Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 20.01.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 31.01.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 31.01.2026
+
W.P.(C) 18908/2025, CM APPL. 78730/2025, CM APPL.
78731/2025, CM APPL. 78732/2025
RAHUL SINGH TOLIA
Through:
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ANR.
Through:
+
.....Petitioner
Mr. Shakti Singh, Adv.
.....Respondents
Ms. Arunima Dwivedi, CGSC
along with Mr. Abhiraj Singh,
GP, Ms. Monalisha Pradhan
and Ms. Priya Khurana, Advs.
W.P.(C) 121/2026, CM APPL. 620/2026, CM APPL.
3753/2026
DARSHAN GATTANI
.....Petitioner
Through: Ms. Aakriti Dhawan, Mr.
Mayank Jain and Mr. Madhur
Jain, Advs.
versus
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Akash Vajpai, CGSC along
with Mr. Harsh Bajpai, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
JUDGMENT
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
1.
These Petitions assail the correctness of the Judgment and
Order dated 22.05.2025 [hereinafter referred to as ‘Impugned
Judgment’] passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:11:17
W.P.(C) 18908/2025 & connected matter
Bench, Delhi [hereinafter referred to as ‘Tribunal’] in Original
Applications which raised substantially similar challenges. Since, both
the Petitions arise from the same lis and turn upon overlapping issues,
they are being disposed of by way of this common judgment.
However, for the sake of convenience, the W.P. (C) 18908/2025 is
being treated as the lead case to extrapolate our decision in both the
Petitions, while highlighting the distinct facts of W.P. (C) 121/2025,
as and when relevant.
BRIEF BACKGROUND:
2.
The dispute arose due to the wrongful cadre allocation of the
Petitioners, as reflected in the Cadre Allocation List dated 05.04.2019
[hereinafter referred to as ‘List of 2019’], which is alleged to be
wrongful and contrary to the applicable Cadre Allocation Policy dated
05.09.2017 [hereinafter referred to as ‘Policy of 2017’].
3.
The Petitioner appeared in the Union Public Service
Commission-Indian Forest Service (UPSC-IFS) Examination, 2017
and was selected for appointment to the Indian Forest Service (IFS)
vide final result dated 19.02.2018. Upon selection, the Petitioner, duly
submitted his preferences for cadre allocation, indicating, inter alia,
his first preference as the Uttarakhand cadre. However, by way of the
List of 2019, the Petitioner was wrongly allocated the Maharashtra
cadre. Similarly, to point out very briefly, the Petitioner in W.P. (C)
121/2025, was allocated the Kerala cadre, as against his home cadre,
i.e., Rajasthan Cadre.
4.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:11:17
Prior thereto, the Respondent No.1 had issued the Policy of
W.P.(C) 18908/2025 & connected matter
2017, under which, a candidate was to be allotted to his/her home
cadre on the basis of merit, preference and availability of vacancy at
his/her turn in the relevant category. Further, the policy also provided
that for allocation to the home cadre against an insider vacancy, a
candidate must (i) express his preference for the zone in which his
home cadre falls, and (ii) indicate his first preference to the home
cadre within that zone; failing which, the candidate shall not be
considered for allocation to his home cadre at all.
5.
It is pertinent to highlight, at this stage, that the cadre allocation
pursuant to the Civil Services Examination (CSE) is carried out in two
stages, namely, determination of vacancies and the procedure for
allocation of cadres against such vacancies.
6.
Aggrieved by the wrongful cadre allocation, the Petitioner in
W.P.(C)18908/2025 and W.P.(C)121/2025, approached the Tribunal,
in the years 2021 and 2022, respectively, seeking to set-aside the List
of 2019, thereby allocating the Petitioners their preferred home cadre,
i.e., the Uttarakhand cadre and Rajasthan cadre. However, the OAs
filed by the Petitioners were dismissed by the Tribunal, resultantly, the
Petitioners have assailed the impugned judgment before this Court.
7.
This Court has heard learned counsel for the parties at length
and with their able assistance perused the paper book.
CONTENTION OF THE PARTIES:
8.
It is the case of the Petitioner that, at the first stage of
determination of vacancies, there occurred an error in cadre-wise
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:11:17
W.P.(C) 18908/2025 & connected matter
vacancy distribution on part of the Respondent No.2. Further, it is also
his case that on account of the said error in cadre-wise vacancy
distribution at the stage of determination of vacancies, he was not
considered for allocation to his first preference, i.e., Uttarakhand
cadre, as an insider, in terms of the Policy of 2017.
9.
It is contended that the Petitioner was wrongfully allocated
Maharashtra Cadre, owing to no fault of his and purely on account of
the alleged mistake committed by Respondent No.2 in the distribution
of cadre-wise vacancies. Had the aforesaid error not occurred, the
Petitioner would have been allocated to the Uttarakhand cadre in
accordance with his merit, preference and the governing Policy of
2017.
10.
Per contra, learned Counsel for the Respondents have argued
that since the cadre allocation software for the Indian Administrative
Services (IAS) was under process, the Respondents had to carry out a
manual determination of vacancies, which led to a situation where the
names of certain officers of the 2016 batch were erroneously taken
into account twice, as their names had already been included in the
2018 list, resulting in double counting of 2016 batch officers. This
double counting, in turn, affected the vacancy calculation for the 2017
batch and led to an artificial reduction of cadre gaps.
11.
While acknowledging that there were errors in the vacancy
calculations, it was contended by the learned counsel for the
Respondents that any re-allocation at this stage would have a
cascading impact on the subsequent cadre allocation exercises
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:11:17
W.P.(C) 18908/2025 & connected matter
undertaken by the Ministry and would, consequently, jeopardise the
overall cadre management.
