Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
IN THE HIGH COURTOF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on:18th February, 2026
Pronounced on:1st June, 2026
+
RSA 202/2024, CM APPL. 70406-70407/2024 & 70409/2024
1.
DALJEET SINGH
S/o Late Sh. Raghubir Singh,
R/o Village Shahbad Daulatpur,
Delhi- 110042
2.
MANJEET SINGH
S/o Late Sh. Raghubir Singh,
R/o Village Shahbad Daulatpur,
Delhi- 110042
3.
RAJ KUMAR
S/o Late Sh. Raghubir Singh,
R/o Village Shahbad Daulatpur,
Delhi- 110042
4.
KAMLA
W/o Late Sh. Ranjeet Singh,
(LR of Late Sh. Ranjeet Singh)
R/o Village Shahbad Daulatpur,
Delhi- 110042
5.
SANTOSH BALHARA
W/o Sh. Sunil Balhara,
(LR of Late Sh. Ranjeet Singh),
R/o Kh. No. 131, Gali No. 1,
Neb Sarai, Delhi- 110068
6.
VIKRAM JEET RANA
S/o Late Sh. Ranjeet Singh,
(LR of Late Sh. Ranjeet Singh)
R/o Village Shahbad Daulatpur,
RSA 202/2024
Delhi- 110042
7.
SAPANA
W/o Sh. Vivek Mathur,
(LR of Late Sh. Ranjeet Singh),
R/o H. No. 310B, Opp. Sr. Sec. School,
Karala, Mohammadpur Majri,
Delhi- 110081
.....Appellants
Through:
Mr. Sahil Rao, Advocate
versus
1.
JAI KISHAN,
S/o Late Sh. Daya Nand,
R/o H. No. 398, Near PNB Bank,
Village Shahbad Daulatpur, Delhi- 110042
2.
PRADEEP KUMAR
S/o Late Sh. Daya Nand,
R/o H. No. 398, Near PNB Bank,
Village Shahbad Daulatpur, Delhi- 110042
3.
SUNITA
W/o Late Sh. Daya Nand,
R/o H. No. 398, Near PNB Bank,
Village Shahbad Daulatpur, Delhi- 110042
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Naveen Kumar Yadav, Advocate
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
Regular Second Appeal under Order XLII read with Section 100 of
RSA 202/2024
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) has been filed against the
judgment dated 10.07.2024 whereby the learned District Judge has upheld
the judgment dated 10.07.2024 passed by the learned Civil Judge, whereby
the
Suit
of
the
Plaintiffs/Respondents
seeking
to
restrain
the
Defendants/Appellants from dispossessing the Plaintiffs from the Suit
Property was allowed, while the relief of Mandatory Injunction seeking
directions for raising the boundary wall alongside the suit land of the
Plaintiffs, was dismissed.
2.
The Plaintiffs/Respondents had filed a Civil Suit bearing CS No.
53489/16 (Old No. 360/12) for Permanent and Mandatory Injunction.
3.
The facts in brief, are that the Plaintiffs are the owners, actual
cultivators and in physical possession of agricultural ancestral land bearing
Khasra No. 15/22/1 situated in the Revenue Estate of Village Shahabad,
Daulatpur, Delhi, admeasuring 1 Bigha 2 Biswas (hereinafter referred to as
the „Suit Property‟). The Defendants are the owners of land adjoining the
Suit Property on both sides, bearing Khasra Nos. 15/21/2 (1-9) and 15/22/2
(3-14),
admeasuring 3 Bighas 5 Biswas, situated in Village Shahabad,
Daulatpur, Delhi.
4.
On 20.05.2012, Plaintiff No. 1, Jai Kishan, visited the Suit Property
and was shocked to find that the boundary pillars on all sides of the Suit
Property had been demolished and that the Suit Property of the Plaintiffs had
been merged with the adjoining land of the Defendants. It was claimed that
the Defendants attempted to encroach upon and grab the Suit Property of the
Plaintiffs by raising a boundary wall on one side thereof; however, the said
attempt was thwarted due to the intervention of the local villagers and the
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RSA 202/2024
protest lodged by the Plaintiffs. Consequently, the construction of the
boundary wall was stopped.
