Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:3284
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH
AT SHIMLA
Cr.MP(M) No: 2887 of 2024
Reserved on: 05.01.2026
Decided on : 09.01.2026
__________________________________________________________
Dashrath Singh
...Petitioner
versus
State of Himachal Pradesh.
...Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ranjan Sharma, Judge
1 Whether approved for reporting?
For the petitioner
:
For the respondents :
Mr.
Prikshit
Advocate.
Rathore,
Mr. Hemant K. Verma,
Deputy Advocate General,
for respondent.
Ranjan Sharma, Judge
Bail petitioner, Dashrath Singh, who is
in custody since 13.04.2021, has come up before
this Court, seeking regular bail under Section 483
of the Bhartiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023
[hereinafter referred to as 'BNSS'], originating from
FIR No.32 of 2021, dated 11.04.2021, under Sections
302 of the Indian Penal Code registered at Police
Station Nahan, District Sirmour, [HP].
FACTUAL MATRIX IN INSTANT BAIL PETITION:
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes
2026:HHC:3284
-2-
2.
Case set up by Learned Senior Counsel
is that bail petitioner has been falsely implicated
and he has no connection with the alleged offence.
It is averred that an FIR No 32 of 2021, dated
11.04.2021 was registered under Section 302 of
Indian Penal Code but the petitioner has no role
in the aforesaid accusation. It is averred that on
11.04.2021, that one Shri Jittu has telephonically
informed to police of Police Station Majra that a
scuffle took place at Jogiban and on the basis of
alleged information police of Police Station Nahan
went to alleged place and telephonically contacted
Jittu, upon which Jittu disclosed that he escaped
from
place
of
occurrence
and
his
friend
Maan
Singh was allegedly killed by Dashrath and his
dead body of deceased was lying on highway. It
is averred that informant Jittu came from Nahan
side and identified the dead body of Maan Singh
and his statement under Section 154 CrPC was
recorded.
2(i).
It is averred that petitioner moved an
2026:HHC:3284
-3-
application for regular bail [Cr.MP(M) No. 298 of
2024], and the same was dismissed as withdrawn
on 07.03.2024, [Annexure P-1].
2(ii).
It is averred that the bail petitioner is
in custody since 13.04.2021 for 4 years and 1
month
and
prolonged
detention
and
deprivation
of speedy trial has curtailed his personal liberty
under Article 21 of the Constitution of India. It
is averred that incarceration cannot be preventative
nor
punitive
on
the
basis
of
mere
accusation,
which are yet to be tested and proved. It is averred
that there are no past criminal antecedents of
the bail petitioner. It is undertaken bail petitioner
shall not tamper with the evidence and shall abide
by all the conditions as may be imposed by this
Court.
In these circumstances, instant application
has been filed through his brother, praying for
bail in instant case.
PROCEEDINGS BEFORE THIS COURT:
3.
Upon listing of instant bail application
2026:HHC:3284
-4-
and upon issuance of notice, Status Report dated
13.03.2025 was filed. Thereafter a Fresh Status
Report dated 09.05.2025 was filed and thereafter
Fresh Status Report dated 10.07.2025 was filed
showing stage and status of trial. The matter was
adjourned on the request of Learned Counsel for
petitioner between July to September 2025, when,
on 05.09.2025 placing on record the Zimni orders.
Mateer
was
adjourned
on
couple
of
occasions
but on 31.10.2025, the same was postponed, at
joint request of Learned Counsel for the parties,
so as to enable him to file Fresh Status Report
which was filed on 27.11.2025 and another Status
Report
dated
05.12.2025
and
the
matter
was
heard and was reserved on 05.01.2026. During
the course of proceedings, Learned Counsel for the
petitioner has placed on record the Zimni orders
and statements of witness recorded by Learned
Trial Court, to indicate that delay in trial was not
attributable to the bail petitioner.
3(i).
The
Status
Reports
dated
13.03.2025,
2026:HHC:3284
-5-
09.05.2025, 10.07.2025, 27.11.2025 and 05.12.2025
being pari-materia, narrate the entire sequence of
events
leading
to
the
incident,
registration
of
FIR and Investigation conducted and material on
record reveals that out of a total of 34 PW’s, the
statement of 19 PWs have been recorded by Trial
Court, as on day.
3(ii).
Perusal of Status Reports indicate that
the offence took place about four years back in
the night intervening 10/11.04.2021. Status Report
indicates that the complainant, Jittu telephonically
informed the police that a scuffle took place at
Jogiban and based on said information, the police
personnel went to spot at a place, Rukhri nearby
an
under-construction
hotel,
alleging
that
Maan
Singh was killed and his dead body was lying on
highway.
3(iii).
On
reaching
the
spot,
police
recorded
statements under Section 154 CrPC of complainant
-Jittu.
The
petitioner
stated
he
undertakes
the
task of cutting hair of ladies and he resides with
2026:HHC:3284
-6-
his wife Rajni and two children at Majra. The
complainant and Maan Singh are residing together
for last two and half years at Dhaulakuan on
rent. It is averred that on 10.04.2021 at about
9.00
p.m,
complainant
Jittu
and
Maan
Singh
went on a motorcycle UP-86Z- 3294 to Dhaulakuan
and
met
Dashrath
near
bus
stand,
who
was
riding his own motorcycle. Thereafter, Maan Singh
and Dashrath consumed liquor at Fauzi Ka Dhaba
and since Maan Singh had consumed excess liquor
thereafter the bail petitioner-Dashrath Singh carried
him
towards
Kolar
and
Jittu
came
slowly,
by
driving the bike of Dashrath. Prosecution story,
as disclosed by complainant Jitu is bail petitioner
drove the bike at a high speed and the complainantJittu remained behind at a distance and when,
the
complainant-Jittu
reached
Banthala
Rukhadi
at 11.15 pm during the night, he noticed that dead
body of Maan Singh was lying on National Highway
showing
apprehension
that
someone
has
killed
him and his neck and clothes were strained with
2026:HHC:3284
-7-
blood.
3(iv).
Based on investigation, the Status Report
indicates that complainant-Jittu stated that both
Man Singh and the petitioner-Dashrath consumed
liquor
and
while
they
were
on
their
way and
had reached a place near Bankalan Rukhdi hotel,
he
saw
that
petitioner-Dashrath
had
laid
Maan
Singh on the road and was giving thrashing to
him with a rod embedded with an iron weapon,
which resulted in the death of Maan Singh.
