The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. With the aforementioned observations, the instant writ petition is dismissed.
17. There shall be, however, no order as to costs.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
In the High Court at Calcutta
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Partha Sarathi Sen
WPA 27134 of 2026
Sri Debal Kumar Sen
VS.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
For the Petitioner
: Ms. Sohini Chakraborty
Mr. Ashim Ghoshal
Mr. Ushananda Jana
For the respondent/State
: Mr. Dibashis Basu, Ld. AGP
Ms. Sneha Dutta
Mr. Chandrachur Lahiri
For the respondent Nos.2 & 3
: Mr. Jaydeep Kar, Sr.Adv.
Mr. Siddhartha Ghosh
Heard on and Judgment on
: 07.10.2026
Partha Sarathi Sen, J.:1. In this writ petition the reasoned order dated 17.08.2026 passed by the
Special Secretary to the Government of West Bengal – UDMA and as has
been communicated vide Memo dated 19.08.2026 issued by the Joint
Secretary, Government of West Bengal – UDMA, is impugned. By the said
reasoned order, the respondent-State decided not to allow the writ
petitioner’s application for transfer of lease as made by the writ petitioner
on 18.05.2022.
2. For effective adjudication of the instant writ petition, some relevant facts
leading to filing of this writ petition are required to be dealt with and
those are as under:(a) A Registered Deed of Lease dated 13.12.1994 was executed
by and between the respondent/State (lessor) and the writ
petitioner (lessee) for a period of 99 years in respect of the
land in question for the purpose of erecting a building for
residential/commercial/institutional/ mixed use purpose
and for no other purpose with a rider that in the event the
lessee desires to assign and/or part with the possession of
the leased out land, written consent of the lessor is required
to be obtained.
(b) On
18.05.2022,
the
writ
petitioner
approaches
the
respondent No.3/authority seeking permission to transfer
the said leased out land to a third party.
(c) In the meantime, that is on 09.11.2023, the UDMA,
Government of West Bengal, published a notification to the
effect that the said department had noticed that a large
number of plot of land allotted on lease hold basis under
control of the said UDMA remains unutilized violating the
terms and conditions of the lease deed and in such cases
the said department has decided to initiate appropriate
proceeding for resumption of the said lands where the plots
are found to be unutilized in violation of the lease condition
by issuing a show-cause notice.
(d) By a communication dated 16.09.2022, the respondent No.
3/authority communicated the writ petitioner regarding
approval of the application for transfer by the said authority
with a further intimation that the matter would be sent to
the parent department that is the UDMA.
(e) Thereafter, for a considerable period, the respondent/State
did nothing and thus finding no other alternative, the writ
petitioner approached this Court by filing WPA 17201 of
2025 (Debal Kumar Sen vs. The State of West Bengal and
Others) which came to be disposed of by a Co-ordinate
Bench of this Court on 08.04.2026 wherein it was directed
that the Additional Secretary, to the Government of West
Bengal would consider the writ petitioner’s application for
transfer dated 18.05.2022 in accordance with law and
dispose of the said application for transfer by passing a
reasoned order.
(f) Pursuant to the order dated 08.04.2026, the impugned
reasoned order came to be passed.
3. At the time of hearing, Ms. Chakraborty, learned advocate appearing on
behalf of the writ petitioner strongly contended that the order impugned
is not justified in the eye of law inasmuch as prior to the publication of
the notification dated 09.11.2023 by the UDMA expressing their decision
to take appropriate steps for resumption of the unutilized land, the writ
petitioner on 18.05.2022 made an application for transfer of the lease
hold land as allotted to him. It is argued by Ms. Chakraborty that taking
recourse to the subsequent notification dated 09.11.2023 the impugned
order was passed wherein no opportunity of hearing was given to the writ
petitioner prior to rejection of his prayer for transfer of the lease hold
land.
4. It is further argued by Ms. Chakraborty that from the impugned order it
would reveal that on 07.06.2023 the UDMA department had taken a
decision regarding the process of dealing with the application for transfer,
however neither such communication nor such decision was ever
communicated to the writ petitioner. It is thus submitted by Ms.
Chakraborty that the impugned reasoned order dated 17.08.2026 is
perverse since it bears no logic and the same may be set aside.
5. Per contra, Mr. Kar, learned senior advocate appearing on behalf of the
respondent Nos. 2 and 3 submits before this Court that there is no
infirmity and/or illegality in the impugned order, inasmuch as the
respondent/State has taken a conscious policy decision with regard to
the unutilized plots of land under the control of the UDMA department
since it has been noticed by the UDMA department that many lease hold
plots like the plot in question, as involved in the instant writ petition,
remains unutilized violating the condition of lease. It is thus submitted
by Mr. Kar that in absence of any glaring illegality and/or perversity,
there cannot be any occasion to disturb the well-reasoned finding of the
respondent/State.
