Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Judgment reserved on: 03.11.2025
Judgment pronounced on: 07.02.2026
+ ARB.P. 1723/2024
DALMIA CEMENT (BHARAT) LIMITED
Through:
Mr. Anirudh Bakhru, Ms. Niyati Kohli,
Mr. PrathaVir Agarwal & Ms. Shubhi
Agarwal, Advs.
versus
M/S ESS ESS TECHNOFABS PRIVATE LIMITED
Through:
...Petitioner
Mr. Anirudh Bakhru, Ms. Niyati
Kohli, Mr. PrathaVir Agarwal & Ms.
Shubhi Agarwal, Advs.
versus
M/S ESS ESS TECHNOFABS PRIVATE LIMITED
Through:
...Respondent
Mr. Varun Bedi & Ms. Swati Ahalwat,
Advs.
+ ARB.P. 1725/2024
DALMIA CEMENT (BHARAT) LIMITED
Through:
...Petitioner
...Respondent
Mr. Varun Bedi & Ms. Swati Ahalwat,
Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE JASMEET SINGH
JUDGMENT
1.
These are petitions filed under Section 11 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996, (“the Act”) arising out of the work
Digitally Signed
ARB.P. 1723/2024 & ARB. P. 1725/2024
By:MAYANK
14:48:06
order/purchase order dated 11.10.2020 and 04.11.2020, respectively,
seeking appointment of a Sole Arbitrator to adjudicate disputes between
the parties.
FACTUAL MATRIX AS PER THE PETITIONER
2.
The petitioner, namely Dalmia Cements (Bharat) Limited is a public
company engaged in the business of manufacturing and selling of
cement and other allied products.
3.
The respondent, namely M/S Ess Ess Technofabs Private Limited is
engaged in the business of Manufacturing and installation of fabricated
metal products.
4.
In the year 2020, the petitioner engaged the respondent for providing
material and services for mechanical fabrication and erection job of two
projects, namely AFR feeding system and clinker silo at its DDSPL unit
based in Rohtas, Bihar (“Project 1”) and the installation of cooler at
Rajgangpur unit, Odisha (“Project 2”) respectively.
5.
As regards with the project 1, the letter of indent was issued on
15.09.2020
and
subsequently
the
petitioner
issued
a
work
order/purchase order dated 11.10.2020.
6.
As regards with the project 2, the Letter of Indent was issued on
30.10.2020
and
subsequently
the
petitioner
issued
a
work
order/purchase order dated 04.11.2020.
7.
The aforesaid said work order/purchase order contained an arbitration
clause being Clause No. 28 of the general terms and conditions of the
work order/purchase order.
8.
The nature of purported disputes in both these petitions are similar,
hence are being dealt, together. It is the case of the petitioner that the
Digitally Signed
ARB.P. 1723/2024 & ARB. P. 1725/2024
By:MAYANK
14:48:06
respondent failed to execute the work within the time schedule and the
petitioner had to engage the third party contractors for completion of
the projects.
9.
Subsequently, the respondent sent two demand notices dated
06.01.2023 and 10.01.2023, making demands of Rs. 61,65,000/- and
Rs. 87,00,000/- along with interest, respectively.
10. In view of the disputes between the parties, on 04.08.2023 the
respondent filed reference under Section 17 and 18 of the Micro, Small
and Medium Enterprise Development Act, 2006 (“the MSMED Act”)
relating to the both the claims before the District Micro & Small
Enterprises Facilitation Council, Mohali, Punjab (“the Facilitation
Council”) for an amount of Rs. 1,01,65,000/- along with interest with
respect to the project 1 and Rs.87,00,000/- along with interest, with
respect to the project 2.
11. The petitioner disputed the jurisdiction of the Facilitation Council by
raising a preliminary objection and also filing an application under
section 16 of the Act on 14.12.2023.
12. The petitioner then proceeded to file its Statement of Defence (“SOD”)
on merits, it was filed without prejudice to the objections raised under
Section 16 application.