3(v).
During
the
spot,
video
spot
where
place.
After
soil,
motorcycle
investigation,
the
graphed
photographed
the
aforesaid
taking
into
and
police
visited
the
incident
had
taken
possession
the
blood,
UP86Z-3294,
mobile
phone
of
Maan Singh, weapon of offence, ante postmortem
of dead body was conducted at Forensic Science
Laboratory, Nahan.
REBUTTAL BY LEARNED COUNSEL:
4.
In
rebuttal,
Learned
Counsel
for
the
petitioner, places reliance on depositions of the
2026:HHC:3284
-8-
PWs,
including
deposition
dated
19.11.2025
of
the complainant-Jittu-PW 19, who has not at all
supported the prosecution story. The complainantJittu has denied that the bail petitioner-Dashrath
had called him at about 9:00 on 10.04.2021, on
his mobile asking him to come to Dhaulakuan.
The
complainant-Jittu also denied that bail petitioner
-Dashrath went to Dhaulakuan on the motorcycle
of Maan Singh. The complainant-Jittu denied that
petitioner Dashrath and Maan Singh had consumed
liquor
at
Dhaulakuan.
Even
PW-9-complainant-
Jittu has specifically denied to have been present
on the night intervening 10/11.04.2021 at 11:15,
when, Maan Singh was alleged to have assaulted.
He denies to have seen Maan Singh’s dead body
and
blood
oozing
out
from
his
neck.
PW-9-
Complainant-Jittu deposed before Trial Court that
he did not know about extra marital affairs of
wife of bail-petitioner with Maan Singh and even
factum of consumption of liquor was also denied.
It
is
pointed
out
that
trial
has
not
2026:HHC:3284
-9-
been
delayed
on
his
part.
He
further
submits
that detention cannot be preventative nor punitive
and
denial
of
speedy
justice
and
prolongation
of trial on the basis of mere accusation cannot
be the basis for curtailing the personal liberty
of the bail petitioner, when, out of total 34 PWs
only 19 have been examined as yet and the trial
is likely to take consideration time for conclusion.
Learned
Counsel
for
the
petitioner
asserts
that
the Status Reports do not indicate any adversial
past antecedents and do not point out any adverse
conduct during his judicial custody for the last
more 4 years and 8 months now. It is submitted
that the bail petitioner shall participate in the
trial,
on
each
for
ensuring
and
every
conclusion
of
date
the
hereinafter
and
trial,
bail
the
petitioner may be put to any conditions, as this
Court
may
deem
fit
and
proper,
which
shall
be earnestly complied with by the bail petitioner
and therefore, it is prayed that the prayer for
bail, may be accepted by this Court.
2026:HHC:3284
- 10 -
5.
Heard,
Mr.
Counsel
for
petitioner
and
Verma,
Learned
Deputy
Advocate
the
Prikshit
Rathore,
Mr.
Learned
Hemant
K.
General
for
Respondent-State and have gone through available
material on record.
MANDATE OF LAW ON BAIL:
6.
Broad parameters have been mandated
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court regulating the claim
for
bail in the cases of Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia
versus State of Punjab (1980) 2 SCC 565, Ram
Govind Upadhyay versus Sudarshan Singh (2002)
3 SCC 598; Kalyan Chandra Sarkar versus Rajesh
Ranjan, (2004) 7 SCC 528; Prasanta Kumar Sarkar
versus Ashish Chatterjee, (2010) 14 SCC 496;
reiterated in P. Chidambaram versus Directorate
of Enforcement, (2019) 9 SCC 24
and in Sushila
Aggarwal versus State- NCT Delhi, (2020) 5 SCC
01; CBI versus Santosh Karnani (2023) 6 SCALE
250; which have been reiterated by the Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
in
State
of
Haryana
versus
Dharamraj, 2023 SCC Online SC 1085, that after
2026:HHC:3284
- 11 -
taking into account the accusation, gravity, status,
position in society claim for bail is to be examined.
While considering claim for bail, allegations being
frivolous or groundless is to be seen. Depending
upon the facts of each case, the bail can be
refused, in case, prima facie case or reasonable
grounds exits and if an offence is serious. Severity
of punishment including reasonable apprehension
of fleeing away from investigation and trial and
the character, past antecedents, behavior, means,
position and standing of an accused ; likelihood
of offence being repeated; reasonable apprehension
based
the
on
cogent
and
convincing
accused
may
thereafter
witnesses or
the
victim
material
threaten
may
be
either
that
the
examined and
danger of justice being thwarted by grant of bail
etc. are relevant factors for denying the concession
of bail. It is mandated that bail can neither be
by
way
of
a
punishment
nor
preventative
and
mere accusation cannot form basis for prolonging
the incarceration and for curtailing the personal
2026:HHC:3284
- 12 -
liberty of petitioner-accused under Article 21 of
the Constitution of India. However, while examining
the claim for bail, a balance has to be carved
out between the personal liberty of an accused
under Article 21 vis-à-vis societal interests also.
6(i).
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Criminal
Appeal
No.
of
2023,
Saumya
Churasia
versus Directorate of Enforcement, decided on
14.12.2023 held that the claim for bail, is to
be examined by a Court, without delving into the
evidence on merits but by forming a prima-facie
opinion on totality of facts in the light of broadparameters referred to above.
6(ii).
the
While dealing with the claim for bail,
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
has
reiterated
the
principles for grant of bail in Criminal Appeal
Nos. 3528–3534 of 2025 (Arising from SLP (Crl.)
Nos. 516–522 of 2025), in State of Karnataka
versus
Sri
Darshan,
etc.
has
mandated
that
while considering claim for bail neither a detailed
examination
of
the
evidence
nor
any
findings
2026:HHC:3284
- 13 -
touching the merits of the case is to be resorted to.
In
backdrop
proceeds
to
of
above
analyze
the
parameters,
this
claim
bail
for
Court
in
the
instant case.