ANALYSIS AND REASONING:
12.
We have heard the rival submissions advanced by the learned
counsel for the parties and have duly perused the paper book.
13.
At the outset, we deem it appropriate to note the chronology of
events. The Petitioner in W.P. (C) 18908/2025 approached the
Tribunal by filing his OA only in the year 2021, whereas the
Petitioner in W.P. (C) 121/2025, filed his OA even later, in the year
2022. Evidently, as on date nearly a period of 7 years has elapsed
since the cadre allocation was finalized and implemented in
compliance of List of 2019 dated 05.04.2019. Therefore, any
interference at this belated stage is not found appropriate, since such
interference would amount to unearthing coffins long buried in the
sands of time, thereby unsettling what has, by now, been laid to final
rest.
14.
As far as the validity of the Impugned Judgment is concerned,
in the considered view of this Court, the same does not merit any
interference. It is for the reason that the foundation of the challenge
before this Court as well as the Tribunal, is the admitted error in the
vacancy determination process, which according to the Petitioner,
deprived him of allocation to his first preference, i.e., Uttarakhand
Cadre, against an insider vacancy.
15.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:11:17
However, the question which arises in the aforesaid backdrop,
W.P.(C) 18908/2025 & connected matter
is whether such error, in the facts of the present case, warrants judicial
interference, at this stage, by way of directing a re-allocation of cadre
in favour of the Petitioner.
16.
It is not disputed that cadre allocation is carried out on a batch-
wise, all-India basis, by adopting a uniform methodology for
determination of vacancies and for allotment, while taking into
consideration the merit and overall cadre strength and requirements of
all participating States. Accordingly, any correction or re-working in
respect of one batch, or one officer within a batch, would necessarily
lead to a re-calibration of the entire allocation exercise for that batch,
in turn, impacting the allocations made in the successive batches on
the existing vacancy and cadre position.
17.
In the present case, the Respondents have explained that the
error resulted from manual processing when cadre allocation software
was still under development, and that the double counting of certain
2016 batch officers affected the vacancy computation for the 2017
batch, thereby altering the cadre gap figures.
18.
If this Court were to accept the contention of the Petitioner and
direct a re-allocation in his favour on the basis of a corrected vacancy
computation, it would inevitably open the floodgates to similar claims
from other officers of the same batch as well as subsequent and prior
batches who might, on a retrospective recalculation, assert that they
too were prejudiced in terms of their cadre allocation. However, in
view of this Court, such an exercise would, in effect, require a
wholesale re-opening of past cadre allocation exercises across
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:11:17
W.P.(C) 18908/2025 & connected matter
multiple years, resulting in cascading consequences for cadre
management throughout the nation.
19.
Therefore, this Court is not persuaded that such a large-scale
unsettling of settled allocations will either be feasible or advisable in
the exercise of writ jurisdiction, particularly where the cadre
allocation, as it stands, is broadly in conformity with the Policy of
2017 and where rectification is no longer confined to a narrow,
individualised correction.
20.
It is equally significant to note that it is not the case of the
Petitioner that, the allocation to Maharashtra Cadre has adversely
affected him, leading to civil consequences in terms of diminution of
his pay, seniority, status, promotional avenues or other substantive
service incidents vis-à-vis what he would have enjoyed had he been
allocated to Uttarakhand Cadre. The Petitioner has merely disputed
the location and preference of cadre, which, by itself, does not confer
an enforceable, vested right warranting judicial intervention in a
highly structured, policy-driven, all-India allocation exercise.
21.
The Supreme Court in Union of India & Ors. v. Rajiv Yadav,
IAS & Ors.1, has held that cadre allocation is merely an incidence of
service, to be effected in accordance with the applicable policy and
overall administrative exigencies. It is in this backdrop, that Courts
have consistently exercised restraint in unsettling such allocations,
except in cases where egregious illegality or mala fides have been
demonstrated, thereby affecting the very process of allocation.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:11:17
(1994) 6 SCC 38
W.P.(C) 18908/2025 & connected matter
However, in the present case, no such circumstances have been
established, warranting a departure from the settled principle of
judicial interference.
22.
Moreover, this Court cannot remain oblivious to the fact that
the Tribunal, by way of the Impugned Judgment, has already taken a
serious view of the errors in the vacancy determination process. In that
context, the Tribunal has also directed the Central Government to
prepare an appropriate report and place it before the Cabinet Secretary
for the purpose of developing an online system for calculation of
vacancies, thereby reducing scope for human error in future exercises.
23.
Further, the Tribunal has also directed the constitution of an
enquiry committee to identify the person or persons responsible for
such miscalculation and to examine whether such error was deliberate
or otherwise. To put it in other words, systemic corrective and
accountability measures have already been set in motion by the
Tribunal, which this Court finds to be a sufficient institutional
response to the lapse, without embarking upon a batch-wise or
individual re-engineering of cadre allocations already made.
24.
In these circumstances, while the error in vacancy calculation
may be a matter of concern from the standpoint of administrative
robustness and fairness in future exercises, however, it does not,
justify the grant of individual relief to the Petitioner by way of
re-allocation of cadre after a passage of almost 7 years. To do so
would not only unsettle settled positions but also invite a multitude of
similar petitions from officers across different batches, rendering the
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:11:17
W.P.(C) 18908/2025 & connected matter
entire cadre management exercise vulnerable to continuous litigation
and uncertainty.
CONCLUSION:
25.
In view of the foregoing discussions, this Court is of the
considered view that the impugned judgment warrants no interference.
26.
Accordingly, having found no merit, the present petitions, along
with pending applications, stand disposed of.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J.
JANUARY 31, 2026
sp/hr
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:11:17
W.P.(C) 18908/2025 & connected matter
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review