13. In view of the disputes between the parties, the petitioner invoked the
dispute resolution clause i.e. Clause No. 28 of the general terms and
conditions of the work/purchase order by sending a notice invoking
arbitration under Section 21 of the Act dated 12.01.2024.
14. On 30.04.2024, the petitioner also filed its evidence before the
Facilitation Council. However, on 08.07.2024 the petitioner filed writ
petitions being CWP no. 15704/2024 and 15708/2024 before the
Digitally Signed
ARB.P. 1723/2024 & ARB. P. 1725/2024
By:MAYANK
14:48:06
Hon’ble High Court of Punjab and Haryana seeking directions against
the Facilitation Council to first decide the Section 16 application dated
14.12.2025 and also to quash the claim petition filed by the respondent
before the Facilitation Council.
15. Meanwhile, the Facilitation Council had already reserved the case for
award vide Order dated 11.07.2024.
16. The High Court of Punjab and Haryana in the aforesaid writ petitions
passed an Order dated 18.07.2024 directing that no final Order shall be
passed by the Facilitation Council. Further, the writ petitions, were
disposed of vide judgment dated 09.09.2025 with direction that the
Facilitation Council to firstly decide the Section 16 application and
conclude the proceedings within 6 months.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER
17. Mr. Bakhru, learned counsel for the petitioner, contends that the
MSMED Act, 2006 does not confer jurisdiction over the Facilitation
Council to adjudicate claims arising out of the contracts in the nature of
works contracts i.e. composite contracts for supply of goods, materials
and services. Reliance is placed on National Textile Corp. Ltd. v. Elixir
Eng. Pvt. Ltd.1, P.L. Adke v. Wardha Municipal Corporation2, Kone
Elevators India Private Limited v. State of Tamil Nadu3, and Indian Oil
Corporation Ltd. and Another v. Adarsh Nobel Corporation Ltd4.
18. Further, the learned counsel also relies on a judgment of a Coordinate
Bench of this Court rendered in Tata Power Company Ltd. v. Genesis
SCC OnLine Bom 653.
2021 SCC OnLine Bom 13986.
(2014) 7 SCC 1.
2025 SCC OnLine Ori 2737.
Digitally Signed
ARB.P. 1723/2024 & ARB. P. 1725/2024
By:MAYANK
14:48:06
Engineering Company5, and submits that in this case also the nature of
the works contract was similar, and it was held that the respondent will
not be entitled to the benefit of the MSMED Act.
19. It is further submitted that the Facilitation Council is not having
jurisdiction to adjudicate the present disputes between the parties and the
disputes need to be adjudicated as per the agreed procedure as
enumerated under Clause No. 28 of the general terms and conditions of
the work order /purchase order.
20. The statutory arbitration under the MSMED Act was wrongly invoked by
the respondent, and this court is having the jurisdiction to decide this
Section 11 petition by prima facie satisfying itself regarding the nature of
contract between the parties, which is that of a composite contract i.e.
works contract and then the Facilitation Council would be divested of the
jurisdiction.
21. Further the learned counsel also raises a contention that there was no
reference to arbitration by the Facilitation Council and the Facilitation
Council proceeded to decide the issue in preliminary and fast track
manner without consent of the parties, being in non-compliance with
Section 21 of the Act and that of the party autonomy.
22. It is further submitted by the learned counsel that even otherwise, the
benefits of the MSMED Act cannot be availed by the respondent as on
the date of execution of the works contract i.e. in 2020, the respondent
was not an MSME and the subsequent registration as MSME was never
communicated to the petitioner. In this regard, reliance is placed on
Gujarat State Civil Supplies Corp. Ltd. v. Mahakali Foods pvt. Ltd6.
2023 SCC OnLine Del 2366.
(2023) 6 SCC 401.