ANALYSIS OF CLAIM FOR BAIL IN INSTANT
CASE:
7.
facts
Taking into account the entirety of the
and
circumstances
and
the
material
on
record as is borne out from the Status Reports
and the statutory provisions and mandate of law,
this Court is of the considered view that bail
petitioner [Dashrath], is entitled to be enlarged on
bail, for the following reasons:
PRIMA FACIE ACCUSATION
PETITIONER DOUBTFUL:
8(i).
AGAINST
BAIL
Perusal of the Status Reports indicates
that the prosecution story appears to be highly
doubtful. The prima facie case accusation against
the bail petitioner-Dashrath appears not to have
is not made and there are no reasonable grounds
to infer the accusation against the bail petitioner
at this stage.
2026:HHC:3284
- 14 -
Perusal of Status Reports indicate that
entire prosecution story is that one Shri Jittu
informant-complainant
telephonically
informed
the
police that a scuffle took place at Jogiban and
based on said information, the police went to spot
at a place, Rukhri nearby an under-construction
hotel, alleging that petitioner-Dashrath had killed
Man Singh and his dead body was lying on the
highway.
Statements
under
Section
CrPC
of complainant-Jittu reveals that on 10.04.2021 at
about 9.00 pm, complainant-Jittu and Maan Singh
went on a motorcycle to Dhaulakuan and petitioner
-Dashrath met them near bus stand, who was
riding his own motorcycle. Thereafter, both Maan
Singh
and
Dashrath
consumed
liquor
at
Fauzi
Ka Dhaba and since Maan Singh had consumed
excess liquor. Complainant-Jitu informed the police
that when, he reached Banthala Rukhadi at 11.15
pm during the night, he noticed that dead body
of Maan Singh was lying on National Highway
2026:HHC:3284
- 15 -
apprehending
blood
was
that
Maan
oozing
out
Singh
from
was
his
killed
neck
and
and
his
clothes were strained.
Based
Report
on
indicates
investigation,
that
the
Status
complainant-Jittu
stated
that both Man Singh and the petitioner-Dashrath
consumed liquor and while they were on their way
and had reached a place near Bankalan Rukhdi
hotel,
he
saw
that
petitioner-Dashrath
had
laid
Maan Singh on the road and was giving thrashing
to him with a rod embedded with an iron weapon,
resulting in death of Maan Singh.
Perusal of depositions of PWs, including
deposition
dated
19.11.2025
of
complainant-
Jittu-PW19,
who
has
all
supported
the
prosecution
story,
who
that
bail
not
at
deposed
the
petitioner-Dashrath had never called him at about
9:00 on 10.04.2021 to come to Dhaulakuan. The
complainant-Jittu denied that the bail petitioner
Dashrath and Maan Singh had consumed liquor
at Dhaulakuan. Even PW-9-complainant-Jittu has
2026:HHC:3284
- 16 -
specifically denied to have been present on the
night intervening 10/11.04.2021 at 11:15, when,
Maan Singh was alleged to have assaulted and
he denies to have seen Maan Singh’s dead body
and the fact that blood was oozing out from his
neck.
Based
on
the
material
on
record
but
and without resorting to assessment of evidence,
this Court, is of the view that the prima-facie
accusation against the bail petitioner appears to
be doubtful and no reasonable grounds exist to
believe the accusation against the bail petitioner.
8(ii).
Moreover, the factum as to whether the
petitioner murdered {Section 302 IPC} Maan Singh
is to be tested, examined and proved during the
trial and,
therefore,
bail
cannot
be
denied
by
presuming guilt, at this stage, when, the prima-facie
accusation appears to be doubtful at this stage.
INFRINGMENT OF PERSONAL LIBERTY UNDER
ARTICLE 21 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA:
9.
While reiterating the principle that bail
is a rule and jail is an exception it has been
- 17 -
2026:HHC:3284
mandated that the personal liberty of a person
cannot
be
curtailed
on
mere
accusations;
and
an accused is to be treated as innocent till the
guilt was established in accordance with law, as
has been outlined by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in Guddan alias Roop Narayan Versus State
of Rajasthan, 2023 SCC OnLine SC 1242, in
the following terms:“11. In the case of Sanjay Chandra V. Central
Bureau of Investigation, (2012) 1 SCC 40,
while hearing a bail Application in a case of
an alleged economic offence, this court held
that the object of bail is neither punitive
nor preventative. It was observed as under:
"21.
In bail applications, generally, it
has been laid down from the
earliest times that the object of bail
is to secure the appearance of the
accused person at his trial by
reasonable amount of bail. The
object of bail is neither punitive
nor preventative. Deprivation of
liberty must be considered a
punishment, unless it is required
to ensure that an accused person
will stand his trial when called
upon. The courts owe more than
verbal respect to the principle that
punishment
begins
after
conviction, and that every man is
deemed to be innocent until duly
tried and duly found guilty.
23.
Apart from the question of
prevention being the object of
refusal of bail, one must not lose
- 18 -
2026:HHC:3284
sight of the fact that any
imprisonment before conviction
has
a
substantial
punitive
content
and
it
would
be
improper for any court to refuse
bail as a mark of disapproval of
former conduct whether the
accused has been convicted for it
or not or to refuse bail to an
unconvicted person for the
purpose of giving him a taste of
imprisonment as a lesson.
25.
27.
The provisions of Cr PC confer
discretionary
jurisdiction
on
criminal courts to grant bail to the
accused pending trial or in appeal
against convictions; since the
jurisdiction is discretionary, it
has to be exercised with great
care and caution by balancing
the valuable right of liberty of an
individual and the interest of
the society in general. In our
view, the reasoning adopted by the
learned District Judge, which is
affirmed by the High Court, in our
opinion, is a denial of the whole
basis of our system of law and
normal rule of bail system. It
transcends
respect
for
the
requirement that a man shall be
considered innocent until he is
found guilty. If such power is
recognised, then it may lead to
chaotic situation and would
jeopardise the personal liberty of
an individual.
This Court, time and again, has
stated that bail is the rule and
committal to jail an exception. It
has also observed that refusal of
bail is a restriction on the
personal liberty of the individual
guaranteed under Article 21 of
the Constitution."
- 19 12.
2026:HHC:3284
Further, in the case of Sandeep Jain v.