5.
The Plaintiffs made written complaints dated 26.05.2012, 29.05.2012
and 29.07.2012 to the local Police, but no action was taken thereon. It was
further averred that the concerned SDM had, vide Order dated 03.05.1999,
directed demarcation of the Suit Property. The Plaintiffs, therefore, claimed
that they had a reasonable apprehension that the Defendants would
dispossess them from the Suit Property by illegally taking possession thereof
and merging it with their own land.
6.
Accordingly, the Plaintiffs sought a decree of Permanent Injunction
restraining the Defendants from illegally interfering with or taking
possession of the Suit Property, and a decree of Mandatory Injunction for
directing the Defendants to restore the demolished boundary pillars to their
original position.
7.
The Defendants, in their Written Statement, asserted that the
adjoining lands on either side of the Suit Property, bearing Khasra Nos.
15/21/2 (1-9) and 15/22/2 (3-14), belong to them and their brother, Surjeet
Singh, and that they are the recorded Bhumidars, in possession thereof. It
was further stated that the Suit Property of the Plaintiff, is situated between
the aforesaid two Khasra numbers of the Defendants and that, ever since the
consolidation proceedings conducted in the year 1975-76, the land has
remained in their possession.
8.
It was claimed that, under the garb of the present Suit, the Plaintiffs
intend to take possession of the Suit Property. However, according to the
Defendants, the right, title and interest of the Plaintiffs, has already been
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RSA 202/2024
extinguished, on account of lapse of time. It was further contended that the
efficacious remedy available to the Plaintiffs was to file a Suit under Section
84 of the Delhi Land Reforms Act, 1954. Moreover, the Defendants asserted
that the present Suit was barred under Section 185 of the Delhi Land
Reforms Act, 1954.
9.
The Defendants further stated that no passage had been provided by
the Consolidation Authority, for access to the Suit Property at the relevant
point of time and, therefore, the question of the Plaintiffs being in
possession thereof, did not arise. According to the Defendants, a wheat crop
had been sown by them on the Suit Property and was standing thereon, at the
relevant time. The remaining averments made in the plaint were denied, in
toto.
10.
No Replication was filed on behalf of the Plaintiffs.
11.
The issues on the pleadings were framed on 23.11.2016, as under:
“(i) Whether the suit is barred under section 185 DLRA?
OPD
(ii) Whet her the plaintiff is entitled to the decree of
permanent injunction, as prayed for? OPP
(ii) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the decree of
mandatory injunction as prayed for? OPP
(iv) Relief.”
12.
The Plaintiff No. 2-Sh. Pradeep Kumar examined himself as PW-1
and proved the site plan, aksizra, khatoni, the Police complaints and also the
demarcation report dated 09.10.2014 as Ex.PW1/A to PW1/1 to PW1/12.
13.
The Defendant No. 4 Sh. Raj Kumar Rana examined himself as DW-
1 and deposed on similar lines as the defence taken in the Written Statement.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RSA 202/2024
14.
DW-2, Sh. Lalit Kumar Rana, Halka Patwari from the office of the
SDM, Alipur, produced and proved the original Aks Shizra pertaining to the
Suit Property and the two Khasra numbers of the Defendants, as well as the
Khasra Girdawari records of all the concerned Khasra numbers for the
period 2016–2018.
15.
The learned Civil Judge, on appreciation of the evidence held that
the Suit for Declaration and Injunction was not barred under Section 185 of
the Delhi Land Reforms Act, 1954. It was further observed that DW-1, Sh.
Rajkumar Rana, had admitted in his cross-examination that, “as per the
revenue record, plaintiffs are the owner of Khasra No. 15/22/1 (1 Bigha 2
Biswas), i.e., the Suit Property.” He also admitted that there was no Khasra
Girdawari reflecting possession of the Suit Property, in favour of the
Defendants. While DW-1 stated that he had been cultivating the Suit
Property for a long period, his testimony was found to be inconsistent and
contradictory, as he subsequently stated that they had been cultivating the
Suit Property, only since the year 2017.