Digitally Signed
ARB.P. 1723/2024 & ARB. P. 1725/2024
By:MAYANK
14:48:06
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT
23. Mr. Bedi, learned counsel for the respondent, submits that the respondent
is a duly registered MSME since 2009, which was subsequently renewed
in 2016 and then revalidated as UDYAM registration on 14.01.2021, in
accordance with the Government of India notification dated 26.06.2020
and 06.08.2020. In the aforesaid notification dated 26.06.2020, the new
process of registration as UDYAM registration was introduced and later
vide clarification dated 06.08.2020, it was clarified that the existing
enterprises registered prior to 30.06.2020 shall continue to have the same
validity till 31.03.2021, thereby making the status of respondent as an
MSME continuous and valid even prior to the Letter of Indent and work
order/purchase order issued by the petitioner.
24. He states that the respondent on non-payment of invoices invoked the
statutory remedy under Section 18 of the MSMED Act by filing a claim
before the Facilitation Council. The arbitration was initiated by the
Facilitation Council accordingly vide Order dated 25.09.2023, upon
failure of conciliation between parties. Further, the petitioner is also
actively contesting the matter before the Facilitation Council and in light
of this fact the petitioner is estopped from invoking arbitration as even a
buyer can file a counterclaim before the Facilitation Council.
25. The respondent places reliance on Silpi Industries v. Kerala State Road
Transport Corp.7, to contend that the MSMED Act is statutory and
mandatory and that any party to a dispute can make a reference under the
said act. Further the respondent contends that the instant Section 11
petition is barred by Section 24 of the MSMED Act, which confers
overriding effect on Section 15 to 23 of the MSMED Act.
(2021) 18 SCC 783.
Digitally Signed
ARB.P. 1723/2024 & ARB. P. 1725/2024
By:MAYANK
14:48:06
26. He further relies on Gujarat State Civil Supplies Corp. Ltd. (Supra) and
contends that it is a settled position of law that the MSMED Act being a
special legislation prevails over the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1996, and the contractual arbitration clause cannot oust the arbitration
under the MSMED Act. Accordingly, after invoking the jurisdiction of
council, any independent arbitration clause stood superseded.
27. The petitioner has already invoked the writ jurisdiction of the Hon’ble
Punjab and Haryana High Court, wherein the petition was disposed of
with direction to the Facilitation Council to decide the Section 16
application and conclude the arbitration proceedings. Thus, the present
petition constitutes forum shopping and abuse of process of law.
28. It is further submitted that the petitioner is trying to circumvent the
process under the MSMED Act by way of this petition.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS
29. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the material
and documents placed on record.
STATUTORY REMEDY VIS-À-VIS ARBITRATION AGREEMENT
30. The preliminary objection raised by the respondent is that the present
petition is not maintainable before this Court, inasmuch as the arbitration
proceedings are already being conducted entirely before the MSME
Facilitation Council, S.A.S. Nagar (Mohali). It is the respondent’s
specific case that it has rightly invoked the special statutory mechanism,
and the proceedings have already reached an advanced stage. The
petitioner’s attempt to invoke the jurisdiction of this Court, despite
statutory arbitration already being initiated, is an abuse of process of law.
Digitally Signed
ARB.P. 1723/2024 & ARB. P. 1725/2024
By:MAYANK
14:48:06
31. It is important to have a glance at the relevant clause of the general terms
and conditions of the work order/purchase order/service order annexed
with the Letters of Indent dated 15.09.2020 and 30.10.2020 between the
parties, which reads as under:
“Clause 28:
Dispute Resolution And Jurisdiction: It agreed and
understood between the Parties that in the event of any
dispute or differences arising out of or relating to or with
reference to or in connection with this Order, including its
termination, the same shall be referred to the jurisdiction of
the courts at New Delhi only. It is further, agreed and
understood between the Parties that in case of any dispute
arising out of this Order, the Parties shall refer the disputes
to arbitration for the adjudication by a Sole Arbitrator
appointed by Employer and the seat of arbitration shall be
at New Delhi only.”