National Capital Territory of Delhi, (2000) 2
SCC 66, this Court, while hearing a bail
application held that conditions for grant
of bail cannot become so onerous that
their existence itself is tantamount to
refusal of bail. This Court held as under:
"We are unable to appreciate even the
first order passed by the Metropolitan
Magistrate imposing the onerous
condition that an accused at the FIR
stage should pay a huge sum of Rs. 2
lakhs to be set at liberty. If he had paid
it is a different matter. But the fact
that he was not able to pay that
amount and in default thereof he is to
languish in jail for more than 10
months now, is sufficient indication
that he was unable to make up the
amount. Can he be detained in custody
endlessly for his inability to pay the
amount in the range of Rs.2 lakhs?
If the cheques issued by his surety
were dishonoured, the Court could
perhaps have taken it as a ground
to suggest to the payee of the cheques
to resort to the legal remedies provided
by law.
Similarly if the Court was dissatisfied
with the conduct of the surety as
for his failure to raise funds for
honouring the cheques issued by
him, the Court could have directed the
appellant to substitute him with
another surety. But to keep him in
prison for such a long period, that
too in a case where bail would
normally be granted for the offences
alleged, is not only hard but
improper. It must be remembered that
the Court has not even come to the
conclusion that the allegations made
in the FIR are true. That can be
decided only when the trial concludes,
- 20 -
2026:HHC:3284
if the case is charge-sheeted by the
police."
PERSONAL LIBERTY AND CLAIM FOR BAIL:
10.
While dealing with the claim for bail,
in the context of personal liberty under Article 21
of the Constitution of India being sacrosanct, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court, held in Criminal Appeal
No. 2787 of 2024, titled as Javed Gulam Nabi
Shaikh versus State of Maharashtra and Another,
in the following terms:“18
Criminals are not born out but made.
The human potential in everyone is
good and so, never write off any criminal
as beyond redemption. This humanist
fundamental is often missed when
dealing with delinquents, juvenile and
adult. Indeed, every saint has a past
and every sinner a future. When a
crime is committed, a variety of factors
is responsible for making the offender
commit the crime. Those factors may be
social and economic, may be, the result
of value erosion or parental neglect; may
be, because of the stress of circumstances,
or the manifestation of temptations in
a milieu of affluence contrasted with
indigence or other privations.
If the State or any prosecuting agency
including the court concerned has no
wherewithal to provide or protect the
fundamental right of an accused to
have a speedy trial as enshrined under
Article 21 of the Constitution then
the State or any other prosecuting
agency should not oppose the plea for
bail on the ground that the crime
committed is serious. Article 21 of
2026:HHC:3284
- 21 -
the Constitution applies irrespective of
the nature of the crime.
10(i).
In
We may hasten to add that the petitioner
is still an accused; not a convict.
The over-arching postulate of criminal
jurisprudence
that
an
accused
is
presumed to be innocent until proven
guilty cannot be brushed aside lightly,
howsoever stringent the penal law may
be.
We are convinced that the manner in
which the prosecuting agency as well as
the Court have proceeded, the right of
the accused to have a speedy trial could
be said to have been infringed thereby
violating Article 21 of the Constitution.
In view of the aforesaid, this appeal
succeeds and is hereby allowed. The
impugned order passed by the High Court
is set aside.”
Central
Bureau
of
Investigation
versus Dayamoy Mahato Etc. 2025 SCC On
Line SC 2775, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held
as under:
13.
The rights enshrined under Article
21 and their application to undertrials
has
often
been
the
subject
of
consideration before this Court and, in
one voice it has been held that the
rights of fairness, dignity and liberty
apply to each and every prisoner,
irrespective of the nature of offence
that they stand charged for. If
this is not maintained then essentially,
it would render a difference between
an undertrial and a convict, obsolete
to a certain extent. We say, to a
certain extent because certain facets
of Article 21 apply even to those who
have been convicted under law. In
2026:HHC:3284
- 22 -
the case of the former, should these
rights not be granted to them or be
available to them in their full extent,
it would in a sense render them
guilty without it being so. To state the
obvious, such a position is wholly
impermissible.
14.
The
jurisprudence
of Article
has, as it develops, recognised various
facets to be intrinsic to the right
to life and liberty such as speedy
trial, timely completion of investigation,
fair trial etc. Unduly long incarceration
especially as a undertrial when,
the crucial aspect of guilt is yet
to
be
decided,
is
particularly
offensive to this sacrosanct right,
if not sustainable as per procedure
established by law. Circumspection
in granting the relief of bail in heinous
offences and more so offences that
shock the conscience of the society
such as in this case, stems from a
place
of
concern,
understandably
legitimate
at
that,
about
public
order, societal security, overall peace
and the general deterrent force in
criminal law. The scales of Lady Justice
must balance on the one handthe
constitutionally consecrated
and
jealously guarded right under Article
21 and on the other, the recognition
that individual liberty is not absolute
and is subject to just exceptions
i.e.
the
paramount
considerations
of national interest, sovereignty and
integrity of the nation.
ADHERANCE TO PRINCIPLE:- BAIL IS RULE:
11.
of
Depriving the petitioner of the concession
bail
shall
negate
the
principle
that ‘bail is
a rule and jail is an exception’, as outlined by
- 23 -
2026:HHC:3284
the Hon’ble Supreme Court, in Manish Sisodia
vs Directorate of Enforcement, SLP (Criminal)
No.8781 of 2024, as under:“49.
We find that, on account of a long
period
of
incarceration
running
for
around 17 months and the trial even not
having been commenced, the appellant
has been deprived of his right to speedy
trial.
50. As observed by this Court, the right
to speedy trial and the right to liberty
are sacrosanct rights. On denial of
these rights, the trial court as well as
the High Court ought to have given
due weightage to this factor.
52.
The Court also reproduced the observations
made in Gudikanti Narasimhulu (supra),
which read thus:
“10. In the aforesaid context, we may
remind the trial courts and the High
Courts of what came to be observed
by
this
Court
in
Gudikanti
Narasimhulu v. Public Prosecutor,
High Court reported in (1978) 1 SCC
240. We quote:
“What is often forgotten, and
therefore warrants reminder, is the
object to keep a person in judicial
custody pending trial or disposal
of an appeal. Lord Russel, C.J.,
said [R v. Rose, (1898) 18 Cox]:
“I observe that in this case
bail was refused for the prisoner.
