The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
21. 09.2026 Das Organochem Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Subrata Ghosh & Ors. (AD 26) (S. Banerjee) Mr. Saptansu Basu, Sr. Advocate Mr. Suddhasatva Banerjee Mr. Soumyadeb Sinha Ms. Abhismita Goswami Ms. Suranjana Chatterjee …for the petitioner Mr. Aloke Chatterjee Mr. Arghya Mullick Mr. Shivam Adhikary …for the opposite-party no. 1 On the prayer of Mr. Basu, learned Senior Advocate, for the petitioner, leave is granted to the learned advocate-on-record of the petitioner to amend the cause-title of the civil revision application, here and now. This application under Article 227 of the Constitution of India is at the instance of the defendant no. 1 and is directed against a judgment and order dated August 21, 2026 passed by the learned Additional District Judge, 10th Court at Alipore in Misc. Appeal No. 274 of 2024. The order dated July 15, 2024 passed by the learned Civil Judge (Jr. Division), 1st Court at Alipore in Title Suit No. 775 of 2023 allowing the application under Order 39 Rule 4 of the Civil Procedure Code filed by the petitioner, was challenged by the opposite-party no. 1 by preferring the Misc. Appeal No. 274 of 2024. The said misc appeal was allowed by the learned Additional District Judge, 10th Court at Alipore by a judgment and order dated August 21, 2026 thereby restoring the ad interim order of injunction passed by the learned trial judge by an order dated June 7, 2023. The opposi…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CO 3270 of 2026
Court No. 6
(265719)
21.09.2026
Das Organochem Pvt. Ltd.
Vs.
Subrata Ghosh & Ors.
(AD 26)
(S. Banerjee)
Mr. Saptansu Basu, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Suddhasatva Banerjee
Mr. Soumyadeb Sinha
Ms. Abhismita Goswami
Ms. Suranjana Chatterjee
…for the petitioner
Mr. Aloke Chatterjee
Mr. Arghya Mullick
Mr. Shivam Adhikary
…for the opposite-party no. 1
On the prayer of Mr. Basu, learned Senior
Advocate, for the petitioner, leave is granted to the
learned advocate-on-record of the petitioner to amend
the cause-title of the civil revision application, here
and now.
This application under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India is at the instance of the
defendant no. 1 and is directed against a judgment
and order dated August 21, 2026 passed by the
learned Additional District Judge, 10th Court at
Alipore in Misc. Appeal No. 274 of 2024.
The order dated July 15, 2024 passed by the
learned Civil Judge (Jr. Division), 1st Court at Alipore
in Title Suit No. 775 of 2023 allowing the application
under Order 39 Rule 4 of the Civil Procedure Code
filed by the petitioner, was challenged by the
opposite-party no. 1 by preferring the Misc. Appeal
No. 274 of 2024. The said misc appeal was allowed by
the learned Additional District Judge, 10th Court at
Alipore by a judgment and order dated August 21,
2026 thereby restoring the ad interim order of
injunction passed by the learned trial judge by an
order dated June 7, 2023.
The opposite-party
no. 1 filed a
suit for
declaration that the opposite-party no. 1 is the coowner of A and B schedule property and for
permanent injunction restraining the petitioner and
his men and agents from making any construction in
the C schedule property encroaching upon the vacant
land in A and B schedule property.
The learned trial judge, by an order dated June
7, 2023, passed an ad interim order of injunction
restraining the petitioner from encroaching upon the
A and B schedule property for a limited period.
Petitioner thereafter filed an application under
Order 39 Rule 4 of the Civil Procedure Code alleging
that
material
facts
plaintiff/opposite-party
were
in
suppressed
the
plaint
by
the
and
the
injunction application and for such reason the ad
interim order of injunction should be vacated.
The learned trial judge by an order dated July 5,
2026 allowed the application under Order 39 Rule 4
of the Civil Procedure Code and the learned Judge of
the appellate court allowed the appeal thereby
restoring the ad interim order of injunction passed by
the learned trial judge.
Being
aggrieved
the
defendant
no.
has
approached this Court.
Mr. Basu, learned Senior Advocate, appearing
for the petitioner submits that the opposite-party no.
1 in the plaint as well as in the injunction application
has admitted that the petitioner is the owner of the C
schedule property. He submits that the oppositeparty no. 1 has suppressed the fact that the petitioner
has become absolute owner of A, B and C schedule
property by virtue of a deed of conveyance executed
sometime in the year 1963 by the predecessor-ininterest of the opposite-party no. 1 along with other
co-sharers. He further submits that when the learned
trial judge after being satisfied with the fact that the
ad interim order of injunction could not have been
passed if such facts were not suppressed, allowed the
application under Order 39 Rule 4 of the Civil
Procedure Code, the learned Judge of the appellate
court ought not to have reversed the said order only
on the ground that the title of the petitioner by virtue
of the said deed is a matter of evidence. He, therefore,
submits that the order passed by the learned Judge of
the appellate court suffers from perversity and for
such reason the same is liable to be set aside.