32. The arbitral proceedings were commenced in Mohali pursuant to the
reference filed by respondent under Section 18 of the MSMED Act
before the Facilitation Council located there, for recovery of its dues, the
relevant section reads as under:
“18. Reference to Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation
Council:
(1). Notwithstanding anything contained in any other law
for the time being in force, any party to a dispute may, with
regard to any amount due under section 17, make a
reference to the Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation
Council.
Digitally Signed
ARB.P. 1723/2024 & ARB. P. 1725/2024
By:MAYANK
14:48:06
(2) On receipt of a reference under sub-section (1), the
Council shall either itself conduct conciliation in the matter
or seek the assistance of any institution or centre providing
alternate dispute resolution services by making a reference
to such an institution or centre, for conducting conciliation
and the provisions of sections 65 to 81 of the Arbitration
and Conciliation Act, 1996 (26 of 1996) shall apply to such
a dispute as if the conciliation was initiated under Part III
of that Act.
(3) Where the conciliation initiated under sub-section (2) is
not successful and stands terminated without any settlement
between the parties, the Council shall either itself take up
the dispute for arbitration or refer it to any institution or
centre providing alternate dispute resolution services for
such arbitration and the provisions of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 (26 of 1996) shall then apply to the
dispute as if the arbitration was in pursuance of an
arbitration agreement referred to in sub-section(1) of
section 7 of that Act.
(4) Notwithstanding anything contained in any other law for
the time being in force, the Micro and Small Enterprises
Facilitation Council or the centre providing alternate
dispute resolution services shall have jurisdiction to act as
an Arbitrator or Conciliator under this section in a dispute
between the supplier located within its jurisdiction and a
buyer located anywhere in India.
(5) Every reference made under this section shall be decided
Digitally Signed
ARB.P. 1723/2024 & ARB. P. 1725/2024
By:MAYANK
14:48:06
within a period of ninety days from the date of making such
a reference.”
33. Section 24 of the MSMED act confers overriding effect to the Sections
15 to 23 of the said act in case of inconsistency with any other law,
which reads as under:
“24. Overriding effect.—The provisions of sections 15 to 23
shall have effect notwithstanding anything inconsistent
therewith contained in any other law for the time being in
force.”
34. The respondent has raised an objection touching upon a crucial issue of
statutory arbitral mechanism. The issue is whether this Court will/should
entertain the present petition when the statutory arbitration is already
being conducted at the seat of the Facilitation Council, despite the parties
having contractually stipulated a different seat of arbitration under the
arbitration Clause No. 28 of the said agreement.
35. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has authoritatively established in
Harcharan Dass Gupta v. Union of India8, that the MSMED Act, being
a special statute governing disputes of specific categories to be resolved
through a specific forum and process, prevails over the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996, which is a general law. The Hon’ble Supreme
Court squarely relied on and approved Gujarat State Civil Supplies
Corporation Ltd. (Supra), and the relevant paragraph reads as under:
“8. We have given our anxious consideration to the
submissions of both the parties. In our view, the issue is no
more res integra and is covered by the decision of this
Court in Mahakali. As we need to do nothing more than
2025 SCC OnLine SC 1111.
Digitally Signed
ARB.P. 1723/2024 & ARB. P. 1725/2024
By:MAYANK
14:48:06
refer to the relevant portions of the binding precedent, the
reasoning, as well as the conclusion in this decision are
extracted herein for ready reference. At the outset, the
following two paragraphs clearly explain the principle on
the basis of which the court holds that the MSMED Act
overrides the Arbitration Act:
42. Thus, The Arbitration Act, 1996 in
general governs the law of Arbitration and
Conciliation, whereas the MSMED Act, 2006
governs specific nature of disputes arising
between specific categories of persons, to be
resolved by following a specific process through a
specific forum. Ergo, the MSMED Act, 2006 being
a special law and the Arbitration Act, 1996 being
a general law, the provisions of the MSMED Act
would have precedence over or prevail over the
Arbitration Act, 1996…”
36. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Gujarat State Civil Supplies
Corporation Ltd.(Supra) held that the private arbitration agreements
cannot restrict or supervene the MSME Facilitation Council mechanism
and the relevant paragraph reads as under:
“44. The submissions made on behalf of the counsel for
the buyers that a conscious omission of the word
“agreement” in sub-section (1) of Section 18, which
otherwise finds mention in Section 16 of the MSMED Act,
2006 implies that the arbitration agreement independently
entered into between the parties as contemplated under
Digitally Signed
ARB.P. 1723/2024 & ARB. P. 1725/2024
By:MAYANK
14:48:06
Section 7 of the Arbitration Act, 1996 was not intended to be
superseded by the provisions contained under Section 18 of
the MSMED Act, 2006 also cannot be accepted. A private
agreement between the parties cannot obliterate the
statutory provisions. Once the statutory mechanism under
sub-section (1) of Section 18 is triggered by any party, it
would override any other agreement independently entered
into between the parties, in view of the non obstante clauses
contained in sub-sections (1) and (4) of Section 18. The
provisions of Sections 15 to 23 have also overriding effect
as contemplated in Section 24 of the MSMED Act, 2006 when
anything inconsistent is contained in any other law for the
time being in force. It cannot be gainsaid that while
interpretating a statute, if two interpretations are possible,
the one which enhances the object of the Act should be
preferred than the one which would frustrate the object of
the Act. If submission made by the learned counsel for the
buyers that the party to a dispute covered under
the MSMED Act, 2006 cannot avail the remedy available
under Section 18(1) of the MSMED Act, 2006 when an
independent arbitration agreement between the parties
exists
is
accepted,
the
very
purpose
of
enacting
the MSMED Act, 2006 would get frustrated.”
(Emphasis added)
37. In the instant petition, the respondent, located in Mohali (Punjab),
invoked the statutory mechanism under Section 18 of the MSMED Act
Digitally Signed
ARB.P. 1723/2024 & ARB. P. 1725/2024
By:MAYANK
14:48:06
at Mohali, Punjab by filing a claim dated 04.08.2023 against the
petitioner. Although the agreement between the parties designates Delhi
as the seat of arbitration, the arbitration proceedings are being conducted
in Mohali only as per the provisions of the MSMED act.
38. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Harcharan Dass Gupta (Supra)
established that the seat of arbitration in MSME cases is statutorily
determined by the supplier’s location, not by contractual designation.
Since, the respondent prima facie is a MSME located at Mohali, Punjab,
the jurisdiction of the facilitation Council located at Mohali was
correctly invoked. The relevant paragraph reads as under:
“10. The issue relating to „seat of arbitration‟ in all cases
covered under the MSMED Act is settled in view of the
pronouncement of this Court in Mahakali. This position is
also true by virtue of the specific provision of the MSMED
Act, that is, sub-Section (4) of Section 18, which vests
jurisdiction for arbitration in the Facilitation Council where
the supplier is located: …”
39. More importantly, the Gujarat State Civil Supplies Corporation Ltd.
(Supra) judgment clarifies the significance of the deeming fiction
created under Section 18(3). The Hon’ble Supreme Court in this decision
emphasized that the non-obstante clauses contained in sub-sections (1)
and (4) of Section 18 of the MSMED Act, confer overriding effect over
any other law for the time being in force, including the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996, and noted that when the MSMED Act was
enacted, the legislature was fully aware and conscious of the existing
Arbitration Act. The relevant paragraph reads as under:
“43. The Court also cannot lose sight of the specific non
Digitally Signed
ARB.P. 1723/2024 & ARB. P. 1725/2024
By:MAYANK
14:48:06
obstante clauses contained in sub-sections (1) and (4) of
Section 18 which have an effect overriding any other law for
the time being in force. When the MSMED Act, 2006 was
being enacted in 2006, the legislature was aware of its
previously enacted Arbitration Act of 1996, and therefore, it
is presumed that the legislature had consciously made
applicable the provisions of the Arbitration Act, 1996 to the
disputes under the MSMED Act, 2006 at a stage when the
conciliation process initiated under sub-section (2) of
Section 18 of the MSMED Act, 2006 fails and when the
Facilitation Council itself takes up the disputes for
arbitration or refers it to any institution or centre for such
arbitration. It is also significant to note that a deeming legal
fiction is created in Section 18(3) by using the expression
“as if” for the purpose of treating such arbitration as if it
was in pursuance of an arbitration agreement referred to in
sub-section (1) of Section 7 of the Arbitration Act, 1996. As
held
in K.