It cannot be too strongly
impressed on the, magistracy of
the country that bail is not to
be withheld as a punishment,
but that the requirements as
to bail are merely to secure
the attendance of the prisoner
at trial””
53. The Court further observed that, over
a period of time, the trial courts and
- 24 -
2026:HHC:3284
the High Courts have forgotten a very
well-settled principle of law that bail
is not to be withheld as a punishment.
From our experience, we can say that it
appears that the trial courts and the
High Courts attempt to play safe in
matters of grant of bail. The principle
that bail is a rule and refusal is an
exception is, at times, followed in
breach. On account of non-grant of bail
even in straight forward open and shut
cases, this Court is flooded with huge
number of bail petitions thereby adding
to the huge pendency. It is high time
that the trial courts and the High
Courts should recognize the principle
that “bail is rule and jail is exception”.
55. As observed by this Court in the case
of Gudikanti Narasimhulu (supra), the
objective to keep a person in judicial
custody pending trial or disposal of
an appeal is to secure the attendance
of the prisoner at trial.
56. In the present case, the appellant is
having deep roots in the society. There
is no possibility of him fleeing away
from the country and not being available
for facing the trial. In any case, conditions
can be imposed to address the concern
of the State.
57.
Insofar as the apprehension given by
the learned ASG regarding the possibility
of tampering the evidence is concerned,
it is to be noted that the case largely
depends
on
documentary
evidence
which is already seized by the prosecution.
As such, there is no possibility of
tampering with the evidence. Insofar as
the concern with regard to influencing
the witnesses is concerned, the said
concern can be addressed by imposing
stringent conditions upon the appellant.”
NO PAST CRIMINAL ANTECEDENTS:
12.
Learned Counsel for the bail petitioner
asserts that the petitioner has no past criminal
2026:HHC:3284
- 25 -
antecedents. The status report does not indicate
any past criminal antecedents and, therefore, in
view of these facts, the present accusation which
is yet to be tested, examined and proved during
the trial, cannot be made the basis for prolonging
the incarceration of the bail petitioner in facts of
in the instant case.
MANDATE OF LAW GRANTING BAIL ON
PROLONGED INCARCERATION AND DENIAL
OF SPEEDY TRIAL:
13.
Learned Counsel for the petitioner submits
that FIR was registered on 11.04.2020 and the
petitioner is in custody for about four years and
eight months as on day. After the completion of
Investigation
and
and
filing
of
Charge,
Framing
of
Challan-Police
the
Trial
Report
Court
had
commenced and out of 34 PWs, the statement
of 19 PWs have been recorded as yet and trial is
likely to take considerable time for conclusion.
13(i).
While
dealing
with
the
claim
for
bail
in a matter relating to accusation under Section
IPC
and
taking
into
account
the
versions
2026:HHC:3284
- 26 -
and
cross
versions
coupled
with
the
fact
that
accused had suffered incarceration for more than
months
much
coupled
progress
in
with
trial
the
fact
there
and
trial
was
is
to
no
take
considerable time, the Hon’ble Supreme Court, in
Mukesh Kumar versus State of Rajasthan and
another, 2023 SCC OnLine SC 2025, granted the
bail to the accused therein, in the following terms:2. The petitioner is accused of giving one blow
on the head of the deceased with a danda
(Bamboo). It may also be mentioned that
occurrence took place on 08-06-2020 and
the deceased succumbed to his injuries on
12-06-2020.
5. After cancellation of bail by the High Court,
the petitioner has again surrendered on 16-112022 and is in custody.
7. It may be seen that there are cross-versions
and both sides suffered injuries. The question
as to who was the aggressor will depend
upon the appreciation of evidence and
will be decided by the Trial Court at an
appropriate stage. It is not expedient or
desirable for this Court to express any opinion
in relation thereto at this stage.
8. Suffice to say that the petitioner has been
in custody for more than 14 months, the
crucial witnesses have since been examined
and there is no likelihood of tampering with
the evidence. Even otherwise also, the witnesses
are close family members of both sides,
hence there is no likelihood of winning over
the witnesses.
2026:HHC:3284
- 27 -
9. Since conclusion of trial will take considerable
time, we deem it appropriate to release the
petitioner on bail.
11. Consequently, without expressing any views
on the merits of the case, the petitioner is
directed to be released on bail, subject to
his furnishing bail bonds to the satisfaction
of the Trial Court.
12. The petitioner and his family members as
well as Respondent No. 2 and his family
members will ensure that no untoward incident
takes place again.
13(ii).
In a similar fact-situation, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Praveen Rathore versus State
of
Rajasthan and
another,
SCC
OnLine
SC 1268, granted bail to accused who was facing
incarnation
for
more
than
four
and
half
years
under Section 302 read with Section 120-B of IPC,
in the following terms:
2. The above-stated FIR has been lodged
on a complaint made by Mahadev Meena, who
has alleged, inter alia, that his son - Chetan
Prakash got married with Anita Meena on
21.01.2011. He was, thereafter, selected as
Assistance Intelligence Officer in the Intelligence
Bureau. Anita was working as a second
grade teacher, at that time, and later on,
she got appointment as First Grade Lecturer
in a Senior Secondary School. He further
alleged that the petitioner (Praveen Rathore)
was also working as an Officer in the Intelligence
Bureau. He came in close contact to his
daughter-in-law (Anita Meena) and when
his son-Chetan Prakash objected to it,
- 28 -
2026:HHC:3284
the petitioner threatened him with dire
consequences. The complainant's son was
found unconscious near railway culvert on
14.02.2018 and was declared as dead when
he was taken to the hospital. His nails of
hands and legs were found to be blue.
5. It is not in dispute that the petitioner, by
now, has undergone more than four and
a half years' of sentence. The prosecution
intends to examine 76 witnesses, out of
whom 53 have already
deposed.
All
the crucial witnesses have already been
examined. The instant case was adjourned
on few occasions to enable the prosecution
to examine Chauthmal Kashyap and Manohar
Rathore, who were stated to be the vital
witnesses. Their deposition is also complete.