16.
From the testimony of DW2 and admissions made by the Defendants,
it emerged that the Plaintiffs were the owners and in possession of the Suit
Property, while the Defendants failed to establish their settled possession
over the same. Accordingly, the Suit for Permanent Injunction was decreed
in favour of the Plaintiffs and the Defendants were restrained from
interfering with the peaceful settled possession of the Plaintiffs over the Suit
Property.
17.
Insofar as the Mandatory Injunctionfor directing the Defendants to
reconstruct the boundary wall allegedly demolished by them is concerned, a
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RSA 202/2024
reference was made to the testimony of PW1, who had admitted that they
had never raised boundary pillars around the Suit Property and thus, it was
held that no question of them having been demolished by the Defendants
arose. The relief of Mandatory Injunctionfor directing the Defendants to
reconstruct the boundary pillarswas, therefore dismissed.
18.
Aggrieved by the said judgment, the Defendants/Appellants preferred
RCA DJ 39/2019.
19.
However, the learned District Judge re-affirmed the assertions made
by the learned Civil Judge, by referring to the testimonyof the Plaintiffs,
Halka Patwari as well as the Defendants, and concurred with the
observations of the learned Civil Judge. It was held that there was no
merit in the Appeal and it was consequently, dismissed.
20.
The present Regular Second Appeal has been filed by the
Defendants/Appellants, assailing the Judgment dated 10.07.2024 passed by
the learned District Judge.
21.
The grounds of challenge are that for the purpose of grant of
Injunction to protect the possession of an owner or any person, it must be
established that such person was in lawful possession of the Suit Property.
However, the Plaintiffs, in paragraph 3 of the plaint, had admitted that, “on
20.05.2012 when Plaintiff No. 1 visited the Suit Property, he was shocked to
see that not only had the boundary pillars on all sides of the Suit Property
been demolished, but that the Suit Property had also been merged by the
Defendants with their own land.”.
22.
These averments stood corroborated by the Complaints dated
20.05.2012, 29.05.2012 and 28.07.2012 made by the Plaintiffs/Respondents
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RSA 202/2024
to the Police wherein also, it was stated that they have been dispossessed by
the Defendants and also sought restoration of possession.
23.
It is further contended that once it was proved from the testimony of
PW1 that he was not in physical possession of the Suit Property, then a
simplicitor Suit for Injunction was not maintainable, without claiming
possession.
24.
The onus was on the Plaintiffs to prove their possession and to show
that they were actually in possession of the Suit Property. Admittedly, no
crops were recorded in the official Khasra Girdawari record for the Suit
Property from 1996 to 2011, which, according to the Appellants, strongly
indicated that the Plaintiffs were not in possession thereof during this period.
25.
However, the learned Trial Court, in his judgment dated 27.02.2019,
decided the issue of possession in favour of the Plaintiffs, mainly because
the Defendants were not able to prove their own settled possession. It is
claimed that the decision improperly shifted the burden of proof from the
Plaintiffs, who were required to establish their possession independently.
26.
It is further contended that the Suit has been decreed despite the
Khasra Girdawari records reflecting no cultivation by the Plaintiffs from
1996 to 2011. This omission, according to the Appellants, significantly
undermines the Plaintiffs’ claim of physical possession, as the absence of
crop records during the this period, contradicts their assertion that they had
been actively and regularly cultivating the Suit Property.The learned District
Judge erred by heavily relying on an outdated Khatauni records, while
disregarding the need for current possessory proof.
27.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
The Plaintiffs, in their cross-examination, had admitted that the
RSA 202/2024
boundary pillars, which were alleged to have been demolished by the
Defendants, had in fact, never existed. This crucial inconsistency, according
to the Appellants, demonstrated the absence of a valid cause of action and
ought to have resulted in the dismissal of the Suit.
