, the instant appeal stands allowed.
80. Pending interlocutory application(s), if any, also stands
disposed of.
I Agree
(Sujit Narayan Prasad, J.)
(Arun Kumar Rai, J.)
(Arun Kumar Rai, J.)
07th January, 2026
A.F.R.
Alankar/
Uploaded on 08.01.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review