7. Taking
into
consideration
the
period
already spent by the petitioner in custody
coupled with the fact that conclusion of
trial will take some reasonable time however,
without expressing any views on the merits
of the case, we are inclined to release him on
bail.
8. The petitioner is, accordingly, directed to be
enlarged on bail subject to his furnishing
bail bonds to the satisfaction of the Trial Court.
RIGHT TO SPEEDY TRIAL CANNOT
ECLIPSED BY NATURE OF THE OFFENCE:
13(iii).
BE
While dealing with right of an accused
for speedy trial, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Arvind Dham versus Directorate of Enforcement,
2026, SCC Online SC 30, {decided on 06.01.2026}
has outlined that the right of speedy trial under
Article 21 of the Constitution cannot be eclipsed
2026:HHC:3284
- 29 -
by the nature of offence and prolonged incarceration
of a person and delayed trial, is a ground for
granting bail, in the following terms:
13(iv).
“17.
A three Judge Bench of this Court
in Padam Chand Jain (supra), reiterated
that prolonged incarceration cannot
be allowed to convert pretrial detention
into punishment and that documentary
evidence already seized by the prosecution
eliminates the possibility of tampering
with the same.
18.
The right to speedy trial, enshrined
under Article 21 of the Constitution,
is not eclipsed by the nature of the
offence. Prolonged incarceration of an
undertrial, without commencement or
reasonable progress of trial, cannot be
countenances, as it has the effect of
converting pretrial detention into form
of punishment. Economic offences, by
their very nature, may differ in degree
and fact, and therefore cannot be treated
as homogeneous class warranting a
blanket denial of bail.”
While
dealing
with
the
claim
for
bail
in a case relating to accusation under Section
302 IPC, a Co-ordinate Bench of this Court, in
Cr.MP (M) No 2618 of 2023, Jasbir Singh versus
State of Himachal Pradesh, decided on 4.11.2023
has
affirmed
the
right
to
bail
in
view
of
the
2026:HHC:3284
- 30 -
prolonged
detention
of
the
accused
therein,
in
the following terms:5(ii). ….. In 2021 (3) SCC, 713, Union of India
Versus K.A. Najeeb, Hon’ble Apex Court
considered various judicial precedents where
Article 21 of the Constitution of India
was invoked in case of gross delay in disposal
of cases of undertrials and consequential
necessity to release them on bail. The earlier
decisions were reiterated that liberty granted by
Part-III of the Constitution, would cover within
its protective ambit not only due procedure
and fairness, but also access to justice and
speedy trial. It was held that once it is obvious
that a timely trial would not be possible
and the accused have suffered incarceration
for a significant period of time, the Courts
would ordinarily be obligated to enlarge
them on bail. Some relevant paras from the
judgments are extracted hereinafter:“10.
It is a fact that the High Court in the
instant case has not determined the
likelihood of the respondent being guilty
or not, or whether rigours of Section
43D(5) of UAPA are alien to him. The
High Court instead appears to have
exercised its power to grant bail owing
to the long period of incarceration and
the unlikelihood of the trial being
completed anytime in the near future. The
reasons assigned by the High Court
are apparently traceable back to Article
21 of our Constitution, of course without
addressing the statutory embargo created
by Section 43D (5) of UAPA.
11. The High Court’s view draws support from a
batch of decisions of this Court, including
in Shaheen Welfare Assn, laying down that
gross delay in disposal of such cases would
justify the invocation of Article 21 of
the Constitution and consequential necessity
- 31 -
2026:HHC:3284
to release the undertrial on bail. It would
be useful to quote the following observations
from the cited case:
“10.
Bearing in mind the nature of the crime
and the need to protect the society and
the nation, TADA has prescribed in
Section 20(8) stringent provisions for
granting bail. Such stringent provisions
can be justified looking to the nature
of the crime, as was held in Kartar
Singh case, on the presumption that
the trial of the accused will take place
without undue delay. No one can justify
gross delay in disposal of cases when
undertrials perforce remain in jail,
giving rise to possible situations that
may justify invocation of Article 21.” …
(emphasis supplied)
12. Even in the case of special legislations like
the
Terrorist
and
Disruptive
Activities
(Prevention) Act, 1987 or the Narcotic Drugs
and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (“ the
NDPS Act”) which too have somewhat rigorous
conditions for grant of bail, this Court
in Paramjit Singh v. State (NCT of Delhi),
Babba v. State of Maharashtra and Umarmia
alias Mamumia v. State of Gujarat enlarged
the accused on bail when they had been
in jail for an extended period of time
with little possibility of early completion
of trial. The constitutionality of harsh conditions
for bail in such special enactments, has
thus been primarily justified on the touchstone
of speedy trials to ensure the protection
of innocent civilians.
13. We may also refer to the orders enlarging
similarly situated accused under the UAPA
passed by this Court in Angela Harish Sontakke
v. State of Maharashtra. That was also a
case under Sections 10, 13, 17, 18, 18A,
18B, 20, 21, 38, 39 and 40(2) of the UAPA.
This Court in its earnest effort to draw
balance between the seriousness of the
- 32 -
2026:HHC:3284
charges with the period of custody suffered
and the likely period within which the
trial could be expected to be completed
took note of the five years’ incarceration
and over 200 witnesses left to be examined,
and thus granted bail to the accused
notwithstanding Section 43D(5) of UAPA.
Similarly, in Sagar Tatyaram Gorkhe v. State
of Maharashtra, an accused under the UAPA
was enlarged for he had been in jail for
four years and there were over 147 witnesses
still unexamined.
15. This Court has clarified in numerous judgments
that the liberty guaranteed by Part III
of the Constitution would cover within its
protective ambit not only due procedure
and fairness but also access to justice and a
speedy trial. In Supreme Court Legal Aid
Committee (Representing Undertrial Prisoners)
v. Union of India, it was held that undertrials
cannot indefinitely be detained pending trial.
Ideally, no person ought to suffer adverse
consequences of his acts unless the same
is established before a neutral arbiter.
However, owing to the practicalities of real
life where to secure an effective trial and to
ameliorate the risk to society in case a
potential criminal is left at large pending
trial, Courts are tasked with deciding whether
an individual ought to be released pending
trial or not. Once it is obvious that a timely
trial would not be possible and the accused
has suffered incarceration for a significant
period of time, Courts would ordinarily
be obligated to enlarge them on bail.