28.
The learned Civil Judge as well as the learned District Judge have
overlooked the admissions made by the Plaintiffs, which clearly show that
the cause of action first arose on 20.05.2012, when Plaintiff No. 1 observed
that the Defendants had allegedly started occupying the property by
demolishing the boundary pillars and had extended threats to the Plaintiffs.
They also acknowledged that they made Complaints to the Police in May
and July, 2012 seeking restoration of possession of the Suit Property. These
complaints, according to the Appellants, constitute an admission by the
Plaintiffs that they had been dispossessed and were seeking to regain
possession. These admissionsdemonstrated that the Plaintiffs were not in
possession of the Suit Property; this key consideration was allegedly
overlooked by both the Courts, while decreeing the Suit in favour of the
Plaintiffs.
29.
Reliance is placed on Narayan Bhagwantrao Gosavi Balajiwale v.
Gopal Vinayak Gosavi, 1960 AIR 100, wherein it was held that admissions
constitute substantive evidence and, unless satisfactorily explained or
rebutted, may have a decisive bearing on the determination of a party’s
claim to possession.
30.
Reliance is also placed on Radha Kishan v. Salig Ram, 1952 AIR SC
47, wherein it was held that matters concerning agricultural land fall within
the exclusive domain of the revenue courts under the Delhi Land Reforms
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RSA 202/2024
Act, and that such jurisdictional limitation, is substantive in nature. It is,
therefore, claimed that both the Courts overlooked the mandatory
jurisdictional bar and erroneously exercised jurisdiction in the matter.
31.
The Supreme Court in Kishan Lal v. Lal Chand AIR 1964 SC 500held
that denial of a material witness, compromises the fairness ofthe trial and
infringes upon the party’s fundamental rightto substantiate their claims
through adequate representation.
32.
The Supreme Court in S.P. Chengalvaraya Naidu v. Jagannath,
(1994) 1 SCC 1, held that possession must be established through cogent
and reliable evidence and that historical records, by themselves, may not
constitute proof of current possession where a contrary claim is supported by
evidence. The recent revenue records, such as the KhasraGirdawari, which
could have reflected the current status of possession, were not produced in
support of the claim for injunctive relief. Reliance is also placed on
Anathula Sudhakar v. P. Buchi Reddy, (2008) 4 SCC 594.
33.
It is further contended that the report of the Local Commissioner has
been unjustifiably discarded, despite recording the Appellants’ peaceful
possession of the Suit Property. Moreover, in Suraj Bhan v. Financial
Commissioner, AIR 1969 SC 221, it was held that the firsthand observations
of a Local Commissioner regarding possession carry considerable
evidentiary value in adjudicating disputes relating to land possession.
According to the Appellants, the disregard of this impartial report constitutes
a serious procedural lapse, as it deprived the Courts of objective evidence
regarding the status of possession of the Suit Property.
34.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
The reliance on an old Khatauni, without the production of recent
RSA 202/2024
KhasraGirdawari records to establish continuous possession, created a
material gap in the evidence. In Konda Lakshmana Bapuji v. Government of
Andhra Pradesh, (2002) 3 SCC 258, it was held that the grant of injunctive
relief requires proof of continuous and uninterrupted possession, failing
which the claim of possession remains unsupported and thus, untenable.
35.
The substantial questions of law have arisen in the present Regular
Second Appeal, as the legal principles governing protection of possession
and the burden of proof are alleged to have been erroneously applied, while
deciding the Suit. It is, therefore, submitted that the impugned judgment
dated 10.07.2024 passed by the learned District Judge be set aside and the
Suit of the Plaintiffs be dismissed.
36.
The Respondents/Plaintiffs in support of their Appeal have given a
brief synopsis reiterating and re-affirming the grounds of Appeal as stated
hereinabove.
Submissions heard and record perused.
37.
Essentially, the Appeal is directed against the grant of the relief of
Permanent Injunction, whereby the Appellants have been restrained from
interfering with the peaceful possession of the Plaintiffs/Respondents over
the Suit Property.