Prabhakaran v. P.
Jayarajan [K.
Prabhakaran v. P. Jayarajan, (2005) 1 SCC 754 : 2005
SCC (Cri) 451] , a legal fiction presupposes the existence of
the state of facts which may not exist and then works out the
consequences which flow from that state of facts. Thus,
considering the overall purpose, objects and scheme of
the MSMED Act, 2006 and the unambiguous expressions
used therein, this Court has no hesitation in holding that the
provisions of Chapter V of the MSMED Act, 2006 have an
effect overriding the provisions of the Arbitration Act,
Digitally Signed
ARB.P. 1723/2024 & ARB. P. 1725/2024
By:MAYANK
14:48:06
1996.”
(Emphasis added)
40. From a conspectus of the above discussion, it is clear that the statutory
remedy contained in the MSMED Act prevails over any other private
arbitration agreement between the parties. A deeming fiction operates to
treat this statutory remedy as an arbitration agreement in itself having its
own force.
41. In the arbitration proceeding being conducted at Mohali, the petitioner
filed an application under Section 16 before the Facilitation Council
challenging its jurisdiction and since the same was not being adjudicated
upon, the petitioner herein also filed writ petitions before the Hon’ble
Punjab and Haryana High Court being CWP Nos. 15704/2024 and
15708/2024.
42. The Hon’ble Punjab and Haryana High Court while disposing of the writ
petitions vide judgment dated 09.09.2025 has directed the MSME to
consider Section 16 application and conclude the proceedings
expeditiously.
43. Most of the submissions made on behalf of the petitioner are identical to
the objections raised vide Section 16 application filed on 14.12.2023
challenging the jurisdiction of the Facilitation Council to adjudicate the
disputes raised by the respondent/claimant. The major objections raised
under the Section 16 application can be summarised as under:
A. The nature of the contract is that of works contract and the facilitation
Council has no jurisdiction to adjudicate these claims arising out a
works contract.
B. The respondent was not a registered MSME as on the date of work
Digitally Signed
ARB.P. 1723/2024 & ARB. P. 1725/2024
By:MAYANK
14:48:06
order and was registered as an MSME after the work order/purchase
order was issued.
C. There were deficiencies in the execution of the work assigned by the
respondent which has caused huge losses to the petitioner herein.
D. The claim filed before the Facilitation Council falls outside the scope
of adjudication vested with the Facilitation Council as the claim do
not arise under Section 15 to 18 of the MSMED Act.
E. The dispute resolution mechanism under Clause No. 28 of the general
terms and conditions of the work order should be triggered and
arbitration should be initiated accordingly at the assigned seat i.e.
New Delhi. Thus, only the Courts at New Delhi would have
jurisdiction.
F. The Facilitation Council has failed to conduct the conciliation as per
the MSMED Act, 2006 read with Punjab MSEFC Rules, 2021 and
thus, the Facilitation Council cannot initiate the arbitration
mechanism.
44. Once the Hon’ble Punjab and Haryana High Court has already
adjudicated upon the writ petition filed by the petitioner and directed the
Facilitation Council to decide the Section 16 application, this Court
under Section 11 of the act is not required nor would it be prudent to
adjudicate the same issues which are already pending.