6. Mr. Lahiri, learned advocate appearing on behalf of the respondent/State
supports the impugned order. Mr. Lahiri further submits that no cogent
reason has been shown by the writ petitioner for interfering with the said
impugned order.
7. This Court has meticulously gone through the entire materials as placed
before this Court. This Court has given its due consideration over the
submissions of the contending parties.
8. For effective adjudication of the instant writ petition, this Court at the
very outset proposes to look to internal page No. 3 of the impugned
reasoned order wherein the decision of the respondent /State, more
specifically of the UDMA department regarding the mode of dealing with
the application for transfer of the lease hold land has been quoted and
the same is reproduced hereunder in verbatim :
“.....
that
the
development
authority
should
dispose
of
the
applications for transfer of leasehold rights at their end in the context
of the provisions of the lease deed executed between the lessor and
the lessee and during processing such cases, if it is found that the
provision of lease deed has been violated then the proposal for
transfer permission should be processed only after the lessee takes
corrective measures, if so permissible as per provision of the lease
deed and if, no corrective measure is taken or the violation is such
that corrective measures are not permissible as per the lease
condition,
then
resumption
process
may
be
started
by
the
Development Authority (if there is such provision in the lease deed) or
other actions may be taken as per provisions of the lease deed after
giving the lessee reasonable opportunity of being heard.
For example, if the leased out land is kept vacant beyond the
permissible period and even after giving sufficient more time to start
the construction work, the land is kept vacant and the lessee
approaches for transfer of leasehold right, that should not be
allowed."
9. On careful perusal of the aforementioned quoted decision of the UDMA, it
appears to this Court that the said decision of the UDMA has got two
parts, namely, (a) relating to the mode of dealing with the application for
transfer in the event it is found that the lessee has violated the condition
of lease and when the lessee was asked to take corrective measure, no
corrective measure is taken or the violation is such that the corrective
measures are not permissible. (b) the development authority would start
the process of resumption as per the condition of the violation of lease
against the lessee after giving a reasonable opportunity of being heard to
the lessee.
10.
At this juncture if I look to the internal page No. 4 of the instant writ
petition, it appears to this Court that the Special Secretary to the
Government of West Bengal, UDMA Department while passing the
reasoned order noticed that there was conscious violation on the part of
the lessee with regard to Clause No. 23 of the lease deed.
11.
For effective adjudication of the instant writ petition, this Court at this
juncture also proposes to quote Clause 23 of the lease deed in verbatim.
“23. The Lessee shall construct building according to
the rules of the Sriniketan Santiniketan Development
Authority or any other local authority that may come
into being having jurisdiction and according to the plans,
elevations, designs and sections as may be sanctioned by
the said authorities in that behalf within three years
from the date on which the demised land is allotted to
the Lessee. The Lessee shall also obtain prior permission
in writing from the Sriniketan Santiniketan Development
Authority or any local authority, as the case may be,
before
making
any
addition
or
alterations
to
the
sanctioned building plan including that of the boundary
wall.”
12.
Keeping in mind the spirit of paragraph 23 of the Registered Deed of
Lease as has been executed by and between the respondent/State (lessor)
and the present writ petitioner (lessee) vis-à-vis the operative part of the
impugned order, it appears to this Court that the Special Secretary to the
Government of West Bengal rightly noticed that there occurred violation
on the part of the lessee regarding Clause 23 of the Lease Deed and thus
in terms of the decision of the UDMA department on 07.06.2023, it has
rejected the prayer for transfer of the writ petitioner.
13.
At the time of argument, Ms. Chakraborty though contended that the
said decision dated 07.06.2023 was neither communicated to the writ
petitioner nor any opportunity of hearing was given prior to passing of
the reasoned order of rejection, however this Court most respectfully
disagrees with the submission of Ms. Chakraborty inasmuch as no case
has been made out on behalf of the writ petitioner that for not
communicating the decision of the UDMA as taken on 7.06.2023, the writ
petitioner suffers a serious prejudice and further the giving of reasonable
opportunity of hearing in terms of the decision dated 07.06.2023 would
arose only when the respondent/State being the lessor and/or the
respondent
Nos.
or
authority
being
the
parastatal
of
the
respondent/State initiates a proceeding for resumption.
14.
This Court finds no whisper in the impugned order regarding the
resumption of the leasehold land of the writ petitioner rather it appears
to this Court that the Special Secretary to the Government of West
Bengal, has only rejected the prayer for permission of transfer.
15.
In view of the discussion made in above, this Court thus finds no
reason to interfere with the impugned reasoned order dated 17.08.2026
as has been communicated to the writ petitioner vide memo dated
19.08.2026.
16.
With the aforementioned observations, the instant writ petition is
dismissed.
17.
There shall be, however, no order as to costs.
18.
Urgent Photostat certified copies of this order, if applied for, be
supplied to the parties upon compliance with all the necessary
formalities.
(Partha Sarathi Sen, J.)
[Sws.M[AR(C]
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review