Per contra the learned advocate appearing for
the opposite-parties submits that the opposite-parties
have admitted that the petitioner is the owner of only
C schedule property. He further submits that the
petitioner in the application under Order 39 Rule 4 of
the Civil Procedure Code claimed that the petitioner is
a co-sharer in respect of Schedule A and B property
and such facts were not within the knowledge of the
opposite-party no. 1 and for such reason it cannot be
said
that
the
opposite-party
no.
suppressed
material facts at the time of passing of the ad interim
order of injunction.
With regard to the scope of Article 227 of the
Constitution of India the learned advocate appearing
for the opposite-party no. 1 places reliance upon a
decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of
Essen Deinki –Vs.- Rajiv Kumar, reported in (2002) 8
Supreme Court Cases 400.
Heard the learned advocates for the parties and
perused the materials placed.
After
going
through
the
plaint
and
the
injunction application, this Court finds that the
opposite-party has admitted that the defendant no.
1/petitioner is the owner of the property mentioned in
C schedule of the plaint. However, in the pleadings
the opposite-party no. 1 has not disclosed the source
of
his
knowledge
about
the
ownership
of
the
petitioner in respect of the C schedule property.
After going through the application under Order
39 Rule 4 of the Civil Procedure Code this Court finds
that the petitioner has specifically stated about the
devolution of title upon the petitioner by virtue of the
registered deed of conveyance. In paragraph 5 of the
said application the petitioner has specifically stated
that the plaintiff/opposite-party no. 1 has failed to
annex the title deed of the defendant no. 1/petitioner
intentionally to suppress the real facts before the
Court.
The learned trial judge noted the case made out
by the opposite-party no. 1 in details in the order
dated July 15, 2025 as well as the claim made by the
petitioner that he became owner by virtue of purchase
of
the
suit
property.
The
learned
trial
judge
specifically noted that Mohini Mohan, i.e., the direct
predecessor of the plaintiff was a party to the deed of
sale and the fact that Asutosh, had another son,
namely, Nalini Mohan was evident from RS Record of
Rights which fact was also suppressed by the
plaintiff/opposite-party.
After being satisfied with the fact that the
plaintiff/opposite-party no. 1 suppressed material
facts, the learned trial judge vacated the ad interim
order of injunction which was passed on June 7,
2023.
However, the learned judge of the appellate
court after recording that the learned trial judge has
noted that there was suppression of material fact
made by the plaintiff/opposite-party allowed the misc.
appeal thereby setting aside the order passed by the
learned trial judge only on the ground that whether
there was sale or whether the plaintiff inherited the
suit property, is a matter of evidence.
As observed hereinbefore that in the plaint and
in the injunction application the plaintiff/oppositeparty has admitted that the defendant/petitioner is
the owner of a portion of the suit property but has not
disclosed the manner as to how the defendant no. 1
became the owner. The learned trial judge specifically
recorded the suppression made by the opposite-party
no. 1in the injunction application. To the mind of this
Court, the suppressions as noted by the learned trial
judge are suppressions of material facts relevant for
consideration at the time of passing an order of
injunction. This Court is of the considered view that
the learned trial judge was right in vacating the ad
interim order of injunction.
It now well-settled that for the purpose of
reversing an order, the appellate authority has to
come within the close quarters of the reason assigned
by the learned trial judge and then assign its own
reasons for arriving at a different conclusion.
This Court finds that the learned judge of the
appellate court without considering the reasons
assigned by the learned trial judge reversed the order
passed by the learned trial judge only on the ground
that the issue of title is a matter of evidence.
It is now well-settled that there is a distinction
between “prima facie case” and “prima facie title”.
While deciding an application for injunction, the
Court has to consider the prima facie case and not
the prima facie title which has to be proved by way of
adducing evidence at the time of trial. The learned
judge of the appellate court confused itself between
the expressions „prima facie case‟ and „prima facie
title‟ while reversing the order passed by the learned
trial judge.
The Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Essen Deinki
(supra) held that the power of superintendence under
Article 227 can be used to keep the subordinate
Courts or tribunals within the bounds of their
authority.
To the mind of this Court, the learned judge of
the appellate court failed to perform its duty as an
appellate court while deciding the appeal and for such
reason this court is inclined to interfere with the
order of the learned judge of the appellate court.
Accordingly, the judgment and order dated
August 21, 2026 passed by the learned Additional
District Judge, 10th Court at Alipore, South 24
Parganas is set aside. The order passed by the
learned trial judge dated July 15, 2024 stands
restored.
The
learned
advocate
appearing
for
the
petitioner is right in submitting that even if the
vacating
application
is
allowed,
the
injunction
application has to be decided on its merit.
The petitioner is directed to file the written
objection to the injunction application within three
weeks from the date of receipt of a server copy of this
order, if not already filed.
The learned trial judge is requested to dispose of
the temporary injunction application as expeditiously
as
possible
without
granting
any
unnecessary
adjournment to either of the parties.
Before parting, it is made clear that the
observations made hereinbefore are only for the
purpose of supporting the ultimate conclusion in this
order and the learned trial judge shall be free to
decide the injunction application being uninfluenced
by the aforesaid observations.
(Hiranmay Bhattacharyya, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review