45. The issues raised by the petitioner in the present petitions are to be seen
from the prism of the law contained in Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1996, while the issues raised by the petitioner in its Section 16
application filed before the Facilitation Council are to be seen from the
prism of the MSMED Act. A perusal of the judgment quoted
hereinabove shows that once a party to a dispute is a duly registered
Digitally Signed
ARB.P. 1723/2024 & ARB. P. 1725/2024
By:MAYANK
14:48:06
Micro, Medium or a Small scale Enterprise, the provisions of the
MSMED Act, being a special and a later legislation, would prevail.
Hence, the present petition cannot be entertained on this ground alone.
46. The major contention raised by the petitioner in the present petition is
that the contracts in question are works contract i.e. composite contract,
not covered by the jurisdiction of the MSMED Act, and hence the
Facilitation Council lack jurisdiction to adjudicate the disputes herein
concerned. The said issue has already been raised by the petitioner in its
Section 16 applications concerning both the subject contracts in
paragraph No. 3 (I) to 3 (VII) of the respective applications. It is
imperative to mention that as a rule of prudence, since the issue has
already been directed to be adjudicated by the Facilitation Council by the
Hon’ble Punjab and Haryana High Court, it will not be proper for this
Court to adjudicate the same once the issue is already pending before the
authority which is competent to rule on its own jurisdiction.
47. Another contention of the petitioner that the respondent was not a
registered MSME as on the date of execution of the contract between the
parties, is unfounded, misconceived and a mere bald allegation. The
petitioner has not produced any documentary evidence to substantiate
this allegation. At the same time, the respondent has furnished relevant
information regarding its prior registration and re-registration after
change in policy. In this view, the respondent is an MSME registered on
15.12.2009. The copy of relevant acknowledgement is reproduced as
under:
Digitally Signed
ARB.P. 1723/2024 & ARB. P. 1725/2024
By:MAYANK
14:48:06
Digitally Signed
ARB.P. 1723/2024 & ARB. P. 1725/2024
By:MAYANK
14:48:06
48. In light of the above discussion, I am of the view that the respondent was
a registered MSME on the date of execution of agreement between the
parties and has rightly invoked the statutory mechanism laid down under
the MSMED Act. The same prevails over any private arbitration
agreement between the parties as the deeming fiction operates in favour
of the statutory remedy.
49. Additionally, the same contention is pending under section 16 application
before the Facilitation Council and it has already been directed to decide
the issues expeditiously.
50. Further, it is no longer res integra that the arbitral tribunal i.e. the
Facilitation Council is empowered to rule on its own jurisdiction. The
Hon’ble Supreme Court has made the following observations in Gujarat
State Civil Supplies Corp. Ltd (Supra) concerning the power of the
Facilitation Council to rule on its own jurisdiction:
“48. When the Facilitation Council or the institution or the
centre acts as an Arbitrator, it shall have all powers to
decide the disputes referred to it as if such arbitration was
in pursuance of the arbitration agreement referred to in
sub-section (1) of Section 7 of the Arbitration Act, 1996 and
then all the trappings of the Arbitration Act, 1996 would
apply to such arbitration. It is needless to say that such
Facilitation Council/institution/centre acting as an arbitral
tribunal would also be competent to rule on its own
jurisdiction like any other arbitral tribunal appointed under
the Arbitration Act, 1996 would have, as contemplated in
Section 16 thereof.”
(Emphasis added)
Digitally Signed
ARB.P. 1723/2024 & ARB. P. 1725/2024
By:MAYANK
14:48:06
51. Be as it may, it will not be prudent to decide the same contentions which
are already pending before the Facilitation Council. The petitioner may
approach this Court in accordance with law once the relevant application
is decided by the Facilitation Council.
CONCLUSION
52. In view of the above it is reiterated that the respondent availed its
statutory remedy rightly before the Facilitation Council and jurisdiction
of the same has already been challenged on the same grounds as raised in
this petition. The Facilitation Council is duly empowered to rule on its
own jurisdiction.
53. Accordingly, the petitions are disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
JASMEET SINGH, J
FEBRUARY 07, 2026/SS
Digitally Signed
ARB.P. 1723/2024 & ARB. P. 1725/2024
By:MAYANK
14:48:06
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review