38.
The first aspect which is not even disputed is that, as per the Revenue
Record, the Suit Property is in the name of the Plaintiffs. This aspect has
been admitted by DW1 in his testimony that the Plaintiffs are the owners of
the Suit Property. The second material witness was DW2, Sh. Lalit Kumar
Rana, Halka Patwari, who also deposed that the Suit Property was owned by
the Plaintiffs and was situated between the two parcels of land, belonging to
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RSA 202/2024
the Defendants on either side. While the Defendants had asserted that
pursuant to the consolidation proceedings, the Suit Property, being located
between their two parcels of land, had remained in their possession since
1975-76.
39.
However, the learned Civil Judge rightly referred to the testimony of
DW2, Halka Patwari, who deposed that, as per the revenue records, there
was an entry of Jowar crop for Kharif 2016, in the Suit Property. Thereafter,
in the Rabi season, there was no entry of any crop. Likewise, in respect of
the Khasra numbers belonging to the Defendants, there was no entry of any
crop for Kharif, 2016 and the subsequent Rabi season of 2017. There was no
record showing any crop standing in any of the aforesaid three Khasra
numbers. DW2 further explained that crops may have been standing in the
aforesaid fields, for which reason no corresponding entry was made in the
Khasra Girdawari for the year 2017-2018. The Revenue Record, therefore,
clearly reflected that the Suit Property was recorded as being in the
possession and cultivation of the Plaintiffs.
40.
There was a Demarcation Report dated 09.10.2014, the authenticity of
which was questioned by the Defendants. The said Report had been
prepared in the presence of both the Defendants/Appellants and the
Plaintiffs. DW1 admitted his signatures on the Demarcation Report and
admittedly, no complaint was made before any authority in regard to the
Demarcation Report; rather, DW1 denied the suggestion that the
Demarcation Report dated 09.10.2014, Ex. PW1/12, and the Khasra
Girdawari had been manipulated or falsely prepared at the instance of the
Plaintiffs. These two documents lend support to the claim of possession, set
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RSA 202/2024
up by the Plaintiffs.
41.
The main contention of the Defendants in support of their plea that the
Plaintiffs were not in possession of the Suit Property, was that it was a
landlocked parcel of land and that no rasta/passage existed through which
the Plaintiffs could access or cultivate the Suit Property. However, DW2,
Halka Patwari, had deposed that, as per the Aks Shizra, there were more
than 500 Khasra numbers, which did not have any rasta or passage.
42.
It is a known fact that in cases where the lands are situated adjoining
each other and there is no independent rasta or passage, the owner of a land
parcel is entitled to access his land through the adjoining plots surrounding
the Suit Property. Merely because there is no independent access, does not
lead to the conclusion that the Plaintiffs were not in possession of the Suit
Property.
43.
The Appellants had vehemently contended that, according to the
Plaintiffs themselves, the boundary pillars had been removed and the
Defendants had merged the Suit land with their own land. However, the
Revenue Record clearly reflected that crops were being cultivated by the
Plaintiffs, thereby evidencing their possession over the Suit Property.
Moreover, merely because the boundary pillars had not been erected by the
Plaintiffs, does not divest them of their rights in the Suit Property, of which
they are admittedly the recorded owners.
44.
It may also be noted that where the property is a vacant plot of land,
possession ordinarily follows title and is determined with reference to the
person recorded as the owner of such land.
45.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
The learned Civil Judge thus, upon appreciation of the entire
RSA 202/2024
evidence on record, rightly concluded that the possession of the Plaintiffs
stood established, and this finding of fact was affirmed by the learned
District Judge in the impugned judgment dated 10.07.2024.
46.
From the aforesaid discussion, it is evident that the present Second
Regular Appeal challenges are only to the finding of fact and there is no
substantial question of law, which has been raised.
47.
There is no merit in the present Appeal, which is hereby,
dismissed.Pending Applications, if any, are also disposed of.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
JUNE01, 2026
N
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
RSA 202/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review