17. It is thus clear to us that the presence of
statutory restrictions like Section 43D (5) of
UAPA per se does not oust the ability
of Constitutional Courts to grant bail on
grounds of violation of Part III of the
Constitution. Indeed, both the restrictions
under a Statue as well as the powers exercisable
under Constitutional Jurisdiction can be
well harmonised. Whereas at commencement
- 33 -
2026:HHC:3284
of proceedings, Courts are expected to
appreciate the legislative policy against grant
of bail but the rigours of such provisions
will melt down where there is no likelihood
of trial being completed within a reasonable time
and the period of incarceration already
undergone has exceeded a substantial part
of the prescribed sentence. Such an approach
would safeguard against the possibility of
provisions like Section 43-D (5) of UAPA
being used as the sole metric for denial
of bail or for wholesale breach of constitutional
right to speedy trial.”
5(iv). ……A previous bail petition bearing Cr.MP
(M) No.1458/2022 instituted by the
petitioner was dismissed on merit on
02.09.2022. While deciding the aforesaid
bail petition, considering the fact that
FIR in question pertained to the year
2020, it was hoped and expected that
the learned Trial Court would make
endeavour to expedite the trial. We are
now at the fag end of 2023. In terms
of the status report filed by the respondent,
the prosecution has examined 16
witnesses thus far. Statements of
23 prosecution witnesses still remain
to be recorded. The zimni orders placed
on record reflect that the trial has
been deferred time and again for want
of presence of prosecution witnesses.
Considering the fact that at this
stage 23 witnesses remain to be
recorded, it is apparent that the
trial is not going to be concluded in
near future. The petitioner, who has
already spent about three years and
five months in custody, in my
considered opinion has made out a
case for his enlargement on regular
bail at this stage. There is no criminal
history of the petitioner. The apprehension
expressed by the prosecution about
the likelihood of petitioner’s tampering
with the evidence or winning over
2026:HHC:3284
- 34 -
remaining witnesses, can be taken
care of by imposing stringent conditions
and
also
granting
liberty
to
the
respondent/State to seek cancellation of
the bail in case the conditions are violated
by the petitioner. In view of all the
aforesaid reasons and without expressing
any opinion on the merits of the case,
the present petition is allowed. Petitioner
is ordered to be released on bail in
the aforesaid FIR …..”
13(v).
This Court in Cr.MP(M) No 490 of 2024
Manoj Kumar versus State of Himachal Pradesh,
decided on 17.09.2024, granted bail to an accused
who had been in custody under Section 302 read
with
Section
102-B
IPC,
for
more
than
for
years and 2 months on the ground that prolonged
detention curtails the personal liberty under Article
21 of the Constitution of India.
Based
on
the
material
on
record
as
borne out from the Status Reports and the PW
Evidence and the mandate of law coupled with
the fact there is neither any prima case nor any
reasonable grounds exist to believe the accusation
against the bail petitioner at this stage coupled
with the fact that trial is likely to take considerable
2026:HHC:3284
- 35 -
time for its conclusion ; with another added fact
that delay in trial was not attributable to the
bail petitioner therefore, further detention certainly
amounts
to
implicating
the
bail
petitioner
on
mere accusation or conjectures-suspicion, by way
of punishment, defeating the very intent and object
of bail; by making petitioner to be incarcerated
for 4 years and 8 months now ; and in these
circumstances, the plea for bail carries weight and
the same is accordingly granted.
NOTHING
ADVERSARIAL
REGARDING
TAMPERING WITH EVIDENCE OR WITNESSES
ETC:
14.
Status Report(s) filed by State Authorities
have not pointed out any cogent and convincing
material to show that after release on bail, the
petitioner
is
likely
to
tamper
with
evidence
or
may cause inducement, threat or promise to any
person or persons acquainted with the facts of
the case.
15.
NOTHING
RECOVERABLE
PETITIONER:
FROM
BAIL
Status Reports filed by State Authorities
2026:HHC:3284
- 36 -
do not indicate that any recovery is still attributable
to the petitioner in the aforesaid incident.
NOTHING
ADVERSARIAL
REGARDING
OBSTRUCTING OR THWARTLING JUSTICE :
16.
have
Status Reports filed by State Authorities
neither
pointed
out
any
adversarial
circumstances nor placed on record any cogent
and convincing material on record to infer that
after release on bail, the petitioner may obstruct
or thwart the cause of justice in any manner. In
absence of any cogent and convincing material,
the plea for bail, deserves to be granted to the
petitioner, in the instant case.
APPREHENSION OF FLEEING AWAY
TRIAL OR JURISDICTION OF COURT:
17.
FROM
Learned State Counsel has objected to
the grant of bail on the ground that petitioner
is a resident of Village Gadhi Dudhadhari, Post
Office Hathrus (UP) and there is every possibility
that petitioner may flee away, which shall obstruct
the trial hereinafter.
2026:HHC:3284
- 37 -
The above apprehension is misconceived
for
the
reason,
that
mere
apprehension
cannot
be the sole basis for prolonging the incarceration
and such apprehension, if any, can be addressed
by imposing stringent conditions in bail order
by
mandating
the
bail
petitioner
not
to
leave
the jurisdiction of this Court without the permission
of the Trial Court and with the mandate that
the
bail
petitioner
shall
appear
in
the
trial
on each and every date hereinafter and failure
to appear except for the extreme medical grounds
{involving
hospitalization
only},
non-appearance
shall entail automatic cancellation of bail order,
in which event the police-State Authorities shall be
free to arrest the bail petitioner forthwith.
CONCLUSION:
18.
In the facts of instant case, the plea of
petitioner for bail carries weight, for the reason,
that firstly, prima facie prosecution story appears
to
be
highly
doubtful
and
improbable
at
this
stage even as discussed hereinabove; and secondly,
2026:HHC:3284
- 38 -
the Status Report(s) reveal that the bail petitioner
is in custody since 13.04.2021 and is undergoing
incarceration for about four years and eight months
;and thirdly, conclusion of trial is likely to take
considerable time, when out of total 34 PWs, only
PWs
have
been
examined
and
the
trial
is
still likely to take considerable time; and fourthly,
delay in trial is not attributable to the petitioner;
and fifthly, the bail petitioner- accused is presumed
to be innocent unless proven guilty; and sixthly,
the continued detention can neither be punitive
nor preventative ; and seventhly, continued detention
in guise of penalizing the petitioner by presuming
guilt cannot be permitted; and eighthly, even the
State Authorities have not placed any cogent and
convincing
material
that
after
release
on
bail
there is possibility of the accused fleeing away
from
trial
or
an
accused
is
likely
to
threaten
the witnesses or is likely to thwart justice; and
ninthly, even the State Authorities have not placed
anything on record to show that petitioner has
2026:HHC:3284
- 39 -
misused liberty granted to him earlier; and tenthly,
the accusation is yet to be tested, examined and
proved during the trial; and eleventhly, the denial
of the right of speedy trial as mandated in Article
21 is an added factor for granting bail ; and
lastly, in order to safeguard the rights of bail
petitioner
and
the
interests
of
the
State,
this
Court imposes stringent condition in this order
hereinafter mandating that the infraction, violation
or misuse of concession-liberty shall entitle the
police/State
Authorities
to
seek
cancellation
of
concession of bail and with an added condition
that the bail petitioner shall appear in the trial
hereinafter except for the extreme medical grounds
{involving hospitalization only} and non-appearance
before the Trial Court hereinafter shall entail
automatic cancellation of bail order, in which
event the police-State Authorities shall be free to
arrest
the
bail
petitioner
forthwith ;
and denial
of bail shall deprive and curtail the fundamental
rights of personal liberty and deny the right of
2026:HHC:3284
- 40 -
speedy trial under Article 21 of the Constitution
of India is sacrosanct. On totality of the facts and
circumstances and the mandate of law, referred to
above, claim of the petitioner [Dashrath Singh]
for enlargement on bail carries weight, in peculiar
facts-situation of this case.
DIRECTIONS:
19.
Based on the above discussion and the
material on record and the mandate of law and
for reasons recorded hereinabove; and in peculiar
facts, the instant petition is allowed; and the
State Authorities are directed to release the petitioner
[Dashrath Singh] on bail, subject to the observance
of the following conditions:
(i)
Respondent-State
Authorities
shall
release the bail petitioner [Dashrath
Singh] on furnishing a personal bond
of Rs 75000/-{Rupees Seventy Five
Thousand}
in
like
with
two
sureties
each
amount
to
satisfaction
of
Learned Trial Court concerned; out
of which one surety should be a
permanent resident of place where
the
petitioner
resided
at
the
time
2026:HHC:3284
- 41 -
of alleged offence Nahan [Himachal
Pradesh] and another surety should
be permanent resident of Village Gadhi
Dudhadhari,
Post
Office
Hathrus,
[Uttar Pradesh];
(ii)
Bail petitioner shall hereinafter appear
before the Trial Court on every date
of trial except for extreme medical
exigencies (hospitalization only) and
failure
to
appear
shall
result
in
automatic cancellation of bail, without
notice ;
(iii).
Failure to comply with condition no
(ii) shall entail arrest of bail petitioner
without notice ;
(iv).
Bail
petitioner
jurisdiction
of
shall
not
leave
Trial
Court
the
without
the permission of Trial Court ;
(v).
Learned Trial Court can impose any
other condition, if so desires, to ensure
the presence and effective progress of
trial hereinafter;
(vi).
Petitioner shall abide by all condition
(s), which may be imposed by Learned
Trial
Court/this
Court,
in
view
of
this order;
(vii)
Petitioner shall neither involve himself
nor shall abet the commission of any
offence
hereinafter.
Involvement
in
any offence whatsoever or abetting
thereof
shall
entail
automatic
2026:HHC:3284
- 42 -
cancellation of bail granted in terms of
this order ;
(viii)
Petitioner shall disclose his functional
E-Mail IDs/ WhatsApp number and
that of his surety to Learned Trial
Court;
(ix)
Petitioner after release, shall report
to
Investigating
Officer
or
Police
Station,
concerned,
Sunday
of
month
every
SHO
of
on
2nd
at
11.00
a.m., only for having an update on
good conduct and behaviour;
(x)
Petitioner shall not jump over the bail
and also shall not leave the country
without the prior information of the
Court;
(xi)
Petitioner shall not tamper with the
evidence in any manner;
(xii)
Petitioner
shall
not
cause
any
inducement, threat or promise {directly
or
indirectly}
other
to
person
witnesses
acquainted
or
any
with
the
case;
(xiii) Petitioner is free to seek modification
of any condition contained hereinabove,
if need arises;
(xiv) State Authorities are free to move
this
Court
for
seeking
alteration/
modification of any of the condition
contained in this order or any condition
2026:HHC:3284
- 43 -
imposed by the Learned Trial Court
as a sequel to this order, in fact
situation of instant case or if the
circumstances so necessitate, at any
time herein-after;
(xv) State Authorities are free to move
this Court for seeking cancellation of
bail, in case, petitioner violates
any
conditions {except condition no (ii)
&
(iii),
which
entails
automatic
cancellation of bail order} hereinafter:
20.
Observations made in this judgment shall
not be construed in any manner as an indictive of
findings, for or against the parties herein, either
for purpose of investigation or for trial, which shall
proceed in-accordance with law, irrespective of any
of the observations contained hereinabove.
21.
Petitioner
is
permitted
to
produce/use
copy of this order, downloaded from the web-page
of the High Court of Himachal Pradesh, before the
authorities concerned, and the said authorities shall
not insist for production of a certified copy, but
if required, may verify about the passing of this
order from the Website of this Court.
- 44 -
22.
2026:HHC:3284
Registry is directed to forward a copy
of this order to Superintendent of Police, Sirmour
at
Nahan
for ensuring
compliance of
directions
in Para 18(viii) & 18(ix) of this order to keep an
update on good conduct and behaviors of the bail
petitioner [Dashrath Singh], and copy of this order
be transmitted to Superintendent of Police, District
Hathras (UP) with directions to forward the same
to concerned police station for compliance, here-inafter.
In aforesaid terms, the instant petition
and all pending miscellaneous application(s), if any,
shall also stand disposed of.
January 09, 2026
[tm/himani]
(Ranjan Sharma)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review